The thing that I have always loved about Emilie Autumn is that she was always the embodiment of the scorned woman, in all her tragic beauty. The rawness in her vocals and her lyrics is why I keep coming back to her, even a decade later.
+1 Don't listen to her as much as I used to but I always come back to her Opheliac album when I need this certain healing... Know about her since I was 13 back in 2006 through MySpace, still one of the best music discoveries for me 💜🖤
I have no idea why people are saying her voice is bad. I haven't listened to any of her other songs, but from this one, I'd say her voice is actually really cool.
No, her voice would be mezzo-soprano if she did opera. Contralto range singers outside of pop would be singers like Cher, Tracy Chapman, Lalah Hathaway, Ana Carolina etc
Nobody should be questioning her voice or talent. She's the most unique and talented person. I have listening to Emilie since I was 13 years old, that's 10 years. Every time I listen to her there is always something new for me in her songs. And unlike anyone else, has been there for all of that time for me through everything
LOL. My dad introduced me to her _type_ of music when I was five (2005, Evelyn Evelyn). He struggled with depression. Guess Amanda was right... It really does run in the family.
It's Emilie Autumn, shes not trying Too Hard. Autumns music is pain filled anger and when you're angry or hurting then the whole song is perfect especially the are you suffering part.
Ok my take is her voice isn't suppose to sound nice or pretty its filled with anger and pain and honestly i can feel it. One of the reasons i love this song is i can relate to the raw emotion in it.
It's entirely a stylistic choice. She sings in a more "traditional" way in some of her other songs, like Shalott, Marry Me, and her rendition of Gloomy Sunday, for example, but here this voice is meant to sound like this.
thank you so much! ;^; i had faved a lot of wingedzephyr's emilie autumn vids to find them easily, but since they were made private, i've had a time of finding new ones that were just as good! These are perfect! thank you!!
Not sure how on point this is with the meaning of the song... Not sure I understand the lyrics, but I kinda get vibes of Medea and Jason from this song...
Of course we are. If you really wanted to know why, go watch another song from this artist - Shalott if you want something softer. Even better, "The Art Of Suicide". If you really like watching what you hate, go watch "I Know Where You Sleep". EA forever!
@@nicorizzo5402 She does so many different things with her voice in this song. The vocal range alone is impressive, the fact that there’s clearly talent behind it even more so.
Maybe it’s just because I watched an hour long video about Rule of Rose and have got it on the brain, but this song really reminds me of Wendy from that game.
Emilie Autumns music is like mental illness personified. Depression, borderline personality disorder, bipolar even adhd. It’s no wonder many of us with these are drawn to this music. I wonder what she’s up to these days.
She is naturally a contralto who occasionally hits some soprano notes. I don't think I've heard her go higher than a high f though, which would make her a mezzo by range and not a true soprano.
Misery loves company and Liar I dedicate to a man and he is a man despite the words to these songs, I do love him, wish I didn't, but I dedicate these words to him. Ginzo
Lindsey and Emilie are very very different in many ways and honestly, I love them both. Do I love EA more? Hell yeah. But I also love Lindsey. It's really not fair to compare them when they're so vastly different from each other.
Madisun Purtell i guess you are right, just for me, whenever i could listen to lindsey stirling, i prefer emilie. so in that way i can compare them for me. in the end lindsey stirling has lots of fans who love her music and enjoy it, so it cant be totally bad or anything. i didnt want to sound too serious in that comment sorry for that :/
You didn't by any chance come here due to the mentioning of this song via a certain Provocative Envy, did you? As both a Tomione and EA fan, I'll admit I sort of imploded a bit when she mentioned it.
You mean she repeats the same lyrics? The lyrics she repeats are worth repeating. Or you mean she writes about a lot of the same topics? The stuff she writes about is stuff I can relate to.
