The Grand Canyon Mid-air Collision | A Short Documentary | Fascinating Horror
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 чер 2024
- "On the 30th of June, 1956, a passenger flight departed Los Angeles bound for Kansas City..."
As always, THANK YOU to all my Patreon patrons: you make this channel possible.
/ fascinatinghorror
SOCIAL MEDIA:
► Twitter: / truehorrortales
► TikTok: / fascinatinghorror
► Suggestions: hello@fascinatinghorror.co.uk
CHAPTERS:
00:00 - Intro
00:36 - Background
02:38 - The Grand Canyon Mid-air Collision
08:37 - The Aftermath
MUSIC:
► "Glass Pond" by Public Memory
SOURCES:
► “Over the Edge: Death in the Grand Canyon” by Thomas Myers and Michael Ghiglieri, published by Puma Press, 2012. Link: www.google.co.uk/books/editio...
► Civil Aeronautics Board Accident Investigation Report, published by the Civil Aeronautics Board, April 1957. Available via: web.archive.org/web/201502201...
► "The Site of a 1950s Plane Crash Just Became a National Landmark" by Adrienne LaFrance, published by The Atlantic, April 2014. Link: www.theatlantic.com/technolog...
#Documentary #History #TrueStories
In 1956 my aunt was a TWA Stewardess in Los Angeles - and felt badly that she gained job seniority because her co-workers were lost on that flight.
Damn, that must be the worst way to get promoted! What a story. I hope she made her peace with the loss of her friends. It must have been hard. Thanks for sharing.
Wow. I hope she was able to find comfort in having been given another chance at life and didn’t feel a lot of regret and remorse about it.
@@saragrant9749 have I seen you in the Fatal Motorsport channel before?
Is she still alive?
Ugh.
Womentalk. "Make peace with their loss" "Find comfort"
She didn't die in screams, fear, dismemberment and fire. Never sympathy for the horrifically fated in life, only the ones that have to "deal" with the loss.
Man, when you think about it from a standpoint of physical space, the odds of two planes randomly being in the exact same point at the exact same altitude at the exact same time is just mind-blowing.
Especially when there were far fewer planes in the sky - although if they were coming from the same place and going to see the same sights (the Grand Canyon) it's not all that surprising they might get there at the same time and crash.
Rumour has it that the women in green still haunts the site. When the cry went out 'hand up, who wants to see the Grand Canyon from the air? She was the only one who didn't raise her hand.'
@@KebabMusicLtd Is that an actual legend?
@@KebabMusicLtd That is literally impossible as there were no survivors and that would not have been broadcast on the radio.
Not really, their flight plans were both from LA and the Grand Canyon is a tourist attraction. It's more amazing this did not happen sooner.
I had no idea this was the 1st commercial airplane accident to exceed 100 fatalities, I didn't even know there was a collision above the Grand Canyon in the first place
The chasm beckons, like a siren singing
Same here. I know about the helicopter crash there in 2001, I was there one week prior. They banned flying in the canyon after that. You can only fly over it now I think.
This accident lead to major changes in how ATC was used within the US as the CAB as it was then did not use anything but VFR in most cases and it had little direct communication with pilots, most orders for ATC went via the airline's dispatchers.
The situation here was not helped by aircrew deviating to show off the Canyon to the passengers and you created a point where the pilots literally could not see the other aircraft approaching, Discovery did an hour long Mayday/Air Crash Investigation into it a few years back and that is worth tracking down.
@@tehjamerzIs that from a song or poem?
Same here. Hopefully the passengers and crew only had a short time of panic.
If ever you wonder about health and safety rules, just remember something tragic has usually happened that means these rules have been bought in…. Be safe x
"Safety rules are written in blood."
Sometimes it is the opposite. A billionaire Train company owner will lobby a Republican (Trump) to repeal laws requiring Automatic Brakes on Trains carrying dangerous materials. Then the Train crashes.. and the Water and Food supply of half the nation is r(h)uined!
Like seat belts
Almost like those pesky government regulations that politicians are always saying they are going slash to set the market free, almost like those regulations were put there for a reason. Oh well, now l think l might to go to town in my self driving Tesla because what could possibly go wrong.
True! We never learn, many people have to die before health and safety are a concern!
The way this story started off made me think of those word problems in math class...
