Is Cultivated Meat the Future of Food? | Uma Valeti | TED
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 чер 2024
- The way we raise animals is destructive to humans, animals and the environment, says cardiologist and entrepreneur Uma Valeti. He presents a solution that doesn't require you to give up your favorite protein-packed meals: cultivated meat, grown directly from animal cells. Reportedly some of the "most chicken-y chicken" you'll taste, Valeti envisions how such cultivated meat could save billions of animal lives, improve human health and help protect our planet.
If you love watching TED Talks like this one, become a TED Member to support our mission of spreading ideas: ted.com/membership
Follow TED!
X: / tedtalks
Instagram: / ted
Facebook: / ted
LinkedIn: / ted-conferences
TikTok: / tedtoks
The TED Talks channel features talks, performances and original series from the world's leading thinkers and doers. Subscribe to our channel for videos on Technology, Entertainment and Design - plus science, business, global issues, the arts and more. Visit TED.com to get our entire library of TED Talks, transcripts, translations, personalized talk recommendations and more.
Watch more: go.ted.com/umavaleti
• Is Cultivated Meat the...
TED's videos may be used for non-commercial purposes under a Creative Commons License, Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives (or the CC BY - NC - ND 4.0 International) and in accordance with our TED Talks Usage Policy: www.ted.com/about/our-organiz.... For more information on using TED for commercial purposes (e.g. employee learning, in a film or online course), please submit a Media Request at media-requests.ted.com
#TED #TEDTalks - Наука та технологія
(Make it cheaper) + (Make it healthier) = Game over for tradicional meat
*in the long run
If you can make cultivated meat cheaper than regular meat & taste better, you will take over the industrial ag market.
Is it also possible for Milk?
It has already been done, and it's much more simple for milk. It's about to hit the shelves pretty soon.
Google entry: milk fermentation lab grown:
"Lab-grown dairy is made with all the same cells as traditional dairy, only it is created in a giant bioreactor rather than a factory farm. Here, a process known as precision fermentation is used, which is similar to what has been used for decades to brew beer, make insulin, and produce rennet for cheese."
Precise fermentation and cellular agriculture are the future. The disruption of industrial ag. and intensive animal farming have begun and will gain speed following an exponential curve. Politicians will try to slow it, but they won't succeed... sheer math shows it clearly.
The future of what?
@@Vscustomprinting of food
It may be the future the industry is trying to push on us, but it will fail, just like "impossible" meat. Cellular Agriculture cannot remove carbon from the atmosphere the way Regenerative Agriculture can. I don't know, but I'm willing to guess that it probably won't provide proper nutrients for humans either...just like impossible meat.
@@VscustomprintingThe future of our timeline. Duh.
This is the best news I’ve heard in a LONG time!!! Yes!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
The future is here! It's impressive ❤
I know that it is plant-based, but since I tasted Impossible Burgers, I have thought that I liked them at least as much as real hamburgers. I hope you succeed in bring this to market at an affordable cost.
I definitely like Impossible Burgers too. I would all for meat being replaced
it is not plant based, you are misunderstanding this. these are meet cells grown in a petry dish.
@@garcipat Pretty sure OP is referring to Impossible Burgers.
@@garcipat I meant to say the Impossible Burgers are plant based. I have no issue with cell-culture grown meat.
@@grkuntzmd Thank you for clarifying at the end!
I'm all about this idea! It's important to outline what will be done with the agricultural land after mass adoption. Finding a way to compensate animal farms through land regeneration would be a win-win. Building condos on that land will negate the impact near cultivation will have.
Totally in support of this!
There is a lot of good information here. I do feel the representation of the ethical challenges that come with implementation of lab grown meats were oversimplified.
There is so much more to this than weighing the value of tradition vs, or slaughter vs....
Yes and it will be a long journey before this becomes common. The ethical arguments and backlash will be part of that journey.
