An Unhinged Deep Dive Into The CATS Fandom

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 581

  • @NotDavDraws
    @NotDavDraws 7 місяців тому +1228

    The brainrot radiating from this video, love it.
    Thanks for your service queen Carley

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +75

      this is the highest compliment

  • @dangitgrace5579
    @dangitgrace5579 7 місяців тому +954

    Watching a video about CATS that’s sponsored by a sex toy company is honestly exactly how I want to spend my valentines day and any other way is incorrect

    • @cecille5833
      @cecille5833 7 місяців тому +26

      this is what i call using God's internet in a God honoring way

  • @liminalprincess
    @liminalprincess 7 місяців тому +1071

    help? carley I didn’t even know there was a cats fandom. you help me discover something new everyday.

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +118

      so sorry to break the news to you bestie

    • @sir-dame-sander
      @sir-dame-sander 7 місяців тому +33

      cats fandom veteran here! I am so sorry. leave while you can

    • @benamisai-kham5892
      @benamisai-kham5892 7 місяців тому +12

      I always thought the original cats musical had a huge fandom, if we're talking about the new one then I'm surprised

    • @blugreen123
      @blugreen123 7 місяців тому +2

      Came here to say the same thing. I had no idea. 😂

    • @bookcat123
      @bookcat123 4 місяці тому +1

      I was absolutely into reading Cats fanfics in high school 😂
      Edit: …and I’ve just discovered that Rumblepurr’s Jellicle Chronicles is gone. Wow, sudden sad nostalgia.

  • @PurpleMonkeySox
    @PurpleMonkeySox 7 місяців тому +649

    Y’all haven’t lived until you’ve been to a cats drag show 😭❤️✨

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +195

      WHAT

    • @PurpleMonkeySox
      @PurpleMonkeySox 7 місяців тому +54

      Imagine if the cats actually did burlesque… but good not james cordon

    • @PurpleMonkeySox
      @PurpleMonkeySox 7 місяців тому

      Look up papa t*tty in the PNW

    • @junofrancis
      @junofrancis 7 місяців тому +16

      @@uncarley you've mentioned being from toronto i 10/10 recommend revue cinemas cats showing (i do not know if/when theyre doing it again but i know they've done at least 2 so far.) its a "rowdy" showing with a shadow cast some of whom are drag performers. words can not express.

    • @ghosttrain9022
      @ghosttrain9022 7 місяців тому +8

      Isn't Cats itself drag?

  • @bro.that.is.adorable.2633
    @bro.that.is.adorable.2633 7 місяців тому +351

    If you haven’t seen it yet, I highly recommend Black Nerd Comedy’s video about CATS (2019). This movie causes him to descend into madness

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +39

      omg i will watch!

    • @zanay9038
      @zanay9038 7 місяців тому +23

      Kennie JD's video is similarly unhinged/unhinging

    • @kaemincha
      @kaemincha 7 місяців тому +7

      truly it was the best video i saw about the madness of CATS at the time, and i watched a lot of videos

    • @Hessed3712
      @Hessed3712 7 місяців тому +1

      He still hasn’t recovered 🤣

    • @VenusAD
      @VenusAD 7 місяців тому +1

      Welp, I know what I'm watching next.

  • @kyoyameganebereznoff
    @kyoyameganebereznoff 7 місяців тому +154

    My defense of Cats is that every actor on that stage is both a super talented singer and a super talented dancer and they’re all performing the whole show. Plot or not, spectacle or not, it’s impressive.

    • @gracel2mart
      @gracel2mart 6 місяців тому +14

      I heard of one Cats actress giving herself a type of hip displasia only seen in cats, bc she was doing so well at the cat movements for years

  • @isabellefreitag_
    @isabellefreitag_ 7 місяців тому +248

    I love how sometimes I randomly develop intense hyperfocus on the most bizarre things, like the 2019 Cats movie and all the musical by proxy, and then Carley just grants my wish for a serious debate on the topic and drops a full 24 minute video on the subject so I don't have to have lengthy conversations with the voices in my head.
    I appreciate your service, bestie

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +52

      i make videos because i stumble upon niche things and NEED to talk about them so im happy to fill that void in your life

    • @claiternaiter446
      @claiternaiter446 7 місяців тому +5

      Same! Just a few days ago I started randomly watching old Cats video essays and all the sudden here’s a new one for us! The timing is excellent.

    • @Yahoodoraze
      @Yahoodoraze 7 місяців тому

      Im so glad I’m not alone in this 😪

  • @emmasdot
    @emmasdot 7 місяців тому +38

    The Cats soundtrack according to Carley:
    1. This is My Name and Here are Some Adjectives to Describe Me
    2. Actually Here Is My Name
    3. Midnight
    4. My Name is Jellicle
    5. Slippery Jinglebleans

  • @Sophia-rq6oo
    @Sophia-rq6oo 7 місяців тому +289

    A wise person once said “fandom isn’t activism” and tumblr (and all other fandom places this sort of thing has spread to) needs to internalise that. Fandom is the sandpit on a playground, if you feel self righteous about something then turn that energy towards actual real life issues instead of trying to control what people do in the sandpit. It’s a literal waste of energy and tbh reeks of a desperate need to control others. Get involved in local community care instead. Join a volunteering group or something. Just go offline.

    • @louc.6735
      @louc.6735 7 місяців тому +28

      lmao immediately thought of people drawing warrior cats with palestine flags. like idk on the surface it's harmless but it strikes me as... performative and cringe, idk.

