UPDATE: I JUST GOT A WII U HOOKED UP AND IT'S CHARGING THE GAMEPAD. IF IT LETS ME ON, I'M GOING TO TRY TO FINALLY BEAT WHY ARE YOU STEALING FROM RUINS BEFORE THE SHUTDOWN I couldn't figure out how to include it but the old Carl vs Poo videos are some of my favorite memories as well, here's a spicy one: ua-cam.com/video/J_IROKZA4Y8/v-deo.html So long MM1 and thanks for all the memories! And thank YOU all for the years of awesomeness
I've only been watching you for like 8 years now definitely not nostalgic I dropped out after 7th and most my nights were League of Legends, Chef Boyardee, and Mario Maker Now I'm like an adult or something Ive moved myself thru 3 different states in that time Regardless im about to crack a can open with the same cat I had back then and enjoy this
I loved the troll where there was a clear trap with a fire mushrom inside it. But the opening where pointing in the direction you where suposed to go. So there didn´t look like there where any way to go inside it without doing it by purpose. Then the level forced you to go back and tricked Carl to enter the cage.
I remember nearly every single one of these clips after seeing them, but so many I'd just completely forgotten about before this video! So many amazing memories
I love how all the Kaizo clips have me going "Wow, Carl is insanely good at Mario" and then all the troll clips have me going "Wow, Carl is insanely bad at Mario"
@@CarlSagan42 he said and clears first view the second part of one of barbs hard levels and does the same at AGDQ where you first tried the last room of the relay race. I think you are more often than not a really good gamer :)
That's a favorite of mine, too, but I believe 4:38 might have been the first time I saw genuine "troll magic" and it absolutely floored me. Had the exact same reaction as Carl, then laughed uproariously for at least a full minute as I rewatched it a dozen times or more! I think that one just might take the cake for me 😂😆😅
You still are the most genius MM puzzle level creator I have come across. No other puzzle creator in the game has reached your level of integrity. That's how much I loved your levels
The first SMM1 video I watch was Carl playing the SMW underwater level called Master & Commander. Whenever I hear the SMW underwater theme, I always hear Carl sings "Barb is a peace of shit" every time lol. Thanks for the memories SMM1.
Just saw this on my feed, wanted to share a memory. Back in high school I would stay up till like 2am watching your mario maker videos. Idk why but I found them very very relaxing, and I would pass out watching em. Great times. I would do it like every night haha. Other than that I never had any interest in mario maker really, I do have the game but didnt play it much. I watched more for the personality rather than just the game. That was atleast 6-7 years ago now. Time flies.
That's what my mind thinks all the time when watching Carl's content. Knowing the he started streaming with Yoshi's Island speedruns vs failing the simplist of trolls shows he has a wide range of play.
Well, there are still other levels with cheated clear checks and some that became impossible when glitches were patched. Team 0% may have been able to cheese some of those groups, but not all. Trimming the herbs just got attention for being a cheated clear check that people genuinely believed wasn't cheated for a while.
It was this and your GDQ exhibitions that brought me to twitch in the first place. Thank you for being you Carl and thank you for being so dang entertaining!
i can think of a few other notable things that could have been included in this compilation: -Pause for Effect, Mecha Bowzilla and other extremely creative levels -the "Barb is a piece of shit" song from Master and Commander -the introduction of the Carlbox and Uno Mas, among several memes that are still used to this day -Brain Power -X=9 and Y=4 among several others
Damn. Sad to see it go. Been watching you since 2016 and remember seeing some of these videos when they were originally published. Here's to many more memories being made in SMM2 and (hopefully) SMM3. Thank you Carl for everything you have done for this community.
Your MM1 videos will always have a special place in my heart. They'd always get me through the stress of life and i always go back to a few. This video was a blast to watch
24:09 Probably my favorite Carl moment. Along with an extremely difficult super expert level that was not featured (can’t take anymore of this), that horrendous seanhip troll level which was the first of the “artful” troll levels, and the Carl vs Poo saga
True story, back in February of 2017, I had mono, which basically knocked me out and made me bedridden for a month. Your videos were some of the only things that helped keep myself sane during that time period, and I’ll be forever grateful for that!!!
I remember being subscribed to you, Carl, ever since the Mario Maker 1 troll days (before the tea spillage clip). To see this legendary game go is honestly saddening. Rest in Peace, Mario Maker 1, you provided many great memories, and will go down in history! ❤️ o7
It dawned on me a couple days ago that I have been watching you since... at least 6 or 7years now. That's crazy. I genuinely don't know where the time went. Thank you. ❤
I’ve been a long time fan of your content and I’m proud to say I was there for most of these clips (not live but for the UA-cam vids) and this has been quite the trip down memory lane. Thank you for this, Carl, and thank you for all the great content you’ve made for us and yourself to enjoy ❤
Oh man, I can’t believe these were from so long ago! Your MM1 videos and Discord are what got me into level designing several years ago, and now I’m modding Celeste and making my own sprites! I think it was due to you that I found out how cool level making and speedrunning can be.
My favorite classic Carl moments were when he’d play a Steve-O level or Barb’s “Master and Commander”. I still look up some of those old vods when I’m feeling low & they help. Thanks for all the fun memories over the years Carl & MM1
Man, watching Carl's MM1 videos was my guilty pleasure through college. So many good memories watching the hot garbage runs, the Carl vs. Poo challenge, ALL the troll levels, the amazing level clears, the science talks, and so many more amazing videos. I found you through 360Chrism back in 2016, when I was watching his stream and he encountered a ridiculously hard puzzle level that killed his 100 Mario run. Later, someone in his Discord linked your video beating it. I watched it and was amazed by its sheer difficulty, but happy that it got beat. Got recommended more of your videos as a result and, well, here we are. Thanks for all the amazing Mario Maker content over the years, Carl! Here's to many more laughs, science, and trolls in the years to come!
