MLB is still suffering today from Selig's mistakes. His handling of player steroid use. His cowtowing to Peter Angelos in the relocation of the Expos. The legal case is still ongoing today. How this clown got into the HOF is beyond me.
@JD - best, most accurate youtube comment I've read in a long time! Selig being in the HOF is criminal. He took his used car salesman DNA and used to sell MLB out and become a multi-millionaire - all while ripping out the integrity of the game and pricing out working class fans! He took the game from the people and sold to big corporations! F*%K Selig!!!!
Bob Costas killing it! "Pete Rose is banned from Baseball. This segment brought to you by DRAFT KINGS?" Wit doesn't reach a higher plain with that statement. Brilliant Bob!!!
Here's a solution: we have a back log of deserving players. If you won't fill out a full form of 10, your ballot doesn't count. Send in a blank ballot? Doesn't count.
So here is the question I will ask. In ten to fifteen years will these same writers put no pitchers in that are suspected for having doctored balls to become better at their trade? That is just as much of a competitive advantage, and I could say a much bigger one than steroids are. Ask any hitter which is harder to hit. A pitch going a couple of more MPH or a pitch that breaks much sharper from doctoring. Oh and if you think for one moment that pitchers weren't cheating in the 90's I have a bridge I want to sell you.
I hear what you're saying, but doctored baseballs I'm sure go back to Cy Young, Christy Matthewson and Walter Johnson. That's been a constant since the game began. Hell, Whitey Ford doctored a baseball or two with his wedding ring and he's in the Hall
Usually I’m all for shunning cheaters, but baseball people have to let this PED thing go. I’m more pissed none of those Astro players haven’t gotten punished for cheating their way to a World Series title. And what’s worse is when all those guys were taking steroids, baseball was at its absolute peak in popularity. You don’t see the owners of these teams and league executives complaining when their profits skyrocketed from these guys crushing the long ball. Let these guys into the hall of fame.
@@RaiderNation327 He didn’t test positive for Roids, it was for PEDs. And that test still isn’t 100% since we are unsure if it was a false positive or what specifically he did.
Whether its Steroids, Speed or Cocaine the last 50 years of baseball has a very shady back story. Gambling and womanizing removed and lets not forget alcohol abuse( not that I see this benefiting a player).
You stayed to the end… thanks for watching. This segment brought to you by Draft Kings…. As a Reds fan who never saw Pete play live it’s a crime he’s not in. Draft kings, fantasy sports. It’s all gambling. Let Pete & Barry and the Rocket in
So what’s the steroid era? Google the history of PED’s, testosterone , etc and their use in competitive sports, Olympics etc……. Hank Aaron played 23 seasons and there was testosterone running crazy in the league even then.
What, PED's in the 1960's , 1970's in baseball? I highly doubt it. Can you cite an example? Steroids, PED's certainly existed in sports (Olympics) back then, but not in baseball. Greenies, yes, and many players took them, but that's completely different.
@@jamesanthony5681 It was absolutely in baseball by the 70s. Most weightlifters were using it at that time you think they went to different gyms? Honestly back then it wasn’t stigmatized yet.
Enough of the sanctimony by the MLB and the voting writers…who cares. They were allowed to play, they played well and put up amazing numbers that entertained millions. And, put Pete Rose in for Christ’s sake…enough pretending you are oh so holy.
Let the living members already in the HOF’s vote. Do this for all of them football baseball whatever. Let the best of the best decide who their piers are.
The elite inner circle is was he one of the best at his time. Palmeiro was incredibly consistent BUT was he ever a top five player in the league? Not even close. I mean be honest. he was really never top ten. Those are the elite inner circle. The guys that were at the very best for years upon years. Palmeiro was not one of them.
@@angelicalynn1259 I’m guessing you aren’t old enough to have seen Palmeiro play. The man should have been a first or second ballot entry into the HOF. Rafael was elite
@@MikeHart72 Yes I saw him play. First off he did fail a drug test which is what has kept him out. I did say he should be in but he was not elite. Elite being one of the very best. Sorry but he never was (only three top ten MVP finishes proves that). Longevity does not make one elite.
Ortiz making it makes this whole thing a friggin joke. Failed a test, _and_ isn't a first ballot if Edgar Martinez who was never implicated in any way was 10th ballot.
No, they don't. He knowingly broke the cardinal rule in baseball and then voluntarily accepted the lifetime ban to prevent baseball from releasing all the evidence they had found while investigating him. He chose his punishment, now he gets to live with it the rest of his life.
