Mark Kermode Reviews Sherlock Holmes

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 73

  • @BartAlder
    @BartAlder 9 років тому +46

    'It's the least Guy Ritchie Guy Ritche movie Guy Ritchie has ever made.'

  • @popc5245
    @popc5245 8 років тому +31

    Sherlock and Watson in that movie sound like Kermode and Mayo

  • @RobertLeather
    @RobertLeather 4 роки тому +13

    I heard this live... I almost crashed the car I was so shocked.

  • @ConstantineBooth
    @ConstantineBooth 13 років тому +26

    I'd pay to watch a film about the geezerish antics of Jimmy the Snout

  • @glennwoddle8272
    @glennwoddle8272 10 років тому +16

    jimmy the snout - lol - hahaha - love kermode

  • @BelatedCommiseration
    @BelatedCommiseration 13 років тому +4

    I like the fact that Mark Kermode did seem to be genuinely pleased to have derived pleasure from a Guy Ritchie film! Could the infamous sea have parted? Personally I can see where Mark is coming from on some points. I liked Lock Stock and Snatch and thought they were interestingly done and amusing. Sure, its all geezers and guns, but I first watched it as almost a caricature of that world, and it was funny, it was only when I realised Ritchie was serious about it that I began to worry.

  • @TulseLuper
    @TulseLuper  15 років тому +5

    Well it's like with James Bond; nobody wanted to see a grittier version after the Pierce Brosnan era, but it took Daniel Craig and Casino Royale to prove them wrong.
    What I like about the clip is their timing. Most comedies nowadays are totally lacking in this department. The snappiness of their relationship is on display beautifully there; you really get a sense of interplay. Maybe because Law and Downey really know what they're doing unlike the geezers Ritchie normally works with.

  • @Garciamrcool
    @Garciamrcool 15 років тому +2

    they are one of the very few good shows on any BBC radio or TV. They need to stay together

  • @RamBam3000
    @RamBam3000 10 років тому +23

    The woman is Irene Adler... the only woman Holmes has ever admired. And the only woman who ever got the better of him. See "Scandal in Bohemia" So - not a thrown-in character put in there as a sop to the American audience.

    • @garymitchell5899
      @garymitchell5899 4 роки тому +3

      There is admiration between the two, but certainly no question of love, because it wouldn't work, and it doesn't here. She is used here purely as a sop to American audiences, and it doesn't work.

  • @adamj6645
    @adamj6645 8 років тому +5

    Wow a Guy Ritchie movie that Mark likes.

  • @DaveNoodles
    @DaveNoodles 7 років тому +4

    This is a spot on review. Enjoyable film.

    • @Gadget-Walkmen
      @Gadget-Walkmen 3 роки тому

      Not spot on. This film is amazing and mark is wrong to criticize it like this.

  • @Needham90
    @Needham90 14 років тому +1

    This was a fun reinvention of the Holmes scene. Good film!

  • @buttonman6262
    @buttonman6262 4 роки тому +12

    Both Sherlock Holmes films are brilliant and I won’t hear another word said about it.

    • @Gadget-Walkmen
      @Gadget-Walkmen 3 роки тому +2

      yep! mark is wrong here, these guy richie holmes movies are incredible and mark is being ignorant.

  • @Onmysheet
    @Onmysheet 11 років тому +2

    I would like to hear his view on the BBC Sherlock: A Study In Pink.

  • @Thehypicriticalgamer
    @Thehypicriticalgamer 11 років тому +2

    I liked lock stock and Snatch and liked this movie. It was really fun.

  • @StokeCityFC44
    @StokeCityFC44 9 років тому +1

    amazing, i might have to watch this one at some point then

    • @StokeCityFC44
      @StokeCityFC44 9 років тому

      ***** I'm sold with the London Bridge showdown, gotta suggest this for my next movie night with the girlf

  • @Goochbot
    @Goochbot 12 років тому +4

    "A Cameron movie that you liked"
    Wait, surely Avatar isn't the first? If he didn't like Aliens or Terminator 2 I'd be very surprised.

  • @zalkin83
    @zalkin83 13 років тому

    Wow, I thought I was listening to a review of the second Sherlock Holmes movie. I didn't realize it was a review of the first one until the last minute. They're really similar.

  • @squamish4244
    @squamish4244 12 років тому

    Also as the white black guy in Tropic Thunder playing off the younger guy and the actual black guy. (Because Ben Stiller and Jack Black's characters were insane as well).

  • @meio4744
    @meio4744 10 років тому +25

    It's more entertaining when he doesn't like a movie.

    • @Gadget-Walkmen
      @Gadget-Walkmen 3 роки тому

      But he's clearly wrong here and is not smart. These new holmes movies are amazing!

    • @KydzPlays
      @KydzPlays 3 роки тому

      @@Gadget-Walkmen He praised the movies. What are you talking about?

    • @Gadget-Walkmen
      @Gadget-Walkmen 3 роки тому

      @@KydzPlays which ones? The new Sherlock Holmes movies? He’s not a fan of them as he said.

    • @KydzPlays
      @KydzPlays 3 роки тому

      @@Gadget-Walkmen He said he enjoyed this one.

    • @Gadget-Walkmen
      @Gadget-Walkmen 3 роки тому

      @@KydzPlays really? Because the next, the best one, he said he didn’t which is unfortunate.