3 years ago, at 22 years old i almost took my own life. I was abused as a kid, broken, depressed, anorexic, bulimic, suicidal. I went in & out of psych units like it was a game of tic-tac-toe. Suicide watch. I was on enough Antidepressants to kill a horse. I hated myself. I wanted out. I wanted the pain to stop. The gaslighting* to end. *(when a psycho makes a sane person question their own sanity, and thus think they themselves are the insane one). I wanted power. I got into witchcraft. I thought it would give me the identity i wanted, to be set apart from people who hurt me. It only made me sicker. Sicker. Thats what it did to me. The doctor said id never get well. That i would suffer severe Chronic Manic depression, and never be well, that id be stuck on antidepressants all of my life. I would plot suicide on a daily basis, binging and purging my food as often as opening and closing a door. The pain was too real. People choked me. Assaulted me. Told me i was ugly, i felt worthless. Nothing ever got better. Then my mother died. The (1) & only soul who ever loved /emotionally supported me was removed from the earth. I was stuck living with people who broke me, ruined my identity, thus causing me to hate God. I thought God hated me, that he was just like the ones who tortured me, a family of abusers, who cover up all their actions with the mask of religion. I didnt know that God is on my side. I didnt know that Jesus would Love and Defend me, and fight for me and that He later would heal me, rescue me from Family. The ones who caused me pain. The ones who choked me for wearing a necklace. I moved out after family threatened to throw all my belongings on the front yard, and have me permanently institutionalized in an insane asylum, when they were the ones who caused my mental illness via abuse. They blamed me for the abuse they did to me. To take my life in an insane asylum when they were the ones who made me suicidal. Next morning i spoke with my dead moms parents who let me live with them. I stayed on the antidepressants, prescribed. But they only made me sicker. I got deeper and deeper into witchcraft, thinking it was a solution. But it made me even more suicidal. Self hatred was inescapable. I decided i was going to kill myself. I was going to take all my pills. But then Jesus stepped in. I didnt die. I surrendered my life to Jesus to make me well and heal me. The deity i blamed for me being abused wanted to heal me. He Was fighting for me and Loved me all along. He wanted to love me. He wanted to give me His Heart. HE LOVES ME. JESUS. LOVES. ME . Jesus miraculously healed me - i am off all drugs and dont need them and i dont have any mental illnesses. I work a job and am totally healed , full of joy. I’m now a born again Christian, who wants the entire world to know that JESUS WANTS TO HEAL YOU HE. LOVES. YOU. Nuff said.
You don't have to have proper vocal chords to be able to fluctuate your voice. Nor do you have to have a beautiful singing voice in order to make good music.
Can someone tell me why 'The Asylum For Wayward Victorian Girls' is like $250 online? Do I have to guy to a regular bookstore or will it be $250 there, too? I really want the book, but I don't have that much money to spend.
Ryuk Senpai your welcome ^-^ Also I don't know if you know this but right now if you pre order the audio book version (29.99) you get 50% off of the physical copy of the book (with the 50% off it turns into $37.50) so all together you would spend about 68$ without shipping so you get the audio book version (with her signature) with the normal book for seven dollars less than if you bought the book by itself. :)
The thing that I have always loved about Emilie Autumn is that she was always the embodiment of the scorned woman, in all her tragic beauty. The rawness in her vocals and her lyrics is why I keep coming back to her, even a decade later.
"I'll spend eternity comparing all my poetry to yours."
"... And by the way, your poetry sucks."
Love you, Em. This is healing.
+1
Don't listen to her as much as I used to but I always come back to her Opheliac album when I need this certain healing... Know about her since I was 13 back in 2006 through MySpace, still one of the best music discoveries for me 💜🖤
I have no idea why people are saying her voice is bad. I haven't listened to any of her other songs, but from this one, I'd say her voice is actually really cool.
She's a rare female contralto, which is basically like a female bass. It's really unique and I think it's beautiful.
She reminds me a lot of the way Amanda Palmer sings too.
No, her voice would be mezzo-soprano if she did opera. Contralto range singers outside of pop would be singers like Cher, Tracy Chapman, Lalah Hathaway, Ana Carolina etc
Yup its good
her singing is good ..there is parts that are pure singing and parts that are ....emotive growling etc....its part of the performance
Nobody should be questioning her voice or talent. She's the most unique and talented person. I have listening to Emilie since I was 13 years old, that's 10 years. Every time I listen to her there is always something new for me in her songs. And unlike anyone else, has been there for all of that time for me through everything
LOL. My dad introduced me to her _type_ of music when I was five (2005, Evelyn Evelyn). He struggled with depression. Guess Amanda was right... It really does run in the family.
It's Emilie Autumn, shes not trying Too Hard. Autumns music is pain filled anger and when you're angry or hurting then the whole song is perfect especially the are you suffering part.
It's not about anger. It's about sadism and sexual obsession.