I started watching your videos around that time, what great memories! Carl Money, Brain Power, the memes were so good, Seanhip's puzzles, the troll levels, even the little music that plays when someone subscribed. I was never a twitch guy, but for a very long time I never missed a single upload here on UA-cam, It's no coincidence that I remember all these highlights! Thanks for all the entertainment, Carl!
Unbelievable how much time has passed. Favorite memories were always watching your one screen puzzle solves/speedruns on my work breaks. MM1 you will be missed
I downloaded all my favorites levels before shutdown (2 among them are from you). I was very active on SMM1 on my side as well, but SMM2 didn't reach my expectations. The fact they remove Amibo power-ups, 100 Mario Challenge and the internet site for bookmarks, i have to say I was disappointed a little bit, even for a so great game and all communities it created around the world. My favorite memories in MM1 is a level I created (not necessary a good one but with a lot of mechanics I discovered by myself), has been played by a youtuber with more than one million subscribers, and got viral for a while. Some players shared it to other youtubers, but one of them is now a friend of mine 🙂
This truly is the end of an era. I've been watching you since MM1, and it's crazy to think that we're all getting ever closer to saying the same thing about MM2 when (hopefully) MM3 comes along. Thank you for all the memories and laughs, Carl ❤
I actually rewatch the old videos a lot - usually starting with the legendary, original Twice Twice and then going down the rabbit hole. I never owned MM1 myself, but I absolutely loved watching you over the years. Besides the original Twice Twice, I think my favourite levels were Master and Commander as well as the castle level by Burg(?). Oh, and many of the puzzle levels. It was an all around great time!
Been subbed since ‘16. One of my favorite creators. I miss his blowups. So epic. The Bob Ross hype. The brain power song. Master and Commander. I hope you keep it rolling, dude.
Watching this, I realized just how long I've been watching you. I can't even remember how I ended up finding out about you. To me, your videos are just a part of my week. Every blind moment, every clutchsagan... all of it. Only one of these videos I didn't watch upon release: your first one. I hope I see many more. Thank you Carl.
I started watching you and your Mario maker content when I started middle school, and next month, I’m graduating from high school! Love you and everything you do, Larl ❤❤❤
Watching this video brought back a ton of memories. The first video I ever watched was you playing through Mecha Bowzilla, (I was 11 then, I hit 18 last October, time flies), and I've been devouring your content since. I'm so glad this game came out and I love the community that has spawned; even though I'm not an active participant, watching from the sidelines has been an absolute joy. From you banging your head against the wall with seemingly impossible kaizo levels, to banging your head against the wall fighting against your own tunnel vision, this game and this channel has been a pleasure. Keep kicking ass Carl!
I always loved watching your MM1 vids every week. Your explanations of the mechanics were my favorite part since I am not very good at it. It was nice for someone to break down what was going on. I learned so much from not just that but also from all the science stuff which was a nice treat. Thanks for all the memories Carl. I hope Nintendo makes MM3 so the fun never stops. If not that's fine, I love all of your playthroughs of different games. Specially your recent Slay the spire one, that game is my jam! Keep up the good work o3o!!
Honestly, rewatching your explanations of how mechanics work was what draw me to your videos and why I've been a fan of you and your work since 2015. It got me more into speedrunning, it got me into Kaizo, it got me into watching troll levels and appreciating garbo, got me back into science, got me into watching Poo (who then opened another can of worms altogether), it got me into streaming. I owe SMM and you personally Carl for a lot in my life. Thank you!
I think one of my favorite memories is Shawnhips mega troll level, seeing a puzzle making genius go mad with power was hilarious. Anyways, I've been watching you since middle school, and I am now in college, keep up the amazing content (:
I know that the pretendo team will be working to make their own servers after official ones shutdown, but I’m gonna miss playing on official ones. For anyone interested, they archived all the Mario maker content and have a snapshot server in read only right now (meaning you can play but can’t upload), and they’re gonna work on a ton of other games and stuff before everything is just like how it used to be.
Heya Carl! I’ve actually never left any comments before, but I’ve been watching since I started high school back in 2015 when I got hooked on your kaizo content and Yoshi’s Island rando videos. It’s sad to see SMM1 go, and it’s kinda humbling to think of just how far we’ve come. Here’s to many more years (and hopefully SMM3!) P.S. Loving the CarlPlayin first-time play through, reminds me a lot of some of that magic from the early days of Carlblind from SMM1
I literally learned English from scratch while watching your mario maker videos, back in 2016 I could not speak a word of english but before I knew it I was slowly understanding more and more. So thank you Carl and Mario Maker for the awesome content and learning experience
I remember stumbling upon your troll level videos back in 2018/2019 when I was going through a hard time in my life and immediately got hooked on both your content and Mario Maker in general, to this day I still love watching all your content, and have so many great memories and laughs. Can't wait to see what the future brings for Mario Maker! (Hopefuly SMM3, please Nintendo)
Oh wow, how time flies. Im not great with words, but i wanna say: Thank you so much Carl for all of the content that you have made (and still are creating). It feels like it was yesterday when you had the first twice twice encounter, or another spectacular pink birdo level. You actually had such a great impact on my life with your videos. Be it speedruns, troll levels, the silly puns or the hot spaghetti, watching your content was always amazing. It was also due to you and your science discussions / talks at the end of the videos that I decided to become a scientist myself!! So from the bottom of my heart thank you Carl and thanks to the awesome MM Community! I sadly never got to play MM1 as I didnt have a WiiU but I almost got one just because of that haha Much love, Hope to see you many more years!❤❤❤
Thank you for all the memories ❤ I remember watching almost all of these 😊 also it's awesome to see you just destroy levels as much as I love to see you spaghetti all over the place 😂 RIP MM1 you will be missed
I never played Super Mario Maker but I saw this guy named Grand Poo Bear playing it in a youtube video once. From there I found an entire community of people who played this game. I never used to watch people play games before but after seeing that I had to see what else people could come up with. Now it's awesome to see how many SMM guys have rom hacks and SMM2 levels that are absolutely exhilarating to watch. Thanks for all the great memories Carl and the rest of the Mario Maker community. It's truly been a blast.
