There is a lot of good prospects, however there is no one to take a risk on. Take the guy if he is there but there are plenty in the first 5 rounds that have skills. All of them need to be developed. Mays and Williams maybe can play day one and will but they are not 100% safe. It depends on where they go. Not sure Chicago is not a good place for a QB, they do not develop them.
I feel like 95% of quarterbacks needs a support system to have any kind of success in the league so totally agree with you there. Risks are everywhere and you just gotta pick your poison. Love your analysis here
I like that but I try to focus on the players strengths rather that weaknesses. Great coaches in the NFL build their offense around their QB’s strengths :)
Mr Warrior that could totally be true - I agree that’s a huge aspect to a players success! I just can’t measure it from the position I’m in so I didn’t even talk about it. I don’t know the guy personally :)
If Jaden daniels doesn’t win Heisman is he still your qb2? Let’s me real his draft stock went up after winning Heisman despite not playing any more games
What’s up Pookie. I got Jayden and Drake in the same tier. Less of a 2 or 3 situation. I rank them the same as their strengths are in different areas but both at a high level . Looking forward to them both balling out in the league!!
Solid video but I’ve got beef with one of the takes. Talking about Penix “you can’t do it all by yourself” he had 3 NFL caliber WRs including Rome Odunze who is a top 10 pick and Polk who is probably a round 2 guy. On top of that he also had the #1 offensive line in all of football - they literally won the Joe Moore award for best O Line in football Plus, not mentioning the fact that he had not one, not two, not three, but four season ending injuries throughout his college career is crazy. I love Penix as a player and I do think he’ll shine if he stays healthy but clean it up w ur analysis big dog. Subbed to the channel you’re gonna pop off one day
Hey brother i appreciate it big time!! 🤞🏼❤️ Penix is for sure surrounded by tons of talent - his interior O line just got cooked in the Natty Champ :) Hope you have the best day my man!!
Could you explain to me why everyone says Caleb will be a bust? I've seen so many people either saying he's the next Mahomes then I see others saying he'll be like bryce young
Humans like to go against the popular view to make themselves sound different. Professional hating some might say. Caleb showed a lot of emotion and people weren’t a fan of that. I personally like the emotion. The only fair knock imo is that his Senior year wasn’t extremely productive and he improvises too much. Nobody is perfect and if Caleb goes to a half decent situation he’s going to be great. Thanks for coming to my Ted talk
Is there a big skill difference between Rattler and JJ? I know they were in different tiers in the video, but the quality of the team they were on were very different
I’d say so personally. Very much agree on the different teams part. I think JJ’s game is more translatable to the NFL as he’s much more accurate and precise. The Good tier to Solid Tier is a pretty big skill gap
So, I don't share your enthusiasm for Williams. I am bothered that he played worse in '23 than '22 and I have questions about his leadership and intangibles. That said, I thought this was among the best analysis videos I have seen. I appreciate the production quality and your delivery as well as the analysis.
Cade I just found you and I absolutely love your content, especially these lists. We all know qbs are nearly impossible to evaluate, and I think the stats are something like 50% of first rounders don’t end up being that franchise qb or solid 10yr starter. Do you think their success is based on who drafts them? Man, like you I really like all 6 top qbs, but I think whoever goes 3 overall would much rather play for the Vikes than NE. Sorry to go off. Lmk what you think. -Shane
Shane! First off, thank you so much brother. Appreciate you Sir🤞🏼❤️ Second off, I strongly agree with you. I personally think that QBs that aren’t selected 1st overall are dang near completely reliant on the team that drafts them. Thus I bet Daniels is praying the Vikings trade up for him and he doesn’t land in New England. Who is your fav prospect between Nix, Penix and JJ?? 🤔
I have Drake Maye as my number 1 QB because of his size, arm talent, and his pocket awareness. Also, I have Caleb Williams lower because with his lack of elite speed, I think his improvisational abilities will take a bit of a hit, and even though he has really good arm strength, it's just not at the level of Maye's IMO.
@@CadeRathbone I dont think that he is a great processor, and the fact he didnt have his break out until year 5 are red flags to me. If im drafting a 5th year guy, I'd expect him to have an incredible feel for the game. Jayden Daniels showed great down field accuracy, but I think his production was too reliant on his elite receivers. Obviously I could be very wrong but I dont quite see it with him lol.
