The Exodus: What Does Merneptah's Stela Really Say?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
  • Many people talk about Merneptah's famouns stela, but does it really give evidence that the Exodus happened?
    Religion of the Black Land is a new book, by Danita Smith. It discusses Kemetic and Kushite theology, from the perspective of their documents:
    - The 42 Declarations of Innocence
    - The Shabaka Stone (Memphite Theology)
    - The Ausarian Tale (and Auset)
    - The Teachings of Ptahhotep
    - The Victory Stela of Piankhy
    Please check it out on AMAZON, on my author page: www.amazon.com...
    Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @blackandeducation
    Email for serious inquiries at: blackandeducation@gmail.com
    Images in Open Access and public domain:
    “Shabti of Merneptah,” Egyptian Art. Metropolitan Museum of Art,
    New York. Edward S. Harkness Gift, 1926. Open access image.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 39

  • @blackandeducation
    @blackandeducation  Місяць тому +11

    Analyzing documents for yourself is a better way of discovering history, rather than watching a television show that asks questions, but never walks through the document that they know exists

    • @dehaven46
      @dehaven46 Місяць тому

      The stars are the people these ancient texts are referring to! It's all astrology mythology! How I recognize it is the meanings of names. Theophic names 👍🏿 I mean no disrespect is not referring to people or what's going on in Earth it's all astrology and what's going on above

  • @excelternow
    @excelternow Місяць тому +7

    These ancient kingdoms come alive through your narrative 🎉 Very enlightening podcasts, Thank you!🌟💯💖

  • @Bikdeni
    @Bikdeni Місяць тому +5

    During my visit to Egypt last year, our guide explained that the Merneptah's stela proves Isreal existed, but later said the words in Medw spelled "Israr".. and the name Isreal had not been "achieved" yet. So I asked how does his prove that it was Isreal? He cited "because all the Egyptologists came together to "make it so!"

    • @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk
      @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk Місяць тому

      the words transliterated are isrr you have to remember there are no vowels in mdw ntr

    • @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk
      @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk 19 днів тому

      this cant be correct transliterated it would be srr there are no vowels present in ancient egyptian

  • @blackandeducation
    @blackandeducation  Місяць тому +5

    Merneptah was the son of Rameses II and was ruler at a time when Kemet was at the height of its international power

    • @welyotu821
      @welyotu821 27 днів тому

      When do join to me a member need the link please

  • @nefertinaabrams1853
    @nefertinaabrams1853 Місяць тому +1

    Love the way that you explicate the information, which is very interesting and relatable.

  • @brentoniverson1020
    @brentoniverson1020 Місяць тому +3

    Appreciate you 👁❤️💪🏿💯

  • @TheButterphoenix
    @TheButterphoenix Місяць тому +2

    thank you for sharing your amazing research & heart with us.

  • @blackandeducation
    @blackandeducation  Місяць тому +5

    If the Exodus really did exist or happen, I don't think the Stela of Merneptah is a reference that says that, maybe some other sources...but not this one...in my opinion.

    • @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk
      @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk Місяць тому +2

      it is the only known writing in egypt to mention isreal but it isnt close to the exodus the translation is something like israel is a widow of egypt her seed is no more

    • @Keith-g3l
      @Keith-g3l Місяць тому

      ​​@@ChrisThornburn-ke5xkthe stela does not say Israel. Caucasian translators use that word to fit their biblical narrative. The word in itself is nothing more than the combination of three Egyptian deities. Is=isis. Ra=the sun. El=the source. Also there was no people called nubians in that area or of that time frame not even people called egyptian. The land mass up and down the nile was called tamare and the people were all nappy hair wide nose big lips. Again foreign translators try to portray people living in different areas of the same land as being of different races or ethnicity same as when europeans devided africa up to make it seem like nigerians and cameroons are a different people when both names are of european origin.

    • @Keith-g3l
      @Keith-g3l Місяць тому

      ​​@@ChrisThornburn-ke5xkthe stela does not say Israel. Translators use that word to fit their biblical narrative. The word in itself is nothing more than the combination of three Egyptian deities. Is=isis. Ra= the sun. El=the source. Also there was no people called nubians in that area or time period. The land mass up and down the Nile was called tamare and the people were all nappy hair wide nose big lips. Again foreigners try to portray people living in different areas of the same land as being of a different race or ethnicity same as when europeans divided up africa to make it seem like Nigerians and Cameroons and their neighbors are a different people.

