I hope that one day we can look at the greatest wrestling game ever made, and remember the dark ages when we were asking for it to include more than 12 face types.
I've been waiting for a game like this for about 30 years and the only thing close to it is Fire Pro Wrestling World, No Mercy and Here Comes The Pain. Then there are plenty of awesome Japanese wrestling games, but only in Japanese.
Just wanna say thanks to everyone taking the time to watch this, especially if you subscribe, like, or contribute to the discussion. I really appreciate the feedback. I'm starting to feel like I'm on to something here.
I feel a great middle point for this game would be look at the older SvR or Smackdown series. They had limits, yet provided the variations needed to create something distinct yet within the confines. Hell people still are creating modern wrestlers in here comes the pain. Just simple things like generic logos to manipulate to add some depth to a face or recreate certain attire parts would majorly help. Look at something like WWE 12 to 2k14. They had limits yet we've seen so many great creations done with some limits.
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
Devs "You say you want more CAW parts. What do you mean? We gave you 3 types of singlets with next to no customization abilities and shorts with like 20 different flags on them. What more could you want‽"
This popped into my feed randomly and I have to say this is a really well thought out and presented video, great work sir. I wish either AEW or Yukes would reach out to the community to roadmap these things. There is a wealth of knowledge and a huge ammount of potential with Fight forever or any potential sequal. It just feels like it's falling on deaf ears at the moment. Hopefully that changes!
Thank you @Defract! Your WWE CAWs are incredible. I'd love to see this game improve to the point where people aren't embarrassed to create and share stuff in it. For now, I'm playing Fight Forever on the highest difficulty: creative advocate. Zyddie did say that he watched it and forwarded it in one of his feedback reports, so I'm taking it as far as I can as an a regular gamer with no influence :)
I really do want this game to succeed. The game play is great, it's everything else that brings it down. Fingers cross the devs push forward and make this the best game can be
You nailed pretty much everything 🎉 Even just making all the parts from the AEW in game roster available, with the ability to change the colors, would open so many possibilities already
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
lots of great ideas! I'd probably put another 20 hours into Fight Forever if they just gave us the option to pallette swap the attires for people on the roster
I honestly think that even the stuff that's deemed "Unrealistic" is more than reasonable with a company like Yuke's behind things. Especially when a lot of that stuff, we got in the SVR games that came out 15 years ago. That being said, you nailed this video, I don't think there was a time that I absolutely didn't agree. One thing that I would throw in, as a way to improve the sharing option, is a "Code" feature for the creations kinda like how they did it in the Mass Effect games. You could share your Shepard across between PS and Xbox by entering a code at the bottom of the creation menu in Mass Effect, and it would set your Commander the exactly how it was when the code was made. That would be a way to get around the issue of community creations, and not having to constantly go back and forth between looking at the formula and looking at the options to make sure you selected the correct ones.
That's brilliant! Someone else suggested QR codes which I thought was a great idea but I wasn't sure how it would work to get the scanned formula back into the game. Sounds like the Mass Effect model would be perfect.
I feel I'd really get into the AEW game, but CAW Might be one of the most important features of wrestling games for me. Sadly their current CAW system is just too bare.
I know this is the first AEW game for major consoles and PC platforms so it's normal for building a foundation for future games in this franchise. But this is not Yuke's first wrestling game as they have been making wrestling games for many a decade now. So I would think they could just copy and paste the best Creation features, among others, from the old WWE games into AEW FF with some improvements where needed. Sadly still can't use our own music like in the XBox360/PS3 days either.
They built this game from the ground up in Unreal, so even though they've done these things before they're kinda starting back at the beginning here. I think they would've come closer if they had more time/money/etc.
The CAW has always been my favorite part of wrestling games . Number one is , I love using my creativity to create my own characters/persona and move sets . I would legit buy a game where you had to create your whole roster ! But that is my idea of fun . Two is to create wrestlers who exist , but are not on the game . But mainly my first reason . It just adds so much for me personally .
Yeah, I love doing both too. If you haven't already you might want to take a look at Fire Pro Wrestling World. It's 2d - but you can in fact make a promotion and the entire roster/movesets/factions/arenas.
This really just absolutely nailed what would improve this game vastly for me. I like playing this game and I think it's fun, but the character creation is such a big portion of what gives wrestling games such long, long lives. I was even going through to make my own roster, but having to do a full Road to Elite for every single character really burned me out. I seem to recall community creations being something that were offered and rejected early on in the process, but brought back up near the end of development, so if there's any chance those can be implemented I think it would do so much for this game.
Love all your suggestions although I don’t think they’re going to add sliders but adding all the existing roster’s parts and allowing us to recolour them would be a game changer. The restrictions of items that can be put together are very annoying. They got a Bret Hart type costume but don’t let you put a jacket with it for example 🤯 Agree on the accessories being available as entrance only. Super annoying they’re not. No one wears glasses in a match. Just even put them all in the entrance attire section and make them available to set for entrance only or in ring too like you can with tops (including jackets as you could put a manager in a suit but they’d have no top ringside). Tattoos are a big problem too. There’s not a single option for full sleeves which tons of wrestlers have. Being able to use in game wrestlers’ tattoos would help a lot but allowing multiple tattoos to be selected would help too. Definitely should be able to change attires of existing wrestlers too and the street clothes options is a waste of time if you can’t use them in ring as nobody’s playing through RTE with every wrestler. Let’s hope they do something to improve it soon.
Really nice video! I have to admit my faults because a few days ago I absentmindedly watched the video and after the first screen of the 25 edits I thought "Ok, another person who wants an unrealistic overhaul of the mode". I took my time to watch it and I can say that your video is perfect, and I am not a CAW guy (even in wwe2k I don't like to use them). By the way, from a gameplay perspective, the last time I found a wrestling game as good, fun and satisfying as AEW:FF was WWE 2K14. I just hope they continue to support it, I mean TK constantly signs a lot of big names, they have big and fan favourites names like Edge, Samoa Joe, Castagnoli, Saraya etc. under contract... If they insist on pushing the development of this game, I think that any DLC would be an easy money maker. And with that money they could build a more solid CAW mode, new match types, new gears, arenas etc...