No Nix accuracy? I don’t think that’s supported by the tape at all. His ball placement and accuracy are excellent. If I was going to knock him, it’s on the short throws. I think it’s probably a focus issue. The other issue is not looking downfield enough. Other than that, his tape is elite.
I hate when people say that because McCarthy has never put the team on his back he won't be good in the NFL. The first time his team trail in the fourth quarter this year he lead them down the field and they scored. I'm not saying he is going to be anything special but come on find something that he does bad instead of something that is a result of him and the team being good, so he doesn't have to do it.
Great video! Just subscribed! Looking forward to more content! As a Commanders fan, I’ve been going back and fourth between Daniels and Maye since I learned we had pick 2! My hair is falling out trying to figure this out lol
Hey thank you very much Kenny!! Welcome! Aw yeah you’re going to be stressing until April 25th lol. Looking forward to making more mock drafts and Tier Lists for you sir!!
i have no idea why people think the bears should draft caleb williams, 100% the right move is to trade down and get marvin harrison and 2 other draft picks (mayybe get laiaitu latu or dallas turner and some o linemen)
I'm a Michigan Bro and i'll think he will be alright BUTTTTTTTTTTTT, he probs won't be the best player out of the Michigan draftboard personally. Roman and Mikey I think will span out for great carrerrs.
Honestly no. Footballs weird that way and people have to find the right situation to succeed sometimes and that’s okay. It’s hard to be consistent when you have 10 other variables (players) on the field that could determine your success
Michael is a really good player. Full transparency, I was trying to get this list out as fast as possible and just totally forgot him. I hope he balls out at the next level 🫡
Bro has blown up this is crazy❤
All thanks to y’all 🤞🏼❤️❤️ more tiers are in the works!!
very surprised he only has under 500 subs, this video was amazing
Thank you very much i appreciate it sir!! 🤞🏼❤️
There is a lot of good prospects, however there is no one to take a risk on. Take the guy if he is there but there are plenty in the first 5 rounds that have skills. All of them need to be developed. Mays and Williams maybe can play day one and will but they are not 100% safe. It depends on where they go. Not sure Chicago is not a good place for a QB, they do not develop them.
I feel like 95% of quarterbacks needs a support system to have any kind of success in the league so totally agree with you there. Risks are everywhere and you just gotta pick your poison. Love your analysis here
Jayden is so exciting man, the film is absolutely eye popping he’s a big play waiting to happen
Luke he’s going to be something special!! I hope he gets surrounded with the right talent wherever he goes 😎
Jayden Daniels is going to be something special!!
He’s a game changer 🤠
This could be a very promising QB class
Thanks for the leg work. Good list.
Hey thank you very much Mr Samuel!! 🤞🏼❤️
This is great editing and sound for a developing channel
Congrats ‼️‼️
Super Sam i appreciate that big time
Brother!! 🤞🏼❤️
I know it’s a lot but if you have time you should make a video on which nfl team would fit each of these guys the best
That’s a great idea my man!! I’ll start drafting a video up once all these head coaches shake out 😎 thank you for the inspiration!!
Fire edits dude, hidden gem UA-cam channel. Keep grinding!
Caden I love your name brother and I appreciate that more than you know my man 🤞🏼❤️ have the best day!!
Great quality for such low leadership you’re gonna get there bro just subscribed
Alex you’re the man🤞🏼❤️ thank you very much!!
You should report how far each QB can throw the ball. Milton can throw it 85 yds.
I like that a lot!! Good idea!
bro you're gonna blow up, your content and editing skills are ON POINT! God bless man I'm following !
Ant thank you so much my man🤞🏼❤️God bless you brother!! Made my day
bro reminds me of football analysis.
You should give the height and weight of each QB, their age and speed. Caleb is too short, Daniels has a weak arm. Maye should be #1.
I like that but I try to focus on the players strengths rather that weaknesses. Great coaches in the NFL build their offense around their QB’s strengths :)
Take Caleb out, how do you rank this qb class among others in the past?
Still better than majority. Lots of great options here for rebuilding teams!
Great video keep it up
Alex i appreciate that more than you know brother 🤞🏼❤️ thank you!!
Great video, I'm with you on the love for Jayden Daniels. Love from the UK my man 💙
James my man i appreciate that big time🥹 made my day - have a great one brother!!
You too brother, been binge watching your videos this evening and had to show some love. Keep smashing it man!
Aye stop it now - no one wants to see a grown man cry
What Draft vid should I do next - RB or TE??