  • @margaretgleason
    @margaretgleason 7 місяців тому +251

    i need you to know that i just spent a week working backstage for CATS: Young Actors Edition with a cast of 29 8-13 year old who were VERY INTO CATS. this video is healing something deep in my soul.

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +37

      OH MY GOD

    • @Man-ej6uv
      @Man-ej6uv 7 місяців тому +15

      you deserve a purple heart

    • @susannahlewis8464
      @susannahlewis8464 7 місяців тому +7

      Good lord, who decided that was a good idea???

    • @imprettyinept7012
      @imprettyinept7012 7 місяців тому +6

      Ngl 13 year old me would be happy to hear that. I'd always get confused looks whenever I brought up my genuine love for Cats, so it's nice to know all those Cats fans found each other. Although I get it, 8-13 is like the height of children being annoying lol.

  • @BooksRebound
    @BooksRebound 7 місяців тому +204

    Bold to get into the drama 20min into a 23min video lmao. Thats iconic behavior. "You will sit there, and you *will* watch me!"

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +54

      my channel is me info dumping for hours on end

  • @sir-dame-sander
    @sir-dame-sander 7 місяців тому +63

    re: “there are no themes or plots in cats” there are ABSOLUTELY themes and plots in cats but like 99% of them are on complete accident, which is frankly far far worse than there being none in the first place. most of cats can fall into place in six-ish different concise ways, none of which I think were even remotely intended by alw (by ts eliot Maybe, but that’s another story). analyzing them got so bad for me I had to make a whole 40 minute video about it. unfortunately

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +8

      omg i need to watch this video

  • @margot9349
    @margot9349 7 місяців тому +98

    a criminal lack of discussion around skimbleshanks

    • @kaylamatters
      @kaylamatters 7 місяців тому +3

      My favorite cat for sureeeee

    • @dwell7315
      @dwell7315 7 місяців тому +3

      As a music nerd I love him bc his song is in 13/4, a truly NONSENSE time signature

    • @castielabloodwings6301
      @castielabloodwings6301 6 місяців тому

      I love him!!! But my favorite is Rum Tum Tugger

  • @fairycat23
    @fairycat23 7 місяців тому +81

    Cats musical shipping discourse has such similar energy to Warrior Cats shipping discourse. Please consider making a video about that. There is so much to explore, and yet more because Warriors actually has a plot.

    • @bub4522
      @bub4522 7 місяців тому +7

      Become the cat shipping channel

    • @camille1324
      @camille1324 7 місяців тому +6

      Boy oh boy does it have a plot. Truly one of the literary canons of all time

    • @alicethemad1613
      @alicethemad1613 7 місяців тому +10

      It certainly has plots. Many of them. Some might say too many. Just the most plot ever. This is not a compliment.

    • @camille1324
      @camille1324 7 місяців тому +6

      @@alicethemad1613 idk if I’d be a *better* person if I hadn’t spent a year or two of my childhood gobbling those books down at a rate that literally caused my mother to send me to a child psychologist out of concern that I refused to spend my time doing anything but reading them or talking about them, but I’d certainly be a *different* one.

    • @alicethemad1613
      @alicethemad1613 7 місяців тому +6

      @camille1324 man I never even got past the first book and those things still consumed my life as a child. I was the kid getting into clan wars on the playground being yelled at by teachers because I refused to communicate in anything but meows and hisses.