Well thank you for giving it 2 chances! I felt like I had to acknowledge the 'big ask' stuff upfront so people wouldn't get hung up on it. And I agree, the bell to bell gameplay is good. Fingers crossed for more support.
Great video mate. Captures pretty much all my thoughts on the CAW limitations. Recently played the Saints Row reboot and the character creation suite while limited in places felt infinitely more flexible. Struggled to go back to Fight Forever CAW
Great video! I hope AEW sit up and take notice. The idea of people being able to share the CAW formulas is great! I usually just download CAWs for my wrestling games.
I remember printing out gamefaqs translations and huge formulas for wrestlers in the SFPW 6 man scramble days. It does suck but with so few options it’s a lot easier than pre-network connected games
Also I always thought a good idea if you don’t want to go full blown community creations is to allow QR codes for caws that don’t require custom assets
I loved the video and you nailed it! I’m glad you didn’t come out bashing the game and saying it’s dead like a lot of UA-camrs. I feel like down the line you will see many of these things happening. I think maybe around Christmas or sooner we will get an update that will give us some of these updates.
Thanks! I think a lot of the frustration people have is justified. But personally I don't see anything to be gained looking at it from a negative perspective, especially since the goal is to get the devs to consider honing in on stuff wrestling gamers care about. I hope they do, but also in being realistic there is nothing officially announced at the moment so it could go either way.
What sucks is it seems say for the pin system, the gameplay in ring has been well received. This definitely seems like a learning experience for the dev team. While you don't need an extremely super in depth system like 2k games. There has to he a happy middle ground. Look at games like the Aki games, or the fire pro series. They had a certain confines yet provided enough tools for players to make it work. And work well at that.
I almost didn't subscribe because you have 69 subs. However, the feeling of wanting to improve a genre of game that you're passionate about hits hard to home.
CAW is a major reason people play wrestling games. If they just gave the option to create or uploading logos it would help immensely. They could just use all the wrestlers body's and outfits an allow people to color swap them would be better than what they have now.
How about the ability to import custom updated video titantrons of wrestlers from past, present and now? especially when fixing their entrances accurately.
I just want match options. Not necessarily types but let me set the rules that are basically standard on other games. Count out, dq, rope break, tornado options, falls count anywhere, etc I was honestly shocked when looking at match options the first time Edit: unlinking caw attributes/skills from RTE doesn’t seem unrealistic to me. At the least they can just make two pools of caws
@@tom_wears_glassesexactly! I immediately think it’s on purpose but I can’t fathom why. Honestly I think wrestling empire is probably the best implementation of match options. I’m a huge Fire pro fan but mdickie still wins there. Of course there’s KOC2 and ASPW that had some cool unique options (choose announcers and commenters, setup specific body health/damage, match crowd preferences, etc). I could go on and on
I bought this game for $80 and have only played it for a total of 5 hours. That’s almost 100% due to the trash CAW. This is a great video of what we needed.
@@tom_wears_glasses they’re very reminiscent of the aki games. 2 of my favorite things they had was interrupting moves which was huge for multi player matches with your friends… and till this day they have the best hell in a cell. You have space to fight ringside & you could even climb the cell from the inside. This was a great alternative to the smackdown franchise
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
Its insane to thing that WWF Attitude have a way better robust CAW System then AEW Fight Forever !!! My only cae in AEW is The Rock because he is the only one that look accurate to someone not in the game !!! But its missing a lot of Rock move like the People Elbow or ddt spit punch many more !!!
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
for me is the game play fix like submissions tag team fix and community creations . and move set pack .like fire pro wrestling game and wwe games is very important thank you
Thanks! I got Zyddie to include it in one of his feedback reports ... can't control if anyone watches it or does anything but I'm pushing it as far as I can.
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
I’d also love an easier way to unlock everyone. I know that’s part of the fun but I’m old now and don’t have as much time as I didwhen I was playing VPW and No Mercy for hours. Someone send me save data or something 🙏
Yea I rarely play as actual wrestlers or have mained actual wrestlers, I always create a certain handful of wrestlers/characters in any game and build that character up. FF really put me off with that super limited CAW feature. Tried to create so Asian wrestkers and they literally all have the same face 😂
17:09 - Had to fire up the game to see something and what would the purpose of copying a ring attire over to entrance attire do if the ring attire is always part of the entrance attire? If your ring attire is a pair of trunks, kneepads, and boots, you have that on in your entrance. 18:04 - Using the left and right directions on the left joystick lets you cycle through moves faster.
17:09 - The purpose of copying a ring attire to an entrance attire (17:09) would only be valuable if they also implemented 18 Set Entrance Attire Separately (16:27). Because then you'd have more control over both (so you could do stuff like using suit jackets for in-ring or wearing sunglasses only for entrances), but without 'copy to' it would create the annoyance of having to re-make the entrance attire every time. So if they implemented both we'd get more flexibility without sacrificing convenience. 18:04 - True! But even the fast cycle still takes a very long time to go from the top of the list to the middle/bottom.
Good ideas on making the creation suite better in AEW. Sadly if they cannot meet the standards set by WWE 2k or even Fire pro series in terms of options then its going to always be sub par. Especially for those who create their own wrestlers and Efeds. And they charged a full $60 for the game. A game that they should have charged only $29.99 to $39.99 for. At least those prices it would have lessened the blow of much of the criticism. I also feel there is a disconnect between AEW and Yukes. It comes down to how much Tony Khan is willing to spend. And THQ wanting to make a game that they can be proud of as a company. I knew that the game was going to have issues. When Kenny Omega and Cody Rhodes was trying to lower expectations 2 yrs before the game came out. And AEW was marketing the game as an "alternative". To more sensible and long time consumers. Saying something is going to be an "alternative" is akin to saying your product is at best a good knock off or at worst just a sub par derivative product. Sadly for the the AEW game its the latter for now.
please @tomwearsglasses i have 2 questions .. first can I remove the hairband of nick jackson(young buck) ? i mean play without the hairband , second I saw trailers of mjf but he is without scarf , can i put his scarf ? please can yo check that for me
With Omega at the helm and him being a huge gamer , I assumed the AEW CAW options would be super awesome ! I guess I was wrong . I almost bought an updated system just for this game too . Because all I care to play are wrestling games . And the CAW is my favorite feature of wrestling games besides gameplay , but its neck and neck almost . I'm glad I saw this video first !!!!! I would have been extremely disappointed . I hear the gameplay is cool though .