@@kinggremlin4574 A rule is a rule. What's this "cardinal" rule bullsh×t? Are you believing the drug users and ofher cheaters didn't know they were in the wrong or damaging the game because it wasn't a "cardinal" rule they were breaking? They were guilty and knew it was wrong as much as Pete did. And most of them lied about it, just like Pete did, yet you want to keep punishing him and give them a pass??? smh
Anybody who enjoyed this conversation would like Bill James Whatever happened to the Hall of Fame. I don't live too far from Cooperstown, consider it one of my favorite little towns of all time. But the hall is pretty ad hoc and podunk and has been from it's inception. Some rich people who loved the village and lake gave them a terrific tourism business industry with the hall at the heart of it
Personally I always liked the Cosmic Baseball Association's suggestion about Pete Rose: that since he so wants to be in the Hall of Fame they should literally wall him up in Cooperstown like in the Poe story "The Cask Of Amontillado", placing his honorary plaque over the brickwork and hence he would be entombed forever in his own literal Hell of Fame. This segment brought to you by Draft Kings.
There is a reason to keep Rose out sorry. He agreed to a lifetime ban to keep everything from becoming public. I agree with the others but not Rose. If he ever gets in it should be after he is gone.
You sort of contradicted yourself. If it's okay to put him in AFTER HE DIES.....why can't you put him in while he is alive. I know it's a lifetime ban, but kind of silly and mean-spirited to say one hour after he dies..."okay, all is forgiven...let's put him in." And to complete the hypocrisy, MLB net can broadcast his funeral, sponsored by Draft Kings.
It should only be about numbers. If we bring character into things then we wouldn’t have much of a hall of fame. The first 60 years at least had guys that wouldn’t even respect a non white person. If we’re being honest. And though it was common all humans know it was never RIGHT or MORAL..
if they have to put something in writing about ped era players in the h.o.f... then they should put something about h.o.f. segregation era players too... what's right is right... segregation is the biggest black eye in any/every American sport!!!
If you're going off of stats, yes he's a hall of famer. If you are going off of the "Story of baseball" argument, like Bob and Rich were talking about, not so much. Palmeiro's most famous moment of his career was off the field when he wagged his finger at congress saying he didn't do steroids. He had a very solid career, but was only a 4 time all star, finished top 5 in MVP voting once, and never played in a World Series. Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, Sosa, Ramirez, and A-Rod are much more integral to the story of baseball and you can't really tell the story of the 90s/2000s without them.
It's a simple fix: you just create a Dopers' Wing at the HOF; and while they're at it, also add a Gamblers' and Game Fixers' wing, so Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson can also gain entry.
Bonds is one of the greatest players ever played. The greatest hitter. The HR champ. Steroids doesn’t make you a good player. People of all eras did drugs and had PEDs. Get over it crank.
My point is this, don't tell me the hall of fame is about baseball.... Because its not....clearly its about how you are liked, more than its about how you played the game.....
Ppl need to get over it. Regardless if they used PEDs. They still put in work. They still hit those home runs. Or made those strikes. We all know the history. They still deserve to be in the HOF
@@RaiderNation327 you still need to have the skill to hit the ball. PEDs doesn’t improve your batting avg. it’s either you can hit the ball or strike out.
So a very talented player comes up to the plate, the ballpark moves the walls in 30 feet for him( analogy to peds) , and after his at bat they move those walls back out for the honest talented player ( maybe he's not as very talented who is cheating)
It's supposed to be about the history of the game The Good The bad and The ugly. You're not supposed to pick and choose what part you want to remember and what part you want to forget.
There is an argument for a PED-era wing so you can tell that ugly story (instead of giving them all bronze busts). In my opinion the Hall is a museum and should be able to figure itself out. If people don't agree, they don't need to go. We all know who the best players were without needing the Hall's seal of approval.
It was never proven that Joe Jackson participated in the Blacksox scandal or that Pete Rose ever attempted to throw a game or shave points. Yes, Pete did bet, but anyone who ever saw him play knows it just isn't in his DNA to try to lose a baseball game. Many players took PED's before they were banned by MLB. All of these players should be judged strictly by their baseball statistics when it comes to the HOF. I would also suggest that it is time to take the voting away from baseball writers. Too many players that were with small market or losing teams that should be in are not because the writers don't really know about them and too many have gotten in for the opposite reason. The HOF should create a committee that would actually vet potential nominees during that five-year period from when they stop playing to when they are eligible.
