The NEW Ultimate Minecraft HORROR Mod Tier List

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
  • The NEW Ultimate Minecraft HORROR Mod Tier List
    With hundreds of new horror mods coming out it begs the question which ones are actually good. I went through the pain of playing most of them and ranked the best ones in a tierlist so all of you can have the best Minecraft HORROR experience.
    📱 Follow Me:
    Join my discord: / discord
    Follow my twitter: / pandehyt
    #tierlist #minecrafthorror #mcyt

КОМЕНТАРІ • 153

  • @AussieKitKat
    @AussieKitKat 21 день тому +70

    most of the mods you put up the top are dweller reskins. And your opinions on those in the highest tier seem to be based on community response instead of what you really think, most of this is L opinions.

    • @UP51L
      @UP51L 15 днів тому +3

      I hate when popular things are popular, too.

    • @AussieKitKat
      @AussieKitKat 15 днів тому +5

      @@UP51L What was popular was effortless garbage that was overhyped

    • @avatar00987
      @avatar00987 12 днів тому +1

      Yeah I disagree with a lot but any opinion is an opinion not an L one

  • @minecad2828
    @minecad2828 22 дні тому +78

    Imo, Cave Dweller Evolved shouldn't be at the top since it's literally just a stolen resource pack published as a mod

    • @brguii
      @brguii 21 день тому +2

      i believe you mean the cave dweller reimagined, the cave dweller evolved is the source of all 1.19.2 dweller mods, including reimagined

  • @kermitthedepressedfrog5291
    @kermitthedepressedfrog5291 Місяць тому +27

    I can't agree with you o the Midnight Lurker. I think it's one of the best. The way it watches you, slowly creeps twoards you, multiplies?!, peeks around corners and comes out of the ground to scare you is pretty unique. It doesn't just attack on sight. It actually makes you feel very uneasy

    • @emmidiefriedliebende4940
      @emmidiefriedliebende4940 21 день тому

      I absolutely agree with that! Also, I really like the design… Most of the dwellers are just ugly, but the midnight lurker has an interesting body shape that makes it look even more creepy!

    • @kosovthehonse
      @kosovthehonse 11 днів тому

      you can kill it very easily and doesnt do too much

  • @gamerplays8401
    @gamerplays8401 Місяць тому +108

    I feel like The Silence is like the most horrorfying fucking thing ever.

    • @user-dt6rp9dn8l
      @user-dt6rp9dn8l Місяць тому +9

      yeah but you almost cant do anything like walking sprinting being in water

    • @NcxLights
      @NcxLights Місяць тому +3

      Fr the jumpscares made me close my game is 0000.1 second

    • @lowchlna
      @lowchlna Місяць тому +5

      the creator fucked silence over hard

    • @brondlini5459
      @brondlini5459 Місяць тому +4

      I thought that too, until I realized it's just constant jumpscares.

    • @htrt7658
      @htrt7658 22 дні тому

      @@user-dt6rp9dn8l you can add your own mods..

  • @VanillumHC
    @VanillumHC 18 днів тому +8

    who let him cook

  • @slifer7535
    @slifer7535 Місяць тому +48

    Btw Siren Head isn't a dweller it was created by Trevor Henderson

    • @GB-sr9kv
      @GB-sr9kv Місяць тому

      💀💀bro what does this mean

    • @FireRaptor05
      @FireRaptor05 Місяць тому +23

      @@GB-sr9kv it means hes not a dweller. he is a monster originally created by horror artist Trevor Henderson a few years back

    • @subway2227
      @subway2227 27 днів тому +6

      @@GB-sr9kv Is your brain intact? They just explained it

    • @GB-sr9kv
      @GB-sr9kv 27 днів тому

      @@subway2227 is your brain intact? not once did he call the siren head a dweller dumbass

    • @jpvthegamer1209
      @jpvthegamer1209 26 днів тому +8

      This comment reminds me of when people thought Siren Head was an SCP

  • @PiterAviation
    @PiterAviation 15 днів тому +30

    Never let bro cook...💀🙏

  • @rhythmkittyfever
    @rhythmkittyfever 2 дні тому

    ngl i feel like pitting some of these mods against eachother is kinda like comparing apples to oranges? like the og cave dweller and from the fog are both mods that are meant to add onto the already existing subtle horror of minecraft, whereas mods like the man from the fog or some of the dweller reskins are literally just dropping a horror game monster into minecraft. obviously there's nothing wrong w that, lots of people obviously really enjoy the new challenge that brings but it does feel kinda stacked against mods that want to fit the already existing minecraft formula xP

