The Fog (1980/2005) side-by-side comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 вер 2021
- Side-by-Side Directory: mattskuta.com/sbs/
A side-by-side, shot-for-shot comparison between the 1980 film The Fog and the 2005 remake. This video is intended to show the different choices made by two groups of filmmakers, one creating an original work and the other adapting it. - Розваги
The budget of the original was 1 million dollars and the remake was 18 million but it somewhat was worse than the original
the original uses beautiful real film cinematography.The remake uses digicam
It’s not about budget, it’s how you use it.
John Carpenter and Debra Hill...Cinematography by Dean Cundey.....Production Designer Tommy Lee Wallace...all geniuses.
The only thing that the 2005 film had going for it is when the ghost ship passes by the Sea Grass. In the 1980 film, we only see the ship itself. In the 2005 film, we can actually see a few ghosts on the ship when it passes by. I also liked the scene with the ghost trying to break into Andy's room in both films. But, personally, I loved the 1980 original film much more than its remake. My opinion.
100% agree.
Funny, that’s actually, for whatever reason, my favorite scene in the 2005 version too. When the ghost breaks into Andy’s room. It’s OK in the original as well, but I feel like Tom Welling and the kid sell the fear factor a little better.
@@corneliusdobeneck4081 same here 🎉
@@only257
I seen The Remake so I like the remake.
The Fog. 1980. Still a superior film. Thank you for the side by side comparison Matt.
No comparison the original movie is a classic the opening scene sets the tone.
One of my favorite movies of all time love John carpenter
I prefer the 1980 one
Agreed 🎉
I heard John was on set for the remake but he was mostly there just to say high and leave for a paycheck. I kinda find that funny.
@@pugtie4695 Can’t fault him for that really.
@@horrorfanandy4647 never said I was.
@@pugtie4695
Fair enough. Sorry, I should have made it clearer I meant myself when I said that, but as we’re both in agreement on the matter all is well 🤣
John Carpenter is amazing! Great job, Matt!
Of all the great films out there and their inferior remakes, The Fog has probably the biggest difference in quality between the two.
No, POLTERGIEST remake was weak and forgettable as fuck.
I have absolutely loved the original for years. I never saw it in the theatres sadly, but I saw it on VHS in the mid 80's. The remake was a horrid let down. The only thing I can give it a bit of credit for is that it does give a little more of the back story. But the mood, music, cast and direction style of the original just can't be topped.
The 2005 version was like they used a bunch of high school kids for the movie's characters.
Yeah, the 2005 remake was all the worst aspects of 2000s Horror Movies. Everyone's too damn young! You can tell the influence of the "Scream" films was still in full effect at the time.
I had never seen this before but your video is excellent!!! Thanks for the hard work!
No matter which film you like the story of vengeance being fulfilled remains the same. Always felt bad for the folks on the island who didn't know that the islands wealth was built on lies but I loved that the sailors kicked ass with no remorse!
Now you know why Rob Zombie Halloween was not a shot for shot remake it was longer different and more story driven.
John Carpenters original is still the best and can’t be touched but Robs remake offered a different take and a new spin it was not a complete copy-cat this movie tried that and failed HARD!
Also Robs film is the only Halloween movie to take place in a span of 17 years seeing Michael for several days, weeks,months and years all four seasons Fall,Winter,Spring,Summer.
The other Halloween movies take place in a span of two days or just one day.
Never seen such a divided movie
Can you please do an "Open Your Eyes"/"Vanilla Sky" side-by-side?
The only good things about the remake were the special effects and make up on the ghosts.
(...and the girls)
@@geckoi8166 ASHLEY GREENE WAS 10/11/12/13/14/15/16/17/18 YEARS ON THE REMAKE!!!SHE WAS/IS SO CUTIE 😍😍😍😍😍👑👑👑👑💗💗💗👌👌👌👌💞💞💞💞
OG Fog all day
John Carptenter's film was so much more intense. AND the fog generated on the set by the effects people and lit by the brilliant cinematographer, Dean Cundey was far more effective than what appeared in the remake. Carpenter's film will continue to be the one remembered, not the remake.
I think the less is more approach is something that should have been kept or just not remaking an already perfect ghost story
Not revealing the ghosts completely, keeping the mystery of the back story and using the fog itself, the time it was released benefitted it also
The remake was just not good, it was coming off the back of them early 2000’s slashers/horrors which included a fair few remakes that were just bombing in cinema.
You either loved them or hated them - I hated this one
I feel like the whole remake movie was ruined just by that one scene where the ghost breaks into the kid's room & honks like a squeaky paper horn 😂😂
Matt Is back
Great job with the remake
I love how they dove deeper into the people of the Elizabeth Dane and how the descendants of the founding fathers were targeted and the story if Elizabeths resurrection and return to her true love
I really enjoyed the artifacts appearing on the beach and especially the story of the town in the photos
I’m a fan of the classic and the remake
both movies are awesome 10/10
@Mmm i love it dont care what you think.