So I would assume when a woman im interested in send me this I should be concerned?
@@robertball8696 dont be scared...it just means you'll have an exciting time:)
She's incredibly talented. Her music is so unique.
The pre-chorus is so beautiful.
Ok my take is her voice isn't suppose to sound nice or pretty its filled with anger and pain and honestly i can feel it. One of the reasons i love this song is i can relate to the raw emotion in it.
I think it's funny how a lot of the comments are telling her she can't sing but on other songs they're worshipping her
range, her best and worse. good song? sing o f pitch might match internal instability.
Exactly!! This other guy told me she couldn't sing, and I was like if she couldn't sing, then why is she a singer?!?! LOL SHE HAS talent!!
This song sounds like the obsessive lover anthem.
SolitaireMasta thats the point
She doesn't have a tradionally nice voice, but that's what makes it all the more beautiful.
Evan
Her voice sounds a lot better in some of her other songs, such as What If and Marry Me
Emilie canta hermoso! En esta canción el estilo es distinto simplemente.
It's entirely a stylistic choice. She sings in a more "traditional" way in some of her other songs, like Shalott, Marry Me, and her rendition of Gloomy Sunday, for example, but here this voice is meant to sound like this.
Her songs really just hav a way of conveying so much emotion and I just appreciate it so much
thank you so much! ;^; i had faved a lot of wingedzephyr's emilie autumn vids to find them easily, but since they were made private, i've had a time of finding new ones that were just as good!
These are perfect!
thank you!!
This is my life. *-* She's taught me so much through her music and I adore everything she has to say. Gah. EA
"Lawyer, lawyer, lawyer, LAAAAAWWWYEERR!!!"
Arent's Lawyers hired liars?
Like hookers?
@@schwarzeseis4031 You get it!
she's such a brilliant artist. oh and the viola(idk if it's really a viola but it sounds like) at the start sounds a little like an electric guitar.
It's an electric violin. Its name is Elgar.
that's awesome, I loved wingedzephyr I'll have to subscribe :)) Thank you!!!!
this song is perfect everytime
Not sure how on point this is with the meaning of the song... Not sure I understand the lyrics, but I kinda get vibes of Medea and Jason from this song...
Oh my wow, this is awesome...
Jesus I can sadly relate to this
Of course we are. If you really wanted to know why, go watch another song from this artist - Shalott if you want something softer. Even better, "The Art Of Suicide". If you really like watching what you hate, go watch "I Know Where You Sleep".
EA forever!
I just found out about her
and i personally like her voice
This is one fo my favorite song that she made
thank you. also a critique of your style. the words come a trifle sooner than I think they should but still, it is fantastic.
Wow , the pic . I think my heart just stopped.
Right? I love this pic but I can't find it anywhere.
This song is just like my ex he's a liar but any way i love u emillie and ur so awesome im goth but i can't tell a lie i love u
Yes she can. She just tends to vary her voice a lot. In some songs she sounds like she can't sing, but she can really.
Her vocals in this song are very impressive anyway.
@@nicorizzo5402 She does so many different things with her voice in this song. The vocal range alone is impressive, the fact that there’s clearly talent behind it even more so.
Spread The Plague. 💕
ARE YOU SUFFERING? Why yes I am, thank you for asking Emilie! 💄💋💗
BPD anthem.
Maybe it’s just because I watched an hour long video about Rule of Rose and have got it on the brain, but this song really reminds me of Wendy from that game.
This is my favorite one
I used to be so obsessed with her
Used to be?
11 people are suffering.
perfectly explains how ana sounds
3 Miles away from love what do you mean by "ana"?
+Elise M anorexia, when ya have the disorder you can hear her saying things lretty similar to this
3 Miles away from love Wtf? I have anorexia and it's nothing like this. My bpd is though.
Emilie Autumns music is like mental illness personified. Depression, borderline personality disorder, bipolar even adhd. It’s no wonder many of us with these are drawn to this music. I wonder what she’s up to these days.
Madisun I agree also emilie hates being compared to ppl.
I wonder what the song is called... ;)
Ok maybe her Voice isn't the prettiest but she's very expressive and has unique content so....
Notre Dame Lover of Cathedr
Try ‘Rose Red’ when she chooses to use her voice like that her voice can sound beautiful
Damn, 7th grade anthem right here
Whaat, that's way too harsh, ozzy is awesome
Best song ever! xD
Yes, yes we are into it. And proud of it. Also, if it is in the form of a question, you should put a question mark. Have a nice day~!
well played....
