as a Muslim I am obligated to respect other faiths, Judaism in particular has a very honourable mention in the Qur'an as a divinely revealed religion from Allah (SWT) I wouldn't eat Ice cream in front of a fasting person, I would consider that disrespectful.
I think there were other reasons for Ashura. Muslims tend to forget the massacre and martyrdom of the Holy Prophet's beloved grandchildren and family in Karbala on Ashura. A section of Muslims only keep fast until Asr salaat and then drink some water so not to fast because it is a day of mourning, not celebration. It just depends on which perspective feels the most authentic one.
@@skyejacques But in Islam we can't mourn for people die more than 3 days. If we have to do so then prophet Muhammad first we must mourn. But in his life, prophet never mourn someone for every year or beat himself right? That's why Shia contradict with the prophet do.
صاحب القناة انسان راقي ومهذب ومحترم وكل انسان حر بدينو ومعتقدو وبالنهاية اليهودية والمسيحية والاسلام من منبع واحد لان الرب واحد صديقي صاحب القناة لدي بعض الأسئلة اذا تكرمت علينا بالاجابة
"7/27/09 From The Lord, Our God and Savior The Word of The Lord Spoken to Timothy, For All Those Who Have Ears to Hear (Regarding believers in Messiah taking part in a Jewish fast during the month of Av) Thus says The Lord your God, The God of Israel, The God of all, He who searches the hearts and minds, even to the innermost thoughts and intentions:[1] I alone see the heart of man, and I alone test the quality of each man’s work, to reveal of what sort it truly is.[2] Therefore, I ask you, shall you seek to do as those who have rejected The Messiah, as those who have forsaken Me and remain void of the Spirit?! I tell you the truth, their fasts and offerings are not accepted, their sacrifices I hate! Shall My own people, who are not My people, come before Me in My name to fast for the dead?! Shall they call on My name, while at the same time rejecting The Son of Salvation?! Lo, they will indeed come, yet I will turn to them the back! For they have no voice before Me; they remain broken off! Says The Lord. And what of you, beloved, where do you stand? And where have I placed you, according to your acceptance of The Messiah? Answer, if you know. For indeed it has come to pass, even since the day I dwelt among them in the flesh, behold, they were broken off that you might be grafted in. For out of unbelief they have been forsaken for a time. Yet the day has come and is nearly upon them, when they will be grafted in again, for I am able to graft them in again.[3] Yet of that day, it has not yet fully come. And so I ask you, why do you now endeavor to take part in the futile customs of the unbeliever? How is it you seek to seat yourself among those who lack knowledge and forsake understanding? Their fasts are in vain! They are not accepted! Yet I ask you, all you who have not denied Me, who also believe this Word, why do My servants fast on the Sabbath as I have commanded them?[4] And of you who I did not command, why do you also take part? (Yes, you too shall fast, indeed, I will require it of you. Yet only those who present themselves before Me in sincere devotion, as one swallowed up in much sorrow over the absence of The Bridegroom,[5] and over all this death which has come and is coming and shall fill the world with tears and blood, shall be accepted.) Beloved, over this you shall fast, over this you shall wail: All these crying children, all these hardened hearts, All this death and murder, all this injustice and godlessness... Tears as a river, tears and blood and much wailing, Great evil and the slaughter of the innocent... Says The Lord. Yet those of Israel go out to cry over all their dead, and fast because of all this punishment I have allowed to overtake them. Yet I hear no repentance! I hear no wailing at all over their forsaking of The Holy One who poured out His life for them, nor over that which their fathers had done to Him, the sin of which remains atop their marred heads![6] Enmity, such bitter tears! My own people, who were the apple of My eye, forsake Me still! Therefore, take no part in their festivals! Take no part in their wailing over the dead, as though I am not able at this very moment to call them forth from their graves and from their tombs, to raise them ALL from the dust of the earth once again! Thus says The Lord, to all those of Israel who have drunk from My cup and eaten of My bread, all who remain grafted in; hear the Word of The Lord your God, yes I, YAHUWAH, The God of your fathers, The God of all: Be not offended in My words, nor wag the head at My speech, nor push out the hand against My words in these Letters. For your eyes have seen and your ears have heard, and within your hearts you have understood the grace of Him who was crucified upon the tree. Again, I say, wag not your head. Rather that which honors Messiah, do. And that which I have decreed as a perpetual ordinance,[7] continue therein, according to The Messiah YahuShua being the goal and fulfillment thereof, for He is worthy. And in so doing, do you also become worthy because of Him. And that which you do in remembrance of Him, to bring glory to His name, honors Me; even as that which you offer up in thanksgiving, in His name, glorifies Me. For I AM HE, YAHUWAH, The One who reigns and causes to be, The One who is and has always been, The Eternal God, The Everlasting who is from everlasting to everlasting; I AM. Therefore if you fast, fast as one who longs for the Return of The Bridegroom, even as a sign to those Who are near and to those who are afar off... And beloved, fast for those perishing, for those Who are about to receive of My Judgment, Which is stored up and must be poured out; Fast and lament and pray that they repent before the time... And fast also for those who at present Remain broken off,[8] yes, beloved, pray for Repentance in Israel, for a great awakening, That all come to accept Me as I truly am, That all be broken atop The Stone,[9] Before calamity and judgment overtake this world... For the time has come, says The Lord." www.thevolumesoftruth.com/Who_Among_You,_O_Israel,_and_Among_You,_O_Olive_Branches,_Has_Fasted_Unto_Me%3F!_Says_The_Lord_God
Your videos and are so diverse and interesting. You make them for such a large audience and I hope you can come to American one day and maybe even perform live because I really love your videos! I like how your comparing the religions because it doesn’t divide it, it makes us equal so thank you so much for this.
