Konstantin Kisin vs. Entire Audience at Doha Debates

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 10 тис.

  • @triggerpod
    @triggerpod  5 місяців тому +370

    Thank you to Doha Debates for hosting - UA-cam: www.youtube.com/@DohaDebates

    • @koopon3900
      @koopon3900 5 місяців тому +5

      Qatar is the largest funder and exporter of terrorism and violent political Islamism in the world today.

    • @NewHerseyAccent
      @NewHerseyAccent 5 місяців тому +87

      Cheers for your adamantine resolve Konstantin! Especially in such a clearly hostile environment.

    • @delta-gg
      @delta-gg 5 місяців тому +54

      glad you're still alive. may as well be 'Doha Dictates'

    • @THE_Quiz_Channel2412
      @THE_Quiz_Channel2412 5 місяців тому +13

      @@triggerpod why is gru hosting the debate

    • @meggysaurusrex
      @meggysaurusrex 5 місяців тому +28

      Goddamn you really dived into the deepest, darkest hole of the beast with this one!
      Holyshht, she actually uncritically quoted Gnome Chumpski 😂.

  • @MrS-pe6sd
    @MrS-pe6sd 5 місяців тому +4119

    Arabs that have adopted western culture living in the west so they can critique western culture is the height of irony

    • @Ontheroadagain15
      @Ontheroadagain15 5 місяців тому +84

      Exactly

    • @michaelweber5702
      @michaelweber5702 5 місяців тому +160

      Unfortunately too many Muslims come to Europe and the U.S. , Canada , Australia , and New Zealand and have no desire to assimilate and they push for western people to adopt Muslim culture , with sharia law and of course censorship . We can not let that defeat our culture ! ( Absurdly , we in the west are responsible for being so weak in that WE allowed this obvious danger to happen to us . ) I pray that both western folks and Muslim folks learn to guide and teach each other the benefits of western society and the freedoms it brings ... May God bless all humans on planet earth (everyone)

    • @mikestrom6178
      @mikestrom6178 5 місяців тому

      @@michaelweber5702 the cult must be banned from the west. There is no peace living with them, they have no care for us or our societies.

    • @edwardd652
      @edwardd652 5 місяців тому +32

      Is not that what makes Western culture so great? being receptive to criticism, even from foreigners.

    • @HelloJamesBond
      @HelloJamesBond 5 місяців тому +15

      Hahaha my friend, you’ve absolutely hit the nail on the head 😂😂

  • @stud6414
    @stud6414 5 місяців тому +7319

    Arabs calling people colonialists is rich.

    • @UpriseMusic
      @UpriseMusic 5 місяців тому +333

      Yep. Muhammad spent the last years of his life organizing battles and the eventual siege of Israel.

    • @minizimi3790
      @minizimi3790 5 місяців тому +38

      . . . hmmm, got to remember that one.

    • @gwyn111
      @gwyn111 5 місяців тому +284

      And Slavers too. The Taquiyya is strong!

    • @blowfish1702
      @blowfish1702 5 місяців тому +95

      Yeah, I wonder what part of the world they get their name from and why they are now so far from it...

    • @aliyum8455
      @aliyum8455 5 місяців тому +6

      They arent perfect. How are they colonialists tho?

  • @davidhenry3553
    @davidhenry3553 5 місяців тому +4304

    I am from Pakistan, Fatima Bhutto comes from a wealthy feudal family in Pakistan, her grandfather made an alliance with the army and came into power, her dad was labeled a terrorist and shot dead in front of his own house, while her aunt was prime minister of Pakistan, her family is in power since last several decades in the province of Sindh, in Pakistan still that Province is crap, her grandfather party is corrupt from top to button, all the people her family is surrounded with are feudal lords and still practice slavery, The only reason she is not in Pakistani politics is that her aunt 'Benazir Bhutto' and uncle "Asif Ali Zardari" took away everything and throw them in oblivion, but she only sees in justice in the west. she can't even step foot in Pakistan and criticize anything. Yet she is sitting here and talking about justice around the world, without uttering a word about the society she came from, Hypocrisy is Amazing the West empowers her, which she hates most. The West has huge problems but it is far better than the alternatives we have.

    • @origanev1986
      @origanev1986 5 місяців тому +289

      amazing, thanks for sharing

    • @JillaneJones
      @JillaneJones 5 місяців тому +159

      Thanks for sharing.

    • @kyrusinek
      @kyrusinek 5 місяців тому

      From her point of view "her family" was maintiang law and order and anything bad that happend......well that was because of the west!
      Thanks for sharing btw I wouldn't of know.

    • @davidsingh6944
      @davidsingh6944 5 місяців тому

      I have Christian and Islamic cousins. I love my Islamic cousins dearly but their faith originated in heresy and keeps their societies in oppression.

    • @elizabethjones5041
      @elizabethjones5041 5 місяців тому +91

      Thank you x

  • @ya15555
    @ya15555 2 місяці тому +140

    "The nine months in which Israel has been committing genocide"??? Clearly she is unbiased 🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @commenceun
      @commenceun Місяць тому +13

      You can't commit genocide for 9 months. You either do it all at once, and do nothing. Very biased audience

    • @evawilhelm5113
      @evawilhelm5113 Місяць тому

      Well. She’s no more subjective than any other person in the west.

    • @Inventor1488
      @Inventor1488 22 дні тому

      ​@@commenceunmost of them are literall students from Qatar brainwashing universities

    • @Inventor1488
      @Inventor1488 22 дні тому

      ​@@evawilhelm5113you sound like an islamist

    • @terrypussypower
      @terrypussypower 7 днів тому

      They clearly have no idea what the word “genocide” actually means. Or why saying Israel is “committing genocide” is one of the worst antisemitic slurs imaginable.

  • @gingerbill128
    @gingerbill128 5 місяців тому +5456

    Arabs lecturing about slavery is ludicrous

    • @letmelie4757
      @letmelie4757 5 місяців тому +269

      Lecturing about anything honestly, I can't think of anything their culture could teach ours that has any actual value🤣 There's a reason Saudi Arabia is changing to be like the west and not the other way around

    • @TJ-kk5zf
      @TJ-kk5zf 5 місяців тому +116

      and you missed their series on women's rights?😂

    • @HannarrMontannarr
      @HannarrMontannarr 5 місяців тому

      @@letmelie4757 Also the only reason they have money or any political clout is because westerners gave value to the oil under their deserts and ways to extract it. islam is in comparison to the west as a culture, entirely morally and ethically bankrupt.

    • @letmelie4757
      @letmelie4757 5 місяців тому +81

      @@TJ-kk5zf I can't believe that's real😂 Dude that's like an Ant lecturing you on individualism

    • @TJ-kk5zf
      @TJ-kk5zf 5 місяців тому +21

      @@letmelie4757 great analogy

  • @Girtharmstrong69
    @Girtharmstrong69 5 місяців тому +1061

    Arabs lecturing anyone on colonialism is pretty cringe

    • @cliomaniac
      @cliomaniac 4 місяці тому

      ua-cam.com/users/shorts_mRcaKGCVP0 agree

    • @supersosiska
      @supersosiska 4 місяці тому

      And yet we have to take them seriously, since they're colonizing the west with their method!

    • @TheFirstCause
      @TheFirstCause 4 місяці тому +1

      They are taking advantage of the white Woke suicidal empathy problem. It is pathetic. Their people are STILL actively enslaving around the world.

    • @adampark4238
      @adampark4238 4 місяці тому +8

      This video certainly backfired in the ladt week

    • @charleshill2121
      @charleshill2121 4 місяці тому

      Also at one point we got a critique of the western contribution to climate change....😂😂😂Brought to you by doha....😂😂😂 and slavery of black Africans in the west...form Qutari who had chatle slavery till the 50s. Whose city was built and homes were cleaned by kafala system effective slaves. Legal until like yesterday. They built the world cup stadium using modern slavery 2 years ago Lol😂😂😂😂😂 The bare faced cheek of it.

  • @09bamasky
    @09bamasky 5 місяців тому +2091

    As soon as Konstantin made the FACTUAL STATEMENT that slavery was the NORM prior to Western/Christian culture, everyone got extremely uncomfortable and tried to shut him up.

    • @TheAcad3mic
      @TheAcad3mic 5 місяців тому +79

      Not western, British. That particular element was British, brought about as a direct result of Britain being one of the worst affected places by the barbery corsairs for the best past of 200 years.

    • @pankowalski-m6l
      @pankowalski-m6l 5 місяців тому +18

      No one got uncomfortable, their just laughed at his framing. They laughed because he said Britain ended it. The key point here was who ended it.

    • @Kyushu314
      @Kyushu314 5 місяців тому +127

      Laughter is often a mask for discomfort.

    • @09bamasky
      @09bamasky 5 місяців тому +39

      The philosophy undergirding British society was Christian. The same is true for American society. The Founders planted the seeds of emancipation in the founding documents. In the same way, it wasn’t the Civil War that ended slavery in the U.S. That happened to be the culminating event - like the Barbary pirates in Britain.

    • @09bamasky
      @09bamasky 5 місяців тому +120

      @@pankowalski-m6l They were the first country to formally make slavery illegal.

