When a real, qualified scholar speaks, there is no room for spéculation. This one is our honor, may Allmighty bless him, protect and inspire him. Commendable teachings.
I simply love this man! Hands down! His exegeses! His style to put across his thoughts! His articulation! And his scholarship! He's simply a blessing for those who have the capacity and capability to listen and to understand....Gratitude!!!❤❤❤
To understand the holy Koran you need to study sciences, no other way possible. This man is a physicist and up to now I really learned a lot of him in short time. Much blessings
The Quran verse that is the KEY TO OPEN THE LOCK is Surah Al-IMRAN 3:5-7 The verse talks about the two kinds of language that Allah uses in the Quran. One factual and the other Muttashabiat = Allegorical/ Symbolic! We need to be very, very careful to not confuse the two kinds of language.
agree on the approach the North Pole shifting, geomagnetic reversal cause the sun to appear to rise from the west from the perspective of the north pole. Thank you sheikh
Great ...one thing is sure that something big change is going to happen in our universe ..that these verse are pointing out...we are only concerned on sun rise but something beyond and big thing is going to happen
actually Dzhanibekov effect can explain it. a rotating body in space will periodically flip 180 degrees around it's axis if it's centre of balance is off. this means the earth will flip upside down and continue rotating. the earths centre of balance is being offset by its core moving, and by the huge transfer of materials to build concrete cities all over the world. Add the melting of the ice caps etc. The earths balance is changing.
I am an astronomer and that is incorrect. Dzhanibekov effect only works on small objects that have little to none gravitational force pulling on them. Earth is a massive body kept stable by the sun’s and moon’s gravity. This effect will never flip earth on its axis.
@tanerserdar but if the earth's mass distribution changes, that wouldn't be the case anymore would it? a new equilibrium lock would need to be created wouldn't it?
A German revert once ( around 25 years ago ) commented on the increasing no of western reverts to Islam that the sun of Islam will rise from the west .. And that the east will go through sort of darkness... Who knows
Yes , the scholar Bediuzzaman Said nursi tells sth similar. The islamic world become like westerners, the West will give a birth to Islam. There must be absolutely a better translation but it was close to this. And we have already seen this, many middle eastern countries have been very against Islam in their behaviours and ahklaq like being dishonest or hypocrite people. Islam is like leaving whom doesn't deserve it and moving towards whom deserves it more... We as born Muslims must be scared of this and try to be better muslims...
If we put it in the context of one the signs which says dajjal period a day will be long as a year, month and a day, it fits into thinking the earth rotation will slow down and then spin the other way
Listened you for 21 minutes, very interesting, thanks for picking this topic. If I heard correctly, sunrise from West, will be for short time. one day sun will rise from West and come midway, then will go back and set in West. From next day, it will rise from east as regular. So may be some Galectical events happen in future which can change the gravity in such a way for very short time. Whatever it makes, sun will rise from West one day, that's one of the major signs of end time. We may never know how it can happen but it will happen. Quran says, it is not the eyes but their heart is blind. So reason isn't important right now but belief is. Time is passing soon!
Good point, but the current data suggests that the universe will not collapse, its expansion is getting faster, so thermodynamic death (the big freeze) seems more likely.
So if the earth’s magnetic pole shifts, does that mean that our observation of the direction shifts as well i.e. East becomes West, West becomes East, since we rely on compass?
yup 😁 it rotate's Antarctic North to south and Antarctic South to north Insya 'allah in slow m0w it rotate's and More time for tornadoes, earthquake & tsunami 👍🏼
If I remember it right, it is said in a Hadith that when the sun rises from the west, the people will indeed believe (what choice so they have ?) but their belief will not do them good. If you don't interpret this literally then why won't their belief do them well if they still can repent?. If the interpretation is literal then indeed nothing good will come out of their belief because the earth spinning in the opposite direction means the world is ending. Lately there is data that shows indeed the earth can spin in the opposite direction. And ALLAH AWJ knows best. 🙏✨♥️
That’s exactly what he explained in the video. The only thing he was trying solve how it would actually happen. There is a need to some scientific explanation to how the sun could rise from the West.
