Masaman's 2021 Ethno-Racial Map of the World (Part 2: Europe)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лют 2021
- Here is the latest installment in the 2021 Masamap series chronicling the distinct ethno-racial-religious-linguistic groups of the world, this time focused on the European continent. With over 700 million people, Europe is certainly a hardy task to pinpoint the different ethnic and cultural identities that transcend borders and modern nations, but I feel I have created a good representation of not only the historic ethnic groups of the continent, but also some of the more contentious nuances surrounding the linguistic and religious makeup of some of these groups.
Part 3 will be out shortly, followed by an eventual release of the full map, but keep in mind, some of the areas may change, as I reserve the right to revise and edit my work. Thank you all so much for the encouragement and patience you've shown over the years and thanks for watching!
I hope you are safe in Texas, Masaman.
We all hope.
Everything is normal now, the temperature is so hot we’re dying of heat now
@@dungeonbeast1087 I’m sorry 😐 you should move up north.
Love your pfp
@@noensomserdegsoveomnattenp7732 you should watch acts 17 apologetics and pfander films and dcci ministries and christian prince and Rob christian on UA-cam channel and watch all the videos on UA-cam noen 😀😀
Those who are saying that this is more ethnolinguistic than "ethnoracial" are right. It doesn't take into account all the assimilation. Especially in the Balkans.
from trieste to thesaloniki people are genetically the same, so it's actually more racial than ethinc sonce he put serbs and croats in the same group
@@gahdhsh623 but they are the same group
@@Maroke21 by language and genetics yes, by ethnicity not so much since modern croatian ethnicity is based primarily on the differences with serbs (roman catholicism)
I would call this an ethno-linguistic map, not an ethno-racial map.
Also because using the word "race" for humans is a big no- no in certain european cultures (*cough* germany *cough*)
@@valentinmitterbauer4196 US people are obsessed with the term race, that's why, even though it is incorrect for this topic
I mean yeah cause it doesn't account for all the assimilation. Especially in the Balkans.
Because we think today of all Europeans as single race. Thus ethno linguistic rather than racial. Racial map would include Dinarics, Pontids, Alpinids, Nordics etc subraces of Europeans. People of every ethnicity can belong to any of above sub races altough some may be more common than others in particular ethnic group
yeah i dont see gorals and lemkos with are not acctualy from slavic desent
As an italian, I think that classifying both Tuscany and Sicily, whose inhabitants have completely different cultures, under the same group, while leaving regions like Emilia-Romagna, which is much closer to the central italian culture than the venetian one, outside of it, is a little weird. I'd suggest making a new subdivision for the central italian dialects, which are spoken in most of Latium, Umbria, Marche and in some parts of Abruzzo, and including the tuscan dialects too in it, since all of these regions have been highly influenced by standard "tuscan" italian language and culture. Nonetheless, great work on everything else, keep going!
Emilia has nothing to do with central italy. It's northern italy and it was part of lombardy before 1861, we speak a celtic romance dialect just as lombardy and piedmont
@@andersen3692 Emilia was part of Lombardy in middle age but before 1861 there was independent dukedoms.
Furthermore Romagna never was part of Lombardy. Indeed the name Romagna (land of romans) is just in contrast with Lombardy (land of lombards=longobardi).
But you are right about the linguistic issue: both the dialects emiliano and romagnolo are with a celtic substrate like lombard and piedmontese. All dialects under the line La Spezia-Rimini (Tuscan, Umbro, Marchigiano, Romanesco, Neapolitan, Abruzzese, Pugliese, Calabrese, Siciliano) are eastern romance, above the line (Emiliano, Romagnolo, Lombard, Piedmontese, Veneto) are western romance,
In my opinion, the division of Italy that Daniele suggests - Northern, Central (Tuscany, Lazio, Umbria, Marche), and Southern - is justified but tricky. Such a division occurs in this paper, for example: www.nature.com/articles/srep32513/. The problem with it is that there's significant crossover between the 'Nord' and the 'Mezzogiorno' with the north and south parts of the centre, respectively. For example, people from Lazio and Abbruzzo can both cluster as southerners on a PCA chart, while people from Emilia-Romagna/Liguria and Tuscany can both cluster as northerners. The central group itself also shows significant differences within; Tuscans only share strong genetic affinity with Corsicans and tend to differ genetically from the Latin-Umbrian-Marche group who speak 'Central Italian' dialects. You can see this illustrated on the map and PCA chart in the paper which show (a) the significant overlap between south-central (ie. Lazio) and southern populations and (b) that the more homogenous Tuscan group clusters closer to its northern neighbours than its fellow 'centrals' to its immediate south: i.imgur.com/tpLc14V.png.