As an on/off viewer at this time, these videos used to make my day when they popped up in my feed. Now, as a sub, I still look forward to vids to this day. Thx Carl
One of the games of all time. I'm a more recent fan of the channel, but the fondness for this game is really incredible. I don't know if we'll ever get a game with this exact feeling again, and that's really bittersweet.
Man, what a trip down memory lane. You were one of the first Mario Maker streamers I ritualistically watched and you kept me sane through many awful days at work, Carl. Thank you for all the work you've put into your content over the years. Here's hoping we get MM3 for even more! Regardless though, I'll pretty much watch whatever you put out, Mario or not, so as long as you're still willing to upload content, loads of us will be here to watch. :)
I'm happy to say that I remember most of the clips seen so far! The amount of creativity that the MM/romhack communities constantly display always amaze me. One of my favorite parts of these old videos is when you'd download the levels and see how the technical aspects work. One of the biggest missed bits from MM 2!
It feels weird to have nostalgia for a game that's not that old, but I had a great few years making, playing, and watching SMM levels. It hurts to see the game gone forever (at least on official servers). Thanks to all the great people in the maker community and thank you Carl for bringing joy to so many and helping to foster the community.
I've been there since pemature detonation, it was actually the first mario maker level i've ever seen. I got instantly hooked, and i'm still here (Even thought i never own any modern nintendo console). Thanks Carl for all those years of fun, laugh and love !
Hi Carl thanks for the trip down memory lane :) It was really amazing to see, I've been following you since the beginning of Mario Maker and this was so much nostalgia. I have very fond memories of puzzling seanhip2 with you.
SMM1 was how I first found your channel. It was veeeery early in the game's life cycle and it was the first time i started watching people play video games for fun. It's been almost 8 years since then. Thank you for the many many hours of joy you've brought to my life, and for sending me on a path to eventually discover every single other video game youtuber in one way or another. Thank you for all the years, and I look forward to many more.
Carl, thank you for almost a decade of entertainment, laughter, and great content memories. One of my favorite SMM1 moments outside of this video was the level Barb sent to Carl that was just 4 rows of invisible blocks and one magikoopa. RIP SMM1, gone but not forgotten.
As many others have mentioned, I started watching very early in the MM1 days and taking these strolls down memory lane have been a delight and only a little bit sad. Thanks for all the incredible content Carl!
Thanks for all the content - I found out about Mario Maker and its community through you and its been alot of fun years. Even if it shuts down now the saga continues on with Romhacks and MM2 Looking forward to the next decade of trolls and fake pipes :D
I never comment on videos, but i just wanted to thank you for all the memories! Started watching around 2015-2016 when you were playing Seanhips puzzle levels, and i never stopped watching! To see the whole troll level journey, from hot garbage to the most amazing levels ever made, is something I'll never forget. On to MM3 (hopefully) ❤
Looking back at it, playing Mario maker and watching your videos (especially the puzzle videos) are what inspired me to buy MM2 on the switch and start making puzzle levels myself, which in turn inspired me to even make my own puzzle game. Thank you for all the awesome memories over the years!
I remember being obsessed with finding the HARDEST MM1 level back then, and I came across pit of pePanga skyzo. I wanted to beat the level myself so I looked up completion videos to get familiar with the level. That is where I found someone who was energetic, funny and popped off really freaking hard when beating the level. Thank you Carl. I hold a tremendous amount of respect for you.
Watching you play MM1 troll levels was the most entertaining experience back then. I’d find myself staying up way later than I should have, laughing my sorry butt off, and replaying the best moments over and over. These days I’m trying harder to manage my time a little better so I don’t catch as many recaps, but I’ll never forget all the fun you and your evil friends gave me. Thank you so much for the smiles and memories.
Thank you for sharing this. Over the years, i've watched a lot of youtubers on and off but you're the only one i'm still watching religiously. Keep it up
Been watching for years. So happy I found your channel. You're so wholesome. I hope you can find strength in the fact that you inspire and spread positive vibes to your fellow man. Thanks for the memories MM1!
Ever since the "Mecha bowzilla" video blew up I found it as well and since then have been subbed to your channel, I can barely believe that it already has been 7 years since I started watching your channel. Your videos truly have become a thing I look forward to and enjoy them to the fullest. Thank you for being you Carl!
Thank you for all the years, SMM1. There have been too many things that I loved to see you play Carl but the puzzle level with two identical screens on top of one another where you must eventually use both to solve the level is a memory I've been keeping in my head for a while. Don't remember if it was actually from the first game though or its name. Let's see that SMM3 and actually 3D troll levels, imagine ALL the jank that would come from an extra dimension!
