Timbs v. Indiana [SCOTUSbrief]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 43

  • @DMM-cv5fh
    @DMM-cv5fh 5 років тому +8

    I teach poly sic and history at a four year liberal arts university and I love all the material the Federalist Society puts out. Use it in my classes all the time, thank you!

    • @slappy8941
      @slappy8941 5 років тому

      You teach "many thus"?

  • @HistoryNerd808
    @HistoryNerd808 5 років тому +13

    Timbs is right on this and hopefully, CAF as a whole is struck down. Gorsuch in the hearing this morning said it best, "Are we still litigating the incorporation of the Bill of Rights in 2018? Really?" I also think it's showing also that Gorsuch and Sotomayor are building a friendship in the same vein as RBG and Scalia and an ideological alliance on many questions of liberty as well.

    • @ramiroofaragon9323
      @ramiroofaragon9323 5 років тому +1

      Gorsuch becomes more interesting with time.

    • @HistoryNerd808
      @HistoryNerd808 5 років тому +3

      @@ramiroofaragon9323 It really shows the difference between the libertarian originalist(Gorsuch, Scalia) vs the conservative one(Thomas, Kavanaugh) as well as the generation gap on the right wing of the court

    • @robinsss
      @robinsss 5 років тому

      this shows why we could never have Singapore style punishment for drugs in America...……………………………..they would be struck down under the 8th amendment…………….…………………………………………….so without Draconian drug laws like in Singapore, the war on drugs would never work...……………………………..here or in England

    • @HistoryNerd808
      @HistoryNerd808 5 років тому +1

      @@robinsss Which is a very good thing

    • @robinsss
      @robinsss 5 років тому

      yes...…..……………………...but many conservatives that say the war on drugs could work don't understand that stringent laws are needed and in the west that goes against our legal structure

  • @kennethh5657
    @kennethh5657 5 років тому +7

    I think the fundamental question becomes, Is law enforcement a extension of the court or not? If not, then where does law enforcement derive thier power to enforce the law? Is not Theft the tactic of a thief?

  • @poodlescone9700
    @poodlescone9700 5 років тому +2

    So if someone did not commit a crime, then wouldn't any civil forfeiture be illegal under the 8th Amendment?

  • @freethinker5039
    @freethinker5039 5 років тому +3

    In fifty years they will forfeit your house for a speeding ticket

  • @JUDDLILIHA
    @JUDDLILIHA 5 років тому +1

    love every second of this.... thanks guys.

  • @brenthunter5078
    @brenthunter5078 5 років тому +1

    It is a law enforcement tactic, they take whatever they want, and you have to sue them to get it back if you are aquitted or even if the prosecutor decides not to go through with charging you. Civil court doesn't require proof beyond a reasonable doubt, so the d.a. always gets to keep and sell your sstuff. This does not keep us safe. I'm not sure why you even said that. It makes literally no sense.

    • @xxdfoster
      @xxdfoster 5 років тому

      Did you read the brief/summary?

  • @josephmedlow536
    @josephmedlow536 5 років тому

    Very well explained. I’m impressed :)

  • @MattGalindoRE
    @MattGalindoRE 5 років тому +1

    Victory

  • @lauriesthought1231
    @lauriesthought1231 5 років тому +2

    Indiana pretty place to live and raise young children if you homeschool them. Indiana is a very racist state, run by the good old boys system. Thankful I moved to a state where the police dept is to busy to look for ways to incarcerate regular folks minding their buisness.

    • @jeremyknight1927
      @jeremyknight1927 5 років тому

      Mary Loretta Huge drug problem in Indiana. Wouldn’t say that’s folks minding their own business. And pretty much every state has a bunch of racist people. Indiana isn’t any different from its surrounding states

    • @xxdfoster
      @xxdfoster 5 років тому

      Ya,, my state isn't the problem it's the fucking meth and heroin junkies and dealers in bed with local police. Homeschool? The fuck is wrong with a nice school like cathedral? ...