With the North-Central-South division somewhat undermined or problematised by this evidence, a binary North-South division becomes more appealing. The question then is where to draw the cultural/genetic/linguistic 'line.' I think @Masaman classified Tuscan as a part of the Southern group out of linguistic convenience rather than on a historical/genetic basis. Tuscan is traditionally grouped as part of the Italo-Dalmatian language group that dominates Southern Italy, but it is notably not grouped as a 'Central Italian' dialect under the Italo-Dalmatian subheading, it's always considered its own thing relative to the dialects of Lazio, Umbria, and Marche. Genetically and culturally, it makes more sense to put Tuscans in the Northern group with which they somewhat overlap - more so than they do with Sicilians or Calabrians. A map here - www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1683007/ - further illustrates this, showing that both the Campania-Lazio and the Tuscany-Lazio borders are genetically salient while the Tuscany-Emilia border is just linguistic: imgur.com/vdvf8Zr. A map of Haplogroup R1b-u152 distribution further shows Tuscan affinity with the North rather than the South: i.pinimg.com/originals/cb/ba/7d/cbba7d594c9f58d5594200a95adb8377.jpg.
Tl;dr: I would prefer a North-South binary division of Italy on the map to a North-Central-South one. However, speakers of Tuscan dialects ought to be grouped with the North while Central Italian dialect speakers should be grouped with the South. I do agree with the general sentiment in this thread though that it's odd to see 'Southern Italian' extend all the way up to Tuscany, and if this is solved by splitting Italy in three it would be okay (though not preferable).
"dialects"
Oh man, I knew Italy will be a mess. I agree though. He should go over some parts of Europe again to look more after culture and ethnic-historic connections. It is similar but less extrem in Germany and Poland.
My family is from Southern France (South-East) and I live in Northern France
And it really seems to me that we have genetical differences
In my family we all have black or dark brown hair, and when I visit my grand-parents, it’s the same for their neighbors
But in my school, everyone from French origin (they are mainly from Northern France) has light or medium hair color, most of girls have dark blond hair
I mean I met no one except me from French origin with black hair (or even curly hair but I am the only one in my family to have curly hair so not very relevant) 😂😂😂
Physically, there is no difference about skin tone or eyes color, and it difficult to remarks the other differences
But the difference with hair color is VERY remarkable and I think that it means something
The differences about Northern and Southern France in food, architecture etc are very numerous
Nice hair
maybe because of the mediterranean admixture input in southern france, while northern france has germanic admixture input
Nice hair
You most definitely look Mediterranean.
@@xXxSkyViperxXx Northern France is also Celtic. Thatʼs why 3% of the population there is red-headed, which is quite a lot in numbers, knowing that in Ireland is at 11%
As a native west-Frisian speaker.
Everytime I see something about Europe and languages I hope that they'll atleast mention Frisian. It could just be my strong sense of nationalism though :P
Friesland is uniek, maar is onderdeel van Nederland!
I want to learn frisian since its the closest thing to my native language but there isnt that many sites for it😔
@@jolandajong4068 Dat klinkt hiel agressyf :/
Do you actually want to be independent though? I imagine this would have few benefits and a lot of negatives. I think more autonomy within the Netherlands and Germany you would have a better shot to preserve your culture and language and maybe make it more popular again. I root for you.
@@joze838 I don't think independence would be beneficial. My own thought about it is that Fryslân is like the east Germany of of the Netherlands in the way that we have a lot of agricultural area that fuels the rest of the nation for an important amount. (This is what I think, might not be 100% factual)
What I would like is more recognition for our unique slowly dying language. Especially looking at Germany and the eastern and northern Frisian languages which are only spoken by a few thousand people and are very endangered.
I didn't even know they existed until like a year or 2/3 ago.