I love this song first time hearing it but I have heard her other songs I like it a lot because she sounds kinda angry....
I absolutely love her music but the suffering part seemed a little bit off.
🖤
Perhaps.
And yes that is always a possiblility.
Sometimes trolls are amusing.
The Manic Depressive Mix is much better than the original. Check it out if you haven't yet. :)
No, I still like the original better, but the manic depressive mix is the best of the remixes.
Official anthem of the yanderes
Gybsin Parris USODAAAAAAA!
this reads like a 12 year old comment
mark d. s. How so? I'm 26 and I agree.
ILOVEYOUILOVEYOUILOVEYOU.
Her voice is weird but it works. Like I have no clue what her range is. I wanna say alto but at some points it's too high.
She is naturally a contralto who occasionally hits some soprano notes. I don't think I've heard her go higher than a high f though, which would make her a mezzo by range and not a true soprano.
Sony Vegas perhaps? My girlfriend uses it and she loved it. However I don't know anything about video making to give a personal review.
Ozzy is a fantastic singer! its talking he struggles with ._.
Misery loves company and Liar I dedicate to a man and he is a man despite the words to these songs, I do love him, wish I didn't, but I dedicate these words to him. Ginzo
Please respect other people's music taste/ style. I'm not asking you to like it. Just to accept that it's what I (and others) like.
liar, fire, tire, plyer, dire, shire, crier, dryer, flyer, tryer, buyer, friar, hire, choir, sigher, wire
If only I could give 50 thumbs up...
Yeah it's fucking amazing isn't it? ;D
lol How does Ozzy relate? Does he like EA or something?
Um lol amount of views doesn't mean anything. Like Rebecca Black's Friday. And 100+ likes is an awfully small number in ratio of 11,000+ views hahaa
@PeninaPoison You get a thumbs up because we thought the same thing :D
I believe he is stating that Ozzy can't sing :P
2p usuk everywhere. I'm sorry it's just too fitting.
I just learned this song is about Billy Corgan lol
Makes me think of borderline personality disorder
perhaps they were reffering to themselves? that or just being a troll.
this music remembers me to my ex-bf, that asshole
This music is almost about witchcraft.
im sorry but when it comes to make modern violin music, lindsey stirling looses to emily in every way. xD
Lindsey and Emilie are very very different in many ways and honestly, I love them both. Do I love EA more? Hell yeah. But I also love Lindsey. It's really not fair to compare them when they're so vastly different from each other.
Madisun Purtell i guess you are right, just for me, whenever i could listen to lindsey stirling, i prefer emilie. so in that way i can compare them for me. in the end lindsey stirling has lots of fans who love her music and enjoy it, so it cant be totally bad or anything. i didnt want to sound too serious in that comment sorry for that :/
compare Emilie with Lindsey is like compare apples with potatoes....XD
***** in french "pomme de terre" is even the normal term for potatoe. but even then i dont feel that this analogy makes sense. :)
Apples and oranges
wingedzephyr's got nothing on you especily since they made there videos private. :)
Yup, it's an acquired taste.
Tomione ^_-
You didn't by any chance come here due to the mentioning of this song via a certain Provocative Envy, did you? As both a Tomione and EA fan, I'll admit I sort of imploded a bit when she mentioned it.
Yes! I love Tomione and Provocative Envy's fic Nightmare! Did you know she's writing a sequel? :D
I squealed when I saw the prologue up, ngl. I'm so excited for it!
she can sing, but my boyf has right, she sings too often too much the same things. But i still like her songs though :)
You mean she repeats the same lyrics? The lyrics she repeats are worth repeating. Or you mean she writes about a lot of the same topics? The stuff she writes about is stuff I can relate to.
wenn es gott gibt, bekommt er nun konkurenz
USODAAAAAA!
3 years ago, at 22 years old i almost took my own life. I was abused as a kid, broken, depressed, anorexic, bulimic, suicidal. I went in & out of psych units like it was a game of tic-tac-toe. Suicide watch. I was on enough Antidepressants to kill a horse. I hated myself. I wanted out. I wanted the pain to stop. The gaslighting* to end. *(when a psycho makes a sane person question their own sanity, and thus think they themselves are the insane one).
