Spyro reignited trilogy and crash bandicoot n-sane trilogy. Deserve to be on this list. I know they're technically both packages of three games but you included a package of two games so it counts imo.
Yours and his logic is stupid just because they bundle games together doesn't make them remakes , they're still remasters because they are shot for shot the same exact games just better graphics glad they didn't make the list
@@RagnarokMic played both trilogy packs and they are god awful. If that is the gold standard then i don't ever want to see a platform game ever in my life.
In 2017 I was in an accident that left me in a wheelchair for the rest of my life. I was 27.. I spent a year in the hospital. My gf brought me her 3DS and the Pokémon Silver remake. It really helped me get through. I played the original so it brought me back to a better time and kept me busy. Great game ❤
I think everyone has a time in their life where a game comes in to take our mind off of reality, allowing us to detach for as long as that game lets us to find some peace. I couldn't imagine your circumstances, but Im glad you had some reprival from your gf (who seems like a keeper) This alone is EXACTLY why Video Games, like Cinema, are a true art form.
Explains a lot as to why HeartGold and SoulSilver are so expensive at game stores, even used. $200 USD for a used, decade old DS cartridge but a damn fine game. First Pokémon game I'd ever played was Gold version, so yes the remakes were an amazing addition. 😁
I have one major issue with Super Mario All-Stars: the block-breaking physics in SMB1 and Lost Levels. On the NES versions, Mario rebounds off the blocks when he breaks them, but in All-Stars he jumps through them and all of your momentum is lost. But yes, the All-Stars versions of SMB2 and SMB3 are excellent.
100% My gold standard for Pokémon Remakes. Then FRLG for Kanto. SDBP was close since it was basically a port with upgraded graphics. I rank, sadly, ORAS below those three basically because there felt like a lot of hand holding to drag me to the next plot point and then the stuff that was added was "meh".
I am a huge Resident Evil fan, but I just can’t agree. None of the remakes are perfect. They might be great reimaginings, but that’s about it. Resident Evil 4 in particular is far from perfect. Lost a lot of its charm, simplified some boss designs, cut many memorable scenes and locations, etc. While not as bad as Resident Evil 3, it’s just not as good as the original in my eyes, even if it’s still a great game. Although, I love the remake’s Louis, he is amazing and deserves the world.
Very fair comment. If they were faithful recreations that preserved the og's only then they could have been considered perfected, like how it was with RE1.
I think it turned out a lot better than expected. It’s not a 1 to 1 remake and I feel that the original was better in a lot ways (Leon was cooler), but do people really enjoy that? The original RE1 remake was good, but everything was pretty much the same as the OG, though it better graphics and some new areas.
@@nightinxgale7083 RE1R is the closest to perfecting its original game, it achieved this by being faithful and preserving the og. Being a reimagining that changes things drastically for no good reason can't grant RE4R the title of perfected or nearly perfected RE4, just different RE4. So i don't think it should be on this list.
See... I could never get on with the original RE games back in the day. The 'tank' controls were nothing other than frustrating to me. I really wanted to enjoy them like everyone else did, but they just annoyed me. I LOVED finally being able to experience a version of Resident Evil 2 that didn't make me want to snap my controller in half.
FF7R's inclusion on this list is debatable. First and foremost, because its not a "remake" in the common sense of the word in this context, bit a complete reimagining of the story with little inact from the original. Secondly, it didn't "exceed expectations", it delivered something entirely different for an entirely different group of gamers. Anyone being honest about this will remember that what was teased, promised, then dangled in front of the fanbase for years was a visual overhaul using updated assets from Advent Children, and much more powerful hardware. That is what people wanted, perhaps with the return of some cut content to flesh some sections of the game out, but that was it. Nobody asked for a complete overhaul of the game, its story, it's mechanics, and its characters. They especially didn't ask for it across multiple, full-priced installments. Now FF7R was by no means a bomb or failure, but in reality it was entirely different from what the fanbase wanted, so its inaccurate to consider it under this lists criteria.
Agreed. There’s so much great about the remake, particularly the combat and fleshing out parts of Midgar . But the remake of the story nearly ruined it. I’m playing a different universe of a game I loved, and I’m not loving the new universe.
I still can’t believe how good the combat system feels in FF7 remake. I was bummed they changed it from turn based to real time, but I was wrong. Probably one of my favorite combat systems ever
If ever get a remake of Fallout 3 it should have the Wild Wasteland perk and while hearing the radio we could hear 3 Dog unironically talking like Eden and Eden saying stuff like praising comunism and saying that america should be rebuilt to become a worker's paradise or something like that (I ask for forgiveness for my poor use of the english lenguage)
Tomb raider Anniversary deserved to be in a high position. It transformed the classic first game in a perfect version with great controls, perfect level design and it tied its story with legend
It wasn't perfect but I loved TOLZ Awakening and Skyward Sword remakes. Nintendo make skippable cutscenes, reduced the repetition and improved controls. I was satisfied.
They didn't leave it out, they changed the lore so the Verdugos became U-3. It's in the journal entries in the castle. And be honest, that thing was a fucking nightmare to fight, I'm glad they left it out, it was a horrendous section with stupid time limits as well as way too close quarters to be fighting something that could move and attack like that.