  • @sir-dame-sander
    @sir-dame-sander 7 місяців тому +150

    as promised here in MY Insane Cats Fandom Story. formatting this greentext style bc it’d be fucking unreadable as a big block of text
    - be me
    - cats the musical fan, dumb teenager
    - in groupchat with several other cats the musical fans
    - our number one group activity is keeping up with this one fanfic, “the silver protector and me”
    - it’s 70k words of munkustrap x the author’s self insert oc
    - from the moment you pick TPSAM up it’s not great from a writing perspective but the further you read the more unhinged the plotlines get
    - everyone can shapeshift into normal cats with no explanation. the main character is french n everybody else is incredibly aroused by it. all the girl cats frequently body shame the main character for being too skinny. the love interest is abusive towards his son because he thinks he might be gay. there’s a bunch of sex slavery just like an insane amount
    - this isn’t really that alarming to us. obviously the author might sort of be goin through it but at the end of the day it’s just a fanfic
    - however. there is also an author’s note at the end of every chapter where the author (we’ll call her jazzie after her self insert) shares wayyyyy too much about her life
    - we learn a bunch through these. she’s british. she has a terrible ex. she loves the guy who’s she’s currently dating but he hates cats the musical. she’s been to cats the musical 115 times. she has a 7 year old son
    - she also links her instagram + tumblr. maybe this was a dick move of us but being teenagers we check them out
    - jazzie’s instagram is pretty normal other than the fact that everyone but her looks miserable in every photo
    - whatever. they might just have resting bitch face
    - jazzie’s tumblr is CRAZY
    - we discover that she’s been in several bona fide large scale scandals
    - you name it jazzie has posted it. most recently she’s gotten in trouble for comparing the traditional body modification of various unrelated african cultures to, and I quote, “dumb bimbos getting too much plastic surgery”
    - she’s also fighting on a daily basis with people who hate her fanfic over its various Issues, including one heated debate with an actual sex trafficking survivor
    - about a week after we start checking in on jazzie’s tumblr, she posts that she’s going to be taking a break n moving all her mutuals into a discord server
    - this server will also house the live drafting of new chapters of TPSAM
    - being idiot teenagers we decide we HAVE to get into this server to watch TPSAM get drafted live. its siren song is far too strong for morals to assuage us
    - in an attempt to gain mutualhood before jazzie leaves for good, I create my cishetsona
    - her name is abi n she’s a 17 year old girl living in indiana who loves only two things: cats the musical and her homophobic 23 year old fiancée who works in his dad’s garage
    - she’s a closet tuggoffelees shipper as well but she openly ships mistoffellees/victoria (which is for some reason the default straight ship in cats even though victoria canonically hooks up with plato. no I’m not sure why either)
    - abi begins participating in the cats the musical fandom by posting annoyingly heterosexual content
    - within one (1) week, this has gotten her into jazzie’s discord
    - a few of my co conspirators have played the same trick. there’s maybe four or five of us in there
    - inside this discord we are exposed to fandom drama we never even knew existed
    - jazzie frequently complains to the server about her current boyfriend. she hates how much he dislikes cats the musical, n hates even more that he’s always telling her to pay more attention to their kids (plural) instead of writing cats the musical sex slave fic
    - do you remember how I only mentioned the 7 year old son earlier. this is the first mention we hear of another kid
    - the next day something terrible happens
    - we MEET the other kid
    - he is 12 years old n he is a SERVER MODERATOR
    - this means he’s been fully privy to the active drafts of his mother’s super explicit cats the musical sex slave fanfic
    - apparently nobody on the server was aware this moderator was jazzie’s son either, because her genuine mutuals seem just as shocked as we do
    - at this point one of the real mutuals snaps n tells jazzie that while she loves TPSAM, kids shouldn’t be anywhere near it. a good half of the server enthusiastically agrees with this
    - jazzie takes this as a personal attack on her parenting abilities n the server fucking implodes
    - a couple days later the whole thing gets taken offline
    - abi gets a message from jazzie apologizing for the whole situation n thanking her for not attacking her like everyone else
    - I don’t have the energy left to tell her abi isn’t real, so abi says “thank you. it’s no problem”
    - there is brief discussion of reporting jazzie to some kind of authority, but we decide that’ll probably only make it worse for her kids, so we don’t
    - we figure she got the message to not involve her preteen son in the drafting of her sex slave fanfiction when all of her friends left her
    - TPSAM has not updated since. I really hope it’s because jazzie stopped neglecting her kids for it
    - it’s for the best she stopped. I hope her family is doing better now
    - but frankly I’m a bit sad we’ll never get lines like “can I cum in you?” “oui!” ever again

    • @uschilou
      @uschilou 7 місяців тому +43

      This was everything and I thank you for sharing.

    • @ricardojanate
      @ricardojanate 7 місяців тому +30

      Thank you for sharing this. I'm living for the unhinged actions of everybody involved, creating a cishetsona lol, infiltrating the servers and tracking this person online footprint down. And than there is jazzie, oh god. Truly unhinged behavior, but more of an electric chair than be friends with, truly insane girlboss gatekeep gaslight behaviour.

    • @ufollie
      @ufollie 7 місяців тому +26

      cishetsona plzzzz

    • @RespektTheBovril
      @RespektTheBovril 7 місяців тому +17

      Thank you for sharing this with us, this is what the internet was created for. Also obsessed with the concept of a cishetsona

    • @juliayang3294
      @juliayang3294 7 місяців тому +5

      i love this. thank you so much

  • @raekwonmalik
    @raekwonmalik 7 місяців тому +74

    not exactly the gift i expected to receive on valentines day, but i’m grateful nonetheless! thanks carley ❤

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +9

      happy valentines day!

  • @jurassicsnark
    @jurassicsnark 7 місяців тому +74

    14:20 I always thought mungojerrie and rumpleteazer were siblings

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +19

      right?? it feels like they're siblings

    • @lalas181
      @lalas181 7 місяців тому +4

      They have huge sibling vibes to me, too, imo.

    • @WaftingCurtains
      @WaftingCurtains 7 місяців тому +1

      I def always thought they were siblings.

    • @quesorealp
      @quesorealp 7 місяців тому +5

      Theyre usually not, but yeah it turned into REALLY popular fanon a few years ago

    • @imprettyinept7012
      @imprettyinept7012 7 місяців тому +9

      It depends on production. Sometimes they have sibling vibes, sometimes they have couple vibes (like in the two recent(ish) Mexico tours where Mungojerrie slaps Rumpleteazer's ass before the cartwheel); cats has no real cannon and any of the cats can be related, dating, or friends depending on the production. That being said, Cats replicas have (unfortunately) been getting more streamlined in recent years so there's a more consistent cannon (but tbh I hate some of the choices like young Grizabella or Macavity being Old Deut's son but that's a me problem) but most of the fandom nowadays generally abides by the rule "no cannon" (all this shit went down several years ago after the 2019 film) and knows that there isn't a correct answer to any of the cats' interpersonal relationships.

  • @ellaronci2703
    @ellaronci2703 7 місяців тому +79

    i didnt think this channel could get any more unhinged....but here we are

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +4

      hahahaha THANK YOU

    • @ellaronci2703
      @ellaronci2703 7 місяців тому

      @@uncarley so glad to be here 😂💕

  • @Helenex23
    @Helenex23 7 місяців тому +151

    I watched cats when i was a kid, i always thought it was just a fever dream i had

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +15

      honestly fair

  • @ephemeraltrash6209
    @ephemeraltrash6209 7 місяців тому +39

    ok as for the mungojerry/rumpleteaser drama, I once adopted a cat whose parents were siblings, and yeah she did have a bunch of extra toes and as rocks, but my point is that cats don't know as much about genetics as we do.