Got into watching MM because of you. The last time I fired up my wiiu was to make you a 1 screen puzzle. The solution… hit the hidden block in the top of the screen. Glad that one never saw the light of day, and glad I still watch your vids 8 years later 😅
I remember each and every one of these moments, believe it or not you were a big part of my childhood carl! Your videos would always and still do help me get through the bad times. Goodbye mario maker 1, and thank you Carl for this little trip down memory lane ❤
I may not keep up with the Mario Maker community as much nowadays but I watched a ton of these back when they first came out. The GDQ showcases in particular always blew me away. I think my favorite MM1 memory is seeing you play 7 Troly pieces, that was the first time my mind was completely shattered by how far someone could take a troll
dont know if ive ever commented here before but, ive been watching old mario maker one videos of yours and im so glad you made this, love remembering these legendary moments. onwards to more content and hopefully eventually a mario maker 3
It's insane how nostalgic I'm getting over Mario Maker 1. I didn't own a Wii U so I only watched videos and livestreams of the game until Mario Maker 2, but that didn't stop me from being a fan. It's sad to see it go but I'll forever cherish the memories it gave me
So many gems in this video! I never even played MM but your videos and your enthusiasm really got me hooked and I still am! It's sad it's gone now but were lucky you still have the videos
Mario Maker has been around since 2015. Crazy how long it's been out. Watching these made me get a Wii U and the game and make levels. I still have the entire box with the book and everything that came with it. It is in my collection of Nintendo games. These videos are the best, I liked the single screen puzzle levels, those are my favorite videos.
Tbh its still kinda unbelievable that MM1 is ending. I had so many fun times and so many laughing with Carl and his MM1 levels. I know there is much incredible troll opportunities in MM2 too but some things like overlaying Pipes will never be the same like it was in MM1. Thank you for your wonderful videos Carl and have a great one ^^
Such a great and nostalgic compilation!! Not to mention the hairy story we just went through. Amazing journey! Glade to have experienced all the years of laughter!
This compilation brought up so many memories. First watched you during your 'One More' levels, and have been watching since. People forget that you actually can play this game a little, I nickname you ThaCarl721 for those levels. Gonna miss all the overlaid pipes, Seanhip puzzles, flying cannons, moving thwomps, and just overall genius that this community displayed. MM2 may be a better, more polished game, but there's just something about MM1 that 2 will never have. Through Carl I discovered Barb, Beast, Poo, Panga, and so many other streamers. RIP MM1 you legend
I remember being in high school and randomly coming across your channel. I still remember the first SMM1 video. One of the Most memorable moments was Carl's speghetti sauce ad😂
This video gives me so much nostalgia. I can't believe it's been so long since I was in high school, watching your SMM1 videos. This era of CarlSagan42 will always hold a special place in my heart ❤
Carl playing Super Mario Maker and making Fly Me To The Stars made me connect with the core of my childhood. It also made me remember why Nintendo is the best videogame company. Super Mario Maker is a piece of art. It brought to life the dreams of many people, me included, who always wanted to make their own Mario levels. And man, most of us really suck at it. But the flowing content of the multiple streamers of this AWESOME community keeps the spark of creativity alive, to this day and beyond. Thank you so much, dude.
Your troll series vs. Grandpoo bear getting revenge on each other will always be my favorite memory of this game, mole-ing each other back and forth. So amazing
After all these years i still remember all these things, carls videos has had a massive impact on my childhood, i am so thankful for such a loving and kind community with so many talented people. A purely sacred corner of the internet, thank you all for everything and thank you carl❤
Thanks for the memories ! Never had the chance to play a minute of SMM but I remember all of these over the years ! Funny to look at SMM again and notice all the changes in the physics of the game compared with SMM2. Also, lainky mario
My brother and I have been watching you since when I was in Middle School (I'm a Junior in College now, funny how time flies). Thank you for all the memories and laughs during these past years! RIP MM1, you will always have a special place in our hearts
I have to carefully look at the screen and memorize which buttons to press when I see certain things happen on the screen. I notice people like Thabeast will often close their eyes (or not and just kinda stare into the distance) solving a kaizo section in their head and I'm like dang
UPDATE: I JUST GOT A WII U HOOKED UP AND IT'S CHARGING THE GAMEPAD. IF IT LETS ME ON, I'M GOING TO TRY TO FINALLY BEAT WHY ARE YOU STEALING FROM RUINS BEFORE THE SHUTDOWN
I couldn't figure out how to include it but the old Carl vs Poo videos are some of my favorite memories as well, here's a spicy one: ua-cam.com/video/J_IROKZA4Y8/v-deo.html
So long MM1 and thanks for all the memories! And thank YOU all for the years of awesomeness
Ty Carl
I've only been watching you for like 8 years now definitely not nostalgic
I dropped out after 7th and most my nights were League of Legends, Chef Boyardee, and Mario Maker
Now I'm like an adult or something
Ive moved myself thru 3 different states in that time
Regardless im about to crack a can open with the same cat I had back then and enjoy this
Man, so many great memories. For the old time fans can you go back and clear "why are you stealing from ruins?"
^
If he clears that... then that's the death of a legend
The big storyline in all of this for me was whether Carl will finally clear 'Why are you stealing from ruins?'
At this point, the real question is, “Why AREN’T you stealing from ruins?”
I loved the troll where there was a clear trap with a fire mushrom inside it. But the opening where pointing in the direction you where suposed to go. So there didn´t look like there where any way to go inside it without doing it by purpose. Then the level forced you to go back and tricked Carl to enter the cage.
Ruins is Carl's Trimming the Herbs
I remember nearly every single one of these clips after seeing them, but so many I'd just completely forgotten about before this video! So many amazing memories
To this day, I hadn't forgotten about the fake boot-pipe. Legendary.
I love how all the Kaizo clips have me going "Wow, Carl is insanely good at Mario"
and then all the troll clips have me going "Wow, Carl is insanely bad at Mario"
I become good with practice and careful research. On the fly, I'm a spaghetti monster.
@@CarlSagan42 Pretty much. Thanks for all the awesome memories
@@SmugLookingBarrel: The duality of Larl
@@CarlSagan42Schrodinger Carl
@@CarlSagan42 he said and clears first view the second part of one of barbs hard levels and does the same at AGDQ where you first tried the last room of the relay race.