I have a suggestion for my brother and sister to watch the Furqan qureshi blog channel for this concept, especially, the mysterious door episodes, may Allah Guide us.
yup 😁 it rotate's Antarctic North to south and Antarctic South to north Insya 'allah in slow m0w it rotate's and More time for tornadoes, earthquake & tsunami 👍🏼
The physical idea of "West" is relative to the reference frame we use on Earth. It is not absolute. Allah knows best what is the true meaning behind this hadith, but it could be the knowledge (sun 🌞) rising from the Western region. Since all the major signs are negative, this could mean that the knowledge ( illumination) will be false too, adding to the deception of Dajjal at that time.
Sheikh Imran also has similar standing and understanding of this. I am personally convinced as well. This seems the most practical interpretation. Allah knows the best.
The metaphoric sounds more logical. Because if there is a supernova, why should the tawba not accepted after that? What about the hikma that tawba an eeman is not accepted after that?
It's a bit like when the Pharaoh's iman was not accepted after he believed in God after seeing the Red Sea part and then join back, engulfing him and his army. As in, the Prophet (pbuh) warned people about this and they didn't believe; seeing an absolute sign like that and only believing afterwards means that one wasn't going to believe without it the way God had wanted people to believe.
Tbh it's hard one. About Venus I think the slowing down was due to it's thick atmosphere that is hundreds of times more dense than earth. Also some studies claimed that earth days had gone faster bc of pumping ground water. So a change of distribution of mass on earth could dramatically affect it's spin. Maybe earth losing it's moon by a giant impact will contribute to a change In the precession effect than will cause a massive shift of the earth mass to it's poles like losing the poles glaciers melting or something.
The comment that the mention is from the Hadith not the Quran is not fair as anything The Prophet (S.A.W.) said is unquestionable as Allah (S.W.T.) Has comfirmed in the Quran that The Prophet never says anything on his own accord but from a Revelation from The Lord-Allah.
Motion retrograde has happened on mars i think over 20years ago according to nasa. The sun rose from the west for a few days. Then it returned to normal. Can someone Say if this true. Motion retrograde means slowing of the rotation of earth not stopping or rotating the other way.
A meteor does not need to have a full on head collision rather one or more glancing blows in opposing direction and then in direction of clockwise direction
A simple question for you. If the sun rising from the West is not to be taken literally, what else of the signs of the Last Hour are not to be taken literally? All of them? Only some? Why only some? Who decides? Is Isa alaihissalam's second coming also not to be taken literally? To be consistent, you would have to not take that literally too. Which, if you do not take that literally, then that means you are no longer an Ahlul Sunnah, at the least. But if you are to take the second coming literally, why the inconsistency? What criteria from the Quran or Sunnah are you using to accept the second coming literally but not the sun rising from the West literally?
One could say this (I'm not a scholar, mind you): the Second Coming is foretold in the Qur'an according to most interpretations, when God says that all of the Children of Israel will believe in Jesus, pbuh, before his death, meaning that Jesus has to come back to earth and eventually die here. OTOH, such a quasi-explicit statement is not made by God regarding the sun rising from the west. Wallahu a'lam.
@@minskdhaka Still does not answer the question. Why do you take the second coming literally, regardless whether it is mentioned in the Qur'an or not, albeit not explicitly. Does it mean that you only take the Words of Allah سبحانه وتعالى literally but not the word of His Prophet ﷺ, and if so, why, and based on which Quranic or Sunnah principle have you decided to do so? Do you than take the word "istiwa" in the Qur'an literally? If you do not, then explain the standard you use to determine which or what is to be taken literally and which or what is not. Where in Islam can you find the usul that the Words of Allah سبحانه وتعالى are to be taken literally but not that of His Prophet ﷺ? That is the fundamental question that need to be addressed to resolve this matter.
Thank you. The easiest way is to happen it virtualy. So at that time people will live more in a virtual world and there the sun will raise from the west. Believing in all what Allah does this other guy does the oposite. So thats a guess too.
Slowing down doesn't mean it will be constant there a counter force that earth is spinning against once the force is overcome the slowing down will be sped up and will start spinning opposite
There is no such theory. The sun rotates because of angular momentum. It began to rotate when the stellar nebula collapsed about 4.6 billion years ago. Its spin is slowing because of the gravitational forces acting upon it. But it will take billions of years to slow down.
