Masaman's 2021 Ethno-Racial Map of the World (Part 3: South-Central Asia)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 тра 2021
- Today I will be unveiling part 3 of my series showcasing the ethno-racial map of South-Central Asia aka the Middle East, India and Central Asia. This is by far one of the most diverse regions of human habitation on Earth, from a genetic, linguistic, cultural, religious and phenotypic standpoint and hence is of great interest to many around the world, including myself.
Apologies for the delays. I lost a lot of progress due to my crappy computer, but thank you so much for waiting and being patient! Stay tuned, the rest is coming, I've been working on so many projects lately that I'm getting side-tracked and struggling with finishing any of them, but needless to say, they are all awesome and you will not be disappointed. Thank you so much for watching!
Mason, I'm blown away by how much care and massive effort you put into your work.
Is not it sad that such a great mapping is done by only a man who is fascinated by differences and resemblances of human groups but not by a top university.
"Pink is essentially a combination of red and blue"-Masaman 1:54
@@dilpreetbassi3116 wise words xd
@@cantoprak7428 because they would be slated as racists, that's how f up is today's world. Masaman is the King.
@@TheTARANISh Yeah, a university would never allow a student or a professor to dwelve in this subject.
Dang I was starting to get worried this video would never come
I would like all of that - language, religion and haplogroup maps. And then please sell those as posters so I can put them on my wall to reference at all times xD And while you‘re at it, just make those for all major periods in human history :D No but seriously, imagine having something like that as an app. That would be such a dream :0
The masamap app is a really good idea, so many subcategories and graphs for citing
No lie I would pay good money to have that app, that’s genius!
@@juevenito Like an interactive MasaMap, that you can zoom into like a Google map would be great.
and you would get all that information free?
@@ikengaspirit3063 yeah, without street view
If classrooms across the English-speaking world is not watching Masaman, something is wrong
They aren't, something is wrong.
Source - am a student that spends lots of times in classrooms in the English speaking world
*aren’t watching
Man I was just wondering where you went! This made my day!
Good to have back after so long Masa 🙌 Appreciate the hard work 💯
"Pink is a combination of red and blue"
My man Masaman is not an artist, but he makes great videos regardless.
that part actually annoyed me, I'm not an artist
Do you know how RGB values work?
He's not wrong, magenta is the combination of red and blue light. Just mess around with an RGB color picker and you'll see that to be true.
Yeah it’s red and white
pink is a combination of red and blue when it comes to screens and lights etc.
but when it comes to paint, its a combination of red and white.
the rules of paint are different
Amazing and detailed as always, Masaman!
Great video Mason! This was really well made. I hope the episode on East and Southeast Asia will come out soon. Keep up the good work! ❤
The work that you are doing is great, this is really really good, great research and effort you put in this maps, very detailed and we can see you are doing the best of the best, seriously you are awesome.
Mason, thank you for these fantastic videos. I watch them with a focus I rarely put into other things. Good work!
I thought the last world map was an impressive achievement from Mas, but this v.2.1.x map just blows that last one away. Amazing stuff dude.
As a middle easterner i love and respect all ethnics of Middle East, Semetic, Arian, Caucasian, Turkic, Greek & Hindus. Its one of the oldest civilization on earth and despite their long conflicts and friendships they managed to pass most of their ancestors culture and languages through out mellenias.
Please for God-Sake, we Indians are Totally different from these Arabs. Please don't Mix our Ethnicity with them. We're More Related to the South-East Asians (Thailand, Myanmar) than Arabs or Persians. So Please 🙏🙏🙏
@@gouthamsudheer5544 Well it depends on where you're from. Pakistan and Northwestern parts of India have more cultural influence from Persia, whereas eastern part of India is more culturally related to South East Asia. India isn't a homogeneous country.
@@cradiun2853 Well, Pakistan is a Totally different Country. They people are Closer to these Middle-Easternerns. But an AVERAGE INDIAN is Highly Different from these Pakistanis and Afganistanis.
How much Percentage of Indians Reside in the North-Western Part? Not even 20% of the Total Population of Indians Reside there.
That's Why I have to Advice to these Westerners who sometimes have this Weird Habit of Grouping Our Indian Culture under Middle-East. We are Totally different from these Over-Conservative Sharia Islamic Arabs. Our Culture is More Related to the Liberal South-East Asia (Thailand, Myanmar) than the Over-Conservative Sharia Middle-East.