I'm a proud Christian but I love this channel :) May God bless us all despite our differences. There's 1 God yet we're all God's people. Peace, love and blessings to you all!
Yeah God is one and He is not a man or die on the cross. Learn more about new testemant and you will find "what is the real teaching of jesus". Peace to you
@@kurulusosmanenglishsubtitl9289 Neither of them verses provide a negation to my claim. 49:12 - Is about backbiting against another Muslim, this does not include non-Muslims. 4:148 - Says Allah does not like negative thoughts to be voiced, except by people who have been wronged - Again absolutely nothing to do with not speaking ill of non-muslim's. Furthermore Allah Subhanawatala himself speaks ill of the disbelievers. And uses a wide range of imagery and insults for those who refuse to believe in his highness. They are likened to cattle (camels, cows, sheep), a goat-herd, dogs, asses, etc. (Surah 25:44, 2:171, 7:175-177, 62:5), but in some passages it is much harsh than that: For example *"To Allah, there are no animals viler than those who do not believe and remain unbelievers"* (Sura 8:55). and Sura 98:6 *"Indeed, they who disbelieved (Non-muslims) among the People of the book and the polytheists will be in the fire of Hell, abiding eternally therein. Those are the worst of creatures."* Allah calls them and i quote *"The worst of creatures"* - Meaning they are even worse than animals and worse than shaytan himself. Furthermore there is a principle in Islam, *If something is not specifically forbidden then it is permissible.* Speaking Ill of non-Muslim's is not specifically forbidden and instead encouraged by the above verses. So on the balance of everything I would say you can definitely speak ill of Non-Muslims, but refrain from speaking Ill against Muslims. As-salamulaykum.
its not just prohibited in ramadan but for our whole life. anyway speak ill of others does not void our fast unlike eating and having sex during the day
@@qasmb1546 (104:1) Woe to every fault-finding backbiter Backbiting means mentioning something about a person (in his absence), that he hates (to have mentioned), whether it is about: His body, his religious characteristics, his worldly affairs, his self, his physical appearance, his character, his wealth, his child, his father, his wife, his manner of walking, his smile, it is the same whether you mention that about him with words, through writings, or whether you point or indicate him by gesturing with your eyes, hand or head. Hopefully next time you’ll do your research before slandering someone else’s religion. Peace.
Slight correction. The fast of Esther isn't because of the fast that was mentioned. That fast occurred in the megillah but it is not why we fast on the fast of Esther. The reason Jews fast today is commemorating the fast that all the Jews did before going to war. The name was just given in the merit of Esther.
@@CoolBoy-gv3qz لا كفار يا حاج أي حد مش بيوحد الله ولا مصدق بنبوة سيدنا محمد ولا بيتبعه يبقى كافر.. ديانتهم كانت مؤقتة لغاية ما ربنا يبعث الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم..
Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) saw the Jews fasting not on Yom Kippur but on the Fast of the First Born. This is were the name Ashura came from “the 10th plague” and that is the day when God saved Prophet Moses (pbuh) from Pharaoh.
Informative and good animation. ☺️ I am a Christian and looking into information about other religion's fasting reasons and how-tos. Thanks for this! ✨
I have a Q, 2:08 in the fasting during Yom Kippur, aside from the other pics, you can't eat or drink for 25 hours - does that include swallowing of saliva?
