The Transformative Vision of Esperanto | Esther Schor | TEDxRoma
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 жов 2024
- Esperanto is a visionary metaphor: for universalism; for neutrality; for technologies that break down barriers; for multiculturalism and harmony. It’s a vision of transformation; it makes the future present. A future of generosity, equality of access, and optimism about what we humans can do, when we do it together.
L’Esperanto è una metafora visionaria: che include l’universalismo; la neutralità; le tecnologie che abbattono le barriere; il multiculturalismo e l’armonia. È una visione di trasformazione in grado di rendere il futuro presente, fornendoci la possibilità di immaginarci un futuro di generosità, parità di accesso e ottimismo su ciò che noi esseri umani siamo in grado di raggiungere, quando agiamo insieme. Esther Schor is a poet and professor of English at Princeton University. Her most recent book is Bridge of Words: Esperanto and the Dream of a Universal Language, both a cultural history of the language-movement and a memoir of her seven years among Esperantists in the U. S., Vietnam, Turkey, Cuba, Holland, Brazil and Uzebekistan. Her essays and reviews have appeared in The New York Times Book Review, The New Republic, The Wall Street Journal, The Times Literary Supplement, Tablet Magazine and the Forward.
Esther Schor è poetessa e professoressa d’ inglese presso la Princeton University. Il suo libro più recente è Bridge of Words: Esperanto and the Dream of a Universal Language, storia culturale del movimento linguistico dell’Esperanto, ed esperienza diretta come Esperantista negli Stati Uniti, in Vietnam, Turchia, Cuba, Paesi Bassi, Brasile ed Uzbekistan. I suoi articoli e saggi critici sono apparsi sul The New York Times Book Review, The New Republic, The Wall Street Journal, The Times Literary Supplement, Tablet Magazine e Forward. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at www.ted.com/tedx
Superbly argued and superbly sensible. In this divided world, the moment for Esperanto is now.
Except the world has always been ''divided'''(in the sense Esperantists imagine it).
Absolutely!
@@dariendude17 I was learning Esperanto. I am learning it again. Esperanto is now.
@@lashachakhunashvili1399 jes. Jes gis es
What about now
I've learned English, so I'll learn Esperanto as well.
I pray for more thoughtful people, for a world with no wars
How is it going ? did you learn it?
@@luispablo3543 ču vi šavas lernas?
Actually, only 4.8% of the population of planet Earth speaks English natively. And that percentage is steadily falling. Mostly due to the rapid population increase of non-native English speakers.
Esperanto is WAY EASIER to learn than English. I love Esperanto. It's helping me to learn German and Polish.
Esperanto is the good way to understand how the european languages work. With help of Esperanto I've started to learn Spanish and French with a great pleasure. And more fast.
"Actually, only 4.8% of the population of planet Earth speaks English natively."
Um....where did that number come from?
That is just over how many people live in the US.
What about much of Europe where in many countries you are taught ESL since grade school and heard it spoken even before you are school age. Then you have Ireland and the UK which are clearly English speakers. Sweden....just try to speak broken Swede there and they will flip to English to make it easier for you. You will find that same thing in many countries around the EU.
India has many millions of English speakers, and no a heavy accent doesn't mean someone isn't a fluent speaker.
Australia, New Zealand, parts of Africa, Canada, all over Central and South America you have multi-language speakers some of which are fluent in English. Then you have the rest of Asia.
L2 speakers are a consideration too.
Native language I loved listening to this. It Pretty well encapsulates why I learned Esperanto. To one of the comments above, the number actually currently stands at 6% native English speakers. A native speaker isn’t just another way to say that someone is fluent in a language. But rather, that the language was acquired as a child, before the age of 12. There is some debate on that age range depending on the linguistic paradigm you’re using.
No one in the comments ever said that people do not learn fluent English as a second language. It is totally doable, people do it all the time, as the comment mentions.
But aside from that, there’s a lot of beauty and learning another language, even when you don’t have to because other people in the world speak English too LOL! That’s really not the point anyone was trying to make.
I personally wish I had studied Esperanto before trying to learn Spanish, I am absolutely certain it would’ve been much easier. Esperanto is a wonderful sandbox that you get to play with an experiment with, With a very regular rules… At the same time it can get very complex and it allows learners to figure out what it’s actually like to learn a language. Testo different methodologies, encounter different psychological Roblox and how to work with them, you’ll learn a lot about yourself.
