As a South African who’s parents suffered from actual apartheid, it really infuriates me when people say Israel is an apartheid state.. Please stop !!!!!! You are decreasing the severity of actual apartheid, this is very insulting to people who actually suffered from it in South Africa. Can Arabs and Muslims please stop piggy backing on the struggles black people have faced ? Thanks
Representative Tlaib still has family in Gaza. Are you saying she should be happy that her relatives in Gaza are in danger. The U.S. isn't at war with Gaza, Israel is. Stop acting like Representative Tlaib is commiting treason for telling the truth about Israel.
On the other hand, she does not have as her first loyalty the country of Israel, which Aipec has seen to it that most Americans haave been forced to bow down to.
Nobody is talking for Plaestine in the U.S., this is a rare occurrence. If you want to blame someone, blame the zionist lobby that is dragging your millitary to wage wars around the world and bankrupting you in the process. You can not claim back your freedom until you acknowledge that you are not free, and you can not calim back your freedom until you identify who stole I from you. I definitely oppose Rashida in many of her views, but she's talking about the unconditional support Israel receives without accountability or consequences (and why), and that's the first step to YOU claiming back your freedom.
The problem is that the US has 'received ' millions of Muslims and other foreigners who want to impose their agenda, ideologies like they are doing in Europe, destroying our culture and transforming our country into another third world country.
Her position is one of morality and standing up for human rights, so it's a safe assumption she's not a fan of little kids being kept in cages for 12 months
She probably doesn't know or care about the southern border --- unless it's some southern border located in the Middle East. She's not really a US representative, she only represents "her people" on a different continent
She was born and raised in the US. You are being a plain racist who ignores how the US is funding crimes against humanity, she wants her country to stop funding state terrorism. What exactly is wrong with that?
USA should do the right thing to send this woman to Palestine 🇵🇸 to genuinely represent her own country and fight for the well-being of the Palestinians. She is wasting here her own precious time, spit and the US taxpayers’s money!
@@_Make_America_Native_Again And we the people have every right to share our opinions on OUR elected officials. She is my neighbor's and fellow citizen's elected official. I can criticize her, just as they can criticize mine. And any representative who displays such brazen racism and hatred toward any group is NOT living up to the ideals of America.
@@Undomaranelu can criticize her but your criticism is invalid on a fundamental level. Advocating for less spending on Israel benefits both palestinians and americans. Less of our tax money will be used for war and directed towards helping communities. That is just a fact. And what are america's ideals? We destroy countries across the world and try to destabilize governments for our own benefit. Trump and Biden included.
In other news April 5, 2024 Dearborn, Michigan Islam rally participants screaming Death to America. Rashida Talib's district. Take your own advice.@@chickenfarm09
Racist to condemn an apartheid state? You ppl are incredibly racist to ignore the amount of crimes against humanity israelis have done against arabs and other groups of people.
@@waltonsmith7210 Just because one is pretending to “stand up to” something, especially by being THAT SOMETHING themselves, doesn’t excuse or exempt them from being THE VERY THING THEY CLAIM to be standing up to. You may sit back down ma’am. 👇 🤡🤣
Maybe don't just pray, maybe speak out and stop Apartheid just like what was done in South Africa decades ago. Thank God Nelson Mandela isn't around to see history repeating itself
What I see is a woman with an influential opportunity to acknowledge the violation of humanitarian rights of her people and she is standing up even with all this hate and anger directed specifically at her. Finally someone standing up for peace and social justice instead of promoting division, hate, and racism. Not everyone liked activists like MLK Jr. or Ghandi, but it takes courage to speak out. We used to be a nation that stood for humanitarianism. I applaud this woman.
Since the arabs lied through their teeth about Israel attacking a hospital and killing 500 Palestinians, perhaps you might wonder what else they’ve been lying about. I’m just sayin’.
It does take coverage and you are right. Not everyone liked MLK Jr and the FBI wired tap his phones. If we are to condemn what is wrong then we must be consistent.
I love this comment. I heard bad things about out her and after watching this video, I am convinced there is a concerted effort to drown out her voice.
She must be here because her parents had to run away, as my friend's parents did when Isrsel took their land. All her aunts and uncles had to do the same. 😔😡
To all who sympathies with the Palestinians, and condemn Isreal. You have no knowledge of History. By electing other than Americans to Congress. You should forfit your voting status.
She cares about freedom, truth and justice. And her Palestinian relatives. If being an American Congressional representative means you can't care about an oppressed people, then the president and US government has no right to interfere with Ukraine.
Did anyone ever ask her why she lives in America? Everyone in the US has the choice to go live in any country they choose. I don't lime Canada anymore. We are seriously thinking on moving to the US. But let me tell you something. When we do move from Canada, we will not go there and try to turn the US laws and customs into Canadian. If we want that kind of laws we would not leave Canada.
Tlaib’s parents immigrated from the general Palestinian area. They immigrated to Nicaragua and later migrated to the USA where they raised 14 children in a house filled with the hate which dominates Rashida Tlaib’s life. She is the oldest child born into that toxic household and represents the disruptive element being introduced into American culture from that part of the world.
@@FreedomNLiberty-rn3xvoh yeah??? And what about the deliberate actions of Hamas beheading and burning babies not to mention killing defenseless elderly men and women in their own homes? Or did you forget and leave that out? My guess is that’s not disturbing enough to you 🤔
Ah yes, we should just throw people out of government for speaking out against Apartheid systems. Better yet, why don't you imprison her just like South Africa did to Nelson Mandela. Hmm yes, you're clearly on the right side of history.
Criticizing a state is not racist; she didn't say a single thing about Jews, or the people of Israel, she condemned the actions of their government. Calling it racist is pure propaganda.
She claimed that Israel is racist, which is pure BS. I am Black and I grew up in Israel. I had all the exact same opportunities as every other Israeli. Israel spent millions of dollars to rescue my family from violent oppression in Ethiopia. They now live free in Israel, which is the most racially and ethically diverse nation in the entire Middle East. Tlaib makes me sick.
@@JazzATrain she specifically said they were racist against Palestinians; are you a black Palestinian? Doesn't matter though, because the claim is that she made "anti-Semitic" remarks, which she did not. I don't even like her, but it's BS to claim her remarks were racist. She might be wrong, or you might simply disagree with her, but racist? Why is criticism of Israel ALWAYS called racist, when no one is even bringing up race? Sounds like propaganda to me...
@@SuperRayW BTW...There are no Black Palestinians. Did you ignore the fact that Tlaib made endless accusations that Israel is racist. In fact, EVERY time she condemns Israel she calls it a "racist nation". I am simply saying that this is total hypocrisy! I can't even safely travel in the Palestinian territories (because whenever they see a Black man they assume he is an Israeli Jew and harass or threaten him). In my hometown of Haifa, citizens of all religions, races, ethnicities and national origins get along great. In my experience the most racist people in the region are Palestinians. Every Palestinian I've met dreams of eradicating all Israelis. To claim they are innocent victims of "racism" is the ultimate propaganda...
@@SuperRayWShe doesn’t know who, when, why and to where the term Palestine was applied. 99% of the World doesn’t. There’s no Palestine outside of the Jewish Context. The Greek word Palestina was used by the Greeks to label the Jewish Geographical Area around 600 BC. The Romans in 1AC revived the Name and the British in 20AC defined the Modern Borders.