  • @SirPablo2Pablo
    @SirPablo2Pablo 2 місяці тому +74

    Konstantin speaks
    12:00
    20:15
    24:34
    33:20
    36:00
    41:26
    47:00
    51:30
    1:05:00
    1:10:00
    1:23:19

    • @Inventor1488
      @Inventor1488 22 дні тому +6

      Thank you

    • @hamburglar83
      @hamburglar83 16 днів тому +10

      Thanks….wanted to skip the hypocrites

    • @vrclckd-zz3pv
      @vrclckd-zz3pv 8 днів тому

      ​@@hamburglar83 that's the dumbest thing I've read today. If you don't listen to the hypocrites you aren't going to have the context to understand what it is that he's talking about.

    • @vikim1135
      @vikim1135 7 днів тому

      ​@@hamburglar83great point. I keep listening and where is the right of minorities in the middle east

    • @HelloBello-j8o
      @HelloBello-j8o 2 дні тому +2

      Thank you so much 🙏

  • @randomusername0121
    @randomusername0121 5 місяців тому +1073

    The irony of Doha debates having to be held in the "wicked west" to ensure people aren't locked up for saying something spicy 😂

  • @Todars
    @Todars 5 місяців тому +697

    You know what this debate reminded me of? An old soviet anecdote:
    An American and a Soviet meet.
    They start arguing about which country is the most free.
    The American says:
    “America is the freest country. I can go to the White House and say that Reagan is a fool.
    Nothing will happen to me for that!”
    The Soviet replies:
    “So what? I can also go to the Red Square and say that Reagan is a fool. And nothing will happen to me either!”
    This is what they are arguing about being schooled in Qatar, and completely ignoring Konsts points. That’s the beauty of their “freedom of speech”

    • @iralubarsky1726
      @iralubarsky1726 5 місяців тому +71

      The saddest part is that this panel’s happening in Bradford, UK. I’m not sure such discussion with KK would be possible in Qatar.

    • @larryl164
      @larryl164 5 місяців тому +27

      The same annecdode came to my mind. What a bunch of hyprocats that calls other hypocrites, except Konstantin.

    • @Todars
      @Todars 5 місяців тому +5

      @@iralubarsky1726 indeed, meant to refer to the students who study there. Thanks for pointing it out

    • @saxav88
      @saxav88 5 місяців тому +28

      Another old Soviet joke is : How many TV channels does the USSR have ? Answer = Two. Channel one is 24 hour Soviet propaganda. Channel two is a KGB officer ordering you to turn over !

    • @larryl164
      @larryl164 5 місяців тому +20

      @@saxav88 exactly, and those clowns from aljazira came to Britain, teach us democracy.

  • @daxrico266
    @daxrico266 5 місяців тому +813

    I'm so glad there's people like Konstantin out there unapologetically defending Western values

    • @jonbaxter2254
      @jonbaxter2254 5 місяців тому +30

      It's sad he only is allowed to because he is an immigrant.
      We all should be bold enough to speak like he does.

    • @josephjohnston7499
      @josephjohnston7499 5 місяців тому +19

      He is unafraid to go into the lion’s den.

    • @rosemaryalles6043
      @rosemaryalles6043 5 місяців тому +13

      Me too. He's one of the best. 💜

    • @Woodsaras
      @Woodsaras 5 місяців тому

      Theres no such things as "western values". Nothing unique about it. So why the fk make the distinction.

    • @veganandlovingit
      @veganandlovingit 3 місяці тому +4

      if all the immigrants to the west were like Konstantin wow the West which is already the best would be one hundred times better

  • @jacobcohen9205
    @jacobcohen9205 4 місяці тому +69

    Ms Bhutto is the latest grifter from that famous Pakistani political dynasty and
    crime family. Any Pakistani politician criticising any country on its records involving justice, free speech, torture, corruption and religious intolerance is beyond absurd.

  • @gustavocambeiro5545
    @gustavocambeiro5545 5 місяців тому +834

    Non-westerns complaining about the west is hysterical. Ironically, they live in the west and won't ever dare leave.

    • @gustavocambeiro5545
      @gustavocambeiro5545 5 місяців тому +45

      @@RojaJaneman No they don't...lol

    • @SuperGamli
      @SuperGamli 5 місяців тому +31

      Wait, I just heard that free speech and liberty in Qatar is doing great.

    • @Tiadeal
      @Tiadeal 5 місяців тому

      No one wants to live in the west anymore. Not even westerners lol

    • @ms8742
      @ms8742 5 місяців тому +3

      Exactly!

    • @gustavocambeiro5545
      @gustavocambeiro5545 5 місяців тому +8

      @@SuperGamli careful, people might think this comment is sincere.

  • @lordhawkeye
    @lordhawkeye 5 місяців тому +1019

    "The west need to do better!!"
    "Can you name a place that does it better?"
    "Do not distract from my point!!"

    • @rath6375
      @rath6375 5 місяців тому +61

      It's not necessarily wrong to say that the best can be improved, but it's the height of arrogance to assume you can improve on the current gold standard without _at least_ the careful study of what's been tried and failed elsewhere and in the past.

    • @Robisquick
      @Robisquick 5 місяців тому +15

      What’s more important is to complain but with the disposition of gratitude or respect that there is this solid society.

    • @baruchhashem49
      @baruchhashem49 5 місяців тому +11

      Why Qatar of course 😂😂😂

    • @frankxu4795
      @frankxu4795 5 місяців тому +3

      Maybe take a moment to look at Asia? South Korea, Japan, and China accomplished in a couple of generations what took Europe centuries. They’ve surpassed most European countries without sharing the same values. Maybe they did it better?

    • @schroecat1
      @schroecat1 5 місяців тому +38

      @@frankxu4795 If you truly believe that then I encourage you to visit these countries and live in them for a time. There are a lot of things to admire in Japan and Korea, but they aren't models to be copied. They've been successful because they were willing and able to integrate certain elements of western civilisation and fuse them with their own endemic cultures more successfully than most other cultures have. And because the west gave them an enormous amount of support in achieving this goal. To suggest, however, that they have "surpassed" Europe is... shall we say ignorant?

  • @m2chan
    @m2chan 5 місяців тому +1592

    if there no Konstantin ,I won't give a minute to watch this rubbish program .

    • @subchan6595
      @subchan6595 5 місяців тому +66

      cant belive host intros "experts" as writers from the guardian. They constantly think we dont have eyes ears and a brain.

    • @goldeneagle256
      @goldeneagle256 5 місяців тому +39

      those viewpoints people show here are really scary, especially the points on the so-called genocide on gaza thats not being protested at all. i was also rather shocked by the anti jewish and anti israeli introduction to this sham of a debate

    • @sbaumgartner9848
      @sbaumgartner9848 5 місяців тому +22

      British journalist Tim Sebastian was the original moderator. After that there have been too many Middle Easterners moderating. The 'debate' is fluff and people like Konstantin are wasted being a speaker. However I give him credit for at least getting through to a few people. I haven't made an opinion yet on Steve C, but unless I missed something he didn't offend me and had credible comments. Fatima was useless and the female moderator was terrified when the topic of the Slave Trade was brought up.

    • @aiyubpatel9165
      @aiyubpatel9165 5 місяців тому +5

      If there's no Konstantin. You would actually learn something. Konstantin talks BS

    • @tlilmiztli
      @tlilmiztli 5 місяців тому +17

      @@aiyubpatel9165 And some argument?

  • @redhat4363
    @redhat4363 2 місяці тому +41

    Palestine Palestine.. what about all the atrocities committed by your own people in other Arab countries? the fuck is the obsession over Palestine? what a boring meeting.

    • @Inventor1488
      @Inventor1488 22 дні тому +11

      Never ask Arabs how did they arrive to dominate the entire North Africa

    • @michaellamont2605
      @michaellamont2605 5 днів тому

      It's the Jews ✡️
      Afghanistan 🇦🇫 no more Buddhists
      Iran 🇮🇷 no Zoastrians
      Jordan 🇯🇴 no Druze
      Come to think of it
      ALL other cultures are being ethnically cleansed

  • @themindakviking
    @themindakviking 5 місяців тому +596

    Hearing Al Jazeera referred to as truthful or unbiased is absolutely incredible. What a time to be alive.

    • @SunilFrancisGeorge
      @SunilFrancisGeorge 5 місяців тому +42

      It’s almost as if we’ve been transported to a world where black is white, left is right, and Al Jazeera is the gold standard for unbiased journalism.

    • @superablemind-s.a.m6937
      @superablemind-s.a.m6937 5 місяців тому

      bloody more truthful that the BBC or CNN or Fox.. RUFKM.... have you even watched Al Jazeera at all... I have been for six months now and feel relieved to have the facts rather than having my head in the dirty sand..

    • @0000vicky0000
      @0000vicky0000 5 місяців тому

      It’s wild how they yap on about how western media is biased… when they have literally no diversity in thought or freedom of opinion in their media 😂

    • @nope-ot9pg
      @nope-ot9pg 5 місяців тому +11

      ​@@SunilFrancisGeorgetwilight zone

    • @MickaelLewis
      @MickaelLewis 5 місяців тому

      keep in mind this whole event is sponsored by the Qatar foundation. Qatar state sponsored & financed media conglomerate is..... Al -Jazeera. this is quite literally a therapy session for Qatar...or to be a bit more sinister: Qatar explaining & demonstating publicly how investing massively into western universities is allowing them to *slowly change the western narratives for new eastern [Qatari] perspective* . Qatar is also the 2nd largest funder of Hamas so the audience bitching about western narrative is the heaviest of irony: why don't they ask the qatari leadership about the billions transferred to Hamas why it didn't moderate the Hamas leadership to avoid october 7th?! either they taken for fools or they're complicit.