  • @dapperdab4530
    @dapperdab4530 Місяць тому +6

    I'm making a modpack that just adds as much content as possible. I'm not trying to make it perfectly balanced, but I don't want it to be too unfair. But I've been wanting to add some horror mods, but not dwellers, or anything that just goes: "Ah ha! I've appeared out of nowhere, blasted your ears off, and now you're dead!". If there is such thing as a horror mod that dosent do that, perhaps even had some progression, please tell.
    Also the modpack is for 1.20.1, and don't suggest born in chaos, I already have it installed, and it's one of my favorite mods

    • @Hethatapproaches
      @Hethatapproaches 28 днів тому

      dude whats ur modpack name?? i genuinely would have it

    • @TH3V01DF0X
      @TH3V01DF0X 22 дні тому

      give us the modpack!!!

    • @TH3V01DF0X
      @TH3V01DF0X 22 дні тому

      like please every other one is like either too laggy or just instant ear death

    • @dapperdab4530
      @dapperdab4530 22 дні тому +1

      @@Hethatapproaches It's not published, it was supposed to be a personal modpack, but if you're interested I'll post it and send the name. I have no coding knowledge so I haven't edited anything of the mod, it's just vanilla create, twilight forest, aether, ect. But if you're still interested I'll put it up.

  • @JamesNJoe
    @JamesNJoe Місяць тому +8

    i feel like some of this should come from the mechanics more
    the knocker isn't just spawn and chase. it has a lot of other things it does, doors you place may open on their own with a different noise, it will wake you up when you sleep at stare at you through one of you windows. (The same may happen, except it just watches you sleep), it may sit on your bed and attempt to jumpscare you upon sight, and a lot of other features

    • @Ryyouu
      @Ryyouu 25 днів тому +3

      Yeah a lot of these felt like they were ranked highly just from character design. A creepy design doesn’t mean it’s a good horror mod. There was like no difference between “must have” and “this is what horror is about.” Like, the justification for siren head was that it’s large and “entertaining,” but entertaining =/= scary.

    • @JamesNJoe
      @JamesNJoe 25 днів тому

      @@Ryyouu exactly

  • @glub_sylveon6412
    @glub_sylveon6412 Місяць тому +3

    the knocker is the only one that has made me scream with his new update like he deserves a higher rating in my opinion

  • @LockheartCrow
    @LockheartCrow 9 днів тому +2

    Bruh the knocker is much more than just a dude who does a lot of damage, and you didn’t rate the others based on damage alone.

  • @SBBroncos
    @SBBroncos Місяць тому +2

    I would put man from the fog above the rake because every time the rake spawned, the rake literally crashed my game. Every time. No joke.

  • @PiterAviation
    @PiterAviation 15 днів тому +4

    The silence rate is a joke right?....

    • @NomadHarrison
      @NomadHarrison 13 днів тому +1

      It's scary, but it has too many jumpscares that after some time become annoying. At least it's not Silence 2.0... But the dimension teleport is cool.

  • @TheWanderer1000000
    @TheWanderer1000000 Місяць тому +12

    Bro be hatin on the Silence. One of the best mods. It can teleport you into a nightmare dimension randomly. Scary as hell. Reminds me of the dimension door mod.

    • @Proximitythreethousand
      @Proximitythreethousand Місяць тому +1

      Nah the silence fell off hard

    • @lowchlna
      @lowchlna Місяць тому +5

      the creator fucked silence over hard

    • @mpg7115
      @mpg7115 Місяць тому

      @@lowchlna how so?

    • @mikeh6356
      @mikeh6356 19 днів тому

      nah man u die in that dimension u lose all ur shit even with gravestones

  • @OCCENYT
    @OCCENYT 29 днів тому +2

    3:56 i think cat boy is ready ^_-

  • @Jacobwd2002
    @Jacobwd2002 28 днів тому +14

    doesn't help that no one ever makes a video on what their mods do, this is literally the best way to get info on the mods without sitting tru a 40 min video
    thank you for these lists

  • @mpg7115
    @mpg7115 Місяць тому +4

    the silence should be at the top of all of them, this shit catches you offguard all the time with the png jumpscares and loud noises you'd never expect them and the new dimension and structures it adds. What also makes it terrifying is when the main mob in this mod that dude with the knife spawns in there's this nun massacre chase music which makes you deaf and scared at the same time

    • @scottcroox1059
      @scottcroox1059 Місяць тому +1

      I aggree

    • @vierzehn575
      @vierzehn575 23 дні тому +6

      png jumpscares are terrible and the old version of the mod was better, now you can't even walk around without being attacked and its loud as hell for a mod called the silence

    • @ÜlkücüFatih
      @ÜlkücüFatih 6 днів тому

      ​@@vierzehn575 is 2.0 really that annoying? İve been playing the 1.19.2 and its sometimes doesnt let me walk and have a look around twilight forest with my friend(he hates silence a little) beacuse freakin silence always teleports us to the dimension and spawns in overworld in front of my bed so we cant even explore twilight forest. İ mean even anomlay and man from the fog is less annoying then this mf

  • @echingun7809
    @echingun7809 Місяць тому +5

    You should try out the anomaly

    • @Pandeh
      @Pandeh  Місяць тому +1

      i will!