Hello I just want to signal a little imperfection in your map. I come from the french department of Vendée and I can assure you that people living in the south of the loire-atlantique department, south of the Loire (what is called "Pays de Retz", including mainly Machecoul, Saint-Philbert-de-Grand-Lieu and Pornic) are NOT and never were breton speakers. They speak, as their Vendeans brothers an Oïl dialect called Poitevin (or Poitevin-Saintongeais).
Thank you for all your work.
+1, I live in the Pays de Retz, and nobody consider themselves as Breton or Celtic, except those coming from the rest of Brittany.
But I thought before roman conquest all of what is now france was celtic or ,gaulic tribes...
@@RagingCajun985 true but breton are really distinct to the rest of France
C'est vrai qu'on a souvent tendance à oublier que le Sud du 44 n'est pas breton
I think all of the Gallo dialect regions are included as part of the Frankised Bretons the same way Scottish, Scots, and Ullans aren't differentiated.
Wow man.. Hadn't tuned in for a while. You've grown for miles in quality of substance! Great to have the language-gene pool side by side. This is going somewhere
-Oh no.
-What?
-Masaman made a linguistic map or Europe.
-What was that noise?
-A horde or berserk europeans coming to correct the most minute detail about regional dialects and local varieties.
-What do we do?
-Run, run for your life!
It will improve the map anyway
@@clips_a_la_menthe *he
Yes Im one of them. Europe for the Europeans.
@@clips_a_la_menthe you should watch acts 17 apologetics and pfander films and dcci ministries and christian prince and rob christian on UA-cam and watch all the videos on UA-cam yaourthilde 😀😀
I feel attacked 🥴
my mans just disappeared off the face of the planet i hope he's good
Love it! Keep up the good work, Mason!
Love your content, keep it up with the great work 👍🏻
Seems to be missing the Saami.
The Saami are there. Look to the north of Scandinavia.
And uhhh all Finno-Ugrians? Imagine talking like the Sámi are somehow the only non indo-euros. You must be American.
@@finnicpatriot6399 That's because you are ignorant, masaman knows about uralic peoples. Your countrymen are ashamed of you now.
@@roadtonever sd
@@finnicpatriot6399 Masaman is American himself...
This man out here somehow managing to come up with even BETTER demographic maps every year, hope u stay well in texas mason 💯
I really love your videos and find them so fascinating.
Greeks and Italians often go by the term “Una Faccia, Una Razza” (One Face, One Race), although it mainly applies to southern Italians as throughout ancient times south Italy was inhabited by Greeks (Magna Graecia). It’s pretty apparent aswell .. South italians have a darker skin tone and tend to be pretty short (not all obviously) compared to central and northern Italians. Also, us Italians can tell where someone is from in Italy judging by their last names
Beh generalmente è vero ma calcola che al nord c'è stata una massiva immigrazione dal meridione.
@@seraph9384 si, questo è vero frate
Almeno la lingua la potreste avere un po piu simile.
Well… Italy took over half of map in ancient times, so no wonder the south is darker. But, however, greeks are darker/shorter than Italians though.
@@noensomserdegsoveomnattenp7732 yes thats true, the romans did in fact take over pretty much the whole of Europe. And yes, Greeks are shorter and darker than most Italians, except the South Italians where there was a large Greek influence. Trust me, you see an old Greek man or an old Sicilian man they will look like brothers lol
Can you please make the next video soon, I am waiting for it. I've been waiting so long, I am excited to see the next one;)
an apulian and a tuscan would have a reeeally hard time understanding each other... or better: if the Tuscan spoke his "dialect" and so did the Apulian, the Apulian would understand the tuscan (because of the similarity with standard italian) but the Tuscan would never understand the Apulian.
It so strange that you have so different dialects in rather area.