Why does anyone need to be apart of some hall of fame to feel better about themselves !! Especially people who have made hundreds of millions of dollars while playing for a living !! Every one else is working for a living not making millions and in no need of a hall of fame and still live a fulfilling life !! What kind of world are these weirdos in that u still need glorified years after you were glorified for several decades ! 🤔 cry babies !! And it's sad and embarrassing !!
Too many current day announcers deem players HOF er’s long before their playing days are over. Calm down talking heads. There is time for discussions after they are retired. If they are HOF er’s the public knows !
Weird how so many ball players did roids and yet none of them even sniff the greatness of Barry Bonds. It's almost like roids aren't magic or something.
The writers should ponder this: Did they vote in Gaylord Perry? If you can't vote for Bonds or Clemens because they 'cheated', how did you vote for Perry?
So, Big Papi is in. A real nice guy. He sure could swing a bat. He didn't set any records though and he wasn't much of a base-runner. I never saw him play any defense, and I'm a lifelong Yankees fan! Yet some like Pete Rose, A Rod, Barry Bonds... - Complete Ball Players - have NO place in the Hall?
I fundamentally disagree. Use of PEDs is disrespectful to the statistical nature of the game. The history of the game is the numbers. Football and basketball are about championships. Baseball with its 162 games are about the numbers and PED numbers make it all a video game. Letting them in does a disservice to Aaron, Ruth, Koufax and every other greats achievements.
All utterly irrelevant....”disrespect” doesn’t negate an obviously deserving resume. Openly ridiculous that Bonds etc aren’t in. One day a non-HOF team will actually be better than a HOF team because of this nonsense
But some of those guys back in the 60's through the 80's used greenies, but since they were all later banned, nobody's trying to discredit or punish the players who took greenies. Baseball waited too late to test and put sanctions in place.
Bonds was a HOF’r before he got big! If he continued to play in the same trajectory for 15 years with little injury, he would have been a guaranteed inductee!
@@NipItInTheBud100 Have you ever played competitive sports? I bet you haven't. He was about the last one to do steroids. It was only when everyone else was doing it that he succumbed. What are your feelings about steroid PapI? He flat out failed his test.
Bernie Madoff was a HOF money manager until he cheated. Like Bonds, his numbers were fugazi. Can’t separate the bad from the good and say, “even if he hadn’t cheated ...” You can’t be an upstanding citizen for 20 years then go around shooting your neighbors’ dogs and expect to retain that high stature. Bonds didn’t have to give any of the money back. He didn’t have his name erased from the record books. But you want to honor him as well? A bridge too far.
One problem: adding those words to everybody’s plaque lumps people like Griffey and Thome in with people who were proven to have taken PEDs, which isn’t fair. So the only solution IS for someone to parse out who’s guilty.
If didn't ask the voters not to vote for him he would be elected. He got 70% the previous year , I don't recall any player getting that many votes and missing .
Barry Bonds did it to himself. *shrug* he was an awful PERSON before steroids and even worse after them. And he didnt need them. He was a HOFer before, and now he's not one after. Hope it was worth it just so you could say 'i won' - because he def. lost homie.
Or, they could face the consequences of their actions and never get in to the hall. How many players never had success because they faced people who cheated? Where’s their justice?
Makes you appreciate how good Ruth,,mantal and maris really were. Bigger parks,,,dead balls,,,,no roids,, smoking,,,being hung over all the time,,, if you think about it it makes bonds,, McGuire and Sosa look stubid
I strongly disagree with the Palmeiro comments, I think if you put Bonds in ( who was prosecuted ) then you have to put all the others in as well. They are all deserving and let's be honest for something that has been around since the 1930's are you going to tell me that no one used them up until this thing explodeded?
I can’t believe these people who want cheaters into the baseball Hall of Fame they cheated they did not deserve to be in the baseball Hall of Fame get over it
They cheated and showed no remorse. They like Rose don't get in. Their records are tainted and worst of all they took spots from clean players and sent others who refused to use back to the minors.
Bob keeps mentioning Bonds natural merits. That's the problem there was nothing natural about them. The intigrety of the game is suspect and questionable because of their choices and selfishness. How could you even allow thei
@@Gnofg pudge played for texas roiders...bagwell us believe...piazza however if so, must of done it since day 1. ortiz and the rest are even ore obvious.
Here’s a fact. No one benefitted more from steroids than Bud Selig and he’s in the HOF
MLB is still suffering today from Selig's mistakes. His handling of player steroid use. His cowtowing to Peter Angelos in the relocation of the Expos. The legal case is still ongoing today.