  • @MONSTAVR_THE_CREATOR
    @MONSTAVR_THE_CREATOR 2 дні тому

    Never let bro cook lol

  • @user-fi2xb5mc4i
    @user-fi2xb5mc4i 14 днів тому +1

    the goat man : huh . why my name is the goat man ? cuz am the best !

  • @Griild_cheese
    @Griild_cheese 7 днів тому

    Originally, it wasn't called the cartoon dweller it Originally made by the same guy who made like the character of the siren head, so it's originally wasn't the cartoon dweller it was actually cartoon cat

  • @strateupgamr7
    @strateupgamr7 Місяць тому +2

    Bro, the knocker is terrifying. Doesn't matter what you have, if you see a face running at you, you're gonna freak out. Give him at _least_ bottom of "must need in mod packs," it's actually terrifying.

  • @furnacemanisinmyhouse
    @furnacemanisinmyhouse День тому

    Never cook again.

  • @TheOneWhoWatches-j5l
    @TheOneWhoWatches-j5l 27 днів тому +5

    HOW DARE YOU PUT ME SO LOW ON THE LIST!!!!

  • @sirenhead666wo-s4arrival
    @sirenhead666wo-s4arrival Місяць тому +4

    WHERE IS SUPER PLAT?🎉❤

  • @Karol_polak
    @Karol_polak 29 днів тому +2

    the silence....................................................

  • @MixScript
    @MixScript 27 днів тому +4

    The silence had so much potential too...

  • @NathanAlejver
    @NathanAlejver 2 дні тому

    Cries in 1.20.1

  • @Ang3la990s
    @Ang3la990s 20 годин тому

    Never cook again

  • @TheOldCheese
    @TheOldCheese 19 днів тому

    Its funny he uses the autizms rake for the image but in the video clip he shows some different rake mod autizms rake is a crazy good mod and it doesnt randomly teleport to you or something it actually sneaks towards you its one of the few horror mods that i deem actually good

  • @dylanhartley4074
    @dylanhartley4074 Місяць тому +5

    Siren Head is a W right now

  • @Sharky-the-piano-guy
    @Sharky-the-piano-guy 8 годин тому

    Bruh, i have the cave dweller mod but i cant find him in survival and i also have the rake but they just dont spawn

  • @Xen0240
    @Xen0240 3 дні тому

    You can't put a goofy ahh looking 3 headed reskin in the top and then put the original cave dweller so low

  • @aquawrld
    @aquawrld 2 дні тому

    gotta say none of these mods are actually scary lmao

  • @mastziox_YT
    @mastziox_YT 26 днів тому

    you had put all of the most un scariest mods on the most highest level... you do not know how scary the knocker is man...

  • @GamerWeebYoutube
    @GamerWeebYoutube 13 днів тому

    the one who watches is hella terrifying, mostly now cus of the new update

  • @habibi9612
    @habibi9612 12 днів тому

    where can i find these mods and what version should i play on them?

  • @sespis2r
    @sespis2r 8 днів тому

    i get too scared playing horror mods so i add jujutsucraft to the modpacks so i can fight back

  • @Josuavl387
    @Josuavl387 21 день тому

    ngl. the damned from apollyon looks kinda scary but is really weak. me and my friends got it stuck in water. and just killed it with a few axe swings.

  • @XdFlyxer
    @XdFlyxer 28 днів тому

    You deserve 100k subs keep posting
    W editing🎉

  • @Oliver2006assassin
    @Oliver2006assassin 13 днів тому

    how do i make it so i can add all of these and play with friends ?