Who can't be criticized??????? We live in a free nation. We have a congress that is full of elected officials who completely DISAGREE with each other, yet they are ALL 100% FREE to stand up and express their personal opinions. Can you name a single member of Congress who has been arrested for expressing their opinion??????? We are NOT Saudi Arabia, North Korea or Russia! Voltaire was referring to oppressive dictatorial regimes.
@@Jelperman True. I think the Voltaire quote he was thinking of was...“It is dangerous to be right in matters where established men are wrong.” Voltaire was referring to oppressive leaders.
The story of Israel is actually quite beautiful. God is a poet regarding Israel. It's been an up and down relationship with these two. I read Isaiah 27. If only men could treat women like God treats Israel when they are obedient to God. Thank You God for giving us the Jewish people to help us gentiles.
Does she represent Palestine or American's ? Perhaps she should start representing the people who voted her into Congress, rather than her own personal interests! That goes for the rest of the squad too!!
Ah yes because foreign policy clearly isn't a part of being a politician. Perhaps Congress shouldn't be wasting their time on resolutions to protect a clearly apartheid system and she wouldn't have to push back in the first place
@@simonsobo4644 Interesting that you conflate criticism of the Israeli state with taking on American Jews. This equivalence you spout is itself an antisemitic trope...
@Magamonster how does that counter my point? The same people who fought apartheid in south africa have called israel an apartheid state. Just look at what Desmond Tutu and Nelson Mandela have said about Palestine.
@@EHed-kv2wb South Africa and Israel are absolutely nothing alike. Israel is by far the most racially and ethnically diverse country in the Middle East. I am Black and I grew up in Israel. I had absolutely all the same rights that every other Israeli has. Israel spent millions of dollars rescuing my family from brutal oppression in Ethiopia. My family now lives free and happy in Israel. Israelis come in all races and Jews come in all races. We are not a monolithic dictatorial Islamic republic. What hypocrisy! Islamic nations drool lover the idea of eradicating the one and only tiny Jewish state, so that the entire Middle East will be made-up solely of Islamic republics. Now that is true apartheid!
@@JazzATrain i am talking about palestinians, and other arabs. People who have been removed from their land and do not have the right of return and are still being removed. Even israel's own human rights group b'tselem has called israel an apartheid state. The people who suffered under and defined apartheid are calling israel an apartheid state. Iran and other islamic nations being bad on their own ways does not give Israel the right to commit crimes against humanity and continue to colonize palestinian land for jews.
All citizens of Israel, regardless of faith, ethnicity or gender, including all Arab citizens, have full civil rights, freedom of speech, freedom of assembly and freedom of religion - civil and human rights, which no person, Arab or otherwise, has literally anywhere else in the rest of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA). Did Indigenous Africans or Indians have such rights in Apartheid South Africa? Of course not. In Israel, Arabs have been Supreme Court justices, CEOs of major banks, high-ranking police department and army officers, doctors, lawyers, university professors and members of parliament. Did Indigenous Africans or Indians have such positions in Apartheid South Africa? Of course not. Was achieving such heights even possible for non-White people in Apartheid South Africa? Of course not. In Apartheid South Africa, there were separate and very unequal beaches, fountains, public bathrooms, restaurants and hospitals for Indigenous Africans and Indians. In Israel, there are none of those things. In Israel, Arab and Jewish citizens can and do go to the same beaches, parks, restaurants and hospitals - all things that would have been illegal and impossible for non-White citizens to do in Apartheid South Africa. These apartheid claims are just another in a long line of antisemitic blood libels, and the misuse of this libel to attack Israel - typically by apologists for brutal Arab dictatorships and terrorist organizations who actually engage in extreme gender and faith-based discrimination and other forms of repression against their citizens - is an insult to those who suffered under actual Apartheid.
It is a shame Israelites can't be free to enjoy their lives without worrying about Islamic terrorism, which happens on a daily basis. The Palestinians deliberately kill as many innocent Israeli citizens as possible because of the Palestinian's Pay to Slay scheme. This is the policy of the Palestinian Authority (PA) which offers large and continuous cash payments and other incentives to individuals who carry out “resistance,” including terrorist acts, inside Israel and the West Bank. These payments to individuals or their families total $300 million a year. In 2010, the PA passed a series of resolutions stipulating that every Palestinian inmate in an Israeli prison who is convicted of a "terrorism-related offense" is to receive a monthly payment. In 2013, the PA's prime minister at the time, Rami Hamdallah, amended the law, offering additional benefits to prisoners upon their release. Palestinian Media Watch, which found that "the PA is diverting the payments through the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), a trick it has used in the past." As AFP reported in June 2020, Abbas ordered his security services to destroy "secret documents, fearing possible Israeli raids on their offices." The Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis noted at the time that the PA might have had the past in mind. An Israeli raid in September 2000 resulted in the seizure of PA and PLO documents which showed that "senior Palestinian Authority officers were actively involved in terrorism, providing logistical and financial assistance" to other terrorist groups. In addition to this, the autobiography of the late Mohammed Oudeh, better known as Abu Daoud, named the current Palestinian president, Mahmoud Abbas Abbas as one of the three senior officials of Fatah who assisted and funded Daoud in the Munich massacre of 1972, in which members of the Israeli Olympic were murdered by a Palestinian terror organisation.
Sounds more like Nelson Mandela when he spoke out against apartheid in a different country. Everybody instinctively knows now he was on the right side of history
Israel is the only Jewish country in the world with a Jewish population of less than 7 M. And it is surrounded by countries who wish them dead. Jews have suffered for centuries in that region, and they are hardened because they realize their existence on the face of earth is always under threat. Israel and Jews in general are too precious, because of their contributions to the humanity in virtually every field. So, Rep. Tlaib I would suggest you stop hating Israel and do something constructive.
Probably that it's in no way a valid excuse for modern day injustices and an oppressive apartheid system. Do you think Germans should be beaten & have their houses bulldozed just cause their grandparents were in the Nazi military?
We do have a right to stop funding them until they give equal rights to all their citizens and end their apartheid system. US gives them billions of dollars a year & gives them weapons
In my opinion, she should also be sent to Palestine. Why is she in the United States? The reason is simple, because in Palestine she will live a less good life.
@@GizmoJeff232 you have no knowledge of what she has nor what is going on in Israel. There is always too sides to a story and Israel isn’t as innocent as they proclaim to be.
@@GizmoJeff232ts not wrong to hate a racist country. A country racist towards arabs that includes denying them right to return to their homes and continuous expulsion from their land. If you think israel does not do any of that, you are factually a racist towards arabs.
Rashida Tlaib's support for certain radical ideologies is deeply concerning, and some believe it warrants further scrutiny. Additionally, concerns have been raised about her financial ties to Iran, leading to discussions about potential conspiracy charges so we have been hearing. On another note, there have been allegations of Iran engaging in extensive social media manipulation to influence global geopolitics, which some argue is a more significant issue than even Russia's involvement in such activities. Personally she she be investigated at the highest levels due to her security clearances and potential information leaks to Iran.
As a Black African from Kenya who converted to Judaism I can say without a doubt Israel is not an aparthied state but a free democratic state. All peoples from Black and Ethiopian Jews to Arab Israelis all have equal citizenship and rights under the great Jewish state of Israel. In summary the only difference between Israel and America or Canada or any other country is that Israel is a Jewish state.
As a white Irish man, I never experienced any xenophobia when I moved to America. I guess all those central Americans who say that America is xenophobic or violating their human rights must be lying because I, as a white European, never experienced such things.