Unfortunately, the creation tools are very weak at the moment. But keep an eye on this game. It does have good gameplay, they just need to build on it (roster, CAW options, match options). Despite all the 'game is dead' videos - they're still doing steady patches, pushing the game on tv, and there's rumors of season 2 content. Hopefully that means more than just paid roster DLC, but until somebody goes on record it's just hope and speculation.
This game and the teams behind it have so far been extremely mod friendly. They even host mod discussions on the official AEW Games Discord. They're 1000% more supportive than 2K in that aspect. If you're on PC, just hang out and keep an eye on Nexusmods and LynchReborn on Twitter.
@@tom_wears_glasses unfortunately right now installing mods will replace assets instead of adding assets so it is not really mod friendly, it is just comparatively more open than the 2k games which are less in urgent need of adding content.
It should be the obvious. That’s like a new phone dropping and forgetting to add a camera, bluetooth, touch screen, internet, App Store, flashlight…. Those are all the essentials
Your ideas are awesome but I hate to be the pessimist dude when I say I believe they specifically designed the game to "force" DLC purchases and that won't change in the near future. The lack of options was done on purpose IMO, not due to a lack of time. With character packs first announced as DLCs I knew they would make the CAW aspect of the game as limited as possible. Overall they went the easy way for themselves and made it as difficult as possible for people to make more of what the game offered. I've been a AEW fan before the first Dynamite aired on TV, watched the free PPVs and all that... I didn't fall for the trap though, and I'm glad I didn't. Hopefully they turn this game upside down in the future but I wouldn't keep my hopes up too much.
I think it's fair and justified to pessimistic about the game. As far as what we'll get in the future - all that's confirmed is another fix patch and that they're working with a third party on the Steam audio issue. Even Season 2 paid DLC is still speculation. But whether they've figured it out or not yet, they'll make more DLC money by boosting the game's sales and generating continuing interest. Which is only gonna happen if they add more engaging content (options, match types, creative assets, etc.). People that skipped or dropped the game aren't gonna buy more character DLC if they don't have a reason to load up the game in the first place.
Do you mean CAWs or the regular roster? For CAWs - you can equip a shirt from 'Tops' from Entrance Attire - then it'll ask you if you want to wear it in the ring also. It's confusing. If you mean regular roster members - I made a mod that gives you more interesting shirts on PC but I'm hoping they make it a regular feature for everyone.
Thanks! I really enjoy your videos as well. I especially appreciate your Jurassic Express and FTR tag setup videos - saved me a lot of time because I agonize over putting together movesets :)
@@tom_wears_glasses thank you! Your video is incredibly thoughtful, and I hope it gets on the radar of folks at AEW Games, THQ, or Yukes. You’ve succinctly laid out everything that could overhaul the creation suite with minimal effort. Again, great job!
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
I think the biggest problem here is we've all been spoilt rotten with the WWE 2k games and let's be honest the options available in the WWE games creation suite is insanely good, yes I no it has its issues to but when you go back to a 2k game to create wrestlers arenas championships move sets it always feels like you are only limited by your imagination whereas AEW feels like your limited because you are I honestly haven't touched it since launch and probably won't again I went back to the WWE games or no mercy on the good old N64
No Mercy is 4life. Right now Fight Forever has a double-problem of having a limited roster AND limited creation tools to supplement compared to 2K games. Not sure if you saw the recent Season 2 preview pic on the AEW Games twitter but it does hint that they're going to add more CAW attires and options. How much and how soon is another story. You might wanna give it like 6 months and check to see if they've added anything interesting.
Actually this is false, I’m not asking for or expecting 2K levels of customization. You could do way more with PS2 & GC era Creation suites but the tools simply aren’t here in this game.
CAW has to be redone and if they can't do that, then make a sequel/reboot and focus on things people want instead of battle royales and other junk nobody asked for, and keep Kenny Omega away from the development team, his ideas are what destroyed this game and he should be called out for this
@@ezanderson8834 there’s literally nothing to do. I knew from the midnight reviews when I saw only 7 match types and almost half of them are only 1 on 1. I grew up playing the absolute panicle of wrestling games with basically every match possible & variations. No way I can do anything but that.
@Mannyisdatnigga well they can allow us to mess with wrestling attires no mercy was awesome they didn't have too many match types. Also not being able to invite whoever you want to stadium stampede is just crazy and allow ppl to Play mini games online simple things would improve this game so much
@@ezanderson8834 you’re not factoring that 3D wrestling gaming was still at its inception. The first one came in 1998 wwf warzone. By the time no mercy came out we actually had a good amount of matches. The only thing we were truly missing from the product at the time was hell in a cell & tables. No mercy literally pushed the 64 to its limit.. we’re in 2023 on 4 gaming generations better. No excuse to have less match types than no mercy. Lol omg don’t get me started on stadium stampede. Easily the worst battle royale I’ve seen. It’s a complete disconnect from the core gameplay. There’s literally no wrestling. Just a bunch of running & strike spamming. Plus it’s filled with over 90 percent bots.. and the reason you can invite because it’s a solo experience. If you could invite you could just team on solo players and that’s not fair. What they could’ve done is make a duos or trios mode but that still wouldn’t compensate for the terrible non skilled gameplay the mode has to offer
Your point outs are valid but in Yuke's defense, its their first wrestling game since WWE 13, they lost their assets to 2K due to the license loss and had to rebuild from scratch for AEW so its basically exactly like WWF Attitude and No Mercy and WrestleMania 2000. Creation is there but limited AF.