  • @elgalu2740
    @elgalu2740 23 дні тому

    good video, i loocking for dwellers adn i need this

  • @JMplayz0
    @JMplayz0 13 днів тому

    Bruh that Mickey mouse dweller 5 of them spawn in same time in my Minecraft java world

  • @N.-A.-Y
    @N.-A.-Y Місяць тому

    Y'all should try Midnight Lurker with his HD Texture

  • @OliviaDaGamerrrr1
    @OliviaDaGamerrrr1 13 днів тому

    assimilator mod got removed

  • @TheNineMiners
    @TheNineMiners 10 днів тому

    Ngl one who watches update was needed

  • @ErlanPubg
    @ErlanPubg Місяць тому +5

    My english so bad but..
    You need put the first cave dweller to SsS rank for respect bro..🗿💀 because Fist dweller make minecraft creator mod make more horror mod..
    Im not scare of herobrine, but that man is legend.. So i give my respect..🗿

    • @Pandeh
      @Pandeh  Місяць тому

      I understand but the way I rank them isn't JUST on nostalgia, the mod itself is really trash compared to newer mods.

    • @ErlanPubg
      @ErlanPubg Місяць тому

      @@Pandeh i know that😂🗿

  • @brguii
    @brguii 21 день тому

    some things i'd like to add, some of these are just my opinion, please don't hate :]
    the slumbering omen "girl" with cool animations is a guy, for any of you freaks out there
    the rake video you used is not the same rake mod as the image is showing
    the evolved cave dweller should've replaced the reimagined cave dweller, since it was the real source of almost all dweller mods
    the OG cave dweller should've been higher, the only reason people don't play it is because it is 1.19.3 and not 1.19.2/1.20.1, which no good horror mods are on, and it's got a new update, which is very good, and it is the ONLY reason minecraft horror has came back
    i agree with the silence, too much spawnrate, png jumpscares randomly, that random dimension where you can just lose everything in
    apollyon isn't really that good, too high spawnrate, got lore i guess yeah, but it's too much
    midnight lurker is way underrated, it fits minecraft's style, like the steve dweller, og/evolved cave dweller, knocker, mftf yknow those guys
    the one who watches has always been my favourite horror mod, and the newest update which is good.
    the irritator "crawling" or fitting through HALF BLOCK spaces, is just because it's a reskin
    the assimilator is a lot faster than other dweller reskins (other than cantbreathe, which is imo the scariest dweller, just because of the speed and sounds)
    also with the silence, it crashes in multiplayer
    beware the rain would be much better if either they didn't one shot you, even through walls like they do, or they spawn less
    the man from the shadow is an okay horror mod, just too high of a spawnrate
    AND the knocker also spawns in PEACEFUL mode and still kills you, so you're never truly safe from him
    also, you should do another video with more of the dweller/horror mods there are out there, i can name a few that i find really good that wasn't in this, this is a great video and it'd be nice to see more!

  • @mutantseekproductions4112
    @mutantseekproductions4112 Місяць тому

    Bro called the lost a women 💀

  • @amisharme744
    @amisharme744 21 день тому

    Man from the Fog kinda sucks ass tbh. He just kinda spawns in, breaks everything, and insta-kills you.

  • @erkanalpay7733
    @erkanalpay7733 16 днів тому

    the :
    Anomaly...

  • @DIzzieBizzie
    @DIzzieBizzie 17 днів тому

    Yeah there may be a lot of horror mods, too many though. They are just being thrown about and come out flimsy, but ey there is a banger or two. Also just saying, the Cartoon dweller should probably be put on the bottom tier, just imagine if you try to play multiple, extended sessions with this dude in it... all the talking, it would get really repetitive, it'd be more annoying than scary, i've seen a video or two on people playing with the mod, so i'm not just making this up, and to make it worse i remember there being a tiny amount of variation in the lines. Unfortunately i can't really remember anything good from the mod so i'm basically just taking a huge shit on all of it, but safe to say you can enjoy this as a one and done type of thing

  • @linguine4500
    @linguine4500 Місяць тому +2

    Half of these aren't even dwellers, trevor henderson creatures or creepypastas

    • @Pandeh
      @Pandeh  Місяць тому +1

      @@linguine4500 yeah it’s a horror mod tier list lol

  • @kyledea187mdkjr5
    @kyledea187mdkjr5 26 днів тому

    Where would the anomaly rank at?

  • @thedarwin6363
    @thedarwin6363 13 днів тому

    come on why these utbers cant add simple link to video. I have hard time finding cave dweller for example. There is too much good copy cats of this

  • @EzraGamez845
    @EzraGamez845 Місяць тому

    What would you rate Phen-228?
    (AKA The Boiled One Phenomenon)

  • @LincolnAbeorhma
    @LincolnAbeorhma 15 днів тому

    What about goat man….