If you’re already learning a language, keep it up! If you’ve considered learning a language but find it far too intimidating (but you still find it interesting) me maybe starting with Esperanto would be a good idea. Whatever you do, happy learning!
@@mjs28s Native language, not secondary language
I'm now totally inspired to learn Esperanto, especially as it has no irregularites and is easy to learn. We need to become a global family with "a plank of wood" over every stream on earth.
How did it go? Did you learn it?
faru! estas tre facila
One problem, there are more than fifty such languages floating around.
Mi tute konsentas!
Ne lasu viajn sonĝojn esti sonĝojn!
@@jaerivus Yes, but Esperanto is the best choice for many reasons, including popularity and establised culture.
I have loved Esperanto since I first found a description in a scouting book,for gaining the linguist's badge. The study of Esperanto is enduring,and I am constantly intrigued by the hidden shades of the grammar. Although the language itself can be quite quickly learned,that is only a first step into learning the complexities of the grammar and syntax. For me this has been a lifelong study. Esperanto is absolute genius!
tre dankon, dankegon pro la publikigado de ĉi tiu konferenco pri Esperanto
*This language should be established as the only official language in all international forums. It's enough that native English speakers are born with privileges over others!!!*
I couldn't agree more.
Mi ne povus pli konsenti.
Thank you Esther!!!
I met Esther briefly at an Esperanto convention in DC in 2010, after I had picked up Esperanto as an entertaining pastime in college. Fast forward to 2023, years after she gave this talk, and she has inspired me with her message to pick it up again. Dankon!
A great feature of Esperanto is the ease with which you can meet people as you travel. I used it all over Eastern Europe. Thanks to their Jarlibro (Yearbook) I was able to find a Buddhist monk/teacher in Sri Lanka while I was living in pre-internet Iowa. I have sister puppet companies in the Baltic states thanks to contact via Esperanto.
Koran dankon Esther pro la inspirado! Bonajn dezirojn el Danio, kie ankaŭ troviĝas esperantistoj .
Thank you very much Esther for the inspiration! Best wishes from Denmark where you can find Esperanto speakers too.
What a wonderful speaker and a wonderful speech! Kaj ŝi pravas.
Jes ja!
Came here to watch this video as I start my journey in learning Esperanto! I am looking forward to a transformative year ahead. This is a great Ted Talk as to the reason why!
En paco, Liz
Dankegon pro tio ke vi diskonigas nian amatan lingvon Esperanton! / Thank you for spreading the word about our beloved language Esperanto!
Kia bona publika parolanto! Mi dankas vin pro la espero kaj ĝojo kiu nun pleniĝas mian koron.
What a good public speaker! Thank you for the hope and joy which now fills my heart.
“Plenigas”. 😉
This is great reasoning...there is no question Esperanto is a good idea. Wish more people found out about it!
Esperanto IS NOT any kind of mix. Such statements just push people away from learning it, cause one starts to think that it's just a kinda klingon or elfish joke for nerds, where it's not! Esperanto is unique, solid, live and very expressive communication tool, potentially better than any other! Although most of its vocabulary was taken from Latin and some other languages, it totally differences from all of them and Latin itself. Its grammar structure is so elegant, logic and genius. Even if there weren't other Esperantists and tons of books, it would be worth to learn Esperanto only for its elegance itself.
Bedaŭrinde, 2:20 devus esti “poŝtelefono.” Iel, ne gravas. La tempo por Esperanton lerni estas nun. La konverĝo estas nun. Multan dankon, sinjorino Ester SCHOR. ❤️
Mi pensis same kiam mi vidis tion... Ŝajnas neglektinda detalo, sed...
@@PascalBlondiau hahahah mi komence ne komprenis "neglektinda", ĉar mi pensis ke ĝi estas ne-glekt-ind-a, sed en mia vortaro ne estas la vorto "glekta". Mdr
13 million subscribers yet only 482 views?
I just linked this TEDx talk to my Facebook page.
TEDx has a bad reputation.
I have 7k subs and my videos get more views than this :(
To be fair, TEDx itself would have a lot of followers but you'd only watch the videos that interest you. I'd say their subscriber to views ratio would be pretty low all over.