Awesome animation you did! Very informative. One thing, it isn't accurate that Muslims should not have sex in Ramadan. In Quran it has a verse that during fasting at night men can join their women. Please be more accurate “It is made lawful for you to have sexual relations with your wives on the night of As-Siyam (fasting). They are Libas (i.e., body-cover, or screen) for you and you are Libas for them. Allah knows that you used to deceive yourselves, so He turned to you (accepted your repentance) and forgave you. So now have sexual relations with them and seek that which Allah has ordained for you (offspring), and eat and drink until the white thread (light) of dawn appears to you distinct from the black thread (darkness of night), then complete your fast till the nightfall. And do not have sexual relations with them (your wives) while you are in I`tikaf in the Masjids. These are the limits (set) by Allah, so approach them not. Thus does Allah make clear His Ayat to mankind that they may acquire Taqwa.“ Surah Al-Baqarah (2:187)
But why is the animation "copy and paste" when it's about to illustrate how Yom Kippur is similar to Asshura in some ways? :/ Like, you wouldn't say that the latest book by an author is a plagiarized version of the previous version of the book
Can you explain why? Granted, I’m in the US, and I don’t expect anyone to refrain from eating or drinking in front of me during my religious fasts, not even fellow Jews of differing levels of observance.
@@truepeacenik It's just a matter of respect and culture. If you don't mind people eating in front of you when you're fasting, good for you, I don't mind either. But the Islamic etiquette is that you don't eat in front of people fasting.
@@DarioHaruni Sorry, but by logic a Muslim follows Islam, a Jew follows Judaism, and a Christian follows Christianity. And every one believes that he has a time in the year to fast, so it is not their fault that they break their fast in the fasting of others
and don't forget Muslims are human like u so don't try to make and try to figure out any thing wrong with them human kills and betray and spoil and destroy not Muslims and please this is just a video u just can search a fault of a Muslim character who is designed not true person
The Historical Version of the origins of the Ramadan needs to be relook... Kindly check how early Muslims used to keep fast and when the present style of Roza started like not eating from morning till evening... What happens when the ayat was revealed... What happened once with the first Muslim caliph and then how the another ayat revealed to respond to that query...
Muslims fast on that day because of Moses pbuh, but muslims also fast on the day before and the day after, on 9th, 10th and 11th of the month. anyway i get to know more bout judaism from this jews channel. nice that u put muslima character there but i hope you can make a proper character of muslim woman to cover their head properly (hijab covers all hair) also covering at least till the chest, and the dress must cover all body except palm of hands (muslimah wear long sleeves long dress). God bless ya
So is yom kippur a day of fasting because Moses and his ppl were saved by God? Or did God command this day for fasting in the Torah? Muslim asking. Thank you and peace🤍
Same reason why god commanded through Muhammad to the muslims to fast on the day of Ashura. We are just observing the event on different calendars. Though, the ruling on fasting on the day is "recommended" and not "mandatory".
Hello. I am not religious, but I am interessting in all religoins. CAn someone give me a link to the jewish/mosaic ( maybe also islamic ) calender? I want to know, what time you are fasting :)
Muslims fasts on 9th and 10th of Muharram. Ashura' commemorates the day that Allah saved the Children of Israel from Pharaoh. Fasting on Muharram 10, known as the Day of 'Ashura', expiates for the sins of the past year. When the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) arrived in Madinah in 622 CE, he found that the Jews there fasted on Muharram 10 and asked them the reason for their fasting on this day. They said," This is a blessed day. On this day Allah saved the Children of Israel from their enemy (in Egypt) and so Prophet Musa [Moses] fasted on this day giving thanks to Allah." The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said, "We are closer to Musa than you are." He fasted on that day and commanded Muslims to fast on this day. (Al-Bukhari) Ibn 'Abbas reported: The Messenger of Allah fasted on the day of 'Ashura' and ordered the people to fast on it. The people said, "O Messenger of Allah, it is a day that the Jews and Christians honor." The Prophet said, "When the following year comes, Allah willing, we shall fast on the ninth also." The death of the Prophet came before the following year. (Muslim and Abu Dawud) For more on 'Ashura' and Muharram
I want to ask, if one non jew but who believes in God can eat of Easter Lamb. I just bought yesterday kosher meat and it turned out to be sacrificed to Pesach. I do not know what to do. Should i eat it ?
We don’t sacrifice anything since the destruction of the temples, this is either just a lie from the butcher or a sacrifice from the idolatrous Samaritans
@@ananonjonvic6623 can i eat beaf that was slaughtered in Pesach ? Maybe i misunderstood. I meant general that was slaughtered on that day or occasion?
@@BenjaminSonofJacob no problem, the temple is no more so there is no risks of being like a sacrifice. Plus, the sacrifices were made the first day of Pesach and slaughter an animal during Chabat or holidays was authorised only in the Telple for sacrifices so if a meat is kasher it can’t been slaughtered the day the sacrifices were made in the past
@@Aurora-sz8by that doesn’t make sense cuz hijab and being well covered for women is one of islam’s priorities so they should represent the muslim woman in the true identity of islam
@@biuless5275 And what about the permissibility of an uncle or maternal uncle with his sister’s daughter and his brother’s daughter, isn’t it permissible for you?