How this clown got into the HOF is beyond me.
@JD - best, most accurate youtube comment I've read in a long time! Selig being in the HOF is criminal. He took his used car salesman DNA and used to sell MLB out and become a multi-millionaire - all while ripping out the integrity of the game and pricing out working class fans! He took the game from the people and sold to big corporations! F*%K Selig!!!!
And even the writers who won’t vote for them benefited from their careers.
@@joecommenter1332 Because he's an old out of touch closet racist white man just like a majority of the BBWA.
Great statement, finally someone said it. Totally resent Bud Selig.
Bob Costas killing it! "Pete Rose is banned from Baseball. This segment brought to you by DRAFT KINGS?" Wit doesn't reach a higher plain with that statement. Brilliant Bob!!!
However, you can't tell baseball history without Pete Rose or Shoeless Joe.
Okay but Pete rose cheated. He knew what he was doing.
@@brendangilmartin4002 weren't ped's also cheating?
@@charlesappalachia8252 yes
@@charlesappalachia8252 Pete signed a deal to never go in.
Clemens, Bonds, Shoeless Joe, and PETE, in order of priority
Here's a solution: we have a back log of deserving players. If you won't fill out a full form of 10, your ballot doesn't count. Send in a blank ballot? Doesn't count.
And if you do this for 2 or 3 years consecutively, you're disqualified from voting in further ballots. Hold them responsible as well.
You'd start seeing truly fringe guys get in then
Barry Bonds is the most dangerous hitter to ever enter the batter's box....there's no way around that
Anyone thinks that the steroid era is over is in as much denial as 20 years ago. BTW it also started long before the 90’s.
So here is the question I will ask. In ten to fifteen years will these same writers put no pitchers in that are suspected for having doctored balls to become better at their trade? That is just as much of a competitive advantage, and I could say a much bigger one than steroids are. Ask any hitter which is harder to hit. A pitch going a couple of more MPH or a pitch that breaks much sharper from doctoring. Oh and if you think for one moment that pitchers weren't cheating in the 90's I have a bridge I want to sell you.
I hear what you're saying, but doctored baseballs I'm sure go back to Cy Young, Christy Matthewson and Walter Johnson. That's been a constant since the game began. Hell, Whitey Ford doctored a baseball or two with his wedding ring and he's in the Hall
Oh and NO ONE is talking about the rampant amphetamine usage in all sports, AND that definitely impacts focus for pitching and batting🤡
Been saying this for YEARS!! Wish I would have seen this before I just wrote a comment a few minutes ago.
Some say that was Hank Aarons juice.
Thank god the joke that is the rock n roll hall of fame doesn’t keep musicians out for drug use
Usually I’m all for shunning cheaters, but baseball people have to let this PED thing go. I’m more pissed none of those Astro players haven’t gotten punished for cheating their way to a World Series title. And what’s worse is when all those guys were taking steroids, baseball was at its absolute peak in popularity. You don’t see the owners of these teams and league executives complaining when their profits skyrocketed from these guys crushing the long ball. Let these guys into the hall of fame.
IMO, the fact that Ortiz got voted in completely discredits the argument of keeping Bonds, Clemens, Sosa, Palmiero, and others out.
Big Papi never tested positive for Roids, the others did.
@@RaiderNation327 He didn’t test positive for Roids, it was for PEDs. And that test still isn’t 100% since we are unsure if it was a false positive or what specifically he did.
@@RaiderNation327 We know, but the didn’t specify which type of PED he took. Not all PED’s are steroids.
@@Jorge-lh6px 😂 man stop the bullshit! He tested positive dude
In the 03 tests, many legal supplements are known to have generated positives.
Clemens and Bonds belong in for what they did BEFORE the steroids.. it's ridiculous
Exactly!! Bonds was a first ballot hall of famer without the juice, he was simply the best hitter ever with.
I agree......but then why did they feel the need to do it? To me, that is the question.
Love Bob Costas, really miss him calling ball games like he once did.
....and Bob Costas is a national treasure.
The baseball HOF is a mockery without Barry Bonds in it.
Whether its Steroids, Speed or Cocaine the last 50 years of baseball has a very shady back story. Gambling and womanizing removed and lets not forget alcohol abuse( not that I see this benefiting a player).
Don’t forget dipping tobacco!
You stayed to the end… thanks for watching. This segment brought to you by Draft Kings….