Evildea nobody cares about esperanto
I actually would not describe Esperanto as multiculturalist. I'd describe it as more interculturalist. There is a subtle difference between these. Multiculturalism does not necessarily envision a common language: in that respect, it can lead to a tower of Babel and confict between cultures. Interculturalism does promote a common culture, even if only an auxiliary one, that everyone learns as a common second culture to allow the development of intercultural relations.
We can even take Warsaw of Zamenhof's time as an example. He witnessed multiculturalism first hand, with four different language groups many of whom were not able to communicate with one another. This motivated him to create Esperanto to promote more just and fraternal relations between them. In other words, he created Esperanto so as to advance multiculturalism towards interculturalism.
And just a point about Esperanto being an artificial language. Esperanto is an artificial language just as English is an artificial language. IN fact, the word artificial is redundant since by definition, a language, any language, is artificial. That said, we can perhaps distinguish along a spectrum of planning and say that, relatively speaking, Esperanto figures among the more planned languages and English among the more ad hoc ones with regards to the regularity of their respective orthographies, grammars, and lexicons.
Esperanto is of course multiculturalist. I'd describe it as more interculturalist and transnationalist.
Who learning esperanto like me in 2020 😍❤️
2021 :-)
Me 2021
moi aussi en 2012!
Mi aktuale studas ĝin, 2021 (per Duolingo)!
How are yall doing rn in Esperanto?
Up to 4.8% are native speakers of some 50 English dialects. Majority of up to 12.8% are speakers of International English, which is harder to understand for Native speakers. I've already started avoiding noise articles (a/an & the, whenever possible, didn't use in this paragraph) - my contribution to IE (Globish). I never write numbers with words, & use international symbols/words where possible.
Estu inteligenta, kaj parolu Esperanton.
I'm currently reading Bridge of Words, a book this woman wrote, and it's the most in-depth piece about Esperanto I've ever read
moved me deeply. thank you. ♥
mi parolas esperanton, me estas komencanto. ĝi estas facile lernebla lingvo,
ĉiuj devas studi ĝin. great video
hows your Esperanto journey? fruitful i hope! my friend i myself have just started and wish to see the potential progress i can make, please update me
@@smokinwoodzI've just started!! have you stayed with it!!!
I want to live in a world where i could lift my middle finger and say Fiku vin and be understood universally
I don't speak Esperanto and I know what you said so there's that
"Fek' al vi" is more commonly used, but your variant is also understandable :)
MI ridas pri tio!
lol
Thank you for giving us this & Emma. You have picked up her torch & made it your own. With it you are bringing light for us to use. Please take strength from your grateful readers & students & continue to make day from night. (I had to use “&” to make you smile)
Belege, Esther! Kial tiom malmulte da diskonigo pri tiu ĉi mirinda parolado? Kia vervo! Kiom da trafaj metaforoj! Kaj hej! mi esperas, ke baldaŭ ĝi atingos 10 milon da spektintoj. Gratulojn!
I've never seen such a good lecture like this one!
Chances of Esperanto:
-Turists language
-New bisness language
-Mars
I prefer the term "Designer Language" or maybe, Bespoke?
2 things, 1, thanks to the duolingo meme going around lately i decided to download it after hearing her mention it. 2. this video was posted on my birthday. Saluton Esperanto!
Thank you Esther; I agree!
Beautiful speech!
Mi amas Esperanton 💚 mi havas verdan koron
Dankegon, Esther, pro via kortuŝa kaj samtempe energia parolado!
Mi lernis Esperanton per Duolingo kaj mi estas Esperantisto! 😀
ive only learned esp for a few days but i understand it! :D
I just today did one set of lessons on duolingo and I can already relatively well understand this sentence
Ankaŭ mi! Estas afable renkonti vin!
@@jaerivus Saluton! Kiel longa vi studas Esperanton?
@@aguynamednathan Mi studis ĝin dum iomete pli ol unu jaro.
Great lecture, I loved it!
Agreed
In Esperanto: "Bonega prelego! Mi amis ĝin!"
Interesting language codex. However, did you really buy the part about the angelic Jewish mind? Jewish Bolsheviks massacred over 60 million Russians and Ukrainians between 1919 and 1940. If this man came up with a great idea, a great invention, so be it, but I can do without the fawning over Jews.
Here we are, a powerfully-argued statement for the benefits of learning esperanto, and the video presentation text is in English and 80% of the comments below are in English.