You can beat Malenia(second phase) in Elden Ring if you stun her and do a crit while she’s at low hp triggering her second phase where she will be at one hp
I want to nominate the Advance Wars 1+2 Reboot Camp. Say what you want about the graphics but the game is a love letter to all Wars series and not just the GBA ports they remade
One day I would love to see the Borderlands series on this list. I absolutely love that series, but 2 had the best content and 3 had the best mechanics, and I love 1 because it has my favorite DLC... I want them to remake the first one and the handsome Jack ones with 3's mechanics, like mantling, sliding, and slamming for splash damage. I would really like it if they also let you choose any playable character in any game, because then I could be Krieg all the time! This is absolute fantasy wishful thinking lol, but it would be so cool... Oh yeah, they could also redo the bosses in 1 and 3 lol.
I disagree with the final fantasy seven remake.... As an old school gamer who wanted a turn based remake With updated graphics we could have had it but they did not give that to us
Hm. I did not enjoy Samus Returns - even compared to the original. The controls methods with the circle pad are not a good match imho and I truely hate the way they implemented the dodge mechanic (which does feel more like work than an option). The impression has become even more obvious after Metroid Dread optimized the controls and is much more comfortable to hold.
if HGSS is on this list, ORAS better be on the next. It IS the best remake in both gameplay and sales. Only Gen 6 game worth playing again ngl. ...okay XY weren't that bad, but ORAS just knocks them out of the park for that generation.
FF VII Remake was a sequel that shat on the characters. Cloud being moody and broody the whole time made him come off like an asshole and having Jessie go through her crisis while we knew that it was Shinra is trying to have your cake and eat it too
FF7:R shouldn’t be on this list. It’s a continuation moreso than a remake of the original. The upcoming mobile game Ever Crisis is more of a real remake of FF7.
I was a fan of the FFVII remake but I also kinda hated it. I was hoping for an amazing more in depth remaster of the original. The chocobo races, knights of the round, all of that. It wasn’t there. Still a good game just felt like the creative liberties were cheap and sacrificed a flawless narrative in favor of a game that just wasn’t FFVII
Gonna have to disagree with numba 1. Resi 3's REmake was meh at best and Resident Evil 4 plays better but thats about it. Short of a couple of character changes the entire story feels worse.
Doesn’t even play better. I’ll take the laser precise chef’s kiss tank controls of the original over the clunky, floaty, stun lock heavy, stagger RNG gameplay of the remake.
@ZombiemanTemple Ah, not gonna lie I forgot my rage early on of the nonsense that was 4 shots to the head for a flinch. Once you play on professional and have to get stupidly good with the parry system, a lot of the other bullshit disappeared from the mind 😅
I have to disagree with RE4 if only because I feel like RE2 has had a longer time to leave a better impression on people and considering it was a remake of one of the PSone games it had a lot more capabilities of showing the differences when compared to RE4, which on a surface level just feels like a graphically upgraded version of the original RE4.
Also I ***greatly*** have to disagree with HG/SS if only because of Voltorb Flip alone. The inability to just outright buy the coins to get the rewards from the Game Corner that was present in every game preceding it and having to be forced to play the minigame was a huge mistake. Really about the only thing HG/SS did *right* when compared to the remainder of Gen IV was the fact it's engine was far better optimized and saving data wasn't a chore every single time you had to access the PC, and only took longer than usual if you played through the game a lot in a single session between saving. Also, the *other* thing that really did hit a nerve with HG/SS? The fact you couldn't decorate your bedroom anymore. That was one of the things I enjoyed a lot with the protagonist's home in Gen II and honestly am surprised isn't something that became a staple for every game in the series since that point onward.
Resident Evil is my favourite gaming series easy.. I’m just not a massive fan of the RE4 Remake it was kind of a drag. I know it’s loved by many I just I dunno it wasn’t for me..
I’d still kill for an FF6 remake with 7 remake’s battle system, especially if they made it co-op and expanded the story. I’m of that age where 6 will always be greater than 7. Mostly need to rebalance how espers make every character essentially the same and make the individual character skills more substantially relevant to play style.
"I’m of that age where 6 will always be greater than 7." So am I, which begs me to ask why in the ever-loving gingersnap hell would you want to destroy it with the garbage battle system of FF7R?
GIVE US A PROPER FF8 REMAKE!!! 7 got we know...and 9 is getting a remake...and 8 only got a port F that ....give us the first 3d FF in the franchise a proper remake
It ain't perfect, it's just different. No longer the same game. They just swapped for a clunkier version of controls we've already seen in Assassin's Creed, Uncharted, The Last of Us, The Evil Within, Shadow of Mordor, and BIO Revelations 2.
As a fan of the original FF7, I’m appalled anyone can call the remake better. The original game was a complete package: with fantastic story, characters, lore, progression, exploration, and battle system. Remake takes the first 5 hours of the game and literally pads out the run time with little to no world building. Remake has something around 15-20 hours of padding. So much padding that there are full chapters that are only padding. Mini games are less game and more padding. Heck even enemy encounters are padded to heck and back. FF7R is symbolic of everything wrong in the games industry. All graphics and presentation, padding, with a smattering of lizard brain “Push Button at Exact Moment or Die” gameplay. It’s far from perfect and it makes the FF7 franchise worse with its existence.