RB definitely! Tryna see where you rank Jonathon Brooks 🤘
Say less king😎
Great rankings
Thank you Sir I appreciate it a ton!! 🤞🏼❤️
As a Bears fan my mouth be WATERING
The Bears time is NOW
We're taking MHJ not a QB
That is a real possibility
He's got a personality worse than Johnny manziel (C. Williams) I don't think it's his talent that's lacking but I think his intangibles will hurt him
Mr Warrior that could totally be true - I agree that’s a huge aspect to a players success! I just can’t measure it from the position I’m in so I didn’t even talk about it. I don’t know the guy personally :)
Where would Jordan Travis be ranked if he wasn’t injured?
That’s a great question that I don’t know because I haven’t looked at him yet :) I’ll throw him in 2.0 for sure!
If Jaden daniels doesn’t win Heisman is he still your qb2? Let’s me real his draft stock went up after winning Heisman despite not playing any more games
What’s up Pookie. I got Jayden and Drake in the same tier. Less of a 2 or 3 situation. I rank them the same as their strengths are in different areas but both at a high level . Looking forward to them both balling out in the league!!
Solid video but I’ve got beef with one of the takes. Talking about Penix “you can’t do it all by yourself” he had 3 NFL caliber WRs including Rome Odunze who is a top 10 pick and Polk who is probably a round 2 guy.
On top of that he also had the #1 offensive line in all of football - they literally won the Joe Moore award for best O Line in football
Plus, not mentioning the fact that he had not one, not two, not three, but four season ending injuries throughout his college career is crazy.
I love Penix as a player and I do think he’ll shine if he stays healthy but clean it up w ur analysis big dog. Subbed to the channel you’re gonna pop off one day
Hey brother i appreciate it big time!! 🤞🏼❤️ Penix is for sure surrounded by tons of talent - his interior O line just got cooked in the Natty Champ :)
Hope you have the best day my man!!
Could you explain to me why everyone says Caleb will be a bust? I've seen so many people either saying he's the next Mahomes then I see others saying he'll be like bryce young
Humans like to go against the popular view to make themselves sound different. Professional hating some might say.
Caleb showed a lot of emotion and people weren’t a fan of that. I personally like the emotion.
The only fair knock imo is that his Senior year wasn’t extremely productive and he improvises too much.
Nobody is perfect and if Caleb goes to a half decent situation he’s going to be great. Thanks for coming to my Ted talk
Is there a big skill difference between Rattler and JJ? I know they were in different tiers in the video, but the quality of the team they were on were very different
I’d say so personally.
Very much agree on the different teams part. I think JJ’s game is more translatable to the NFL as he’s much more accurate and precise. The Good tier to Solid Tier is a pretty big skill gap
Do more videos like this
Thank you, Tim!! You got it 🫡
Pratt above Rattler & Milton
My man! You’re prolly right. Haven’t even looked at his stuff tho tbh
i need the steelers to take a qb dis draft
Charles who would you like them to take?? 👀
So, I don't share your enthusiasm for Williams. I am bothered that he played worse in '23 than '22 and I have questions about his leadership and intangibles. That said, I thought this was among the best analysis videos I have seen. I appreciate the production quality and your delivery as well as the analysis.
Hey Zip city i appreciate that a ton!!! Thank you very much 🤞🏼❤️❤️
Cade I just found you and I absolutely love your content, especially these lists.
We all know qbs are nearly impossible to evaluate, and I think the stats are something like 50% of first rounders don’t end up being that franchise qb or solid 10yr starter.
Do you think their success is based on who drafts them? Man, like you I really like all 6 top qbs, but I think whoever goes 3 overall would much rather play for the Vikes than NE.
Sorry to go off. Lmk what you think.
-Shane
Shane! First off, thank you so much brother. Appreciate you Sir🤞🏼❤️
Second off, I strongly agree with you. I personally think that QBs that aren’t selected 1st overall are dang near completely reliant on the team that drafts them. Thus I bet Daniels is praying the Vikings trade up for him and he doesn’t land in New England.
Who is your fav prospect between Nix, Penix and JJ?? 🤔
Would have trounced Cam Ward in that last tier with Milton
Respect it🫡
Did you forget jordan Travis bc of his injury
All else but that I love
Yeah I just forgot to add him in there. Thank you Brodie!! 🤞🏼❤️
@@CadeRathbone w
@@CadeRathbone where would you have put him like pre injury
@@CadeRathbone or after idc
I have Drake Maye as my number 1 QB because of his size, arm talent, and his pocket awareness. Also, I have Caleb Williams lower because with his lack of elite speed, I think his improvisational abilities will take a bit of a hit, and even though he has really good arm strength, it's just not at the level of Maye's IMO.