Sorry This event will not happen physically It’s a metaphor It just means that at the believers in general and the Museum in particular will not seek guidance or reference from the teachings of the Prophets in particular in the suna of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) but from the west as we witness now And Dajal having one eye doesn’t means physical one eye but have one vision ; Dunya and forget the hereafter
The tafseer has covered the Sun ( Quran ) the incorrect tafseer The rise appears to be that western language/scholars will expose the true interpretation of the Quran Muhammad said I had to fight for the revelation of the Quran but Ali will have to fight for its interpretation What happened to Ali and you now know why he was unalived, the tafseer after that is based upon forged hadith's , and hadith's that were not transmitted verbatim hence bukhari having similar narrations seemingly talking about the same thing but with different words , proof nothing was recorded verbatim leading to Chinese whispers And the stars shall fall , = the famous " scholars" both dead and alive shall be exposed and their errors for all to see , and these stars shall disperse and scatter ( run away knowing how many people they have mislead )
First of all the noble prophet is not your work-buddy. When use his name you should include (saw). Secondly, what experience do you have in Quranic exegesis to make a disrespectful claim that the tafsir is wrong when there is a consensus among the majority of mufassirun on what the verse is referring to. Can you provide a link where we can check your credentials as an expert on Usul al Tafsir?
@@tanerserdar For starters he isn't a prophet for me because I'm not or was from banu Israel, prophets came to them , and Allah says prophethood has ended, so I address Muhammad as Rasool Allah not Nabi though he was one I don't need to put (saw) at the end of Muhammad as I say that anyway I don't need to literally write ✍️ that down , just to please a literal like you I'm not going to answer any of your questions because from your reply you need to get the basics right
@@thebeesnuts777 I am not a literalist. You have no idea about Islamic sciences. Muhammed (saw) is both a rasul and nabi. All resuls are also nabis, but not all nabis are resul. Anyway, no need to argue… have a good day.
@@tanerserdar Thank you I didn't know that Muhammad was a nabi and rasool and I didn't know Musa was a nabi or rasool , ,,,, and in-between them I didn't know they were prophets Are you serious of course I know that , you obviously don't know the difference between a Messenger and Nabi , if you did you wouldn't be addressing Muhammad as a Nabi
You need to listen to sheikh Imran Hosein analysis on the subject if you want to get an indebt response on the subject...May Allah continue to bless him and may the message of righteousness continue to be spread...
With respect to your sheikh Imran, it is not ethical to advertise sheikhs in other channels. This is an academic platform where scholars with vast knowledge on Islamic sciences present their views, not a platform for people to advertise their sheikhs, you are welcome to follow whichever sheikh you wish to follow but you should go and thank them under their videos. We pray for all scholars and sheikhs who explain Islam. Only Allah knows who has profound knowledge in Islamic matters.
@@tanerserdar Those who are truly looking for knowledge and a better understanding of the Religion, should encourage others to do research and follow the teaching of others with a more compressive understanding of Quran....Once the individual is speaking truth and spreading the words of righteousness, you should help spread the message and not try to fight down the individual by suppressing their Teachings...... Ur platform should be used to help spread the true message of Islam regardless of what others think. Try not to be bias and one-sided in ur heart and mind, but instead be open up and free and u would be bless by Allah Most High in ur struggle and quest for knowledge...So let's all try help and teach each other along the way in life journey and struggle
@@JohnDoe-vl1if Its not my platform brother, I made a non-bias comment. There are many people who follow many different sheiks and scholars. People who like listening to academics who are experts in their fields come here, and I am one of these people. I trust the scholars here, that’s why I listen to them. Thank you for your response.
@@tanerserdar Peace and Blessings to you and your family and may your journey in seeking knowledge continue to grow and expand by the Grace of Allah... It's all Love, Unity, 1 mission and not a Competition...