@@sodinc We say that potentially each part of Italy ,because it has it's own culture and language, could be it's own country if it really wished, it is just that all those linguistic and cultural entities do not have an army of their own to claim it :)
(if you think about it the only thing that differentiate a "dialect" from a language, it is having it's own army- ergo- nation state to legitimize it)
@@GiulioImparato yeah, that it is some practical logic
I can definitely vouch for this! My family is from Florence (literally where the Italian language started... Dante), and we moved to Australia in the year 2000. I grew up with both English and Italian, so i’m fluent in both but speak the Florentine dialect of Italian, which isn’t THAT much different to Italian but still has its fair share of differences. Anyways, i work with my Father who can barely speak english and we work with another Italian guy who moved here, who’s from Bari (Apulia) .. When dad and i speak in Florentine he can chat along with us, but my god when he speaks his dialect it sounds like a completely different language! Thankfully, he knows how to speak the usual Italian otherwise there’d be some communication issues 😂
@@GiulioImparato Why should we? The Italian national sentiment is even more stronger than the German one, which relies on the welfare to keep its unity. Italians want to be Italians, we are not like the Yugoslavs.
Incredibly creative! Great work, as always!
Our boi is back at it again 😎. Loved your video very interesting content that's hard to find videos on. I'm a dyslexic nerd so I prefer to watch videos and documentaries to learn about things that interest me. can't wait for the next vid
Great work, although I have to ask if you will make a part two to cover the European countries you missed out from this (Iberia, Greece, Scandinavia, England, Baltics).
I recall that during the French mutiny during W.W. 1,the soldiers spoke in Occitan,which the commander did not understand. Sigh*..how complicated we are. As usual,fascinating. Love your work,Mason.
language can create a nation equally as genes like Hungarians
Thank you for making this, amazing work
You forgot to mention the Frisians and the Frisian language! We are also genetically different from the Dutch.
Hey, you aren't forgotten, he marked you on the map, see 👉 8:35
I'm wishing you to survive and grow bigger as a separate nation 😉 You are so unique culture with unique language.
@@Deines7 Friesland is unique, but it's better off being part off the Netherlands. Language's naturally change over time, if we divide the world to every dialect and language we would have thousands of countries.
@@jolandajong4068 I don't know if many many countries is bad thing, at least if it's easy to move between them
I doubt the genetical difference. Frisians are one of many germanic tribes, which are genetically similar/identical. Saxons, Franks, Thuringians, Allemanns, Bavarians and others are all western germanic, as are the frisians. The difference is mainly cultural/linguistic, but every other tribe has its own dialect/language as well. Saxons speak plattdütsch for example.
So frisians arent really any different from other germanic tribes.
You are not, stop spreading racist extremism.
You're so passionate about population genetics, haplogroups, history, geography and so on..more so than most people on UA-cam. Good job, I love your work, you clearly put so much effort into these. I can't even imagine all the research, dedication, editing and publishing of these. How long does it take you, on average, to research, organize data and make a single video? I am curious? :P
You are working on the great project, it is super cool!
Catching up with your channel, keep up Masaman! 👍🏽
Great and Amazing task...Honorable Masaman,
All the way from East Africa [ Kenya ]
I swear to god the wait for the full version is killing me
I don't think its coming. it seems hes ended doing youtube.
www.reddit.com/r/Masastan
@@Nick-lv6ii Don’t be fooled. That notice was put up weeks/months before his last three videos were released. He wouldn’t make an announcement like that and upload 3 new videos then quit after promising a third part to his ethnic map. That claim was erroneous and from the subreddit moderator who to my knowledge has little contact with Masaman. Part 3 is coming, I’m certain of that.
@@Nick-lv6ii nah that was just for the subreddit because it was a mess
and not even a deliberate mess like 2balkan4you
@@Nick-lv6ii That subreddit community has been put into *_"private"_* mode! *_Honestly, I just CANNOT EMOTIONALLY STAND IT when social media channels are put into "private" mode (i.e. Facebook Groups, Reddit subreddits, etc.) when they are on the Internet - and I DO NOT mean the Dark Web (where that would be expected there) - mind you - as that is_*_ _*_*CENSORSHIP!!!*_* 😡😡😡🤬🤬🤬😤😤😤👎👎👎
Awesome as usual. Thank you.
I love your videos. I can't believe someone had the wisdom and the desire to make such a video. This is very interesting to me. - TAV ♥️🇺🇸🌎👍
Job, appreciate your effort
*@Masaman* _Could you maybe make a map/s about the distribution of dominant hair color in Europe/world? In percentages or something like that. In particular the distribution of red and blond hair. Cool video btw!_
Great work! I suggest next time you can do a world map relating similar skin tones to similar latitudes.
Love this Channel.
