DeBoer and the staff can only do so much with Milroe at QB! Here’s the thing, DeBoer inherited a 2 loss team that even Saban had a really hard time getting this bunch to play at a high level…Kalan got that team plus lost 40+ players off that roster to the draft or portal! There isn’t a coach out there who can take over a team, lose 40+ players off of the roster just 10 months ago, hire an entire new coaching staff, and then have to play a QB who’s not capable of running the offense who’s gonna be great in there first year! Bama is on the way up, just gotta give DeBoer time to get thru these first year issues and get the players in here to run his system. Sure he may make new coaching changes as well, but DeBoer is doing the best he can with what he’s got!! I have 100% faith that Coach will fix the issues and build an unstoppable program.
@@mattbarker1411 They brought in 14 from the transfer portal. 40 players transfers out or went to the draft. 20 left before Saban retired, 10 after he retired and 10 selected in the draft
It is widely known that when Milroe was benched last year, the Offense quit playing hard. They would not play for anyone but Milroe. That attitude carried to this season.
I don’t think it’s completely a Jalen Milroe problem, I think it’s a Coaching Staff and OC problem. When Deboer got to Alabama he was immediately on a time crunch and he didn’t have much time to make a coaching staff that was as good as Nick Sabans, Nick Saban wasn’t dominant because of him alone, it was that he was great and he had a great support staff around him, I think that if we don’t make the playoffs then just beat Auburn and win the bowl game and allow Deboer to fix things in the offseason
I agree. The oc should give him some easy dink and dime pass plays. I know it’s just a video game, but in madden when I struggle completing passes, I give my self some check down plays. Pure bad play calling.
I think if Milroe could throw the ball more accurately the defense has to respect not just the run but also his passing game. He also targets 1 receiver for most games. If he could read defenses he could also spread the ball around. If the opposing teams take the quarterback run away we lose because there is no passing game.
They messed up last year because they played Tyler first and not Ty. And if you remember Ty brought them back and they won the game. That was a terrible offensive coordinator playing favorites.
You mean the same Jalen Milroe that sat behind Bryce Young for two years and has started the last two years? He can't read the Zone Defense and can't run the RPO. He is a ball hog. He doesn't follow blocks. Even the commentators said during the Oklahoma game he was starring down receivers before throwing it to them. He throw a 60 year pass to nobody. Even Jake Coker said that attempt at a tackle says alor about his leadership. No intermediate passes and cant go through progressions. I think if ty simpson would played the whole game last year against usf the dcore would be a lot better. I think the only reason he is still the starter is his NIL deals. And KB is more worried about being friends than whats right by the team.
Saban knew Milroe was the problem.. Thats why he stepped down out the blue he couldnt go through a year with inaccurate throws and a running QB .. He went thru it with Hurts and benched him at halftime of a National Chip .. looks like Saban saved himself from the stress this year
Deboer didn't have a choice. He needed to keep the team together, so Milroe stays at QB. #mattbewrong We have only seen Ty with the 2s. Milroe is a one read qb that is selfish with the ball.
@@Oregon12-0why? Because he can run? Not one running QB has won a natty at Alabama. Not one. Minus Tua, who came in at the very end of a natty game. You need brains at the QB position.
I can accept the interceptions. The best QBs have those games. I can’t accept or defend passing up on the tackle on the pick six. There is simply no excuse for that unless you are trying to lose. It’s not a question of whether Milroe is better than Simpson. It doesn’t matter how good you are if you are trying to lose.
I think you'll agree, his peak is plenty for a team where Alabama is at this season. The problem is, getting him there consistently. Say what you will about Will Howard, but Ryan Day has taught him to firm up a plateau high enough for OSU to be a formidable team. I wonder if any NFL team could use him as a reliable backup.
I would give Jalen some blame. Here’s my problem with Jalen he doesn’t have the necessary pocket mechanics or even the fundamentals you need as a quarterback. Teams don’t believe he can consistently beat them throwing from the pocket. My worry is his play by play accuracy, and sometimes his decision making can be cause for concern. But also the offensive play calling really isn’t that great either, it’s become way too predictable.
The team has been held hostage by the Cancer 5. They told Saban that if Milroe wasn't starting they would lay down. Proof of that is how the O-line played against South Florida in 2023 when Milroe was benched. This again shows how weak Deboer is as a coach; that he even named Milroe a captain.
Before this season started I told a few folks that Jalen milroe wouldn’t even be better than Blake sims & they called me crazy…. Look who sounds crazy now
You should do a little research there buddy. Milroe's stats are actually a little better than Sims. And on top of that. Sims didn't have to worry about being sacked as much. 14 TIMES in his career at Bama. Milroe has put up the same or better numbers at Bama, even though he's had to worry about being sacked WAY MORE. 67 TIMES he's been sacked to be exact. Numbers don't lie.