That's not correct. Yukes (the developers) were making the games up until 2K19. ThqNordic and THQ are not the same company. The latter was the publishers of the WWE games until WWE 13. The former does not have all of the same staff as the original.
So you’re comparing aew to 2 wrestling games that came out in 1999. Wow dude !! Gaming has evolved so much in those 24 years. There’s over 2 decades worth of wrestling game templates to follow & all they came up with was 7 match types, a boring story mode & the worst creation suite ever after 3-4 years of development. There is no excuse for that at all !
@@tom_wears_glassesthey didn’t though, did they? Modders had to get around things like EAC but thankfully since it’s a well known engine there’s some preexisting knowledge. If they did do something to help with modding I must have missed it and am curious
They give mixed messages because the pre-launch FAQ said they don't but the day after that Zyddie said they do. Basically, they don't support it in the sense of offering modding tools or have like an in-game mod workshop thing. But they do host and moderate two modding forums in the official AEW Games Discord - one for Modding Discussion and another for Modding Promotion. So, we can do whatever we want as long as we figure it out (which already covers everything from making characters and arenas to changing options and match types). My big concern would be that if they supported it on a higher level they might also be liable to moderate it - which would mean no WWE/NJPW/etc. content and that would effectively kill it. I think what we have is a pretty fair system.
I wanted to like this game but I regret even buying it I'm never touching it again, disappointed with Yukes. Not only the Caw is disappointing the gameplay is pretty bad too.matches are too short I beat a guy with just a punch ect. AEW fight forever is trash also more freedom for Caw and stats are nice not everyone has the time to unlock stats for every single stats for CAWs. Too bad I bought the game on playstion and can't get a refund.
The Creation suite in this wrestling game is probably the worst I've seen for any wrestling game for this generation of consoles it's the worst very disappointing
The fact that AEW can't see their game is shit, and they are actively asking their fans to spell out what is wrong with the game is funny. Saying you have 100 slots doesn't make the suite better 😂😂 you can't even face morph and that's been in WWE games since the PS1
The lack of facial features is soul crushing and the lack of facial fair is pathetic. They could just add all the in game characters hair and facial hair would change the game. It doesn't even have ponytails. That's weird af. The didn't give af 😂
No amount of DLC will save this abomination of a game. The lack of match types was the final nail in the coffin. At least you have dancing minigames LOL
Couldn’t agree more. How the hell are there only 7 match types. We had more in no mercy 23 years ago.. and to make it worst there’s more mini games than match types lol
I hope that one day we can look at the greatest wrestling game ever made, and remember the dark ages when we were asking for it to include more than 12 face types.
I've been waiting for a game like this for about 30 years and the only thing close to it is Fire Pro Wrestling World, No Mercy and Here Comes The Pain. Then there are plenty of awesome Japanese wrestling games, but only in Japanese.
This game will never be good, keep coping. ❤ then, now, forever.
You gotta be trolling if you’re calling this the greatest wrestling game ever. This is a beta not a full game lol
@@mdkane1921the Japanese games are worth having. Find a way. Either grab the old consoles or possibly through an emulator.
Fire Pro Wrestling World already exists...
Just wanna say thanks to everyone taking the time to watch this, especially if you subscribe, like, or contribute to the discussion. I really appreciate the feedback. I'm starting to feel like I'm on to something here.
I feel a great middle point for this game would be look at the older SvR or Smackdown series. They had limits, yet provided the variations needed to create something distinct yet within the confines. Hell people still are creating modern wrestlers in here comes the pain. Just simple things like generic logos to manipulate to add some depth to a face or recreate certain attire parts would majorly help. Look at something like WWE 12 to 2k14. They had limits yet we've seen so many great creations done with some limits.
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
Devs "You say you want more CAW parts. What do you mean? We gave you 3 types of singlets with next to no customization abilities and shorts with like 20 different flags on them. What more could you want‽"
This popped into my feed randomly and I have to say this is a really well thought out and presented video, great work sir. I wish either AEW or Yukes would reach out to the community to roadmap these things. There is a wealth of knowledge and a huge ammount of potential with Fight forever or any potential sequal. It just feels like it's falling on deaf ears at the moment. Hopefully that changes!
Thank you @Defract! Your WWE CAWs are incredible. I'd love to see this game improve to the point where people aren't embarrassed to create and share stuff in it. For now, I'm playing Fight Forever on the highest difficulty: creative advocate. Zyddie did say that he watched it and forwarded it in one of his feedback reports, so I'm taking it as far as I can as an a regular gamer with no influence :)
I really do want this game to succeed. The game play is great, it's everything else that brings it down. Fingers cross the devs push forward and make this the best game can be
You nailed pretty much everything 🎉 Even just making all the parts from the AEW in game roster available, with the ability to change the colors, would open so many possibilities already
Right?! There's so many useful parts that are already in the game.
Exactly. This would be the easiest thing they could do to get people off their backs until they make other improvements/additions.
Exactly was thinking the same thing
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
Yes and not having to play road to elite to improve create a wrestlers would be good same with a universe type mode.
Use the storage from unnecessary mini games and put into better caw and more wrestlers
😂😂😂😂😂
Ax's hair from Survivor Series 1990
😅😅😅😅😅
You got me good with that one.
lots of great ideas! I'd probably put another 20 hours into Fight Forever if they just gave us the option to pallette swap the attires for people on the roster
I honestly think that even the stuff that's deemed "Unrealistic" is more than reasonable with a company like Yuke's behind things. Especially when a lot of that stuff, we got in the SVR games that came out 15 years ago. That being said, you nailed this video, I don't think there was a time that I absolutely didn't agree.