Take an example bro what Israeli did the Palestinians living inside isolated Gaza. The Jewish author Ilan Pappe wrote a book called The Biggest Prison on Earth ". Israeli regime is only regime which IGNORED so many UN resolutions
U.S. Is perfectly happy to follow human rights groups’ judgments when it comes to N Korea, Iran, China etc. But Israel apparently cannot be apartheid by defintion, no matter their actions.
No - Israel is not an aparthoid state because it is just NOT. You are aware that Jews come from Israel and that they are not colonists but natives? You does your bigotry blind you to those facts, not to mention your problem with demographics numbers.
@@mrbrklyn Apartheid is different from whether you describe Israel as a colonial or settler state. The issue is you have a large population of Palestinian subjects whose fates are controlled by Israel, but are not allowed to be either Israeli citizens, or citizens of their own state. Even Israeli human rights organizations agree that Israel practises apartheid.
@@ailblentyn Israel is a state of about 7 million Native peoples defending themselves against a Billion Arabs who want them dead. That is not apartheid. BTW - The very few "Israeli Rights organizations" you quote are radicalized left wing bigots that represent nothing but the fringe of Israeli society or even academia. But in Israel, unlike the Palestinian territories, we don't execute people to using their right to free speech, even if they are repugnant and bigots.
@@mrbrklynyou just decided that they're natives , they didn't live in the area for 2000 years and then came out out of nowhere and decided that they're entitled to the land more than the people that have been living on it for the last 100 years. Yupp makes so much sense lol
Being a lawmaker is way to cut off US aid to Israel. US aid is crucial in helping Israel attack her people. So stop being ignorant and recognize there are multiple ways to help your people. People who have been suffering for over 7 decades.
If she did that, you'd just turn around and call her selfish. There's no winning in US politics & the corrupt media cause it's just a cesspit of greed and immorality. There's a reason the US propped up Apartheid South Africa too
she doesn't realize that this has been going on with both groups for centuries and we can't help this, and she really is hysterical about this, why doesn't she do her job for her state???
No this has not been going on for centuries, at least in its current form. What has been going on for centuries is both Christian and Muslim bigorty and violence against Jews. And something can be done about it.
@@BenBrisker And just in case you don't watch that, they're literally ziptying 9 year old Palestinian girls in that clip for nothing. Open your goddamn eyes
@@jenni0278He’s right and you’re wrong. Israel treats all Israeli the same way like the US treats all Americans the same way. Non Israelis are not Israelis.
She's 100% right. The denial of reality regarding the racism, occupation and apartheid by the Israeli state is absurd. Its obvious that the emperor has no clothes
please tell me you're aware that Israel came to "occupy," as you people call it, the West Bank, Sinai Peninsula, and Gaza as a result of a DEFENSIVE war.
@@simonsobo4644 A "defensive" in which Israel attacked first. Also, nations cannot expand their territory via military action. The world collectively decided this after WW2 for reasons that should be obvious...
@@IcarianX If what the world wants is taken into account how come the Arabs don't have to abide by Resolution 181? The Arabs tried to militarily destroy Israel 4 times before changing tactics and now going full-on Hitler/trump and declaring themselves the victims. If nations can't expand militarily what about the Crimea? And how 'bout that outpouring of heartfelt grief for those Crimeans the world ignored. But as it turns out, I agree with you. Israel should not be allowed to expand by wars of conquest, nor any country. Israel was ready to return 94% of the territory taken during The Six Day War but the Arabs won't take "Yes" for an answer. However, if it was up to me I'd abandon that 94% with one proviso: Next time we're attacked we're taking that place over. After Israel abandons that land, whether Arabs have made peace or not, the Arabs lose whatever land they attack from.
It is a shame the Israelites can't be free to enjoy their lives without worrying about Palestinian terrorism, which happens on a daily basis. The racist Palestinians deliberately kill as many innocent Israeli citizens as possible because of the Palestinian's Pay to Slay scheme. This is the policy of the Palestinian Authority (PA) which offers large and continuous cash payments and other incentives to individuals who carry out “resistance,” including terrorist acts, inside Israel and the West Bank. These payments to individuals or their families total $300 million a year. In 2010, the PA passed a series of resolutions stipulating that every Palestinian inmate in an Israeli prison who is convicted of a "terrorism-related offense" is to receive a monthly payment. In 2013, the PA's prime minister at the time, Rami Hamdallah, amended the law, offering additional benefits to prisoners upon their release. Palestinian Media Watch, which found that "the PA is diverting the payments through the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), a trick it has used in the past." As AFP reported in June 2020, Abbas ordered his security services to destroy "secret documents, fearing possible Israeli raids on their offices." The Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis noted at the time that the PA might have had the past in mind. An Israeli raid in September 2000 resulted in the seizure of PA and PLO documents which showed that "senior Palestinian Authority officers were actively involved in terrorism, providing logistical and financial assistance" to other terrorist groups. In addition to this, the autobiography of the late Mohammed Oudeh, better known as Abu Daoud, named the current Palestinian president, Mahmoud Abbas Abbas as one of the three senior officials of Fatah who assisted and funded Daoud in the Munich massacre of 1972, in which members of the Israeli Olympic were murdered by a Palestinian terror organisation.
@gerrycoleman7290 No, I just know what apartheid is, the consistent breach of signed treaties and endless persecution of another people is when it's happening. She was quoting several of the biggest human rights groups in the world and the biggest human rights body in Isreal, too. There's nothing wrong with that. Sorry if it upsets you.
If the Jews have a right to establish the state of Israel for historical claims to that land, than the Mongolians have the right to rule over China Russia East Germany Austria Poland etc. since they conquered those lands and the Native people of this named continent currently called America have the right to establish a free native state on Manhattan island since even the name is in Native American and it was theirs for over 10000 years. And no, it was not bought from the natives so don’t even try that argument.
Ebcause she is a duly elected member of Congress and in the US we have freedom of speach even if the speaker is a hateful bigot who wants to kill all the Jews.
If the shoe fits, wear it. Desmond Tutu, Nelson Mandela and others who suffered under the Apartheid regime in South Africa have called Israel an apartheid state. I'd like to see Netanyahu's fanboys explain how they know more about apartheid than Desmond Tutu.
OK. I will explain it again.... I know MUCH more about Israel the Desmond Tutu ever did! I am a Black man who lived in Israel. Tutu NEVER lived in Israel. Desmond Tutu was completely WRONG about Israel...not because he didn't know about apartheid, but because he didn't know about Israel. Being an expert on your own country does not make you an expert on all countries. Tutu had NO CLUE about the reality on the ground. Explain to me how someone who has NEVER been to my home town knows more about it than I do.
@@JazzATrain Israel's own largest human rights organization, along with the United Nations and countless other international agencies have concluded for a long time that Israel is an apartheid state. Maybe you should go live in an occupied territory or the Gaza strip and see how much compassion you get there
@@thehumanity0Some Jews are the worst enemies of Jews. Israel can’t occupy their Native Homeland. Jews are Native of Judea whilst Arabs are Native of Arabia. Jews didn’t invade Arabia but Arabs invaded Judea and lost the Land. The problem is that they don’t accept it.
@@thehumanity0 Don't you love how he writes "Black man" Lol. Don't engage with these people. He is a Zionist replying to these messages, not a "Black man" A black man KNOWS what Zionists think of black people.