@scottisizzle research says that in sims senior year he has 1,019 more passing yards than milroe, 13 more passing TDs than milroe, and only 1 more INT than milroe. Idk wat stats u looking at but Blake clears milroe by a thousand miles. & this ten years ago when bama was all about running the ball
Let's also NOT FORGET Blake Sims had Lane Kiffin as OC and if Jalen Hurts had Lane Kiffin in the Bama vs Clemson game Dabo Swinney has to wait until Trevor Lawrence arrives. If Jalen Milroe had an OC who's more of a Lane Kiffin or Steven Sarkisian or or even a Dan Mullen OVER Nick Sheridan (who SHOULD HAVE NEVER BEEN Alabama's OC in the 1st place) Milroe's numbers and that Crimson Tide offense is WAY BETTER. i'mma keep saying it. ELiTE COACHES make a huge difference #rtr🐘🏈
I'll answer your question with another question. Since Milroe is perhaps one of the most athletic person on the team, and is known for his runs. Why not make him a RB/WR? I mean he is the leading rusher the team has right now. Imagine what a real OC could do with another QB under center and Milroe in the backfield. They would be the first two QB backfield at the same time in college football. Think of the offense that could be drawn up. A new variant of the wishbone could come into play. Think of the headaches it would give defenses. Just a thought.
Well, hello 🤗👋. Just a few days ago, I suggest Ed that Milroe be the running back, and Ty Simpson the QB in the Iron Bowl.... Great 😃 minds think alike 😮🏈🏈🏈
Milroe struggled the 1st half. Putting Ty Simpson in couldn’t have turned out any worse than a struggling Milroe. So, I’d say your wrong & DeBore should have pulled Milroe.
You pull Milroe and the team quits, it’s a culture problem at Bama this year and last. Ty is a better QB and passer, and we could not be any worse with him. Time to get rid of the problem! We all knew that Milroe is a great athlete but a terrible QB.
The coach is mistake is not replacing me last year. DeBoer made the same mistake by continuing with him. So it is a coaching problem Melro does not even come close to having mid-level D1 quarterback skills was set up to fail because he lacks the skill set to succeed
As someone pointed out, Milroe is a great RB, but a stubborn player who is truly not a QB. O’Brien saw this and so have the next 2 off coordinators. He is a senior and still has issues at QB. We have great WR, great RB, and a good line, but the QB has hurt us in the three games. Scoring 3 points in a game is not coaching but a QB problem. Wake up and admit it! His stock is dropping like a rock. Name a team in the NFL that wants him, I can’t.
Nobody in the league is reaching for Milroe. The only good mobile qbs are Lamar and Hurts, both way better passers. He compares better to 44% completion rate Anthony Richardson and nobody wants that.
When your QB has more carries than your RB’s I’d call that a problem. Maybe it would be acceptable if you had 5 Ryan Williams type WR’s and you ran 5 WR 90% of the time and your offense was working. Bama has RB’s that would start just about anywhere else. Challenge the O-line, line up and play grown man football. Make them stop the run. And don’t let Milroe run the ball 30 times a game. Hell maybe put in Ty Simpson and let’s see how he runs the offense!
Ty didn’t even get one start last year. Just a half a game against south Florida. And looking back on it Milroe didn’t play any better against south Florida this year! Give Ty a real shot
I always thought that Millroe's game revolved around his confidence in himself and the team, like at the end of last season when he started to pick up, and at the beginning of this season, he was doing fantastic, but after that loss with vandy and problems with coaches I think his confidence is pretty low so he forces himself to be the hero and makes terrible decisions
HAPPY Thanksgiving 🦃 Matt. I had Taco I Thanksgiving 🦃 Thursday😅❤ 🏈. Way better than Taco 🌮 Tuesday. Now that I'm seventy.four years old, 🗝️ I'm wat too old to be slinging around twenty.pound turkeys ...Gobble Gobble.😅🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃
The problem with Jalen Milroe is if you can make him play qb he’s horrible, if he gets to run around and occasionally throw a deep ball or a wide open intermediate he’s pretty good…the issue is people figured out how to make him play qb
you can say milroy is better but we want know till someone else plays a game. I didn't see Simpson do anything that wrong in the usf game last year the limited time he was in. simpson is not a better athlete but i believe he is a better qb. everything seems to run smoother when he's in, with milroe it looks like a house on fire type of thing. I think we will see this next year only simpson will probaly be with another team
There are many issues with Alabama. We miss the glory days. It is likely that we will never see the success that we had under Saban but we are lucky to still be considered for the playoff this season. Also, I will mention that DeBoer was much better his second season at Washington, so I am hoping that we will see the same thing next season.
Biggest mistake deborr made was keeping him. Shoulda let him walk. Not sure dude even listened to saban. Just an average game manager would have given bama one less loss, meaning bama would have been guaranteed to make playoffs.
It’s not because people think Ty is better overall than Milroe. It’s that they think Milroe isn’t doing the job rn and that it’s time for a change. Maybe defenses have figured out Milroe and now we need to give them something else to deal with.