السلام على من اتبع الهدى في الاسلام يوجد فقط دينين دين الاسلام الي يشمل رُسُلُهُ موسى وعيسى وبقية الرسل والانبياء ودين الشيطان وهو دين الوثنيين لكن هم بدولو وغيرو وادخلو اشياء من الوثنيين.
@@people.of.thebook ليش أنت لا تؤمن بموسى و رسالته؟!!.. و أنت بدلت و ادخلت على العقيدة التي جاء بها موسى عليه السلام، عقائد وثنية؟ !!.. كلامه وين و أنت حطيت حالك وين :)))) المهم : 1_0 لصالحه. .
@@eugeniev-a4 Qur'an. I was talking about the Qur'an. The Muslim got his stories confused and relocated Haman from Persian Kings to Egyptian Pharaoh. Small mistake of place and epoch. Well what do you expect from a "god" that couldn't distinguish fable from fact (Story of sleepers in the Cave & Alexander Romance)
This from Torah really proves who actually is confused “If a man happens to meet a virgin who is not pledged to be married and rapes her and they are discovered, he shall pay her father fifty shekels of silver. He must marry the young woman, for he has violated her. He can never divorce her as long as he lives.” (Deuteronomy 22:28-29)
i am muslim and i'll be fasting tomorrow to remember the Passover
as a Muslim I am obligated to respect other faiths, Judaism in particular has a very honourable mention in the Qur'an as a divinely revealed religion from Allah (SWT)
I wouldn't eat Ice cream in front of a fasting person, I would consider that disrespectful.
The entire video makes slight jabs at Islam. Jews are pretty good at slowly subversive paths (like satan).
im fasting as a muslim in the same Jewish days...as a way of the solidarity with em...God bless all jews..christians & muslims
That is so sweet! Wish you well and lots of happiness! God bless❤
Better you refer to your local mufti on this matter.
Thanks for sharing this video, I’m Muslim and I wanted to know more about this connection of the 10th of Tevet for Jewish and Ashura for Islam!
Same here.....
yemkippur and 10th Muharram...does they fall on same date.what was Muharram called before kurbala happened in islam
I think there were other reasons for Ashura. Muslims tend to forget the massacre and martyrdom of the Holy Prophet's beloved grandchildren and family in Karbala on Ashura. A section of Muslims only keep fast until Asr salaat and then drink some water so not to fast because it is a day of mourning, not celebration.
It just depends on which perspective feels the most authentic one.
@@skyejacques But in Islam we can't mourn for people die more than 3 days. If we have to do so then prophet Muhammad first we must mourn. But in his life, prophet never mourn someone for every year or beat himself right? That's why Shia contradict with the prophet do.
صاحب القناة انسان راقي ومهذب ومحترم وكل انسان حر بدينو ومعتقدو وبالنهاية اليهودية والمسيحية والاسلام من منبع واحد لان الرب واحد صديقي صاحب القناة لدي بعض الأسئلة اذا تكرمت علينا بالاجابة
تفضل
"7/27/09 From The Lord, Our God and Savior
The Word of The Lord Spoken to Timothy, For All Those Who Have Ears to Hear
(Regarding believers in Messiah taking part in a Jewish fast during the month of Av)
Thus says The Lord your God, The God of Israel, The God of all, He who searches the hearts and minds, even to the innermost thoughts and intentions:[1] I alone see the heart of man, and I alone test the quality of each man’s work, to reveal of what sort it truly is.[2] Therefore, I ask you, shall you seek to do as those who have rejected The Messiah, as those who have forsaken Me and remain void of the Spirit?! I tell you the truth, their fasts and offerings are not accepted, their sacrifices I hate! Shall My own people, who are not My people, come before Me in My name to fast for the dead?! Shall they call on My name, while at the same time rejecting The Son of Salvation?! Lo, they will indeed come, yet I will turn to them the back! For they have no voice before Me; they remain broken off! Says The Lord.
And what of you, beloved, where do you stand? And where have I placed you, according to your acceptance of The Messiah? Answer, if you know. For indeed it has come to pass, even since the day I dwelt among them in the flesh, behold, they were broken off that you might be grafted in. For out of unbelief they have been forsaken for a time. Yet the day has come and is nearly upon them, when they will be grafted in again, for I am able to graft them in again.[3] Yet of that day, it has not yet fully come.
And so I ask you, why do you now endeavor to take part in the futile customs of the unbeliever? How is it you seek to seat yourself among those who lack knowledge and forsake understanding? Their fasts are in vain! They are not accepted!
