My husband who passed away in 2016 showed me this, quoting it's one of the most beautiful moments in live concert history ever. Smiling each time as I watch this, remembering him.
Sorry for your loss My brother passed away and this song was played at his funeral. I found it very hard to listen too till this year. He died at 15. I feel he still around me when i hear this song.
@@JB-xq8js Sorry to hear about his loss. I completely relate to that too, about feeling their presence when their music is being played. Its very strange as well, the feelings are difficult to comprehend.
The whole band was great here, but this girl's composure and calmness is commendable too. She didn't go crazy during the whole song and that allowed Bono to sing while lying down, which is a very difficult posture to sing. This is still one of the best live performances ever! U2 is love :)
Bueno, hasta donde yo sé, acostado es la mejor y más correcta forma para poder identificar la respiración diafragmáticamente, dónde no hay forma de equivocarse y respirar incorrectamente, dicho esto, pienso que se consigue una mejor forma de llegar a las notas sin esfuerzo
@@littlemissblackdress7587 ua-cam.com/video/nrDBqdWeB_U/v-deo.html my acoustic cover of the song for the person who introduced me to this Live version of the song. (Feel free to read description of video)
The girl at the end will never forget that moment for as long as she lives. I’m sure her story has already been passed down generations. 2022 is listening 💯
My dad passed away yesterday and now I'm making a playlist with all the songs he loved and I remember him by. This is one of them. Thank you dad for showing me the greatest artists of all times. Loved, missed and never forgotten 🤘🔥❤
Courage a vous 💖 , soyez fort(e) 🙏🌹 ,votre pere etait un saint homme j en suis sûr , cette chanson c est juste de l'amour pur et simple, elle donne envie d aimer, tellement... Je vous envoie tt mon Amour aussi , sans ambiguité , en Respect a vos mots et en pensant à votre pere aussi... J ai perdu le mien en 2008 et j ai eu bcp de mal après a surmonter son absence.. la musique aide beaucoup et elle nous comprends toujours 💖 Prenez soin de vous mon ami(e) 😘😘😘
Hey. This is also what I am doing now. It sucks because im crying. But at the same time, i am smiling. I hope you and your family got through it. I love you man.
I know it’s been a year since your Dad passed but I’m sure you still miss him very much, because I know all too well God bless you and I pray your doing well ❤
This young lady was blessed to live in a time in which she could just enjoy this one in a million experience instead of whipping out her phone to add to her social media
We all lived moment by moment back then. You had to make the best of every moment, and really be present and involved in it, because your memory of it was the only thing that would keep it alive. No cell phones in everyone's pocket, so that they could basically lose the entire moment by only focusing on recording it and trying to capture the perfect ridiculous "selfie", so that thousands of people could see the moment, but nobody really gets to really experience it.
Just imagine: your a great (female) fan of U2. And you are chosen to meet Bono on the stage to lie beside him and sing with him "With Or Without You", the most popular and most beautiful song of this band. Could there be possible something greater in your life?
How did we get from 1987 to 2023 soo damn fast, seems like yesterday we were young and innocent with our whole life a head of us!😪 Too all those amazing days we thought would last forever!💕
TBF, Larry Mullen Jr. (and possibly Adam Clayton in his in-ear monitors too) literally plays the song with a click track in his ear because of the synth programming / backing track that goes along with the song, but I get your point. ;)
I love this - brings a wee tear to my eye. Imagine being the girl and having this memory! Also the audience all in the moment with no fucking phone cameras!
Mi papá escuchaba rock y una de sus bandas favoritas era U2. Siempre me hacia escuchar de pequeña y ahora a mis 31 años, también escucho y las canto. Hace 5 años que se fue. En día que lo vi en su ataud, le puse esta canción, mis hermanos y yo lloramos. Fue la última vez que lo vi, le pusieron esta y otras 2 canciones que para mis hermanos quedaron marcados hacia mi papá, yo puse esta porque mi papi siempre me cantaba esta canción y la sentí especial para mi. Te amo papi y te extraño tanto. Esta canción me hace acordar tanto a ti y llorar al extrañarme.
This concert was held very very shortly after Bono’s father passed away. You can feel the heaviness throughout the whole show, especially during ‘Kite’. He really knows how to channel his energy. I couldn’t imagine performing after something like that. One of my favorite concert DVDs of all time from one of the best bands ever.
+MARK FERGUSON Hi I am 55 years old as well and I do feel the same way.Where are you living ? USA or England?I am hungarian born american, staying inHungary and I don't see the chance to meet the boys! Anyway it is good to hear my generations reaction to this greatness.Greetings: László
I'm 51 and have been to a number of U2 shows. I've also seen many other artists including Paul McCarney, Rod Stewart, Bob Seger and many other. No one..and I mean NO ONE, not even sir Paul comes close to U2. Go. You won't regret it.