Bama Receivers don’t get any separation.. we always want Milroe to make anticipation throws, but when he do, the receivers are not there and it’s a turnover.. It’s a reason why 5 and 2 are the main receivers.. the other ones are still learning the offense
Let’s just call it what it is….Alabama has always, at least within the last 15 years, been a team that hasn’t really produced very good quarterbacks. Instead, it has been a place where below-average quarterbacks go and look far better than they truly are because of the fact that they have a whole offensive line full of high 4-star and 5-star talent, 5-star running backs, and 5-star wide receivers. This has always made Alabama quarterbacks look far greater than they really were because Alabama, as a team, was 90% of the time far greater than the opponents they played. Now, in the last few years, with NIL, the transfer portal, and all, more teams are becoming equally competitive, which is now showing that Alabama isn’t the place where any below-average quarterback can go and look far better than they really are. Just look at all the Alabama quarterbacks that have gone to the NFL in the last 15 years - not one of them was ever a top 5 quarterback in the NFL.
There’s a million different problems with this Alabama team, but they’re still very young and the coaching staff is new to the SEC. Im an Alabama fan and as disappointing as this season was, I kind of expected it. SEC is a completely different ball game and I’ve chalked this season up to the coaching staff learning differences of the SEC and the players are still very young and trying to adjust to new schemes offensively and defensively. I think in a year or two Kalen DeBoer will have it all figured out and we’ll see a completely different Alabama team. The fact that Kalen DeBoer has only lost 3 games in his first year coaching in the SEC is kind of impressive. All of the other big names you’ve seen in the SEC didn’t come close to that record in their first year and yea I know there’s a big difference in the rosters but it’s still new schemes and new coaching staff. They need time to adjust. I think the future for this team is very bright despite the season they’ve had this year.
the problem is that they are too reliant on milroe playing well. When he has played bad bama played bad, when he played great vs UGA and LSU bama played their best games
He’s being exposed for not being able to read a defense and coach isn’t hard enough to make them hungry for winning, I hope the NFL wants milrow or he’ll be back (shit)
I totally disagree with matt this is Jalen’s fourth year with Alabama. He has many more games starting than Ty Simpson. if Ty Simpson would’ve been playing all last year as a starter they’re not even close. Simpson is an actual quarterback. He can read defenses and throw the ball accurately and catchable.
The other teams have figured out Milroe's weaknesses. He'll never be as effective as he was. And remember when everyone speculated that he would be much improved under Deboer? Never happened.
Jalen Milroe is a world class athlete. He could play any sport and excel. Ive noticed a pattern with athletes like this, they rely too heavily on their athleticism and not on reading defenses. Jalen Hurts is a good example. You can tell he started working on his field iq and look at what happens. Athleticism plus field IQ turns you into Tom Brady. Remember the IQ lasts the athleticism fades.
Go watch every game after the Georgia game and tell me how many of those deep balls he has actually hit. Obviously ignore the drops, but just go look at how inaccurate he is now. Bro is missing wide open guys that a high school QB would hit. He and the WRs aren't meshing well for some reason.
The problem with literally ANY AL QB is that they run the plays that are called. People can say Milroe makes poor decisions with RPO's, but now add in an O-line leaving holes, giving the QB limited time to pitch the ball before being chased down?! Definitely a coaching issue, IMO.
Mattbediddy…we all know lockeroom politics has played apart in milroe staying in the last two seasons. Well known person that gets paid to cover Bama basically stated it online the other day.
The offense is to dependent on milroe and he not there yet due to his inconsistency and so is the entire team is in consistent. Not saying he wouldn't continue to improve in NFL im sure he can if he continue to work at it and stay focus on the the game.
I’ve been saying this for a while. Especially after that second half against Georgia, they might’ve just found the recipe to stop Jalen and that offense. Then they went on to lose to Vandy that next game. I should’ve bet on it but that was toooo risky 😂
Bro just a running back with a low key good hand it’s not gone work .. RG3 for an example Yes the dual threat quarterback is a hood package to have but only few qb in history made anything of it Lamar Jackson Cam newton And Mike Vick So the odds of being a great qb as a duel threat is low
He doesn't need to even think about coming back for his senior year. Seriously dude, we're good. Take your butt to the draft! See if you can find a job for DeBoer in the NFL too while you're at it.
Jalen is very talented, but he lacks refinements for the next level as a passer. He has a long delivery, but very good velocity, and you mentioned the long balls. Jalen hasn't ever learned how to "work a defense" for advantages, and he struggles reading defenses overall. He is a great person, but it doesn't translate to consistently high level play or great field leadership. Reminds me of some players who have great physical skills but who are never challenged by a coach to refine their game to become a great player. Coaches just give them the ball, call a play, and tell them to win the game. Love you, Jalen, but need depth to your ability to lead and manage an offense if the next level will be success!
"Does Alabama have a Milroe problem?". Yes. Because in all of Bama's losses, the number of turnovers if they weren't and were scores, Bama wins all those games and at least ties OU. So, it's impossible to say MIlroe hasn't been the problem. He's been the deciding factor in every game, so how can he not be the problem in the losses? It's said but it's the truth. When Bama isn't turning over the ball, they are moving the ball most of the time. If he were a good passer and consistently good at it, you could even overcome those INT's. Get a stop, go score. But that just hasn't been the case.