"One plane leaves LA at nine o'clock going two hundred miles an hour, and the other plane leaves Chicago at eight forty-five going four hundred miles an hour. How long does it take for them to have a midair collision above the Grand Canyon?"
:)
I once saw a joke, if the train bound for nowhere and the midnight train going anywhere are both going 25 mph, do they collide before the gambler breaks even?
Funny, I guess. Now, could you go read my comment?
Oof. I don't know if I should laugh or cry.
I used to think this kind of math question is stupid. Not anymore
83 yr old Phoenix native. I remember this clearly. When the announcement was made on radio stations, I rode my bicycle to a friend's house to inform him. He was 17 years old and had a Private Pilot's license.
These videos are extremely well done. Well written, researched, and narrated. No superfluous gore, just top tier story telling.
I often find his clean narrative more chilling when he says there were no survivors in acccidents like this.
@@faerie7dragon
I would like to add that the absence of disturbing music and multiple repetition of movie scenes with actors with scared faces contributes greatly to the quality.
That’s why I consider this channel to be one the best finds during lockdown.
I also love that they’re short and to the point. 10/10
theyre not well done. often times if theres videos of the incident he doesnt even mention it. he also often leaves out a lot of details
My mom was nine when her parents, brother and her were scheduled to be on the United plane headed to Chicago. They were returning from being stationed overseas and decided to remain in California an extra day to sightsee. It was an incredibly lucky decision! To this day, my mom is still an anxious air traveler!
You never know... maybe them getting on the plane would have delayed or sped-up the flight by just seconds and enough for the collision to instead be a near-miss...
@@mattakins3557 Yep. This.
They had an incredibly lucky escape
They sure were lucky!
Amazing to hear the human stories from these tragedies from the other side of the world its the beauty of the internet.
I live at the South Rim of the Canyon, and it's honestly surprising how little attention is paid to this crash. There's a big memorial at the local cemetery, which the vast majority of tourists do not visit, and a smaller plaque, the one shown at the end, at Desert View. And, that's pretty much it. Then again, given how horrific this incident was, in virtually every sense, it's probably not too surprising that the Park Service doesn't want to promote knowledge of it. At least it spurred the creation of the FAA. Also, I actually hadn't known that radar wasn't used in civilian flights AT ALL before this happened. I know it was still a fairly new technology at the time, but still, the benefits seem pretty clear.
There were a couple civilian radars in place, but those were used at major airports to better track planes on arrival and departure. The CAA, predecessor to the FAA, had plans to make a civilian radar network across the USA but was having issues with getting the money and equipment to build it. Radars small enough to fit on planes were only declassified later that year, and radar beacons/transponders for planes weren't a thing until 1960. The CAA also didn't have the authority to mandate airline practices, which was a major part of the switch from the CAA to the FAA. The FAA had the budget to install radars and the authority to force company-based controllers to use them.
Well most state parks don't advertise the deaths on the grounds lol
But yes, I was just there...I'm not sure why tourists would go to a local cemetery, so I dont feel too bad.
A plaque at the observatory/gift shops would better helpful.
My wife and I visited the Grand canyon last year and I made sure to visit and get a picture of both memorials. We actually spent almost an hour at the cemetery just looking through all the graves, which, as you know, don't even have to do with the crash. One of my neighbors is a retired American Airlines captain who has visited various crash sites but he hasn't been to that one, and so I did all of the above with him in mind.
@@R2Bl3nd I would have liked to visited them, but I was at the cabins at the North Rim.
@@ajjdgj6tmgedvnmtmek They also weren't considered necessary outside of congested air space.. "big sky" mentality.
The way you pack so much detail into such a short video is a lesson to documentary-makers everywhere.
It's really great!
Yes but also no, shows like minutes before disaster and shit like that have to pan it the most they can so they can have 3 adds at least, adds were what keept tv alive.
Totally agree
Chester Arnold Crewse and his teenage daughter Hellen Colleen, my grandfather and aunt, were lost on TWA flight 2 that day. It was five years before I was born but I can remember seeing how this affected my father throughout the rest of his life.
I know that this may sound too lighthearted for what actually happened, but by any chance did this tagefy make your dad afraid of flying?