I agree that the FF7 Remake shouldn't be on this list. The best thing about it was most definitely the combat. But I also agree with you that the padding was ridiculous. It actually ruined the game for me (even though I finished it). Another thing that also took me out of the game is the character interactions (acting, voice acting and dialogue) . After seeing characters interact in and out of cutscenes in games such as TLOU, the recent Resident Evils and God of War, it's very hard to go back to the FF character interactions. With those annoying squeaky Japanese schoolgirl voices and sounds, characters over-expressively emoting and moving in a way that works perfectly in a system with severe graphical limitations, but looks ridiculous on a powerful system that can have people moving realistically (even in a fantasy setting) and that too neatly spoken and over-explanatory dialogue that fits text way better than spoken word. Because of those two things, I never really managed to get engaged and immersed into that world. I just stayed for the combat mechanics.
Resident Evil 2, 3, and 4 aren't remakes. There reimaginings that cut enemies/locations, changed lore and removed features that made the originals great with the zapping system and live selection choices.
We're gonna have to agree to disagree on FF7. It doesn't hold the same impact as the original. The brothel area is too clean and almost glorified. Despite the fact that in the original it's filled with females that were sold to settle debts. In the original, Sector 7 was a slum and horribly poverty stricken. It gives you feelings for its denizens because of the conditions they are forced to live their lives in. By the time they drop the plate on it, you are fully invested in defending these people and making their situation better. The remake just isn't there.
@@OversoulGaming that's a cheap excuse. They knew they were stepping on toes and not putting out a faithful product. They had no intention of doing so. They've already made a statement about Chocobo races not being a thing. Despite it being loved so many fans.
@@carminescurse The really sad part is that Yoshinori Kitase literally told us, in his own words, that they weren't going to make any big changes or crazy departures from the original game. He straight up lied to us. I actually DO like the remake, I do, but it's NOT FFVII in the way it should have been. If they told us from the start this was going to be alternate timeline/things will be different, I'd have been able to accept that a lot more easily. Instead we were lied to and are now being strung along while they figure out what they can piece out for DLC and suck more money out of us.
Yea well good flop. FF7R is an absolute slap in the face to the people who grew up playing and loving the original. Don't get me wrong, it IS a good game, I enjoy it, but it is NOT a remake and it isn't the FF7 most fans wanted. If they had told us from the off that it was alternate timeline /reboot, then fine, that could have been acceptable. Instead Kinase literally lied to us and told us "no big changes" were happening.
Um the first Pokémon in the player’s party walking with them wasn’t introduced in HeartGold and SoulSilver. It was actually introduced in Diamond and Pearl where you could have cute Pokémon like your starter walk with you in Amity Park. How do I know this? I’ve played Diamond and Pearl. Also, the move Rock Climb was introduced in Diamond and Pearl. So basically, HeartGold and SoulSilver happened because of Diamond and Pearl. HeartGold and SoulSilver didn’t come before Diamond, Pearl and Platinum but after.
Pokemon Yellow had Pikachu following you around first. But D/P/P was the first to have a wider selection of pokemon to follow in that one area. And then SSHG was the first to let us have the pokemon follow everywhere.
@@lyrainealei7848 I don’t get why What Culture Gaming says that HeartGold and SoulSilver introduced the Pokémon following you around mechanic when it was done first in Pokémon Yellow and also don’t get why they said that Rock Climbing was also introduced in HeartGold and SoulSilver when Diamond and Pearl actually introduced the move Rock Climb. Oh I do get why they said that. Because they didn’t play any of the previous Pokémon games.
Disagree with RE4. RE4 is one of my favorite games and the remake definitely did a great job. Perfect though? I think not. No U-3 boss fight, no Ada in Mercenaries, no assignment Ada, no separate ways. Granted Capcom may add these in DLC, which would be great. Sadly you never know with Capcom… Also praising them for adding quality of life features shouldn’t be the reason why it’s “perfect”. Things like weapon shortcuts have been in since RE2 remake, at this point it’s expected to have those features.