As a Reds fan who never saw Pete play live it’s a crime he’s not in. Draft kings, fantasy sports. It’s all gambling. Let Pete & Barry and the Rocket in
So what’s the steroid era? Google the history of PED’s, testosterone , etc and their use in competitive sports, Olympics etc……. Hank Aaron played 23 seasons and there was testosterone running crazy in the league even then.
What, PED's in the 1960's , 1970's in baseball? I highly doubt it. Can you cite an example? Steroids, PED's certainly existed in sports (Olympics) back then, but not in baseball. Greenies, yes, and many players took them, but that's completely different.
@@jamesanthony5681 It was absolutely in baseball by the 70s. Most weightlifters were using it at that time you think they went to different gyms? Honestly back then it wasn’t stigmatized yet.
Baseball has a consistency and credibility problem.. Can't take the baseball Hall seriously with all their hypocrisies.. Dead sport
It's a damn shame that Pete Rose is so black balled.
Pete blackballed himself. He didn't want to be exposed and take his medicine. He signed a lifetime ban.
Costas always makes so much sense. Well said, sir.
Enough of the sanctimony by the MLB and the voting writers…who cares. They were allowed to play, they played well and put up amazing numbers that entertained millions. And, put Pete Rose in for Christ’s sake…enough pretending you are oh so holy.
8:44 great quote
Weird to say Palmeiro is not in the elite inner circle when he's one of only six players with 500 home runs and 3000 hits but ok
Add 1,800 RBI's to it and if that is not elite then I don't know what is then.
Palmeiro not elite? Stop! 3000 hits? 500 home runs? He's elite. Case closed.
@@johnts1 If that is not elite , then I don't know what elite is.
Big Papi had a loveable persona for TV . It's not just stats.
@@PFB1994 I'd say both. If you don't have the stats you could be prince charming, you are not getting in.
Let the living members already in the HOF’s vote. Do this for all of them football baseball whatever. Let the best of the best decide who their piers are.
Would hold so much more weight than writers. Not even close
absolutely!
I couldn’t agree more.
Why? There are consequences to one’s actions. Period.
Palmeiro was elite and should be in the HOF !! Hits ,HR and RBI combination makes him 1 of 4 .
The elite inner circle is was he one of the best at his time. Palmeiro was incredibly consistent BUT was he ever a top five player in the league? Not even close. I mean be honest. he was really never top ten. Those are the elite inner circle. The guys that were at the very best for years upon years. Palmeiro was not one of them.
@@angelicalynn1259 I’m guessing you aren’t old enough to have seen Palmeiro play. The man should have been a first or second ballot entry into the HOF. Rafael was elite
@@MikeHart72 Yes I saw him play. First off he did fail a drug test which is what has kept him out. I did say he should be in but he was not elite. Elite being one of the very best. Sorry but he never was (only three top ten MVP finishes proves that). Longevity does not make one elite.
Ortiz making it makes this whole thing a friggin joke.
Failed a test, _and_ isn't a first ballot if Edgar Martinez who was never implicated in any way was 10th ballot.
What about Curtis Shilling who is left out for personal views and Pete Rose who is out for gambling which is heavily endorsed now at days.
Who’s Curtis Shilling?
If they are gonna put guys from the steroid era in…they MUST Put Pete Rose in too!
No, they don't. He knowingly broke the cardinal rule in baseball and then voluntarily accepted the lifetime ban to prevent baseball from releasing all the evidence they had found while investigating him. He chose his punishment, now he gets to live with it the rest of his life.
@@kinggremlin4574 A rule is a rule. What's this "cardinal" rule bullsh×t? Are you believing the drug users and ofher cheaters didn't know they were in the wrong or damaging the game because it wasn't a "cardinal" rule they were breaking? They were guilty and knew it was wrong as much as Pete did. And most of them lied about it, just like Pete did, yet you want to keep punishing him and give them a pass??? smh
Anybody who enjoyed this conversation would like Bill James Whatever happened to the Hall of Fame. I don't live too far from Cooperstown, consider it one of my favorite little towns of all time. But the hall is pretty ad hoc and podunk and has been from it's inception. Some rich people who loved the village and lake gave them a terrific tourism business industry with the hall at the heart of it
Personally I always liked the Cosmic Baseball Association's suggestion about Pete Rose: that since he so wants to be in the Hall of Fame they should literally wall him up in Cooperstown like in the Poe story "The Cask Of Amontillado", placing his honorary plaque over the brickwork and hence he would be entombed forever in his own literal Hell of Fame. This segment brought to you by Draft Kings.