  • @dylanshearsbyart
    @dylanshearsbyart 5 місяців тому +627

    Konstantin "Where is better than the west?" Everyone there: "uhhh, lets keep this to bashing the west please"

    • @joenweazu
      @joenweazu 5 місяців тому

      Exactly 💯. Nitwits!!!

    • @Jenny-nz8fb
      @Jenny-nz8fb 5 місяців тому

      Exactly, total joke however I would say that freedom of speech is being violated in the west by for example not being allowed to call men who think they are women « men ».

    • @dpmjole
      @dpmjole 4 місяці тому

      He's just a clown, admits he's pro-Ukranian and keeps bringing up how Russia lacks freedom of speech and to critique the govt.
      in Ukraine, family members critiquing the govt among themselves get locked up, you don't even need to protest or publish anything, SBU simply joins your family chat and next morning you're on your way to a multi-year sentence as a "traitor"
      hypocrite much??

    • @nassim0775
      @nassim0775 4 місяці тому

      Yeah cuz that country that dropped 2 nukes and killed millions of lives is definitely not western

    • @brotherben4357
      @brotherben4357 2 місяці тому +6

      “Let’s side-step, dodge, duck, weave, skip, hop and jump our way out of this question …”

  • @Hmmmmmm674
    @Hmmmmmm674 5 місяців тому +677

    If there was no Konstantin Kisin, this would've been an hour of people agreeing with each other and no real debate

    • @Theonlycontractor
      @Theonlycontractor 5 місяців тому +41

      And filled with lies

    • @MichaelWilson-nr1tz
      @MichaelWilson-nr1tz 5 місяців тому +3

      Like this comment thread! 😂

    • @racheljavellana2111
      @racheljavellana2111 5 місяців тому +3

      good point

    • @Dazza0187
      @Dazza0187 4 місяці тому +13

      They did the same thing to Douglas Murray, only he was in Doha so a likely more hostile audience.

    • @johnperemy7700
      @johnperemy7700 2 місяці тому +4

      Agreeing with each other That under favorable circumstances spoken lies are the truth

  • @westernman3290
    @westernman3290 2 місяці тому +30

    What most Muslims mean when they are not being heard is that their views aren’t dominant in the space

  • @ShockedBones
    @ShockedBones 5 місяців тому +1546

    Muslims...in BRADFORD...accusing westerners of colonisation lmao

    • @TalkingDonkeyz
      @TalkingDonkeyz 5 місяців тому +10

      I hate this talking point all it would take is reading the definition of colonisation or colony to realise it’s fallacious. Why not address reality and talk about what has caused our country to rely so heavily on legal immigration?

    • @sultanskinny
      @sultanskinny 5 місяців тому

      @@TalkingDonkeyzdon’t bother. People like this are illiterate in the only language they speak. Don’t waste ur breath.

    • @nathang4570
      @nathang4570 5 місяців тому

      It doesn't rely on it, mass immigration has been a detriment to the UK.
      How ever, I will say it is not the only issue, the social welfare state has not just drawn in millions of migrants that become a burden on the tax payer but has also created several generations of lazy natives who rely on the state but should they be motivated to get a job, they are not competing for those jobs with their local peers anymore, but the entire world.
      Stop the immigration and get rid of the welfare state.

    • @jeffashley766
      @jeffashley766 5 місяців тому +16

      it's so sad that alot of these woke americans are going along with this narrative

    • @londonman8688
      @londonman8688 5 місяців тому

      then off to do some grooming

  • @andremiller1836
    @andremiller1836 5 місяців тому +284

    28:58 Non of the arab speakers are willing to name a place where it seems better to express freedom of speech than in the West. Interessting and thanks to Konstantin .

  • @bonniesumo1004
    @bonniesumo1004 5 місяців тому +1919

    The only thing this debate achieved was showing us all that Islam in the West is too dangerous.

    • @christopheresson3158
      @christopheresson3158 5 місяців тому

      I'm from Glasgow and happen to be down in London ATM and sweet fuck Islam has took over this. I don't like any religion but that by a mile the worst.

    • @jameslevitt7313
      @jameslevitt7313 5 місяців тому

      But Zionist that promote abortion , lgbt agenda , pornography , illegal wars , mass immigration and debt are A OK 👌

    • @jonbaxter2254
      @jonbaxter2254 5 місяців тому +155

      We've known that for decades, but governments are terrified of them for some reason...

    • @oioisweetheart3500
      @oioisweetheart3500 5 місяців тому

      All this Muslim people in Christian countries and hating our values.
      Wouldn’t they be more comfortable and happy if they move to an Islam country.
      Hypocrites and ungrateful.

    • @UnknownUnknown-xf6lo
      @UnknownUnknown-xf6lo 5 місяців тому +41

      Oil reason.

  • @vandyke2025
    @vandyke2025 3 місяці тому +40

    This is ironic. People oppressed by religion are criticising other people for censuring free speech 😂

    • @Cara.s_Life_Is_Pink
      @Cara.s_Life_Is_Pink 2 місяці тому +4

      When most of the women in that room proudly wear their oppression on their heads, I can't understand how they act and speak as if it is 'the west' oppressing them.

  • @FoxyMuz
    @FoxyMuz 5 місяців тому +548

    What even is this 'debate'? Konstantin is literally the only dissenting voice in the room

    • @nataliamundell6266
      @nataliamundell6266 5 місяців тому +58

      And they struggled as opposition to just one guy

    • @terrracottta
      @terrracottta 5 місяців тому +40

      My thought exactly! What kind of debate is that if all these free speech lovers couldn't care less about free speech as long as they are allowed to spew their antisemitic propaganda and not even being challenged by anyone.

    • @divinvarghese3501
      @divinvarghese3501 5 місяців тому +44

      Konstatin is surrounded by Islamist who is shouting victim cards 😂

    • @bzeldin82
      @bzeldin82 5 місяців тому +20

      Not once did anyone answer him directly or disprove him factually.
      Also, he made a greag point over and over. That we don't live in a vacuum, but rather a real world. Reality trumps feelings.

    • @doughayden
      @doughayden 5 місяців тому +4

      110 percent ... of course what they don't understand is it looks so one sided.

  • @MD-vt9iw
    @MD-vt9iw 5 місяців тому +3649

    Good luck convincing people to give up their illegitimate yet profitable claims of victimhood.

    • @Itsstuff7328
      @Itsstuff7328 5 місяців тому +32

      I can't believe how much money they are CURRENTLY collecting.

    • @Three_Lions-1986
      @Three_Lions-1986 5 місяців тому +64

      ​@user-wj6dt5bq3w who is playing victim in this video? Europeans don't play victim. All the others do.

    • @shabbaranks7968
      @shabbaranks7968 5 місяців тому +3

      You haven't even watched it it was posted 40 min ago you complete ideologue

    • @johnsmithers8913
      @johnsmithers8913 5 місяців тому +104

      ​@user-wj6dt5bq3w Don't see too many Europeans or Christians in the Middle East today, especially in government positions.....where are these colonizers?

    • @bubberbucky7
      @bubberbucky7 5 місяців тому

      ​@@shabbaranks7968shut up coomer

  • @cubanheelsbeerbelly
    @cubanheelsbeerbelly 5 місяців тому +612

    This wasn't a debate this was an Islamic grievance meeting with Konstantin as the sole token defender of the west.

    • @therealpollyanna5846
      @therealpollyanna5846 5 місяців тому +1

      ...and of course Gaza and genocide had to be mentioned in the same sentence. The green clothed, kafir wearing, Hamas supporters on the stage, never miss an opportunity.

    • @FC-PeakVersatility
      @FC-PeakVersatility 5 місяців тому +28

      Our token defender and he's actually not a westener

    • @barshorun1485
      @barshorun1485 5 місяців тому +4

      Crazy

    • @Anamouad2125
      @Anamouad2125 5 місяців тому +4

      bro do you even know what a westener means 🤦‍♂️@cuban....

    • @cubanheelsbeerbelly
      @cubanheelsbeerbelly 5 місяців тому

      @Anamouad2125 no dude I have no idea what the west is or what it stands for. I'm just saying a bunch of bullshit. Why don't you enlighten me 🤯🤓🤡🤣🤣

  • @elibazri5294
    @elibazri5294 2 місяці тому +15

    Couldn’t get into one subject without talking about the poor people of Gaza, same people who celebrated October 7, and now crying to the world.

  • @soctejedor-qh3kd
    @soctejedor-qh3kd 5 місяців тому +526

    When Fatima is speaking, no rushing from host. When Konstantin is speaking, suddenly 'we have to bring in other voices'. 🤪

    • @Sandra-de3tz
      @Sandra-de3tz 5 місяців тому +35

      Exactly

    • @brachakishinevsky5896
      @brachakishinevsky5896 5 місяців тому +23

      I noticed it too!!!

    • @dcarts5616
      @dcarts5616 5 місяців тому +14

      I thought I was only one who noticed.

    • @snoopy104
      @snoopy104 5 місяців тому +6

      To be fair, Konstantin spoke far more than Fatima did. (Which I didn't mind at all.)

    • @Man_fay_the_Bru
      @Man_fay_the_Bru 5 місяців тому +28

      Without lies, Islam dies

  • @XDontConformX
    @XDontConformX 5 місяців тому +388

    Everyone criticizes the west, yet everyone wants to live here.. weird. We have to be careful what we wish for

    • @theinngu5560
      @theinngu5560 5 місяців тому

      The people who do that ..the ones filled with so much hate are brainwashed and mentally ill…I feel sorry for them as mindsets like this, through ignorance, suffer a lot. Somehow, not sure how, I hope they change.