  • @tocotronicon
    @tocotronicon 7 місяців тому +37

    i also think they're siblings, but lbr, that fact has never kept people from shipping two characters before

  • @dillm412
    @dillm412 7 місяців тому +45

    I was in a production of Crazy for You and someone in the cast found a really old, homemade website where somebody had hand-drawn each character in Crazy for You as a jellicle cat. The cats fandom goes to unknown depths

  • @godoggo9346
    @godoggo9346 7 місяців тому +16

    It is the “Heavyside Layer” not heavenside. But your freestyling of a song about “words that describe me” was so on point that it’s overall a very accurate background/intro section.
    Ok so you mentioned the movie is based on the musical based on the book. But did you know the book is based on stories T.S. Elliot told his niece, and also some made up words his niece would say. Like “jellicle cats” comes from her little british toddler pronunciation of “jolly little cats,” there is also the rival troupe of “pollicle dogs” whoch comes from “poor little dogs.”

  • @emerycorner
    @emerycorner 7 місяців тому +92

    when the cats movie came out, i kept sending screenshots of the characters to my friend and that scared them

  • @nightcrysalin
    @nightcrysalin 7 місяців тому +43

    Cats feels like a Riverdale plot

  • @daisymae6
    @daisymae6 7 місяців тому +76

    My secondary school did cats for their yearly drama production when I was 13 or 14. It was an interesting decision.

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +14

      OH MY GOD

    • @graceelizabeth130
      @graceelizabeth130 7 місяців тому +6

      ours did hairspray...(doing it again this year) with a MAJORITY white school 🤢

    • @Hessed3712
      @Hessed3712 7 місяців тому +1

      Definitely a choice.

    • @lucyo9636
      @lucyo9636 7 місяців тому

      Mine too and I was IN IT 😭

  • @loulyz9422
    @loulyz9422 7 місяців тому +47

    Exactly the person I want to spend my Valentine’s Day with

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +9

      happy valentines day bestie!

  • @sir-dame-sander
    @sir-dame-sander 7 місяців тому +35

    re: tuggofflees. I’ve never been a very active shipper myself but it’s always been so funny to me how people keep trying to cancel them for having a “problematic narrative” when there’s no consistent narrative between them. sure, maybe actors will flirt depending on which production you’re seeing but that’s the extent of it. all this “who’s the boy who’s the girl” “mistoffellees is like a child” (INSANE thing to say in general) “tugger doesn’t listen when people say no” is I guarantee you based 100% on one or two incredibly specific fanfics they read. the only canonically abusive relationship in cats (n one of the only canon relationships in cats in general) happened between demeter + macavity, we know this for sure since she’s explicitly hiding from him the whole show. there is Nothing like that going on with literally any other pairing

    • @sir-dame-sander
      @sir-dame-sander 7 місяців тому

      sorry for leaving like 3+ comments I only have one more n I promise it’s an insane cats fandom story

    • @AGK1999FE
      @AGK1999FE 7 місяців тому +6

      Yes. Who cares. Also idk, I don't like the "gender roles" and "who's the boy and who is the girl" thing. Guys are allowed to be small and feminine. Girls are allowed to big and masculine. I just don't see relationships that way, I see it as a character being with a character

    • @sir-dame-sander
      @sir-dame-sander 7 місяців тому +3

      @@AGK1999FE exactly, yeah. I suppose it becomes a problem when that’s the *only* way relationships are ever portrayed but it’s still a very real dynamic that people just have sometimes. also when it comes to a stage show like cats appearance (and to an extent personality) is EXTREMELY subjective anyway thanks to hundreds of different actors playing the same written role. there have been plenty of small tuggers + large mistos, I’ve seen tugger played like a femme glamrocker n mistoffellees played like a classically masculine dandy. hell tugger was even a mid 2000s rapper for a little bit in the london revival. appearance/personality in theatre really just depends on who’s playing who n when

    • @quesorealp
      @quesorealp 7 місяців тому +1

      I have not seen anybody in the fandom trash on tuggoff for reasons other than being “overated”, but to be fair i’ve only known about it since 2022. All of that is so wild since actors characterization’s in Cats vary so much it!! Some fanfics are weird, sure, but they’re just that, fanfics.

    • @sir-dame-sander
      @sir-dame-sander 7 місяців тому +2

      @@quesorealp YOU ARE SO SO LUCKY. IVE SEEN DISCOURSE I CANT EVEN COMPREHEND TO THIS DAY

  • @syd3360
    @syd3360 7 місяців тому +26

    In the delirium of 2020 all me and my housemates watched for like 2 weeks was the cats stage recording and THAT was when i realised i was a mentally ill queen
    Thank u for validating my life choices xoxo

  • @helloihaveacoupon
    @helloihaveacoupon 7 місяців тому +37

    i don’t know anything about cats, but i’m still going to watch this cause it’s carley🤷🏻‍♀️

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +2

      you are so kind!