Sorry But the event will not happen physically The sun rising on west is the metaphor The meaning is the believers in general and the Muslim (ahlu suna) in particular will seek guidance and reference from the western civilization Most of those signs that annonce the approche of the doomsday are metaphorical For instance; the saying of dajal having one eye means that the people will only interest on the worldly things not the hereafter
Sorry But the event will not happen physically The sun rising on west is the metaphor The meaning is the believers in general and the Muslim (ahlu suna) in particular will seek guidance and reference from the western civilization Most of those signs that annonce the approche of the doomsday are metaphorical For instance; the saying of dajal having one eye means that the people will only interest on the worldly things not the hereafter
That's not true... The eye of the dajjal already has a description. How he will die had been mentioned. The sword of 'Isa ('alayhi salâm) will have his blood on it. This has nothing to do with not thinking about the hereafter. What are you talking about?
@@FamilyMBAYE About his eye resembling a floating rotten grape with the word kafir in the middle of his forehead. He will have the ability to split a man in half, and then bring him back to life, which will be one of the things that the doubters and disbelievers fall for. Taking him as their Lord. The prophet (saws) said don't fall for this, you won't meet your Lord until you die. He will show people a fake jannah and a fake hell fire. The prophet (saws) said jump into the one with the fire. If you recite the last two verses of Surah al khaf you will be safe from the fire says the prophet (saws). Now you tell me how this makes sense with how you framed this dajjal to be? Because you seem to be more informed than the prophet himself (saws)
@@adrianrouse83 Salam Brother And please don’t put words in my mouth please Where did I said that I am more informed than the Al-Amiin (sws)? I am not the one who doubts any saying of Him (SWS) Khadiss is a true knowledge but you need sometimes wisdom to understand the meaning in its context Once again his eye “resembling “ a floating rotten grape) is a metaphor. “Riding “the ten last verses of surate kahf frequently particularly in Friday will help you getting the wisdom to decorticate the tricks of dajal
@FamilyMBAYE First of all, I'm only quoting what the Qur'an says and what the prophet (saws) says. Your are the one who has to explain why you are taking these things as a metaphor. Second of all, maybe you need to go back and read CAREFULLY what i said. I said you SEEM to be more informed. I never said you said anything. And reciting surah al khaf on Fridays was a separate hadith. May Allah guide us both. Ameen 🤲 As salâmu alaikum
My opinion money.. because human go to west for work n money not like before khalifah turkey Uthmani... correct me if i wrong..but Allah wnow all 😊.bad from me. all Good from ALLAH..
Sir, Quran,the words of the Arab God Allah many times say some funny things to please his devotees,muslims and should be taken as jokes of the almighty Allah.
THE SON OF MAN OR GOD WILL COME FROM THE WEST,AND THE EVERY BODY KNEES WILL KNEEL AND SAY, YOUR THE LORD,😮 JUST SAYING DONT TAKE NOTES, PROFESSOR THANKS,
Assalamu Aleykum , The sun will rise from the West is the second coming of the Prophet Muhammad as Imam Mahdi in the West. (Sura Al Baqara,2:258). The Prophet Muhammad came back with Prophet Issa (Sura Az-Zukhruf, 43:63).The 1883 eruption of Krakatoa is a scientific indication (en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1883_eruption_of_Krakatoa). Another scientific evidence is when their believers die and get buried the disappear from the grave right away (ua-cam.com/video/_ffVoOxbMf8/v-deo.html)
@@user-qb2lv8uo4x Yes, it is clearly stated throughout the Holy Quran the second comings of the Prophets Muhammad and Issa son of Maryam; here are some examples: To the Prophet Muhammad, God said: “We will return you for another mission (Sura28:85) "to the people who have not joined yet (Sura 62:3)." To Issa son of Maryam, God said: "They neither killed him, nor crucify him (Sura 4:157),”"every soul shall taste death”(Sura 29:57)"; if you read through the lines it means Issa must die like all souls which implies a second coming. And the meeting of the Prophets Muhammad and Issa, in their second coming is when God metaphorically talks about "when the sun and the moon are joined together at the same location, same descent" (Sura 75: 9); the same Sura talks about their skin color as “when the moon shall be black”(Sura 75:8).
@@plumlaye7836 Stop spreading lies, 28:85 says Allah will return Muhammad to Mecca, and He has. The verse refers to Muslims migrating from Mecca and states that they will return. There is no teaching in Islam indicating the Prophet will return to this world after his death. Only references to the return of the Messiah.