@@gouthamsudheer5544 Whats is your definition of "Average Indian". India is not a homogeneous country.
The 20% part i agree with. Most Indians don't have much in common with middle eastern, only northwestern part do.
Also when I say culture, I don't mean religion . I mean ethnic, linguistic and genetic commonalities
@@cradiun2853 Ethinically, Linguistically and Genetically we Indians are Highly Different from these Over-Conservative Sharia Middle-Easterns. In South-Asia Only Pakistan is Similar to these Middle-Easternerns. That's Why Today that Country is also Highly Conservative.
Bro, I have One Doubt. Are Uttar Pradesh people more Closer to Middle-Easterns or Not??
absolutely amazing! You're maps have really helped me understand the world and make my own maps.
Mason, thank you for the work you've done so far and the work you will do in the future. Definitely think about the way to make this project have the impact it deserves. A map, a poster those are great ideas - but I think that there is still something more powerful that could be done.
Glad to hear you Masan your contents are some of the best on anthropology and easily the Best on UA-cam no other channel is this dedicated.
I love this SOO much. the amount of detail is inspiriring. I am Very excited to see your map of the Americas
Superb! I am loving this. So glad you undertook this obviously MASSIVE project :) It really brings together your earlier individual nationality videos in a great way!
Absolutely phenomenal video. Simply stunning. I was waiting a long time for this one. Many thanks 🙏👍
EXTREMELY underrated channel. Should have at least 500k subs. 1mil seems too much as your presentation doesn't seem that league and your upload schedule is slow but the quality and the content are 100% fantastic and definitely make up for it. Also it seems you're really just doing it for the fun of it which is much better than any other reason.
u see many people are dumb so they dont get what he is talking about so they dont care really
what a society of spectacle does to qualify content creators
Over rated crap.
He is wrong , population expanded to middle east and to all the europe from India
Subs usually equates to highly debated subjects and while this certainly falls under such topic this guy's isn't brining the key components of politics into it which not only serves as a dividing factor but adds to the public interest. Nobody actually cares about the facts.
When the maps you make are so detailed and huge that they crash the tab it's opened at, it's a damn good map. No need to rush the project. Make it as best as you can, and we will all wait patiently :)
Awesome Video, have been waiting for this for quite sometime, excellent content!
When you do the Americas again keep in mind that in the south of Mexico and Guatemala many claim to be "mestizo" or "ladino" but are genetically at least 80% indigenous, I think this is an important distinction between the mestizos of the north who are actually closer to 50/50.
I’d love to see a religious map, because religions, unlike ethnic backgrounds, have discrete distinctions which makes it easier to show on a map.
Yeah it's too easy
not quite as distinct as you might think: Some religions get mixed, like Shinto and Buddhism in Japan, or versions of Christianity incorporating local traditions. There are also frequent disagreements about what sects are included in a particular religion, like if Mormons count as Christian (not to mention the more radical people who accuse major parts of their religion as not really following that religion, like Protestants I've heard distinguishing between "Christians" and Catholics, or Wahhabi Muslims considering Shi'a's to be not unbelievers). There are also weird amorphous groups, like New Age spiritualists and Unitarian Universalists, or various different traditional beliefs that blur together and cross lines between religion, medicine, and other beliefs and ritual traditions. There are small and relatively large new religious movements like little cults, many of which sound like their Christian or Buddhist or some other religion, even if that's debatable. It's also not clear if some things count as religions, like is Confucianism a religion? Is atheism a religion? What if it's mixed with the Kim-worship in North Korea or other dogmatic political ideologies some like to call religions? What about the other ritual groups like wellness cultures or fan groups some people like to call religions? (Some people like to call all sorts of things religions, especially when they disagree with them.) Are different approaches to philosophy religions?
@@Mr.Nichan Indeed, nothing is completely discrete when it comes to humans.
@@Mr.Nichan Often atheistic or agnostic sentiments get grouped under the umbrella of "Irreligosity", and also a distinction is drawn between older and newer traditions like New Age or Pagan revivalisms (though Unitarianism might be too old to be grouped with these). Those are two possibilities.
@@Dummy257 As someone who grew up going up going to a Unitarian Universalist church, I don't think it's a religion. It's mostly just an organization of people with different religions: spiritualists, pagans, christians, atheists, agnostics, buddhists, muslims, and others are all welcome to come and discuss religion, listen to sermons, work on community service projects, socialize, etc, as long as they uphold a few shared principles, including respecting all religions. It's basically the "church" of secularism. I don't think that's how Unitarianism has been in the past, though. The UU church came about from a merger of Unitarian and Universalist churches in the 1960s. I've been told that part of how the merger started was because they had combined youth education groups, so kids grew up sort of with both.