BARRY BONDS, ROGER CLEMENS, RAFAEL PALMEIRO, JUAN GONZALEZ, MARC MCGWIRE, need to be in the HALL OF FAME…period….
If baseball didn’t revoke the Astros’ championship then there’s no reason for the sport to keep Bonds/Clemens/Rose out of the Hall of Fame either
There is a reason to keep Rose out sorry. He agreed to a lifetime ban to keep everything from becoming public. I agree with the others but not Rose. If he ever gets in it should be after he is gone.
You sort of contradicted yourself. If it's okay to put him in AFTER HE DIES.....why can't you put him in while he is alive. I know it's a lifetime ban, but kind of silly and mean-spirited to say one hour after he dies..."okay, all is forgiven...let's put him in." And to complete the hypocrisy, MLB net can broadcast his funeral, sponsored by Draft Kings.
Build a PED HOF wing in Rob Manfred's basement. Done. Next question.
Costas nailed it.
It should only be about numbers. If we bring character into things then we wouldn’t have much of a hall of fame. The first 60 years at least had guys that wouldn’t even respect a non white person. If we’re being honest. And though it was common all humans know it was never RIGHT or MORAL..
Great point.
The museum is for the history. Not the hall.
if they have to put something in writing about ped era players in the h.o.f... then they should put something about h.o.f. segregation era players too... what's right is right... segregation is the biggest black eye in any/every American sport!!!
I disagree about Palmeiro he’s one of 4 ppl with 3000 hits an 500 home runs how do u not put him in if you let bonds or anybody in that era in?
If you're going off of stats, yes he's a hall of famer. If you are going off of the "Story of baseball" argument, like Bob and Rich were talking about, not so much. Palmeiro's most famous moment of his career was off the field when he wagged his finger at congress saying he didn't do steroids. He had a very solid career, but was only a 4 time all star, finished top 5 in MVP voting once, and never played in a World Series. Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, Sosa, Ramirez, and A-Rod are much more integral to the story of baseball and you can't really tell the story of the 90s/2000s without them.
It's a simple fix: you just create a Dopers' Wing at the HOF; and while they're at it, also add a Gamblers' and Game Fixers' wing, so Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson can also gain entry.
The people that didn't cheat shouldn't be snubbed for following the rules. You choose to cheat, you remain outside Cooperstown looking in.
And who decides if a player cheated? And when did they cheat?
@@jamesanthony5681 The. Rules.
Dude, you are absolutely delusional if you think everyone in the Hall never cheated
the records is the problem...aaron is the home run leader and maris the single season king...bonds records do not count..
Amen. Gracias Al. Now Peggy needs some loving lol
Bonds is one of the greatest players ever played. The greatest hitter. The HR champ. Steroids doesn’t make you a good player. People of all eras did drugs and had PEDs. Get over it crank.
@@jacobcarter1947 Even the current players today are doing drugs / have PED's? And I beg to differ, Hank Aaron is the GOAT. Period.
@@jacobcarter1947 facts
@@musicman76enator Hank is not better than Bonds 🤷🏽♂️ so stop the bullshit
The career leaders in Home runs and Hits are both NOT in the hall of fame? How is that possible?
My point is this, don't tell me the hall of fame is about baseball.... Because its not....clearly its about how you are liked, more than its about how you played the game.....
If Bonds gets in....so should Pete because basically the rules don't matter
If any steroid user is voted in Rose should be enshrined first
Agree neither should be in
We don’t want these cheaters in the Hall.
Would you put a note underneath Bud Seligs plaque that says that he made his fame by allowing steroid use
Ppl need to get over it. Regardless if they used PEDs. They still put in work. They still hit those home runs. Or made those strikes. We all know the history. They still deserve to be in the HOF
We'll never get over it. Ever.
@@RaiderNation327 you still need to have the skill to hit the ball. PEDs doesn’t improve your batting avg. it’s either you can hit the ball or strike out.
So a very talented player comes up to the plate, the ballpark moves the walls in 30 feet for him( analogy to peds) , and after his at bat they move those walls back out for the honest talented player ( maybe he's not as very talented who is cheating)
More steroids - more PED’s - let these players extend their careers into their 40s.
It's supposed to be about the history of the game The Good The bad and The ugly. You're not supposed to pick and choose what part you want to remember and what part you want to forget.
There is an argument for a PED-era wing so you can tell that ugly story (instead of giving them all bronze busts). In my opinion the Hall is a museum and should be able to figure itself out. If people don't agree, they don't need to go. We all know who the best players were without needing the Hall's seal of approval.
put it in the members hands, take it away from the press.
