Week 10 Top 25 Rankings from SG1 Sports (2024 College Football Season)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 121

  • @BBallRambling
    @BBallRambling 3 дні тому +4

    Boise State and Ohio State have the same accomplishments. Barely lost at Oregon and have defeated unranked teams.

    • @robertsmith4145
      @robertsmith4145 2 дні тому +2

      But Boise state has better wins!! That Wazzu win looks pretty good

    • @floyd2155
      @floyd2155 2 дні тому +1

      Ik right Boise state is underrated

  • @caleb10jag61
    @caleb10jag61 3 дні тому +17

    Why is Missouri ranked? There is absolutely no reason they should be ranked. I love your videos and the content you make, and even when i disagree with stuff i can understand for the most part, but having Missouri ranked makes absolutely no sense. They have nothing on their resume to suggest a top 25 resume

    • @Luchabul
      @Luchabul 3 дні тому

      I mean, they have the top 25 cusper in Vanderbilt. That's better than Ole Miss, that's better than Colorado.

    • @SG1SportsCFB
      @SG1SportsCFB  3 дні тому +3

      I don't disagree, but there aren't any unranked teams that deserve to be ranked. I guess I could have just done a top 22?

    • @WestonLong28
      @WestonLong28 3 дні тому +1

      @@SG1SportsCFB It is impossible this season to make a top 25, at least right now. It feels like there are 17-18 actually good teams, and then everyone else is a jumbled mess. Hard to blame you for those bottom spots.

    • @caleb10jag61
      @caleb10jag61 3 дні тому

      @@SG1SportsCFB honestly when making my own rankings, I had 22 teams I thought deserved it and spent about an hour trying to figure out the other 3 teams , so I completely get that. I just think when you break down resumes of teams to consider , I think ole Miss, navy , Memphis, Syracuse, and even Arkansas would deserve it over them.

    • @peytonclark1353
      @peytonclark1353 3 дні тому

      Give Missouri a break ik they got blown out in there 2 losses but they were to pretty decent teams one great team in A&M. And if they had Brady Cook it would have been closer anyway. They still ranked in the AP poll too still that's probably why

  • @joshuamulberger9112
    @joshuamulberger9112 3 дні тому +3

    Based off of the methodology you are using, I would say overall makes sense. Just some changes I would make. Missouri shouldn't be ranked, broken record I know, and Texas is too high. They have no signature wins and have a loss. Top 5 teams right now, with the exception of Georgia because of their resume, should all be undefeated teams. Id put Miami or Indiana in the 5 spot for now. Once again, only based off of the methodology used.

  • @tyusbrooks9997
    @tyusbrooks9997 2 дні тому +1

    Can you explain why osu is in the top 10 if we're looking at resume. 0 good wins. Their claim to fame is a close game against oregon. Boise did the same thing, plus they have a ranked win. There are alot of teams that should be ahead of osu if we're talking resume.

  • @WestonLong28
    @WestonLong28 3 дні тому +10

    Typically your rankings are great, but Ohio State was lucky to beat Nebraska. Indiana won by 49. I'm a husker fan that was at both games... it's not close. I'd take Indiana to beat Ohio State, even in Columbus. Hoosiers have a better record too. How in the world is OSU at 6 and IU at 7?

    • @YoMom-ww1vj
      @YoMom-ww1vj 3 дні тому +1

      We will see when they play each other in a couple weeks. Oregon almost lost to Idaho and crushed Illinois lol every team has off days.

    • @joshuamulberger9112
      @joshuamulberger9112 3 дні тому

      I'd switch Indiana with Texas, and switch Miami with Ohio state based off of the methodology used

    • @James-p2d
      @James-p2d 2 дні тому

      Ig people don't realize what trap game are Nebraska was a trap game looking ahead to the Penn st game

    • @James-p2d
      @James-p2d 2 дні тому

      George and Oregon both had one and BYU had one against Oklahoma st

    • @James-p2d
      @James-p2d 2 дні тому

      And Mami got bail out by the refs in 2 games

  • @Jacquaid
    @Jacquaid 2 дні тому

    Thank you for respecting beating Vandy in Nashville. That team has been scary this year.