I love this series! It's wonderful to see just how diverse our world is.
Omg so happy you are back Keep up good work masa man
love ur work dude these are probably the most detailed ethnolinguistic maps in the world and they are made by you
I forgot how much I missed your videos. Great work as usual.
I saw someone suggest to Name Explain that you and he do a collab. I love you both.💜✌🏻
It could be some shorter (#Shorts) lighter fair for your channel. Who knows what you two could come up with.
🤟🏼🦋
I wait for your videos, keep chugging on!!!
Been literally waiting for this since you mentioned it in your last video!!!! FINALLY A NEW MAP!!!! 😁😁😁
Thanks for another amazing video.
Your ethics group videos are pretty interesting. Looking for to see your next video in this series.
Saying, Hi form Victoria, BC, Canada
It’s so great to hear from you again!!!!!
Can we just take a moment to just appreciate the incredible amount of research and effort that was put into this map. I am so privileged to be living in a time where I can access something like this
Your work is amazing! Please continue. :)
This is awesome. You're awesome. Your work -at least in this and the last video of the series- is super interesting. It's remarkably concise, though I definitely wouldn't mind a more in-depth and textured version (eg., photos, thematic glosses and comparisons of some groups).
Mostly though I just respect your effort and enthusiasm. Especially since I am currently wading through a philosophy MA it really warmed me up to head that this project brings forth your interest in a genuine and passionate way. God knows school is more of a "yes sure I'm boring, adequately good at fitting myself to these stale arbitrations and fundamentally non-creative" vibe. Fact is that interest is transmitted by being shown that of another, so this is a great one in this way too!
Way to go making these videos. Hope you're doing well these days.
This looks like very hard work.
Well done!
Good to see you back man
Excellent videos, very informative and accurate. Keep it up!
Take you time my friend, it is some amazing work.
I always shudder at the thought that I might once again accidentally forget to turn down the volume from 100% after watching a Masaman video and blow out my eardrums
The video I have been waiting for!!!!
Awesome, thanks for making this. Truly interesting and highly appreciated. Cheers from Mexico :)
Yet another brilliant product! These maps are university quality and should be used as references in various endeavors!
HE IS ALIVE!!! I'm so relieved...
You are doing a fuckin good job bruh, it's noticed and appreciated
Amazing job, I am so excited for this to finish
And another absolutely amazing job!
The job you are doing with this type of maps, deserves a presentation of it for the UN, so they start to use them in work... congrats
Wow this is so accurate, especially the one with North East India,
The way you divide the distinct dna in states like Assam and Manipur is quite accurate. Also you did well with the mix people in this region
Vedics are only Aryas, Vedics are only IE. Vedics conquered East too R1a1aY/R1a1Y is the conqueror, it's in SE Asia, China too.
More👉All European, Mediterranean, C.Asian, G.steppe nations are founded by race of Bharath, Vedic/Arya warrior caste R1a1a/R1a1Y (Kshatriya ), this marker didn't exist in steppe to Europe before 1k BC. They've descended from horse riding CimmeArya, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Roxolani, TochaArya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan Aryas who've conquered G.steppe then Europe, China in the 1k BCs from India-Iran areas after Vedics from India conquered upto Anatolia (Mittani-Hatti-Hari) in 2k BCs. Greco-Roman are M-H-H Charioteer Arya descents, only Aryas can bring IE language, chariot, Mitra, thunder/sky God, astronomy, astrology, funerary cremation in Greece-Italy. Aryas in west have turned blonde/white breeding with white/blonde women (Celts R1bY Yamnyan, Veneds R1aY Sintashtan) like brown Jews have turned blonde. Kshatriyas were massive in height/girth, brown skinned, dark haired/eyed (Check G-R, Irani, Saka, TochaArya, Kushan, Xiangno images). Europe's Monarchies came 1300 years after Sakas' 700 BC. empire, literature after 7th c CE. Greece-Italy Monarchies came 1000 years after M-H-H.
Proven conquest of west by Vedics.
👉In 2k BCs Mittani-Hatti-Hari conquered upto Anatolia.
👉In 800 BCs CimmeArya, Saka conquered Balkan, Ukraine, Russia.
👉In 500 BCs Parsha conquered Greece, Balkan.