U2 is my oldest love in music. Bono's voice, Edge's great sound and guitar playing and the solid and original spine of the band with Larry and Adam who are always forgotten... Just one of the best bands still active that never changed a band member and that was never afraid to take chances. I would love your input on a video of my first album. It got the attention of one of my heroes Joe Bouchard (ex bass player founding members of BÖC) who is following us on Soundcloud but returns from people who likes same music is always the best. If you have just 3 minutes to listen and a bit more to comment, that would mean the world to me. Keep rockin' :ua-cam.com/video/YJqmsXd8QH4/v-deo.html&t
Considerando de acuerdo a los comentarios, de que su padre acababa de fallecer, estaba sensible en ese tiempo, y en su voz se nota la nostalgia, como si se le fuera a quebrar la voz al punto del llanto, es el plus más importante para un artista, cantar con el alma, ¿ y el resultado?.... Grandioso !!
His voice isn't as "strong" as the original recording but I think the fragile, gentle way he sings the song here compliments the vulnerability in the lyrics perfectly.
This song was played in my big brothers funeral in November 2024! He wanted this to be played when he left us.. The cancer took him way to young, only 53 years old! I dont think there was Anny bigger U2 fan then him❤️ he is the reason U2 is my favourite band ever and everytime i listen to this song it will remind me of him and how much i miss him❤️
I have chills!!! This is by FAR the most beautiful performance I’ve ever seen. I wish I was there to see it live. The girl brought up on stage will NEVER forget this day. I absolutely love when artists interact with their fans like this! It fills my heart! ❤️ 3:42 is when the tears started streaming down my face. Also, this song hits different when you have someone in mind. 💔
"The girl brought up on stage will NEVER forget this day." Actually it was more than one day as she was a paid performer and part of the act that always got picked to be the girl that got to go on stage. Still a good show and a good song, but now you know the rest of the story.
I'm not a big U2 fan but what an amazing point of view starting at 1:45 min. when they both sing together and the lips are moving synchronous.. Goosebumps
This is the first U2 song I fell in love with around 1988, at the young age of 10. The powerful turn of phrase in the lyrics combined with the power of the music sent chills through me then, and still does today. And, Oh, to be that girl! 🥰
Same here, but I was only 7 at the time. U2 music has been with me my whole life, through hard times and good, and in dreams. These times we are living now need more focus on good music like this and God. May we all be blessed and forgiven, amen.
My Dad had this song bookmarked.. Love U2, they were a huge part of my growing up... My Dad recently passed away with cancer... Just going through his songs... LOVE YOU DAD...
I feel lucky that I got the privilege to witness something so pure, so deep, so innocent, so spiritual and most importantly so beautiful that I can't even imagine. Bono was crying!!!!!! need not to say more. ♥
@Beyondthe Crowd Dude go fuck yourself. You don't understand anything, not the music of U2 or even what art is. Go back to your negativity and stay there. Bono has emotions, I think YOU lost them
@Beyondthe Crowd If you like the music of U2, you know Bono means this. Of course he has an ego, I do too and you do too. So why do you only put Bono in the dark light while he has done the most magnificant things? I love it that you're an artist, that's awesome. But I think you, as an artist, should know better about him
@Beyondthe Crowd so?? Look, we see the sky blue. But no, It's not. According to science, there is nothing called sky even. What we see is nothing but the reflection of sunlight through water particles. The fact is, what u see or how u see depends on the level of knowledge and wisdom. U buddy is living in a small room doesn’t mean the world is small. It's ur misfortune that u can't get out of ur dark, small room to discover the beautiful, huge world. Whatever, different people would be there with their different opinions. So what?
THIS hits like no other and still does in 2024! 🖤 Epic concert to be able to lay down and be one together in that emotional experience with the best band in history. My all time #1 fav U2 song and always will be forever.🤘🏻
Still making spines tingle in 2021 - certainly that young lady's memory she will never forget! The best guitar riff ever that sustain intro is superb - U2's Greatest song. Cant believe this was 19 years ago 😮😮😮👍👍👍👏👏👏👏👏
Summer 2021 was the greatest summer in my life. Once I came home in the morning after a night with my friends, and this song suddently played in radio. Now I always connect this song with the best time of my life.
Butch Ma that's an odd question. No I'm not, but the sheer joy on her face is infectious. Haha I wouldn't be so thrilled to be up in front of everyone like that, but maybe for her, the rest of the world faded away for a brief moment & it was just them. :)
I saw U2 back during Pop Mart tour, Bono was so very awesome about interacting with the audience. He certainly made everyone feel happy they were there!! awesome band.
What most folks don’t know is that this performance is about his father who was dying at the time of cancer. I’ve always thought of THIS performance as Bono singing to his dad.
I was not expecting to get emotional while watching Sing 2, but when the audience started to sing along with Ash and then the Calloway started to play his guitar it almost got me in tears. Everything about that moment in the movie was absolutely perfect, especially this song and the fact that it was voiced by Bono himself. They truly did justice to this timeless song!