The fact that FF7:R is even on this list is an utter crock. 1. It's not even 1/3 of the original game 2. Half the plot is glorified fanfiction due to the time ghost shenanigans 3. It's censored across the board, forget Tifa's terrible over designed monochromatic "improved" look, they censored most of the course language Barrett used to swear like a sailer and now he barely has a personality to speak of, several plot points such as the Honey Bee Inn, Hojo's twisted treatment/plans for Aerith during her captivity at ShinRa, Jenova/Sephiroths rampage through ShinRa, the list goes on. 4. The combat system completely robbed people of any freedom of choice, instead of fighting however you wanted you HAD to fight their way due to the stagger system they integrated, otherwise you'd be hacking away at basic enemies for an hour cause you weren't using the damn method they wanted you to, CLOUD IS SWINGING A 7 FOOT PIECE OF IRON AND BARRET HAS A GUN FOR AN ARM EVERY HIT SHOULD STAGGER, and took all control away from players when it came to when and how to use summons, and god forbid you use a limit break right before one of their goofy cinematic boss phase transitions cause you're gonna end up doing 0 damage due to the boss becoming invincible at set points of health to initiate the transitions... 5. For the english dub they couldn't even be bothered to hire the existing voice actors from past entries who have been voicing the characters for years, across various FF installations and stuff like Kingdom Hearts. Aside from the graphics and music the Remake was a bloody insult, not an accomplishment. I had my complaints about the Dead Space Remake, but it sure as hell deserves to be on this list more than FF7:R
The first computer was created in 1852. Pong was created in 1972. It was roughly 150 years between the first building sized computers that could only add a few numbers together, and the Iphone. It took about an eighth of that time to go from pong to hyper realistic virtual reality worlds with their own ecology, economy, and fictional population. This is why I don't dismiss Simulation Theory
Yeaaaaah probavly gonna be an unpopular opinion but I'll stand by it.FF7 remake/sequel is kinda what's wrong with the remakes lol. Bland, overly padded, garbage voice acting, convoluted plot revisions..just a giant cash cow from an incredible IP that deserved way more than what Nomura has done to it.
The original RE4’s gameplay was just so damn precise and satisfying, while RE4R’s gameplay is just a claustrophobic mad dash of cheap ass stun locks and unreliable stagger RNG. It’s a truly terrible remake that disgraces virtually every part of the original. It saddens me deeply that it has become the definitive way to experience RE4 by all the gen z losers, and the original is becoming all but forgotten.
How is Dead Space Remake not on this?!
The horror, the horror…
Agreed it was amazing
As amazing as it was, the remake still wasn't as warranted as the games on the list
I feel like it would have been on the list if it was 11 positions long
It was masterpiece remake, Dead Space (2023) deserve to be on this list
Spyro reignited trilogy and crash bandicoot n-sane trilogy. Deserve to be on this list. I know they're technically both packages of three games but you included a package of two games so it counts imo.
Yours and his logic is stupid just because they bundle games together doesn't make them remakes , they're still remasters because they are shot for shot the same exact games just better graphics glad they didn't make the list
Those are some trash games you pointed out.
@@Setorrs Spyro and Crash are gold standard platform games, good try though.
Yeah, especially over a Pokemon game, improvement means very little to those.
@@RagnarokMic played both trilogy packs and they are god awful. If that is the gold standard then i don't ever want to see a platform game ever in my life.
In 2017 I was in an accident that left me in a wheelchair for the rest of my life. I was 27.. I spent a year in the hospital. My gf brought me her 3DS and the Pokémon Silver remake. It really helped me get through. I played the original so it brought me back to a better time and kept me busy. Great game ❤
I think everyone has a time in their life where a game comes in to take our mind off of reality, allowing us to detach for as long as that game lets us to find some peace. I couldn't imagine your circumstances, but Im glad you had some reprival from your gf (who seems like a keeper) This alone is EXACTLY why Video Games, like Cinema, are a true art form.
Explains a lot as to why HeartGold and SoulSilver are so expensive at game stores, even used. $200 USD for a used, decade old DS cartridge but a damn fine game. First Pokémon game I'd ever played was Gold version, so yes the remakes were an amazing addition. 😁
I have one major issue with Super Mario All-Stars: the block-breaking physics in SMB1 and Lost Levels. On the NES versions, Mario rebounds off the blocks when he breaks them, but in All-Stars he jumps through them and all of your momentum is lost.
But yes, the All-Stars versions of SMB2 and SMB3 are excellent.
Me already looking at all the remakes coming out and thinking, "Welp, gotta get started on a Part 2 of this list huh mate?"
Odin Sphere Leifthrasir and Muramasa Rebirth: Complete Collection deserve at least honorary mentions.
I got Odin sphere on Playstation 4 played the original on the 2 and was in love with everything about it and am not disappointed
WTF is this
Definitely Odin Sphere: Leifthrasir, such a massive improvement it feels terrible to try to play the original version in comparison.
the system shock remake is a masterpiece. i really hope they port it to consoles so everyone can experience this absolute gem
Medievil Remake deserves at least a shoutout. I just have to appreciate an oldie but a goodie classic game.
I want to check that one out.
Nice ending message. Love it. Thanks for the well wishes, here's wishing the same to you all!
HGSS is still the best mainline game in the Pokemon franchise and absolutely worth playing today
100% My gold standard for Pokémon Remakes. Then FRLG for Kanto. SDBP was close since it was basically a port with upgraded graphics. I rank, sadly, ORAS below those three basically because there felt like a lot of hand holding to drag me to the next plot point and then the stuff that was added was "meh".
Your positive messages at the end of your videos always help my day, cheers.
I am a huge Resident Evil fan, but I just can’t agree. None of the remakes are perfect. They might be great reimaginings, but that’s about it.
Resident Evil 4 in particular is far from perfect. Lost a lot of its charm, simplified some boss designs, cut many memorable scenes and locations, etc. While not as bad as Resident Evil 3, it’s just not as good as the original in my eyes, even if it’s still a great game.