_"...the representation of the ethical challenges that come with implementation of lab grown meats were oversimplified...There is so much more to this "_ Such as?
@@OfTheGaps my answer depends on whether you are genuinely inquiring/hadn't wandered that train of thought, or simply seeking debate.
@@xoRaQxo I'm not really seeking debate. I am genuinely curious as to what the ethical downsides are that would come close to outweighing the upsides. I also think it feels slightly underhanded to complain that the ethical implications have not been addressed, and then not mention what those implications might be.
@@OfTheGaps observation more than complaint. I'm also not referring to one side or the other, just that the arguments are numerous. Even aside from religious beliefs that inevitably have a strong opinion, there's the cost analysis. There will be economic effects that go beyond the larger whole. The costs to consume, produce, market, distribute and so on. Factors increase exponentially the longer you travel a thought path here. I'm not interested in my own report or TedTalk.
I do think this matter should be brought to a full table for these discussions however.
Great presentation. I wholeheartedly support the development of cultivated meat. Our current and near future food production systems are a horrifying mess.
I live next to a dairy farm that also produces meat. I have witnessed the spraying of slurry across the pasture here, recycling the waste from the cattle feeding to grow more fodder. It's a crazy and dangerous closed cycle both for public health and animal welfare.
Only one thing I had hoped to learn was missing here. What is the production stream for nutrients in this production process?
This is the future!!! So much healthier, too!😊
Goodbye Prime ribs or bone broth but seriously it sounds like a no-brainer !
😢What about all the baby cow serum required to grow lab meat and the hardships of making the muscular fibers have the same texture as regular meat? Have they overcome that? Are there no downsides? Is this a Ted presentation for the sake of knowledge or just and ad?
I vaguely remember that I read one scientific study about replacement for that serum. That was many many months ago. I came here to hear a report of their progress but that ad like presentation with little details was disappointing. However they seem to be more confident and; make no mistake; if they can't replace that serum this product will never succeed. So maybe they did? I need to find more information ...after a presentation form expert. :\ Sigh...
If it can prevent the current mass slaughters of cows, it would still be progress. Maybe this is just a step before we can reach that level.
Pollution...start with large factories becoming clean..
Let people eat what they want..dont force people to eat just chemicals.
let's accelerate this please
Awesome!
Just wondering if It has B-12 in it, curious mind
My thoughts too. There are the nutrients, amino acids etc in meat. For me it's not just about taste or environment
This felt more like an ad than a Ted Talk tbh.
It was. He even went full-on Ron Popeil with the 'wait, there's more'. Ted has gone shill lately, a sad demise to a once great platform.
Leave it to entitled viewers to think that they know better than TED what is and what isn't a TED talk. For this particular issue it is absolutely impossible to discuss the problem without having a solution. Because people simply don't give a #### about living beings suffering as long as it not happening to them or in front of them. If you were an expert, you'd be up there giving a talk. But you're not, so you're in the ####### UA-cam comment section leaving insightful little comments. I wonder what else you have done today. I'm guessing that you've been having insightful little opinions about other things, too.
WEF Bot detected
@@chrysarium The guy shills his own company on the TED talk, no conflict of interest at all. re: living beings, I do care - about humane treatment of livestock, the poor having access to healthy food, If his solution is that good, it will make business sense and succeed. I hope he does honestly. However, did you notice he never mentioned pricing? Check his website, no place to get it. This will not be a mainstream access product, but something the elite can brag about trying at the next cocktail party. I want to hear solutions, on the ground, for the people that have food insecurity now. Oh, and the TED moniker is tarnished at best anymore, because of this kind of 'guest'. Tickets probably come with a free set of Ginsu knives.
@@chrysarium 90 seconds in, this guy lies about climate change, saying animal agriculture is the "leading cause"...not even close, look it up. When they begin like this, only the people who will believe anything stick around.
Yes!
As long as texture, taste and proteins are there same as real meat + price is same or lower(!) I could at least give it a try.