I believe that he senses or feels what you are experiencing...don't forget to tell him what you treasure that you will miss about him! These treasures belong to you forever. Blessings...
This is the reason they are the greatest and most loved band of all time , they went beyond playing their great music , they expressed a message of love and that's why it touched so many hearts since 1980
Been to a couple of their concerts but this was just something else. I can’t imagine what that lady felt, probably thought she was in a dream. Unbelievable!
@@Vagabon1729dho-_ Do you know that we can very well love Jimi Hendrix and still consider that With or Without You is one of the best songs we have listened to? Enfin bref, j'espère qu'en 5 ans tu es devenu un type moins condescendant. Sinon tant pis, faut bien des tocards dans la vie.
E quando ouvi essa musica pela primeira vez tinha so 18 anos e foi muito feliz minha juventude foi ouvindo essa banda agora aos 50 anos quando ouco essa banda me vejo jovem linda plena amoooo U2
Durante años soñé con esta escena, quien pudiera estar tirada en el piso en un concierto con Bono mientras te canta uno de sus mejores temas, simplemente impactante ❤
Diese Musik von U2 begleitet mich schon über 35 Jahre. Jedes Mal, wenn ich dieses Lied höre, verweile ich und genieß dieses Lied. Auch nach dieser langen Zeit ist die Faszination geblieben. Es gehört zu meinen TOP 3- Liedern forever!!!
Música eterna! 14/06/2024... ouvindo direto da Polônia, em meio a meu ano sabático, que iniciou em Dezembro/2023. Já é bem o 15° país e ainda faltam uns 8. Tudo que é bom acaba, mas só a música tem o poder de ser eterna.
bro, I have never seen these guys perform live, this is my first video I have seen them performing live. It was really nice how he treated that lady, it was really sweet! he just laid there singing with her, and then he kissed her hand and helped back into the audience, thats the kind of stuff kids should be seeing their favourite singers do, because it shows the kids how to treat one another and not objectify one another like how you see pop singers these days doing strip shows for their audience members on stage.
Una de las canciones más bellas de ésta legendaria e inmortal banda. La dulzura y el comportamiento mesurado de la muchacha en el escenario hacen de ésta (desde ya impecable interpretación), una muy especial y de las más hermosas que haya visto en vivo.
My dad came at home one day with this DVD...a music concert. I found it boring and I snob it. Few days after I decided to play it. More the concert was going and more I was in that sound...and then this song started. I don’t know how I was signing a song that I never listened before. 19 years are passed and this is still my favorite song ever. Being in Rome 2009 and Boston 2017 had been 2 of the most beautiful moment of my life.
LYRICS: See the stone set in your eyes See the thorn twist in your side I'll wait for you Sleight of hand and twist of fate On a bed of nails she makes me wait And I wait without you With or without you With or without you Through the storm, we reach the shore You give it all but I want more And I'm waiting for you With or without you With or without you, ah-ah I can't live with or without you And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give, and you give And you give yourself away My hands are tied, my body bruised She got me with nothing to win And nothing left to lose And you give yourself away And you give yourself away And you give, and you give And you give yourself away With or without you With or without you, ohh I can't live with or without you With or without you With or without you, ohh I can't live with or without you With or without you
I was at the 2009 LA concert, I was on the floor, close to the extended stage, the concert was going full tilt, and Bono ran by me in total darkness, with his sunglasses on. Bono is the coolest.
4 роки тому+7
I once sent a girl this song after knowing her for a few months and said I loved her that much and couldn't live without her, sadly we couldnt be together :( I always think of her when I listen to this song
he went away, without me.....and waits for me .....in Heaven .... "Through the storm we reach the shore You give it all, but I want more And I'm waiting for you...."
My husband who passed away in 2016 showed me this, quoting it's one of the most beautiful moments in live concert history ever. Smiling each time as I watch this, remembering him.
im sorry for your loss
💜🙏💜
Sorry for your loss
My brother passed away and this song was played at his funeral. I found it very hard to listen too till this year. He died at 15. I feel he still around me when i hear this song.
@@JB-xq8js Sorry to hear about his loss. I completely relate to that too, about feeling their presence when their music is being played. Its very strange as well, the feelings are difficult to comprehend.
He was right its AMAZING
No Smartphones, No pictures, no selfies... just pure experience and memories
This was over 20 years ago, smartphones didn’t exist yet
So ist es und es war die schönste Zeit die es je gab ich vermisse die 80 er . Keine Handys nur Emotionen auf den Konzerten
Pero a la chica le quedó precisamente este video que millones hemos visto... más que suficiente !!