I think you are more often than not a really good gamer :)
The fake pipe that's actually a boot is still possibly my all time favourite SMM1 troll. It's so good.
Icay making that level for Carl after just loved cause first level was such an awesome moment of recognition. It might be My all time favorite too.
I'm really proud of it too :3 And I'm still so happy Carl ended up falling for it exactly how I intended lmao
@@Icayy: That was awesome, truly a classic moment. Your levels inspired a lot of what was to come, so thanks(? 😋) for your efforts!
That's a favorite of mine, too, but I believe 4:38 might have been the first time I saw genuine "troll magic" and it absolutely floored me. Had the exact same reaction as Carl, then laughed uproariously for at least a full minute as I rewatched it a dozen times or more! I think that one just might take the cake for me 😂😆😅
Yeah that one was great.
So many great memories, i always go back and watch MM1 vids all the time.
damn its the real Seanhip. so many great memories indeed.
You were an inspiration Sean, I remember making many horrible 1screen puzzles as a 13yo trying to emulate you😂. Good times
Watching Carl play your puzzle levels was what got me into Mario Maker! Thank you!
You still are the most genius MM puzzle level creator I have come across. No other puzzle creator in the game has reached your level of integrity. That's how much I loved your levels
The first SMM1 video I watch was Carl playing the SMW underwater level called Master & Commander. Whenever I hear the SMW underwater theme, I always hear Carl sings "Barb is a peace of shit" every time lol. Thanks for the memories SMM1.
One of the best MM1 videos! Still cracks me up when i hear it 😂
YES!! 🤣
Just saw this on my feed, wanted to share a memory. Back in high school I would stay up till like 2am watching your mario maker videos. Idk why but I found them very very relaxing, and I would pass out watching em. Great times. I would do it like every night haha. Other than that I never had any interest in mario maker really, I do have the game but didnt play it much. I watched more for the personality rather than just the game. That was atleast 6-7 years ago now. Time flies.
that’s crazy i’ve never met anyone else that has this same experience, through high school every fuckin night i’d watch till 2am…
Carl: Creates and clears extreme precision levels.
Also Carl: I just got hit by my own kaizo block!
That's what my mind thinks all the time when watching Carl's content. Knowing the he started streaming with Yoshi's Island speedruns vs failing the simplist of trolls shows he has a wide range of play.
they may be shutting it down, but the silver lining is that trimming the herbs WAS cleared!!! its shutting down completely beaten
Well, there are still other levels with cheated clear checks and some that became impossible when glitches were patched. Team 0% may have been able to cheese some of those groups, but not all. Trimming the herbs just got attention for being a cheated clear check that people genuinely believed wasn't cheated for a while.
who cleared it ? is there a video ?
Yeah, first I heard about it! @@Cashman9111
It was this and your GDQ exhibitions that brought me to twitch in the first place. Thank you for being you Carl and thank you for being so dang entertaining!
GDQ and ThomAndy`s shenanigans for me lol. 😂
i can think of a few other notable things that could have been included in this compilation:
-Pause for Effect, Mecha Bowzilla and other extremely creative levels
-the "Barb is a piece of shit" song from Master and Commander
-the introduction of the Carlbox and Uno Mas, among several memes that are still used to this day
-Brain Power
-X=9 and Y=4
among several others
Damn. Sad to see it go. Been watching you since 2016 and remember seeing some of these videos when they were originally published. Here's to many more memories being made in SMM2 and (hopefully) SMM3. Thank you Carl for everything you have done for this community.
11:27 Seven stupid pieces has to be my all time favorite level for that genius CP1😂
Your MM1 videos will always have a special place in my heart. They'd always get me through the stress of life and i always go back to a few. This video was a blast to watch
24:09 Probably my favorite Carl moment. Along with an extremely difficult super expert level that was not featured (can’t take anymore of this), that horrendous seanhip troll level which was the first of the “artful” troll levels, and the Carl vs Poo saga
True story, back in February of 2017, I had mono, which basically knocked me out and made me bedridden for a month. Your videos were some of the only things that helped keep myself sane during that time period, and I’ll be forever grateful for that!!!
I remember being subscribed to you, Carl, ever since the Mario Maker 1 troll days (before the tea spillage clip). To see this legendary game go is honestly saddening. Rest in Peace, Mario Maker 1, you provided many great memories, and will go down in history! ❤️ o7
o7
o7 😢
It dawned on me a couple days ago that I have been watching you since... at least 6 or 7years now. That's crazy. I genuinely don't know where the time went. Thank you. ❤
I’ve been a long time fan of your content and I’m proud to say I was there for most of these clips (not live but for the UA-cam vids) and this has been quite the trip down memory lane. Thank you for this, Carl, and thank you for all the great content you’ve made for us and yourself to enjoy ❤
Oh man, I can’t believe these were from so long ago! Your MM1 videos and Discord are what got me into level designing several years ago, and now I’m modding Celeste and making my own sprites! I think it was due to you that I found out how cool level making and speedrunning can be.
My favorite classic Carl moments were when he’d play a Steve-O level or Barb’s “Master and Commander”. I still look up some of those old vods when I’m feeling low & they help. Thanks for all the fun memories over the years Carl & MM1
Man, watching Carl's MM1 videos was my guilty pleasure through college. So many good memories watching the hot garbage runs, the Carl vs. Poo challenge, ALL the troll levels, the amazing level clears, the science talks, and so many more amazing videos. I found you through 360Chrism back in 2016, when I was watching his stream and he encountered a ridiculously hard puzzle level that killed his 100 Mario run. Later, someone in his Discord linked your video beating it. I watched it and was amazed by its sheer difficulty, but happy that it got beat. Got recommended more of your videos as a result and, well, here we are. Thanks for all the amazing Mario Maker content over the years, Carl! Here's to many more laughs, science, and trolls in the years to come!