One thing that I would throw in, as a way to improve the sharing option, is a "Code" feature for the creations kinda like how they did it in the Mass Effect games. You could share your Shepard across between PS and Xbox by entering a code at the bottom of the creation menu in Mass Effect, and it would set your Commander the exactly how it was when the code was made. That would be a way to get around the issue of community creations, and not having to constantly go back and forth between looking at the formula and looking at the options to make sure you selected the correct ones.
That's brilliant! Someone else suggested QR codes which I thought was a great idea but I wasn't sure how it would work to get the scanned formula back into the game. Sounds like the Mass Effect model would be perfect.
I feel I'd really get into the AEW game, but CAW Might be one of the most important features of wrestling games for me. Sadly their current CAW system is just too bare.
Hope all of this comes man really want this game to be great
ALL of these suggestions are great and should be implemented at some point. Hopefully someone from THQ Nordic or Yukes see's this video. Good stuff.
Thanks! I'm pushing it as far as I can from the outside
Fantastic articulation and critique, thank you for taking the time to do this. Hope @AEW GAMES is listening...
I know this is the first AEW game for major consoles and PC platforms so it's normal for building a foundation for future games in this franchise. But this is not Yuke's first wrestling game as they have been making wrestling games for many a decade now. So I would think they could just copy and paste the best Creation features, among others, from the old WWE games into AEW FF with some improvements where needed. Sadly still can't use our own music like in the XBox360/PS3 days either.
They built this game from the ground up in Unreal, so even though they've done these things before they're kinda starting back at the beginning here. I think they would've come closer if they had more time/money/etc.
I really liked this video. Love when gamers give constructive criticism. Instead of just the typical "game bad" rage clickbait.
Thanks! Yeah, I'm honestly surprised UA-cam has been recommending this since it doesn't have an angry title/thumbnail.
The CAW has always been my favorite part of wrestling games . Number one is , I love using my creativity to create my own characters/persona and move sets . I would legit buy a game where you had to create your whole roster ! But that is my idea of fun .
Two is to create wrestlers who exist , but are not on the game . But mainly my first reason . It just adds so much for me personally .
Yeah, I love doing both too. If you haven't already you might want to take a look at Fire Pro Wrestling World. It's 2d - but you can in fact make a promotion and the entire roster/movesets/factions/arenas.
This really just absolutely nailed what would improve this game vastly for me. I like playing this game and I think it's fun, but the character creation is such a big portion of what gives wrestling games such long, long lives. I was even going through to make my own roster, but having to do a full Road to Elite for every single character really burned me out. I seem to recall community creations being something that were offered and rejected early on in the process, but brought back up near the end of development, so if there's any chance those can be implemented I think it would do so much for this game.
If they do any more updates, I hope they focus on the fan feedback and build in more of the things like this that add longevity to the experience.
Love all your suggestions although I don’t think they’re going to add sliders but adding all the existing roster’s parts and allowing us to recolour them would be a game changer. The restrictions of items that can be put together are very annoying. They got a Bret Hart type costume but don’t let you put a jacket with it for example 🤯
Agree on the accessories being available as entrance only. Super annoying they’re not. No one wears glasses in a match. Just even put them all in the entrance attire section and make them available to set for entrance only or in ring too like you can with tops (including jackets as you could put a manager in a suit but they’d have no top ringside).
Tattoos are a big problem too. There’s not a single option for full sleeves which tons of wrestlers have. Being able to use in game wrestlers’ tattoos would help a lot but allowing multiple tattoos to be selected would help too.
Definitely should be able to change attires of existing wrestlers too and the street clothes options is a waste of time if you can’t use them in ring as nobody’s playing through RTE with every wrestler.
Let’s hope they do something to improve it soon.
Yeah, these are good examples. Let's hope!
Really nice video! I have to admit my faults because a few days ago I absentmindedly watched the video and after the first screen of the 25 edits I thought "Ok, another person who wants an unrealistic overhaul of the mode".
I took my time to watch it and I can say that your video is perfect, and I am not a CAW guy (even in wwe2k I don't like to use them).
By the way, from a gameplay perspective, the last time I found a wrestling game as good, fun and satisfying as AEW:FF was WWE 2K14.
I just hope they continue to support it, I mean TK constantly signs a lot of big names, they have big and fan favourites names like Edge, Samoa Joe, Castagnoli, Saraya etc. under contract... If they insist on pushing the development of this game, I think that any DLC would be an easy money maker.
And with that money they could build a more solid CAW mode, new match types, new gears, arenas etc...
Well thank you for giving it 2 chances! I felt like I had to acknowledge the 'big ask' stuff upfront so people wouldn't get hung up on it. And I agree, the bell to bell gameplay is good. Fingers crossed for more support.
Great video mate. Captures pretty much all my thoughts on the CAW limitations. Recently played the Saints Row reboot and the character creation suite while limited in places felt infinitely more flexible. Struggled to go back to Fight Forever CAW
I haven't played the reboot but I used to love messing with my character in Saints Row 3.
Agree 100%. Love that you were realistic with your ideas.
Great video! I hope AEW sit up and take notice. The idea of people being able to share the CAW formulas is great! I usually just download CAWs for my wrestling games.
Thanks! It's a lot of work to type out the formulas - I think more people would share if it was easier.
I remember printing out gamefaqs translations and huge formulas for wrestlers in the SFPW 6 man scramble days. It does suck but with so few options it’s a lot easier than pre-network connected games
Also I always thought a good idea if you don’t want to go full blown community creations is to allow QR codes for caws that don’t require custom assets
Great Video! Send this to Zyddie and AEW GAMES and THQ! Very Well Done!
He said he watched it and it was good - next time we're both on at the same time I'm hoping to actually talk about the ideas.
I agree with everything you said. Please fix this game. It's fun to play already.
I loved the video and you nailed it! I’m glad you didn’t come out bashing the game and saying it’s dead like a lot of UA-camrs. I feel like down the line you will see many of these things happening. I think maybe around Christmas or sooner we will get an update that will give us some of these updates.