@@tanerserdar The Lord bless you. Why would a Muslim spread lies if he’s already the winner? You’re just following the mainstream interpretation. Unless you know what the abjad Aleef (ا) stands for, please don’t get yourself in trouble God, by doubting anyone. Please ask God to open for you the hidden, then you will know only God knows; man doesn’t know anything.Salam
Sorry But the event will not happen physically The sun rising on west is the metaphor The meaning is the believers in general and the Muslim (ahlu suna) in particular will seek guidance and reference from the western civilization Most of those signs that annonce the approche of the doomsday are metaphorical For instance; the saying of dajal having one eye means that the people will only interest on the worldly things not the hereafter
Sorry But the event will not happen physically The sun rising on west is the metaphor The meaning is the believers in general and the Muslim (ahlu suna) in particular will seek guidance and reference from the western civilization Most of those signs that annonce the approche of the doomsday are metaphorical For instance; the saying of dajal having one eye means that the people will only interest on the worldly things not the hereafter
![Chris Langan - The Interview THEY Didn't Want You To See - CTMU [Full Version; Timestamps]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9miVG2xT5jY/mqdefault.jpg)
When a real, qualified scholar speaks, there is no room for spéculation. This one is our honor, may Allmighty bless him, protect and inspire him. Commendable teachings.
Masha Allaah.. Great and wise explanations. May Allah bless him.
I simply love this man! Hands down! His exegeses! His style to put across his thoughts! His articulation! And his scholarship! He's simply a blessing for those who have the capacity and capability to listen and to understand....Gratitude!!!❤❤❤
Very, very interesting.
I have just subscribed to this channel.
Mashallah this reaction video is a great idea and a wonderful addition
We need more wondering, pondering and reflection on Quran. Thanks Doctor ❤❤❤
To understand the holy Koran you need to study sciences, no other way possible. This man is a physicist and up to now I really learned a lot of him in short time. Much blessings
The ayaat in revelation and the ayaat in creation. Very good point.
Beautifully explained 👍
Absolutely great explanation. Thanks.
Thank you for your beautiful and sensible explanation.🙏
MashaAllah i really love listening to ur lectures u really amazing MashaAllah
Very informative
Marvellous, bless you
Brilliant.
Thanks a lot Isra Academy
The Quran verse that is the KEY TO OPEN THE LOCK is Surah Al-IMRAN 3:5-7
The verse talks about the two kinds of language that Allah uses in the Quran. One factual and the other Muttashabiat = Allegorical/ Symbolic!
We need to be very, very careful to not confuse the two kinds of language.
It indicates a new beginning.
thank you😊😊
You're welcome 😊
agree on the approach the North Pole shifting, geomagnetic reversal cause the sun to appear to rise from the west from the perspective of the north pole. Thank you sheikh
Tnx❤
Great ...one thing is sure that something big change is going to happen in our universe ..that these verse are pointing out...we are only concerned on sun rise but something beyond and big thing is going to happen
By The Quran we get indication only...we have to search or say we will have go deeper in cosmic knowledge to understand the meaning of verse...
actually Dzhanibekov effect can explain it.
a rotating body in space will periodically flip 180 degrees around it's axis if it's centre of balance is off.
this means the earth will flip upside down and continue rotating.
the earths centre of balance is being offset by its core moving, and by the huge transfer of materials to build concrete cities all over the world. Add the melting of the ice caps etc. The earths balance is changing.
I am an astronomer and that is incorrect.
Dzhanibekov effect only works on small objects that have little to none gravitational force pulling on them.
Earth is a massive body kept stable by the sun’s and moon’s gravity.
This effect will never flip earth on its axis.
@tanerserdar but if the earth's mass distribution changes, that wouldn't be the case anymore would it? a new equilibrium lock would need to be created wouldn't it?
@@zenastronomy Anything is possible. 👍
A German revert once ( around 25 years ago ) commented on the increasing no of western reverts to Islam that the sun of Islam will rise from the west ..
And that the east will go through sort of darkness... Who knows
AGREED. This is the true explanation.