Voy HH vvvvvv voy a verlos voy HH HH HH HH vvvv
Que bello
The whole band was great here, but this girl's composure and calmness is commendable too. She didn't go crazy during the whole song and that allowed Bono to sing while lying down, which is a very difficult posture to sing. This is still one of the best live performances ever! U2 is love :)
Bueno, hasta donde yo sé, acostado es la mejor y más correcta forma para poder identificar la respiración diafragmáticamente, dónde no hay forma de equivocarse y respirar incorrectamente, dicho esto, pienso que se consigue una mejor forma de llegar a las notas sin esfuerzo
REALLY She was a plant. Wow
A moment to remember ❤
@@dawnmartz8483 Ну, да. Музыку-то, может, и не так запомнят, как то, что они лежали на полу.
@@irenamoiseykina7724 I'm sorry I don't understand what you are saying...
They made this girl a moment that she will never forget.
I wonder where she is now, what happened to her after that.
totally unnecessary move, especially being an older married man. I'd take one without the sleeping antic.
And the whole time, Bono was just laying there thinking about one thing, the thing he loves more than anything.......bono
@@sulanibabetherapy
Who is sheee
Thank GOD... this moment was captured on tape. For the world to see and share.... Simply beautiful.
Oh yes ...Marnoleus😢😮🎉😊😊🎉😂❤
Amen
F2563d. 😂😂😢😅😅😅in in ❤mzee MA LAW IN😅smiley 😅😮🎉is love mema. Amandas in law 😢🎉of meme 😊
Fortunately, I was at this show. Sick like an animal... Great time!
I'm not a U2 fan, but bringing that fan onstage and lying down with them and singing was one of the coolest things I've seen a rock band do.
I would love this moment to manifest for me at an Incubus show... just saying... a girl can dream... but we'd actually sing well together. :-)
So Awesome!!! I can only imagine how magical that was!!!
How can a human being not be a U2 fan? Sorry for asking but I find it strange. U2 is life.
I don’t trust a non fan of u2
@@littlemissblackdress7587 ua-cam.com/video/nrDBqdWeB_U/v-deo.html my acoustic cover of the song for the person who introduced me to this Live version of the song. (Feel free to read description of video)
That girl will never ever forget THAT moment!
Who could??!! I might not have survived that moment. Drop dead from heart attack. LOL
EVER!
O B V I O U S L Y :)
1:18
Oh! Certainly..... 20 years ago. Anyway 🤗🤗🤗
The girl at the end will never forget that moment for as long as she lives. I’m sure her story has already been passed down generations.
2022 is listening 💯
The most beautiful moment between a fan and a artist :-)
+Amélie Sonvaux same girl in two different provinces
+Amélie Sonvaux Narcissism at its best. I love U2 but this is just embarrassing considering how they started.
Pure love, pure joy, that was phenomenal.
+Sunil Mandava Pure pure self indulgence, pompous idiot (not you!)
l
My dad passed away yesterday and now I'm making a playlist with all the songs he loved and I remember him by. This is one of them. Thank you dad for showing me the greatest artists of all times. Loved, missed and never forgotten 🤘🔥❤
keep going! I wish you the best
❤
Courage a vous 💖 , soyez fort(e) 🙏🌹 ,votre pere etait un saint homme j en suis sûr , cette chanson c est juste de l'amour pur et simple, elle donne envie d aimer, tellement...
Je vous envoie tt mon Amour aussi , sans ambiguité , en Respect a vos mots et en pensant à votre pere aussi...
J ai perdu le mien en 2008 et j ai eu bcp de mal après a surmonter son absence.. la musique aide beaucoup et elle nous comprends toujours 💖
Prenez soin de vous mon ami(e) 😘😘😘
Hey. This is also what I am doing now. It sucks because im crying. But at the same time, i am smiling. I hope you and your family got through it. I love you man.
I know it’s been a year since your Dad passed but I’m sure you still miss him very much, because I know all too well God bless you and I pray your doing well ❤
You gotta hand it to him for sounding so good singing while laying down.
👍
☺
Facts!
He often recorded laying on a couch in the studio with a cheap Shure sm 58
You have to hand it to her for being able to get up off the stage! I'm straight but damn I would have been weak. Powerful song.what a voice 👌 👏
This young lady was blessed to live in a time in which she could just enjoy this one in a million experience instead of whipping out her phone to add to her social media
We all lived moment by moment back then. You had to make the best of every moment, and really be present and involved in it, because your memory of it was the only thing that would keep it alive. No cell phones in everyone's pocket, so that they could basically lose the entire moment by only focusing on recording it and trying to capture the perfect ridiculous "selfie", so that thousands of people could see the moment, but nobody really gets to really experience it.
Just imagine: your a great (female) fan of U2. And you are chosen to meet Bono on the stage to lie beside him and sing with him "With Or Without You", the most popular and most beautiful song of this band.
Could there be possible something greater in your life?
How did we get from 1987 to 2023 soo damn fast, seems like yesterday we were young and innocent with our whole life a head of us!😪
Too all those amazing days we thought would last forever!💕
Amen!
Yes I know
The music was excellent
😮😮😮😮
Can we also give props to the drummer & bassist, like metronomes throughout the whole performance.. great stuff.
Yes, yes we can.