I started watching your videos around that time, what great memories! Carl Money, Brain Power, the memes were so good, Seanhip's puzzles, the troll levels, even the little music that plays when someone subscribed. I was never a twitch guy, but for a very long time I never missed a single upload here on UA-cam, It's no coincidence that I remember all these highlights! Thanks for all the entertainment, Carl!
Unbelievable how much time has passed. Favorite memories were always watching your one screen puzzle solves/speedruns on my work breaks.
MM1 you will be missed
I downloaded all my favorites levels before shutdown (2 among them are from you). I was very active on SMM1 on my side as well, but SMM2 didn't reach my expectations. The fact they remove Amibo power-ups, 100 Mario Challenge and the internet site for bookmarks, i have to say I was disappointed a little bit, even for a so great game and all communities it created around the world.
My favorite memories in MM1 is a level I created (not necessary a good one but with a lot of mechanics I discovered by myself), has been played by a youtuber with more than one million subscribers, and got viral for a while. Some players shared it to other youtubers, but one of them is now a friend of mine 🙂
That's awesome i hope youve found another outlet for that design creativity :)
It's been so long man. I remember a lot of these clips from when they came out, can't believe how long ago that was.
This truly is the end of an era. I've been watching you since MM1, and it's crazy to think that we're all getting ever closer to saying the same thing about MM2 when (hopefully) MM3 comes along. Thank you for all the memories and laughs, Carl ❤
Ahhh, now this is some nostalgia. I watched you ALL THE TIME in high school and remember most of these moments, thanks for being awesome Carl :D
The puzzle speedrun era is still one of my favorites. Thanks for the MM1 memories.
I actually rewatch the old videos a lot - usually starting with the legendary, original Twice Twice and then going down the rabbit hole. I never owned MM1 myself, but I absolutely loved watching you over the years. Besides the original Twice Twice, I think my favourite levels were Master and Commander as well as the castle level by Burg(?). Oh, and many of the puzzle levels. It was an all around great time!
Been subbed since ‘16. One of my favorite creators. I miss his blowups. So epic. The Bob Ross hype. The brain power song. Master and Commander. I hope you keep it rolling, dude.
Hey Carl you’re a really great person when it comes to Mario. You just jumped straight into my heart
Watching this, I realized just how long I've been watching you. I can't even remember how I ended up finding out about you. To me, your videos are just a part of my week. Every blind moment, every clutchsagan... all of it. Only one of these videos I didn't watch upon release: your first one.
I hope I see many more. Thank you Carl.
I started watching you and your Mario maker content when I started middle school, and next month, I’m graduating from high school! Love you and everything you do, Larl ❤❤❤
I’m in the same boat lol
Watching this video brought back a ton of memories. The first video I ever watched was you playing through Mecha Bowzilla, (I was 11 then, I hit 18 last October, time flies), and I've been devouring your content since. I'm so glad this game came out and I love the community that has spawned; even though I'm not an active participant, watching from the sidelines has been an absolute joy. From you banging your head against the wall with seemingly impossible kaizo levels, to banging your head against the wall fighting against your own tunnel vision, this game and this channel has been a pleasure. Keep kicking ass Carl!
I always loved watching your MM1 vids every week. Your explanations of the mechanics were my favorite part since I am not very good at it. It was nice for someone to break down what was going on. I learned so much from not just that but also from all the science stuff which was a nice treat. Thanks for all the memories Carl.
I hope Nintendo makes MM3 so the fun never stops. If not that's fine, I love all of your playthroughs of different games. Specially your recent Slay the spire one, that game is my jam! Keep up the good work o3o!!
the puzzle WR were always my favorite part of the sean hip level videos
Honestly, rewatching your explanations of how mechanics work was what draw me to your videos and why I've been a fan of you and your work since 2015. It got me more into speedrunning, it got me into Kaizo, it got me into watching troll levels and appreciating garbo, got me back into science, got me into watching Poo (who then opened another can of worms altogether), it got me into streaming. I owe SMM and you personally Carl for a lot in my life. Thank you!
Seeing some of Carl's old footage is genuinely crazy. I only know him for his love of Toll Levels, never knew he had such absurd skill with the game.
I think one of my favorite memories is Shawnhips mega troll level, seeing a puzzle making genius go mad with power was hilarious. Anyways, I've been watching you since middle school, and I am now in college, keep up the amazing content (:
I know that the pretendo team will be working to make their own servers after official ones shutdown, but I’m gonna miss playing on official ones.
For anyone interested, they archived all the Mario maker content and have a snapshot server in read only right now (meaning you can play but can’t upload), and they’re gonna work on a ton of other games and stuff before everything is just like how it used to be.
Heya Carl! I’ve actually never left any comments before, but I’ve been watching since I started high school back in 2015 when I got hooked on your kaizo content and Yoshi’s Island rando videos. It’s sad to see SMM1 go, and it’s kinda humbling to think of just how far we’ve come. Here’s to many more years (and hopefully SMM3!)
P.S. Loving the CarlPlayin first-time play through, reminds me a lot of some of that magic from the early days of Carlblind from SMM1
you and this game have given me some phenomenal memories. thank you so much for helping define a part and era of my life and now remember it.
Such a bittersweet moment
Gonna miss MM1, found some amazing content creators thanks to it (yourself included)
I literally learned English from scratch while watching your mario maker videos,
back in 2016 I could not speak a word of english but before I knew it I was slowly understanding more and more.