  • @happynotredamefan3736
    @happynotredamefan3736 3 дні тому +10

    No way Missouri should be ranked. Navy should be ahead of Washington State honestly

    • @BraedenAmick
      @BraedenAmick 3 дні тому

      Exactly when Missouri has played anyone any good they've gotten blown out they are definitely not a top 25 team

  • @Lukas-j1o
    @Lukas-j1o 2 дні тому +1

    I am a Michigan fan. Let’s just say I’m not excited with Oregon coming to the big house this Saturday.

  • @danielprensky4571
    @danielprensky4571 3 дні тому +1

    Like your explanation but I would have Oregon, BYU, Georgia

  • @BBallRambling
    @BBallRambling 3 дні тому

    Respect your BYU ranking

  • @ryannelson2653
    @ryannelson2653 3 дні тому +1

    If this is a resume ranking then Ohio State is way too high. They are ranked 15 in Strength of Record.

    • @tyusbrooks9997
      @tyusbrooks9997 2 дні тому

      Exactly. Their best accomplishment is the same thing boise did.

  • @JVPlayz96
    @JVPlayz96 3 дні тому +1

    My Top 25:
    1) Oregon (8-0) Best team in the country, enough said although I won't forget the sluggishness in the Idaho game they had
    2) Georgia (6-1) Lost to Bama in a wild finish but has a win over Texas by 2 possessions on the road. Questionable game against Kentucky.
    3) BYU (8-0) Undefeated but almost lost to Oklahoma State at home
    4) Penn State (7-0) Undefeated but has looked shaky and not very dominant in some of their games (UCLA and Illinois home games in particular)
    5) Indiana (8-0) Undefeated but still needs a Top 25 win or a very close loss to Ohio State to solidify their legitimacy
    6) Miami (8-0) Needs Duke to look solid and to play into the Top 25 and to beat them to have a quality win on the year
    7) Pittsburgh (8-0) Undefeated, played Cal and Cincy close but a win against Clemson will solidify their legitimacy
    8) Notre Dame (7-1) Lost to NIU but has wins against A&M and Navy, which are two quality wins
    9) Texas A&M (7-1) Blew out Mizzou and got a solid win against LSU but lost to ND at home by 2 possessions
    10) Texas (7-1) Lost to Georgia by 2 possessions at home and allowed Vandy to keep it close
    11) Ohio State (6-1) Has a close 1 point loss against Oregon (the best loss of the season so far) but allowed Nebraska to take the game down to the wire
    12) Tennessee (6-1) Lost to Arkansas (not a great loss considering Arkansas got blown out by LSU at home) but did beat Bama by one score at home
    13) Iowa State (7-0) Undefeated but doesn't have a Top 25 win. Needs to beat KSU in the last game of the regular season
    14) Boise State (6-1) Has the 2nd best loss in the country with a 3 point road loss at Oregon and has wins over Wazzu and UNLV
    15) SMU (7-1) Kept it close with BYU and barely beat Duke (who is underrated this year). Has a win against Louisville but not a Top 25 team.
    16) Army (7-0) Has blown out their opponents but are not facing quality opponents. Need to beat Notre Dame and Navy to solidify legitimacy.
    17) Alabama (6-2) Has a win over Georgia but lost on the road at Vandy and kept it close with South Carolina. Also lost to Tennessee by one score but blew out Mizzou.
    18) Clemson (6-1) Although offense looks good after week 1, the Georgia loss cannot be overlooked as well as the fact that they don't have any Top 25 wins.
    19) LSU (6-2) Lost to USC in week 1 by one score. Has a win over Ole Miss in OT and a blow out win against Arkansas but has a loss to Texas A&M by 2 scores on the road.
    20) Washington State (7-1) Did get blown out by Boise State but does have a win against Texas Tech. Not a strong enough schedule but a quality team nevertheless.
    21) Kansas State (6-1) Overrated AF, barely beat Kansas and got clobbered by BYU 38-9. Most impressive win is against Colorado, who lost to Nebraska 28-10.
    22) Ole Miss (6-2) Lost to Kentucky at home (really bad loss) and to LSU in OT but does have a good win against South Carolina on the road. Still needs a Top 25 win.
    23) Navy (6-1) A 2 score win against Memphis but a bad blowout loss to Notre Dame 51-14.
    24) Memphis (7-1) Highest quality win is a home win against North Texas. Has a 2 score loss to Navy. Needs a win against Tulane and a conference championship win to possibly be considered for the playoffs.
    25) Illinois (6-2) Lost to Penn State by 2 scores and got blown out by Oregon but did beat Nebraska (something Colorado wasn't able to do).