Although, I love the remake’s Louis, he is amazing and deserves the world.
Very fair comment. If they were faithful recreations that preserved the og's only then they could have been considered perfected, like how it was with RE1.
I think it turned out a lot better than expected. It’s not a 1 to 1 remake and I feel that the original was better in a lot ways (Leon was cooler), but do people really enjoy that? The original RE1 remake was good, but everything was pretty much the same as the OG, though it better graphics and some new areas.
Some of the stuff they cut out though was outdated misogynistic BS that only appeals to incels
@@nightinxgale7083 RE1R is the closest to perfecting its original game, it achieved this by being faithful and preserving the og. Being a reimagining that changes things drastically for no good reason can't grant RE4R the title of perfected or nearly perfected RE4, just different RE4. So i don't think it should be on this list.
See... I could never get on with the original RE games back in the day. The 'tank' controls were nothing other than frustrating to me. I really wanted to enjoy them like everyone else did, but they just annoyed me.
I LOVED finally being able to experience a version of Resident Evil 2 that didn't make me want to snap my controller in half.
I will say I’m surprised you didn’t have Dead Space on this list
I feel the same way
FF7R's inclusion on this list is debatable. First and foremost, because its not a "remake" in the common sense of the word in this context, bit a complete reimagining of the story with little inact from the original.
Secondly, it didn't "exceed expectations", it delivered something entirely different for an entirely different group of gamers. Anyone being honest about this will remember that what was teased, promised, then dangled in front of the fanbase for years was a visual overhaul using updated assets from Advent Children, and much more powerful hardware. That is what people wanted, perhaps with the return of some cut content to flesh some sections of the game out, but that was it.
Nobody asked for a complete overhaul of the game, its story, it's mechanics, and its characters. They especially didn't ask for it across multiple, full-priced installments. Now FF7R was by no means a bomb or failure, but in reality it was entirely different from what the fanbase wanted, so its inaccurate to consider it under this lists criteria.
Agreed. There’s so much great about the remake, particularly the combat and fleshing out parts of Midgar . But the remake of the story nearly ruined it. I’m playing a different universe of a game I loved, and I’m not loving the new universe.
I still can’t believe how good the combat system feels in FF7 remake. I was bummed they changed it from turn based to real time, but I was wrong. Probably one of my favorite combat systems ever
Black Mesa? Considering it's developed by regular people, it deserves a mention in my book
I dont consider re4 no here, it still has something missing from the original one, i wold put the re1 remake ínstead of the fourth one, and dead Space
Was expecting Black Mesa on this list
If ever get a remake of Fallout 3 it should have the Wild Wasteland perk and while hearing the radio we could hear 3 Dog unironically talking like Eden and Eden saying stuff like praising comunism and saying that america should be rebuilt to become a worker's paradise or something like that (I ask for forgiveness for my poor use of the english lenguage)
Speak for yourself, Jules!! The first RE4 holds up pretty much perfectly. Pauses band QTEs and all
Let's hope in the future the soon super mario rpg remake makes the list
Tomb raider Anniversary deserved to be in a high position. It transformed the classic first game in a perfect version with great controls, perfect level design and it tied its story with legend
Heart gold for life
Come on, Jules. Spyro Reignited, Odin Sphere Leifthrasir and Crash N-Sane Trilogy deserved at least a honorable mention.
The Spiderman stealth sections are fine.
You missed some the spryro and crash bandicoot trilogy remake, crash team racing remake, spiderman remastered, resident evil 1 remake
-Yakuza Kiwami & 2
-Medievil
Meanwhile the Dead Space remake is in the corner like "what am I, a joke to you?"
I recently played the remastered Version of shadow of the colossus and it is a diamond made from a gem
11:34 "Your memo, Memo-mo "
I need to play final fantasy 7… I just keep hearing so much about it and I love FF10.
AM2R should be on here instead of Samus Returns; although it's not an official release, it's objectively better.
Lol, still waiting on that Let's Go 2 to Bring Gold and Silver finally up to par with Let's Go Eevee and Let's Go, Pikachu
It wasn't perfect but I loved TOLZ Awakening and Skyward Sword remakes. Nintendo make skippable cutscenes, reduced the repetition and improved controls. I was satisfied.
Top 10 remakes people are looking forward to. For example perfect dark remake.
Hey you forgot Dead Space !!
Still can’t believe they left U3 out of the re4 remake. Seems like a crime
There are hints that it would show up in a Separate Ways DLC, but Capcom hasn't made any announcements on the matter yet, so who knows.
They didn't leave it out, they changed the lore so the Verdugos became U-3. It's in the journal entries in the castle. And be honest, that thing was a fucking nightmare to fight, I'm glad they left it out, it was a horrendous section with stupid time limits as well as way too close quarters to be fighting something that could move and attack like that.
I want a new Pacific Theatre of Operations! I love 4x but not going to hold my breath!
You can beat Malenia(second phase) in Elden Ring if you stun her and do a crit while she’s at low hp triggering her second phase where she will be at one hp
Oh man….. nothing like being a part of a game that’s number one on your list!
