Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.

Hillsborough: resisting injustice, recovering truth

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лют 2014
  • In an event held by the IRR and the Mannheim Centre for the Study of Criminology and Criminal Justice (LSE) and sponsored by SAGE Publications, Professor Phil Scraton hosted a meeting to discuss family campaigns against the state to discover the truth about the deaths of loved ones. Professor Scraton, author of the Race & Class article The legacy of Hillsborough: liberating truth, challenging power and the primary author of the Hillsborough Independent Panel's ground-breaking report, spoke on the campaign for justice pursued by many of the families bereaved at Hillsborough and how the truth was eventually exposed after a two-decade struggle.
    His talk was followed by a discussion which included contributions from members of black families whose relatives have died in police custody.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 18

  • @nztv8589
    @nztv8589 3 роки тому +8

    Well done for getting to the truth finally

  • @kirstys7395
    @kirstys7395 8 років тому +27

    Professor Phil Scraton has found and pushed for the REAL truth to come out. Thank you Prof Scraton, you've done a sterling job. This would be a brilliant source of history being re-written by those who suffered in this terrible event. However, the sound quality is awful and the camera doesn't show us what information he's trying to impart. Brilliant video of a very interesting subject made terrible by a bad cameraman. :( RIP 96 YNWA

  • @tracywilliamsliterature
    @tracywilliamsliterature 2 роки тому +3

    This man is truly wonderful. I will never forget that day in 1989.

  • @spacemunky53
    @spacemunky53 4 роки тому +12

    The nub of it all is ...whos responsibility was it to close the tunnel??? WHO? and why was there no stewards or pigs there to close it ? WHY?? Whos ever job it was is GUILTY!!!!

    • @young321bookie
      @young321bookie 4 роки тому +10

      It was an arranged police-operation, one that went rather wrong. That was an act of evil and nothing less, this was no tragic accident.

    • @danielwalker3535
      @danielwalker3535 3 роки тому +9

      Everyone was guilty on 15th April 89 apart from all the supporters who travelled to Sheffield that day!!! The whole world new this from that day but the evil people in this world started to cover it up immediately!!! The devil is waiting for those responsible! YOU KNOW WHO U ARE COWARDS

    • @MarkHarrison733
      @MarkHarrison733 Рік тому

      @@young321bookie The drunk fans charged the gate.

    • @gwyneth7812
      @gwyneth7812 8 місяців тому

      @@young321bookieMy thoughts too - starting from the delays en-route, to not delaying the game, and it went on.....

  • @melgrant7404
    @melgrant7404 2 роки тому +2

    No one held to account to this day.

  • @alderaanic1042
    @alderaanic1042 Рік тому +2

    Only partial justice has been done. And that was after the Hillsborough independent panel report in 2012 which exonerated the Liverpool supporters of any blame concerning the day of the disaster & that The South Yorkshire Police were to blame as were Sheffield Wednesday FC who never renued the safety licence after the 81 semi final where Tottenham fans were crushed And injured.
    And also the verdict that overturned the deaths as accident to unlawful killing as of 2021 to 97 people (Andrew Devine died after being on life support for over 30 years in July 2021) becoming the 97th victim.
    But still knowbody has ever been charged and help accountable for there actions on the day Super Intendant Duckenfield. Bernard Murray. SWFC club safety officer Mackrell. The list goes on. Oh and the sanitization of Police statements on what they did on the day. Many of the normal PC's were forced to change there statements of what they did that day or it was done without there knowledge and a lot of normal Bobbies did help on that day and suffered PTSD just like the Fans.
    Right from the start of the story of Liverpool fans breaking down Gate C when it was Duckenfield who ordered it to be opened was the beginning of the lie. And story's of drunken tickitless fans arriving at the ground late. Also the media reaction from the Camera men turning there cameras around from photographing the game to taking pictures of dead & dying people crushed up against the perimeter fences ignoring there cries & screams for help ,watching while people's faces turned white and lips And nostrils turned blue.
    And also in particularly The Sun Newspapers front page headlines about Liverpool fans pocketing the dead ,and assaulting Police officers and urinating on officers trying to help .An absolutely abhorrent and downright lies to smear the fans reputation and to sway public opinions on what they called " The Truth"
    What the Liverpool fans ,victims & family's got was only that the deaths were unlawful killings and that they were not to blame. This as well as being the longest running legal case in British history is also the BIGGEST cover up and injustice of the highest order. Superintendent Duckenfield should have gone to prison for this as quite a few other high ranking officers should of too. Duckenfield just escaped in the Private prosecution when the jury was hung (that's a 50/50 guilty/not guilty decision made by the dury) and has again I think in 2019 got off again.
    Please read the Hillsborough Independent Panel Report. It's available online to the public.
    I am not a Liverpool fan I support Carlisle United. And was 11 years old when the Hillsborough Disaster happened. It was my first year of watching Football and at the time being so young you know it's bad but are too young to understand it. And have your childhood to live. But ever since the 20th anniversary I've taken a real interest and watched just about ever documentary ,footage available. And also read Phil Scratons book "The Truth" and read the entire Independent Panel Report.
    As well as the survivors story's on the Hillsborough Disaster website that are more horrific than this video and harrowing to read.
    Without the shear determination of Professor Phil Scraton & later culture Secretary Andy Burnham (On the 20th anniversary) when Liverpool fans erupted into "Justice For tge 96" I doubt we would have had the Hillsborough Independent Panel..so huge respect to both men who fraught for the victims & family's justice.
    A lot of comments on this video like others are bigated , ignorant or darn right offensive. So before posting your comments do some proper research. And post something of value out of respect for the 97 dead. The victims family's who have fought tirelessly for justice. And those people who have died because of suicide or early deaths due to stress as there are many attributed to the worst sporting disaster in the UK and the BIGGEST misscarage of justice or injustice not only in England but in the entire world in sporting terms.
    It has nothing realy to do with Football anymore as times have changed and Hillsborough legacy is that we got safe all seated stadiums for the top two Leagues in English Football.
    But its about human lives ,normal , honest & hard working people who have loved ,lost ,suffered and fought tirelessly for JUSTICE For the 97.

  • @professorbernardkemp7448
    @professorbernardkemp7448 5 місяців тому

    The lack of accountability is truly shameful and of Banana Republic proportions.

  • @hughgordon6435
    @hughgordon6435 Рік тому +3

    Certain "journalists" need to soul search

  • @MarkHarrison733
    @MarkHarrison733 Рік тому

    The drunk fans charged the gate, causing the deaths.