TBF, Larry Mullen Jr. (and possibly Adam Clayton in his in-ear monitors too) literally plays the song with a click track in his ear because of the synth programming / backing track that goes along with the song, but I get your point. ;)
In ear monitors: let's pretend I don't exist
Yesssssss
Het yes bycall meabkjs he was and I'd fine rorever bbe
I love this - brings a wee tear to my eye. Imagine being the girl and having this memory! Also the audience all in the moment with no fucking phone cameras!
always .every time.
I do not think she sleep for a month. Memories of a lifetime
2021 anyone listening to this magnificent song? One of my songs that I most appreciate about U2
Yessss!!! This was fundamentally the song that first spake to my heart in 1984, and again now!
Of course yes!!!
Jag älskar den här låten!!🥰😇😅
Jag älskar allt av U 2! Yes!!
Listen to it 2 days ago
Mi papá escuchaba rock y una de sus bandas favoritas era U2. Siempre me hacia escuchar de pequeña y ahora a mis 31 años, también escucho y las canto. Hace 5 años que se fue. En día que lo vi en su ataud, le puse esta canción, mis hermanos y yo lloramos. Fue la última vez que lo vi, le pusieron esta y otras 2 canciones que para mis hermanos quedaron marcados hacia mi papá, yo puse esta porque mi papi siempre me cantaba esta canción y la sentí especial para mi. Te amo papi y te extraño tanto. Esta canción me hace acordar tanto a ti y llorar al extrañarme.
Espero que tu padre sea parte en Donde Las calles No Tienen Nombre ! 🔊🎵 🌈🫶 ❤ saludos
Bendecida eres......
Muy conmovedora tu historia en verdad , esa es una de las mejores canciones de U2
خدا باباتوبیا مرزه آمین ❤
A random person in the crowd. A random act of love...
That wasn’t random at all, it might have been genuine, but it wasn’t random with one of the most globally known entertainers.
What an emotional moment for that girl.
Something to show her kids
Yes, indeed.
@@brendakelly8448
Guess that was the moment of HER life!!!
Must have been the happiest girl on planet in that night!
we will never know
U2 new
@@zinaidakharitonova4577 Bono knew... He kissed her 💝
Lucky Her! I bet her heart was pounding hard.
@@hearme1991 You can see how hard she breathes. No surprise there!! I'd probably have had a heart attack or something.
No sé si Alguien lo leerá solo quiero que sepa que está Música es Mágica!! Noviembre 2021
This song always brings me to tears, remembering my daughter who passed away in 2014. Exactly how i feel. :’(
My sincere condolences
gdwickham Rest In Peace to your beautiful daughter
ahhh man, dude. I'm so sorry my parent's were never the same after my sister died. I wish you all the best.
Jesus, i'm sorry for your loss man. I have 2 daughters and i can't imagine the pain you have to go through. I hope you're doing alright now.
condolence
She will remember that moment for the rest of her life! 🤗
This is one of the best songs ever made by U2...I feel the emotion in hole my body!!
Michel Bangma. Whole*
Its one of the best songs by anyone ever!
Which hole, man?
I am loving that song
Creepy.
So many pain, feelings and love in this song.
I can't hold my tears watching this masterpiece!
Same brother. This is my dad's favorite song, he died 2 years ago from cancer.
The Edge... arguably one of the best guitarist in the world
You must watch "It might get loud".
👍👍👍👍👍
absolutely. I don't think you need to argue much!
Been watching this video for years; never gets old or less cool. Love it.
This concert was held very very shortly after Bono’s father passed away. You can feel the heaviness throughout the whole show, especially during ‘Kite’.
He really knows how to channel his energy. I couldn’t imagine performing after something like that. One of my favorite concert DVDs of all time from one of the best bands ever.
Can't imagine the pain of him singing that song 😢
It was not this live, but the Slane castle concert in september 2001. This is Boston 2001.
I believe this was shortly before his father’s dearh
at 55yrs old, I have never been to a U2 concert. Still a big fan. It is on my bucket list
+MARK FERGUSON Hi I am 55 years old as well and I do feel the same way.Where are you living ? USA or England?I am hungarian born american, staying inHungary and I don't see the chance to meet the boys! Anyway it is good to hear my generations reaction to this greatness.Greetings: László
Joshua Tree 30th Anniversary Tour
CenturyLink Field
Seattle, WA
May 14, 2017
I'm 51 and have been to a number of U2 shows. I've also seen many other artists including Paul McCarney, Rod Stewart, Bob Seger and many other. No one..and I mean NO ONE, not even sir Paul comes close to U2. Go. You won't regret it.
Live Aid: I WAS THERE!!! & they were stunning..
You'll see them eventually! I believe in you
The most beautiful version of this song.
My dad sings this song to me since the day I was born, he says this song reminds me of what he felt when he saw me being born ❤️
That’s such a beautiful thing for him to say.