    • @JamesHilton-tf2bj
      @JamesHilton-tf2bj 2 дні тому +1

      Overall I would agree, good rankings and good reasoning. Kansas St and Memphis both have 7 wins, not 6, fwiw. I would also consider Tulane or Colorado over Illinois but I’m OK with having them ranked. But overall awesome rankings.

    • @JVPlayz96
      @JVPlayz96 2 дні тому

      ​@@JamesHilton-tf2bj Navy beat Memphis head to head 56-44. I appreciate it though. I corrected the win totals for the teams you mentioned.

    • @James-p2d
      @James-p2d 2 дні тому

      Nebraska was a trap game a 1 point lost on the road on the final play is way better then a 2 score lost at home

    • @JVPlayz96
      @JVPlayz96 2 дні тому

      @@James-p2d Yes but at least Texas got a win against a Top 25 opponent (Vandy is no longer ranked but was at the time they played). Ohio State has yet to get a Top 25 win. If they beat Penn State they'll definitely be back in the Top 5, no question about it. But if they lose they'll probably be out of the Top 15 (depending on by how much they lose by).

    • @James-p2d
      @James-p2d 2 дні тому

      @@JVPlayz96 but still if you lose by 1 point in away game against the number 1 team in the country and literally lose by half a second you cant say a win against a low 25 rank team who lost to Georgia st and get be by 2 scores at home is better

  • @mattbruns7771
    @mattbruns7771 3 дні тому

    so i am a ohio state fan and sg1 this is directed at you so please see this. I think outside of Oregon you can put any team that you have in your top 6 in the top 4 or so. that being said i like the way you rank the teams. i think osu can beat anyone and as you said any team can have a bad game. that being said Nebraska is a good team and i think they where a little overlooked.

    • @aflacktimeYAY
      @aflacktimeYAY 3 дні тому

      Ohio state overlooked them both the fans though OSU has to lock in their schedule is tough here on out

  • @mitch4509
    @mitch4509 День тому

    You rank most of the SEC teams a bit too high imo.
    I have the following teams ranked 3 or more spots lower: Georgia, Texas, LSU, Missouri, Ohio State, Kansas State and Washington State.
    I have the following teams ranked 3 or more spots higher: Miami, Iowa State, Boise State, Army, and Colorado.
    Largest absolute difference is 5 so your rankings are very similar to my rankings.
    24/25 teams are listed in both your rankings and mine. I had UNLV instead of Missouri but don't feel strongly about that.
    My Rankings:
    1 Oregon
    2 Penn State
    3 Miami
    4 BYU
    5 Georgia
    6 Iowa State
    7 Indiana
    8 Notre Dame
    9 Texas
    10 Texas A&M
    11 Ohio State
    12 Boise State
    13 Pittsburgh
    14 Tennessee
    15 Clemson
    16 SMU
    17 Kansas State
    18 Alabama
    19 Army
    20 Illinois
    21 Colorado
    22 LSU
    23 Ole Miss
    24 Washington State
    25 UNLV
    My philosophy involved looking at best wins and the number of losses. Good wins are power 4 teams with solid records or group of 5 with a maximum of 2 losses. I considered brands to determine if a record was solid. For example, I give Tennessee more credit for beating Alabama than I do Pitt for beating Syracuse even though Alabama has a similar record to Syracuse. Tennessee has a loss to Arkansas which takes away that credit but I hope my philosophy at least kinda sorta makes sense.