Easy, stop giving votes to these dorks who havent played since little league and give votes to former players and MLB personnel who know the game.
That's the answer. No more nerds deciding which athletes get in. Other players and baseball executives.
It was never proven that Joe Jackson participated in the Blacksox scandal or that Pete Rose ever attempted to throw a game or shave points. Yes, Pete did bet, but anyone who ever saw him play knows it just isn't in his DNA to try to lose a baseball game. Many players took PED's before they were banned by MLB. All of these players should be judged strictly by their baseball statistics when it comes to the HOF. I would also suggest that it is time to take the voting away from baseball writers. Too many players that were with small market or losing teams that should be in are not because the writers don't really know about them and too many have gotten in for the opposite reason. The HOF should create a committee that would actually vet potential nominees during that five-year period from when they stop playing to when they are eligible.
Keep known juicers out! (Kick existing HOF-ers out if evidence is uncovered as a juicer in the future).
Why does anyone need to be apart of some hall of fame to feel better about themselves !! Especially people who have made hundreds of millions of dollars while playing for a living !! Every one else is working for a living not making millions and in no need of a hall of fame and still live a fulfilling life !! What kind of world are these weirdos in that u still need glorified years after you were glorified for several decades ! 🤔 cry babies !! And it's sad and embarrassing !!
It's ridiculous that bonds, Clemens, get Al aren't in the Hof. Baseball is behind the times and need to catch up
Too many current day announcers deem players HOF er’s long before their playing days are over. Calm down talking heads. There is time for discussions after they are retired. If they are HOF er’s the public knows !
Why dont we let the players vote and decide who gets in? It is their club, their museum. Not the writers.
Weird how so many ball players did roids and yet none of them even sniff the greatness of Barry Bonds. It's almost like roids aren't magic or something.
The writers should ponder this: Did they vote in Gaylord Perry? If you can't vote for Bonds or Clemens because they 'cheated', how did you vote for Perry?
The baseball hall of fame where drug user and gamblers are banned but racist are allowed
Not a single roid or ped or whatever user should be in the hall, zero fucks.
So, Big Papi is in. A real nice guy. He sure could swing a bat. He didn't set any records though and he wasn't much of a base-runner. I never saw him play any defense, and I'm a lifelong Yankees fan! Yet some like Pete Rose, A Rod, Barry Bonds... - Complete Ball Players - have NO place in the Hall?
I fundamentally disagree. Use of PEDs is disrespectful to the statistical nature of the game. The history of the game is the numbers. Football and basketball are about championships. Baseball with its 162 games are about the numbers and PED numbers make it all a video game. Letting them in does a disservice to Aaron, Ruth, Koufax and every other greats achievements.
Ortiz did steroids
All utterly irrelevant....”disrespect” doesn’t negate an obviously deserving resume. Openly ridiculous that Bonds etc aren’t in. One day a non-HOF team will actually be better than a HOF team because of this nonsense
But some of those guys back in the 60's through the 80's used greenies, but since they were all later banned, nobody's trying to discredit or punish the players who took greenies. Baseball waited too late to test and put sanctions in place.
The history of all sports is PEDs . You really think any hall of famer that played before let’s say 1980 never did some kind of PED back then?
@@steohara6353 if any not as much as you think. Being overly muscular was seen as bad for a baseball player. Jose conseco (sp) changed that.
If you can't name all of them you shouldn't call out specific players
Bonds was a HOF’r before he got big! If he continued to play in the same trajectory for 15 years with little injury, he would have been a guaranteed inductee!
too bad he didnt do just that. The consequences of ones decisions are real!
@@NipItInTheBud100 Have you ever played competitive sports? I bet you haven't. He was about the last one to do steroids. It was only when everyone else was doing it that he succumbed. What are your feelings about steroid PapI? He flat out failed his test.
Bernie Madoff was a HOF money manager until he cheated. Like Bonds, his numbers were fugazi. Can’t separate the bad from the good and say, “even if he hadn’t cheated ...” You can’t be an upstanding citizen for 20 years then go around shooting your neighbors’ dogs and expect to retain that high stature. Bonds didn’t have to give any of the money back. He didn’t have his name erased from the record books. But you want to honor him as well? A bridge too far.
@@jjmalaprop9968 Madoff was falsifying his records from the beginning. he died in jail. You analogy is really bad.
@@Gnofg It is undetermined when Madoff became illegitimate. He died in jail because he paid a price. What’s Bonds’ price to pay?