Yet I ask you, all you who have not denied Me, who also believe this Word, why do My servants fast on the Sabbath as I have commanded them?[4] And of you who I did not command, why do you also take part? (Yes, you too shall fast, indeed, I will require it of you. Yet only those who present themselves before Me in sincere devotion, as one swallowed up in much sorrow over the absence of The Bridegroom,[5] and over all this death which has come and is coming and shall fill the world with tears and blood, shall be accepted.)
Beloved, over this you shall fast, over this you shall wail:
All these crying children, all these hardened hearts,
All this death and murder, all this injustice and godlessness...
Tears as a river, tears and blood and much wailing,
Great evil and the slaughter of the innocent...
Says The Lord.
Yet those of Israel go out to cry over all their dead, and fast because of all this punishment I have allowed to overtake them. Yet I hear no repentance! I hear no wailing at all over their forsaking of The Holy One who poured out His life for them, nor over that which their fathers had done to Him, the sin of which remains atop their marred heads![6]
Enmity, such bitter tears! My own people, who were the apple of My eye, forsake Me still! Therefore, take no part in their festivals! Take no part in their wailing over the dead, as though I am not able at this very moment to call them forth from their graves and from their tombs, to raise them ALL from the dust of the earth once again!
Thus says The Lord, to all those of Israel who have drunk from My cup and eaten of My bread, all who remain grafted in; hear the Word of The Lord your God, yes I, YAHUWAH, The God of your fathers, The God of all: Be not offended in My words, nor wag the head at My speech, nor push out the hand against My words in these Letters. For your eyes have seen and your ears have heard, and within your hearts you have understood the grace of Him who was crucified upon the tree.
Again, I say, wag not your head. Rather that which honors Messiah, do. And that which I have decreed as a perpetual ordinance,[7] continue therein, according to The Messiah YahuShua being the goal and fulfillment thereof, for He is worthy. And in so doing, do you also become worthy because of Him. And that which you do in remembrance of Him, to bring glory to His name, honors Me; even as that which you offer up in thanksgiving, in His name, glorifies Me. For I AM HE, YAHUWAH, The One who reigns and causes to be, The One who is and has always been, The Eternal God, The Everlasting who is from everlasting to everlasting; I AM.
Therefore if you fast, fast as one who longs for the
Return of The Bridegroom, even as a sign to those
Who are near and to those who are afar off...
And beloved, fast for those perishing, for those
Who are about to receive of My Judgment,
Which is stored up and must be poured out;
Fast and lament and pray that they repent before the time...
And fast also for those who at present
Remain broken off,[8] yes, beloved, pray for
Repentance in Israel, for a great awakening,
That all come to accept Me as I truly am,
That all be broken atop The Stone,[9]
Before calamity and judgment overtake this world...
For the time has come, says The Lord."
www.thevolumesoftruth.com/Who_Among_You,_O_Israel,_and_Among_You,_O_Olive_Branches,_Has_Fasted_Unto_Me%3F!_Says_The_Lord_God
@@people.of.thebook عزير ابن الله؟
يمكن الله كان قصده عن مذهب عند اليهود @@KenshinExpress
متل الشيعة بيقدسوا علي و بعض طوائف يعبدوه بس مو معناته كل المسلمين بيقدسوا و يعبدوا علي
Thanks a lot for uploading in English, I was waiting for you to upload any video in English, and thanks a lot again,
Salam/Shalom
صاحب القناة انسان راقي و مهذب بغض النظر عن دينة تحية لك يا إلحنان ✋ انا مسلم
Oh very informative video. Thank you. We need to clear up confusions to bring people together.
Thank you al hanan
I love these videos. 👏👏👏
Your videos and are so diverse and interesting. You make them for such a large audience and I hope you can come to American one day and maybe even perform live because I really love your videos! I like how your comparing the religions because it doesn’t divide it, it makes us equal so thank you so much for this.
Thank you so much Mary, please keep following!
These videos are beautiful, comparing the many, many ways in which Judaism and Islam are similar instead of arguing over the small differences.
I'm a proud Christian but I love this channel :) May God bless us all despite our differences. There's 1 God yet we're all God's people. Peace, love and blessings to you all!
Yeah God is one and He is not a man or die on the cross. Learn more about new testemant and you will find "what is the real teaching of jesus". Peace to you
1:40 Muslims are not allowed to speak ill of others any time
not true. they can and do
@@qasmb1546 provide the evidence of your negation. I have the proof of my claim: Quran, chapter 49, verse 12, also see, chapter 4, verse 148
@@kurulusosmanenglishsubtitl9289 Neither of them verses provide a negation to my claim.
49:12 - Is about backbiting against another Muslim, this does not include non-Muslims.