Thanks! I think a lot of the frustration people have is justified. But personally I don't see anything to be gained looking at it from a negative perspective, especially since the goal is to get the devs to consider honing in on stuff wrestling gamers care about. I hope they do, but also in being realistic there is nothing officially announced at the moment so it could go either way.
What sucks is it seems say for the pin system, the gameplay in ring has been well received. This definitely seems like a learning experience for the dev team. While you don't need an extremely super in depth system like 2k games. There has to he a happy middle ground. Look at games like the Aki games, or the fire pro series. They had a certain confines yet provided enough tools for players to make it work. And work well at that.
You make great points in both of your comments. I'm hoping the dev team is learning how important flexibility is to making a wrestling game great.
I almost didn't subscribe because you have 69 subs. However, the feeling of wanting to improve a genre of game that you're passionate about hits hard to home.
Thank you - now my next goal is gonna be 169
I don't understand how the Devs did NOT anticipate the CAW mode would be a major selling point.
Its has NEVER NOT BEEN a major selling point!
Not even Devs, Kenny Omega who is a big gamer should of had this on lock before they even started on RtE story mode
@@distinguishedallureproduct879he was too busy focused on mini games apparently. Like who the hell ever asked for mini games in a wrestling game ?
CAW is a major reason people play wrestling games. If they just gave the option to create or uploading logos it would help immensely. They could just use all the wrestlers body's and outfits an allow people to color swap them would be better than what they have now.
Such a great and well done video thank you SIr. I hope Zyddie will see this and we can get the wrestling game we all want to love.
Share Love not Hate
How about the ability to import custom updated video titantrons of wrestlers from past, present and now? especially when fixing their entrances accurately.
That would be cool! But if they did allow uploading I'd want music too.
If they improved the caw system the game will breathe again in no time
I just want match options. Not necessarily types but let me set the rules that are basically standard on other games. Count out, dq, rope break, tornado options, falls count anywhere, etc I was honestly shocked when looking at match options the first time
Edit: unlinking caw attributes/skills from RTE doesn’t seem unrealistic to me. At the least they can just make two pools of caws
And most of those are in the game already in RTE! We just need an options menu so we can access them.
@@tom_wears_glassesexactly! I immediately think it’s on purpose but I can’t fathom why.
Honestly I think wrestling empire is probably the best implementation of match options. I’m a huge Fire pro fan but mdickie still wins there. Of course there’s KOC2 and ASPW that had some cool unique options (choose announcers and commenters, setup specific body health/damage, match crowd preferences, etc). I could go on and on
I bought this game for $80 and have only played it for a total of 5 hours. That’s almost 100% due to the trash CAW. This is a great video of what we needed.
No mercy let’s you unmask Kane and play with bald look
I expect 25 years on the same options for roster models
outstanding video. i love this. you laid it out perfectly.
My answer to the lack luster caw system is make it like wwe Day of reckoning caw mode
I missed out on the Day of Reckoning games since I didn't have a Gamecube, but I wanna go back and check them out.
@@tom_wears_glassesplease do. They’re probably the most underrated wrestling games ever. WM 19 was good too although the story mode was terrible lol
Ok, I'm sold. Thanks!
@@tom_wears_glasses they’re very reminiscent of the aki games. 2 of my favorite things they had was interrupting moves which was huge for multi player matches with your friends… and till this day they have the best hell in a cell. You have space to fight ringside & you could even climb the cell from the inside. This was a great alternative to the smackdown franchise
What they really need to add is a full to the ring entrance, it's 2023-24 and games from 98-2001 on N64 had full entrances.
Great video & exactly what needs to be done !!
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
Its insane to thing that WWF Attitude have a way better robust CAW System then AEW Fight Forever !!! My only cae in AEW is The Rock because he is the only one that look accurate to someone not in the game !!! But its missing a lot of Rock move like the People Elbow or ddt spit punch many more !!!
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
Add all in game attire to caw parts 100% i didnt know why they didnt do that on day 1 considering they have Kenny’s gear in CAW
for me is the game play fix like submissions tag team fix and community creations . and move set pack .like fire pro wrestling game and wwe games is very important thank you
This is really really good! Hope it gets to the right eyes and ears at AEW.
Thanks! I got Zyddie to include it in one of his feedback reports ... can't control if anyone watches it or does anything but I'm pushing it as far as I can.
Gave up on Fight Forever. Looking foward to Ultra Pro Wrestling. I feel like this is more of what we were all waiting for in a wrestling game.
Ultra Pro looks awesome - it's just gonna be a while before it comes out
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
I’d also love an easier way to unlock everyone. I know that’s part of the fun but I’m old now and don’t have as much time as I didwhen I was playing VPW and No Mercy for hours. Someone send me save data or something 🙏
see fire pro wrestling--that's it. just do that.
Great video. Lets hope THQ and Yukes comes through
Yea I rarely play as actual wrestlers or have mained actual wrestlers, I always create a certain handful of wrestlers/characters in any game and build that character up. FF really put me off with that super limited CAW feature. Tried to create so Asian wrestkers and they literally all have the same face 😂
If they only fix one thing in CAW I hope it's that because ... yeah ... it borders on disconcerting
WWE 2k23 you can do all of this
17:09 - Had to fire up the game to see something and what would the purpose of copying a ring attire over to entrance attire do if the ring attire is always part of the entrance attire? If your ring attire is a pair of trunks, kneepads, and boots, you have that on in your entrance.
18:04 - Using the left and right directions on the left joystick lets you cycle through moves faster.
17:09 - The purpose of copying a ring attire to an entrance attire (17:09) would only be valuable if they also implemented 18 Set Entrance Attire Separately (16:27). Because then you'd have more control over both (so you could do stuff like using suit jackets for in-ring or wearing sunglasses only for entrances), but without 'copy to' it would create the annoyance of having to re-make the entrance attire every time. So if they implemented both we'd get more flexibility without sacrificing convenience.
18:04 - True! But even the fast cycle still takes a very long time to go from the top of the list to the middle/bottom.