👉In 400-200 BC. Sauromata, Alani conquered upto Ukraine, then British Irish Isles, remember RgVedic Goddess Danu.
👉 In 5th c 1 Alani band conquered Spain raiding Greece, Italy.
👉In 4th c. Hun conquered half of Europe descending from Khotan, Xiangno.
++++++++
👉Since 800 BC. Celt, Vened & C.Asian trib@ls are en$laved by CimmeArya, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Roxolani, TochaArya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan.
👉 Whites are next en$laved by Mittani-Hatti-Hari descents Roman.
👉En$laved by Hun descending from Xiangno, Khotan.
👉En$laved by moors, moors' leaders are Irani Aryas.
👉En$laved by Turk, Mongol. Lords of Turk, Mongol & other C.Asian trb@ls are Tocha-Arya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan. R1a1a/R1a1Y is in Chinese, Tibetan, Turk, Mongol, C.Asian, SE Asian, Jews, Arab. Rulers aren't same race of subjects even though they speak subject's language. Trib@ls don't give birth to conquerors. Kshatriya Arya, Ezyptian, Mesopotamian are only martial races.
++++++++
Whites (Celt,Vened) aren't IE/Arya/warrior race, no evidence of native language. Let alone riding chariot, never rode horse. Roman labelled them subhum@n. IBN Fadlan described yellow haired are f!lthiest. Till 10th c. custom of r@ping, hum@n s@crifice. Whites aren't martial race but they @nnihilate weakers, they've @nnihilated native Euros. Roman, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Hun could do the same with C-Vs but didn't. In last 1k years Kshatriyas in west assimilating with whites carried out gen0cides of American, African, Asian, Australian. Hiroshima nuking, WW1/2. British rulers who are R1a1a/R1a1Y l00ted $45 tril. alone from India & feeding whites leaving over 10 mil. starved to death. Vedic civilization is destroyed by her own children.
++++++++
Stark difference in civiliation confirms west is multuracial. Celt, Vened are only whites who've changed others' physiognomy giving their women at same time their whiteness is reduced by others. Browns were Arya from India, Phonecian-Etruscan-Jews from Middle East. Negroids from Sahara. Some C.Asian, native Euros, Gypsies, Mongoloids.
++++++++
Kshatriya are founder of Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism. Kshatriya Buddha, Mahavira, Ashoka TG, Kurus TG are the greats no race on earth could give birth. Abrahamic religions are existing because Kurus TG saved Judaism, he's the only non-Jews regarded "messiah" in Judaism. Literature of all civiliations can't reach 1/4 of Vedic. RgVeda is the oldest IE literature. 40% Earth's population speak Arya languages. Aryas who surpass even great Mesopotamian, Ezyptian can't originate from civilizationless Steppe. Oldest chariot found in "Sinauli" India. Oldest city "Rakhigarhi". None ever rode Chariot in Steppe. Vedics=Aryas=IE.
+++++++
Will Durant, American historian.
"India was the motherland of our race, and Sanskrit the mother of Europe's languages: she was the mother of our philosophy; mother, through the Arabs, of much of our mathematics; mother, through the Buddha, of the ideals embodied in Christianity; mother, through the village community, of self-government and democracy. Mother India is in many ways the mother of us all."
William James, American Author "From the Vedas, we learn a practical art of surgery, medicine, music, house building under which mechanized art is included. They are encyclopedia of every aspect of life, culture, religion, science, ethics, law,
cosmology and meteorology"
@@saumensingh9482 don't spam it everywhere. It will Like look propoganda
Great job man! Keep up with the good work
Thank you for keeping it objective and detailed. I am especially impressed by your description of South Asians.
Yay, youre back!
I'm excited for this video :)
You've got a surprising amount of detail for a large part of the world already, just at this level for the whole world would already be quite the accomplishment.
Absolutely loving these videos 👍
I absolutely love this map! My only wish beyond you continuing your work; Is making the colors between north and south Eurasian not so distinctive
I’m not saying Ik better , I don’t , i just don’t know why they are kept so separated relative to other ancestral groups?
Are they as distinct from each other as East Eurasians and Amerindians to require different colors? Or is Europe having its own color a bit Eurocentric?
I’d honestly love to know.
Ik that any possible decision made is going to be on some level be arbitrary but this specific color choice to me seems a little confusing me.
All that side this is great, keep it up mate.
11:20 Yes, Mason please map the haplogroups of South-Central Asia. That's a great idea, would be interesting to see it.