Compared to its size, Europe has many multi-ethnicity. That's interesting.
💖respect from Tunisia💖
And it's pretty awesome (perhaps not for natives) that big parts of these peoples left over the the Atlantic to settle in North America as well :)
@@steifan in the Americas in general, the Caribbean, Australia, South Africa and New Zealand....
@@steifan In 19th century it was mostly due to famine, misery and a few centuries before to religious persecution
It’s mainly sad,
(but it’s even worse for Native Americans again a few centuries before)
@gg gg Because I am a Mediterranean from Tunisia
My mother's paternal family is Rusyn (Lemko); thanks for pointing out their difference from the Ukrainians & Polish. From my family's research, they see themselves as being distinct from both, and a countryless people.
Love your videos!!
This is so complicated but very interesting and well done!
In eastern Poland, there are *Belarusians* speaking *Polesian* ethnolect of Ukrainian, in the north-east, along the border with Lithuania, there is a small community of *Lithuanians* , *Kashubs* are a nation legally separate from Poles and *Silesians* are a very distinct ethnolectic group of Poles. Many Poles live in Czech Silesia, and Slovak Highlanders are of Polish origin. Basically, you messed up Western Slavs.
*Lusatians* are hardly visible on the map you could use a more contrasting color.
Fun fact: Carpatho-Ruthenians are also commonly called *Lemkos*
As for the Highlanders, aren't most of them ultimately of Vlach origin, though?
Wrong. It's only one part of Carpatho-Ruthenians, there are also Hutsuls and Boykos
There are only two European races: the whites and the Hispanics/Latinx. Subdividing whiteness into "ethnicities/races" is often used by the racists to make excuses for their racism and as a justification for not checking their white privilege. Just sayin SMH I'm half Italian, btw!
@@jessicatriplev9802 what
@@jessicatriplev9802 The most idiotic thing I've ever heard, you must be a disgusting person. To say that all white are the same is like to say that all dark skined people are the same and to ignore the diversity of sub-Saharan people, or to think that the oceanian people are black because they have a similar skin color. I haven't seen a black person live in my life, and I have more respect for their identities than you have for mine, so by what right do you think you can forbid me from talking about the diversity invisible to the naked eye to a stranger in my region. Jesus was killed by the Romans ages before Slav ever set foot in Europe. You being half Italian doesn't make me any closer to you, and thanks God because I despise you. Goddamn American ignorants.
Masaman, I enjoy your videos! I feel compelled to point out that one language is based ON another, not OFF it. Same with ideas and concepts, works of literature and music, and so on. Keep up the good work!
Edit: As long as I'm posting, please use "anyway" instead of "anyways." Cheers.
Love your channel this stuff is so interesting
Cant wait for the full map
This is so informative. Not one traditional media outlet has anything on you,.
Keep it up Masaman !
Wouldn't it be easier to create three maps the first ethno, the second linguistic, and the third religious then the superimpose them as needed?
As an ignorant, I really, really appreciate you, your maps & your commentary. I'm fascinated & your fan. Research & reflection. What a joy!
Awesome work, man!!!
Great work! I hope Asia doesn‘t take so much time, I need more
Bye Mason, it's been a good time watching your videos
"Thank you, everyone, for the memories: the pizza, the guessing, and the most detailed map on the internet. These will not be forgotten. As Mason winds down his UA-cam career, the deprecated function of this subreddit will likewise come to a close. Endless trolling, intrusion from ethnonationalists, personal drama--I can not in good conscience allow the continuance of this subreddit given the liabilities to Mason's reputation. Continue the good conversation on related subs. God bless, Sam"
What program do you use? Because this videos and color schemes are really interesting! Love your channel dude!
Fantastic work!
What is your opinion on the fact that southern gemany austria, swiss and northern italy used to be settled by celtic tribes some thousand years ago before the germans and romans came and took over? They intermixed with the local population and got absorbed but are still felt today I think. In river names like the danube, Iller, Isen, Glom (doesnt this sound scottish?) or some traditions like austrian wrestling rangeln or the "Rauhnacht". I think this is a thing which is often overlook in modern anthropology/science because the germanic and celts are lumped together in the german speaking wordl or associated with the british isles and at best the parts of france/spain which have minorities their.