  • @TulseLuper
    @TulseLuper  15 років тому

    No it's still going. Mayo is leaving his usual daytime slot for Radio 1 but he's still coming back to 5 Live every Friday at 3 with Kermode.

  • @TulseLuper
    @TulseLuper  15 років тому

    I stand corrected.

  • @DontTouchMyCroissant
    @DontTouchMyCroissant 14 років тому +1

    I'm so glad he liked it cos I thought "I liked this movie, but Mark is gonna hate it, and then I feel annoyed the next time I watch it". But low and behold, he likes it, too!

  • @badhead
    @badhead 15 років тому

    Is the Kermode/Mayo show coming to an end?

  • @chrishiggins7166
    @chrishiggins7166 2 роки тому

    The film’s issues are the direction & its length, however the film’s well acted, stylish, well scored & the set pieces seem realistic. (74%) (3.5/5 stars) (positive)

  • @stcolreplover
    @stcolreplover 15 років тому

    BOOOM, i love this guy

  • @lss2388
    @lss2388 15 років тому

    He's moving to Radio 2.

  • @TulseLuper
    @TulseLuper  12 років тому +6

    If you hate Mark Kermode so much, why are you always watching his reviews?

  • @allaboutdmagic
    @allaboutdmagic 14 років тому

    "I'm actually warming to the characters in a Guy Ritchie film!"

  • @TulseLuper
    @TulseLuper  15 років тому

    No he's moving to Radio 1 for the Breakfast show.

  • @TheWolverineiscool
    @TheWolverineiscool 12 років тому

    sherlock holmes was an amazing movie!

  • @TulseLuper
    @TulseLuper  15 років тому

    Yeah, I admit I enjoy Lock Stock and Snatch, but I haven't liked anything since then. But if Kermode likes it then it couldn't be that bad.

  • @TulseLuper
    @TulseLuper  14 років тому +1

    @skinwalkerxxx We'll agree to disagree. I thought Jude Law was very funny and held the film together.

  • @orkavorn
    @orkavorn 13 років тому +1

    Jimmy the Snout! LOL

  • @TulseLuper
    @TulseLuper  14 років тому

    @skinwalkerxxx True, but to me, Downey is only ever as good as his straight men/women. He needs solid actors to be his anchor while he goes crazy (i.e. Val Kilmer in Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, Gwyneth in Iron Man, Jude Law in this.)

  • @mmclaurin8035
    @mmclaurin8035 Рік тому

    WTF does Irene Adler being in the movie have to do with appeasing Americans? She's been in pretty much every Sherlock Holmes production ever made and is entertaining because Holmes rarely meets anyone that can fluster him. She plays a central part in the movie and was portrayed beautifully by McAdams.

  • @Carfer22
    @Carfer22 15 років тому

    radio1? he's on 1?

  • @adrianguinn3331
    @adrianguinn3331 2 роки тому

    Snatch is still one of my top 100 of all time

  • @MagnificentFiend
    @MagnificentFiend 13 років тому +1

    Jimmy the Snout! Mumbles!

  • @filmneek
    @filmneek 12 років тому +1

    Fucking kermode, guy Richie is a genius

  • @90mv
    @90mv 14 років тому +1

    i was surprised at how much i enjoyed the film

  • @mikeb3018
    @mikeb3018 Місяць тому

    jimmy the snout hahaha

  • @gillri
    @gillri 14 років тому

    @TulseLuper yes i thought Law was very good

  • @rdunikk
    @rdunikk 11 років тому

    Irene Adler is Sherlocks love interest even in the books.

  • @robertmcelwaine7024
    @robertmcelwaine7024 7 років тому +4

    Kermode liked Howard the Duck. That is all.

    • @raam726
      @raam726 5 років тому

      Are you serious? Evidence?

  • @lordtufty
    @lordtufty 13 років тому

    @Minic15 så soft

  • @Onmysheet
    @Onmysheet 11 років тому +1

    He's ok but he's no Christopher Nolan or David Fincher.

    • @michaelhall5429
      @michaelhall5429 4 роки тому +1

      They're alright but they're no Welles or Fellini.

    • @Onmysheet
      @Onmysheet 4 роки тому

      @@michaelhall5429 I'm a late bloomer for Fellini. Seen some films of his on MUBI, and liked them, La Dolce Vita being the most.

    • @michaelhall5429
      @michaelhall5429 4 роки тому

      @@Onmysheet I was being a dick and now you're being nice. Both those directors are great though. Although sometimes Fellini goes straight over my head with his intentions. I just thought it was funny you'd compare guy Ritchie to either of those two in the first place

    • @Onmysheet
      @Onmysheet 4 роки тому

      @@michaelhall5429 Yeah. Comparing Guy Ritchie to any of those directors was ridiculous. What was I thinking then? lol

    • @michaelhall5429
      @michaelhall5429 4 роки тому

      @@Onmysheet haha at least it's not as mindless as replying to a seven year old comment.

  • @basquat76
    @basquat76 12 років тому

    Holmes and Watson is the gayest movie couple ever. Even brokeback mountain has to take a backseat to this film

  • @stevensutton4677
    @stevensutton4677 7 місяців тому

    I think Jimmy the Snout and Mumbles were in the Blue Carbuncle, so their absence makes sense.