  • @BetterDays-e8h
    @BetterDays-e8h 2 дні тому

    “Im just going to rank the teams based on who they are on a neutral field”. Look for eight SEC teams-the only Conference that doesn’t have a team without a defeat!!! They have the best uniforms, great mascots, exciting stadium buzz, and and those amazing legacies.

  • @happynotredamefan3736
    @happynotredamefan3736 3 дні тому +1

    Sg1 sport explain Washington State and Missouri over navy?

    • @carterbrown2441
      @carterbrown2441 3 дні тому

      They just lost to Notre Dame by 83

    • @happynotredamefan3736
      @happynotredamefan3736 2 дні тому

      @@carterbrown2441
      So Missouri lost by 34 and we are ranked higher than Bama.

    • @happynotredamefan3736
      @happynotredamefan3736 2 дні тому

      And Missouri got blown out two weeks in a row

    • @carterbrown2441
      @carterbrown2441 2 дні тому

      @@happynotredamefan3736 Missouri has a quality win over vandy

    • @tyusbrooks9997
      @tyusbrooks9997 2 дні тому

      ​@happynotredamefan3736 Missouri has a quality win and they didn't have their starting qb against Alabama for majority of the game. The backup threw 3 ints. It's clear that him being out had a huge impact

  • @ambuse
    @ambuse 3 дні тому

    Can you explain why OSU is ranked so high when they are missing that “signature win”? You said the same thing about pitt and Iowa State but theyre ranked so much lower? The only difference is that those two teams are undefeated which should rank them above OSU if anything. I just dont understand why OSU is so much higher when they literally have the same best win as Iowa State.

    • @SG1SportsCFB
      @SG1SportsCFB  3 дні тому

      Iowa, Michigan State, and Nebraska are quality wins imo. Not great, but solid. And their loss was on the road at #1 in a game they were very close to winning.

    • @ambuse
      @ambuse 3 дні тому

      ⁠​⁠@@SG1SportsCFB Thats all solid reasons but if we’re counting quality losses (oregon) then shouldnt vandy still be ranked since they almost beat texas and mizzou? They have the signature win over bama too. Just a little inconsistent is all

    • @SG1SportsCFB
      @SG1SportsCFB  3 дні тому +1

      Vandy also lost to Georgia State

    • @ambuse
      @ambuse 3 дні тому

      @@SG1SportsCFBand notre dame lost to NIU lol

    • @SG1SportsCFB
      @SG1SportsCFB  2 дні тому +1

      1 loss vs 3

  • @GrannySingaporePVP
    @GrannySingaporePVP 3 дні тому

    I can’t take this seriously. Clemson at 15 and TN at 13 while having Penn st at 4 and UGA at 2. The logic is flawed. Penn St is way over ranked, UGA at 2 is fair but based on your “logic” they should be much lower because they lost to a team you’ve got outside of the top 15 and you’re rewarding them heavily for a win vs Clemson who “barely” made your top 15. TN beats the team that beat the #2 team and sits at 13. Having a 1-loss ND team ranked over 1-loss TN and 1-loss Clemson is criminal considering who ND lost to..
    I could go on and on and on but I’ve already made my point

    • @xxjuliusgamingxx6048
      @xxjuliusgamingxx6048 3 дні тому

      Clemson beat 5 out of 6 teams under .500 if anything shouldn’t even be top 15 over LSU, Boise or bama

  • @BraedenAmick
    @BraedenAmick 3 дні тому +2

    Missouri should not be ranked

    • @propotato4231
      @propotato4231 2 дні тому

      They’re in the SEC, they get special treatment

  • @natebyars2439
    @natebyars2439 2 дні тому

    Ohio state barely wins at home against an unranked team and keeps their spot and Texas beats a ranked team while on the road and loses their spot in the rankings?!!!!! Makes NO sense. Talking about the actual rankings I think your top 5 is fair.