    • @jakosalem
      @jakosalem 5 місяців тому +25

      Yes, and they don't want to criticize the country they came from which far more worst.

    • @SuchaDoofus
      @SuchaDoofus 5 місяців тому

      They want to take over. Islam is a cancer

    • @DaneXbsinthe
      @DaneXbsinthe 5 місяців тому +3

      Can’t change it to suit your beliefs from the outside. For example, you can’t normalize wearing the headscarf if you don’t get everyone in the west to wear one.

    • @johnnyjones5385
      @johnnyjones5385 4 місяці тому

      To be fair the west was great. Unfortunetly it's been going backwards for the last couple of decades.
      Since when saying Let's 'make america great again ' a rascist thing. Wasn't decades ago....
      Saying that I still would prefer the west than the alternatives.

  • @Abdul_Rahman86
    @Abdul_Rahman86 5 місяців тому +658

    I’m Arab Christian. If pakistanis, Indians, Bangladeshis, Sri lannkans knew what Arabs think of them, they’ll know who’s racist.

    • @JasonTaylor-po5xc
      @JasonTaylor-po5xc 5 місяців тому

      What's the common Arab phrase to describe black Africans? It's not pretty. The term "Slav" to refer the people of Eastern Europe is because these people were commonly the slaves of Arabs.

    • @sbaumgartner9848
      @sbaumgartner9848 5 місяців тому +39

      I've lived and married in Egypt. I found Egyptians no longer even like other Egyptians. Their tolerance for different religions and social levels has seriously declined. I also can't believe how low salaries still are for most Egyptians, even with those with university degrees.

    • @phoenix51472
      @phoenix51472 5 місяців тому

      The funniest are the South Asian muslims. Hate the Hindus who were the original civilization of their land, suck up to "fellow" muslims who despise and look down upon those third rate converts.

    • @mw7675
      @mw7675 5 місяців тому +8

      we know

    • @aphaseelec
      @aphaseelec 5 місяців тому +28

      Same with Chinese. Ive never seen racism on a high level until i went to Singapore.

  • @mariamichael1669
    @mariamichael1669 4 місяці тому +7

    Fatima Bhutto living in the West enjoying the fruits of the West whilst loathing and criticising the West, yet no word of her country Pakistan’s failings, and it has many. She is the epitome of hypocrisy.

  • @ervdre
    @ervdre 5 місяців тому +527

    The only reason to watch is Konstantin.

    • @bn_mediorcty
      @bn_mediorcty 5 місяців тому +8

      💯 agree!!

    • @zetristan4525
      @zetristan4525 5 місяців тому +2

      You missed out on Steve Clemons' and various others contributions and additions to what Konstantin said.

    • @chefskengko184
      @chefskengko184 5 місяців тому +2

      ​@@zetristan4525came for KK stayed for SC!

    • @zetristan4525
      @zetristan4525 5 місяців тому +4

      ​@@chefskengko184 SC did distract the conversation away from KK's well-known well-articulated commentary on slavery, after a very vague question, but clearly both KK and SC are wonderfully-intentioned thoughtful guys.

    • @mr_ryan_tee
      @mr_ryan_tee 5 місяців тому +3

      He is a IDF shill

  • @MrPmcMcMental
    @MrPmcMcMental 5 місяців тому +456

    What other countries outside the West invites people to their nation and then lets them sit on a panel and do nothing but criticise their country, culture and entire history?.

    • @Michelle-vv9lk
      @Michelle-vv9lk 5 місяців тому +25

      🎯

    • @malsietah9403
      @malsietah9403 5 місяців тому +9

      @@MrPmcMcMental
      North Korea, I guess?

    • @elkpaz560
      @elkpaz560 5 місяців тому +6

      Other countries have some self respect.

    • @moonants
      @moonants 5 місяців тому +5

      @@Michelle-vv9lk Careful with the 'target' rhetoric, you could be blamed for encouraging assassination.

    • @Shestrongconcept
      @Shestrongconcept 5 місяців тому +1

      exactly 👍🏻

  • @kenricnarbrough8191
    @kenricnarbrough8191 5 місяців тому +2562

    Not a single person of Arab origin has the tiniest right to speak about slavery with that particular history. This Kisin actually has done some reading.

    • @mehmeteminkadiroglu1994
      @mehmeteminkadiroglu1994 5 місяців тому

      I think half of the audience are arabs. Other are muslims from africa, albania, france.

    • @shabbaranks7968
      @shabbaranks7968 5 місяців тому +15

      You haven't even watched it it was posted 40 min ago you complete ideologue

    • @hadror13
      @hadror13 5 місяців тому

      Slavery is still thriving in Arab lands

    • @zorrodm
      @zorrodm 5 місяців тому

      ​@@shabbaranks7968 can easily watch on 1.25x speed

    • @rossmcdonald5600
      @rossmcdonald5600 5 місяців тому +56

      ​@@shabbaranks7968I finished watching it 30 seconds after it was posted.

  • @gelindark
    @gelindark 3 місяці тому +1

    That was a great and precious conversation, thanks for posting it KK. Thanks for hosting @DohaDebates

  • @fribersson
    @fribersson 5 місяців тому +2165

    Konstantin is a global treasure.

    • @mehmeteminkadiroglu1994
      @mehmeteminkadiroglu1994 5 місяців тому

      Is he jewish? 😢

    • @shabbaranks7968
      @shabbaranks7968 5 місяців тому +4

      You haven't even watched it it was posted 40 min ago you complete ideologue

    • @JWWEntertainment
      @JWWEntertainment 5 місяців тому +49

      @@shabbaranks7968
      @fribersson might be familiar with Konstantin's work.

    • @bubberbucky7
      @bubberbucky7 5 місяців тому

      ​@@shabbaranks7968shut up coomer

    • @shabbaranks7968
      @shabbaranks7968 5 місяців тому +1

      @@JWWEntertainment he could of dropped the ball on this debate and made a fool of himself 🤷🏼‍♂️

  • @DrCraigR.Walton
    @DrCraigR.Walton 5 місяців тому +783

    "there is no free speech in the west" *using free speech in the west*

    • @JAYfromTHEworld
      @JAYfromTHEworld 5 місяців тому +42

      …and NOT in Doha😂

    • @SaintKimbo
      @SaintKimbo 5 місяців тому

      Yes, but even their take on it is total nonsense, the 'Free Palestine' narrative, is EVERYWHERE on social media, which is far more popular these days than Mainstream Media, to say that this line of thinking is censored in any way is just bonkers.

    • @TheGologozo
      @TheGologozo 5 місяців тому +13

      the irony!! 🥰

    • @daza3620
      @daza3620 5 місяців тому +1

      You either have free speach or you do not. I do not know about the whole of the west but in the UK we do no have free speach.

    • @jammydodger2111
      @jammydodger2111 5 місяців тому +6

      ​@@daza3620 No, it's not binary as that. This issue is a spectrum and a patchwork. On some issues you can say what you want, on others you cannot, in all nations. In the UK you can criticise the government, in many others you cannot - especially many non-western nations. We have more free speech here than in most places. There is no nation in the world that permits literally anything to be said at all times. Explicit threats of violence for example are usually criminal. UK is getting less in favour of free speech but it's still fundamentally better than most other places.

  • @g3523jaen
    @g3523jaen 5 місяців тому +1668

    The guy really said there is more free speech in Qatar.... Fuck me... 😂😂😂

    • @thecamil10
      @thecamil10 5 місяців тому +224

      Because he is criticising every other country but Qatar.

    • @PWMoze
      @PWMoze 5 місяців тому +151

      Exactly! And no one laughed at him? No one wanted to point out how he is only be allowed to express his opinions there because they are state sanctioned. I'd like to see him ague for a pro-Isreal perspective and see how long he lasted then.

    • @lex_inker
      @lex_inker 5 місяців тому +67

      I almost fell out of my chair.

    • @rodrigoserafim8834
      @rodrigoserafim8834 5 місяців тому +51

      And said it in full conviction.
      Sometimes I have to try really hard to attribute ignorance to something that is so akin to malice.

    • @giliabramovici4117
      @giliabramovici4117 5 місяців тому +25

      It is a free speech society, no one challenges him on his biases…. 😂😂

  • @lwf3723
    @lwf3723 2 місяці тому +8

    The only reason I watched this debate is because Konstantin was inputting!
    KK in the lions den, and he really stood out from the rest!

  • @psmorgan2542
    @psmorgan2542 5 місяців тому +692

    So basically a bunch of hypocrites who don’t know history, shocking.

    • @cinesonicvibes
      @cinesonicvibes 5 місяців тому +37

      1 hour and 30 minutes and no one mentioned hamass......but sure lets trust the arab historian.

    • @psmorgan2542
      @psmorgan2542 5 місяців тому +6

      @@cinesonicvibes Scrutinising one's own history in a critical manner, for the sake of learning from your culture's own mistakes, in order to refine society, is a uniquely modern liberal western project. Often history has just been synonymous with myth and propaganda. Not all societies have equal history keeping methods.

    • @rayarubin6147
      @rayarubin6147 5 місяців тому +11

      Why is the "intelligent" crowd are always the same???
      Some of the limited variety of people invited to these conversations are a red flag to this whole debate.
      As soon as you hear someone pronounce the word Gaza with exaggeration you understand who you are dealing with....