  • @thewrongcrowd6311
    @thewrongcrowd6311 7 місяців тому +5

    i really want to start a discussion around gay fiction written by women for women, because as a gay man i can always tell... if its a first person pov the main character is often a stand in for a woman pov, its a gay man who's written like a heterosexual woman: he's often the bottom in the relationship, is submissive, described as small etc. Also the way the sex/romance is depicted mimics what women traditionally find hot and attractive, it's made to appeal to a female audience and is not actually accurate to how most gay men experience sexuality and romance most of the time (and thats not even beginning to cover how gay sex written by someone who obviously has never had anal sex is HILARIOUS to read because its like oh honey no it does not work that way...)

  • @ciarabecker9800
    @ciarabecker9800 7 місяців тому +5

    There is literally no interpersonal text between the characters. All their relationships are inferred by the body language of the actors and thus change from show to show.
    And there are people on the internet who will tell you that it is immutably immoral to ship cats.

  • @MagnifineGlass
    @MagnifineGlass 7 місяців тому +27

    Thank you for sacrificing your sanity for us haha! You're like the protective layer between me and pop culture I'm scared of 😂

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +4

      so happy to help!

    • @MagnifineGlass
      @MagnifineGlass 7 місяців тому

      ❤ happy Valentine's day!! Hope you feel all the love pouring your way 😊 ​@@uncarley

  • @julieannelovesbooks
    @julieannelovesbooks 7 місяців тому +5

    I am so confused. How did I get here. Why am I here? Help?

  • @chr.ist.ian_v2517
    @chr.ist.ian_v2517 7 місяців тому +29

    Why am I legitimately locked in to this drama rn. Please 😭

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +4

      SAME tho when i found out about this i literally locked in

  • @BandanaBoy78
    @BandanaBoy78 7 місяців тому +16

    unhinged to drop this video on Valentine’s Day. unhinged to say “insertable tail” on this ad read. Thank you for your service

  • @mariusmiller5702
    @mariusmiller5702 7 місяців тому +16

    this video has singlehandedly pointed me out in the crowd and so here are my notes as a certified CATShead:
    -mungojerrie and rumpleteazer are either a bonded pair of cats or from the same litter, as outlined in some of the extraneous texts and the subtext of their song.
    -shipping kittens is generally frowned upon because of the obvious human standards. unfortunately street cats do not give a shit about all that. plus, the whole orgy thing. also none of it is real
    -I think as far as all shipping in this fandom goes...."Hal, it's about cats." perhaps we should calm down or lower the standards because its literally spandex and lycra felines singing showtunes for two hours about the behaviours of a house animal... it might not be that deep. I understand why it can FEEL that deep, but I promise there are real gay people in real life who need advocacy more than "fursonas from children's poems on broadway" do.
    when it comes to CATS(and most fan spaces, honestly) and I want to get upset about something or hit back with some kind of scathing reply I imagine myself saying it in front of a family member and suddenly it becomes clear how unhinged and out of touch it sounds.
    btw this is somehow one of the more embarassing things I've publicly commented about. christ. I'm a cats fan in a youtube comment section. anyways hope this helped... someone.

  • @Emilia-hj5xw
    @Emilia-hj5xw 7 місяців тому +5

    you had me googling 'cat musical orgy' and I think Im on a government list now

  • @samamander404
    @samamander404 7 місяців тому +24

    I think we can all agree that while Cats is absolutely the fever dream we remember it as, Memory was, is, and always will be a soul-breaking bop 🙌

    • @WaftingCurtains
      @WaftingCurtains 7 місяців тому +1

      I tear up almost every time I hear it

    • @caroline7420
      @caroline7420 7 місяців тому +3

      Honestly memory is probably the only reason it’s still on Broadway. By intermission people are terrified and scarred but at last there is that one stunning masterpiece of a balled at the end to right the wrongs that have taken place.

  • @iylamstoy
    @iylamstoy 7 місяців тому +15

    Fun fact, my spouse and I’s first date was watching Cats 2019 in theaters. We were both like this looks terrible wanna go see it? We are married now and also currently watching Riverdale because of you.

    • @alicethemad1613
      @alicethemad1613 7 місяців тому +2

      That’s a diamond solid relationship. You two are literally bound together by bad media

  • @mossalto
    @mossalto 7 місяців тому +7

    I think the primer on what the deal with Cats actually is should be Lindsay Ellis' video on how the hell Cats happened and Sideways' video on how the film just entirely missed the very little point the musical actually had, with this video as a nice chaser of how batshit people can be about literally anything

  • @EmberAwoken
    @EmberAwoken 7 місяців тому +12

    I HAVE BEEN SUMMONED!! 2:46 Explaining how cousins works is literally my favorite thing! So first cousins share a set of grandparents. Second cousins share great grandparents and so on. Your first cousins’ child would still be your first cousin but once removed (there is one generation difference between you). That child’s child would be twice removed. Your child would be second cousins to that child. It’s quite easy once you know exactly what “once removed” means.

  • @natbatrat-d7e
    @natbatrat-d7e 7 місяців тому +8

    weirdest episode of “siblings or dating?” i’ve ever seen

  • @Faeree
    @Faeree 7 місяців тому +8

    I blame Cats 2019 for the pandemic. Rise of Skywalker as well.

  • @GullibleGallbladder
    @GullibleGallbladder 7 місяців тому +3

    I‘ma be honest - even if i might be a party pooper - none of this is anything a real cats fan would even argue about. There was no ill intent behind any depictions, rumtumtugger and mr mistofelees may be gay, they may not (probably but who cares really), kittens are just young cats (think about real cats, „kittens“ have litters of their own all the time, theyre just like young adults but theyre CATS so why are you thinking this deeply into it) but in the end - this is just a feel-good musical about quirky cats and their quirky characters. It pains me to see it disected and basically ripped to moral shreds for no reason.