🤘😎🤘
Heartgold and soulsipver are my favorite pokemon games and imo it went downhill from there
Yakuza 1 & 2 remakes better be here.
WHAT YEAR WERE THEY RELEASED IN BLOODY HELL THIS IS TOP 10S 101 SHT HERE
The ff7 “remake” is a disgrace to the original game and the all stars remakes butchered the Mario trilogy
I think there was a mistake made here.
N°1 IS Dead Space
Resident Evil 4 is not a good remake
CROWBSCAT MADE A VIDEO ABOUT IT!!!
I'm surprised Crash N Sane Trilogy isn't on here.
I really want an airblade remake without the gods damn clock
I want to nominate the Advance Wars 1+2 Reboot Camp. Say what you want about the graphics but the game is a love letter to all Wars series and not just the GBA ports they remade
I wouldn’t say that remakes of all of the Resident Evil games “knocked it out of the park” as 3 was only okay.
RE3R didn't knock it out of the park, it REMOVED the park 😂
@@AndreiCatalin42069thats what he said
@@DanielAntunes1 yeah, i know, i just made a joke about the cut content in that game.
Yea, and 4 was garbage.
One day I would love to see the Borderlands series on this list. I absolutely love that series, but 2 had the best content and 3 had the best mechanics, and I love 1 because it has my favorite DLC... I want them to remake the first one and the handsome Jack ones with 3's mechanics, like mantling, sliding, and slamming for splash damage. I would really like it if they also let you choose any playable character in any game, because then I could be Krieg all the time! This is absolute fantasy wishful thinking lol, but it would be so cool... Oh yeah, they could also redo the bosses in 1 and 3 lol.
I disagree with the final fantasy seven remake.... As an old school gamer who wanted a turn based remake With updated graphics we could have had it but they did not give that to us
Agreed it's not even a remake more a re imagined as its a new story
Hm. I did not enjoy Samus Returns - even compared to the original. The controls methods with the circle pad are not a good match imho and I truely hate the way they implemented the dodge mechanic (which does feel more like work than an option). The impression has become even more obvious after Metroid Dread optimized the controls and is much more comfortable to hold.
if HGSS is on this list, ORAS better be on the next. It IS the best remake in both gameplay and sales. Only Gen 6 game worth playing again ngl. ...okay XY weren't that bad, but ORAS just knocks them out of the park for that generation.
Notveven a mention of the Dead Space remake???
Guess this list needs a...... remake. 😏
Ok I'll let myself out now.
pokemon heartgold and soulsilver was the best remake for pokemon and the last...hope the gamecube games get a remake combination with new stuff.
The remastered version of Gears of War should of made this list 🎉
Remaster is not a remake.
We need a damn Playboy mansion game already
How is the resident evil for the cube not here !! Jelws shame on you
I was thinking the same
FF VII Remake was a sequel that shat on the characters. Cloud being moody and broody the whole time made him come off like an asshole and having Jessie go through her crisis while we knew that it was Shinra is trying to have your cake and eat it too
Since when has Cloud not been a moody, broody asshole? 🧐
I have no memory of the Salazar robot
I hope Nosferatu: the wrath of Malachi will have it's own remake
What now
Gears of War Ultimate is my favorite remake
FF7:R shouldn’t be on this list. It’s a continuation moreso than a remake of the original. The upcoming mobile game Ever Crisis is more of a real remake of FF7.
I was a fan of the FFVII remake but I also kinda hated it. I was hoping for an amazing more in depth remaster of the original. The chocobo races, knights of the round, all of that. It wasn’t there. Still a good game just felt like the creative liberties were cheap and sacrificed a flawless narrative in favor of a game that just wasn’t FFVII
Gonna have to disagree with numba 1. Resi 3's REmake was meh at best and Resident Evil 4 plays better but thats about it. Short of a couple of character changes the entire story feels worse.
Doesn’t even play better. I’ll take the laser precise chef’s kiss tank controls of the original over the clunky, floaty, stun lock heavy, stagger RNG gameplay of the remake.
@ZombiemanTemple Ah, not gonna lie I forgot my rage early on of the nonsense that was 4 shots to the head for a flinch. Once you play on professional and have to get stupidly good with the parry system, a lot of the other bullshit disappeared from the mind 😅
I hope P3R to be the case.
Nier replicant was a brilliant remake. It improved on everything from the orginal game
I want a Banjo Kazooie/Tooie Remake!
I have to disagree with RE4 if only because I feel like RE2 has had a longer time to leave a better impression on people and considering it was a remake of one of the PSone games it had a lot more capabilities of showing the differences when compared to RE4, which on a surface level just feels like a graphically upgraded version of the original RE4.
Also I ***greatly*** have to disagree with HG/SS if only because of Voltorb Flip alone. The inability to just outright buy the coins to get the rewards from the Game Corner that was present in every game preceding it and having to be forced to play the minigame was a huge mistake. Really about the only thing HG/SS did *right* when compared to the remainder of Gen IV was the fact it's engine was far better optimized and saving data wasn't a chore every single time you had to access the PC, and only took longer than usual if you played through the game a lot in a single session between saving.