You've got a lovely dad.
that's the true meaning of with or without you
probobly one of the best live versions ever! this is even better than the studio version for me
U2 is my oldest love in music. Bono's voice, Edge's great sound and guitar playing and the solid and original spine of the band with Larry and Adam who are always forgotten... Just one of the best bands still active that never changed a band member and that was never afraid to take chances. I would love your input on a video of my first album. It got the attention of one of my heroes Joe Bouchard (ex bass player founding members of BÖC) who is following us on Soundcloud but returns from people who likes same music is always the best. If you have just 3 minutes to listen and a bit more to comment, that would mean the world to me. Keep rockin' :ua-cam.com/video/YJqmsXd8QH4/v-deo.html&t
Studio version: 10/10
Live version: out of this world 🌎
Every live U2 song is better than the studio version
Considerando de acuerdo a los comentarios, de que su padre acababa de fallecer, estaba sensible en ese tiempo, y en su voz se nota la nostalgia, como si se le fuera a quebrar la voz al punto del llanto, es el plus más importante para un artista, cantar con el alma, ¿ y el resultado?.... Grandioso !!
His voice isn't as "strong" as the original recording but I think the fragile, gentle way he sings the song here compliments the vulnerability in the lyrics perfectly.
I don't think he sung the original flat on his back.🙃🙃🙃
You all should watch the rattle and hum version
He was singing on his back
@@popxax6776 Agreed 💯....R and H is horribly underrated.
Try singing on your back JG
I am 75 years old, and still moved by the tenderness of this moment...
Inspiration is an eternal treasure！i'm 47❤
Quem é essa menina?
76
This song was played in my big brothers funeral in November 2024! He wanted this to be played when he left us.. The cancer took him way to young, only 53 years old! I dont think there was Anny bigger U2 fan then him❤️ he is the reason U2 is my favourite band ever and everytime i listen to this song it will remind me of him and how much i miss him❤️
❤
I have chills!!! This is by FAR the most beautiful performance I’ve ever seen. I wish I was there to see it live. The girl brought up on stage will NEVER forget this day. I absolutely love when artists interact with their fans like this! It fills my heart! ❤️ 3:42 is when the tears started streaming down my face. Also, this song hits different when you have someone in mind. 💔
👍👍👍👍👍🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿
"The girl brought up on stage will NEVER forget this day."
Actually it was more than one day as she was a paid performer and part of the act that always got picked to be the girl that got to go on stage.
Still a good show and a good song, but now you know the rest of the story.
You nailed it with your comment, I share some hugs with you 🙂
Let's share them, and involve everyone 🫶🏻
To the dude on security that took her to the stage: you MADE this video. Legends don't always wear capes...
Guitarrista brabo, baterista brabo, baixista brabo e vocalista brabo, caramba, só podia ser U2.
I'm not a big U2 fan but what an amazing point of view starting at 1:45 min. when they both sing together and the lips are moving synchronous.. Goosebumps
I can feel you!
I love how she sings with him :)
Bettina- ich werd den Abend auf der Ü30 mit Dir nie vergessen🤩❤️ Dieser Song wird mich immer an Dich erinnern…
This concert was 19 years ago. I’m sure it’s a great memory for her.
This concert changed my life. I'm not exaggerating. This was a life changing experience. It altered the very fabric of who I am. Iykyk
This is the first U2 song I fell in love with around 1988, at the young age of 10. The powerful turn of phrase in the lyrics combined with the power of the music sent chills through me then, and still does today. And, Oh, to be that girl! 🥰
Same here, but I was only 7 at the time. U2 music has been with me my whole life, through hard times and good, and in dreams. These times we are living now need more focus on good music like this and God. May we all be blessed and forgiven, amen.
im here 23 yrs later and how proud i am to have lived this era of music.. we rocked well..amen.
My Dad had this song bookmarked.. Love U2, they were a huge part of my growing up... My Dad recently passed away with cancer... Just going through his songs... LOVE YOU DAD...
he just randomly picked a girl from the audience and gave her the time of her live
how modest he is
he doesn't pick an unattractive girl, just saying!!!
@@johnbarr9840 Rumor has it that they put the pretty girls up front on purpose.
I feel lucky that I got the privilege to witness something so pure, so deep, so innocent, so spiritual and most importantly so beautiful that I can't even imagine. Bono was crying!!!!!! need not to say more. ♥
@Beyondthe Crowd Dude go fuck yourself. You don't understand anything, not the music of U2 or even what art is. Go back to your negativity and stay there. Bono has emotions, I think YOU lost them
@Beyondthe Crowd If you like the music of U2, you know Bono means this. Of course he has an ego, I do too and you do too. So why do you only put Bono in the dark light while he has done the most magnificant things? I love it that you're an artist, that's awesome. But I think you, as an artist, should know better about him
@Beyondthe Crowd so??
Look, we see the sky blue. But no, It's not. According to science, there is nothing called sky even. What we see is nothing but the reflection of sunlight through water particles. The fact is, what u see or how u see depends on the level of knowledge and wisdom. U buddy is living in a small room doesn’t mean the world is small. It's ur misfortune that u can't get out of ur dark, small room to discover the beautiful, huge world.