  • @ahaziahjoshua1397
    @ahaziahjoshua1397 7 місяців тому +20

    Carly telling us nearly every video that its a bad one to start off on is hilarious

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +4

      at this point i dont even know what video is a good one to start at

  • @septiceye_3706
    @septiceye_3706 7 місяців тому +37

    I absolutely love how the sponsored segment gives "talking to your distant relatives on Skype in 2011" energy. 😭😭😭😭 That really sent me down on memory lane for a bit.

  • @whatalsaid
    @whatalsaid 7 місяців тому +7

    I miss the person I was 23 minutes ago BEFORE I found out about the Cats online fandom,

  • @allyson--
    @allyson-- 7 місяців тому +2

  • @rnr212
    @rnr212 7 місяців тому +4

    "MY name is JingleBEANS and I like to playtheguitar and I AM KIND but ALso SLIPPery" as a legitimate imitation of Andrew Lloyd Webber's lyrics had me cackling

  • @SnapeArgento
    @SnapeArgento 7 місяців тому +16

    I was a part of the musical theatre fandom (so I had interactions with the cats fandom), There's an edit with rum tum and jemima with the original song from glee "pretending", and many MANY fanart of them

  • @karakask5488
    @karakask5488 7 місяців тому +13

    I was a kid when Cats came out, and people were obsessed! There were definitely fawning news segments and people waiting in line. It was a whole thing... that I promptly forgot until the horror movie came out in 2019. Thanks for digging up some (possibly traumatizing) memories.

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +5

      it was CATS-mania!

  • @user-lp3ew1xb5u
    @user-lp3ew1xb5u 7 місяців тому +9

    This show was advertised in the same dramatic tone as Apocalypse Now - like something with MAJOR integrity and art when I was growing up in the 90s. That's the vibe that sold tickets back then I guess. I'm sure there's some old commercials somewhere on UA-cams. The songs ARE iconic.

  • @schmegan2
    @schmegan2 7 місяців тому +6

    today i learned the cats fandom drama is pretty much exactly like the hetalia fandom drama and if you understand those words im so sorry

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +5

      oh no another rabbit hold to fall down

    • @Joannachin
      @Joannachin 7 місяців тому +1

      I understood your words

    • @lalas181
      @lalas181 7 місяців тому +1

      I hate that this feels correct. /lh

  • @honorhonor4458
    @honorhonor4458 7 місяців тому +9

    a deep dive on the most romantic musical ever on valentines day!

  • @Sugarcube12897
    @Sugarcube12897 7 місяців тому +3

    Bro I'm in tears that song was beautiful and then I come back to you singing lines/ scat singing about being a cat 😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @ashleynorton
    @ashleynorton 7 місяців тому +1

    Hal…it’s about cats

  • @libby8920
    @libby8920 7 місяців тому +10

    i am loving these fun videos so much

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +2

      omg thank you! i am having a blast making them

  • @LoversLane16
    @LoversLane16 7 місяців тому +5

    I played Victoria at age EIGHT in a dance recital. Full cat head and unitard. WHO LET THIS HAPPEN. WHO PITCHED THIS TO ME.

  • @meganriley253
    @meganriley253 7 місяців тому +12

    Having sudden memories of watching Caroline in the City back in the 90s. It was a sitcom where the funny neighbor characters job was 'dancer in Cats' so she was often turning up in full costume doing weird stuff.

    • @mariaraquelfs
      @mariaraquelfs 7 місяців тому

      Such a good sitcom that's forgotten. Lauren Graham playing a side character is enough to be in mu top 10 90s sitcoms

  • @Mecharnie_Dobbs
    @Mecharnie_Dobbs 7 місяців тому +5

    14:20 Victoria seems underage in the film. It's not stated. It's a vibe.

  • @kittikataclysmic
    @kittikataclysmic 7 місяців тому +3

    My high school drama teacher really really hated Cats. Like with a burning passion. All you had to do if you didn’t want to do class, was mention Cats, and she'd go on half hour rants about how much Cats sucks and how bad it is. Really great way to waste class time and also really funny.
    I was still in high school when Cats the movie came out, and everyone knew it was gonna suck. So, a bunch of theatre kids from my high school got like all the seats at a showing of Cats and tricked my drama teacher to show up to the theatre. The entire movie theatre was filled up with high school theatre kids and 1 adult who was tricked into being there. And she hated Cats. It was a whole event.
    Unfortunately (or, perhaps, fortunately), the theatre kids who planned all of this and invited everyone forgot to invite me and my sister. Like, the next day in school, they were asking me where i was and why i didn’t show, and they genuinely thought they told us the info. But they didn’t and we got accidentally left out. And my sister and i have never seen Cats the movie musical. I blame Cats the movie for every bad thing that's happened since, including the pandemic. You should look into the Warrior Cats fandom.