Both planes were trying to give their pax the best views of the canyon. That being said, the TWA pilot choosing to go 1000 on top at the same altitude as the United flight really sealed their fate.
given how unlikely that he would be at the exact same altitude as the other plane makes this even more bizarrely tragic.
You could say they gave them a good view of the canyon 😂
They all got a really good view of the canyon, up until the end.
The two planes were only in communication with their own ground crew. Each plane did know where the other was assigned that day. But neither knew of the deviation of the other, as this wasn't communicated between the two companies.
@@ThatOpalGuy There was the a "big sky" mentality at the time. Well, the airspace around the Canyon isn't that large at 300mph trying to navigate around clouds. The strangest thing to me is that at the time, the United flight was considered responsible because it was the "overtaking" aircraft. Disregard that TWA went to that altitude and was told to watch out for the United flight.
What’s screwed up is that 4 years later, TWA and United collided again in 1960, except over New York. There was initially a survivor, a 10 year old boy, but he died from his injuries later on in hospital.
At 9 yrs old I remember so well a teacher in the hallway gasping about a horrible plane crash
Then that night the news stations were obsessed with the 10 yr old boy rescued by pedestrians from a snowbank in Brooklyn but he died
My grandmother was supposed to be on that flight, she was a flight attendant for twa back in the 50's. She traded flights with her friend (they did that a lot in those days) and survived because of that. Because her name was on the roster she was mistaken for one of the lost for a bit.
Ah, but if she HAD been on the flight, this might not have happened at all. You know, Butterfly Effect and what not.
What flight? There was 2 flights ✈️ ✈️ ah smell shite 💩
That must be mind-blowing!
Attendants trading flights is still common practice to this day.
The crash that made radar mandatory and gave us the FAA. Quite a few tragedies have happened here in the Grand Canyon state, both infamous and sadly forgotten. To think this happened at the titular location.
And with it, the FAA was given control over both civilian AND military traffic.
Imagine air travel having decent customer service on the flights…
Flying was so incredibly expensive that passengers expected it.
@@neilgerace355 flying is still incredibly expensive yet we expect to be treated like garbage now days.
@telethea the end bringer It was far more expensive and more exclusive in those days.
@@The_child-catcher Since the arrival of jets, flying is immensely cheaper than it was then.
@@The_child-catcher Adjusted for inflation, the seats on either of these flights would have been around $1200 round trip. That's 50% more than a first class non-stop on United today. Since the aircraft were small, every seat was treated as first class in terms of both price and amenities. The trade-off of modern economy seats is that you get them cheaper but they're also significantly worse in terms of amenities.
Ah, nothing like waking up to a fresh disaster video. Good morning! ☕️
Yes, corpse fresh
Midnight before bed bonus here in nz.
It may sound silly, but these disaster videos calm me down when I have panic attacks. Especially nuclear disasters.
nothing like this video on your way to the airport 😅
Good morning from canada mutha fuckaaa!!!!
I watched the Air Crash Investigation episode of this crash and it just blew my mind how different procedures and technology during flights were, I hadn’t ever considered it before. I was especially surprised they were allowed to deviate from flight paths in order to give more scenic views to passengers.
I learned about this crash from an “Air Disasters” program that goes into detail about the investigation.
Only six (I think) sets of human remains could be identified. The rest are buried in a mass grave.
I’ve also seen mention of a hiker who, some decades ago, took a woman’s purse from the crash site. When he was called out on that, he claimed that he was going to see if the woman’s family wanted it.
In response to the 2nd portion of your post: 😞🥀🥀🥀🥀🥀🥀🥀
My response to the last part: that person is suspicious af.
On the 50th anniversary of this accident the Arizona Republic ran a story about this crash. What struck me the most about the article was that several families were so grief stricken that they moved from Chicago and Kansas City to Arizona to be closer to loved ones that perished in the crash.
A relative of mine was in this crash. Thank you for covering it and its importance in aviation safety.
When I visited the Grand Canyon 10 years ago, I bought a copy of 'Over The Edge' (one of your sources for this video). It is a fascinating read! The canyon has really seen it all - plane crashes, murders, flash floods, and not to mention all the people who have somehow fallen into it.
I have this book as well .
So many people dying because of trying to get a better picture and fall .
And so many other mistakes that could have been avoided.
I would guarantee the falls have escalated since selfies have become a thing 😂 crazy
When people start getting nostalgic and sentimental about the good old days or the myth of simpler times, this would be a good example to trot out -- "Oh, you mean like this?".