@Magamonster Mandela was not a communist, you should actually learn what his actual beliefs were instead of regurgitating Sean Hannity lies. At most Mandela was a democratic socialist, but on that note so was Albert Einstein, George Orwell and countless other geniuses in the last 2 centuries - it's really not the sick burn you think it is.
Can someone explain a Logical Practical reason why the Middle East is a ''Holy Land'' ? It's too Hot, it's too Dry, and honestly, most of Europe, both north and south Americas, Africa and Asia are ALL nicer than the middle east... If you're not completely surrounded by lush vegitation, plenty of food and water, and abundant natural resources - WHY in the world does anyone want to live in a (literally) god forsaken wasteland ? Sure, lots of History, but as far as living in the middle east full time ? No way.
There are some who only want to rape and murder. For now their cause is Islam. If it wasn’t Islam they’d find some other cause to rationalize their actions. The last thing arab leaders want is peace because then they’d be expected to actually govern. Also, railing against Israel can be quite lucrative. One particular arab leader amassed over a billion dollars from his career of blaming Israel.
The Middle East is such a hotspot for one simple reason: the Jew. If Jews weren’t invested in the region no one would care about how much the arabs were exploiting their own people. And you’re right about the lack of natural resources in Israel yet that hasn’t stopped the Israelis from creating the largest economy in the entire Middle East. “Palestine” had been a desolate wasteland until Jewish immigrants returned and turned swamps and deserts into arable farmland. And now the argument's being made, rather successfully I might add, that the desert was always blooming and those colonial Zionist devils invaded “Palestine” and are now living large off the sweat and toil of enslaved, noble “Palestinian.”
@Magamonster two wrongs do not make a right. Palestinians have lived on that land for centuries now and many are just descendants of the jews mixing with arabs over a milennia. And Israel is the one currently committing ethnic cleansing, denying this is blatant arab racism.
“No amount of evidence will ever persuade an idiot.”
Mark Twain
Mrs Tlaib is very very beautiful . ❤
She should not be in Congress. Anyone that supports terrorist groups should not be allowed to have any job in our government.
As a South African who’s parents suffered from actual apartheid, it really infuriates me when people say Israel is an apartheid state..
Please stop !!!!!! You are decreasing the severity of actual apartheid, this is very insulting to people who actually suffered from it in South Africa.
Can Arabs and Muslims please stop piggy backing on the struggles black people have faced ? Thanks
As someone from the US, I agree with you. I'm so sorry for what your family had to go through.
Actual Apartheid is the law under Netanyahu.
I believe Rashid’s heart is in Palestine - not the USA.
What heart
@@FreedomNLiberty-rn3xvI agree and you can clearly see it in her emotions. MLK Jr, "injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere."
Representative Tlaib still has family in Gaza. Are you saying she should be happy that her relatives in Gaza are in danger. The U.S. isn't at war with Gaza, Israel is. Stop acting like Representative Tlaib is commiting treason for telling the truth about Israel.
Like many stooges in congress who have their loyalty with israel
Maybe Rashida’s grandmother and her friends should not have raised murderous psychopaths
This woman declares herself to be Palestinian American. So which country does she represent? Kick her out of the house.
America is a melting pot made up of immigrants from all nationalities and religions. Ever heard of the Statue of Liberty & Ellis Island? Probably not
She doesn’t represent the United States!
She is a traitor, 😂
On the other hand, she does not have as her first loyalty the country of Israel, which Aipec has seen to it that most Americans haave been forced to bow down to.
In other news April 5, 2024 Dearborn, Michigan Islam rally participants screaming Death to America. Rashida Talib's district.
Who in Congress fights for the rights of the American people and the needs that we all have? I want to know.
According to Marjorie Taylor Greene President Biden's been fighting for us.
Nobody is talking for Plaestine in the U.S., this is a rare occurrence. If you want to blame someone, blame the zionist lobby that is dragging your millitary to wage wars around the world and bankrupting you in the process. You can not claim back your freedom until you acknowledge that you are not free, and you can not calim back your freedom until you identify who stole I from you.
I definitely oppose Rashida in many of her views, but she's talking about the unconditional support Israel receives without accountability or consequences (and why), and that's the first step to YOU claiming back your freedom.
Not Rashida- she fights for hate & continuing victimhood. She profits off of suffering & hate, which makes the lowest of the low.
You could probably count them on one hand, unfortunately. How sad.
The problem is that the US has 'received ' millions of Muslims and other foreigners who want to impose their agenda, ideologies like they are doing in Europe, destroying our culture and transforming our country into another third world country.
She doesn't belong in our government.
Agree, she's terrible.
For sure who would vote these people in,wake up
Why not?
Hahhaaa,good one,people like gorge santos shud be in your government right,.Do u know how your government f u up.hahhhhaaa
how does she feel about the southern border
They ignore it. AOC has yet to go to the border and cry at an empty parking lot like she did before.
Her position is one of morality and standing up for human rights, so it's a safe assumption she's not a fan of little kids being kept in cages for 12 months
She probably doesn't know or care about the southern border --- unless it's some southern border located in the Middle East. She's not really a US representative, she only represents "her people" on a different continent
In other news April 5, 2024 Dearborn, Michigan Islam rally participants screaming Death to America. Rashida Talib's district.
Tlaib is a disgrace she be fired
Dramatic theatrics. No self control. Shows instability not maturity
Really? She just quoted Israel officials' own words...
Keep turning a blind eye to an oppressive apartheid system. History has already corrected itself once in South Africa, it won't be kind to you either
Truth hurts
muslima is time for you to fight from the field , go back to Gaza
She was born and raised in the US. You are being a plain racist who ignores how the US is funding crimes against humanity, she wants her country to stop funding state terrorism. What exactly is wrong with that?
She needs to go
USA should do the right thing to send this woman to Palestine 🇵🇸 to genuinely represent her own country and fight for the well-being of the Palestinians. She is wasting here her own precious time, spit and the US taxpayers’s money!
They had an interview with her father and he said she is INSANE.
Her Father said nothing of the kind.
Bruv where u got ur high school gossip from?
Ms. Tlaib Should Be Expelled From Congress.
She likes to cry .
She can be expelled. The House has expelled members before.
@@_Make_America_Native_Again And we the people have every right to share our opinions on OUR elected officials. She is my neighbor's and fellow citizen's elected official. I can criticize her, just as they can criticize mine. And any representative who displays such brazen racism and hatred toward any group is NOT living up to the ideals of America.
@@Undomaranelu can criticize her but your criticism is invalid on a fundamental level. Advocating for less spending on Israel benefits both palestinians and americans. Less of our tax money will be used for war and directed towards helping communities. That is just a fact.
And what are america's ideals? We destroy countries across the world and try to destabilize governments for our own benefit. Trump and Biden included.
@@_Make_America_Native_Again Learn how Congress works please.
this woman has brought terror here
yesyes love you
As someone from the uk its amazing to seeing american have a representative that spits in the face of democracy
Maybe you should check out the video footage from Israel that shows who really "spits" and I mean both literally and figuratively.
They loved to talk about the UN. UN is a Islamist ruled group.
Look up videos of district in Dearborn, MI. Obama brought in 10,000+ Islamists.
In other news April 5, 2024 Dearborn, Michigan Islam rally participants screaming Death to America. Rashida Talib's district. Take your own advice.@@chickenfarm09
She should be back to Palestine and Help her country..wrong country to migrate
She needs to be out of congress permanently. We don’t want and need that racist in our govt.
