What if Saruman Stayed Good?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 11

  • @Mason-u7o
    @Mason-u7o 24 дні тому +7

    I think the biggest question is what would've happened without Gandalf the white

    • @person55632
      @person55632 24 дні тому +1

      With Saruman doing his job? It would have been fine. Gandalf says in the book that part of why he was sent back as the white was to replace Saruman.

    • @MarshWaha
      @MarshWaha 23 дні тому +1

      I would like to believe his fate would still be the same. Instead of replacing Saruman I mean just imagine if there were two white wizards? Instead of one that’s one possibility. Because we don’t understand how wizards are upgraded in middle earth. I’m not really sure because I mean, could he be sent back as Gandalf the gray again?sure maybe that I do not know it’s the same question I’ve had too. I’m not exactly sure.

    • @GarretMadden
      @GarretMadden 21 день тому

      Great question, all respects to random “person”, none of this would be possible without Gandalf. He had a more personal relationship with them and their confidence stemmed from knowing he would be there to help aid.

  • @GazBeasley
    @GazBeasley 21 день тому +1

    The wizard’s mission was to advise the people of middle earth not rule so if saruman hadn’t turned i doubt he would’ve started commanding armies as it wasn’t what he was supposed to be doing

  • @toddkurzbard
    @toddkurzbard 24 дні тому +2

    Why, in so many illustrations of Saruman here, does he have Mr. Spock ears?

  • @Pure_Ben
    @Pure_Ben 24 дні тому +5

    This is just an AI readout. The pronunciation is all over the place, no human would refer to Frodosses journey at 16:38, and Middle Earth's story being dramatically cunged at 18:04.
    Put some effort in.

    • @frmattdrummond6535
      @frmattdrummond6535 24 дні тому +3

      Too often these types of video also appear to have been written by AI, with nonsensical ideas which bear no relation to Tokien's canon. I now avoid all AI narrated videos as they're simply lazy, created to farm UA-cam algorithms.

  • @Thekonay
    @Thekonay 23 дні тому +2

    These ai voiceovers ruin names... mehh

    • @franciswalsh8416
      @franciswalsh8416 23 дні тому +1

      I do like the way it pronounced "Wormtongue" though