Those people are a scourge on humanity. Thinking that life was better back in a time where people would have more children than they wanted because two were likely to die before the age of five from something antibiotics or a vaccine could fix. Whenever I see a comment by those dinosaurs it makes me wonder if humans have a future.
What's really shocking is that this didn't happen more often
On the contrary, I'm quite surprised it did happen. I can't imagine how astronomical the chances are of accidentally hitting another object in the air.
@@aloysiusdevadanderabercrombie8 Yeah, I'm with you. You'd have a better chance of winning Powerball. Twice.
@@aloysiusdevadanderabercrombie8 Right, like, honestly what are the odds? Especially considering they were aware of each other.
No in fact it was happening a lot around that time.
in 1960 two planes of the same airlines in this video collided above New York.
My Grandpa told me this story and I didn't believe it at first. Boggles the mind
Hey Fascinating Horror, big fan of your channel and congrats on over 1 million subs!!
I think you could make a really great video on the 1997 Jarrell f5 tornado. I don’t believe you’ve done a tornado disaster before, and this incident in particular is unlike so many. The destruction was on a whole other level, especially for this incident specifically. There was basically nothing left in its path, everything was destroyed down to the foundations. The wind patterns and direction of the tornado also made it so that this was basically a tornado anomaly, nothing like it had ever happened before
I've seen other videos on that tornado. The one still image is both amazing & terrifying. Known as The Dead Man Walking. Can't say I'd be able to keep my senses if I saw something like that barreling towards me.
Well, that's partially attributed to the fact that the tornado crawled along at only 10 mph, subjecting everything to winds or F5 intensity for minutes on end. It also moved opposite of the direction of its parent thunderstorm, meaning that rain and hail came after the tornado rather than before it.
It basically stayed in the same place for five minutes or so, and with F5 strength winds... Nothing was going to survived. There was one family who'd survived a previous tornado and built an underground storm shelter which saved their lives, and a mother and daughter who survived, God knows how, by sheltering in the bathtub, although they lost their husband/father because there wasn't enough room for him in it to.
The photos of the 'Dead Man Walking' are some of the freakiest photos of a tornado that I have ever seen.
Try emailing him. He has an email posted in the description. He was courteous enough to respond to mine. :)
In what country would Jarrell be?
I first heard about this accident during a family vacation to the Grand Canyon a few years ago. I asked the park rangers how often they had to fish idiots out of the canyon who cross the safety barriers and fall into the canyon. He told me they had to just last week. He pointed to a large book covering Grand Canyon accidents, this one was mentioned
Yep. BTW, according to that book aviation accidents are the leading cause of death in Grand Canyon National Park, even excluding this accident.
Yeah that book is pretty thick. When I went there were quite a few people leaning on one foot over the edge for photos. Absolute idiots.
Another accident I've never heard of all, though this one feels really weird to have been ignorant of given all of the fallout from it, including the FAA forming at all. I'm not a person who likes flying or really ever gets to travel at all, but it's still weird that this doesn't seem like one of those disasters in "common" knowledge anymore either despite not being that old. Huh.
(This also reminded me that I still haven't gotten around to watcing your "Falls Into the Grand Canyon" video. I guess I'll do that now finally before I forget again.)
May all the victims rest in peace. Sad how people have to destroy everything they can, the scratch marks on the plaque (shown at the end) are a disgrace. Shame on the people who do such things.
We don't know how those scratches occurred. It could have been something else, who knows?
It always takes a fatal accident for someone to being in procedures that should have been in place from the beginning
It’s called tombstone legislation, and aviation is full of such instances.
Safety regs are pretty much always written in blood.
RIP to the souls on board both aircraft. Good job to the pilots who found the wreckage, and good job to the aviation industry for making needed changes in response to this tragedy.
I am an aviation enthusiast and I love airplanes ✈️. So this episode was double interesting to me. I watch 2 channels devoted exclusively to plane crashes with in depth break down of the causes.
disaster breakdown and mentour pilot?
Dan Gryder & Juan Brown if I had to hazard a guess…
Ever watch JUST PILOTS CHANNEL, and BIG JETS, BLANCOLIRIO CHANNEL?
Highly recommend green dot aviation if you’re looking for another!