  • @explodingmangos3416
    @explodingmangos3416 6 місяців тому +2

    Carley I love you and you have all of the correct opinions about musicals, I will pay you $50 just to talk with you for an hour and be your friend (I think you're worth more than that but I'm poor)

  • @HanneVr-_-._.
    @HanneVr-_-._. 7 місяців тому +6

    I absolutely love cats the musical (tho never enough to be considered in the fandom) so when the movie came out I was so annoyed people didn’t take the musical serious. That being said the musical is absolutely NOT SERIOUS WHATSOEVER. A great video about cats is the one from sideways. A masterpiece😌

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +1

      the movie destroys the musical

    • @HanneVr-_-._.
      @HanneVr-_-._. 7 місяців тому

      @@uncarley oh absolutely! But it did bring a newfound appreciation for the musical to some people so that’s a little win.

  • @_evanwalsh_
    @_evanwalsh_ 7 місяців тому +4

    why do all the cat's names sound like slurs 😭 ty for delivering us this important news carley it needed to be heard

  • @IanFontova
    @IanFontova 7 місяців тому +1

    This channel has improved my life. It provides the exact kind of knowledge that I want to fill my brain storage with. I lke to think that it's a limited storage and I'm making this choice

  • @katieward9701
    @katieward9701 7 місяців тому +7

    Carley, one of your best. What valuable information. Such a privilege to be able to consume content and immediately know which characters will have fanfic.

    • @katieward9701
      @katieward9701 7 місяців тому +3

      Anime is another fun one to do this with. You can tell who’s getting called babygirl on tumblr by a single glance

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +2

      omg thank you this is so so kind it warmed my cold heart

  • @KaelaCeleste
    @KaelaCeleste 7 місяців тому +3

    can’t explain how much this video means to me as a cats apologist

    • @lcruisin
      @lcruisin 7 місяців тому

      Ariana, what are you doing here?! I love your Cats video!!!

  • @meddlesome-
    @meddlesome- 7 місяців тому +1

    not the way they said not being interested or not displaying interest are the same for characterization. my guy that is the whole point of fiction. you present things as they could not be in the real world. the author knows he consented, they wrote him.

  • @h_wolf1464
    @h_wolf1464 7 місяців тому +2

    Have i ever watched cats or had any interest in it (except 1 banger)? Nope. Did that stop me at any point from clicking on this video (&enjoying it immensely)? Noope .

  • @erikdaniels0n
    @erikdaniels0n 7 місяців тому +8

    I had no idea Carly was a musical theatre girlie. We love to see it

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +8

      unfortunately i am yes

    • @erikdaniels0n
      @erikdaniels0n 7 місяців тому +2

      @@uncarleyme too slay queen

  • @jazzycat8917
    @jazzycat8917 7 місяців тому +5

    If Jerrie and Teaser weren't supposed to be interpreted as siblings, then why does the costuming/makeup ALWAYS have them as identical calicos?
    That to me is the give away, if they are unrelated then there is zero reason for why the outfis have to be matching so they're always both calicos, that was a deliberate choice. That combined with their context says to me "siblings in crime".

    • @AnnoyingMystery
      @AnnoyingMystery 7 місяців тому +1

      Because their whole song is about them getting away with crimes/mischief because no one ever knows which of them is which. Cats can be identical to eachother even without being related, so it's just a fun little thing lol. I personally prefer them as twins but it really just depends on the production/actors.

  • @lizabee484
    @lizabee484 7 місяців тому +4

    Lmfao I literally saw the national tour last year and got to hang out with the cast for a hot second. And the idea that one of them would stumble across this video or the CATS fandom is…. So fun and funny to me.
    Also they were all so talented and sweet and kind, very lovely people!

  • @gabriellepotvin8052
    @gabriellepotvin8052 7 місяців тому +6

    As someone that made a présentation full of screenshots of the cats movies for a paper I did for a class for my master's degreee ,It is madness

  • @20mgzoloft
    @20mgzoloft 7 місяців тому +9

    i didn't expect this video at all but im here for it

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +2

      you can never pin me down

  • @WaftingCurtains
    @WaftingCurtains 7 місяців тому +2

    As soon as you mentioned fandom drama I was like oh boy this is going to be about shipping isn't it????
    I love Cats and always will, I've seen it in the theaters a lot of times. Memory is my favorite musical song. Thanks for this.
    (I also have assumed they're siblings.)

  • @mikaylamcfadden7866
    @mikaylamcfadden7866 7 місяців тому +2

    I went to a rowdy showing of this and it did not disappoint. This is best drunk with friends. Never want to seee it again

  • @TheCroniclesOfMe
    @TheCroniclesOfMe 7 місяців тому +4

    Carley did this for us*
    *me and my bestie who suffered/starred in a community theatre production of Cats and we both love your videos

  • @clareb111
    @clareb111 7 місяців тому +1

    Ok but have you heard of the fandom surrounding Starlight Express, Andrew Lloyd Webber’s lesser known musical about roller skating trains????

  • @alicethemad1613
    @alicethemad1613 7 місяців тому +1

    “I love having a brain and the ability to consume fiction critically!”
    (Claims that a ship is canonically problematic because some people draw it or write it in a way they don’t like in their NON CANON FAN WORKS)
    Where is the brain? I would like to see it.

  • @Kay-wp8xf
    @Kay-wp8xf 7 місяців тому +4

    My aunt, the music teacher at my elementary school, played Cats when I was in her class. I remember thinking it was weird. Looking back... I don't think she knew what she had put in the VHS for hwr full class of third graders.