Sometimes you need to fight fire with fire. If this brilliant talk were all in Esperanto, it would be preaching to the converted.
What would be the point of introducing Esperanto to Esperanto-speakers? They already know it. It is targeted at a non-Esperanto audience.
@@ablair7007 Absolutely. We need to present Esperanto in English, Spanish, French, Chinese.....in any other language but not in Esperanto. UA-cam already has lots of material in Esperanto.
I am totally behind this vision
Okay I just started learning Esperanto and I love it. But seriously, can someone tell me where I can get that necklace!?
Mi pensas ke Esperanto ne estos morto. Nun mi lernas Francan kaj Esperanto multaj helpas min por kompreni la francan lingvon gramatikon. Saluton el Indonezio.
Never learned Esperanto and I understood you perfectly :)
@@softwareminimalist ese es el punto, que sea facil para todos, es un idioma para conectar no para separar.
Superbe bonega kaj bela parolado! 💚
Let's raise Esperanto together.
LONGAN VIVON!
Beautiful!
Tre bono! 💚💚💚
Me gustaría poder añadir subtítulos en español y en esperanto a esta charla para que su contenido se difunda más ampliamente.
Mi ŝatus subtekstigi ĉi tiun filmeton kaj en la hispana kaj en Esperanto por ke ĝia enhavo pli vaste diskonatiĝu.
How are there this little views for a TEDx video? Do people find Esperanto that boring? That's odd.. Sed, mi kredas la Esperanto estas bona lingvo!
Ege bonvena estus subtitolado en diversaj lingvoj, inkluzive Esperanto.
Dankon pro via belega prelego, kara samideanino.
Hello, what would you recommend for learning Esperanto.
@@NikonKanava Duolingo! The Esperanto for English speakers course is great and when you finish it (or even before) you'll be able to have conversations. After that, join telegram chat groups (take a look at telegramo.org) to practise conersation :)
@@NikonKanava It depends on how you want to learn. Duolingo probably is great if you have a smartfone and commute every day, but not very suited if you want to advance quickly. For that you need a good teacher. If you are lucky you can go to several weekend-courses. Places like Gresillon and Herzberg offer courses that last one, two or even three weeks. One week already gives you a solid foundation to build upon
Esperanto rises and falls at various times through its history. Many people have suffered and died championing this incredible language,the Zamenhof family being almost wiped out by the Nazis,due to their promotion of world peace. But the language arises time and again,like the Phoenix from its ashes,bringing hope and belief for a united world. The unsettled situation today could well create a new interest in the language,with more people becoming involved in the possibilities inherent in Esperanto,and more likely,captivated by the sheer ingenuity of its construction. You never really finish learning Esperanto,because there are endless avenues you can explore,discovering new aspects in its grammatical construction,and the way subtle meanings can be made by a simple addition of a suffix. If you want a really interesting hobby which can be shared with people all over the world,and at minimal cost,then I recommend you try your hand at learning and mastering this extraordinary language. Bonan vojon!
Vivu Esperanto,ĉirkaŭ la tuta mondo! La lingvo,kiun mi amas dum multe da jaroj,mia lingvista amo!
Please fix the subtitles (ex: Zamenhof, not salmon).
Ahahahahahahahahahahah
Brilliant!
Bonega artikolo, kara samideanino! Vi prezentas la lingvon vere bone! Gratulon!
I’d like to raise one thought problem, consider the Deaf community in this world of lingual accessibility. Where do they fall in? I have studied American Sign Language for the last 5 years and there is an international version, but it is rarely used. Would everyone need to learn that as well? I’d think so, for the vision of unity and full inclusion.
I am all for Esperanto, I am beginning my journey now to becoming an Esperantist. Just wanted to propose that question.
Another advantage of learning Esperanto for grade school children, this is especially true for English speaking children, is that it permits them to look at their own language objectively. English is so irregular in its spelling not to mention homonyms and homophones that it is very confusing to children who are native speakers. Esperanto being so regular and phonetic allow a child to look at their language with different eyes.
Mi ĉiun videoludon tradukos al la esperanta lingvo kaj helpos plifamigi esperanton tiel.
Top, Excellent ! Is there a transcript of this talk or lecture available, somewhere / somehow ?