@Mmm you make me laugh bully
@Mmm 🥰🥰
no. 1980 version or GTFO
Yes You Back Again Matt Skuta Uploads Next:
Cinderella (1950/1996/2015/2021)
Yes
@@benisthedragon909 Thanks You
Please do Carrie 1976 and 2013
1980 version is better saw it when I was 8 in 1992 on tbs at the time 😈
80s Version.. John Carpenter..
saw at the theater rated R ...myBig brother got us in scared the shat out of us..
Finally Your Back Again Stay Safe
So, you got a remake that is essentially the same just with more peng-pong-boink-zoink and a city run by 23year old. hmm ...
Photography looks great in both films, different time, different look.
Where JCs version is simple creating true fear, RWs version makes everything glow and explode rendering the suspense laugheble.
And of course ... American Flag. Because that's important.
And of course someone has to be tied to someone because, yes. Makes the story that much more interesting and thoughtful, because, yes.
Lots of chliches unnesassarily squeezed into a classic film.
Great !!!
I still don’t understand why the guy (I’m assuming he was supposed to be dead?) got up momentarily and almost stabbed her or something? Maybe I wasn’t paying good enough attention?
After seeing you posted two Carpenter movies in a row at THIS particular time, I have a suspicion you’re a fan of the podcast Blank Check. Amirite?
1980 only
Compare the live action Charlotte's web with the animated one.
I only seen the Remake version.
Your Back
Selma Blair is not a patch on Adrienne Barbeau.
This should have never been remade!!!
Hey Matt Skuta You Have 200 Videos In Total
Never knew this movie existed
Dean Cundey's cinematography is so good in the original. The remake looks so boring.
Exactly. Remake looks like every other grungy post-2000 horror movie. The original looks like it was actually filmed in reality. Perfect example at 3:25
@@trent797 I did spot a couple of great shots in the 2005 version, but overall, yeah, not great.
Come on wasent that bad
Wasent that bad
Personally I don’t think it’s a badly shot film overall, it’s the rest of the remake that I take issue with 🤣
I actually don't mind the remake because I didn't expect a lot from it before seeing it,but as far as remakes go I've seen worse.
Sadly the 2005 is the most forgotten film in movie history
Harsh and not fair to say
@@mogensschmidt2498 this could have worked as a sequel if done right just change a few details or something
Please matt skuta has the comparison of tobey maguier's spiderman, andrew garfield's and tom holland's
Please inside 2007 vs 2018, thanks
George orwell animal farm (1954) (1999) side-by-side comparison
The music makes the 1980 fog a lot scarier and the pirates. The are more scary when they don’t talk. 2005 version is too cheesy.
Next Video: Cinderella (1950/1996/2015/2021) side-by-side comparison Because Of The Movie It’s Out Already
I dont know the remake just has a more "Supernatural" feel....
1980 ! The Orginal ! The Rest is Nothing !
1980s easily
I like the eighty’s movie
1980 All the way
The Fog 1980 Wins
Hands down.
It steamrollers it. The remake is kind of soulless for me.
Totally is the best.
The good things about the remake was the angle of making the girl not only a descendant of one of the killers but also, perhaps, the descendant of Blake, so once Blake found his long-lost love again - his soul and the others could be at peace, and some of the makeup and new ways the spirits got their revenge.
No... handled horribly.
1980 version was the best I saw it on tnt I was 8 in 1992 it was the scariest movie I have seen since the evil dead movie from the 80s the remake of the evil dead was good can’t wait for the sequel 🎉
No comparison at all Fog '85 was a classic , Fog '05 TRASH!!
No it wasent
2005 is surpassed the other. Better movie better well know cast too. Better soundtrack too. A 2000s update was a needed. Not to be over done in 2010s or 2020s
It's a pity they didn't a least use Carpenter's main theme from The Fog in the remake, probably a rights issue.
1980 vintage horrors are more realistic than a running modern day zOmbie.....
A film based on Scandinavian and Japanese folklore
Ohh Hell No!!!
1980's. Way Better
Definitely 1980s THE FOG.
The Muppets baby kill count
1980s version just looks comical, 😂😂😂 i dont know why people bitch about the 2005 film it was way way better.
L’originale è sempre meglio
Per essere un remake però non male
the 2005 is trash
Stupid unnecessary remake.
Without question, the original is far superior. The 2005 version is nothing more than a pathetic failure.
I Agree
The 2005 version was terrible, moreso because the 1980 version was so good.
1980 movie for me i thought the remake was abit lame
1980 the Real fog. Masterpiece.
Better than original
Yes 2005 is better
You guys need to Lose the John carpentar nostalgia Goggles and give the remake a chance
Nah.
I did give the remake a chance. It sucked.
@@ElvenRaptor no it dosent hater better than rob zombie halloween movies
@@mogensschmidt2498 Yet its the 1980 version people love.
I didn't like the Rob Zombie Halloween movies, either.
@@ElvenRaptor Fog remake dosent suk some peoble who are not carpentar fans May like it
I loved the 2005 version, although I haven´t seen the one from 1980.