So thank you Carl and Mario Maker for the awesome content and learning experience
Years of watching you play troll levels, I forgot you were a F***N GAMER!! Good to see these old clips again, MK1 will live long in our hearts
I remember stumbling upon your troll level videos back in 2018/2019 when I was going through a hard time in my life and immediately got hooked on both your content and Mario Maker in general, to this day I still love watching all your content, and have so many great memories and laughs. Can't wait to see what the future brings for Mario Maker! (Hopefuly SMM3, please Nintendo)
Oh wow, how time flies. Im not great with words, but i wanna say: Thank you so much Carl for all of the content that you have made (and still are creating). It feels like it was yesterday when you had the first twice twice encounter, or another spectacular pink birdo level.
You actually had such a great impact on my life with your videos. Be it speedruns, troll levels, the silly puns or the hot spaghetti, watching your content was always amazing. It was also due to you and your science discussions / talks at the end of the videos that I decided to become a scientist myself!!
So from the bottom of my heart thank you Carl and thanks to the awesome MM Community! I sadly never got to play MM1 as I didnt have a WiiU but I almost got one just because of that haha
Much love, Hope to see you many more years!❤❤❤
Thank you for all the memories ❤ I remember watching almost all of these 😊 also it's awesome to see you just destroy levels as much as I love to see you spaghetti all over the place 😂 RIP MM1 you will be missed
I never played Super Mario Maker but I saw this guy named Grand Poo Bear playing it in a youtube video once. From there I found an entire community of people who played this game. I never used to watch people play games before but after seeing that I had to see what else people could come up with. Now it's awesome to see how many SMM guys have rom hacks and SMM2 levels that are absolutely exhilarating to watch. Thanks for all the great memories Carl and the rest of the Mario Maker community. It's truly been a blast.
As an on/off viewer at this time, these videos used to make my day when they popped up in my feed. Now, as a sub, I still look forward to vids to this day. Thx Carl
One of the games of all time. I'm a more recent fan of the channel, but the fondness for this game is really incredible. I don't know if we'll ever get a game with this exact feeling again, and that's really bittersweet.
Man, what a trip down memory lane. You were one of the first Mario Maker streamers I ritualistically watched and you kept me sane through many awful days at work, Carl. Thank you for all the work you've put into your content over the years. Here's hoping we get MM3 for even more! Regardless though, I'll pretty much watch whatever you put out, Mario or not, so as long as you're still willing to upload content, loads of us will be here to watch. :)
I'm happy to say that I remember most of the clips seen so far! The amount of creativity that the MM/romhack communities constantly display always amaze me. One of my favorite parts of these old videos is when you'd download the levels and see how the technical aspects work. One of the biggest missed bits from MM 2!
It feels weird to have nostalgia for a game that's not that old, but I had a great few years making, playing, and watching SMM levels. It hurts to see the game gone forever (at least on official servers). Thanks to all the great people in the maker community and thank you Carl for bringing joy to so many and helping to foster the community.
I've been there since pemature detonation, it was actually the first mario maker level i've ever seen. I got instantly hooked, and i'm still here (Even thought i never own any modern nintendo console). Thanks Carl for all those years of fun, laugh and love !
Hi Carl thanks for the trip down memory lane :) It was really amazing to see, I've been following you since the beginning of Mario Maker and this was so much nostalgia. I have very fond memories of puzzling seanhip2 with you.
One of the best nostalgia-trips ever.
SMM1 was how I first found your channel. It was veeeery early in the game's life cycle and it was the first time i started watching people play video games for fun. It's been almost 8 years since then. Thank you for the many many hours of joy you've brought to my life, and for sending me on a path to eventually discover every single other video game youtuber in one way or another. Thank you for all the years, and I look forward to many more.
Carl, thank you for almost a decade of entertainment, laughter, and great content memories. One of my favorite SMM1 moments outside of this video was the level Barb sent to Carl that was just 4 rows of invisible blocks and one magikoopa. RIP SMM1, gone but not forgotten.
As many others have mentioned, I started watching very early in the MM1 days and taking these strolls down memory lane have been a delight and only a little bit sad. Thanks for all the incredible content Carl!
Thanks for all the content - I found out about Mario Maker and its community through you and its been alot of fun years. Even if it shuts down now the saga continues on with Romhacks and MM2
Looking forward to the next decade of trolls and fake pipes :D
I never comment on videos, but i just wanted to thank you for all the memories! Started watching around 2015-2016 when you were playing Seanhips puzzle levels, and i never stopped watching! To see the whole troll level journey, from hot garbage to the most amazing levels ever made, is something I'll never forget. On to MM3 (hopefully) ❤
Looking back at it, playing Mario maker and watching your videos (especially the puzzle videos) are what inspired me to buy MM2 on the switch and start making puzzle levels myself, which in turn inspired me to even make my own puzzle game. Thank you for all the awesome memories over the years!
I remember being obsessed with finding the HARDEST MM1 level back then, and I came across pit of pePanga skyzo. I wanted to beat the level myself so I looked up completion videos to get familiar with the level. That is where I found someone who was energetic, funny and popped off really freaking hard when beating the level. Thank you Carl. I hold a tremendous amount of respect for you.
Bro, i rememebr each and everyone one of these moments. Watching you play mm1 back in 2017 saved me from a dark time of being bed ridden
Watching you play MM1 troll levels was the most entertaining experience back then. I’d find myself staying up way later than I should have, laughing my sorry butt off, and replaying the best moments over and over. These days I’m trying harder to manage my time a little better so I don’t catch as many recaps, but I’ll never forget all the fun you and your evil friends gave me. Thank you so much for the smiles and memories.
Thank you for sharing this. Over the years, i've watched a lot of youtubers on and off but you're the only one i'm still watching religiously. Keep it up
Been watching for years. So happy I found your channel. You're so wholesome. I hope you can find strength in the fact that you inspire and spread positive vibes to your fellow man.