Opposing an illegitimate state that murders children with military precision and drives tanks over peoples homes is not racism.
Racist to condemn an apartheid state? You ppl are incredibly racist to ignore the amount of crimes against humanity israelis have done against arabs and other groups of people.
So the one standing up to racism is a racist. Ok buddy. Whatever you say, Orwell. Lmao.
@@waltonsmith7210
Just because one is pretending to “stand up to” something, especially by being THAT SOMETHING themselves, doesn’t excuse or exempt them from being THE VERY THING THEY CLAIM to be standing up to. You may sit back down ma’am. 👇 🤡🤣
Triggered 🤡🤡🤡🤡 Everywhere… LOL
Jerusalem is the City of God. Pray for the PEACE of Jerusalem.
God will always protect Israel and the Jews Hs chosen people!
@@suzannerobbins6293
Yes...but not those Europeans from RUSSIA
@@suzannerobbins6293didn't Jews plot against Jesus?
Maybe don't just pray, maybe speak out and stop Apartheid just like what was done in South Africa decades ago. Thank God Nelson Mandela isn't around to see history repeating itself
@@suzannerobbins6293lol soooo deluded
What I see is a woman with an influential opportunity to acknowledge the violation of humanitarian rights of her people and she is standing up even with all this hate and anger directed specifically at her. Finally someone standing up for peace and social justice instead of promoting division, hate, and racism. Not everyone liked activists like MLK Jr. or Ghandi, but it takes courage to speak out. We used to be a nation that stood for humanitarianism. I applaud this woman.
Then YOU OBVIOUSLY DONT KNOW ANYTHING ELSE about her do you????🙄
Since the arabs lied through their teeth about Israel attacking a hospital and killing 500 Palestinians, perhaps you might wonder what else they’ve been lying about. I’m just sayin’.
It does take coverage and you are right. Not everyone liked MLK Jr and the FBI wired tap his phones. If we are to condemn what is wrong then we must be consistent.
Tlaib has hatered towards Israelis, or maybe is it just the hamas money speaking.
I love this comment. I heard bad things about out her and after watching this video, I am convinced there is a concerted effort to drown out her voice.
So, you are Palestinian, not an American? RESIGN
She must be here because her parents had to run away, as my friend's parents did when Isrsel took their land. All her aunts and uncles had to do the same. 😔😡
@@jovifan674 she's supposed to be representing communities in Michigan, not rallying anti-semitism toward Israel
@sallifrancis7250 she wants to be heard because nobody talks about the injustices Israel does against Palestine.
@@jovifan674 why does she not go back? She obviously hates America
Shes an american with palestinian heritage
She's a Congressional representative of the United States. She should represent Americans not Palestinians.
She’s an American and a Palestinian, so she has an interest. And if America cares about freedom, so do we.
And Congress should not be supporting Israeli apartheid with American tax dollars
But not the 412 members that voted for this virtue signal resolution? Tell them they represent the United States not Israel.
To all who sympathies with the Palestinians, and condemn Isreal. You have no knowledge of History. By electing other than Americans to Congress. You should forfit your voting status.
She cares about freedom, truth and justice. And her Palestinian relatives. If being an American Congressional representative means you can't care about an oppressed people, then the president and US government has no right to interfere with Ukraine.
How many fake mail in ballots did Tlaib get in with?
Rigged voting machines
In other news April 5, 2024 Dearborn, Michigan Islam rally participants screaming Death to America. Rashida Talib's district.
Did anyone ever ask her why she lives in America? Everyone in the US has the choice to go live in any country they choose. I don't lime Canada anymore. We are seriously thinking on moving to the US. But let me tell you something. When we do move from Canada, we will not go there and try to turn the US laws and customs into Canadian. If we want that kind of laws we would not leave Canada.
To collect money and support for hamas is my guess.
Tlaib’s parents immigrated from the general Palestinian area. They immigrated to Nicaragua and later migrated to the USA where they raised 14 children in a house filled with the hate which dominates Rashida Tlaib’s life. She is the oldest child born into that toxic household and represents the disruptive element being introduced into American culture from that part of the world.
Your question “why she lives in America?” suggests that there’s some people who should, and others who shouldn’t. Who shouldn’t, and why?
Representative Tlaib was born in Detroit. That's why she chooses to live in the U.S.
@MrQuestful if anyone hate the cou try they live in...leave. she is lucky enough to live in a country to do that.
Go away🎉
No, Israel doesn't practice Apartheid. BS. Israel is NOT racist.
That woman is disturbing.
@@FreedomNLiberty-rn3xvoh yeah??? And what about the deliberate actions of Hamas beheading and burning babies not to mention killing defenseless elderly men and women in their own homes? Or did you forget and leave that out? My guess is that’s not disturbing enough to you 🤔
I would say that she’s disturbed.
This woman needs to be thrown out of Congress and her coat hurts. And all of their hate speech needs to be prosecuted to the fullest Of the law
The House can expel a member. And based on that racist rant. Tlaib must be expelled immediately.
hate speech is protected speech per SCOTUS. and rightfully so.
@@XSV9222she has the right to say it. Congress has the right to expel her for it.
Cry harder.
Ah yes, we should just throw people out of government for speaking out against Apartheid systems. Better yet, why don't you imprison her just like South Africa did to Nelson Mandela.
Hmm yes, you're clearly on the right side of history.
Mentally unstable? All anger with priorities elsewhere?
Wasn’t one of your Democrat compatriots going on about anti-semitism, Ms. Congressman?
Criticizing a state is not racist; she didn't say a single thing about Jews, or the people of Israel, she condemned the actions of their government. Calling it racist is pure propaganda.
She claimed that Israel is racist, which is pure BS. I am Black and I grew up in Israel. I had all the exact same opportunities as every other Israeli. Israel spent millions of dollars to rescue my family from violent oppression in Ethiopia. They now live free in Israel, which is the most racially and ethically diverse nation in the entire Middle East. Tlaib makes me sick.
@@JazzATrain she specifically said they were racist against Palestinians; are you a black Palestinian? Doesn't matter though, because the claim is that she made "anti-Semitic" remarks, which she did not. I don't even like her, but it's BS to claim her remarks were racist. She might be wrong, or you might simply disagree with her, but racist? Why is criticism of Israel ALWAYS called racist, when no one is even bringing up race? Sounds like propaganda to me...
@@SuperRayW BTW...There are no Black Palestinians. Did you ignore the fact that Tlaib made endless accusations that Israel is racist. In fact, EVERY time she condemns Israel she calls it a "racist nation". I am simply saying that this is total hypocrisy! I can't even safely travel in the Palestinian territories (because whenever they see a Black man they assume he is an Israeli Jew and harass or threaten him). In my hometown of Haifa, citizens of all religions, races, ethnicities and national origins get along great. In my experience the most racist people in the region are Palestinians. Every Palestinian I've met dreams of eradicating all Israelis. To claim they are innocent victims of "racism" is the ultimate propaganda...
It is racist SUPERRAY!!! Everything she said is a lie and I can prove it. Listen to Yahya Mahamid.
@@SuperRayWShe doesn’t know who, when, why and to where the term Palestine was applied.
99% of the World doesn’t.
There’s no Palestine outside of the Jewish Context.
The Greek word Palestina was used by the Greeks to label the Jewish Geographical Area around 600 BC.