I wanted power. I got into witchcraft. I thought it would give me the identity i wanted, to be set apart from people who hurt me. It only made me sicker. Sicker. Thats what it did to me.
The doctor said id never get well. That i would suffer severe Chronic Manic depression, and never be well, that id be stuck on antidepressants all of my life.
I would plot suicide on a daily basis, binging and purging my food as often as opening and closing a door. The pain was too real. People choked me. Assaulted me. Told me i was ugly, i felt worthless. Nothing ever got better. Then my mother died. The (1) & only soul who ever loved /emotionally supported me was removed from the earth. I was stuck living with people who broke me, ruined my identity, thus causing me to hate God. I thought God hated me, that he was just like the ones who tortured me, a family of abusers, who cover up all their actions with the mask of religion. I didnt know that God is on my side. I didnt know that Jesus would Love and Defend me, and fight for me and that He later would heal me, rescue me from Family. The ones who caused me pain. The ones who choked me for wearing a necklace.
I moved out after family threatened to throw all my belongings on the front yard, and have me permanently institutionalized in an insane asylum, when they were the ones who caused my mental illness via abuse.
They blamed me for the abuse they did to me.
To take my life in an insane asylum when they were the ones who made me suicidal.
Next morning i spoke with my dead moms parents who let me live with them.
I stayed on the antidepressants, prescribed. But they only made me sicker. I got deeper and deeper into witchcraft, thinking it was a solution. But it made me even more suicidal. Self hatred was inescapable.
I decided i was going to kill myself. I was going to take all my pills.
But then Jesus stepped in. I didnt die. I surrendered my life to Jesus to make me well and heal me.
The deity i blamed for me being abused wanted to heal me. He Was fighting for me and Loved me all along.
He wanted to love me. He wanted to give me His Heart.
HE LOVES ME. JESUS. LOVES. ME .
Jesus miraculously healed me - i am off all drugs and dont need them and i dont have any mental illnesses. I work a job and am totally healed , full of joy.
I’m now a born again Christian, who wants the entire world to know that JESUS WANTS TO HEAL YOU
HE. LOVES. YOU.
Nuff said.
WTF are he talling about Ozzy? >:(
Sweet Irony that a song with this title (of al things) would prove so true.
LOL OK UMAD
Boris Johnson brought me here
Well it would be stupid to pay 250 for it.
She only says the same thing often... how original... lol further good song anyway.
The lyrics she repeats are worth repeating.
Dont waste your money. I like ea but the book is stupid...
Are you kidding? It was genius.
I've heard her little snippets of it, plus listened to the flag album, and I'm very excited to read it. It sounds so good.
Not even a little.
What?
Talking about yourself, Eh, Emilie?
Wtf? Emilie's not a liar.
Tell that to Ozzy Osbourne
You don't have to have proper vocal chords to be able to fluctuate your voice. Nor do you have to have a beautiful singing voice in order to make good music.
Joshua Hedges Oi, josh, do me a favour and fuck off
Joshua Hedges You're just jealous you're not a beautiful talented singer like she is.
Um, you're trying to be cool or something?
LOL OK UFAIL
That logic makes no sense to me at all. If she can't sing, she should just stick with looking pretty and playing instruments. Lol
She absolutely can sing, better than most people in fact. I find her vocals incredible.
i love her music; it just seems like she tries too hard sometimes like during the 'are you suffering' parts. Still, i love her music.
When will you ever notice me senpai.. Q.Q...xD
Death notes true author
I LOLed at this comment
It's intentional that her voice is harsh, gruff and cracked during those moments.
Can someone tell me why 'The Asylum For Wayward Victorian Girls' is like $250 online? Do I have to guy to a regular bookstore or will it be $250 there, too? I really want the book, but I don't have that much money to spend.
Same here! :o o.o
on her site its 75$ (still not cheap I know but...yeah) Here it is: www.asylumemporium.com/products/asylum#.U6OAY_ldXZ0 Hope I helped :)
Coolio. I want that for Christmas.
msbloomable thanx!
Ryuk Senpai your welcome ^-^ Also I don't know if you know this but right now if you pre order the audio book version (29.99) you get 50% off of the physical copy of the book (with the 50% off it turns into $37.50) so all together you would spend about 68$ without shipping so you get the audio book version (with her signature) with the normal book for seven dollars less than if you bought the book by itself. :)