Whatever, different people would be there with their different opinions. So what?
@@ashrafsaikh7937 You are contradicting yourself here, he was only giving his opinion too and is entitled to have a different opinion...
@Beyondthe Crowd you-1 fans-11k
I am 77 and love U2.
THIS hits like no other and still does in 2024! 🖤 Epic concert to be able to lay down and be one together in that emotional experience with the best band in history. My all time #1 fav U2 song and always will be forever.🤘🏻
Still making spines tingle in 2021 - certainly that young lady's memory she will never forget! The best guitar riff ever that sustain intro is superb - U2's Greatest song. Cant believe this was 19 years ago 😮😮😮👍👍👍👏👏👏👏👏
U2 has a spiritual way of preparing All their Music.They are a Classic.
"When I look at the world" has entered the chat...
And in 2023
1999
2024!!!!
Summer 2021 was the greatest summer in my life. Once I came home in the morning after a night with my friends, and this song suddently played in radio. Now I always connect this song with the best time of my life.
One of the greatest moments in Rock History, probably the greatest.
This made me smile so big ☺️😁😍That's a memory that girl will never forget 😆
you are the girl?.......
Hawn Cherry Blossom would give me left arm to be her right there x
juan cornejo valdes haha no I'm not. :)
Butch Ma that's an odd question. No I'm not, but the sheer joy on her face is infectious. Haha I wouldn't be so thrilled to be up in front of everyone like that, but maybe for her, the rest of the world faded away for a brief moment & it was just them. :)
@@HawnCherryBlossom 😉💛👍🇮🇪
I saw U2 back during Pop Mart tour, Bono was so very awesome about interacting with the audience. He certainly made everyone feel happy they were there!! awesome band.
Eugénia
1:43 I've seen this clip numerous times..her eyes say everything,the disbelief. "Is this real? Am I dreaming?" Yes to both.
One of the best perfomance in Music History💯
What most folks don’t know is that this performance is about his father who was dying at the time of cancer. I’ve always thought of THIS performance as Bono singing to his dad.
Same. I always come back to this video.
wow i didn't know, thanks
Yeah and Walk On at Slane Castle was about his death. Walk On also played at my Mum's funeral too
No it was not You got it wrong,
It was about his mother with the unconditional love she had for her child
Definitely not about his farther it’s about love torture and being in a love triangle with a girl, and then she gives her self away
I think this girl will remember this show forever
I was not expecting to get emotional while watching Sing 2, but when the audience started to sing along with Ash and then the Calloway started to play his guitar it almost got me in tears. Everything about that moment in the movie was absolutely perfect, especially this song and the fact that it was voiced by Bono himself. They truly did justice to this timeless song!
I was there, crying rivers,. Today, 20 years after I still DO. Best show of my fucking live EVER!
Офигеть!!! Девчонка никогда, НИКОГДА в жизни не забудет этот момент!!!
Это точно😭🔥🔥🔥
elle n’oubliera jamais ce moment de sa vie , c’est encré à jamais dans sa mémoire ❤
My Dad died two days ago.
Miss him so much.
Couldn't get to see him.
I believe that he senses or feels what you are experiencing...don't forget to tell him what you treasure that you will miss about him! These treasures belong to you forever. Blessings...
I listen to this song and it immediately transports me to another time, other feelings, other sensations, it is magical.
For just a moment, she was the luckiest girl in the Universe
yaaas! haha
Really!! such a great Song and for this Girl always to remember with Bono on the Stage..!!like like ..Best Version
Yes sure
That was creepy. Just sing the damn song and leave the theatrical bs for Broadway
@@ttech694 watch naked girls pop music shit... why the fk are you here anyway
That concert is already 20 years old and yet... when you listen to it... time is not something you really think about.
I still come back to this video, 14-15 years after discovering.
I really hope the young lady is doing oke. What a moment to cherish she has.
Amazing... this young woman Will have stars in her eyes for YEARS.
Thanks U2 for such great moment shared with all fans.
Боже сколько раз за все эти года смотрю это видео и каждый раз слёзы…
me too 😭
Same here, watching again in March 2023.
This is the reason they are the greatest and most loved band of all time , they went beyond playing their great music , they expressed a message of love and that's why it touched so many hearts since 1980
Been to a couple of their concerts but this was just something else. I can’t imagine what that lady felt, probably thought she was in a dream. Unbelievable!
I can’t help but wonder how Bono’s wife feels about it.
@@Lilo-A she married a rockstar, not like she didn’t know what she went into…
@@Lilo-A You must be a child. He is a professional. It's a show. It's a performance. He's done it hundred of times. Nothing to do with feelings.
Da kommen einem die Tränen vor Glück bei diesem Lied !
This is one of my favourite songs of all time! Fantastic!