Saban did not bench Milroe to prove to the world that the other QB's sucked. Info from inside the program said he benched him for his BS attitude. Then the players supporting Milroe intentionally tanked in the South Florida game to show their disapproval. That moment was the beginning of the end for Saban. He knew at that moment he was STUCK with Milroe, and the inmates were running the asylum. Fast forward to Deboer. How do you not start the incumbent QB who stayed with the program to "keep the team together" ? Deboer was also STUCK with Milroe. This is why Ryan Grubb bailed for the pros. He knew Milroe could not run his offense, and he didnt want to be saddled with that albatross. Now you have scuttlebutt saying the University of Alabama entered into some sort of business partnership with Milroe (potentially keeping him from being benched), along with a handful of starters again threatening to lay down if Milroe is benched. If Milroe is the bast QB in the program, Bama is screwed for a long time coming. He is horrific as a QB. He is an OC eliminator, because he can't execute the dumbed down 3 play game plan.
I appreciate Milroe's efforts. I know he is trying to win, but I think Bill O'Brien (who I was no fan of) was right. Milroe would have been a better RB. He has no touch on the ball, and seemingly struggles seeing the field when throwing. I think the gem in the trough is Lonergan. As a freshman on ADay he took our offense down the field to score and shows promise in threading the needle on throws. We need to get another QB ready for next year. Not sure Ty is there. We'll see.
The 3 games they lost, he had 28 rushing yards combined, therefore, if he can't run they lose. Offensive playbook obviously sucks as well
The offense sucks because they had to reduce it for what he can do
DeBoer and the staff can only do so much with Milroe at QB! Here’s the thing, DeBoer inherited a 2 loss team that even Saban had a really hard time getting this bunch to play at a high level…Kalan got that team plus lost 40+ players off that roster to the draft or portal! There isn’t a coach out there who can take over a team, lose 40+ players off of the roster just 10 months ago, hire an entire new coaching staff, and then have to play a QB who’s not capable of running the offense who’s gonna be great in there first year! Bama is on the way up, just gotta give DeBoer time to get thru these first year issues and get the players in here to run his system. Sure he may make new coaching changes as well, but DeBoer is doing the best he can with what he’s got!! I have 100% faith that Coach will fix the issues and build an unstoppable program.
@RollTideRoll_GSP where tf did you come up with over half the team leaving when saban retired? It was 14 not 40, but go off......
@@RollTideRoll_GSPBama isn't on the way up with daboer. It's a culture problem. You just don't want to admit it.
@@mattbarker1411 They brought in 14 from the transfer portal. 40 players transfers out or went to the draft. 20 left before Saban retired, 10 after he retired and 10 selected in the draft
He's the Goodwill version of Jalen Hurts
💀💀 im keeping dat
Don’t disrespect Jalen like that
@@OKCSoonerswhich one
@@tjadams1089 Hurts
It is widely known that when Milroe was benched last year, the Offense quit playing hard. They would not play for anyone but Milroe. That attitude carried to this season.
Your statement is not true.
@@TourwithterraYou don't live in reality.
@@Tourwithterrayou're from Atlanta. Tribalism and narcissism runs in your blood. Worry about alcorn St and Florida A&M
Maybe a race issue?
Coach needs to go then,cause he can put in a qualified backup.
I don’t think it’s completely a Jalen Milroe problem, I think it’s a Coaching Staff and OC problem. When Deboer got to Alabama he was immediately on a time crunch and he didn’t have much time to make a coaching staff that was as good as Nick Sabans, Nick Saban wasn’t dominant because of him alone, it was that he was great and he had a great support staff around him, I think that if we don’t make the playoffs then just beat Auburn and win the bowl game and allow Deboer to fix things in the offseason
Losing Grubb was a huge deal. He and DeBoer together are elite offensively
Agree and that is also the amazing talent of Nick Saban - winning every year with a new support staff seemingly every year.
Deboer PAC 12 type of offense will NEVER work at BAMA.
@ well it does something, cause we scored 41 on Georgia so it does something but that was before we ran Milroe every dang play and only occasionally
I agree. The oc should give him some easy dink and dime pass plays. I know it’s just a video game, but in madden when I struggle completing passes, I give my self some check down plays. Pure bad play calling.
I think if Milroe could throw the ball more accurately the defense has to respect not just the run but also his passing game. He also targets 1 receiver for most games. If he could read defenses he could also spread the ball around. If the opposing teams take the quarterback run away we lose because there is no passing game.
Yep
Milroe has never been able to read a defense. He deep ball has not been very good this year.
They messed up last year because they played Tyler first and not Ty. And if you remember Ty brought them back and they won the game. That was a terrible offensive coordinator playing favorites.
He should be a running back or receiver. He is not QB.