Also, the *other* thing that really did hit a nerve with HG/SS? The fact you couldn't decorate your bedroom anymore. That was one of the things I enjoyed a lot with the protagonist's home in Gen II and honestly am surprised isn't something that became a staple for every game in the series since that point onward.
And a massive gameplay DOWNGRADE.
I think Mafia definitive edition deserves an honorable mention
Now the remake that evolve backwards
They say hat System Shock, the game i care most on this list, is also a big time waste of backtracking and a chore in crafting.
Resident Evil is my favourite gaming series easy.. I’m just not a massive fan of the RE4 Remake it was kind of a drag. I know it’s loved by many I just I dunno it wasn’t for me..
I’d still kill for an FF6 remake with 7 remake’s battle system, especially if they made it co-op and expanded the story.
I’m of that age where 6 will always be greater than 7. Mostly need to rebalance how espers make every character essentially the same and make the individual character skills more substantially relevant to play style.
"I’m of that age where 6 will always be greater than 7."
So am I, which begs me to ask why in the ever-loving gingersnap hell would you want to destroy it with the garbage battle system of FF7R?
@@mage1439 Because your opinion isn't the only opinion.
GIVE US A PROPER FF8 REMAKE!!! 7 got we know...and 9 is getting a remake...and 8 only got a port F that ....give us the first 3d FF in the franchise a proper remake
It ain't perfect, it's just different. No longer the same game. They just swapped for a clunkier version of controls we've already seen in Assassin's Creed, Uncharted, The Last of Us, The Evil Within, Shadow of Mordor, and BIO Revelations 2.
As a fan of the original FF7, I’m appalled anyone can call the remake better. The original game was a complete package: with fantastic story, characters, lore, progression, exploration, and battle system.
Remake takes the first 5 hours of the game and literally pads out the run time with little to no world building. Remake has something around 15-20 hours of padding. So much padding that there are full chapters that are only padding. Mini games are less game and more padding. Heck even enemy encounters are padded to heck and back.
FF7R is symbolic of everything wrong in the games industry. All graphics and presentation, padding, with a smattering of lizard brain “Push Button at Exact Moment or Die” gameplay. It’s far from perfect and it makes the FF7 franchise worse with its existence.
Not to mention the fact that the final villain was barely in the game and was not who you had been fighting up to that point.
I agree that the FF7 Remake shouldn't be on this list. The best thing about it was most definitely the combat. But I also agree with you that the padding was ridiculous. It actually ruined the game for me (even though I finished it).
Another thing that also took me out of the game is the character interactions (acting, voice acting and dialogue) . After seeing characters interact in and out of cutscenes in games such as TLOU, the recent Resident Evils and God of War, it's very hard to go back to the FF character interactions. With those annoying squeaky Japanese schoolgirl voices and sounds, characters over-expressively emoting and moving in a way that works perfectly in a system with severe graphical limitations, but looks ridiculous on a powerful system that can have people moving realistically (even in a fantasy setting) and that too neatly spoken and over-explanatory dialogue that fits text way better than spoken word.
Because of those two things, I never really managed to get engaged and immersed into that world. I just stayed for the combat mechanics.
Resident Evil 2, 3, and 4 aren't remakes. There reimaginings that cut enemies/locations, changed lore and removed features that made the originals great with the zapping system and live selection choices.
They are remakes even if they are reimaginings but with everything else you're right, screw 'em, perfected they say...
What a pointless comment, almost as pointless as my reply
@@Ertdoinn reply which is also almost as pointless as making reimaginings of games and not faithful ones at least.
2 was a massive improvement over og. Still the king of remakes imo. 3 was just decent, and 4 was a soul crushing disgrace.
ANOTHER list with Shadow of the Colossus on it.
Erm, Dead Space???
9. it was a good remastered or remake.
We're gonna have to agree to disagree on FF7. It doesn't hold the same impact as the original. The brothel area is too clean and almost glorified. Despite the fact that in the original it's filled with females that were sold to settle debts. In the original, Sector 7 was a slum and horribly poverty stricken. It gives you feelings for its denizens because of the conditions they are forced to live their lives in. By the time they drop the plate on it, you are fully invested in defending these people and making their situation better. The remake just isn't there.
It’s also not a real remake! How is it perfect as a “remake” if it changes the story and cuts 75% of the original content!?
It also exists in a separate timeline from the original so there's that.
@@OversoulGaming that's a cheap excuse. They knew they were stepping on toes and not putting out a faithful product. They had no intention of doing so. They've already made a statement about Chocobo races not being a thing. Despite it being loved so many fans.
@@carminescurse The really sad part is that Yoshinori Kitase literally told us, in his own words, that they weren't going to make any big changes or crazy departures from the original game. He straight up lied to us. I actually DO like the remake, I do, but it's NOT FFVII in the way it should have been. If they told us from the start this was going to be alternate timeline/things will be different, I'd have been able to accept that a lot more easily. Instead we were lied to and are now being strung along while they figure out what they can piece out for DLC and suck more money out of us.