    • @SG1SportsCFB
      @SG1SportsCFB  2 дні тому +1

      Ohio State was 4 last week so they dropped two spots. Texas didn't move.

  • @danielbremner4142
    @danielbremner4142 3 дні тому

    TCU at 35. Generous.

  • @jackinblack19
    @jackinblack19 3 дні тому

    I’m so sick of seeing byu at three I desperately need them to lose

  • @TheKingandTheDawg
    @TheKingandTheDawg 3 дні тому +1

    Missouri shouldn’t be ranked, let’s be honest. What have they done to deserve it? Beat a shit Auburn team by 6?

    • @TheKingandTheDawg
      @TheKingandTheDawg 3 дні тому

      Ole Miss killed SC in Willy B, and went to overtime on the road at LSU. Missouri just lost by 34 to Bama, this is not a Bama team if the past. And have we forgotten the A&M game too? Missouri is a below average SEC team that just happens to have an easy SEC schedule

    • @BetterDays-e8h
      @BetterDays-e8h 2 дні тому

      We must remember Auburn is in the greatest conference in the history of conferences and beating Auburn must be rewarded with as much glory as possible!

  • @minaeldiwany3215
    @minaeldiwany3215 3 дні тому +1

    My Texas Longhorns are number four in my opinion.

    • @natebyars2439
      @natebyars2439 2 дні тому

      Ohio state barely wins at home against an unranked team and keeps their spot and Texas beats a ranked team while on the road and loses their spot in the rankings?!!!!! Makes NO sense

    • @minaeldiwany3215
      @minaeldiwany3215 2 дні тому

      @@natebyars2439 it makes sense to me

    • @James-p2d
      @James-p2d 2 дні тому

      @@natebyars2439 they also lose by 2 scores at home Ohio State lost by 1 point on the road to the number 1 rank team and Ohio State survive a trap game

  • @sandybeachsean6880
    @sandybeachsean6880 2 дні тому

    I don’t like these rankings at all HOWEVER his are WAY better than the AP & COACHES Poll

  • @peytonclark1353
    @peytonclark1353 3 дні тому

    Indiana is fr

  • @Gorion-ch9xo
    @Gorion-ch9xo 3 дні тому

    Illinois shouldn’t be ranked they didn’t even compete they ass

  • @Dawg-Bone
    @Dawg-Bone 3 дні тому

    Hate away:
    Georgia
    Indiana
    Oregon
    BYU
    Miami
    Penn State
    Iowa State
    Clemson
    Texas
    Ohio State
    Notre Dame
    Boise State
    Ole Miss
    Tennessee
    Texas A&M
    Pittsburgh
    SMU
    Alabama
    Virginia Tech
    Kansas State
    LSU
    Louisville
    Washington State
    Army
    Navy

    • @realleppy1299
      @realleppy1299 3 дні тому +1

      There is 0 argument for Indiana over Oregon

    • @Dawg-Bone
      @Dawg-Bone 3 дні тому

      @ Oregon should be 6-2

    • @realleppy1299
      @realleppy1299 3 дні тому

      @@Dawg-Bone but they arent. They’ve won every game on their schedule and against better teams than IU

    • @tyusbrooks9997
      @tyusbrooks9997 2 дні тому

      Vanderbilt beat two teams on this list but they aren't ranked? No explanation possible for virginia tech being here