It might be good if you followed the 23andme region colour scheme as I believe it transitions nicely between continents on their map
thats a mamoth undertaking Sir! huge respect to you.
nice job my man, Masaman
Where have you been, Masaman? We're anxious! :P
Woo hoo keep it up man!
This my shout out to your Woo hoo (out of context but isn't awesome?)
ua-cam.com/video/L4zI6NadpG4/v-deo.html
Crazy project, congratulations mate
Get this man to 1 mil ASAP!
Masa, just wondering: If you could invent your own country with it's own people, culture, history, geography, etc, what would it be like? And would that be a video you'd be interested in making?
I be so into that
I’d love to see this
In the meantime I recommend Limberwisk and other made up countries for April fools' on geography now
I wouldn't tbh but thanks for asking 🙂
in the future, when humanity colonizes other planets and such, there will be a mix of people from all sorts
Hey masaman, a few suggestions:
-Sadlermiut people
-Cossacks
-Aboriginal canarians
-Romani and Dom people
-The mixture of Iberian, Celtic, Arab, Gothic and Roman blood in today's Spain
-Jewish ethnic divisions
-Sirenik people
-Inuit subgroups
-Polynesians reaching Antartica
-Socotrans
-Jeju people
good work ur maps are fascinating
EXCELLENT. ONCE AGAIN
I'm spanish. I look two mistakes in Spain, the groups that you have colored are linguistic groups, but really the genetic groups are:
- Asturias, old Leon Kingdom and Western Andalucia together, because de christian migrations were from north to south.
- Cantabria, Castilla La Vieja, Castilla La Nueva and East Andalucía together.
I'm not sure if anyone has mentioned this but the Icelandic-basque pidgin was always interesting to me
I really hope you are okay, you excellent person expresses his own views without hindrance. May god keep you safe. everybody should input the world their experience or knowledge without politics interference but only honest. from.SOSO. Mahadsanid.
Very cool video again. Could you also explain the ethnicity of kurds of today and their mixture.
There might be even linking to africa as far as I see.
That's great and all but I just can't wait for the tier list
Lmao
1. Ger...
Seems like you forgot Kashubian, which is recognised as a separate language from Polish.
What's that?
@@arvidalexatsinch1163 It's a language spoken around the area of Gdańsk. The signs around there use both Polish and Kashubian.
Kashubian is a Lechitic language from Pommeranian group.
Polish is also a Lechitic langauge but being their own group within.
@@arvidalexatsinch1163 Kashubians and Masurians are the former slavic Prussians who were not displaced but would rather stayed in Prussia/Germany and thus don't want to be considered Polish.
Thank you so much, guys
🇦🇹🇾🇪🇩🇪
Nice having a community that gives good feedback, he did say he reserves the right to change some things so maybe he'll incorporate that which he has not yet
5:56 The split of France remains in the accents when speaking French. It immediately shows from where the person comes. And also the use of different words for the same thing. We have this famous symbolic joke « war » between « pain au chocolat » (North) and « chocolatine » (South) when talking about chocolate croissants.
Keep it up lad!
Is it just me or is the audio quieter than usual?
Yeah, it's quite quiet
Definitely! Voice too low, background music too loud.
Quit that quite quiet voice
Cool, looks quite nice! 👍
Masaman, love y our videos!! You need to update on including Galicia Spain as Celtics as well. That's established science during the Bronze Age.
Great job
Damn you even got the frisian language on it. Very well done!
I also am glad he did that. Bit of a shame Limburg got the same colour as Holland. The languages/ dialects aren't mutually intelligible and there are cultural differences as well.
@@Vincrand you should watch acts 17 apologetics and pfander films and dcci ministries and soco films and christian prince and cira international on UA-cam channel and watch all the videos on UA-cam vincrand 😀😀😀
but he could add a simlar secondary color to occiantia/scots/irish for east frisia which dont speak frisian but are still frisians
Great work. Appreciate it.
The English are at least 50% genetically derived from the pre-Roman Britons, Therefore, they are a mixture of Celts and Germanic incomers. The 'yan tan tethera' sheep counting systems of various parts of England preserve Celtic-derived numerals.
The British are basically Celtic-mixed Germanics, or rather Anglo-Saxons.