Wow. No mention of Plainly Difficult! 😳
Great video! There's definitely not very much coverage of this event, so I'm glad to see this. My great-grandfather's 2nd wife and their two young daughters (both under ten) died on this flight heading home to Kansas City. My great-grandfather was an engineer at TWA. I never even knew this until my dad and I did a family tree project a couple years ago.
I knew this one from the Mayday episode, and one of the reasons I’m fascinated by air crash investigations is finding the why, and how they all made subsequent air travel safer. This particular crash was like the Tenerife crash of its time, leading to profound changes in practices across the board, and opening the way for modern air travel. RIP.
Rhe odds of this collision are nearly incalculable. All the space in the sky,and so few flights in the air back then. Stunning
I love the format of these. As soon as I hear that music I’m immediately pulled in. The narration is so compelling yet respectful. I also love how the lessons learned and improvements made are mentioned at the end. So many times with disaster retelling nobody mentions what happened after and that can be a bit distressing when you’re an anxious person. Knowing that laws or policies got changed or a memorial was made is comforting.
The idea that civil aviation did not use radar back then was surprising, but I was boggled by the concept of each airliner calling its own controller, if I understand him correctly! Whoa!
this was certainly a sad disaster to hear about, the fact that four years later history would repeat itself when another TWA constellation was hit by a United DC8 makes it even sadder
Back in the early 90s, I actually worked with two older ladies at the time who were witnesses to that accident. They both lived in the Park Slope section of Brooklyn where the UAL DC-8 hit. Even now, I can still remember their reactions when I asked them about it. I’m sure they have since passed on, as they would have to both be in their 90s now. RIP Dotty & Mildred.
Well, I have to concur with all of the commenters who always say on your other videos that although they’ve seen or read many other stories about the topic of said video that you include information that they’ve never seen before.
I’ve seen this disaster covered by Mayday Air Disasters and others, but never heard or seen some of the details that you’ve covered here.
It’s because of those previous comments about the details you include in your videos, that I decided not to pass over this one even though I’ve seen so many videos about this disaster before.
I’m really glad that I took their comments to heart! Thank you for your excellent work in providing these extra details, and as others say, without the extra drama ☺️
As a boy in the 60’s my family flew fairly often. Watching these videos makes me realize how much safer flying is today
Interesting to see how a tragic accident led to sweeping changes in air travel safety.
Well done as always. A calm, respectful, just-the-facts presentation without sensationalism, loud graphics, or editing tricks. Also good to see how positive change can come out of a terrible situation.
I’ve watched your videos for a while. I must say that the song you use really gives me the heebie-jeebies and idk why. Keep up the good work!
As a disaster fanatic, I have read, seen, viewed everything out there about this and most other air disasters. This one was so haunting because it was so avoidable. What happened changed so many things about flight though. Thank you for your take and work on this FH. Love this channel ❤️
My father flew on the airlines in the late-fifties onward. He told stories of, airlines preparing steak and fillets for passengers. Smoking on board was the norm. You could go into the cockpit and talk to the pilots. The seats were spacious and comfortable.
I recommend Fascinating Horror's video on Isla Nublar and guarantee you'll enjoy it.
I hope he'll cover the Nakatomi Plaza Disaster some time.
You have earned every one of those 1M subscribers. Great work as always.
One of the few channels that I click the "like" button for each video even before it starts.
My mom, dad, older brother and I, who was 4 years old visited the Grand Canyon 2 months following the accident.
I can still remember seeing the sun reflecting off the aluminum pieces still down in the canyon.
just woke up to 8 inches of snow on the ground, I think I'll stay in bed and watch this
Great job presenting this story. Ironic that in the early days of "luxurious" commercial air travel,no expense was spared for passenger comfort but the same expense didn't apply to the air traffic control systems. Change won't happen until a catastrophic event forces the creation of improved training and updated equipment;making bank is more important than spending a small chunk of said bank on providing the best,most cutting edge training and technology that'd increase potential profits. Profit over people is an ugly,consistent aspect of many industries to this very day. Thank you for shedding light on this forgotten tragedy and the lessons learned from it.
If you read this comment Mr Facinating Horror know you are a valued person
This video seems timely given all the recent "near misses" by planes at airports in the United States, in which planes have nearly run into each other due to air traffic control failures. I fly about 3 times a year and am headed out again in April...so...I'm hoping i won't end up in a Fascinating Horror video someday!