All new things always give negatives. at the beginning as people have not adapted yet
Did not mention comparative cost. Must be more expensive.
He mentions manufacturing at scale at 9:56 and increasing efficiency a couple of times because the cost is the biggest hurdle for cultured meat right now. He mentioned reducing the cost by 99%, but what he is implying with the rest of his talk is that it is still too expensive to compete with farm raised meats.
How to make a badminton ball like this.
Don't worry, most people will eat only this in few decades. It's better in everything except it is not accustomed. But how many of you live without a computer or UA-cam now? Your great grand parents would be disgusted at you. The same as their ggg-grandparents would be disgusted at them. It's normal change, keep your panic down and just taste it when you have opportunity and switch when it's cheaper.
gross
Impressive
Can't come soon enough. Animal agriculture is a horrific industry.
Factory farms are a horror, family farms are a part of nature. You are confusing the two.
@@Ribberflavenous family farms are a waste of land (-> rainforest) and arent able to serve the demand for meat
That's for sure
@Ribberflavenous What do you mean family farms are a part of nature. Family farms are man made and seperate from nature. The overwhelming majority of farms are factors farms, this idea of the family fair you have in your head are is mostly fantasy. Plus those animals go to slaughterhouses, how nice do you think they are.
@@RibberflavenousFamily farms are not “part of nature”. Ridiculous claim. It’s almost as cruel for animals, a lot less efficient and more polluting per sq.
There's no argument the practices in the animal ag industry are horrific. Why not change the practices in the animal ag industry rather than resorting to growing food in a lab that decades from now will be identified as the common denominator of a human health crisis? After everything that's happened in the last decade its the science I trust the least.
I am all for your sentiment. How do you propose changing practices in animal ag without killing the animal? That last act is part of the horrific practice.
My comment was more about treating food animals more humanely. I grew up on a 140 acre family cattle ranch where the animals were cared for and treated well. Grass fed beef that had only one bad day in their lives and even still it was done humanely.
@@vividlightwellness Regenerative, sustainable animal farming is definitely a thing. No one loves the animals more than the farmers raising them, after all :)
animal agriculture must end
The top 1% wealthy and connected will still be chomping on prime beef though
Unless lab grown is healthier/tastier.
Just like the people who's still using fountain pen and mechanical keyboards today.
There is a fact that, you want to produce chicken meat that exactly same with real chicken meat because it is really good.
Am I the only one who's been wondering what is the cost of cultivated meat?
Clear no. It won't have the same nutrients than the real meat. Yes, vegetarians can enjoy this.
Noble goal. I wonder if this will make meat a fine food product that is incredible expensive or straight illegal at some point.
It's unlikely to be illegal any time in the foreseeable future. Criminalizing normal behaviour is not a recipe for success.
I say let's give it a chance.
I’m down for veggies. This one time I was invited to an Indian wedding an the guys that made the food were cooking on the back alleys of the event, they made this Booooomb cauliflower that tasted like buffalo chicken wings. there’s lots of ways to eat vegetables and make it very delicious. But honestly I do not believe in man made chemicals and preservatives that are added to food just to make them taste like meat. Even if the expert say that these chemicals do not harm the body I know they really do.
Or...... vegetables? O.o
bravissimo
it needs to be testing in space how big and complex are the nmeatmaking labs,
What if you are too poor to make this grass food. or there is not enough resources to make it, what about fish.
I believe cultivated meat already exists in usa for pet food
G
And yet.. not a single company that makes cultivated meat has bothered applying for a check by the European Health and Food authorities.
Yeah theres other problems at scale
🫣
Wow.... Happy to hear that human can cultivate animal meat... Happy to be able to live in an incredible and amazing era!
Is that healthy
Well meat isn’t healthy. What’s your point?
so actually，it is also the same as cultivated human meat？Jesus
I mean instead of growing steak with less saturated fat, why not just grow new hearts?