Its sad that they need people to explain this to them. And all things suggested are not to difficult to implement at all
Earned a Sub.. Great video bro
Crossplay is really needed. I match with bots all the time 😢
Good ideas on making the creation suite better in AEW. Sadly if they cannot meet the standards set by WWE 2k or even Fire pro series in terms of options then its going to always be sub par. Especially for those who create their own wrestlers and Efeds.
And they charged a full $60 for the game. A game that they should have charged only $29.99 to $39.99 for. At least those prices it would have lessened the blow of much of the criticism.
I also feel there is a disconnect between AEW and Yukes. It comes down to how much Tony Khan is willing to spend. And THQ wanting to make a game that they can be proud of as a company.
I knew that the game was going to have issues. When Kenny Omega and Cody Rhodes was trying to lower expectations 2 yrs before the game came out. And AEW was marketing the game as an "alternative". To more sensible and long time consumers. Saying something is going to be an "alternative" is akin to saying your product is at best a good knock off or at worst just a sub par derivative product.
Sadly for the the AEW game its the latter for now.
please @tomwearsglasses i have 2 questions .. first can I remove the hairband of nick jackson(young buck) ? i mean play without the hairband , second I saw trailers of mjf but he is without scarf , can i put his scarf ? please can yo check that for me
(1) Right now, no unfortunately. (2) I think he comes out wearing the scarf if he doesn't have a title, but no scarf if he does have a title.
@@tom_wears_glasses thanks for answer tom
Keep up the excellent work.
👍
With Omega at the helm and him being a huge gamer , I assumed the AEW CAW options would be super awesome ! I guess I was wrong . I almost bought an updated system just for this game too . Because all I care to play are wrestling games . And the CAW is my favorite feature of wrestling games besides gameplay , but its neck and neck almost . I'm glad I saw this video first !!!!! I would have been extremely disappointed . I hear the gameplay is cool though .
Unfortunately, the creation tools are very weak at the moment. But keep an eye on this game. It does have good gameplay, they just need to build on it (roster, CAW options, match options). Despite all the 'game is dead' videos - they're still doing steady patches, pushing the game on tv, and there's rumors of season 2 content. Hopefully that means more than just paid roster DLC, but until somebody goes on record it's just hope and speculation.
@@tom_wears_glasses Oh yeah , I still want to play the game for sure .
When the teacher tells the class “Your project can be about anything” 🤣
posted this on the steam forums
Thank you! I'm hoping Zyddie checks it out and maybe even uses it to start an internal conversation.
open it way up to modders on PC and you will have all that stuff in 3 months.
This game and the teams behind it have so far been extremely mod friendly. They even host mod discussions on the official AEW Games Discord. They're 1000% more supportive than 2K in that aspect. If you're on PC, just hang out and keep an eye on Nexusmods and LynchReborn on Twitter.
@@tom_wears_glasses unfortunately right now installing mods will replace assets instead of adding assets so it is not really mod friendly, it is just comparatively more open than the 2k games which are less in urgent need of adding content.
You would think all of this would be Day 0 additions especially from Yukes they were doing this since HereComesThePain 😮
It should be the obvious. That’s like a new phone dropping and forgetting to add a camera, bluetooth, touch screen, internet, App Store, flashlight…. Those are all the essentials
Your ideas are awesome but I hate to be the pessimist dude when I say I believe they specifically designed the game to "force" DLC purchases and that won't change in the near future. The lack of options was done on purpose IMO, not due to a lack of time. With character packs first announced as DLCs I knew they would make the CAW aspect of the game as limited as possible. Overall they went the easy way for themselves and made it as difficult as possible for people to make more of what the game offered. I've been a AEW fan before the first Dynamite aired on TV, watched the free PPVs and all that... I didn't fall for the trap though, and I'm glad I didn't. Hopefully they turn this game upside down in the future but I wouldn't keep my hopes up too much.
I think it's fair and justified to pessimistic about the game. As far as what we'll get in the future - all that's confirmed is another fix patch and that they're working with a third party on the Steam audio issue. Even Season 2 paid DLC is still speculation.
But whether they've figured it out or not yet, they'll make more DLC money by boosting the game's sales and generating continuing interest. Which is only gonna happen if they add more engaging content (options, match types, creative assets, etc.). People that skipped or dropped the game aren't gonna buy more character DLC if they don't have a reason to load up the game in the first place.
this CAW creation is like in the AKI games, but i doesnt translate well into yukes
Appreciate the graduate level history lesson however, I'm seven minutes in and I haven't learned anything...
I just want to be able to have you wear shirts in the ring they have wrestlers in the game that do it so why can't we
Do you mean CAWs or the regular roster? For CAWs - you can equip a shirt from 'Tops' from Entrance Attire - then it'll ask you if you want to wear it in the ring also. It's confusing. If you mean regular roster members - I made a mod that gives you more interesting shirts on PC but I'm hoping they make it a regular feature for everyone.
Great video!
Thanks! I really enjoy your videos as well. I especially appreciate your Jurassic Express and FTR tag setup videos - saved me a lot of time because I agonize over putting together movesets :)
@@tom_wears_glasses thank you! Your video is incredibly thoughtful, and I hope it gets on the radar of folks at AEW Games, THQ, or Yukes. You’ve succinctly laid out everything that could overhaul the creation suite with minimal effort. Again, great job!
Hey I really enjoy youtube and willing to make a diffence in my life and just do things I love to do within my life like making youtube and supporting my family
I think the biggest problem here is we've all been spoilt rotten with the WWE 2k games and let's be honest the options available in the WWE games creation suite is insanely good, yes I no it has its issues to but when you go back to a 2k game to create wrestlers arenas championships move sets it always feels like you are only limited by your imagination whereas AEW feels like your limited because you are I honestly haven't touched it since launch and probably won't again I went back to the WWE games or no mercy on the good old N64
No Mercy is 4life. Right now Fight Forever has a double-problem of having a limited roster AND limited creation tools to supplement compared to 2K games. Not sure if you saw the recent Season 2 preview pic on the AEW Games twitter but it does hint that they're going to add more CAW attires and options. How much and how soon is another story. You might wanna give it like 6 months and check to see if they've added anything interesting.