  • @gabet8188
    @gabet8188 3 дні тому

    This is my top 50 ranking. I’ve got a separate ranking for group of 5 teams that are above .500 as well
    1. Oregon
    2. Penn State
    3. Miami
    4. Ohio State
    5. Georgia
    6. Texas
    7. Tennessee
    8. BYU
    9. Iowa State
    10. Alabama
    11. Clemson
    12. Notre Dame
    13. Texas A&M
    14. Kansas State
    15. Boise State
    16. Ole Miss
    17. Indiana
    18. Pittsburgh
    19. SMU
    20. LSU
    21. Illinois
    22. Washington State
    23. Colorado
    24. Missouri
    25. Vanderbilt
    26. Syracuse
    27. Wisconsin
    28. Nebraska
    29. Michigan
    30. South Carolina
    31. Cincinnati
    32. Iowa
    33. Louisville
    34. Arizona State
    35. TCU
    36. Arkansas
    37. Virginia tech
    38. Texas Tech
    39. UNLV
    40. Navy
    41. Memphis
    42. Army
    43. Tulane
    44. Duke
    45. Minnesota
    46. Louisiana
    47. Florida
    48. Georgia Tech
    49. Western Kentucky
    50. James Madison

  • @someperson3883
    @someperson3883 3 дні тому

    1. Oregon 8-0
    2. Penn State 7-0
    3. Georgia 6-1
    4. Texas 7-1
    5. Ohio State 6-1
    6. Miami 8-0
    7. BYU 8-0
    8. Tennessee 6-1 +1
    9. Clemson 6-1 +1
    10. Iowa State 7-0 +1
    11. Indiana 8-0 +1
    12. Notre Dame 7-1 +1
    13. Texas A&M 7-1 +1
    14. Kansas State 7-1 -1
    15. Pitt 7-0 +2
    16. Boise State 6-1 +2
    17. SMU 7-1 +2
    18. Alabama 6-2 +4
    19. LSU 6-2 -11
    20. Washington State 7-1 +3
    21. Army 7-0 +4
    22. Missouri 6-2 -2
    23. Ole Miss 6-2 NR
    24. Illinois 6-2 -8
    25. Colorado 6-2 NR
    Dropped from Top 25:
    #21 Vanderbilt, #24 Navy

  • @caleb10jag61
    @caleb10jag61 3 дні тому

    My Week 10 Top 40 10/27/24
    Strictly off of Resume
    1. Oregon (8-0)
    2. BYU (8-0)
    3. Penn State (7-0)
    4. Indiana (8-0)
    5. lowa State (7-0)
    6. Miami (8-0)
    7. Pittsburgh (7-0)
    8. Georgia (6-1)
    9. Ohio State (6-1)
    10. Texas (7-1)
    11. Notre Dame (7-1)
    12. Texas A&M (7-1)
    13. Tennessee (6-1)
    14. Boise State (6-1)
    15. SMU (7-1)
    16. Kansas State (7-1)
    17. Alabama (6-2)
    18. Clemson (6-1)
    19. LSU (6-2)
    20. Army (7-0)
    21. Washington State (7-1)
    22. Illinois (6-2)
    23. Colorado (6-2)
    24. Ole Miss (6-2)
    25. Navy (6-1)
    26. Syracuse (5-2)
    27. Arizona State (5-2)
    28. Memphis (7-1)
    29. Arkansas (5-3)
    30. Nebraska (5-3)
    31. Duke (6-2)
    32. UNLV (6-2)
    33. Tulane (6-2)
    34. Missouri (6-2)
    35. Vanderbilt (5-3)
    36. Louisville (5-3)
    37. lowa (5-3)
    38. Michigan (5-3)
    39. South Carolina (4-3)
    40. Louisiana (6-1)

    • @RadicallyOptimistic
      @RadicallyOptimistic 3 дні тому

      Clemson too low, Bama too honestly. Not a fan of BYU

    • @minaeldiwany3215
      @minaeldiwany3215 3 дні тому +1

      My Texas Longhorns are number four let’s be honest here

    • @caleb10jag61
      @caleb10jag61 3 дні тому

      @@minaeldiwany3215I do mine strictly off resume . I’m a UT fan. But mine are strictly off of resume

    • @caleb10jag61
      @caleb10jag61 3 дні тому

      @@RadicallyOptimistic my ranking are strictly off resume.

    • @minaeldiwany3215
      @minaeldiwany3215 3 дні тому

      @@caleb10jag61 what do you mean