    • @natalievu4399
      @natalievu4399 5 місяців тому

      Influenced by western leftist media

    • @NotoriusMaximus
      @NotoriusMaximus 5 місяців тому +11

      bunch of people having exactly the same opinion like a clones or NPCs

  • @rdf5356
    @rdf5356 5 місяців тому +425

    This debate shows that mass migration and multi-culturalism has been a massive mistake 😞

    • @jimmymags6516
      @jimmymags6516 4 місяці тому

      Diversity is our strength , what a joke ....

    • @freyagoldilocks
      @freyagoldilocks 4 місяці тому

      Imported people who hate the West and seek to destroy it! 👍🏻🤦🏼‍♀️

    • @teedeed5390
      @teedeed5390 4 місяці тому +4

      I bee up in 70/80s back then we were all getting along you did have your racists but most folk got on for years now government and media have been dividing us over everything it’s now controversial to say I am a woman those days we were against labels now everyone needs one. ❤

    • @mikolowiskamikolowiska4993
      @mikolowiskamikolowiska4993 4 місяці тому +1

      Now we know

    • @j.j.8159
      @j.j.8159 4 місяці тому

      True, or it shows that it was intentionally subversive from the start..

  • @catsandcrows8880
    @catsandcrows8880 5 місяців тому +631

    Kisin is the only one worth listening to. It was a huge mistake to bring these people to Europe.

    • @malsietah9403
      @malsietah9403 5 місяців тому +19

      @@catsandcrows8880 well said❤️

    • @malsietah9403
      @malsietah9403 5 місяців тому

      @@catsandcrows8880
      and yet they cannot understand why europeans welcomed ukranians with open arms and why we are sick and tired of these islamists wanting to dominate...

    • @ggx444
      @ggx444 5 місяців тому +7

      nah that old guy speaking facts tho

    • @xyzabc9213
      @xyzabc9213 5 місяців тому +9

      @@catsandcrows8880 it’s kinda too late to deport them

    • @jackiechilds8047
      @jackiechilds8047 5 місяців тому

      Stranger still is why they want to come to the West since they clearly believe their cultures are superior.

  • @jayzdanielz1577
    @jayzdanielz1577 2 місяці тому +1

    Doha, pls host these debates in the US. Best youtube content in a year.

  • @amirrezarezaie
    @amirrezarezaie 4 місяці тому +213

    1 man against an army of hypocrites

    • @sandwitht6264
      @sandwitht6264 2 місяці тому

      Beautifully said

    • @shlmzp6
      @shlmzp6 Місяць тому

      I love how they talk about TikTok videos they see as 'facts' LoL

  • @guzopere
    @guzopere 5 місяців тому +1328

    The irony of muslims flogging the west in Bradford

    • @theinngu5560
      @theinngu5560 5 місяців тому

      @palerider955 no they live in their heads in their deluded fantasy version of the West and surrounded by their own type/enclaves….very sad as it breeds and feeds on their negative mind set and is unpleasant for others that are the objects of their hate.

    • @lancebrelsford2568
      @lancebrelsford2568 5 місяців тому +39

      @palerider955 The guy that lives in Bradford and brought up slavery really hammered that home. He said something like, I don't understand what the western narrative is and what are western values?

    • @elkpaz560
      @elkpaz560 5 місяців тому +32

      @@lancebrelsford2568 He was just angry that his values aren't dominant in the UK.

    • @tobyway5093
      @tobyway5093 5 місяців тому

      We dont stand up or have the courage to explain our values, why?​@lancebrelsford2568

    • @nf6386
      @nf6386 5 місяців тому +13

      Oof, that hits hard. They don’t like non-muslims speaking up in Bradford, I’ve heard.

  • @tuber00009
    @tuber00009 5 місяців тому +943

    "Hello, we are here using Western-pioneered communications technologies to use Western logic and Western knowledge to debunk the West."

    • @richy69ify
      @richy69ify 5 місяців тому +123

      Dressed as westerners speaking good English.

    • @xenadonau8356
      @xenadonau8356 5 місяців тому +20

      Best 😂

    • @crissantos44
      @crissantos44 5 місяців тому +23

      ok you win 🤣 Can´t argue with logic

    • @mr.nobody2244
      @mr.nobody2244 5 місяців тому +53

      The amount of hypocrisy and lack of self-awareness is astounding.

    • @n4049
      @n4049 5 місяців тому +1

      And that host. Oddly, she has a perfect British accent... they infiltrate the west, get to know it well from within, and abuse the West's weakness

  • @thomasphilip2892
    @thomasphilip2892 2 місяці тому +8

    Dude at 26:14 : "I recognize the privilege I have of saying whatever I want in Qatar."
    If the Dude says even a single word when in Qatar against the royal House of the Thanis (that rule Qatar) or how they essentialy run the Islamist theocracy on imported slave labour from South Asia and Africa, he wouldn't see the light of the day from that moment on. 😅

  • @tdevry
    @tdevry 5 місяців тому +726

    Asking an islamist to admit to a wrongdoings......is not possible.

    • @aiyubpatel9165
      @aiyubpatel9165 5 місяців тому

      What's an Islamist? Another Muslims focused term made up by the Islam hating/ Muslim hating West.
      We don't need moral lessons from people who wouldn't know what the truth is if it came and hit them in the face and literally said truth.
      Stay in your bigoted, hate filled, brainwashed and supremacist mind

    • @Negev-Israel
      @Negev-Israel 5 місяців тому +24

      Muslim*

    • @kh-fk3ko
      @kh-fk3ko 5 місяців тому

      @@Negev-Israel much like a jew.

    • @alihabibi5254
      @alihabibi5254 5 місяців тому +2

      Asking Muslims to be slaves and accept the status quo is also not possible. You don’t like people who can stand up for themselves

    • @JJandoONER
      @JJandoONER 5 місяців тому

      They rationalize anything and everything. It's called 'Taqiyya', google it

  • @RyanSmith-on1hq
    @RyanSmith-on1hq 5 місяців тому +386

    One guy who understands history in a room full of clowns. Respect for standing firm.

    • @obiwankenobi661
      @obiwankenobi661 5 місяців тому +7

      that white guy from al jazeera was so cringe.. you can just tell his wife walks in front of him and he follows her like a pet.

  • @tyrantsquirrel575
    @tyrantsquirrel575 5 місяців тому +1166

    Basically Konstantin ruining this little mualim struggle session with facts

    • @jimmccusker9148
      @jimmccusker9148 5 місяців тому

      Muslims....the perpetually offended.

    • @Zaphodox
      @Zaphodox 5 місяців тому +35

      Ballsy move to be fair

    • @SaintKimbo
      @SaintKimbo 5 місяців тому +72

      Well said, but Konstantin didn't go far enough, he should have said to the people there, "what sort of fantasy world are you living in?".
      The significance of him saying, "tell me where else is better", just went straight over their heads.

    • @its22dm1
      @its22dm1 5 місяців тому

      @@SaintKimbo And of course the bin bag wearing moderator jumped in to defend the little Jihadist ....
      Such a joke of a debate.
      "Moderator" on one side only...

    • @UpriseMusic
      @UpriseMusic 5 місяців тому +55

      Him and Douglas Murray would have shut this down in ten minutes.

  • @mauriceharting5877
    @mauriceharting5877 Місяць тому +6

    The problem with Palestinians, be they in Gaza, Jordan or Lebanon, have caused problems for the local populations. Palestinians do not understand the meaning of genuine peace. Peace is not just the absence of war, it goes much deeper than that, namely in the hearts and minds of humans. Israel not only has the right to exist as a nation they also have the right to flourish and defend itself from attacks. This is my free speech and I am sticking with it unless a better argument is made by others.

  • @dayamitrasaraswati6276
    @dayamitrasaraswati6276 5 місяців тому +761

    Freedom of speech here in Australia is when BLM can hold protests but anti-lockdown protesters could not speak.

    • @rynolascavio3381
      @rynolascavio3381 5 місяців тому

      AUSTRALIA IS A JOKE

    • @maurikid23
      @maurikid23 5 місяців тому +6

      u know it!

    • @samroscoe944
      @samroscoe944 5 місяців тому

      Yes, but that is because our government doesn't value freedom of speech... They are literally trying to put in place this "misinformation bill" which allows the government to decide on any online content, what is allowed to be said.
      So I totally agree that our country, as a fellow Aussie, is being attacked from within parliament. No country has done more to erode the values and rights of Australians than our Parliament. I wish you the best of luck mate in our coming future as we become one of those countries in the world without the freedoms we once had.

    • @frankxu4795
      @frankxu4795 5 місяців тому +5

      The fact is, nobody’s a fan of free speech if it means letting people they don’t like have a say.

    • @mattsmith8929
      @mattsmith8929 5 місяців тому +6

      Goes outside, gets arrested #Straya

  • @Siris101
    @Siris101 5 місяців тому +577

    Two students from Qatar lecturing the west on morals

    • @HelloJamesBond
      @HelloJamesBond 5 місяців тому +40

      It’s like a Monty Phython sketch for the 21st century

    • @jacovawernett3077
      @jacovawernett3077 5 місяців тому +6

      ​@@HelloJamesBondIt a cartoon.

    • @SunilFrancisGeorge
      @SunilFrancisGeorge 5 місяців тому +13

      it could be a case of not wanting to acknowledge or confront the issues present in their own society.