Actually this is false, I’m not asking for or expecting 2K levels of customization. You could do way more with PS2 & GC era Creation suites but the tools simply aren’t here in this game.
I seriously don't understand how the developer thought that this CAW system was good enough. It really isn't even close to the bare minimum.
CAW has to be redone and if they can't do that, then make a sequel/reboot and focus on things people want instead of battle royales and other junk nobody asked for, and keep Kenny Omega away from the development team, his ideas are what destroyed this game and he should be called out for this
How can they have an nWo t-shirt in the game?!
You can do a better Brody King with Tattoos & the Hakushi Body Paint
Its wild you cant wear kneepads with the kickpads.
They basically put out a demo and got their core fans that over paid for this
And their reply is “it’s only their first game” or “it’s only been 3 months”…
@@MR.__G yea or now it's probably nothing else to do or maybe 🤦🏾♂️
@@ezanderson8834 there’s literally nothing to do. I knew from the midnight reviews when I saw only 7 match types and almost half of them are only 1 on 1. I grew up playing the absolute panicle of wrestling games with basically every match possible & variations. No way I can do anything but that.
@Mannyisdatnigga well they can allow us to mess with wrestling attires no mercy was awesome they didn't have too many match types. Also not being able to invite whoever you want to stadium stampede is just crazy and allow ppl to Play mini games online simple things would improve this game so much
@@ezanderson8834 you’re not factoring that 3D wrestling gaming was still at its inception. The first one came in 1998 wwf warzone. By the time no mercy came out we actually had a good amount of matches. The only thing we were truly missing from the product at the time was hell in a cell & tables. No mercy literally pushed the 64 to its limit.. we’re in 2023 on 4 gaming generations better. No excuse to have less match types than no mercy.
Lol omg don’t get me started on stadium stampede. Easily the worst battle royale I’ve seen. It’s a complete disconnect from the core gameplay. There’s literally no wrestling. Just a bunch of running & strike spamming. Plus it’s filled with over 90 percent bots.. and the reason you can invite because it’s a solo experience. If you could invite you could just team on solo players and that’s not fair. What they could’ve done is make a duos or trios mode but that still wouldn’t compensate for the terrible non skilled gameplay the mode has to offer
Your point outs are valid but in Yuke's defense, its their first wrestling game since WWE 13, they lost their assets to 2K due to the license loss and had to rebuild from scratch for AEW so its basically exactly like WWF Attitude and No Mercy and WrestleMania 2000. Creation is there but limited AF.
That's not correct. Yukes (the developers) were making the games up until 2K19. ThqNordic and THQ are not the same company. The latter was the publishers of the WWE games until WWE 13. The former does not have all of the same staff as the original.
So you’re comparing aew to 2 wrestling games that came out in 1999. Wow dude !!
Gaming has evolved so much in those 24 years. There’s over 2 decades worth of wrestling game templates to follow & all they came up with was 7 match types, a boring story mode & the worst creation suite ever after 3-4 years of development. There is no excuse for that at all !
1:41 “Stwong Baed”
The games foundation is great, but lack caw stuff. Its fine if they release official wrestlers dlc, but at the same time update more. Lets see.
they should just open up the game to modders
They did (on PC)! It's one of the best things about the game.
@@tom_wears_glassesthey didn’t though, did they? Modders had to get around things like EAC but thankfully since it’s a well known engine there’s some preexisting knowledge. If they did do something to help with modding I must have missed it and am curious
They give mixed messages because the pre-launch FAQ said they don't but the day after that Zyddie said they do. Basically, they don't support it in the sense of offering modding tools or have like an in-game mod workshop thing. But they do host and moderate two modding forums in the official AEW Games Discord - one for Modding Discussion and another for Modding Promotion. So, we can do whatever we want as long as we figure it out (which already covers everything from making characters and arenas to changing options and match types). My big concern would be that if they supported it on a higher level they might also be liable to moderate it - which would mean no WWE/NJPW/etc. content and that would effectively kill it. I think what we have is a pretty fair system.
People are wanting it to be too much like WWE2k and thats not what they wanted.
Still waiting for the new dlc on switch
You should check again - AEW Games tweeted this morning that it's live.
In short, is not worth creating wrestlers for this game, only becuase you got to run them in a RTE mode.
Neeeed cross platform community creations 😭
There's no reason why AEW's CAW creation should be so horrendous. In this day and age there is no excuse for such a horrible CAW creation section.
I wanted to like this game but I regret even buying it I'm never touching it again, disappointed with Yukes. Not only the Caw is disappointing the gameplay is pretty bad too.matches are too short I beat a guy with just a punch ect. AEW fight forever is trash also more freedom for Caw and stats are nice not everyone has the time to unlock stats for every single stats for CAWs. Too bad I bought the game on playstion and can't get a refund.
Great video of things that will never happen. No one plays this game. They are not going to update anything anymore.
Most likely not. But I've been able to sleep better and think about other things since I uploaded this, so at least one good thing came from it :)
how tf did they managed to make a game with ps3 graphics in 2023 DOA
The Creation suite in this wrestling game is probably the worst I've seen for any wrestling game for this generation of consoles it's the worst very disappointing
The fact that AEW can't see their game is shit, and they are actively asking their fans to spell out what is wrong with the game is funny. Saying you have 100 slots doesn't make the suite better 😂😂 you can't even face morph and that's been in WWE games since the PS1
The lack of facial features is soul crushing and the lack of facial fair is pathetic. They could just add all the in game characters hair and facial hair would change the game. It doesn't even have ponytails. That's weird af. The didn't give af 😂
You cant fix it.
No amount of DLC will save this abomination of a game. The lack of match types was the final nail in the coffin. At least you have dancing minigames LOL
Couldn’t agree more. How the hell are there only 7 match types. We had more in no mercy 23 years ago.. and to make it worst there’s more mini games than match types lol