With so much sky up there, it still floors me that mid air collisions happen from time to time!
The title alone combines at least two major fears into one.
I've said it before, and I'll repeat it, you are one of the most professional UA-cam historians I've subscribed to. I've found you to be the point but still respectful, calm but not droll, and always ensure to include only the facts (pictures and otherwise) you are aware of. Thank you for providing these stories and not hamming them up for effect.
Another Mid Air Collision is Worth the topic is Uberlingen Mid Air Disaster where Both Plane have install TCAS (Traffic Collision Avoidance System) and yet the other plane chose to follow the ATC than their own TCAS system in the end both planes collided resulted to tragedy most killed are children in the unfortunate turn of events one of the father of the victims hired a private investigator and killed the ATC that responsible that day(Peter Nielsen)
Just looked it up thats crazy!
This one was extremely interesting. Gives us a better view into how things used to be in aviation.
I was on a flight where we went over The Grand Canyon. It's been my "bucket list" to visit via flyover + staying at one of the lodges. All so bittersweet enjoying a lovely view, then Poof! Glad changes were made.
My dad was a TWA pilot at that time. He flew that route and flew Connies. We lived in Kansas City. I was only 5 in 1956 and don't remember this incident but I'm sure my parents talked about it. I had no idea that air traffic control was so lax.
Sadly, throughout history, it has been proven time and time again that the only reason air travel is now the safest form of travel in the world, is only so because of the lessons that came out of tragedies like this.
2 things first your over a million subs now! Congrats! Second I love hearing different peoples descriptions of incidents like this I've seen the air crash investigation yours a few others
Thanks for sharing these tragic stories, may they never be forgotten.
It's been a while since I watched one of these videos but now I'm on a binge - they are so well made!!
Just watched a Mayday episode about this crash. Very interesting, glad to see you covering it as well!
As side note for you @ Fascinating Horror. This crash was a major factor several people chose to sail on board the Andrea Doria the very next month when it was struck by the Stockholm. They were terrified of the idea of flying transatlantic after hearing about this accident.
Oh, those hikers were definitely taking items as souvenirs.
One of the overshadowed crashes despite being 100+ fatalities. I might have cemetery names mixed up but I believe about 29 unidentified bodies (from United Flight) are buried at Grand Canyon Pioneer, and I think about 66 in mass grave at Citizens Cemetery.
And people are still going to take parts found today regardless if “protected” which is sad.
This video fits right in my lunchbreak 😎
I've heard this told from several channels, feel somewhat obligated to watch for the ppl lost. Everyone should be remembered by someone else and hopefully, many
It's always a good day for me when Fascinating Horror covers aviation accidents.
Same here!
I really love your videos. Especially learning about historic events that nobody else really tells.
So many accidents that have made it a lot safer today but there will be more unfortunately...great coverage again 👌
This channel makes my Tuesday mornings!
Grand Canyon Mid-air Collision would make a great band name
This really is a fascinating channel. One of my favorites for sure, we’ll done as well as very respectful. I love your style man.
This shows you that you Never can tell ! Tell the people in your life you Love them !
I've been on a Mayday/plane crash binge recently so thank you for fueling this.
I really love this channel. Even though I know this crash and story already, there was still no question to click and watch the video because the quality is sure to be great.
Hell yeah dude congrats on the million + subs!
Disaster Breakdown has great video on this too. 👍🏻
Wow, another AMAZING episode! I had never heard of this tragedy until a few weeks ago when Mayday started popping into my feed. It was a cable show in the early 2000s about airline disasters. Your episode more succinctly describes what happened tho!
Are those Mayday episodes still up on UA-cam? I miss watching the older episodes - Mayday and Seconds From Disaster both covered some really interesting things.
@@Teverell The Mayday episodes are up, yeah. They're under the channel called "Wonder."
Mayday is Air Crash Investigation now! Wonder on UA-cam has the first 2 seasons, while Disney+ has ACI seasons
Oh sick, 2am upload. Made just for me
haha my thoughts exactly!
Coincidentally a few years later these two airlines collided again over New York resulting in the same number of passenger fatalities.