    • @SunilFrancisGeorge
      @SunilFrancisGeorge 5 місяців тому

      Ladies and gentlemen, prepare to be enlightened! Today, we bring you the sage wisdom of Abdulaziz and Fatima, two bright-eyed students from Qatar, here to set the moral compass of the decadent West straight.
      Fresh from their first semester at Oxford, paid for by their oil tycoon fathers, these champions of virtue are ready to tackle the West's ethical shortcomings. Armed with lattes and MacBooks, they've embarked on a crusade to educate us on the finer points of morality.
      Watch in awe as Abdulaziz, between sips of his ethically-sourced flat white, lectures on workers' rights. Pay no attention to the fact that his family's summer home was built by migrant laborers working in questionable conditions. That's irrelevant to his profound insights!
      Marvel at Fatima's passionate discourse on gender equality, delivered from the comfort of her luxury apartment. Her driver waits patiently outside, ready to whisk her away to the next demonstration. Who says you can't fight the patriarchy in Prada?
      Our dynamic duo is horrified by the West's materialism, frequently discussing it over caviar brunches and champagne. They're not afraid to call out Western hypocrisy, right after they finish their shopping spree on Oxford Street.
      So gather 'round, you misguided Westerners! Let Abdulaziz and Fatima guide you to the moral high ground. Never mind the irony - it's merely a Western construct they've risen above.
      Remember, folks: there's nothing quite like a lecture on ethics from those who've never had to wrestle with the complexities of the real world. Thank you, Abdulaziz and Fatima, for your priceless contribution to our moral education!

    • @jacovawernett3077
      @jacovawernett3077 5 місяців тому +6

      @@SunilFrancisGeorge Very good point. Namaste. It must be very hard to confront a book that has fueled hate whilst thinking it came from some soul hating entity, named Muhammad. Not God. God is a lot kinder than the Quran.

  • @DragonballG.
    @DragonballG. 5 місяців тому +1101

    “All I hear is losers complaining about losing” oof.

    • @frankxu4795
      @frankxu4795 5 місяців тому +22

      It’s like how people believe in this thing called human rights. If it actually existed, you wouldn’t have different countries with their own unique set of human rights.

    • @jamesmcd71
      @jamesmcd71 5 місяців тому +25

      Isn't that the truth. I'll never understand why people want to be a victim.

    • @DmitryYR
      @DmitryYR 5 місяців тому +5

      That hit hard

    • @MrBeesknees95
      @MrBeesknees95 5 місяців тому +1

      Wait when does he say that?

    • @robmik83
      @robmik83 5 місяців тому +27

      @@jamesmcd71 Because being a victim is a perfect alibi, they are not to blame for their screwups.

  • @cianormia8638
    @cianormia8638 4 місяці тому +2

    What a spectacle! 😵 Amazing performance Konstantin! Thank you so much for doing yet another unbelivable job! ❤

  • @rufusreloaded1043
    @rufusreloaded1043 5 місяців тому +1085

    Douglas Murray never said you cant say river to sea, he says if you say it you're a moron and he'll tell you why.

    • @abigailslade3824
      @abigailslade3824 5 місяців тому +128

      And he is right.

    • @jameslevitt7313
      @jameslevitt7313 5 місяців тому

      Zionist Likud party say “ from the sea to the river only Israelis have control “
      Are Zionists also morons ?
      Or are you a hypocrite
      Check ♟️

    • @matthewryan2060
      @matthewryan2060 5 місяців тому +106

      I think Douglas said that most people chanting that nonsense couldn’t even tell which river and sea they’re talking about.

    • @tyhar7493
      @tyhar7493 5 місяців тому +23

      The term can be construed as incitement anyway.

    • @DonXardas
      @DonXardas 5 місяців тому +12

      ​@@matthewryan2060and he was/is right about it.

  • @thecrimsondragon9744
    @thecrimsondragon9744 5 місяців тому +264

    Wow, I have to give it to Konstantin. Even Douglas Murray seemed a little rattled when at these shamefully biased 'Doha debates', but Konstantin held his own admirably.
    I applaud this man's courage 👏🏽

  • @Mike-o1d
    @Mike-o1d 4 місяці тому +247

    Konstantine is the only one in the room with a brain

    • @IntenseBliss1
      @IntenseBliss1 2 місяці тому +9

      There was possibly just 1 other person, the first guy to speak at 13:41

    • @Majdar
      @Majdar 2 місяці тому +5

      @@IntenseBliss1 Yeah I thought that guy also made sense and to prove it, the lady ask him how he sees things, he completely dismantle her narrative about western interest and she says "I think we can move on now" with a laugh. Yeah, of course we can, because she can't counter it with anything but saying the same propaganda over and over.

    • @maryharris9694
      @maryharris9694 2 місяці тому +1

      Agree

    • @stopspreadinghate
      @stopspreadinghate 2 місяці тому

      Without him, this is almost unwatchable. Very little accurate information or critical thought from the rest of the crowd. It's comical that the left and Muslim Arabs unite in their view points, mostly about who is being oppressed and their hatred of the west.

  • @jacobcohen9205
    @jacobcohen9205 4 місяці тому +7

    I'd love to see Ms. Bhuto debate Douglas Murray on anything. She would be made to look like another wealthy, entitled, privileged member of the corrupt Bhutto political dynasty.
    She accuses 'billionaire' families of controlling the press, lol. Oh, the hypocrisy here.
    Her own billionaire family has been guilty of this many times in the past.
    I' definitely 'do' her though.

  • @WolfHowl71
    @WolfHowl71 5 місяців тому +182

    I love how this is an 'Arab conference' held in the 'hated west'. They have such strong free speech that they can't even have their conference in their own country. Brilliant. F**king brilliant.

    • @HelloImadamn
      @HelloImadamn 4 місяці тому +3

      Lol

    • @Irritandarts
      @Irritandarts 4 місяці тому +13

      They don't even see this hypocrisy - they are blind children !

    • @JesstheDJ999
      @JesstheDJ999 4 місяці тому +4

      Hypocrisy at its finest! I thought this debate was in an Arabian country at first. Hypocrites

  • @defyzs7657
    @defyzs7657 4 місяці тому +223

    Love konstantin without being obnoxious loud or rude....he absolutely dismantled these arguments

  • @shoopa9971
    @shoopa9971 5 місяців тому +257

    That woman said she is sick of hearing the UK complaining about illegal migrants destroying their country… WOW

    • @keeya_ks
      @keeya_ks 5 місяців тому +17

      Yet Pakistan threw out a million Afghan refugees within the last year

    • @lissyadams6497
      @lissyadams6497 5 місяців тому +10

      I know I raised an eyebrow at that comment too!

    • @sdust251977
      @sdust251977 5 місяців тому

      Qatar? Free speech? You cannot even get on the Internet unless you buy the one they allowed or you have to use VPN. I'm sure this is s simulation.

    • @alexmendoza9270
      @alexmendoza9270 5 місяців тому

      The chickens have come home to roost. 🐓 ua-cam.com/video/Vy6lFFaX0nQ/v-deo.htmlsi=j4KqEJlecLGPpyYw

    • @skittlishsour7511
      @skittlishsour7511 5 місяців тому +3

      Thats LITERALLY what all the people who rightfully criticize the west and its history of slavery, imperialism & colonialism etc. hear all the time when they talk about what destroyed their countries and their people and their cultures

  • @DG12
    @DG12 12 днів тому +1

    Thank you Konstantin!

  • @mohamedgoldstein5565
    @mohamedgoldstein5565 5 місяців тому +128

    Konstantin gets shut down whenever he makes a good point.

  • @MartinU4179
    @MartinU4179 4 місяці тому +500

    This is what Qatari money sounds like when it talks.

    • @jurdles3
      @jurdles3 4 місяці тому +10

      Completely. Couldn't see past that.

    • @omergabriel6065
      @omergabriel6065 4 місяці тому +14

      A white man who works at the media aran of qatar (al jazira) talks about problems woth the ny times lol
      I want to see if he would still have a job if he will say anything negative about hamas 😂😂😂

    • @CharlesWestinghIII
      @CharlesWestinghIII 4 місяці тому +6

      Exactly that which really illustrated the main failings with Western contemporary media

    • @mistaly1981
      @mistaly1981 4 місяці тому

      Can’t agree more

    • @mistaly1981
      @mistaly1981 4 місяці тому +1

      @@CharlesWestinghIIIcan’t agree more

  • @lastshelter5550
    @lastshelter5550 4 місяці тому +288

    They must’ve invited Konstantin by mistake, I think they intended to have an entire panel that just agreed on everything but he’s a factual fox amongst the chickens! 😂

    • @pau-o5q
      @pau-o5q 4 місяці тому +16

      Qatar has a nasty habit of doing this...

    • @FenrirLupo
      @FenrirLupo 4 місяці тому +12

      @@pau-o5q yup, happened with Douglas Murray as well when he got invited.

    • @chaiam
      @chaiam 4 місяці тому +3

      Incorrect - they are foxes ...AND chickens, he is the wolf.

    • @slavikrogozins691
      @slavikrogozins691 3 місяці тому

      I don't believe that what Konstantin started about slavery is fundamentally true though it is true history. Removal of slavery was made possible by an individual revolution (we as people needed 80% of human resources in order to sustain life), that in turn made WW1 and WW2 possible and I would remind everyone that Brittn was the lead contestant in the arms race. And all the great powers were preparing for war. It was a time of opportunity.

    • @Stephen-lt1tp
      @Stephen-lt1tp 3 місяці тому +2

      Yep and Steve is such a beta word salad slub

  • @markspindler5321
    @markspindler5321 2 місяці тому +1

    Great discussion. Thanks

  • @LA-kc7ev
    @LA-kc7ev 5 місяців тому +75

    Konstantin is smart, quick witted, knowledgable and courageous. Kudos to him! Not many could hold their ground as he. Support for Konstantin and all respect.