Absolutely stunning work. I hope there will be a globe version in the future, because I'd love to combine them with 3D terrain and biome maps. I don't have much knowledge when it comes to map making, but I can imagine it being quite doable once you have all the datapoints or maybe I'm massively underestimating the amount of work such a version would take. (I assume the regions are basically a list coordinates).
Good to have you back!
Ooh if you've got good data on haplogroups for different ethnicities, I'd love to see it, or at least know where you got it. I wanna make a phylogenetic tree for different ethnic groups
Love your content! Keep it up Mason! (Sidenote: Qatar is pronounced like the word "cutter" with an ethnic twist).
Awesome stuff, well worth the wait!
Your knowledge is very impressive! Great job!
Great stuff. Does that map include the chechens? I don't think they were mentioned.
Btw, that map of different haplogroups sounds very interesting.
When he shows the full map of Russia I see what appears to be the Chechen population in the Caucuses
Watching this video should earn you 3 college credits in Human Genetic Anthropology. Bravo Masaman!
Nice to see you back again
Glad I'm subscribed to this channel.
Ohhhh very amusing and detailed. I learn things more than in my sociology and geography classes.
IKEMEN 😂
Wow, well researched. It’s the most detailed categorisation of Asia I’ve seen. Well done, it’s also interesting that you’ distinguished the Anatolian/Caucasian Turks from the Central Asian Turkic nations!
One are mixed raced..the other are native anatolian/caucasian/ iranians who changed language.
@@sunny-td7qg agree
Great work! You shouid out your hardwork into print.
Love this guy and his videos!
Whoa, the wait is over 💦
Oh! I'm really exited about this map. Please, map haplogroups. Genetic maps are difficult to found and understand to common people like me than the religious and linguistic ones.
Another great job 👍 Masaman
JUST AMAZING WORK!
Azeris are in fact to a large extent, of Iranian descent. The Azeris spoke Old Azeri, an Iranic language, up until it was supplanted by Turkish in the 1600s, in large part under the influence of Kizilbash. I myself am of partial Persian and Azeri decent.
Azerbaijani Turks aren’t old Azaris.
Hey masaman, a few suggestions for when you're done making this map series:
-Sadlermiut people
-Cossacks
-Aboriginal canarians
-Dom people
-The mixture of Iberian, Celtic, Arab, Gothic and Roman blood in today's Spain
-Jewish ethnic divisions
-Sirenik people
-Inuit subgroups
-Polynesians reaching Antartica
-Socotrans
-Jeju people
And perhaps mapuche and other patagonian fuegian peoples
@@skalderman but jewish shold be arabic or mixed on the map
Aboriginal Canarians were of North African Amazigh origin, they are pretty much extinct now tbh.
The moder Canarians are just Spaniards mostly from the South of Spain.
@@sinhalalion1806 I would argue that the only thing extinct about aboriginal canarians is their language (and then many canarian names, words and placenames survive in the canarian dialect of Spanish). Most of their traditions survive in one way or another, such as stick fighting, canarian wrestling, silbo gomero, silbo herreño, the shepherd's jump, gofio, traditional canarian trashumance, canarian tattoos, many bits of canarian cuisine, lots of canarian musical instruments, living in caves, etc.
Canarians whose grandparents are also from the island have between 20-80% of canarian DNA.
You can agree with me or not, but you can't say that today's canarians are just settlers from Spain.
@@sinhalalion1806 Thats incorrect. Genetically speaking actually there still are descendants on the islands, although more of them live in the former Caribbean possessions of Spain, such as Cuba, where something like 25% of all 'Spanish' heritage is actually Guanche. Also there still very much culturally Guanche retentions on the islands, such as Silbo on La Gomera, the retention of Guanche mythology in storytelling, the resurging presence of the Iglesia del Pueblo Guanche, teh retention of Guanche surnames and place names.
The language is dead, and Spain refuses to acknowledge their petitions for formal acknowledgement, but the Guanche people are far from extinct. It's more akin to them slowly stripped of their independent identity through willful neglect, akin to how Japan refuses to acknowledge the Matagi people as being ethnically distinct despite their likley being the last descendants of the Eimishi, or how various French ethnic minorities are refused recognition despite having retained their language and culture because of a desire to produce an illusion of homogeneity.
Don't conflate deliberate ethnic erasure and suppression with organic cultural erosion. It's very dishonest and undermines your credibility.