Force him to pass and Alabama is done
You mean the same Jalen Milroe that sat behind Bryce Young for two years and has started the last two years? He can't read the Zone Defense and can't run the RPO. He is a ball hog. He doesn't follow blocks. Even the commentators said during the Oklahoma game he was starring down receivers before throwing it to them. He throw a 60 year pass to nobody. Even Jake Coker said that attempt at a tackle says alor about his leadership. No intermediate passes and cant go through progressions. I think if ty simpson would played the whole game last year against usf the dcore would be a lot better. I think the only reason he is still the starter is his NIL deals. And KB is more worried about being friends than whats right by the team.
I think Bamas biggest problem is our coaching staffs refusal to make any sort of adjustments
Saban knew Milroe was the problem.. Thats why he stepped down out the blue he couldnt go through a year with inaccurate throws and a running QB .. He went thru it with Hurts and benched him at halftime of a National Chip .. looks like Saban saved himself from the stress this year
I cant stop imagining Milroe as a TE. With his speed nobody could cover him. Its possible he could be a top 5 TE in the NFL.
Marty has the MBG sweatshop working overtime 😂
Great video Mattbemrclean!
On the out pass where Alabama missed the block it’s still Milroe’s job to see that and not just throw the football to the other team.
Deboer didn't have a choice. He needed to keep the team together, so Milroe stays at QB. #mattbewrong We have only seen Ty with the 2s. Milroe is a one read qb that is selfish with the ball.
Austin Mack should start
He would lose the team if he pulled Jalen, so I guess we’re screwed
@@Oregon12-0why not Ty he was a 5 star qb and didn’t transfer despite having offers
@@Oregon12-0why? Because he can run? Not one running QB has won a natty at Alabama. Not one. Minus Tua, who came in at the very end of a natty game. You need brains at the QB position.
@@pascho1057 Austin Mack has thrown more touchdowns in 1 season than Ty has in 4 years. Remember Ty vs usf.
Yes yes and yes. Dude shows up when he wants
MartyMcDiddy
Ban
@@Sneedprodbro he’s not getting banned for something like this smh
Ban
Banned. #RollTide
Ban
Idk but MCGiggleBeSkittle😂 was fkn funny. Who ever posted that ur a legend and I owe u a beer buddy!
Happy Thanksgiving to you, Mr. Mattsuperbegreat
He’s been off on the deep ball this year. The few he has had this year, the receivers were wide open and he under threw them most of the time
He should've been benched at the Michigan game last year. Permanently.
Hell, I say the Texas game of last year. *PERMANENTLY*
Thank yu
gonna act like there wasn’t horrendous drive killing snaps that game ?
I can accept the interceptions. The best QBs have those games.
I can’t accept or defend passing up on the tackle on the pick six.
There is simply no excuse for that unless you are trying to lose.
It’s not a question of whether Milroe is better than Simpson. It doesn’t matter how good you are if you are trying to lose.
Your third line may have more merit than you think…
I have been saying this the whole time. If he is not better than Simpson, then we have a big coaching problem and we are screwed anyways.
MartyMcSweaty back in the thanksgiving sweatshop getting oiled up
Thank you matt been telling people this for two years now
I think you'll agree, his peak is plenty for a team where Alabama is at this season. The problem is, getting him there consistently. Say what you will about Will Howard, but Ryan Day has taught him to firm up a plateau high enough for OSU to be a formidable team. I wonder if any NFL team could use him as a reliable backup.
Will Howard has a brain. Will Howard doesn't have tribalistic white friends that will pout and quit if their boy gets benched.
I would give Jalen some blame. Here’s my problem with Jalen he doesn’t have the necessary pocket mechanics or even the fundamentals you need as a quarterback. Teams don’t believe he can consistently beat them throwing from the pocket. My worry is his play by play accuracy, and sometimes his decision making can be cause for concern. But also the offensive play calling really isn’t that great either, it’s become way too predictable.
The team has been held hostage by the Cancer 5. They told Saban that if Milroe wasn't starting they would lay down. Proof of that is how the O-line played against South Florida in 2023 when Milroe was benched. This again shows how weak Deboer is as a coach; that he even named Milroe a captain.
MichaelBeDeboer thanks for the fire vid🔥🔥🗣🗣🗣🥶🥶
Before this season started I told a few folks that Jalen milroe wouldn’t even be better than Blake sims & they called me crazy…. Look who sounds crazy now
You should do a little research there buddy. Milroe's stats are actually a little better than Sims. And on top of that. Sims didn't have to worry about being sacked as much. 14 TIMES in his career at Bama. Milroe has put up the same or better numbers at Bama, even though he's had to worry about being sacked WAY MORE. 67 TIMES he's been sacked to be exact. Numbers don't lie.