  • @bl4531
    @bl4531 5 місяців тому +247

    The Arabs started slavery before the transatlantic slavery started; and konstantin is correct - the Brits did put a stop to it.

    • @colinelliott5629
      @colinelliott5629 5 місяців тому +11

      The transatlantic slave trade was evolution; Africans and Arabs took slaves across North Africa, then the Portugese competed using ships, and then switched to South America when that was invaded, followed by many other European traders.It took the Royal Navy to end it as best it could, but of course has continued where it can, including Arabia.

    • @rustyyb8450
      @rustyyb8450 5 місяців тому

      @@colinelliott5629 Who did the Portuguese learn from? Malaria was endemic, but, the further you got into Africa, the more endemic it was. African's taught the Portuguese & Spanish about North African slaving. African's were profiteers and enablers of Africa's slave export. Until the Reconquista,,, it was European slaves being imported into Africa; Cordoba was Europe's most profitable slave market (export).

    • @koopon3900
      @koopon3900 5 місяців тому +2

      Started it centuries before only recently ended it… (or rather, replaced it with human trafficking)

    • @Nofurtherquestions
      @Nofurtherquestions 5 місяців тому +3

      Well yes. The term slave has its origins in the word slav. The slavs, who inhabited a large part of Eastern Europe, were taken as slaves by the Muslims of Spain during the ninth century.

    • @tomaka121
      @tomaka121 4 місяці тому

      Bro - slavery was probably present since the beginning of humanity

  • @Daniel-gb3en
    @Daniel-gb3en 5 місяців тому +306

    Is anyone else sick of hearing the word "narrative" repeated over and over again?

    • @gingerbill128
      @gingerbill128 5 місяців тому +28

      Yes , though buzzwords like that let you know who you are dealing with very quickly .

    • @pixie3458
      @pixie3458 5 місяців тому +7

      Why don't they use the old expression 'story' 😅

    • @Presterbawn
      @Presterbawn 5 місяців тому +8

      'narrative' is the new 'i can't even'

    • @sebastiennesp1978
      @sebastiennesp1978 5 місяців тому +1

      I am, but of course I did not attend university to study for a worthless degree. Sorry I am a moron...

    • @nickwyatt9498
      @nickwyatt9498 5 місяців тому +4

      Ditto for ‘conversation’.

  • @maayanraviv1549
    @maayanraviv1549 2 місяці тому +2

    Konstantin, you are my hero. ❤❤❤

  • @RexOfVicis
    @RexOfVicis 5 місяців тому +85

    You absolutely KILLED it Konstantin! Absolutely fantastic! Well done sir!

  • @rockybalboagaralhaoitalian4592
    @rockybalboagaralhaoitalian4592 5 місяців тому +325

    African woman wonders why no one talks about their war
    Arab woman continues talking about Gaza

    • @Fozzimo
      @Fozzimo 5 місяців тому +15

      Pretty wild how that one panelist didnt get called out for her hypocrisy after calling out a random bbc anchor for saying ukrainian look like westernere

    • @nope-ot9pg
      @nope-ot9pg 5 місяців тому +5

      The poor Sudan.

    • @LARDYCHRIST
      @LARDYCHRIST 5 місяців тому +22

      The problem there is that the war in Sudan doesn't look good on Instagram and tiktok.

    • @nope-ot9pg
      @nope-ot9pg 5 місяців тому +13

      @LARDYCHRIST exactly!! It's not 'trendy', which makes me dislike the crowd supporting Gaza even more.

    • @babykoda4752
      @babykoda4752 5 місяців тому

      No Jews no news, I say it again, no Jews no news.

  • @jonjonsovich1420
    @jonjonsovich1420 5 місяців тому +127

    Long live Israel and the Israeli people!

    • @pilovwithketchup
      @pilovwithketchup 5 місяців тому

      and long live the fraudulent prime minister who is indicted and has warrants out for his arrest

  • @gregorycapanda5925
    @gregorycapanda5925 2 місяці тому +8

    Here is where a lot of the irritation with middle eastern immigrants that move to Detroit is coming from: We hear all about how you hate where you live, it's oppressive to women, few human rights, no freedom or liberties... complaint after complaint. But, then you move to Dearborn Michigan, and you waive your old country's flag and try to make things the way they were WHERE YOU LEFT!! WHAT?? WHY? You're an American now. Get with the program! When Mussolini was in Italy, my great grand parents packed up, and never looked back! And so did millions of others a hundred years ago and still do. But not the Middle Eastern culture! It's like, HUH?? 😮 Zero sense!

  • @costakonti
    @costakonti 5 місяців тому +153

    funny how these muslims dont like the west but they live in the west

    • @TerryBramow
      @TerryBramow 5 місяців тому +6

      Well said

    • @illyriandescendant7963
      @illyriandescendant7963 5 місяців тому

      Ahhh, that's beyond the point. The topic is How TERRIBLE is the WEST?!?! Don't change the topic, ya kaffir!

    • @lashashapira3406
      @lashashapira3406 5 місяців тому +2

      exactly

  • @jon123xyz
    @jon123xyz 5 місяців тому +244

    In these forums you never see Muslim Arabs criticizing Arabic countries or Pakistanis crticizing Pakistan. But they freak out when westerners do.

    • @kinseyeire
      @kinseyeire 4 місяці тому +9

      Once you notice it , it's hard to unsee it.

    • @mogglie
      @mogglie 4 місяці тому

      This is the core problem. Arabs a bound by culture and religion to never criticise their own path. And it causes so much suffering.

    • @A1un9ine
      @A1un9ine 4 місяці тому

      They look all cheeked up in their arguments thinking they're right for their criticism of the west but Ex-muslims like Sherif Gaber criticising islam in their countries get torched, lynched and beheaded in public demanding lust for it. Don't be by this.

    • @darrene.vonbraun4421
      @darrene.vonbraun4421 4 місяці тому

      Okay🙄🙄
      And in the christian US debates you often hear criticism of Christian western cointries, right?

    • @grahammerritt1329
      @grahammerritt1329 4 місяці тому +7

      Was there a Jewish voice and was their perspective on Gaza articulated and listened to?
      What "town halls" are held in Arab cities with Jewish students at their universities?

  • @gwynnus
    @gwynnus 5 місяців тому +272

    When these kids parrot the word "genocide", you realise just how influential media is

    • @theinngu5560
      @theinngu5560 5 місяців тому

      And how brainwashed/gullible they are

    • @JasonTaylor-po5xc
      @JasonTaylor-po5xc 5 місяців тому +13

      Yeap. I suppose they forgot about the Armenians or all of WW2.

    • @Lurch685
      @Lurch685 5 місяців тому +1

      It’s just being accurate.

    • @NoneNone-zg1cv
      @NoneNone-zg1cv 5 місяців тому +6

      So by that definition, inaccurate.

    • @NoneNone-zg1cv
      @NoneNone-zg1cv 5 місяців тому +3

      So by that definition, inaccurate.

  • @Tom_Swiss
    @Tom_Swiss 5 місяців тому +515

    Likes for Konstantin please ♥️

  • @aceboy5353
    @aceboy5353 5 місяців тому +173

    Kisin,
    You should be awarded the medal of honor. Truly brave and patient. Thank you.

    • @SuperGamli
      @SuperGamli 5 місяців тому +2

      It does take some balls to sit in a room where everyone essentially is against you for 1 and half hour, throwing random shit at the wall. Not only that, the set up of the show was weirdly one sided (against the "west"), the clips, the other guests, the crowd, the blabbering students who could not articulate a single thing through out - which is weird considering it should be a neutral debate, or maybe not?. Do you know why Constantine only answers one part of your question, man up front? Its because it was a non-comprehensive mess about resources and umm something... Same can be said about the people who seem to confuse being heard v.s. free speech. . You are not entitle to people listening to your ramblings. Is the west perfect? No, nothing is. Is it the best we´ve got, yes. If you want to get your hands dirty, go back to your corruption infested dictatorships and start there.

    • @MrCptnNemo
      @MrCptnNemo 4 місяці тому

      I am new to Kisin and triggerometry, but totally agree. Kisin has balls of steel to sit in the western country and listen to hypocrites who pretend Russia China and certain Arab countries are so great. I thought this chat was in Doha, it's in England...;)

  • @nuttall47
    @nuttall47 5 місяців тому +98

    Looking forward to their debate on human rights and religious freedom in Saudi Arabia.

  • @zeeman1124
    @zeeman1124 Місяць тому +3

    "Absolute free speech" Only when it comes to criticizing western values. Ask them what they think about absolute free speech when it comes to criticizing Islam.

  • @MrS-pe6sd
    @MrS-pe6sd 5 місяців тому +180

    She says 1 million people are being displaced from their country. So why aren’t the other Arab countries welcoming them? They aren’t. Why is that?

    • @SunilFrancisGeorge
      @SunilFrancisGeorge 5 місяців тому +11

      Great point! That's an aspect of the refugee crisis that doesn't get nearly enough attention. 🤔 While the West often bears the brunt of criticism for not doing enough to help, the Arab countries that share cultural and linguistic similarities with these refugees aren’t exactly rolling out the red carpet either.
      It’s likely a complex mix of factors that keeps them from being more welcoming-like the economic burden of resettling large numbers of people, social and cultural resistance to diversity, and internal political struggles within those countries.

