Is BookTok Hurting Book Quality? Fast Fashion in Publishing Explored in Less Than 5 Minutes

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 32

  • @Eremon17
    @Eremon17 4 місяці тому +5

    Btw, would love to have a longer video on this, you did a great job!

  • @Eremon17
    @Eremon17 4 місяці тому +4

    So glad, someonse said it! Also the pressure for an author to publish one book a year is just bullshit, I would rather wait two years and get good quality than have one book a year (yes, there are exceptions like George R. R. Martin, but my point still stands)

    • @BookClubbers
      @BookClubbers  4 місяці тому

      Quality over quantity! Who knows if he’ll ever finish the series 🤣

  • @indago5032
    @indago5032 4 місяці тому +8

    Thank goodness someone said it! I hope literature publications shift to an award-based or contest system.

    • @BookClubbers
      @BookClubbers  4 місяці тому

      We’ll have to wait and see!

    • @adroitws1367
      @adroitws1367 3 місяці тому +1

      might happen on small scale/ niche, but wont happen on mass market. Mass produced books need massive consumers to keep the engine running

  • @Cantseemuch
    @Cantseemuch 4 місяці тому +5

    It feels like 80% of new books are cheesy romance novels. Some aren’t really distinguishable. It’s sad because I grew up reading and love novels.
    Thanks to the changing trends I turned to classics, history and more „mature“ books aimed at older readers. Fortunately here in Germany there is a quite active literature culture completely independent from the trends.

    • @BookClubbers
      @BookClubbers  4 місяці тому +2

      For sure! It's hard to find more different types of books as they usually aren't spotlighted. So there's more work on our end to research and find them.

  • @pandapan5797
    @pandapan5797 4 місяці тому +3

    Thats a nicce video! I wish you the best in this channel!!

  • @TheresaReichley
    @TheresaReichley 4 місяці тому +1

    This is what turned me off of writing for money. You basically no matter how you get published are depending on marketing yourself and if you don’t Go Viral, you can forget it. Which means that you can’t keep a day job and break even on the costs of writing and editing and so on. You have to take a second job marketing yourself and your books on top of writing every day and writing 2000 words at that. It’s no longer art, it’s a small business, and I tell people that all the time - don’t bother writing a book unless you’re ready and willing to work 70 hours a week on being successful and being a celebrity pushing social media, don’t start. It’s not a hobby, it a business, and you better be able to do it yourself or you’ll go broke trying.

    • @BookClubbers
      @BookClubbers  4 місяці тому

      Interesting take. Authors can't just rely on publishers to market their book. Its not enough just to get in bookstores anymore. I've seen heaps of more self-publishing happening because people can just market themselves. The landscape has changed for sure. Running a business is hard, and it's not for everyone.

    • @TheresaReichley
      @TheresaReichley 4 місяці тому

      @@BookClubbers traditional publishing will do *some* marketing. But not very much, and they very much expect that you will be doing marketing yourself.

    • @TheresaReichley
      @TheresaReichley 4 місяці тому

      @@BookClubbers it’s not just that they can market themselves, but that either way they have to. The trad publishers do less and less for new authors, and so those authors are stuck with the task of marketing either way.

  • @melodysafo5437
    @melodysafo5437 4 місяці тому

    Very insightful

  • @bradfordwilson4742
    @bradfordwilson4742 4 місяці тому +5

    So publishing industry's have turned into the music industry. Great. Smfh 🤦

    • @BookClubbers
      @BookClubbers  4 місяці тому +2

      It's all about making the most money!

    • @DontCareL0L
      @DontCareL0L 4 місяці тому +2

      @@bradfordwilson4742 Fr fr. It's honestly more like the film industry in my opinion. All about meeting the criteria over quality. Like, Disney has a Queer quota they need to meet. Similarly, books these days have a Queer quota they need to meet too. Especially in fantasy books. And while I, a Queer person, appreciate the representation... I would like books that have QUALITY over criteria. Straight fiction that has a proper storyline, is better than woman x woman with just smut. Money comes from quality. Not quantity. The industry needs to learn that.

  • @fluffy8366
    @fluffy8366 3 місяці тому

    How is it that everything is a problem

    • @Akiono-ih5tl
      @Akiono-ih5tl 3 місяці тому

      i get that, but this one definitely IS a problem

  • @ForkEnthusiast-tw8fg
    @ForkEnthusiast-tw8fg 4 місяці тому

    Nice work.

  • @carminamusic6148
    @carminamusic6148 4 місяці тому

    ❤❤❤

  • @Tamietwist
    @Tamietwist 4 місяці тому +1

    No finally writers get easy marketing and actually sales for their books. Unlike actual shit you don't need. Don't hate. Creatives already have it hard as is. Be happy for someone else for once. 😅

    • @BookClubbers
      @BookClubbers  4 місяці тому +4

      There’s no hate at all? it’s a really nuanced topic. You’re right in that BookTok provides much-needed marketing opportunities, which is a positive. I’ve read heaps of booktok books myself! But dismissing the complexities of the issue, such as the risk of all books starting to feel the same and the marginalisation of diverse books getting published. The ultimate goal is to find a balance where both trend-following and non-trend-following creatives can thrive 🙌 ☺️

    • @DanLyndon
      @DanLyndon 4 місяці тому +5

      Good writers can't get their books sold at all anymore because all people care about is spice level and whether it aligns with certain tropes that booktok wants to recycle over and over again. How on earth is this helping authors, except the few sellouts who just want to get rich off of the trend?

    • @Akiono-ih5tl
      @Akiono-ih5tl 3 місяці тому

      your comment reflects on how dumb you are considering you're a reader who only consume books worse than wattpad quality 😂