Me too
Cause you're never hear Jimi Hendrix
@@Vagabon1729dho-_ Do you know that we can very well love Jimi Hendrix and still consider that With or Without You is one of the best songs we have listened to?
Enfin bref, j'espère qu'en 5 ans tu es devenu un type moins condescendant. Sinon tant pis, faut bien des tocards dans la vie.
E quando ouvi essa musica pela primeira vez tinha so 18 anos e foi muito feliz minha juventude foi ouvindo essa banda agora aos 50 anos quando ouco essa banda me vejo jovem linda plena amoooo U2
Top
Eu também
Durante años soñé con esta escena, quien pudiera estar tirada en el piso en un concierto con Bono mientras te canta uno de sus mejores temas, simplemente impactante ❤
I love how she sings with him :)
That girl will never ever forget THAT moment!
Diese Musik von U2 begleitet mich schon über 35 Jahre. Jedes Mal, wenn ich dieses Lied höre, verweile ich und genieß dieses Lied. Auch nach dieser langen Zeit ist die Faszination geblieben. Es gehört zu meinen TOP 3- Liedern forever!!!
I've never seen a singer who could get even close to Bono's charisma on stage. It's just out of this world
Michael H. Had it and we lost him way to early...
Música eterna! 14/06/2024... ouvindo direto da Polônia, em meio a meu ano sabático, que iniciou em Dezembro/2023. Já é bem o 15° país e ainda faltam uns 8. Tudo que é bom acaba, mas só a música tem o poder de ser eterna.
omg. the young lady never forget this moment. one of the best songs
The day I meet u real u I own peace.in tranquility known uve heard me ask try. Begged gave and. Heard. There will only be. Heaven left for bothus
I love the look on the girl's face whenever she was pulled up on the stage. Priceless!!!
bro, I have never seen these guys perform live, this is my first video I have seen them performing live. It was really nice how he treated that lady, it was really sweet! he just laid there singing with her, and then he kissed her hand and helped back into the audience, thats the kind of stuff kids should be seeing their favourite singers do, because it shows the kids how to treat one another and not objectify one another like how you see pop singers these days doing strip shows for their audience members on stage.
a tip, go and see them live, you won't forget it.
hai pienamente ragione
einer der wunderbarsten Momente der gesamten Musikgeschichte, finde ich!
Bono is THE gentleman, and THE rock star, real inspiration man! :O
Una de las canciones más bellas de ésta legendaria e inmortal banda.
La dulzura y el comportamiento mesurado de la muchacha en el escenario hacen de ésta (desde ya impecable interpretación), una muy especial y de las más hermosas que haya visto en vivo.
The song is nostalgic, disheartening, but it almost always puts a smile on the faces of those who listen to it. We Brazilians love U2 a lot.
My dad came at home one day with this DVD...a music concert. I found it boring and I snob it. Few days after I decided to play it. More the concert was going and more I was in that sound...and then this song started. I don’t know how I was signing a song that I never listened before. 19 years are passed and this is still my favorite song ever. Being in Rome 2009 and Boston 2017 had been 2 of the most beautiful moment of my life.
You're right, the DVD (and the whole Elevation tour) were kinda boring.
the coolest band on the planet. period.
Wow. Bet she will never forget this
LYRICS:
See the stone set in your eyes
See the thorn twist in your side
I'll wait for you
Sleight of hand and twist of fate
On a bed of nails she makes me wait
And I wait without you
With or without you
With or without you
Through the storm, we reach the shore
You give it all but I want more
And I'm waiting for you
With or without you
With or without you, ah-ah
I can't live with or without you
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give, and you give
And you give yourself away
My hands are tied, my body bruised
She got me with nothing to win
And nothing left to lose
And you give yourself away
And you give yourself away
And you give, and you give
And you give yourself away
With or without you
With or without you, ohh
I can't live with or without you
With or without you
With or without you, ohh
I can't live with or without you
With or without you
너무나 아름다운 노래,밴드
눈물이 떨어지게 만드는 노래와 그들의 힘..그런 음악.
I still and always will get chills watching this video. U2 Forever!!!!!!!!
4:04 AMAZING! Just amazing.
Perfect song, I set this song as my wake up alarm. The magic is that I can enjoy my alarm until it runs out before I really wake up.
I was at the 2009 LA concert, I was on the floor, close to the extended stage, the concert was going full tilt, and Bono ran by me in total darkness, with his sunglasses on. Bono is the coolest.
I once sent a girl this song after knowing her for a few months and said I loved her that much and couldn't live without her, sadly we couldnt be together :( I always think of her when I listen to this song
P
he went away, without me.....and waits for me .....in Heaven ....
"Through the storm we reach the shore
You give it all, but I want more
And I'm waiting for you...."
Dönüp dolaşıp kendimi izlerken bulduğum yer burası. Ey yıllar. 2010 Japonya’da ilk defa izlemiştim. O gün bugün hala izlerim. Efsaneee💝