4:148 - Says Allah does not like negative thoughts to be voiced, except by people who have been wronged - Again absolutely nothing to do with not speaking ill of non-muslim's.
Furthermore Allah Subhanawatala himself speaks ill of the disbelievers.
And uses a wide range of imagery and insults for those who refuse to believe in his highness.
They are likened to cattle (camels, cows, sheep), a goat-herd, dogs, asses, etc. (Surah 25:44, 2:171, 7:175-177, 62:5), but in some passages it is much harsh than that:
For example *"To Allah, there are no animals viler than those who do not believe and remain unbelievers"* (Sura 8:55).
and Sura 98:6 *"Indeed, they who disbelieved (Non-muslims) among the People of the book and the polytheists will be in the fire of Hell, abiding eternally therein. Those are the worst of creatures."*
Allah calls them and i quote *"The worst of creatures"* - Meaning they are even worse than animals and worse than shaytan himself.
Furthermore there is a principle in Islam, *If something is not specifically forbidden then it is permissible.*
Speaking Ill of non-Muslim's is not specifically forbidden and instead encouraged by the above verses.
So on the balance of everything I would say you can definitely speak ill of Non-Muslims, but refrain from speaking Ill against Muslims.
As-salamulaykum.
its not just prohibited in ramadan but for our whole life.
anyway speak ill of others does not void our fast unlike eating and having sex during the day
@@qasmb1546
(104:1) Woe to every fault-finding backbiter
Backbiting means mentioning something about a person (in his absence), that he hates (to have mentioned), whether it is about: His body, his religious characteristics, his worldly affairs, his self, his physical appearance, his character, his wealth, his child, his father, his wife, his manner of walking, his smile, it is the same whether you mention that about him with words, through writings, or whether you point or indicate him by gesturing with your eyes, hand or head.
Hopefully next time you’ll do your research before slandering someone else’s religion. Peace.
Oh I feel bad for my Jewish brothers come on give me a hug my love I'm Muslim 😭😭😭
Respect Jews from a Muslim we are Abrahmic cousin's 🙏🙏☪️✡️
not untill Al Mahdi here
Very respectful and nice guy 😔❤
Slight correction. The fast of Esther isn't because of the fast that was mentioned. That fast occurred in the megillah but it is not why we fast on the fast of Esther. The reason Jews fast today is commemorating the fast that all the Jews did before going to war. The name was just given in the merit of Esther.
ALLAH HU AKBAR
Thank u
هو يتكلم عن الديانه اليهوديه وليس دولة اسرائيل ....افهمو الديانة اليهودية مقارنة بالاسلام لانهن اقرب الديانات لبعض ونفس المفاهيم تقريبا
ايوا وكمان اليهود مو معنى هم كفار ولا شي
اليهود مجرد ديانه وكمان نبيهم موسى( ع)
هم ديانه زينا
@@CoolBoy-gv3qz لا كفار يا حاج أي حد مش بيوحد الله ولا مصدق بنبوة سيدنا محمد ولا بيتبعه يبقى كافر.. ديانتهم كانت مؤقتة لغاية ما ربنا يبعث الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم..
αѕ мυѕℓιм🕋 ι ℓσνєтнιѕ ¢нαииєℓ
Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) saw the Jews fasting not on Yom Kippur but on the Fast of the First Born. This is were the name Ashura came from “the 10th plague” and that is the day when God saved Prophet Moses (pbuh) from Pharaoh.
I'm not much religious myself, but I think you are doing God's work with these videos! Thank you!
Thanks for your lovely comment!
@@people.of.thebook But you do not see the black face of the Jewish religion
Informative and good animation. ☺️ I am a Christian and looking into information about other religion's fasting reasons and how-tos. Thanks for this! ✨
0:05 noo don't eat in front of him 😂😂
I thought jews fast for 40 days ? How long do they fast for.
One day
@@people.of.thebook they got 6 compulsory day's how did you work out one?
i am a muslim
No way
I would not eat an ic-cream in front of fasting friend. Its not just food, he is craving this.
I have a Q, 2:08 in the fasting during Yom Kippur, aside from the other pics, you can't eat or drink for 25 hours - does that include swallowing of saliva?