Elkoran dankon pro bonega prezento de nia belega lingvo Mi jam antaŭ kelkaj jardekoj lernis Esperanton kaj ekde tiam verdire vivas kun gxi . kvankam mi parolas aliajn lingvojn inkluzive la Anglan, sed Esperanto , gxi bela , orelplaĉa muziko kaj riĉa esprimpovo kaj certe ĝia interna ideo de paco kaj amikeco ...kaj belegaj libroj estas ĝuo de mia vivo. Ankoraŭfoje koran dankon. Ĝis...
A great talk done through the English language ;)
Because they are notorious monolinguals, & Esperanto would be the easiest to come out of the blind spot. ;))
Estu inteligenta, kaj parolu Esperanton.
2:56 That was a direct attack
Dankegon pro la grandan esperon kiun vi kunportas vian paroladon! Mi estas nur komencanto, sed mi estas jam ekscitita fini ĝin kun Duolingo!
i think i might be the only one but i want a town of epserantists, that way 1 i have somewhere to go to learn it better, 2 than everyone can talk with others without going a cross a country. lol id move there
The internet is for that
Use it to communicate without leaving your city :)
Mi amas Esperanton
Mi satas Esperanto!
Ĉi tio estas mirinda! Dankegon:)
IN 2O13 I COMPLETED A POSTAL CORRESPONDENCE COURSE OF TEN LESSONS IN ESPERANTO, OUT OF EL CERRITO , CALIFORNIA. MY TUTOR WAS ELLEN EDDY. I THOUGHT ABOUT TRYING TO START AN ESPERANTO GROUP HERE , IN OSCODA , MICHIGAN BUT I COULD NOT ACQUIRE A REALLY GOOD COMPREHENSIVE TWO WAY ENGLISH-- ESPERANTO DICTIONARY SO I FIGURED THAT OUR GROUP WOULD HAVE BEEN LIMITED JUST TOO MUCH WITHOUT ONE.
ESPERANTO IS HELD IN HIGH ESTEEM BY ME. THANKS FOR YOUR TIME, AND THANK YOU DR. ZAMENHOF FOR YOUR GREAT GIFT TO MANKIND, ESPERANTO, IT WAS WELL WORTH YOUR EFFORT.
I HAVE FOUND, THAT HARD COVER HOLY BIBLES IN ESPERANTO ARE RARE AND VERY EXPENSIVE. ARE THERE ANY GIDEON BIBLES IN ESPERANTO?
IF I WERE ABLE TO START UP AN ESPERANTO GROUP IN OSCODA, MICHIGAN , IT WOULD BE WRITING AND SPEAKING VERY LIMITED ESPERANTO. A LITTLE ESPERANTO SPOKEN IS A GREAT INSPIRATION, ESPECIALLY IF OUR MEMBERS COULD MARCH IN THE PARADES IN TOWN HERE CARRYING THE ESPERANTO FLAG AND A BANNER IN ESPERANTO AND ENGLISH. THANK YOU AGAIN .
@@chrisjustus5446 In case you really didn't notice, there's something wrong with your caps lock. Like it's stuck on.
WHY ARE YOU SCREAMING
Bonega mallonga prelego. Gratulon al la prelegintino.
Mi lernis Esperanton ekde pli ol kvardek jaroj antaŭe, mi ĝin uzas kaj eĉ tradukis du librojn el la hispana en Esperanton ("La celo atingeblas" kaj "Ŝakon al la teroro", kiujn vi povas serĉi en Interreto, trovinte ilin en mia retejo vi povas ilin elŝuti senpage en formo PDF).
Mi skribas el Medeĝino (Medellín) Kolombio)
Saluton al ĉiuj mi studas Esperanton dum tri jaroj kaj mi pensas ke tiu lingvo estas mirinda ĉar povas konekti al la tuta mondo kaj Fermi la mondo en bonega loko por Vivi
Artificial:
made or produced by human beings rather than occurring naturally, especially as a copy of something natural
I'm learning Esperanto, but it definitely is a man-made language.
So are all other languages, they were all manmade, when you think about it we should be referring to all languages as being man made.
@MorganLeeR Esperanto evolved freely for 132 years... (no thanks to the Akademio..)
All languages are man made.
Yeah, but there is the other conclusion that many people draw from the word 'articicial.' And that is 'unnatural.' If the language was set free and grown wildly through the democracy of kongresoj, the unnatural moniker is not fitting. Constructed language (conlang) has a much more exacting quality to its term.