Thanks for the memories MM1!
So many great memories I had almost forgotten about. I forgot just how much crazy kaizo and speedrun stuff you used to do
Ever since the "Mecha bowzilla" video blew up I found it as well and since then have been subbed to your channel, I can barely believe that it already has been 7 years since I started watching your channel. Your videos truly have become a thing I look forward to and enjoy them to the fullest. Thank you for being you Carl!
I've seen some other creators SMM1 is going away videos, but this one is by far the most full of nostalgia and love.
Thank you for all the years, SMM1. There have been too many things that I loved to see you play Carl but the puzzle level with two identical screens on top of one another where you must eventually use both to solve the level is a memory I've been keeping in my head for a while. Don't remember if it was actually from the first game though or its name. Let's see that SMM3 and actually 3D troll levels, imagine ALL the jank that would come from an extra dimension!
Got into watching MM because of you. The last time I fired up my wiiu was to make you a 1 screen puzzle. The solution… hit the hidden block in the top of the screen. Glad that one never saw the light of day, and glad I still watch your vids 8 years later 😅
I remember each and every one of these moments, believe it or not you were a big part of my childhood carl! Your videos would always and still do help me get through the bad times. Goodbye mario maker 1, and thank you Carl for this little trip down memory lane ❤
I may not keep up with the Mario Maker community as much nowadays but I watched a ton of these back when they first came out. The GDQ showcases in particular always blew me away. I think my favorite MM1 memory is seeing you play 7 Troly pieces, that was the first time my mind was completely shattered by how far someone could take a troll
dont know if ive ever commented here before but, ive been watching old mario maker one videos of yours and im so glad you made this, love remembering these legendary moments.
onwards to more content and hopefully eventually a mario maker 3
It's insane how nostalgic I'm getting over Mario Maker 1. I didn't own a Wii U so I only watched videos and livestreams of the game until Mario Maker 2, but that didn't stop me from being a fan. It's sad to see it go but I'll forever cherish the memories it gave me
So many gems in this video! I never even played MM but your videos and your enthusiasm really got me hooked and I still am! It's sad it's gone now but were lucky you still have the videos
Mario Maker has been around since 2015. Crazy how long it's been out. Watching these made me get a Wii U and the game and make levels. I still have the entire box with the book and everything that came with it. It is in my collection of Nintendo games. These videos are the best, I liked the single screen puzzle levels, those are my favorite videos.
Tbh its still kinda unbelievable that MM1 is ending. I had so many fun times and so many laughing with Carl and his MM1 levels. I know there is much incredible troll opportunities in MM2 too but some things like overlaying Pipes will never be the same like it was in MM1. Thank you for your wonderful videos Carl and have a great one ^^
Such a great and nostalgic compilation!! Not to mention the hairy story we just went through. Amazing journey! Glade to have experienced all the years of laughter!
This compilation brought up so many memories. First watched you during your 'One More' levels, and have been watching since. People forget that you actually can play this game a little, I nickname you ThaCarl721 for those levels. Gonna miss all the overlaid pipes, Seanhip puzzles, flying cannons, moving thwomps, and just overall genius that this community displayed. MM2 may be a better, more polished game, but there's just something about MM1 that 2 will never have. Through Carl I discovered Barb, Beast, Poo, Panga, and so many other streamers. RIP MM1 you legend
I remember being in high school and randomly coming across your channel.
I still remember the first SMM1 video. One of the Most memorable moments was Carl's speghetti sauce ad😂
This video gives me so much nostalgia. I can't believe it's been so long since I was in high school, watching your SMM1 videos. This era of CarlSagan42 will always hold a special place in my heart ❤
Carl playing Super Mario Maker and making Fly Me To The Stars made me connect with the core of my childhood. It also made me remember why Nintendo is the best videogame company.
Super Mario Maker is a piece of art. It brought to life the dreams of many people, me included, who always wanted to make their own Mario levels. And man, most of us really suck at it.
But the flowing content of the multiple streamers of this AWESOME community keeps the spark of creativity alive, to this day and beyond.
Thank you so much, dude.
Mm1 was what originally got me watching your videos, I can't believe how nostalgic some of those clips were
Your troll series vs. Grandpoo bear getting revenge on each other will always be my favorite memory of this game, mole-ing each other back and forth. So amazing
After all these years i still remember all these things, carls videos has had a massive impact on my childhood, i am so thankful for such a loving and kind community with so many talented people. A purely sacred corner of the internet, thank you all for everything and thank you carl❤
Thanks for the memories ! Never had the chance to play a minute of SMM but I remember all of these over the years ! Funny to look at SMM again and notice all the changes in the physics of the game compared with SMM2. Also, lainky mario
Seeing all those old levels takes me back. So long MM1 and thanks for the memories.
My brother and I have been watching you since when I was in Middle School (I'm a Junior in College now, funny how time flies). Thank you for all the memories and laughs during these past years! RIP MM1, you will always have a special place in our hearts
thank you carl for all the awesome memories and for getting me into the game, along with the talented creators of all the amazing levels
Wow this was a trip down memory lane. Been loving your content for years now, specifically got me through some tough times during COVID-19 lockdowns.
The fact that he can even do Kaizo levels with his Aphantasia is extremely impressive.
I have to carefully look at the screen and memorize which buttons to press when I see certain things happen on the screen. I notice people like Thabeast will often close their eyes (or not and just kinda stare into the distance) solving a kaizo section in their head and I'm like dang
I remember coming across your original One More videos of a reposter and I pulled an all-nighter watching them. I was hooked since then.
The legendary tea spill will live on in our hearts forever
It’s so sad looking back on SMM1 and seeing all the cute fun stuff they took out in the sequel :/
We’ll never have it back again