Yes , the scholar Bediuzzaman Said nursi tells sth similar. The islamic world become like westerners, the West will give a birth to Islam. There must be absolutely a better translation but it was close to this. And we have already seen this, many middle eastern countries have been very against Islam in their behaviours and ahklaq like being dishonest or hypocrite people. Islam is like leaving whom doesn't deserve it and moving towards whom deserves it more... We as born Muslims must be scared of this and try to be better muslims...
The east is currently in darkness..
Nice one
@@asmaaaboulfadl5420 who is he? On UA-cam or ?
If we put it in the context of one the signs which says dajjal period a day will be long as a year, month and a day, it fits into thinking the earth rotation will slow down and then spin the other way
Listened you for 21 minutes, very interesting, thanks for picking this topic.
If I heard correctly, sunrise from West, will be for short time. one day sun will rise from West and come midway, then will go back and set in West. From next day, it will rise from east as regular.
So may be some Galectical events happen in future which can change the gravity in such a way for very short time. Whatever it makes, sun will rise from West one day, that's one of the major signs of end time. We may never know how it can happen but it will happen. Quran says, it is not the eyes but their heart is blind. So reason isn't important right now but belief is. Time is passing soon!
Kindly define time or infact short time.
Thank for brilliant information. What about vacuum decay (reverse bit bang)? Can it cause sun rising from west?
Good point, but the current data suggests that the universe will not collapse, its expansion is getting faster, so thermodynamic death (the big freeze) seems more likely.
Why his voice is so amazing to listen
WHAT ABOUT SURA 99 ?
So if the earth’s magnetic pole shifts, does that mean that our observation of the direction shifts as well i.e. East becomes West, West becomes East, since we rely on compass?
If north pole shifts ?
yup 😁 it rotate's Antarctic North to south and Antarctic South to north
Insya 'allah in slow m0w it rotate's and More time for tornadoes, earthquake & tsunami 👍🏼
If I remember it right, it is said in a Hadith that when the sun rises from the west, the people will indeed believe (what choice so they have ?) but their belief will not do them good. If you don't interpret this literally then why won't their belief do them well if they still can repent?. If the interpretation is literal then indeed nothing good will come out of their belief because the earth spinning in the opposite direction means the world is ending. Lately there is data that shows indeed the earth can spin in the opposite direction. And ALLAH AWJ knows best. 🙏✨♥️
That’s exactly what he explained in the video. The only thing he was trying solve how it would actually happen. There is a need to some scientific explanation to how the sun could rise from the West.
I have a suggestion for my brother and sister to watch the Furqan qureshi blog channel for this concept, especially, the mysterious door episodes, may Allah Guide us.
Earth will go retrograde 😮
yup 😁 it rotate's Antarctic North to south and Antarctic South to north
Insya 'allah in slow m0w it rotate's and More time for tornadoes, earthquake & tsunami 👍🏼
The physical idea of "West" is relative to the reference frame we use on Earth. It is not absolute.
Allah knows best what is the true meaning behind this hadith, but it could be the knowledge (sun 🌞) rising from the Western region. Since all the major signs are negative, this could mean that the knowledge ( illumination) will be false too, adding to the deception of Dajjal at that time.
Sheikh Imran also has similar standing and understanding of this.
I am personally convinced as well. This seems the most practical interpretation.
Allah knows the best.
Looking at the circumstances of the events that the Quran has mentioned i think i would go with your theory
The metaphoric sounds more logical. Because if there is a supernova, why should the tawba not accepted after that? What about the hikma that tawba an eeman is not accepted after that?
It's a bit like when the Pharaoh's iman was not accepted after he believed in God after seeing the Red Sea part and then join back, engulfing him and his army. As in, the Prophet (pbuh) warned people about this and they didn't believe; seeing an absolute sign like that and only believing afterwards means that one wasn't going to believe without it the way God had wanted people to believe.
Tbh it's hard one.
About Venus I think the slowing down was due to it's thick atmosphere that is hundreds of times more dense than earth.
Also some studies claimed that earth days had gone faster bc of pumping ground water.
So a change of distribution of mass on earth could dramatically affect it's spin.
Maybe earth losing it's moon by a giant impact will contribute to a change In the precession effect than will cause a massive shift of the earth mass to it's poles like losing the poles glaciers melting or something.