What’s up my man! Drake is going to be a stud for sure. I respect your opinion on having him at #1😎
I think Jayden Daniels will be the big bust of this class
Heard it here first! Just curious, why do you think so?
@@CadeRathbone I dont think that he is a great processor, and the fact he didnt have his break out until year 5 are red flags to me. If im drafting a 5th year guy, I'd expect him to have an incredible feel for the game. Jayden Daniels showed great down field accuracy, but I think his production was too reliant on his elite receivers. Obviously I could be very wrong but I dont quite see it with him lol.
That’s a totally valid argument I see where you’re coming from
No Nix accuracy? I don’t think that’s supported by the tape at all. His ball placement and accuracy are excellent. If I was going to knock him, it’s on the short throws. I think it’s probably a focus issue. The other issue is not looking downfield enough. Other than that, his tape is elite.
I agree with you! I said “sometimes” i get concerned with decision making and accuracy. Nix is gonna do great!
Where’s shendur sanders
He’s staying another year!
I hate when people say that because McCarthy has never put the team on his back he won't be good in the NFL. The first time his team trail in the fourth quarter this year he lead them down the field and they scored. I'm not saying he is going to be anything special but come on find something that he does bad instead of something that is a result of him and the team being good, so he doesn't have to do it.
I said JJ would be good in the NFL not bad! :) Dudes got talent!
Great video! Just subscribed! Looking forward to more content! As a Commanders fan, I’ve been going back and fourth between Daniels and Maye since I learned we had pick 2! My hair is falling out trying to figure this out lol
Maye is a much better prospect
Hey thank you very much Kenny!! Welcome!
Aw yeah you’re going to be stressing until April 25th lol. Looking forward to making more mock drafts and Tier Lists for you sir!!
Finally someone not glazing McCarthy
😭😭😭
i have no idea why people think the bears should draft caleb williams, 100% the right move is to trade down and get marvin harrison and 2 other draft picks (mayybe get laiaitu latu or dallas turner and some o linemen)
There is a real argument to be had there!
JJ won’t do anything, let’s be real
You said it - not me ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
JJ to the Saints
Olave’s value ⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️
I'm a Michigan Bro and i'll think he will be alright BUTTTTTTTTTTTT, he probs won't be the best player out of the Michigan draftboard personally. Roman and Mikey I think will span out for great carrerrs.
@@superbee2281Da fck he won’t come to the Saintssss !! He trashhhh !
Any worries Daniels was a late bloomer? He's 2 years older than Maye and Caleb
Honestly no. Footballs weird that way and people have to find the right situation to succeed sometimes and that’s okay. It’s hard to be consistent when you have 10 other variables (players) on the field that could determine your success
How about Michael Pratt? He’s so much better than Milton.
Michael is a really good player. Full transparency, I was trying to get this list out as fast as possible and just totally forgot him. I hope he balls out at the next level 🫡
Hating Michigan is a valid reason😂
Haha MY MAN
Whoever said that, there’s no such thing as perfect clearly didn’t see this list.
Milton did impress me at the combine, though truthfully. I wouldn’t say enough to move him up a tier, but he showed potential.
Hahaha appreciate you brother 🤞🏼❤️
Yeah I feel the same exact way. A good coach needs to draft him to find success is his scenario!
Caleb Williams = Baker Mayfield
Pro Bowl Baker Mayfield 😎
michael penix should be top 3
What’s up Jacob!! Hey i feel ya - he’s special!!
SOUTH Carolina not Southern 🙄
Sorry Sir - I repeated after saying Southern California. Thanks for the support!
I think jj is going to be better than penix
He’s got the potential!!
Southern Carolina?!?😂😂
lol I’ve been saying Southern California so much it slipped
All good Bigg Dogg! Keep em commin! You're doing great work! Subscribed!
Aye Lonnie thank you very much!!! Appreciate you brother 🤞🏼❤️
Caleb Williams reminds me of Bryce Youbg... He's really small. Caleb is NOT Andrew Luck talent
To each their own opinion I respect it!
i don't like drake bc he tries to be too much of hero and it reminds like allen at times. can't be careless w the rock in the nfl.
Valid point right there sir 🫡
Jayden is going to be way better than Williams. Work ethic alone will push way past Caleb.
Work ethic goes a longggg way!