No
No because you already have saliva in your mouth but also it’s better to spit it out then swallowing it
Awesome animation you did! Very informative. One thing, it isn't accurate that Muslims should not have sex in Ramadan. In Quran it has a verse that during fasting at night men can join their women. Please be more accurate
“It is made lawful for you to have sexual relations with your wives on the night of As-Siyam (fasting). They are Libas (i.e., body-cover, or screen) for you and you are Libas for them. Allah knows that you used to deceive yourselves, so He turned to you (accepted your repentance) and forgave you. So now have sexual relations with them and seek that which Allah has ordained for you (offspring), and eat and drink until the white thread (light) of dawn appears to you distinct from the black thread (darkness of night), then complete your fast till the nightfall. And do not have sexual relations with them (your wives) while you are in I`tikaf in the Masjids. These are the limits (set) by Allah, so approach them not. Thus does Allah make clear His Ayat to mankind that they may acquire Taqwa.“
Surah Al-Baqarah (2:187)
The Christian that fasting 3 days so I can become a better person day 2 and I'm so hungry omg even raw potatoes looks good
great video !
But why is the animation "copy and paste" when it's about to illustrate how Yom Kippur is similar to Asshura in some ways? :/ Like, you wouldn't say that the latest book by an author is a plagiarized version of the previous version of the book
No, this video purpose to educate Muslim and Jews about they are simmilar tradition without debate or hating each other.
I love this channel ❤
Religious Fasting In Every Religion Explained
No, Christians didn’t fast like Jews or Muslims
Can you do this video in french pls
The Muslim girl isn't supposed to eat in front of a guy fasting.
Can you explain why?
Granted, I’m in the US, and I don’t expect anyone to refrain from eating or drinking in front of me during my religious fasts, not even fellow Jews of differing levels of observance.
@@truepeacenik It's just a matter of respect and culture. If you don't mind people eating in front of you when you're fasting, good for you, I don't mind either. But the Islamic etiquette is that you don't eat in front of people fasting.
@@DarioHaruni Sorry, but by logic a Muslim follows Islam, a Jew follows Judaism, and a Christian follows Christianity. And every one believes that he has a time in the year to fast, so it is not their fault that they break their fast in the fasting of others
and don't forget Muslims are human like u so don't try to make and try to figure out any thing wrong with them human kills and betray and spoil and destroy not Muslims and please this is just a video u just can search a fault of a Muslim character who is designed not true person
By the way smoke is haram.
It's a mean of calming one's self, you should control yourself by sheer will power and not any Substances to prove how strong your faith is to allah
Oh sorry I thought you were asking why it's haram in ramadan 😅
@@Soy_boy-by8ez it is Haram through the year not only in Ramadan
loved the explanation!
The Historical Version of the origins of the Ramadan needs to be relook... Kindly check how early Muslims used to keep fast and when the present style of Roza started like not eating from morning till evening... What happens when the ayat was revealed... What happened once with the first Muslim caliph and then how the another ayat revealed to respond to that query...
It is prohibited in islam to eat infront of someone who is fasting
Zaroon Bajwa not it's just frowned upon
No its not, its just bad manners
Zoraiz Umer well it's frowned upon by people that's what I'm saying but it isn't prohibited it's just a dick move
I don’t know about in Islam but it sure is in Judaism
يعني تعرف عبري وعربي وانقلبزي 😮😍😍😍😍
و فرنسي ايضا
من؟
😇هلاو
Muslims fast on that day because of Moses pbuh, but muslims also fast on the day before and the day after, on 9th, 10th and 11th of the month.
anyway i get to know more bout judaism from this jews channel. nice that u put muslima character there but i hope you can make a proper character of muslim woman to cover their head properly (hijab covers all hair) also covering at least till the chest, and the dress must cover all body except palm of hands (muslimah wear long sleeves long dress). God bless ya
We can't even scream, wear make up or perfumes and not even music or dance.
Really?
@Shalom Shalom maybe because both languages are semitic?
@@people.of.thebook No, he must be joking to you.
So is yom kippur a day of fasting because Moses and his ppl were saved by God? Or did God command this day for fasting in the Torah? Muslim asking. Thank you and peace🤍
According to Jewish tradition, it's the second. It's commanded in the Torah.
Peace to you. Shalom.
Same reason why god commanded through Muhammad to the muslims to fast on the day of Ashura. We are just observing the event on different calendars. Though, the ruling on fasting on the day is "recommended" and not "mandatory".
تعلمو يا ناس ماهي الاخوة الانسانية
Hello. I am not religious, but I am interessting in all religoins. CAn someone give me a link to the jewish/mosaic ( maybe also islamic ) calender? I want to know, what time you are fasting :)
Muslims fasts on 9th and 10th of Muharram.
Ashura' commemorates the day that Allah saved the Children of Israel from Pharaoh.
Fasting on Muharram 10, known as the Day of 'Ashura', expiates for the sins of the past year. When the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) arrived in Madinah in 622 CE, he found that the Jews there fasted on Muharram 10 and asked them the reason for their fasting on this day. They said," This is a blessed day. On this day Allah saved the Children of Israel from their enemy (in Egypt) and so Prophet Musa [Moses] fasted on this day giving thanks to Allah."