@scottisizzle research says that in sims senior year he has 1,019 more passing yards than milroe, 13 more passing TDs than milroe, and only 1 more INT than milroe. Idk wat stats u looking at but Blake clears milroe by a thousand miles. & this ten years ago when bama was all about running the ball
Let's also NOT FORGET Blake Sims had Lane Kiffin as OC and if Jalen Hurts had Lane Kiffin in the Bama vs Clemson game Dabo Swinney has to wait until Trevor Lawrence arrives. If Jalen Milroe had an OC who's more of a Lane Kiffin or Steven Sarkisian or or even a Dan Mullen OVER Nick Sheridan (who SHOULD HAVE NEVER BEEN Alabama's OC in the 1st place) Milroe's numbers and that Crimson Tide offense is WAY BETTER. i'mma keep saying it. ELiTE COACHES make a huge difference #rtr🐘🏈
@@scottisizzleSims made it to the playoffs though, right?
I have so much respect for you.
I'll answer your question with another question. Since Milroe is perhaps one of the most athletic person on the team, and is known for his runs. Why not make him a RB/WR? I mean he is the leading rusher the team has right now. Imagine what a real OC could do with another QB under center and Milroe in the backfield. They would be the first two QB backfield at the same time in college football. Think of the offense that could be drawn up. A new variant of the wishbone could come into play. Think of the headaches it would give defenses. Just a thought.
Well, hello 🤗👋. Just a few days ago, I suggest Ed that Milroe be the running back, and Ty Simpson the QB in the Iron Bowl.... Great 😃 minds think alike 😮🏈🏈🏈
@@sheilaseeber2007 The problem is that our current OC would not have a clue to run such a offense.
It worked with Braxton Miller at OSU
SmartyBeGreat is pumping out the content!
Milroe struggled the 1st half. Putting Ty Simpson in couldn’t have turned out any worse than a struggling Milroe. So, I’d say your wrong & DeBore should have pulled Milroe.
Pull him and put in Austin Mack
@@broyo6503he isn't even the second string option. 😂😂😂😂😂
You pull Milroe and the team quits, it’s a culture problem at Bama this year and last. Ty is a better QB and passer, and we could not be any worse with him. Time to get rid of the problem! We all knew that Milroe is a great athlete but a terrible QB.
bro a rb trying to play qb thats the problem
The coach is mistake is not replacing me last year. DeBoer made the same mistake by continuing with him. So it is a coaching problem Melro does not even come close to having mid-level D1 quarterback skills was set up to fail because he lacks the skill set to succeed
Happy Thanksgiving, Matt and family! 🦃🍻💨
The only problem he has is he doesnt have his CDL yet 😂
Most athletic truck driver. 😂
Another great video by Matt
First year coaching , and a young team. This team is doing great. Now, if this was 2nd or 3rd then they have a huge problem.
As someone pointed out, Milroe is a great RB, but a stubborn player who is truly not a QB. O’Brien saw this and so have the next 2 off coordinators. He is a senior and still has issues at QB. We have great WR, great RB, and a good line, but the QB has hurt us in the three games. Scoring 3 points in a game is not coaching but a QB problem. Wake up and admit it! His stock is dropping like a rock. Name a team in the NFL that wants him, I can’t.
Nobody in the league is reaching for Milroe. The only good mobile qbs are Lamar and Hurts, both way better passers. He compares better to 44% completion rate Anthony Richardson and nobody wants that.
Mattbenuting back at it again 😂
He is the worst qb since Blake sims
Blake Sims was a way better QB. I would compare him more to Star Jackson.
I say since Brodie croyle
When your QB has more carries than your RB’s I’d call that a problem. Maybe it would be acceptable if you had 5 Ryan Williams type WR’s and you ran 5 WR 90% of the time and your offense was working. Bama has RB’s that would start just about anywhere else. Challenge the O-line, line up and play grown man football. Make them stop the run. And don’t let Milroe run the ball 30 times a game. Hell maybe put in Ty Simpson and let’s see how he runs the offense!
Matthewbartholomewthegreat how are the withdrawals from the diddy parties?
Ty didn’t even get one start last year. Just a half a game against south Florida. And looking back on it Milroe didn’t play any better against south Florida this year! Give Ty a real shot
Ty Simpson sucks dude, do you have eyes? I’ve never seen him get on the field and thought we were going to score.
@@christianclark8788yet they score when he gets on the field… Now stfu
He did play good had some plays get called back due to holding by the same o lineman
I always thought that Millroe's game revolved around his confidence in himself and the team, like at the end of last season when he started to pick up, and at the beginning of this season, he was doing fantastic, but after that loss with vandy and problems with coaches I think his confidence is pretty low so he forces himself to be the hero and makes terrible decisions
MattBestrokingoffthenutcracker
NAHHHHHH UR COOKED😂😂
You’re done buddy😂
Ban
Mattbegreat is gregging his doucette to Ice Spice feet in pink outfit in fortnite 💀
@@Calebperalta248 yea your done
But if Ty starts a lot of the players would not play
Great video Jack!