    • @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk
      @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk 28 днів тому

      @@Keith-g3l so why dont royal mummies have wide noses big lips and nappy hair what ever that is all studies agree they were caucasian

  • @lf1496
    @lf1496 Місяць тому +2

    Their religion is almost the same as Nigerian IFA. The idea of Balance and having good character are central in IFA. , Balancing water, fire, air, earth. These elements are manifested in the divine beings or energies, the orishas, which are different aspects of Olodumare, the supreme creator. The Yoruba of Nigeria are some of the people who were present in the Nile Valley, migrating there during the Green Sahara, 6,000 - 11,000 years ago. 🌍The orisha Eshu is like Shu a supporter of the creator Olodumare🌍

  • @edgarsnake2857
    @edgarsnake2857 Місяць тому +4

    I agree with you about the Merneptah Stele. The reference to Israel on the stele mentions the conquering of a place, and perhaps the people inhabiting that place, but with no other qualifying facts. The stele says nothing, and implies nothing, that the people inhabiting Israel are a repatriated group who had been held as slaves in Kemet. No evidence has been found to verify 'the Exodus.' Zero.
    But, it's a whopper of a story. And I appreciate you telling the whole story of the Merneptah Stele...where the evidence is literally written in stone..

  • @KHooks
    @KHooks Місяць тому +2

    Danny Williams...Tomb of Kheruef, not Amenhotep my mistake.

  • @kiritugeorge4684
    @kiritugeorge4684 Місяць тому +1

    Excellent video Dr. Smith, I'm grateful. I'd like to second the comment of Mentuhotep II and the expedition to Chad. I've read an artile linked below that talks about how the expedition is massively impactful on the amduat. In particular I find this passage from the article interesting
    “Re gains access to the underworld through the ‘western portico (arry.t) of the horizon,’ a passageway of 1,260 km,” a pretty exact number for a mystical place. “If this number has any factual basis, it could be seen as the distance between the oasis of Dakhlah [the start of the trail] and the northern shore of Lake Bodele,” writes Schneider.
    I find it interesting because of the green sahara theory and that majority of Africans during the time lived around the Chad megalake. Was he amduat a memory of a past time?

  • @lf1496
    @lf1496 Місяць тому +2

    Their religion is almost the same as Nigerian IFA. The idea of Balance and having good character are central in IFA. , Balancing water, fire, air, earth. These elements are manifested in the divine beings, the orishas, which are different aspects of Olodumare, the supreme creator. The Yoruba of Nigeria are some of the people who were present in the Nile Valley, migrating there during the Green Sahara period 6000 -11,000 years ago 🌍The orisha Eshu is like Shu a supporter of the creator Olodumare

    • @dehaven46
      @dehaven46 Місяць тому

      Now, if you go back and read the Quran and the Bible, you will notice where that knowledge comes from! No disrespect intended

    • @lf1496
      @lf1496 Місяць тому +2

      @@dehaven46 IFA is a 20,000 year old system, before there were any Abrahamic religions. No disrespect also❤️

    • @dehaven46
      @dehaven46 Місяць тому

      @@lf1496 I'm saying the abrahamic religions piggyback off of that science👍🏿✌🏿

  • @doorofel6447
    @doorofel6447 Місяць тому +2

    The stele was reported to have been mistranslated. It doesn't say Israel, it says, Jezreel. The town of Jezreel is mentioned in other historical documents, in the very same area.

    • @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk
      @ChrisThornburn-ke5xk Місяць тому

      and the stele cant say jezreel the stele is talking about other kingdoms many translations say isreal you must remember there are no vowels in ancient egyptian writting

  • @user-cx7fz5pi9s
    @user-cx7fz5pi9s Місяць тому

    Wonderful channel 👏 for knowledge seekers

  • @jtg408
    @jtg408 Місяць тому +2

    Was it Ramesses 2 whose haplogroup was A1B1A, making him a Bantu ??

  • @Thutmosis7
    @Thutmosis7 Місяць тому +2

    It had nothing to do with fictional exodus.

  • @ron1313
    @ron1313 Місяць тому

    Before th Völkerwanderung (the great migration) where there what we call "white poeple" in Egypt , was this a large population?
    What's the timeline of SLC45A2 & OCA2 types people in Egypt? Was the downfall of Egypt due to this Völkerwanderung invasion or internal treats?

  • @user-dj6yr2mn3v
    @user-dj6yr2mn3v Місяць тому

    Everything in the Bible is bullshit there was never a mosses lmao 🤣