2 weeks after, 13M subs... Just 974 views... What is wrong?
For god's sake Learn it. Do yourself and especially your children and the coming generation a favor. So much money and time is being wasted all over the world because of not using Esperanto. So much great resources out there can not be used because of this. Many talented people out there don't have access to education in a language they understand. Many don't learn new languages (and they should) because of failure. Esperanto can fix qll of this qnd more. I'm Kurdish living in Iran in a half Azerbaijani city. I learned Azerbaijani and Persian of course. Then jumped to Arabic (not very successful) and then English. It took me two years and I wouldn't consider myself fluent. Do people all over the world a favor and learn it. I assure you it will be easy and fun
Esperantisto cxi tie!
Kvankam mi ne jam legis ĉi-tiun videon, mi ŝatus paroli, ke mi tre ĝojas pri lerni la Esperanton. Ĝi estas tre facila kaj komprenebla lingvo, kiu mi ŝatas uzi. Per ĉi-tiu mi renkontis plurajn homojn, kvankam nur interrete. Mi komunikas kun homoj de multaj fremdaj landoj, inkluzive rusio, ĉinio, kubo, kaj aliaj. Per ĉi-tiu lingvo mi povas komuniki kun homoj, kiuj ne tre bone parolas la anglan, sed nur anstataŭi parolas ion fremdan lingvon tiel la rusan aŭ ion.
Ankoraŭ mi lernas kaj certe ne parolas nek rapide nek bonege. Sed ankoraŭ mi amas ĝin, jam instruas alia amiko pri ĝin, kaj vidas kiel rapide li lernas ĝin kaj ankaŭ kiel ĝojas al lin.
Esperanto ankaŭ montras al mi kiel aliaj lingvoj estas vere facila fakte, ĉar iliaj estas nur iom da instruaĵoj aŭ reguloj ĵus la sama kiel io ajn alia lingvo aŭ sistemo. Sporto, ludo, rilato, laboro, tute havas regulojn kiujn kiu devas lerni kaj uzi sisteme se ili volas sukcese en tiu sistema medio.
Tiel, mi eklernas plurajn aliajn lingvojn ankaŭ, tial la ĉinan, la hispanan, la francan, la italan, la latinan, la japanan, kaj eĉ ankaŭ la korean ktp. Sed kompreneble ne apenaŭ parolis ilin. Ankoraŭ, laŭ mi, mi nur povas lerni tiujn ĉar mi unue studas kaj lernas Esperanton. Kial? Ĉar tiu estas tre facila, pro ĝia logika kaj simpla aranĝo kaj simplaj reguloj iuj ajn povas lerni kun malpi da tempo.
Lernu Esperanton por monda diskuto pri nia komuna estonteco kaj povos gajni mondan pacon kaj kunlaboron.
What kind of jobs with knowledge of Esperanto?
There are very few jobs that require knowledge of Esperanto, but knowing it helps you learn other languages better and faster, and sometimes having it on your curriculum vitae ( "resumé") will make you stand out
I agree with all her points except one minor issue. All the universal languages of their day, Greek, Latin, Arabic, French, and now English (and in the future Chinese?) will have their day in the light based on the economic success of that language's origin. They all have one thing in common, and that is that they're all rooted in an ethnic or cultural origin which isn't universal. Language is a very fundamental aspect of culture. So if a language is going to be universal it has to feel representative and rooted in, if not all, at least the majority of cultures. And that's the biggest issue with the adoption of Esperanto of the "Universal Language". It's a language created by one man, and completely based on the Latin and European language family; which Chinese, Africans, Arabs etc cannot relate to or identify with. Hence not truly universal language. She brought up the issue that there are only 10% native English speakers. Esperanto increases that percentage only incrementally. You could argue it's at least better, but not that it's anywhere near universal.
The Chinese, Africans, Arabs, etc, have the same opportunity to embrace EO as their bridge language & contribute to the universal character. The other choice is currently English, which is in opposite direction (no excuse here). By construct, EO is already universal, as the grammar is flexible enough to be non-European. The words are already international, & anybody can contribute with any missing expressions.