The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said,
"We are closer to Musa than you are."
He fasted on that day and commanded Muslims to fast on this day. (Al-Bukhari)
Ibn 'Abbas reported: The Messenger of Allah fasted on the day of 'Ashura' and ordered the people to fast on it. The people said, "O Messenger of Allah, it is a day that the Jews and Christians honor." The Prophet said, "When the following year comes, Allah willing, we shall fast on the ninth also." The death of the Prophet came before the following year. (Muslim and Abu Dawud) For more on 'Ashura' and Muharram
Muslims can fast almost every day (except Eid) but it's obligatory to fast on Ramadan. Rest it's encouraged to fast on Dhul hajjah., Muharram etc
Interesting, now I know :)
I want to ask, if one non jew but who believes in God can eat of Easter Lamb. I just bought yesterday kosher meat and it turned out to be sacrificed to Pesach. I do not know what to do. Should i eat it ?
We don’t sacrifice anything since the destruction of the temples, this is either just a lie from the butcher or a sacrifice from the idolatrous Samaritans
@@ananonjonvic6623 can i eat beaf that was slaughtered in Pesach ? Maybe i misunderstood. I meant general that was slaughtered on that day or occasion?
@@BenjaminSonofJacob no problem, the temple is no more so there is no risks of being like a sacrifice. Plus, the sacrifices were made the first day of Pesach and slaughter an animal during Chabat or holidays was authorised only in the Telple for sacrifices so if a meat is kasher it can’t been slaughtered the day the sacrifices were made in the past
@@ananonjonvic6623 oh i see. but should not also sacrificial animal be a lamb ?
@@BenjaminSonofJacob yes, you're right
Pourquoi ne mettez-vous pas une traduction en arabe en bas?
Parce qu'il y a une version arabe autre part.
Merci
مرحبا ايان مسلم
الاسلام هي دين الصحيح الوحيد لاغيره و كما تقول القرآن الكريم (و خالفو اليهود)
where the hell is suha
ב''ה
في انتظار الفيديو باللغة العربية
الرابط موجود فوق.
What about the marriage of an uncle or an uncle with the daughter of a brother and sister?
the muslim woman character should wear proper hijab and long dress with long sleeves (cover hair and whole body except palm of hands)
Not every Muslim woman is a hijabi
@@Aurora-sz8by that doesn’t make sense cuz hijab and being well covered for women is one of islam’s priorities so they should represent the muslim woman in the true identity of islam
Maybe she is shi'at
Ramadha
This is weird.
Yami 0 why?
Yulia Brooks just like that.
Lol
@@biuless5275 And what about the permissibility of an uncle or maternal uncle with his sister’s daughter and his brother’s daughter, isn’t it permissible for you?
و خالفو اليهود
السلام على من اتبع الهدى في الاسلام يوجد فقط دينين دين الاسلام الي يشمل رُسُلُهُ موسى وعيسى وبقية الرسل والانبياء ودين الشيطان وهو دين الوثنيين لكن هم بدولو وغيرو وادخلو اشياء من الوثنيين.
إذًا انا من دين الشيطان.
mahmod Nun : الطوفان حول الكعبة و الأضاحي و تقبيل الحجر الأسود و التبرك فيه ليست اعمال و ثنية ؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟؟
People of the Book أهل الكتاب : 😂👏
@@arabianspringbud2642
لك لاااا على شو عم تصفقي أنت فاهمة غلط ..
و جواب إلحنان. .بالعارضة. ما سجل نقطة و الطابة⚽ رجعت عليه :)))
@@people.of.thebook
ليش أنت لا تؤمن بموسى و رسالته؟!!..
و أنت بدلت و ادخلت على العقيدة التي جاء بها موسى عليه السلام، عقائد وثنية؟ !!..
كلامه وين و أنت حطيت حالك وين :))))
المهم : 1_0 لصالحه. .
And their Allah got confused & located Haman to Egypt. Some god
?? it was in Persia. What are you talking about?
@@eugeniev-a4 Qur'an. I was talking about the Qur'an. The Muslim got his stories confused and relocated Haman from Persian Kings to Egyptian Pharaoh. Small mistake of place and epoch.
Well what do you expect from a "god" that couldn't distinguish fable from fact (Story of sleepers in the Cave & Alexander Romance)
This from Torah really proves who actually is confused
“If a man happens to meet a virgin who is not pledged to be married and rapes her and they are discovered, he shall pay her father fifty shekels of silver. He must marry the young woman, for he has violated her. He can never divorce her as long as he lives.” (Deuteronomy 22:28-29)
@@Fundamental_Islam. So?
@@eugeniev-a4 your Torah is written by your r apist rabbis
Lots of lies