Keep doing what you do my g much love
Welcome back. I was wondering if something had happened to you, God forbid. Who cares, just keep churning out content because we all start missing you. You can make a Part 4 about South Asia, what hanky panky went on after 1947?
Yeah the diversity, mixture, combos, combinations, and various kinds of gatherings could bring many of these groups together on mutual and respectable grounds and paths.
tanto tiempo ! glad to see you back
Great to see your back I hate that you take long breaks lol 😂 can’t wait for the south and North America maps
You should watch acts 17 apologetics and pfander films and dcci ministries and christian prince and cira international and shamounian on UA-cam channel and watch all the videos on UA-cam Nicholas 😀😀😀
@@efrencruz4422 i do just really enjoy masamans videos there very unique are there any channels similar to his you would recommend?
@@nicholasrodriguez4990 I don't know nicholas but i recommend soco films and Islam critiqued on UA-cam check them out give it a chance nicholas trust me you are going to like it bro 😀😀😀
@@efrencruz4422 ahh I see u know David wood
@@nicholasrodriguez4990 Caspian report is kinda similar but its geopolitical
Hey Masaman, great video as usual keep it up. I have a question regarding the middle east ethnicity-racial origins and composition - I don't mean this as an offense to anyone from this region. I wanted to ask about the Slavic influx into the region as there have been more than a few sources that indicate that there have been considerable migrations into the area.
First of all, in the migration period (500 to 800 AD approximately) Slavs flooded the Balkans almost to the south of Greece. There are Romans sources that testify that they have been resettled by them to Anatolia and beyond to reestablish the Greek identity in Greece.
I'm not sure about the pre-Ottoman era but I know for a fact that there have been schools patronized by Serbs in Constantiopol but I'm not sure about heavier migration. I know this from studying my nation's history but I'm sure there was movement from Bulgaria and Bosnia not to mention Ruthenia and later Russia.
During the Ottoman era there have been forceful migrations due to the blood tax and even though there was little cultural transfer since kids were mostly moved to Anatolia but they were definitely added to the gene pool. From the 1400s to 1600s the Devshirme system provided all the Grand Viziers in the Ottoman Empire and a bulk of the army.
I know there was an exchange of population during the breakup of the Ottoman Empire but was it that impactful that there is no trace of Slavic people in the Middle East?
I'd appreciate an answer but if you don't have the time I understand. All the best and once again great work!
Big love to India 🇮🇳🇮🇳❤️
ua-cam.com/video/QCOdjzr04xM/v-deo.html
Thank you from India ❤️
@@AyushSingh-mr5cs ❤
Where are you from?
@@adityaguru6654 IRAN .and u?
A world map of the Blood Type Groups, specifying Rh- or Rh+ would be interesting.
OMG! Why am I so hyped?!
Your videos are perfect.
Return of the king 👑
7:59 These are the Christians who belong to Syro-Malabar and Syro-Malankar rites of Eastern Catholicism and Orthodox Christianity who were descendants of the people converted by St. Thomas in the 1st Century AD.
Great work, I love this region of the world
Great work, however how about using a different projection for your maps that better represents the actual land areas occupied by the various countries?
Amazing effort once again!
If you make just one of those other maps I'd suggest haplogroups.
I love this man and his maps, I would love to buy this maps, maybe separate religion from ethnicity and linguistics as they are different, but would love to buy them all
Bro your information is very helpful and informative
Bro this channel gets me
Cand you do a video about the E1b1a haplogroup?
It's clear that You research about the topics extensively. It really lots of efforts to make this kind of video
Hey, Masa, nice to see you eid mubarak anyway. Great work again as allways, you better so called anthropologist. To be honest its interesting intriguing work in your input to the world. Thanks again here come the Sun.
A suggestion: How smooth is the transition between the Indic and Iranic worlds. For example I know that many Sindhi tribes have Balochi origins and there are also transition zones between Pashtun and Punjabi populated areas where both co-reside.
and Hazars & Aimaqs should be more different to other persian peoples
Exactly.. Being a Pashtun from Attock Punjab Pakistan, it's not easy to comprehend until where it's Iranic or Indic. Though theses classifications are merely on the basis of linguistics they don't justify the racial classification. There must be separate study for this.
@@ghanambano6459 yes a separate study is really important , but a separate study should be made why ghanam bano with a female pfp is a man who claim to be kashmiri and punjabi hating while living under panjibis ? what made this guy to act like a female with a fake pfp from internet ? did the bachabazi culture get him ? no one knows