This is theoretically true, but it is false in practise. i have spoken Esperanto to hundreds of Chinese, Japanese and Arabs, and they speak the language fluently and effortlessly. It actually has a lot of non-Indo-European features, and a lot in common with Mandarin Chinese. You can find theses features if you look for them. Just Google "Claude Piron: articles".
In addition - the whole point of Esperanto is to have a language with no "nationality" in order for communication to be on equal terms, ie, everybody being non-native speakers.
@Shahrooz, you are missing one crucial point. Esperanto is based on something universal : logic - same for all people. The aspect of Esperanto may seem european to you (and many) by the aspect of the words. But much, much more important, is what underlies, i.e. logic in grammar.
I agree that there never will be a language that is universal in the sense that all human thoughts and feelings can be expressed precisely in it. I also see it as a bit of problem that Esperantists - and especially the non-europeans - are too modest to introduce words for things that can't be expressed well yet, or too hesitant to use words that haven't been made official yet.
The problem is not language it is culture and the main problem we have today is that the powers that be are trying to wipe out all the old cultures under the name of multiculturalism which is anything but that. I love Esperanto as a language but it's goal of bringing the world together is just a dream. Humans will always be different from one another. Even when we speak the same language and even share similar cultures we will fight each other. It is human nature and always will be. That being said we should still learn Esperanto if for no other reason than to have a language that actually makes sense.
Esperanto is an "open source" language
Mi estas komencanto sed mi tre amas Esperanton. Estas tre bona kaj amuza!
Only because she mentioned "gaydar" and "gejradaro", i don't want to show this video for russians for agitate for Esperanto. It wil be met negatively. Otherwise, she said everything correctly.
Wow... that's sad
one of the biggest problems of Esperanto today: there's too much content about it, and not enough content in Esperanto.
Also, that old-school aesthethic used by the speakers in videos and books is not very inviting for the young genetarions... Instead of translating 19th century books, translate manga, series, animes, movies, (even p0rn, for god's sake!!) that people actually like nowadays! Record high quality gameplays, do streams and pop music.
Otherwise Esperanto will never stop being that weird boomer thing only old people are interested about.
Yeah Luke Amadeus that runs the Polymathy and ScorpioMartianus UA-cam channels does content related to modern-day stuff in Latin as a way to teach it and to have content that people can use to immerse themselves in Latin. I think the same should be done for Esperanto.
Dankon!
It is good idea to have universal independent language, but there is no content on this language, like vlogs, movies etc. ☹️
Yeah, there are lots of IALs, what makes esperanto so good?
There are a lot of material in Esperanto, even movies. For vlogs and videos you have Tubaro.
not enough. And what we have is usually very low quality...
Incorrect. There is more content in Esperanto than any person could consume in their lifetime.
I speak Esperanto fluently, you can watch my videos on UA-cam. I learn Esperanto and then learn English more easily. My mother tongue is Spanish.
Stop talking about Esperanto and start talking in Esperanto. Make videos about everyday life in Esperanto.
I am greatly disturbed by how close the mic is to her mouth, and being able to hear every sound her mouth makes.
I didn't even notice this, as the ideas were so well expressed and so much more interesting.
Belega prelego. Kie tio estis,kaj kiam?
Dankegon
Mi amas ci tiun parolandon.
paroladon
Reconocer solos somos seres ROMANOS.....Son Romanos seres somos Reconocer.......
Ne poĉtelefono, sed poŝtelefono kaj pliaj eraroj
Koran dankon pro la subteno!
la plej bona maniero komenci estas komenci ;)
I love drinking water. Mi amas trinki akvon.
BELEGE!
Three reasons why I stopped learning Eo:
1. It doesn't roll off my tongue naturally like "kiujn."
2. Zealots.
3. Media
I'm not dissing Eo. I'm just sharing my experience.
mi estas komencanto, gaydar? hahaha
I thought that was Demi Moore in the thumbnail lol
English language did what esperanto want to become - I forget it because I don't practice it
But English has many cons that Esperanto does not have.
PLEASE stop putting the microphones right in their mouths. The mouth noises are so distracting.
Kie estas miaj esperantistoj? xD
Esperanto is universial but it also needs a capital city. Because it has no culture, there is not enough film, music, video... Esperanto needs a country and it can still be universial
The whole point is to have a neutral language, one without country, so that it is used on equal terms and nobody having a national advantage.
There is a lot of Esperanto culture - novels, music, poetry, films, videos.