There’s a building on Sterling Place & 7th Ave in Brooklyn that you used to be able to make out the repair that was made to the roof of the building from some part of the UAL DC-8 hitting it, but it’s been 30 years since I lived in Brooklyn.
@@get2dachoppa249 30 years as a number isn't all that long ago if you're a certain age. Still feels like yesterday.
"Permission to ascend to 21,000 ft.?"
"Denied."
"Then, permission to fly 1,000' above cloud cover, which happens to be at 21,000 ft.?"
"...GRANTED!"
Super Constellation is such a beautiful plane
"Permission to climb to 21,000 feet?"
"Denied, there's another aircraft there."
"Permission to climb to 1,000 feet above 20,000?"
"Sure, that will probably be fine."
I know ATC maybe didn't know where the clouds stopped but surely the pilot had an instrument that showed he was at the exact altitude he had been told not to fly at??
The pilot even KNEW there was another plane up there was and STILL didn't pay attention to his altitude!! That's the part that gets me !
He was like "these clouds are impeding visibility I'll tell dispatch I'll navigate via sight to get up to altitude where they told me another plane was" and 🤦🤦🤦🤦
@@anomboing Yeah like, often these things are nobody's fault, or deliberate (eg arson attacks on hotels etc) but this one just sounds like one person's negligence, unless I've missed some part of the story.
I can't shake the feeling the pilot deliberately did this, fully intending to climb to 21,000 feet regardless of the order. That he felt the chance of crashing was so low, and that Ground Control where just being far to cautious, that he could veto them easily with the right words. Something about that height, probably not the view but maybe head winds, was more alluring to him then the risk he put everyone into....
Cause there is no way he couldn't have seen he was at 21,000 feet, the same altitude he was specifically denied prior.
@@lostbutfreesoul It definitely has that feeling of bloody-minded stubbornness, doesn't it.
If no ship like the Titanic had ever sunk before why would anyone think it could? Same thing with this pilot, large aircraft can't crash into one another because it had never happened before. simple false confidence.
Watching those early crashes is fascinating - so much has changed since then
I was just at the Grand Canyon a week ago. The placard is next to the Watchtower at Desert View Point, the very eastern edge of the South Rim of Grand Canyon National Park not far from the Eastern entrance. They also have placards detailing the accident and how it happened.
A few years ago I saw a show that talked all about this accident. A couple of weeks later, I'm an uber driver in Chicago, I picked a woman up from O'Hare airport to take her to her destination in the city. While driving this crash came up in our conversation. She said that at the time she was a little girl and her father was one of the people killed in that crash. Chilling.
Right on time...good MORNING 🌅 Fascinating Horror and morning crew
It essentially took 80 years of aviation accidents to perfect travel. Nothing is a guarantee, but the fact that the United States has not had a major airline crash in over 20 years indicates that it’s gotten as close to perfection as possible.
I couldn't imagine the horror of everyone! May they all rest in peace!
Aviation regulations are written in blood. Great overview of the accident, thank you FH!
its even crazier that this isnt the only time a twa and an united planed collided mid-air. in 1960 2 planes of twa and united crashed above new york.
It's time to watch another episode of Fascinating Horror, while my crowded bus wades through slush and snow across the bridge on my way to wo -- *Communication ceases*
*Fascinating Horror Intro Theme plays*
"On the 28th of February, 2023, a bus carrying..."
I have never heard of this crash and I watch a lot of aviation content. This is one of the worst possible place for a crash to occur since the terrain was so rugged. Great job as always.
The way the National Parks Service handled the clean up and memorial was probably the best they could do, in light of the remoteness of the site. It's good to see the plaque, as a memorial to the dead and a reminder or our shared history.
I like that the release schedule is around my bedtime. Gives me something to listen to as I drift off to sleep.
Wow, it was like the Wild West in the skies
Thanks for this one. I have always been fascinated by this crash. This and the Super Constellation crash that prompted them to change the design of their windows, cause me to have chills every time I see a Super Constellation.
A weird cross-over I have with this crash (totally off topic), is when I think about how Amy and Rory (from Doctor Who)) got zapped back in time and how they would have had to avoid going on these planes. Obviously, they avoided them because they lived to ages 82 and 86, but if I was stuck back in time I would be always racking my brain trying to remember the significant plane crash dates.
When you said "disintegrate", you weren't kidding. That was horrific.