HAPPY Thanksgiving 🦃 Matt. I had Taco I Thanksgiving 🦃 Thursday😅❤ 🏈. Way better than Taco 🌮 Tuesday. Now that I'm seventy.four years old, 🗝️ I'm wat too old to be slinging around twenty.pound turkeys ...Gobble Gobble.😅🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃🦃
Ty will have a great season next year
The dynasty’s over Marty
MartyMcFattytheDaddy with another great video
Banned. #RollTide
Marty Malone is going crazy with 3 videos
The problem with Jalen Milroe is if you can make him play qb he’s horrible, if he gets to run around and occasionally throw a deep ball or a wide open intermediate he’s pretty good…the issue is people figured out how to make him play qb
Honestly Blake Simms was a better QB for Bama Milroe is just best athlete on field most games
Look at the rushing yards. It’s an O-Line problem!
Defenses are stacking the box. They don’t think milroe can beat them with his arm
Milroe's always been a running QB who can pass. If the run's not there he starts to have problems picking out an open receiver.
Good vid Matt be didymium
you can say milroy is better but we want know till someone else plays a game. I didn't see Simpson do anything that wrong in the usf game last year the limited time he was in. simpson is not a better athlete but i believe he is a better qb. everything seems to run smoother when he's in, with milroe it looks like a house on fire type of thing. I think we will see this next year only simpson will probaly be with another team
There are many issues with Alabama. We miss the glory days. It is likely that we will never see the success that we had under Saban but we are lucky to still be considered for the playoff this season. Also, I will mention that DeBoer was much better his second season at Washington, so I am hoping that we will see the same thing next season.
Have that same energy for Jackson Dart
McCorckleBeGreat, South Carolina gonna make it over Bama
2
@@Sneedprod3 on you buddy as trump once said "YOUR FIRED"
Biggest mistake deborr made was keeping him. Shoulda let him walk. Not sure dude even listened to saban.
Just an average game manager would have given bama one less loss, meaning bama would have been guaranteed to make playoffs.
It’s not because people think Ty is better overall than Milroe. It’s that they think Milroe isn’t doing the job rn and that it’s time for a change. Maybe defenses have figured out Milroe and now we need to give them something else to deal with.
Bama Receivers don’t get any separation.. we always want Milroe to make anticipation throws, but when he do, the receivers are not there and it’s a turnover.. It’s a reason why 5 and 2 are the main receivers.. the other ones are still learning the offense
Let’s just call it what it is….Alabama has always, at least within the last 15 years, been a team that hasn’t really produced very good quarterbacks. Instead, it has been a place where below-average quarterbacks go and look far better than they truly are because of the fact that they have a whole offensive line full of high 4-star and 5-star talent, 5-star running backs, and 5-star wide receivers. This has always made Alabama quarterbacks look far greater than they really were because Alabama, as a team, was 90% of the time far greater than the opponents they played. Now, in the last few years, with NIL, the transfer portal, and all, more teams are becoming equally competitive, which is now showing that Alabama isn’t the place where any below-average quarterback can go and look far better than they really are. Just look at all the Alabama quarterbacks that have gone to the NFL in the last 15 years - not one of them was ever a top 5 quarterback in the NFL.
There’s a million different problems with this Alabama team, but they’re still very young and the coaching staff is new to the SEC. Im an Alabama fan and as disappointing as this season was, I kind of expected it. SEC is a completely different ball game and I’ve chalked this season up to the coaching staff learning differences of the SEC and the players are still very young and trying to adjust to new schemes offensively and defensively. I think in a year or two Kalen DeBoer will have it all figured out and we’ll see a completely different Alabama team. The fact that Kalen DeBoer has only lost 3 games in his first year coaching in the SEC is kind of impressive. All of the other big names you’ve seen in the SEC didn’t come close to that record in their first year and yea I know there’s a big difference in the rosters but it’s still new schemes and new coaching staff. They need time to adjust. I think the future for this team is very bright despite the season they’ve had this year.
Mattbehonest this is coming from a Alabama fan. I think when milroe leaves for the draft. I think they should start Austin Mack
the problem is that they are too reliant on milroe playing well. When he has played bad bama played bad, when he played great vs UGA and LSU bama played their best games
He’s being exposed for not being able to read a defense and coach isn’t hard enough to make them hungry for winning, I hope the NFL wants milrow or he’ll be back (shit)
I totally disagree with matt this is Jalen’s fourth year with Alabama. He has many more games starting than Ty Simpson. if Ty Simpson would’ve been playing all last year as a starter they’re not even close. Simpson is an actual quarterback. He can read defenses and throw the ball accurately and catchable.
Great Video Megan! I saw you in West Virginia the other day. Why did you rob that Target though?
Again, as a 6 year old Chinese kid working in the MBG sweatshop I can confirm we get no breaks or days off.
Why does it matter? Isint he going to the league in 2 games?
No one cares about BAMA FOOTBALL BESIDES BAMA FANS AT THIS POINT!
He doesn’t like contact. Stutsman scared him so bad that he just folded.
Happy thanksgiving Macintosh
Happy thanksgiving Micheal
The other teams have figured out Milroe's weaknesses. He'll never be as effective as he was. And remember when everyone speculated that he would be much improved under Deboer? Never happened.