  • @user-jv2zl3wm1x
    @user-jv2zl3wm1x 27 днів тому

    the one who watches got an update

  • @ImightBeJay
    @ImightBeJay Місяць тому +6

    Fire list. Absolute cooked🔥

    • @Pandeh
      @Pandeh  Місяць тому

      Ty🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @CrazedWarriorGang7016
    @CrazedWarriorGang7016 Місяць тому +2

    💪

  • @mutran7450
    @mutran7450 Місяць тому +5

    "Mod is unique but i dont wanna play in it alone so i put it in yellow section. Dis dud pretty scary i will put him there, yea this mod has more mobs but I don't care"
    What kind of mod rating is this lmao

    • @Travminer123
      @Travminer123 Місяць тому +2

      From someone who Jumps on bandwagon to get easy content and views

    • @Pandeh
      @Pandeh  Місяць тому +1

      How do you rank mods?

    • @mutran7450
      @mutran7450 Місяць тому +3

      @@Pandeh to rank mods you need to read description in curse forge, and also spend enough time with the mod or modpack that includes some mods. Because I noticed, nobody is reading description for slumbering omen on curse forge, and people think what mod just adds 3-4 entities and that's it. Basically to make a really good tier list you need to play with every mod, or at least watch a video with it. But sometimes it doesn't work with some mods, as I said earlier. And still we all have our opinion, for this type of video you need to explain why you put that mod here, is it balanced or not, does it works in multiplayer game or it doesn't, etc

    • @Proximitythreethousand
      @Proximitythreethousand Місяць тому +1

      I kinda agree on the aspect that you need to play it to actually rate it

  • @chaosboy0069
    @chaosboy0069 Місяць тому

    You know the one who watches will soon have a Update right?

  • @queueuof
    @queueuof 29 днів тому

    boiled one is def S tier

  • @Lunar_The_Moonlight
    @Lunar_The_Moonlight 22 дні тому +1

    this is te worst tier list bro ur legit putting dweller reskins higher than the one who watches like what

    • @PiterAviation
      @PiterAviation 15 днів тому +1

      Real the silence should be in S or another category for the best horror mod

  • @imruz7204
    @imruz7204 22 дні тому

    get good get scary
    get RLcraft
    you gonna regret playing it

  • @ch1ni
    @ch1ni Місяць тому +4

    Best tier list I've seen in a WHILE💯

  • @Respear
    @Respear Місяць тому +3

    all of these suck

    • @Travminer123
      @Travminer123 Місяць тому +1

      nah tbh from the fog is good since its herobrine and everyone loves that dude

    • @Pandeh
      @Pandeh  Місяць тому +1

      some of them are aight🤣

  • @Reddragon398
    @Reddragon398 Місяць тому

    Where is the goatman!!!

  • @Harap-Alb.
    @Harap-Alb. 10 днів тому

    Reskins are high tier,but actually unique mods aren't? Never make a tier list again,pal

  • @muamerhadzajlija3696
    @muamerhadzajlija3696 Місяць тому +1

    Deam is Silence thet bad lol😅

    • @Pandeh
      @Pandeh  Місяць тому +1

      🤣🤣

  • @SaudiastT
    @SaudiastT 19 днів тому

    I dont like mods that changes how you see

  • @Misty_gt1
    @Misty_gt1 15 днів тому +1

    I play minecraft on ps4 and I'm wondering how can I download these mods????

  • @xxhasur3238
    @xxhasur3238 Місяць тому

    how did u hide the activate windows

    • @Pandeh
      @Pandeh  Місяць тому

      how'd you know 🤔

    • @xxhasur3238
      @xxhasur3238 Місяць тому

      @@Pandeh 6:06 cool video btw

  • @the_silenc
    @the_silenc 24 дні тому

    How dare you

  • @tc2mechanic449
    @tc2mechanic449 15 днів тому

    never list ever again bro

  • @alexkrylewski3218
    @alexkrylewski3218 13 днів тому

    Knocker at the bottom of 3 tier? sheesh, "don't recommend this channel"

  • @Vahria-2_Rivaha-4_
    @Vahria-2_Rivaha-4_ 10 днів тому

    Man from the Fog and Apollyon are good Horror Mods.

  • @6dvvidx995
    @6dvvidx995 Місяць тому

    Hi i man from the fog

  • @TheodoreMongiello
    @TheodoreMongiello 9 днів тому

    I call appolyan o pe pe

  • @SBBroncos
    @SBBroncos Місяць тому

    Where man from the fog

    • @Pandeh
      @Pandeh  Місяць тому

      i ranked him

    • @SBBroncos
      @SBBroncos Місяць тому

      @@PandehOh ok I didn’t see him

  • @Manyak_Kivici3162
    @Manyak_Kivici3162 6 днів тому

    oh my fucking god stop simping for version 1.92 its so bad omfg

  • @doggo_waddo2112
    @doggo_waddo2112 28 днів тому

    Are any of these on console🥲