The Romans in 1AC revived the Name and the British in 20AC defined the Modern Borders.
This is not about your grandma
A Muslim can hold a senior business, medical, academic or political position in Israel. Can an Israeli do the same in a Muslim country? No.
These drama shows just Crack me up. 🤣 the squad needs to take this show to Broadway. 😂🤪🤣
== TAHIB ,TAKE A HIKE ! ==
This aged well...
"To find out who rules over you look at the ones you cannot criticize." -Voltaire
Who can't be criticized??????? We live in a free nation. We have a congress that is full of elected officials who completely DISAGREE with each other, yet they are ALL 100% FREE to stand up and express their personal opinions. Can you name a single member of Congress who has been arrested for expressing their opinion??????? We are NOT Saudi Arabia, North Korea or Russia! Voltaire was referring to oppressive dictatorial regimes.
Voltaire never wrote that.
@@Jelperman True. I think the Voltaire quote he was thinking of was...“It is dangerous to be right in matters where established men are wrong.” Voltaire was referring to oppressive leaders.
@@Jelperman as if you heard everything said...LOL
@@Jelperman It's still true.
She has no place in any part of our government
Why? She literally quoted Israel's own officials' horrific words. Truth hurt much?
Why? She literally quoted Israel's own officials' horrific words. Truth hurt much?
The story of Israel is actually quite beautiful. God is a poet regarding Israel. It's been an up and down relationship with these two. I read Isaiah 27. If only men could treat women like God treats Israel when they are obedient to God. Thank You God for giving us the Jewish people to help us gentiles.
Wish Tlaib was as passionate representing American interests instead of her own twisted views
In other news April 5, 2024 Dearborn, Michigan Islam rally participants screaming Death to America. Rashida Talib's district.
Send her to Palestine
ASAP
Yesterday
I'm sure this is aging well
Does she represent Palestine or American's ? Perhaps she should start representing the people who voted her into Congress, rather than her own personal interests! That goes for the rest of the squad too!!
well AIPAC shouldn't be involved in our government either
Ah yes because foreign policy clearly isn't a part of being a politician. Perhaps Congress shouldn't be wasting their time on resolutions to protect a clearly apartheid system and she wouldn't have to push back in the first place
Most of Congress and the senate represent Israel. There needs to be some diversity of opinion on US foreign policy
There probably aren't enough Jews in her district so she's decided to take us all on.
@@simonsobo4644 Interesting that you conflate criticism of the Israeli state with taking on American Jews. This equivalence you spout is itself an antisemitic trope...
I bet she doesn't even know the definition of apartheid.
The south african government, the people who witnessed and suffered under apartheid have called israel an apartheid state.
@Magamonster how does that counter my point? The same people who fought apartheid in south africa have called israel an apartheid state. Just look at what Desmond Tutu and Nelson Mandela have said about Palestine.
@@EHed-kv2wb South Africa and Israel are absolutely nothing alike. Israel is by far the most racially and ethnically diverse country in the Middle East. I am Black and I grew up in Israel. I had absolutely all the same rights that every other Israeli has. Israel spent millions of dollars rescuing my family from brutal oppression in Ethiopia. My family now lives free and happy in Israel. Israelis come in all races and Jews come in all races. We are not a monolithic dictatorial Islamic republic. What hypocrisy! Islamic nations drool lover the idea of eradicating the one and only tiny Jewish state, so that the entire Middle East will be made-up solely of Islamic republics. Now that is true apartheid!
@@JazzATrain i am talking about palestinians, and other arabs. People who have been removed from their land and do not have the right of return and are still being removed. Even israel's own human rights group b'tselem has called israel an apartheid state.
The people who suffered under and defined apartheid are calling israel an apartheid state.
Iran and other islamic nations being bad on their own ways does not give Israel the right to commit crimes against humanity and continue to colonize palestinian land for jews.
@@EHed-kv2wbread one history book in your lifetime please. You know literally nothing.
Why doesn't she go back and fight with the hamas terroritsts?
She’s 100% correct, freedom for oppressed peoples everywhere
Except for Jews, right?
All citizens of Israel, regardless of faith, ethnicity or gender, including all Arab citizens, have full civil rights, freedom of speech, freedom of assembly and freedom of religion - civil and human rights, which no person, Arab or otherwise, has literally anywhere else in the rest of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA). Did Indigenous Africans or Indians have such rights in Apartheid South Africa? Of course not. In Israel, Arabs have been Supreme Court justices, CEOs of major banks, high-ranking police department and army officers, doctors, lawyers, university professors and members of parliament. Did Indigenous Africans or Indians have such positions in Apartheid South Africa? Of course not. Was achieving such heights even possible for non-White people in Apartheid South Africa? Of course not. In Apartheid South Africa, there were separate and very unequal beaches, fountains, public bathrooms, restaurants and hospitals for Indigenous Africans and Indians. In Israel, there are none of those things. In Israel, Arab and Jewish citizens can and do go to the same beaches, parks, restaurants and hospitals - all things that would have been illegal and impossible for non-White citizens to do in Apartheid South Africa. These apartheid claims are just another in a long line of antisemitic blood libels, and the misuse of this libel to attack Israel - typically by apologists for brutal Arab dictatorships and terrorist organizations who actually engage in extreme gender and faith-based discrimination and other forms of repression against their citizens - is an insult to those who suffered under actual Apartheid.
It is a shame Israelites can't be free to enjoy their lives without worrying about Islamic terrorism, which happens on a daily basis. The Palestinians deliberately kill as many innocent Israeli citizens as possible because of the Palestinian's Pay to Slay scheme. This is the policy of the Palestinian Authority (PA) which offers large and continuous cash payments and other incentives to individuals who carry out “resistance,” including terrorist acts, inside Israel and the West Bank. These payments to individuals or their families total $300 million a year. In 2010, the PA passed a series of resolutions stipulating that every Palestinian inmate in an Israeli prison who is convicted of a "terrorism-related offense" is to receive a monthly payment. In 2013, the PA's prime minister at the time, Rami Hamdallah, amended the law, offering additional benefits to prisoners upon their release. Palestinian Media Watch, which found that "the PA is diverting the payments through the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), a trick it has used in the past." As AFP reported in June 2020, Abbas ordered his security services to destroy "secret documents, fearing possible Israeli raids on their offices." The Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis noted at the time that the PA might have had the past in mind. An Israeli raid in September 2000 resulted in the seizure of PA and PLO documents which showed that "senior Palestinian Authority officers were actively involved in terrorism, providing logistical and financial assistance" to other terrorist groups. In addition to this, the autobiography of the late Mohammed Oudeh, better known as Abu Daoud, named the current Palestinian president, Mahmoud Abbas Abbas as one of the three senior officials of Fatah who assisted and funded Daoud in the Munich massacre of 1972, in which members of the Israeli Olympic were murdered by a Palestinian terror organisation.
@@sharonn381 Nailed it.
Someone at the Capitol said that Talib has a Palestinian flag outside of her office. What a scumbag.
Rashida Hamas 🤯
Karma is having your family live with violence your own people started.
Doesn't that sound like what Maxine Waters said about republicans ?
Sounds more like Nelson Mandela when he spoke out against apartheid in a different country. Everybody instinctively knows now he was on the right side of history
Israel is the only Jewish country in the world with a Jewish population of less than 7 M. And it is surrounded by countries who wish them dead. Jews have suffered for centuries in that region, and they are hardened because they realize their existence on the face of earth is always under threat. Israel and Jews in general are too precious, because of their contributions to the humanity in virtually every field.