Because it’s CHEAPER to prevent disease than treat it. And a lot of people die in surgery.
Well, I would rather you tell the real story, it is 100% investment and for the sole purpose of making money, to reduce the cost of production and increase the profit margin, it is not about animals wellbeing. put lab grown meat on a wide scale in the market, and you push farming animals towards extinction in few decades, because who will raise farming animals just for fun, for thousands of years humans have been raising them for food.
In few decades we will go to the zoo to see the last few cows left :)
You are painting animal food production with too broad a stroke and posing the factory farm as the norm. First, develop a cost effective and palatable replacement for the protein need that is not out of reach for the poor. Second, regulate the confinement of the livestock to livable and sanitary conditions - this mainly effects the factory farms. Most small local ranchers/farmers that operate on a humane basis because they have a conscience, interact with their animals and they are not fools. Stressed animals don't produce as well and they try to make it so that your animals just have that 'one bad day'. Yes, factory farms are a problem, the same as any corporation with shareholders removed from their product and focused solely on the bottom line.
🍻
You are refusing to acknowledge your victims. You continue to treat them as objects to own.
@@Vscustomprinting I acknowledge them as livestock, so yes they are objects that are owned. They are not human with the rights thereof. Same with pets. I do support humane treatment of pets as well as livestock - this is just good stewardship. I do not advocate you eat or believe as I do and I do not share your views. If you have a problem with meat, please don't eat it. Meanwhile ima gonna eat my cheeseburger.
If you can't taste the strong chemical flavor of bleach in rotisserie chicken, especially in leftover chicken kept in the fridge the next day, you might want to get your taste buds checked. These days, meat can be very dangerous. Having lived in the country, we ate fresh food straight from off the farm.
In the United States, our food supply chain is seriously outdated and way too slow from farm to table. Many people are perplexed by why they can't seem to satisfy their hunger. This "food noise" is often due to the fact that our food loses its nutritional value by the time it reaches our plates. You could eat all day and still not get the nutrients you need, just empty calories. This leaves us essentially starving while gaining weight. Unfortunately, poor health consequences are also inevitable in the long run.
Observation: Cultivated meat, also known as lab-grown or cultured meat, is forbidden by law in Italy.
This bioreactor meat is also banned in some states in the US.
Climate change
Cultivated Cannibalism 😂
As long as it's genuinely got all the health benefits of meat...
As much as I do believe that we should look towards alternative meats, like beyond or impossible, I think we need to have stricter standards for cultivated meat, then it could be a real solution. But also cultivated meat feels a bit… iffy. The fact that you need to shape it reminds me of incredibly processed food, and despite the fact that factory farming causes antibiotic resistance, I feel like cultivated meat wouldnt be much better. The thing about antibiotics is that bacteria are the ones that need to be killed by antibiotics otherwise they spread diseases. But when meat is not in the chicken, the chicken’s immune system won’t help causing more need for antibiotics. I just think we need better technology for cultivating meat well.
Cultivating meat can be done in extremely controlled and sterile environments where the equipment is what gets sterilized. With the right technology you could produce meat that won't be exposed to bacteria and therefore wouldn't need antibiotics
@@renegaderaid, what will happen when this cultivated meat meets with oxygen and non labor environment 🤔 a lot of questions
They ve been making it for over a year ? Whos buying it? And what is it in?
They have been making it not selling it my guy. Open your ears 👂 ☺️
😅😅😅
This concept is only good for a ted talk; however, once this idea is sold to an entrepreneur, he wont care about science or saftey but will focused solely on profit, they will introduce hormones and fillers to reduce costs while increasing prices under the guise of sustainability, potentially causing harm to consumers.
🤢🤢🤢
Just start selling it already, you have been talking about it for years now.
I believe the companies making money off of selling animal meat are blocking all of the progress besides the fact that it's a industry in its child fase
its easier to call out a problem than figure out a way to implement a solution
The production is not that easy and some countries forbid it already.