    • @mohammadsufiyaan5330
      @mohammadsufiyaan5330 5 місяців тому +2

      Hitler said the same thing for Jews and European countries

    • @SunilFrancisGeorge
      @SunilFrancisGeorge 5 місяців тому

      @@mohammadsufiyaan5330 The rhetoric used by some countries in the Middle East toward refugees is eerily similar to the hateful propaganda that targeted Jews under the Nazi regime. It’s a reminder that demonizing vulnerable groups of people and turning a blind eye to their plight can lead down a very dark path.

    • @cameroncollier8062
      @cameroncollier8062 5 місяців тому +4

      Because they care about their culture.

    • @koopon3900
      @koopon3900 5 місяців тому

      @@mohammadsufiyaan5330 Except Jews were never considered Europeans. They are called Jews because they are from Judea (modern-day Israel), and are not from Europe, hence they were always treated as outsiders.

  • @easyreader6179
    @easyreader6179 5 місяців тому +297

    Konstantine should've asked the audience who agrees with gay marriage.? And asked how many think homosexuality should be illegal.
    That would shock the lefties

    • @Lurch685
      @Lurch685 5 місяців тому +5

      Islam is 100% right on this issue.

    • @sbaumgartner9848
      @sbaumgartner9848 5 місяців тому +13

      Great opportunity that was missed!

    • @IrradiatedFeline
      @IrradiatedFeline 5 місяців тому +14

      ​@Lurch685 then go and live there.

    • @Lurch685
      @Lurch685 5 місяців тому +3

      @@IrradiatedFeline no thanks. I’ll live wherever I want.

    • @danielhaden6674
      @danielhaden6674 5 місяців тому +4

      @@Lurch685 For now

  • @shloopy5
    @shloopy5 5 місяців тому +289

    They're sitting there bad mouthing the west and the UK, in a debate about whether or not there is freedom of speech in the West 😅😅😅

    • @HelloImadamn
      @HelloImadamn 4 місяці тому +5

      Yeah but didn't you hear that one guy? He was shouted down in a town hall in the west! Basically fascism 😂

    • @leonnozik
      @leonnozik 4 місяці тому +7

      @@HelloImadamn he should file a complaint with the Qatari government...or go on AL Jazeera.

    • @mazilys
      @mazilys 4 місяці тому +1

      Maybe they should leave then. While they can

  • @commenceun
    @commenceun Місяць тому +3

    Holy shit, host is doha

  • @angelpajarillo
    @angelpajarillo 5 місяців тому +234

    This debate was heavily biased , thank god for Konstantin, it was also a bad faith ‘ debate ‘ . The lady who attacked Douglas Murray should not have made an ad hominem attack without Douglas being there to defend himself . It shows a woeful lack of integrity and professionalism .

    • @babykoda4752
      @babykoda4752 5 місяців тому +18

      I completely agree. She was the worst and a bad representation of her kind.

    • @svengali5415
      @svengali5415 5 місяців тому +12

      ....as was her rambling incoherence. Is she a professional broadcaster? good grief

    • @yaweno9555
      @yaweno9555 4 місяці тому +13

      She did that because she is not able to debate him in person. She was in her element here.

    • @lolsaXx
      @lolsaXx 4 місяці тому +5

      Wouldn't have been a debate without him..

    • @HelloImadamn
      @HelloImadamn 4 місяці тому +4

      Fuck I would have paid good money to see him respond to her in real time.
      I don't agree with his idea of deporting people who chant things or locking them up but then again, if you're trying to prove you are an immigrant who is grateful for the chance to live free in the west ..........

  • @andystegall7407
    @andystegall7407 5 місяців тому +114

    I dont want to hear about censorship from people who actively impose censorship on others

    • @joba4848
      @joba4848 5 місяців тому +7

      If these people really believe in freedom of speech, then they would have to accept criticism of Islam and Mohamed. I doubt very much that they would stomach that!

    • @Sandra-de3tz
      @Sandra-de3tz 5 місяців тому +3

      Yeah can you say anything about the religion of the Middle East in the Middle East ?

    • @andystegall7407
      @andystegall7407 5 місяців тому

      @@Sandra-de3tz They come to the west to make it more like whatever sharia law sh!thole they just fled from. If it is so terrible and restrictive here, go back ffs.

  • @shorletav
    @shorletav 5 місяців тому +214

    Kudos to Doha for creating their own carefully constructed echo chamber and marketing it as a debate about "free speech". Evil geniuses those Qataris.
    No sarcasm now: Kudos to Konstantin for staying cool, logical and courteous, even at it dawns on him that he is being used as a pawn for Qatari propaganda.

    • @gnome944
      @gnome944 5 місяців тому

      Well they are investing so much to inflict chaos in the west with the islamists demonstrations and hamas supporting but hey. Atlist they got a bunch of muslims complaining about the place they all fled too. And it's not for being a terrible place to live in. The woman that support the palestinian does not understand why the world support israel. Well they see what hamas isis boko haram el saida are doing and their call do destroy the west and it's values and they understand thar all societies that support 5hem have deferent set of values that are not competable with the western values. Very simple. Ahh and that israel tech and inventions that saves millions around the world worth to keep israel safe.

    • @ruthgrady2824
      @ruthgrady2824 5 місяців тому +3

      You are so correct!!!

    • @aaronrocs
      @aaronrocs 5 місяців тому +2

      It's basically "The View"

    • @leonnozik
      @leonnozik 4 місяці тому

      Just evil..and they do with such a straight face

  • @josephloureiro4535
    @josephloureiro4535 3 дні тому

    Beautiful debate. Props to the moderator, Steve and Konstantin. It was great to hear so many different perspectives without being at each other's throat. Props to the moderator for being unbiased and doing her job brilliantly.

  • @CrystalShip8899
    @CrystalShip8899 5 місяців тому +819

    This was unfair, Konstantin taking on these was like Christopher Hitchens taking on a group of clueless Katie Price's.

    • @shabbaranks7968
      @shabbaranks7968 5 місяців тому +5

      You haven't even watched it it was posted 40 min ago you complete ideologue

    • @JWWEntertainment
      @JWWEntertainment 5 місяців тому +40

      @@shabbaranks7968 aahhhh. A Copy/Paster...

    • @bubberbucky7
      @bubberbucky7 5 місяців тому

      ​@@shabbaranks7968shut up coomer

    • @shabbaranks7968
      @shabbaranks7968 5 місяців тому +1

      @@JWWEntertainment doing my bit

    • @CrystalShip8899
      @CrystalShip8899 5 місяців тому +18

      @@shabbaranks7968 The preview was enough, but you used a big word for today so well done.

  • @angusmacangus3181
    @angusmacangus3181 5 місяців тому +103

    That Arab medical student talking about slavery as if it is happening NOW in the West was very confusing ... until I realized he uses the word "slavery" just as they use the word "genocide" about Palestine.

  • @painless4785
    @painless4785 4 місяці тому +147

    If anyone watching knew who Fatima Bhutto is, would facepalm the biggest facepalm when she calls out billionaires and corruption. A feudal from one of the richest families on earth whose people don't have access to clean water or basic education let alone free speech while they fly in private jets is absolute personification of irony.

    • @JamesZ32100
      @JamesZ32100 2 місяці тому +2

      Her smug looks and her know-it-all air of fake superiority makes me sick

    • @shlmzp6
      @shlmzp6 Місяць тому

      She is trash, a Nazi liar who knows she lies just for the sake of keeling Jews because that's what her imam tells her to do.

  • @Stardust475
    @Stardust475 3 місяці тому +3

    27:00 try criticising Qatari politics, support of caliphaters, or even their leadership. Try criticising Islam and see how that will go down there.
    If they were so concerned about justice, these young people from wealthy Muslim countries would advocate for workers there and their maids.

  • @anahi977
    @anahi977 5 місяців тому +177

    'this ''graduates'' are all like: 'i'm all for free speech as long is pro palestinian lol''

  • @TheMakersRage
    @TheMakersRage 5 місяців тому +71

    After seeing how Douglas Murray was treated in his Doha debate, I'm not surprised Konstantin came to this one locked and loaded.

    • @kamu38
      @kamu38 5 місяців тому +4

      No one touched his points on history, because none of them knew any.

  • @ChuddmasterZero
    @ChuddmasterZero 5 місяців тому +222

    Konstantin was the ONLY one being honest. Everyone likes the idea of participating in a genuine, 'robust' and uncompromising conversation, but VERY few people actually have the courage to speak in that manner. Huge respect to Konstantin for being principled in a room full of sicophants.

    • @DioStole
      @DioStole 5 місяців тому +2

      Why sicophants.. ? everyone was polite, respectful many agreed with some of Konstantin points, what is wrong with you

    • @Kyushu314
      @Kyushu314 5 місяців тому +2

      @@ChuddmasterZero Perhaps ignoramuses and hypocrites might be first and second place descriptors and sycophants might be third in describing the participants in this so-called debate? - KK excepted of course!

    • @Thisisahandle701
      @Thisisahandle701 5 місяців тому +13

      Because of how 95% of the panel took turns to repeat the same point again and again. It was essentially a cascade of anti western rhetoric, with only 1 guy, Konstantin, offering alternate views.

    • @DioStole
      @DioStole 5 місяців тому

      @@Thisisahandle701 you mean the only view you accept and the only view you ever got

    • @soleboxy
      @soleboxy 5 місяців тому

      Thank you!

  • @EmperorsNewWardrobe
    @EmperorsNewWardrobe 2 місяці тому +4

    Konstantin might be the best counter puncher out there, up there with Douglas Murray and Natasha Hausdorff