The comment that the mention is from the Hadith not the Quran is not fair as anything The Prophet (S.A.W.) said is unquestionable as Allah (S.W.T.) Has comfirmed in the Quran that The Prophet never says anything on his own accord but from a Revelation from The Lord-Allah.
Motion retrograde has happened on mars i think over 20years ago according to nasa. The sun rose from the west for a few days. Then it returned to normal. Can someone
Say if this true.
Motion retrograde means slowing of the rotation of earth not stopping or rotating the other way.
A meteor does not need to have a full on head collision rather one or more glancing blows in opposing direction and then in direction of clockwise direction
Can you do your research before writing a comment, check how big meteors are.
A simple question for you. If the sun rising from the West is not to be taken literally, what else of the signs of the Last Hour are not to be taken literally? All of them? Only some? Why only some? Who decides? Is Isa alaihissalam's second coming also not to be taken literally? To be consistent, you would have to not take that literally too. Which, if you do not take that literally, then that means you are no longer an Ahlul Sunnah, at the least. But if you are to take the second coming literally, why the inconsistency? What criteria from the Quran or Sunnah are you using to accept the second coming literally but not the sun rising from the West literally?
One could say this (I'm not a scholar, mind you): the Second Coming is foretold in the Qur'an according to most interpretations, when God says that all of the Children of Israel will believe in Jesus, pbuh, before his death, meaning that Jesus has to come back to earth and eventually die here. OTOH, such a quasi-explicit statement is not made by God regarding the sun rising from the west. Wallahu a'lam.
@@minskdhaka Still does not answer the question. Why do you take the second coming literally, regardless whether it is mentioned in the Qur'an or not, albeit not explicitly. Does it mean that you only take the Words of Allah سبحانه وتعالى literally but not the word of His Prophet ﷺ, and if so, why, and based on which Quranic or Sunnah principle have you decided to do so? Do you than take the word "istiwa" in the Qur'an literally? If you do not, then explain the standard you use to determine which or what is to be taken literally and which or what is not. Where in Islam can you find the usul that the Words of Allah سبحانه وتعالى are to be taken literally but not that of His Prophet ﷺ? That is the fundamental question that need to be addressed to resolve this matter.
Thank you. The easiest way is to happen it virtualy. So at that time people will live more in a virtual world and there the sun will raise from the west. Believing in all what Allah does this other guy does the oposite. So thats a guess too.
Slowing down doesn't mean it will be constant there a counter force that earth is spinning against once the force is overcome the slowing down will be sped up and will start spinning opposite
There is no such theory.
The sun rotates because of angular momentum. It began to rotate when the stellar nebula collapsed about 4.6 billion years ago. Its spin is slowing because of the gravitational forces acting upon it. But it will take billions of years to slow down.
Quran : “ The likeness of Issa ( Jesus ) is the likeness of Adam , when God intended something, he said be and it’s “ Salam
Yes but he created Adam from clay and Isa in the womb of Maryan.
Sorry
This event will not happen physically
It’s a metaphor
It just means that at the believers in general and the Museum in particular will not seek guidance or reference from the teachings of the Prophets in particular in the suna of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) but from the west as we witness now
And Dajal having one eye doesn’t means physical one eye but have one vision ; Dunya and forget the hereafter
you are wrong
The tafseer has covered the Sun ( Quran ) the incorrect tafseer
The rise appears to be that western language/scholars will expose the true interpretation of the Quran
Muhammad said I had to fight for the revelation of the Quran but Ali will have to fight for its interpretation
What happened to Ali and you now know why he was unalived, the tafseer after that is based upon forged hadith's , and hadith's that were not transmitted verbatim hence bukhari having similar narrations seemingly talking about the same thing but with different words , proof nothing was recorded verbatim leading to Chinese whispers
And the stars shall fall , = the famous " scholars" both dead and alive shall be exposed and their errors for all to see , and these stars shall disperse and scatter ( run away knowing how many people they have mislead )
First of all the noble prophet is not your work-buddy. When use his name you should include (saw).
Secondly, what experience do you have in Quranic exegesis to make a disrespectful claim that the tafsir is wrong when there is a consensus among the majority of mufassirun on what the verse is referring to.