@@jotto5866Absolutely right.
Look at the ingredients list of your food bought in supermarkets its already in many mass produced food already including salad packs now
Anyone who believes this investor bait nonsense needs to go read Joe Fassler's journalism on the lab meat industry.
Chicken meat that come from egg or chicken
You will live in the pod and you will eat the bugs
Because the rich people want to keep abusing animals.. you forgot that part
@@Vscustomprinting Some people MUST eat a low inflammatory diet because of medical reasons, this diet is carnivore. It has nothing to do with people "wanting to abuse animals." What an ignorant thing to say. Also, real meat contains essential fatty acids...y'know, the stuff our body needs to function properly. It can't be replaced with vat-meat or plants.
Plant fats DO NOT convert well, and the phytochemicals in plants can cause gut inflammation, big time. Real meat isn't going anywhere. If you want to be an unhealthy vegetarian, be my guest. But don't come at us with this nonsense. P.S. I'm the opposite of "rich."
Do you know what is actually going to happen? the cultivated meat will never replace or even lower the production of the actual meat producers, which means: increasing production, more pollution and more waste. We will only have a new product to choose from....
I think you're right. It may lower ever so slightly...but most likely, eventually, we will learn this bioreactor vat-meat is not nutritionally viable...just like impossible meat.
Cultivated meat will be banned, and some states are already passing laws to ban.
The USA isn’t the world and some states are banning things that don’t exist.
🤣🤣😅😅
What’s the rationale?
It is already banned in 2 states.
@@hermitonthelake Swamp monsters gonna swamp.
But like we will still want dairy and eggs so there will still be farms
You can make dairy and eggs fromnte same process. And dairy and egg farming is horrendous to animals.
Cultivated Meat is disgusting
To the speaker, are you insane, evil, or simply completely mislead?
Ask yourself that.
What? Vat-Meat doesn't sound appealing to you?
I will one day be a guest speaker at TED
Good luck ❤❤🎉
No meat is the future.
Veganism is justice!
for the dead
Soylent Green is PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!!
As a Vegan myself. You are talking nonsense. Cultivated animal products don't cause animal slaughter. It's something that can end the animal ag industry.
My cancer specialist Doctor said I must eat fresh meat for vital nutrients that plants do not have and the body still needs to maintain a healthy body so don't get fooled by fashionable bs eating trends.
And Alkaline balanced.
No. Its poison.
No. It's not poison.
@@ericdanielski4802 how do u know its not poison do you have links to data for its safety and how long is your data points derived from ?
But it’s a cool concept tho I mean I’m still waiting for that expanding pizza from spy kids
It's easy to find the data and reporta but in Today's world we prefer to be spoon fed our information and would rather trust what someone claims than to actually try to educate ourselves using our own brains.
It's FDA approved. Conspiracy theorists in full swing in the commemnt
Answer = NO
God loves you and cares for you so that this message reaches you. God is the one who created this large universe and controls it completely. The greatest loss a person loses in this life is that he lives without knowing God who created him and knowing the Messenger of Muhammad, the last of the messengers, and the Islamic religion, the last of the heavenly religions. Great intelligence, before you believe in something or not, is to read it, study it, and understand it well, and after that you have the choice to believe in it or not to believe in it. I advise you to do this now, before you no longer have time to do so. Life is very short. It is just a test, just a passage to eternal life. Great advice to those who... Understands
I'll keep my grass fed steak. Farts and all.
Yeah seriously. What about the people who *like* to cause suffering to animals as part of their meal? What about them, huh?
@@sachamm Yeah, why should we take @robertrafer9422's right to freely murder innocent creatures out of pure malice and cowardice, for no good reason? We are incomprehensibly BAD people.
@sachamm if your farming anything your killing something. Every acre of corn has rodents etc. If your eating something, most likely an animal had to die. I'll keep my steak.