Let Pete In. Let Pete In. LET PETE IN!!!!!!!!
curt shilling. no pets, just bs politics
One problem: adding those words to everybody’s plaque lumps people like Griffey and Thome in with people who were proven to have taken PEDs, which isn’t fair. So the only solution IS for someone to parse out who’s guilty.
Tom Brady, Suspended for cheating and was on A team known for cheating. I rest my case.
There are too many writers with agendas and the ones who try to do the right thing have no guidelines.
I think they should let him in
Segregation Era and Steroid Era.
It's pretty easy don't have the writer's vote and just let the fans do it.
I was hoping for Curt Schilling to be in the Hall of Fame too
If didn't ask the voters not to vote for him he would be elected. He got 70% the previous year , I don't recall any player getting that many votes and missing .
Barry Bonds did it to himself. *shrug* he was an awful PERSON before steroids and even worse after them. And he didnt need them. He was a HOFer before, and now he's not one after. Hope it was worth it just so you could say 'i won' - because he def. lost homie.
But the fans say, "No". (Repeat)
You shouldn't have to vote someone if they're not hall of fame worthy
The only way to fix it is to have Hall of Famers do the voting
Why do you even want to think about fixing it , they chose to cheat and got caught , that’s life , dont be bigger than life
You don’t let unqualified people Vote for hall of fame.
Or, they could face the consequences of their actions and never get in to the hall. How many players never had success because they faced people who cheated? Where’s their justice?
Makes you appreciate how good Ruth,,mantal and maris really were. Bigger parks,,,dead balls,,,,no roids,, smoking,,,being hung over all the time,,, if you think about it it makes bonds,, McGuire and Sosa look stubid
hey what about the fact that mike trouts shoulders touch his ears and that shohei ohtani exists
I strongly disagree with the Palmeiro comments, I think if you put Bonds in ( who was prosecuted ) then you have to put all the others in as well.
They are all deserving and let's be honest for something that has been around since the 1930's are you going to tell me that no one used them up until this thing explodeded?
Roger Clemens and Barry bonds made baseball millions how dare they not be in the hall of Fame
Lol
There's a good reason they didnt get in. They cheated the game, the fans, and the country. They screwed everyone.
Yeah, like Pete Rose.
@@Tubalcain422 I don't think Pete took roids, he just gambled and slept with other owners' wives.
@@musicman76enator They didn't cheat anyone
Suspected PED usage??
I can’t believe these people who want cheaters into the baseball Hall of Fame they cheated they did not deserve to be in the baseball Hall of Fame get over it
While we're adding asterisks, all players pre-Jackie Robinson, *only played with and against white players.
@Charlie Post Jackie Robinson includes all ethnicities. 🤔🤔🤔
Today is the steroid era. Players are more jacked than ever and hitting more HRs than ever.
Have a very special steroid hallway with dim lights for a dim time in baseball
It was the most popular time in baseball history. Possibly the best time of any sport.
Oh no it was too entertaining
But it's gotta be in Rob Manfred's basement. Don't ask why. It just needs to be there.
@@musicman76enator open 24 hours a day 365.
Bud Selig and the owners wouldn't call it a dim time. They encouraged it. It helped boost attendance after the 94 strike
Cheating is cheating. No admission for cheaters.
They cheated and showed no remorse. They like Rose don't get in. Their records are tainted and worst of all they took spots from clean players and sent others who refused to use back to the minors.
Sorry Bob you’re already incoherent
They let other cheaters in so why not this fresh batch of cheaters? Nice logic.
Yes just put bonds in upper box seat above all other players because he is
Bob keeps mentioning Bonds natural merits. That's the problem there was nothing natural about them. The intigrety of the game is suspect and questionable because of their choices and selfishness. How could you even allow thei
palmerio is better than ortiz...
Ortiz, Pudge, Bagwell, Piazza were all steroids people. My friend played in the college summer leagues with Bagwell. He was not a HR hitter.
@@Gnofg Piazza took roids? When?
@@Gnofg pudge played for texas roiders...bagwell us believe...piazza however if so, must of done it since day 1. ortiz and the rest are even ore obvious.
Ortiz numbers should have an asterisk for hitting at that 300 foot right field wall in Boston. He only had 60 HRs in his first 6 years in the league
@@quiveringmoist7558 It was never proven that Big Papi took Roids. They tested him back then, never a positive test.
If PED players are voted into the HOF, I will no longer purchase game tickets and sports memorabilia.
ROSE OMG