So, Rep. Tlaib I would suggest you stop hating Israel and do something constructive.
Thank you.
Domestic enemy right there
Wonder what she thinks about when muslims invaded Jerusalem
Probably that it's in no way a valid excuse for modern day injustices and an oppressive apartheid system. Do you think Germans should be beaten & have their houses bulldozed just cause their grandparents were in the Nazi military?
Maybe they shouldnt be lobbing rockets in Israel
We have no right to come against Israel.
We do have a right to stop funding them until they give equal rights to all their citizens and end their apartheid system. US gives them billions of dollars a year & gives them weapons
The squad is worthless.
I am a kenyan American but I am thinking America should allow people in America that love America, not just anyone
Rashida must go! Time to vote her out MI!
Her time has truly expired, should be returned to her home in the West Bank with granny
In my opinion, she should also be sent to Palestine. Why is she in the United States? The reason is simple, because in Palestine she will live a less good life.
How is she still in congress
CBsays how do we get stuck in everyone's BS. We need to take care of are own country.
So you havent learned anything fgrom 9/11?
yes, home first Fellow Americans. even one homeless American NO ONE should come in. that is being a traitor.
So angry when she speaks, hard to understand her message.
Not angry but definitely hurt by what’s going on in Israel as many should.
She has no message except hate
@@GizmoJeff232 you have no knowledge of what she has nor what is going on in Israel. There is always too sides to a story and Israel isn’t as innocent as they proclaim to be.
@@GizmoJeff232ts not wrong to hate a racist country. A country racist towards arabs that includes denying them right to return to their homes and continuous expulsion from their land.
If you think israel does not do any of that, you are factually a racist towards arabs.
@@EHed-kv2wb Well spoken (if you support racism).
I dont understand why she is in the US, Go to Saudi Arabia or Pakistan or another muslim country,Go
We will find you RASHIDA
Rashida Tlaib's support for certain radical ideologies is deeply concerning, and some believe it warrants further scrutiny.
Additionally, concerns have been raised about her financial ties to Iran, leading to discussions about potential conspiracy charges so we have been hearing.
On another note, there have been allegations of Iran engaging in extensive social media manipulation to influence global geopolitics, which some argue is a more significant issue than even Russia's involvement in such activities.
Personally she she be investigated at the highest levels due to her security clearances and potential information leaks to Iran.
@@ToccaLucia no not at all she is evoking violence
She has so much hate you can tell
Shes a snake cut of her head, lol
As a Black African from Kenya who converted to Judaism I can say without a doubt Israel is not an aparthied state but a free democratic state. All peoples from Black and Ethiopian Jews to Arab Israelis all have equal citizenship and rights under the great Jewish state of Israel. In summary the only difference between Israel and America or Canada or any other country is that Israel is a Jewish state.
As a white Irish man, I never experienced any xenophobia when I moved to America.
I guess all those central Americans who say that America is xenophobic or violating their human rights must be lying because I, as a white European, never experienced such things.
Take an example bro what Israeli did the Palestinians living inside isolated Gaza. The Jewish author Ilan Pappe wrote a book called The Biggest Prison on Earth ". Israeli regime is only regime which IGNORED so many UN resolutions
Her hearsay propaganda becomes her.
U.S. Is perfectly happy to follow human rights groups’ judgments when it comes to N Korea, Iran, China etc. But Israel apparently cannot be apartheid by defintion, no matter their actions.
Because they aren't why Iran and N Korea aren't either. Iran and N. Korea are just vicious dictators .
No - Israel is not an aparthoid state because it is just NOT. You are aware that Jews come from Israel and that they are not colonists but natives? You does your bigotry blind you to those facts, not to mention your problem with demographics numbers.
@@mrbrklyn Apartheid is different from whether you describe Israel as a colonial or settler state. The issue is you have a large population of Palestinian subjects whose fates are controlled by Israel, but are not allowed to be either Israeli citizens, or citizens of their own state. Even Israeli human rights organizations agree that Israel practises apartheid.
@@ailblentyn Israel is a state of about 7 million Native peoples defending themselves against a Billion Arabs who want them dead. That is not apartheid.
BTW - The very few "Israeli Rights organizations" you quote are radicalized left wing bigots that represent nothing but the fringe of Israeli society or even academia. But in Israel, unlike the Palestinian territories, we don't execute people to using their right to free speech, even if they are repugnant and bigots.
@@mrbrklynyou just decided that they're natives , they didn't live in the area for 2000 years and then came out out of nowhere and decided that they're entitled to the land more than the people that have been living on it for the last 100 years. Yupp makes so much sense lol
You need to go to your country and save your family!!!
Being a lawmaker is way to cut off US aid to Israel. US aid is crucial in helping Israel attack her people. So stop being ignorant and recognize there are multiple ways to help your people. People who have been suffering for over 7 decades.
Yeah she was born in the U.S.
If she did that, you'd just turn around and call her selfish. There's no winning in US politics & the corrupt media cause it's just a cesspit of greed and immorality. There's a reason the US propped up Apartheid South Africa too
She’s delusional 🚮
Did she have inappropriate economic dealings with palestine???
she doesn't realize that this has been going on with both groups for centuries and we can't help this, and she really is hysterical about this, why doesn't she do her job for her state???
No this has not been going on for centuries, at least in its current form. What has been going on for centuries is both Christian and Muslim bigorty and violence against Jews. And something can be done about it.
Why is she yelling?
They think Yelling means you are correct.
She doesn't get jesus was a jew..
She's not technically wrong unfortunately and she has every right to her damn opinion
2M Arabs live in Israel and have the same rights as the Israelis, wheres the Apartheid here?
@@BenBriskerWOW, learn some world history and politics dude
@@jenni0278the next history book you read will be your first. Why so racist?
@@BenBrisker And just in case you don't watch that, they're literally ziptying 9 year old Palestinian girls in that clip for nothing. Open your goddamn eyes
@@jenni0278He’s right and you’re wrong.
Israel treats all Israeli the same way like the US treats all Americans the same way.
Non Israelis are not Israelis.
Is she representing Palestine or America?
Is Mondaire Jones representing Israel or America?
@@IcarianX AMERICA.
There’s literally not one video of this woman where is isn’t speaking about Palestine
Kind of obvious that it is NOT AMERICA.
She's 100% right. The denial of reality regarding the racism, occupation and apartheid by the Israeli state is absurd. Its obvious that the emperor has no clothes
please tell me you're aware that Israel came to "occupy," as you people call it, the West Bank, Sinai Peninsula, and Gaza as a result of a DEFENSIVE war.
@@simonsobo4644 A "defensive" in which Israel attacked first.
Also, nations cannot expand their territory via military action. The world collectively decided this after WW2 for reasons that should be obvious...
@@IcarianX If what the world wants is taken into account how come the Arabs don't have to abide by Resolution 181?
The Arabs tried to militarily destroy Israel 4 times before changing tactics and now going full-on Hitler/trump and declaring themselves the victims.
If nations can't expand militarily what about the Crimea? And how 'bout that outpouring of heartfelt grief for those Crimeans the world ignored.
But as it turns out, I agree with you. Israel should not be allowed to expand by wars of conquest, nor any country. Israel was ready to return 94% of the territory taken during The Six Day War but the Arabs won't take "Yes" for an answer. However, if it was up to me I'd abandon that 94% with one proviso: Next time we're attacked we're taking that place over. After Israel abandons that land, whether Arabs have made peace or not, the Arabs lose whatever land they attack from.