***Question to you all- what is the difference between THIS CONCEPT and taking the actual animal, grinding it into “pink ooze” and shaping it into a McNugget???***
It turns out that most animals can feel pain in the same or very similar way that humans can feel pain. It also turns out that some people don't like inflicting pain on other sentient creatures. So "THIS CONCEPT" as you put it eliminates any inflicted pain on sentient creatures. I'd say that was a good thing, right?
@@sachamm Not at the cost of your health lol. Humans evolved eating animals and some plants. Not bioreactor vat-meat.
@@hermitonthelake Ah yes, it was grown in a vat therefore it will cost you your health. That's what you call Omnivorous Logic. 👍
@@sachamm You clearly have a lot to learn about nutrition. Impossible meat was supposed to be this fantastic product too...go look at the studies on the nutritional profile. I predict this may be no different. Here in the US, the minute a corporation tells me their product is "safe & affective, I know it's not.
@@hermitonthelake Impossible Burgers are unhealthy, therefore vat grown beef will always be unhealthy. Got it.
No thanks
Richard Branson from virgin Atlantic tried it himself and liked it very much
@@samuelzev4076 Oh yeah sure he did like they took they fake c vvd v a c c ine (saline) in front of the cameras so the doppy sheep follow lol
Young people are easily fooled into new stupid ideas sadly but that's always probably been the case so goodluck
And old people cling on obsolete ideas that kill them slowly like smoking somehow makes them cool. Your point is what exactly? Ignorance is bliss? 🤣
are cells living things? do they feel pain? maybe this isnt about removing pain from the equation and more just hiding it so its unseen
I sure cells are not in the same state because it's harder to contain and torture we put inflict.
You have definitely killed some bugs in your life so i mean by your way of thinking you snuffed out a mind and gave them pain beyond belief, I get being empathetic but sometimes life’s just brutal man I mean it’s just survival plus it’s a cool idea I mean instant meat sounds good but I get your hesitation
Cells aren't individually sentient. A cell does not have a brain. What do you think the meat that comes from animals is made out of? It's made from cells.
pls next time think before asking. to feel anything an organism needs a nervous system. meatcells are something different. there is nothing alive, that could feel anything...
cells are living, yes but, they do not have a brain that feels anything. Cells are more like chemical machines.
Pain the way we feel it only can come in higher animals with neuronal cells, and they're not cultivating neuronal cells.
And even if we'd not have removed the pain (which we would), then there are still the environmental advantages, and probably health advantages.
No. Alkaline Is.
Alkaline is what?
@@KlaraZoom Future Of Food.
Have you ever google the criticisms of the "alkaline diet"? Please do.
Isn't this garbage already being banned in certain states already? 🙄🤷♂️
No it's not banned. It's better than kill meat actually
In their 2024 legislative sessions, four states - Alabama, Arizona, Florida, and Tennessee - considered legislation banning the manufacture, sale, or distribution of cell-cultured meat. Florida and Alabama both passed the legislation, and their governors signed it into law.
@@ripleyjustice6057 That's what they said about impossible meat.
@@hermitonthelake I thought I heard about it recently, thanks Herm 🍻
Only if you're uneducated
sry Zak, but as long as this meat is approved to be healthy and edible its the safest, in the longterm cheapest and environmentally friendliest way to produce meat. the resources we waste because of raising animals to slaughter them are eourmous. land, water, crops...
@@Brom97the data doesnt back this up tho. There would be alot of pollution at scale.
@@hermitonthelake I don't know where you're from. But I feel pretty safe in Europe
Short answer:
No.
Yes.
N O T
TED really fell off smh this is terrible
Lmao no, thanks 😊
NO!!
Sounds like poison.
just like your comment
It is poison your right
@@sachamm eat the fake chicken.
@@justanothergrunt9053 I will
@@r.m8146 good luck
no!
No. Absolutly not
No