And so is Scotland. Genetically speaking Scottish people are much closure to English people then Irish people. For instance the Anglo-Saxon colonised all the way up to Edinburgh
Scotland is a prime example of a state created by a dynasty. The Dal Riadan MacAlpines stitched together a country out of the Gaels of Argyll, the Picts, the Welsh of Strathclyde and the English of the Lothians. Three out of four of these groups were Celtic speakers, however.
Genetics doesn't really have anything to do with Ethnicity. The Kingdom of Scotland was founded by the Scots, a germanic people who are, like the English, descendants of Anglo-Saxon immigrants to britain.
In more modern History, Scotland and Scottish Nationalists have began emphasising Scotlands celtic history, of the native picts and the Irish-descendant Gaels, whose language is still being spoken and is now protected.
@@tonuka6257 Scots may be mixed with Anglo-Saxons, but canʼt be considered as such. Theyʼre Celts, the same as the Irish and the Welsh. There is a reason why red hair is at more than 10% in Scotland, Ireland and Wales.
Can’t wait to see the next installment (Asia) as well as the final world map when the series is done!
He hasn't uploaded in over a month. He said he would upload the Asia video a couple of days after this video, though.
@@NorthPoleSun He said he would have it finished in a few days, and that he would upload it "shortly" (soon™). I have no doubt that it's coming, though.
I think some "ethnicities" such as the Asturleonese and the southern Italians need some modifications. For example, most people in the Asturleonese speaking regions have somewhat assimilated into (Castillian) Spanish culture.
Btw, i think you left out Miranda do Douro, where they also speak Asturian.
Great work, keep it up.
You should watch acts 17 apologetics and pfander films and dcci ministries and soco films and christian prince and cira international on UA-cam channel and watch all the videos on UA-cam bro 😀😀😀
@@efrencruz4422 wtf what does religion have to do with any of this lmao
@@antoniosavalgarcia02 it has its part of the culture and history of Europe garcia
@@efrencruz4422 I'm an atheist. Does that make me a different ethnicity? Of course not. Stfu
I love that thx for your explanation
You should watch acts 17 apologetics and pfander films and dcci ministries and soco films and christian prince and cira international on UA-cam channel and watch all the videos on UA-cam grenon 😀😀😀
Thanks for the info I'll watch :)@@efrencruz4422
@@emolohtrab3468 ok but you have to spread the word about all the UA-cam channels in Facebook and Twitter and Instagram and in your country from now on you have a lot of work to do to spread the word in your country but it might take years so take your time grenon 😀😀😀
I was raised in Ireland and I don't think there's so many fluent Irish speakers, most people I know just remember a few phrases
Thats so sad btw
Slavic languages gradually pass into another, so that it is more difficult to set a linguistic boundary by speech, that is, more by historical affiliation. So it is with Russians and Ukrainians.
There are transitional dialects and languages everywhere in Europe, where there is no significant natural obstacle or there ware no recent mass migrations like in case of Poles and Germans after the war (throwing out from homes is the better word in both cases). There was no sharp language border between Polish and German, whole variety of transitional dialects were between today central Poland and eastern Germany. In case of Silesia the most significant difference was the grammar, so vocabulary was vastly shared, exactly the same as in case of eastern Poland.
Excellent work as always. Some day can you tell us more about the ethnic Germans of northeastern France and their relationship with the Franco-phones there please.
The so-called "ethnic Germans", probably Alsaciens and Mosellans are very much francophone
Same with the Walloons from Southern Belgium, they're culturally French, but, mostly, genetically Germanics.
@@silentwitness7132 you should watch acts 17 apologetics and pfander films and dcci ministries and soco films and christian prince and cira international on UA-cam channel and watch all the videos on UA-cam silent witness 😀😀😀
@@silentwitness7132 Iirc they are mostly more Celtic/Gallo-Roman
There are also a few Ethnic Dutch pockets in the North West. Remnants of the furthest extent of Frankish majority settlement
Do you know much about the Solluba people? There's not a lot of info on them but from what i've seen they're a very interesting and distinct group from other Arabic tribes.