Palestine is a myth
It is a shame the Israelites can't be free to enjoy their lives without worrying about Palestinian terrorism, which happens on a daily basis. The racist Palestinians deliberately kill as many innocent Israeli citizens as possible because of the Palestinian's Pay to Slay scheme. This is the policy of the Palestinian Authority (PA) which offers large and continuous cash payments and other incentives to individuals who carry out “resistance,” including terrorist acts, inside Israel and the West Bank. These payments to individuals or their families total $300 million a year. In 2010, the PA passed a series of resolutions stipulating that every Palestinian inmate in an Israeli prison who is convicted of a "terrorism-related offense" is to receive a monthly payment. In 2013, the PA's prime minister at the time, Rami Hamdallah, amended the law, offering additional benefits to prisoners upon their release. Palestinian Media Watch, which found that "the PA is diverting the payments through the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), a trick it has used in the past." As AFP reported in June 2020, Abbas ordered his security services to destroy "secret documents, fearing possible Israeli raids on their offices." The Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis noted at the time that the PA might have had the past in mind. An Israeli raid in September 2000 resulted in the seizure of PA and PLO documents which showed that "senior Palestinian Authority officers were actively involved in terrorism, providing logistical and financial assistance" to other terrorist groups. In addition to this, the autobiography of the late Mohammed Oudeh, better known as Abu Daoud, named the current Palestinian president, Mahmoud Abbas Abbas as one of the three senior officials of Fatah who assisted and funded Daoud in the Munich massacre of 1972, in which members of the Israeli Olympic were murdered by a Palestinian terror organisation.
Tlaib: Shut up.
Why are you getting triggered?
@@MichaelScott261 If you have to ask, then you have serious issues of knowing the difference between right and wrong.
@gerrycoleman7290 No, I just know what apartheid is, the consistent breach of signed treaties and endless persecution of another people is when it's happening. She was quoting several of the biggest human rights groups in the world and the biggest human rights body in Isreal, too. There's nothing wrong with that. Sorry if it upsets you.
@@MichaelScott261Bla, bla, bla, bla
@@gerrycoleman7290 typical 😂
Does this women know about her grand mother want to remove israel.
Ridiculous ranting.
This woman needs to resign. It’s a simple as that. ‘A Muslim extremists sympathizer’. These actions are unacceptable.
What is wrong with her???
🤡🤡🤡
Where's Debbie Wasserman Shultz? Where's Jaime Ratskin? Chuckie Schumer calling out her RACISM??!!
You just named 3 of the biggest scumbags in DC.
@@Mark-bi4ne Mic Drop 🎤
Which is it Tlaib? Your for America or not! Me thinks Not.
If the Jews have a right to establish the state of Israel for historical claims to that land, than the Mongolians have the right to rule over China Russia East Germany Austria Poland etc. since they conquered those lands and the Native people of this named continent currently called America have the right to establish a free native state on Manhattan island since even the name is in Native American and it was theirs for over 10000 years. And no, it was not bought from the natives so don’t even try that argument.
Remember the USS Indianapolis
She is evil
Why is she allowed to speak?
She was elected by her constituents, despite heavy opposition spending by the Israel lobby
Ebcause she is a duly elected member of Congress and in the US we have freedom of speach even if the speaker is a hateful bigot who wants to kill all the Jews.
She is right. Its a shame how afraid so many americans have been raised to be.
Calling out blatant racism is not fear. She should be expelled from congress.
Did she forget she has a microphone
I think she forgot she has a brain.
@@JazzATrainshe doesn’t.
She’s mentally I’ll 😂
If the shoe fits, wear it. Desmond Tutu, Nelson Mandela and others who suffered under the Apartheid regime in South Africa have called Israel an apartheid state. I'd like to see Netanyahu's fanboys explain how they know more about apartheid than Desmond Tutu.
OK. I will explain it again.... I know MUCH more about Israel the Desmond Tutu ever did! I am a Black man who lived in Israel. Tutu NEVER lived in Israel. Desmond Tutu was completely WRONG about Israel...not because he didn't know about apartheid, but because he didn't know about Israel. Being an expert on your own country does not make you an expert on all countries. Tutu had NO CLUE about the reality on the ground. Explain to me how someone who has NEVER been to my home town knows more about it than I do.
@@JazzATrain Israel's own largest human rights organization, along with the United Nations and countless other international agencies have concluded for a long time that Israel is an apartheid state. Maybe you should go live in an occupied territory or the Gaza strip and see how much compassion you get there
@@thehumanity0Some Jews are the worst enemies of Jews.
Israel can’t occupy their Native Homeland.
Jews are Native of Judea whilst Arabs are Native of Arabia.
Jews didn’t invade Arabia but Arabs invaded Judea and lost the Land.
The problem is that they don’t accept it.
@@thehumanity0 Don't you love how he writes "Black man"
Lol. Don't engage with these people. He is a Zionist replying to these messages, not a "Black man"
A black man KNOWS what Zionists think of black people.
@Magamonster Mandela was not a communist, you should actually learn what his actual beliefs were instead of regurgitating Sean Hannity lies. At most Mandela was a democratic socialist, but on that note so was Albert Einstein, George Orwell and countless other geniuses in the last 2 centuries - it's really not the sick burn you think it is.
Can someone explain a Logical Practical reason why the Middle East is a ''Holy Land'' ? It's too Hot, it's too Dry, and honestly, most of Europe, both north and south Americas, Africa and Asia are ALL nicer than the middle east... If you're not completely surrounded by lush vegitation, plenty of food and water, and abundant natural resources - WHY in the world does anyone want to live in a (literally) god forsaken wasteland ? Sure, lots of History, but as far as living in the middle east full time ? No way.
There are some who only want to rape and murder. For now their cause is Islam. If it wasn’t Islam they’d find some other cause to rationalize their actions. The last thing arab leaders want is peace because then they’d be expected to actually govern. Also, railing against Israel can be quite lucrative. One particular arab leader amassed over a billion dollars from his career of blaming Israel.
When was the last time you were there?
The Middle East is such a hotspot for one simple reason: the Jew. If Jews weren’t invested in the region no one would care about how much the arabs were exploiting their own people. And you’re right about the lack of natural resources in Israel yet that hasn’t stopped the Israelis from creating the largest economy in the entire Middle East. “Palestine” had been a desolate wasteland until Jewish immigrants returned and turned swamps and deserts into arable farmland. And now the argument's being made, rather successfully I might add, that the desert was always blooming and those colonial Zionist devils invaded “Palestine” and are now living large off the sweat and toil of enslaved, noble “Palestinian.”
Why are people like Tliab repeatedly re-elected every term. She does not hold the beliefs the people who elected her hold.
Obviously she does reflect their beliefs.
It’s the promise land to the Israeli people from God.
Religion is not an excuse to ethnically cleanse people from their homes.
@Magamonster two wrongs do not make a right. Palestinians have lived on that land for centuries now and many are just descendants of the jews mixing with arabs over a milennia. And Israel is the one currently committing ethnic cleansing, denying this is blatant arab racism.
@Magamonster So just because others did it long ago, makes it right for Israel to do it today? Amazing logic
All religion is evil. I will agree with a few things scriptures say though like: The Earth is given into the hands of the wicked.