  • @D415Y-x0
    @D415Y-x0 7 місяців тому +4

    omg bestie i love seeing you go on a downward spiral of questionable media

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +3

      thank you bestie

  • @alexjames7144
    @alexjames7144 7 місяців тому +1

    Never have I felt more seen, than knowing there's someone out there petty enough to create a 3,000 word essay detailing why their least favourite ship in cats is problematic, referencing historic events in queer liberation.
    I don't know the full context or content of the post and yet, I don't need to. I just KNOW that they are valid and I relate to them on a spiritual level.

  • @louc.6735
    @louc.6735 7 місяців тому +1

    dear pro and anti shippers: please read actual books, thank you. i'm talking like critically acclaimed books that exist to make you think, not monster romances and colleen hoover. please. stop. reading. fanfiction.

  • @moonjunuwu
    @moonjunuwu 7 місяців тому +4

    this entire video is like when you’re writing an essay and you realise that about 600 words ago you started ranting and it all makes no sense

  • @baviddeckham411
    @baviddeckham411 7 місяців тому +3

    my weirdest fandom is definitely you

  • @thrawn4emp
    @thrawn4emp 7 місяців тому +2

    It's so much more fun watching other fandom drama 😭😭😭 i feel like everyone in a fandom should watch this so we can see how absolutely ridiculous our shit is (lookin' at you ofmd)

  • @bunnyellabell
    @bunnyellabell 7 місяців тому +3

    in my honors english class we read the poems the musical is based on and had a choice to act out or dress up as much as we want. i made cat ears and wore them to class and it was so fun. who did my teacher assign to me? grizabella! :) i also had to do rum tum tugger because my group partner didn't show to class. i love the original cats musical so much! rum tum tugger, mungojerrie & rumpleteazer, and magical mister mistoffelees are my fav performances.
    also it's important to explain that the book is about cat personality types! like rum tum tugger is a cat who is super picky and independent. mistoffelees is the cat who is super sneaky and plays tricks. i believe the lore is these domestic cats get a special name depending on their personality and actions, and that's how the cats know them by. kinda like how dusty is also firepaw/heart/star when he joins thunderclan. it's like cat culture lore lol. but i think that's why the play lacks any substantial plot; the book is literally just "this cat so sneaky so quiet he must be magician. his special name is mistoffelees" honestly they could've done better && the 2019 movie should not exist!!! :)

  • @norawin
    @norawin 7 місяців тому +1

    timestamp 9:43 Elaine page is such a beautiful singer and she really embodies the role. I also really liked her version of "don't cry for me Argentina" at ALW's birthday celebration at the royal Albert concert hall.

  • @peachylego
    @peachylego 7 місяців тому +4

    When my cousins & I were between the ages of 3 & 7 years old, we saw the play in person with our families. We loved it so much that we asked to buy the VHS recording and CD so that we could act it out in the living room every night for months lmao

  • @frankievalentine6112
    @frankievalentine6112 7 місяців тому +2

    No one has ever explained CATS to me before and I'm so glad it was you, Miss Carley. Finally I understand something that has always seemed beyond understanding. 😆😆😆

  • @Hannahmorgane
    @Hannahmorgane 7 місяців тому +1

    Wrong, the best version of memories is actually diary of a wimpy kid

  • @frankievalentine6112
    @frankievalentine6112 7 місяців тому +1

    How do we think TS Elliot would feel about it?? Ok or kinda rolling over in his grave??

  • @Lety-Ferreira
    @Lety-Ferreira 7 місяців тому +1

    the fact that shipping/age discourse has reached the depths of the Cats fandom makes me lose all faith in humanity honestly

  • @erikdaniels0n
    @erikdaniels0n 7 місяців тому +11

    omg a new Carly deep dive. Happy Valentine’s Day to us!

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому +4

      happy valentines day!

  • @modkip25
    @modkip25 7 місяців тому +1

    I stopped using tumblr like 2 years ago and... I did NOT miss the mind boggling stupid discourse on that website 😂 people really do be trying to play the morally superior card, the brain rot is real lmao

  • @jamie1343
    @jamie1343 7 місяців тому +1

    I don’t think you understand how “for me” this video really is

  • @elizanewton5049
    @elizanewton5049 4 місяці тому +1

    you should make video on merrily we roll along and just sing its praises

  • @-rianna
    @-rianna 7 місяців тому +2

    who needs a bf on valentines when ur parasocial bestie posts a deep dive explaining the most unhinged lore in existence??? happy galentines bestie

    • @uncarley
      @uncarley  7 місяців тому

      yessss happy galentines

  • @whyisyoutubeshowinghandles
    @whyisyoutubeshowinghandles 7 місяців тому +1

    The song "Memory" briefly appears in Rio 2, of all things. That has nothing to do with anything, I just needed to share.
    Also, not to sound like a nitpick(that's exactly what I'm doing, sorry) but I thought the "singing about themselves" thing was just in the 2019 train wreck version of Cats? All the songs I've seen are from the 1998 version and they seem to mostly be cats singing about what other cats have done for the group. I haven't actually seen the musical though, so most of my knowledge comes from youtube videos and an irl friend who had a massive Cats phase.

    • @whyisyoutubeshowinghandles
      @whyisyoutubeshowinghandles 7 місяців тому

      I'm just going to add replies to things that catch my attention as I go through the video because I don't feel like editing my original comment
      I genuinely always assumed Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer were like, those chaotic and michevious besties. A Team Rocket type of duo, if you will.
      Having said that, the "siblings vs dating" discourse is weirdly relatable as a Vocaloid fan whose favorite Vocaloids happen to be the Kagamines.