Jalen Milroe is a world class athlete. He could play any sport and excel. Ive noticed a pattern with athletes like this, they rely too heavily on their athleticism and not on reading defenses. Jalen Hurts is a good example. You can tell he started working on his field iq and look at what happens. Athleticism plus field IQ turns you into Tom Brady. Remember the IQ lasts the athleticism fades.
Saying he could play any sport & excel is obvious hyperbole
Jalen hurts is very intelligent and milroe I worry about I don’t think he is as smart in the head
Slow news day mat
I also love your video
Go watch every game after the Georgia game and tell me how many of those deep balls he has actually hit. Obviously ignore the drops, but just go look at how inaccurate he is now. Bro is missing wide open guys that a high school QB would hit. He and the WRs aren't meshing well for some reason.
The problem with literally ANY AL QB is that they run the plays that are called. People can say Milroe makes poor decisions with RPO's, but now add in an O-line leaving holes, giving the QB limited time to pitch the ball before being chased down?!
Definitely a coaching issue, IMO.
Mattbediddy…we all know lockeroom politics has played apart in milroe staying in the last two seasons. Well known person that gets paid to cover Bama basically stated it online the other day.
The offense is to dependent on milroe and he not there yet due to his inconsistency and so is the entire team is in consistent. Not saying he wouldn't continue to improve in NFL im sure he can if he continue to work at it and stay focus on the the game.
I’ve been saying this for a while. Especially after that second half against Georgia, they might’ve just found the recipe to stop Jalen and that offense. Then they went on to lose to Vandy that next game. I should’ve bet on it but that was toooo risky 😂
Bro just a running back with a low key good hand it’s not gone work .. RG3 for an example
Yes the dual threat quarterback is a hood package to have but only few qb in history made anything of it
Lamar Jackson
Cam newton
And Mike Vick
So the odds of being a great qb as a duel threat is low
He doesn't need to even think about coming back for his senior year. Seriously dude, we're good. Take your butt to the draft! See if you can find a job for DeBoer in the NFL too while you're at it.
Jalen is very talented, but he lacks refinements for the next level as a passer. He has a long delivery, but very good velocity, and you mentioned the long balls. Jalen hasn't ever learned how to "work a defense" for advantages, and he struggles reading defenses overall. He is a great person, but it doesn't translate to consistently high level play or great field leadership. Reminds me of some players who have great physical skills but who are never challenged by a coach to refine their game to become a great player. Coaches just give them the ball, call a play, and tell them to win the game. Love you, Jalen, but need depth to your ability to lead and manage an offense if the next level will be success!
Milroe vs Simpson?
Mattstillbestrokinghislilgreat
That google translation wild tho
Ban
More like Mattbegreat is mattbeating his great tonight over Alabama Crimson tiding my as
Ban
Matt make college basketball 🏀 content again roll tide
I wish more of these sport pundits could be like Marky here, and be honest about Alabama this season.
"Does Alabama have a Milroe problem?". Yes. Because in all of Bama's losses, the number of turnovers if they weren't and were scores, Bama wins all those games and at least ties OU. So, it's impossible to say MIlroe hasn't been the problem. He's been the deciding factor in every game, so how can he not be the problem in the losses? It's said but it's the truth. When Bama isn't turning over the ball, they are moving the ball most of the time. If he were a good passer and consistently good at it, you could even overcome those INT's. Get a stop, go score. But that just hasn't been the case.
MBG sweatshop? Sounds like something mattbediddy would say
Awww I love watching Matty patty daddy
It is what it is.... #MATTBEDIRTYSANCHEZ-EN...
Saban did not bench Milroe to prove to the world that the other QB's sucked. Info from inside the program said he benched him for his BS attitude. Then the players supporting Milroe intentionally tanked in the South Florida game to show their disapproval. That moment was the beginning of the end for Saban. He knew at that moment he was STUCK with Milroe, and the inmates were running the asylum. Fast forward to Deboer. How do you not start the incumbent QB who stayed with the program to "keep the team together" ? Deboer was also STUCK with Milroe. This is why Ryan Grubb bailed for the pros. He knew Milroe could not run his offense, and he didnt want to be saddled with that albatross.
Now you have scuttlebutt saying the University of Alabama entered into some sort of business partnership with Milroe (potentially keeping him from being benched), along with a handful of starters again threatening to lay down if Milroe is benched. If Milroe is the bast QB in the program, Bama is screwed for a long time coming. He is horrific as a QB. He is an OC eliminator, because he can't execute the dumbed down 3 play game plan.
I appreciate Milroe's efforts. I know he is trying to win, but I think Bill O'Brien (who I was no fan of) was right. Milroe would have been a better RB. He has no touch on the ball, and seemingly struggles seeing the field when throwing.
I think the gem in the trough is Lonergan. As a freshman on ADay he took our offense down the field to score and shows promise in threading the needle on throws.
We need to get another QB ready for next year. Not sure Ty is there. We'll see.