At this point it's a continuation, or alternative/multiverse version of things. I don't count it as a remake and greatly prefer the original
resy 2 should be on here
Yea well good flop. FF7R is an absolute slap in the face to the people who grew up playing and loving the original. Don't get me wrong, it IS a good game, I enjoy it, but it is NOT a remake and it isn't the FF7 most fans wanted. If they had told us from the off that it was alternate timeline /reboot, then fine, that could have been acceptable. Instead Kinase literally lied to us and told us "no big changes" were happening.
hey what about Dead Space?
Um the first Pokémon in the player’s party walking with them wasn’t introduced in HeartGold and SoulSilver. It was actually introduced in Diamond and Pearl where you could have cute Pokémon like your starter walk with you in Amity Park. How do I know this? I’ve played Diamond and Pearl. Also, the move Rock Climb was introduced in Diamond and Pearl. So basically, HeartGold and SoulSilver happened because of Diamond and Pearl. HeartGold and SoulSilver didn’t come before Diamond, Pearl and Platinum but after.
Pokemon Yellow had Pikachu following you around first. But D/P/P was the first to have a wider selection of pokemon to follow in that one area. And then SSHG was the first to let us have the pokemon follow everywhere.
@@lyrainealei7848 I don’t get why What Culture Gaming says that HeartGold and SoulSilver introduced the Pokémon following you around mechanic when it was done first in Pokémon Yellow and also don’t get why they said that Rock Climbing was also introduced in HeartGold and SoulSilver when Diamond and Pearl actually introduced the move Rock Climb. Oh I do get why they said that. Because they didn’t play any of the previous Pokémon games.
Legend of zelda ocarina of time 3ds remake
Disagree with RE4. RE4 is one of my favorite games and the remake definitely did a great job. Perfect though? I think not. No U-3 boss fight, no Ada in Mercenaries, no assignment Ada, no separate ways. Granted Capcom may add these in DLC, which would be great. Sadly you never know with Capcom…
Also praising them for adding quality of life features shouldn’t be the reason why it’s “perfect”. Things like weapon shortcuts have been in since RE2 remake, at this point it’s expected to have those features.
I honestly think “did a great job” would be a stretch.
@@ZombiemanTemple In comparison to RE3 remake id say it's great lmao
What about Yakuza Kiwami 2??
No DS or Metroid Prime remake/remaster? 😅
I kinda object to the FF7 Remake being on this list, 'cus we only have the first part of it so far.
Let's be honest the OG RE4 IS WAAAAAAAAAY better than the remake smh y'all are crazy if you think differently
The fact that FF7:R is even on this list is an utter crock.
1. It's not even 1/3 of the original game
2. Half the plot is glorified fanfiction due to the time ghost shenanigans
3. It's censored across the board, forget Tifa's terrible over designed monochromatic "improved" look, they censored most of the course language Barrett used to swear like a sailer and now he barely has a personality to speak of, several plot points such as the Honey Bee Inn, Hojo's twisted treatment/plans for Aerith during her captivity at ShinRa, Jenova/Sephiroths rampage through ShinRa, the list goes on.
4. The combat system completely robbed people of any freedom of choice, instead of fighting however you wanted you HAD to fight their way due to the stagger system they integrated, otherwise you'd be hacking away at basic enemies for an hour cause you weren't using the damn method they wanted you to, CLOUD IS SWINGING A 7 FOOT PIECE OF IRON AND BARRET HAS A GUN FOR AN ARM EVERY HIT SHOULD STAGGER, and took all control away from players when it came to when and how to use summons, and god forbid you use a limit break right before one of their goofy cinematic boss phase transitions cause you're gonna end up doing 0 damage due to the boss becoming invincible at set points of health to initiate the transitions...
5. For the english dub they couldn't even be bothered to hire the existing voice actors from past entries who have been voicing the characters for years, across various FF installations and stuff like Kingdom Hearts.
Aside from the graphics and music the Remake was a bloody insult, not an accomplishment.
I had my complaints about the Dead Space Remake, but it sure as hell deserves to be on this list more than FF7:R
The first computer was created in 1852.
Pong was created in 1972.
It was roughly 150 years between the first building sized computers that could only add a few numbers together, and the Iphone.
It took about an eighth of that time to go from pong to hyper realistic virtual reality worlds with their own ecology, economy, and fictional population.
This is why I don't dismiss Simulation Theory
Hard disagree on Metroid: Samus Returns. The remake of the original Metroid 2: Return of Samus that was PERFECT was AM2R.
I would argue that Ashley is equally as insufferable as she was in the original. They just replaced “LEON HELP!” With a scream. 🤦🏽♂️
Yeaaaaah probavly gonna be an unpopular opinion but I'll stand by it.FF7 remake/sequel is kinda what's wrong with the remakes lol. Bland, overly padded, garbage voice acting, convoluted plot revisions..just a giant cash cow from an incredible IP that deserved way more than what Nomura has done to it.
JET SET RADIOOOOOOOO
FUTURE!
The original RE4’s gameplay was just so damn precise and satisfying, while RE4R’s gameplay is just a claustrophobic mad dash of cheap ass stun locks and unreliable stagger RNG. It’s a truly terrible remake that disgraces virtually every part of the original. It saddens me deeply that it has become the definitive way to experience RE4 by all the gen z losers, and the original is becoming all but forgotten.