I know this may be a little late but can you talk about the people that live in El Salvador, My whole family’s from there so I thought it would be a cool video
My neighbors from county Cork of Ireland speak Gaelic but didn't teach their kids... things lost over time
That's sad :(
It's their choice of course, and you can't force it on anyone. But I wish people cared more about preserving history and regional varieties
@@tonuka6257 I've seen this kind of thing happen to the minority languages of Russia over the course of my life. The languages aren't suppressed, in fact they're propped up somewhat, but most people decide to only learn the more popular language. As the number of people who know the language goes down, so does the incentive to learn it. It's a downward spiral that can't really be stopped. If no major upsets in the world balance happen, we'll all naturally transition to English being our main language eventually. In other cases, another language will take its place, but the linguistic unification of humanity looks to be an inevitability.
I love how the videos about the ethnicities and races of other continents have few dislikes and overall accept them as facts. But here people really don't like acknowledging the diversity of Europe.
A lot of them are Serbs/people from Yugoslavia who are angry over that segment. Others are zealots and fanatics who are angry that their country was not mentioned in the video.
@@consumerisms why'd serbs be angry
Good video as usual, and btw which country u from? Its hard to see lol
Your videos are cool but could you include more sources in the description? I would like to read more about some of the topics you cover sometimes.
I have always wondered, What Exactly does French mean, are we just a mix of Gauls, Romans and Franks or is it one of these groups dominating the others?
That's where the whole concept of "ethnicity" kind of breaks down. There is no clear cut french ethnicity, because ethnicity is only a social construct. Ethnic identities rise and fall with common language, common education, common laws and common religion. When one of these things change, many people already consider it a different ethnicity despite nothing else having changed.
Chahbhar port indian bengal port world economic forum american iran progress cloth machines agriculture machines hospital machines plane train car bus progress peace 🌎🌍
We are by far mostly Celts. In the south more Mediterranean influence and in the North more Germanic influence. :)
But overall Celts.
Is he still alive?
Love Ur vids👏👏👏👏
Great work! Any comment on the recent findings that a majority of Irish have pre-celtic middle eastern DNA?
Fantastic job! What software are you using?
It might make more sense to divide Asia up into smaller, more manageable chunks since its such a large grouping of land.
Excelente video
thanks for your Great work, but i think you should include the Kashubians in northern poland as it's own ethnicity
Does Portugal and Galicia share the same Ethno-racial culture/language?
the language is basically the same for both, galician has a more spanish-like pronounciation. the northren portuguese and galicians have the same celtic roots (there are ruins of the same people groups in both territories), both influenced by christians, arabs and other iberian kingdoms, etc. Although portugal is a VERY homogeneous country (unlike its neighbour spain), i would say there is a slight, almost impossible to differentiate, division between northren and southren portuguese. The south of Portugal has kinda been influenced more by arabs and has virtually no celtic roots, but thats pretty much about it. This is because galicia and portugal were once the same kingdom and portugal conquered its territory from north to south. As I would say, the northren portuguese and galicians are "the original portuguese people".
in the south of Portugal Arab / Berber influence is counter balanced by the influx of settlers from the northern provinces and by foreigners of the regions of Britain ,France and Germany,that fought in the Reconquista and were given land as reward .Galiza and the third upper part of Portugal are more homogeneous and reflect the remains of the Celtic culture of our ancestors.
@@teixeira476 You´re wrong, southern portugal has the very same celtic roots as the north. Celts were all around western iberia.
Portuguese language and settlers came directly from galician language and people.
Portugal isn't that homogeneous. The native Iberian people were in prolonged contact with Romans, Celts, Germans, Arabs, Phoenicians, etc. There are genetic differences in our territory that translate into physical differences between the population of the southern and northern regions. For example, most Portuguese have brown hair, the minority in the south has dark, curly hair and in the north, blond and straight hair. Another interesting example is the fact that in the northern city, Póvoa do Varzim, there are considerable casesof people with a rare neurodegenerative genetic disease called amyloidotic polyneuropathy. This rare disease is found around the world in some cities of former colonies of Portugal, such as São Paulo. This disease is also common in Sweden, as in Pita, Skelleftea and Uma. This disease was brought on by people from Swedenin the Middle Ages, who settled in this region of Portugal. It should be noted that Póvoa do Varzim has the highest concentration of blonds in Portugal. Genetically and, of course, culturally there are differences associated with Portuguese geography as in any country.