Can you provide a link where we can check your credentials as an expert on Usul al Tafsir?
@@tanerserdar
For starters he isn't a prophet for me because I'm not or was from banu Israel, prophets came to them , and Allah says prophethood has ended, so I address Muhammad as Rasool Allah not Nabi though he was one
I don't need to put (saw) at the end of Muhammad as I say that anyway I don't need to literally write ✍️ that down , just to please a literal like you
I'm not going to answer any of your questions because from your reply you need to get the basics right
@@thebeesnuts777 I am not a literalist. You have no idea about Islamic sciences. Muhammed (saw) is both a rasul and nabi. All resuls are also nabis, but not all nabis are resul.
Anyway, no need to argue… have a good day.
@@tanerserdar
Thank you I didn't know that Muhammad was a nabi and rasool and I didn't know Musa was a nabi or rasool , ,,,, and in-between them I didn't know they were prophets
Are you serious of course I know that , you obviously don't know the difference between a Messenger and Nabi , if you did you wouldn't be addressing Muhammad as a Nabi
@@tanerserdar
Do you know the difference between Anbiyaa and Nabiyeen ? I bet you don't
Hi
You need to listen to sheikh Imran Hosein analysis on the subject if you want to get an indebt response on the subject...May Allah continue to bless him and may the message of righteousness continue to be spread...
With respect to your sheikh Imran, it is not ethical to advertise sheikhs in other channels.
This is an academic platform where scholars with vast knowledge on Islamic sciences present their views, not a platform for people to advertise their sheikhs, you are welcome to follow whichever sheikh you wish to follow but you should go and thank them under their videos.
We pray for all scholars and sheikhs who explain Islam. Only Allah knows who has profound knowledge in Islamic matters.
@@tanerserdar Those who are truly looking for knowledge and a better understanding of the Religion, should encourage others to do research and follow the teaching of others with a more compressive understanding of Quran....Once the individual is speaking truth and spreading the words of righteousness, you should help spread the message and not try to fight down the individual by suppressing their Teachings...... Ur platform should be used to help spread the true message of Islam regardless of what others think. Try not to be bias and one-sided in ur heart and mind, but instead be open up and free and u would be bless by Allah Most High in ur struggle and quest for knowledge...So let's all try help and teach each other along the way in life journey and struggle
@@JohnDoe-vl1if
Its not my platform brother, I made a non-bias comment. There are many people who follow many different sheiks and scholars. People who like listening to academics who are experts in their fields come here, and I am one of these people. I trust the scholars here, that’s why I listen to them.
Thank you for your response.
@@tanerserdar Peace and Blessings to you and your family and may your journey in seeking knowledge continue to grow and expand by the Grace of Allah... It's all Love, Unity, 1 mission and not a Competition...
@@JohnDoe-vl1if Jazakallah Khayr 🤲
Hi hello
May be the current day physics not advanced enough to shed any light on this matter. We may find some answers thousand years later. Allah knows best.
Agreed
Sorry
But the event will not happen physically
The sun rising on west is the metaphor
The meaning is the believers in general and the Muslim (ahlu suna) in particular will seek guidance and reference from the western civilization
Most of those signs that annonce the approche of the doomsday are metaphorical
For instance; the saying of dajal having one eye means that the people will only interest on the worldly things not the hereafter
There is no such verses in the quran.
Sorry
But the event will not happen physically
The sun rising on west is the metaphor
The meaning is the believers in general and the Muslim (ahlu suna) in particular will seek guidance and reference from the western civilization
Most of those signs that annonce the approche of the doomsday are metaphorical
For instance; the saying of dajal having one eye means that the people will only interest on the worldly things not the hereafter
That's not true...
The eye of the dajjal already has a description. How he will die had been mentioned. The sword of 'Isa ('alayhi salâm) will have his blood on it. This has nothing to do with not thinking about the hereafter. What are you talking about?
@@adrianrouse83
Salam
What is the description?
Yes there will be dajal or even dajaliiuna but not with a one physically eye
@@FamilyMBAYE
About his eye resembling a floating rotten grape with the word kafir in the middle of his forehead. He will have the ability to split a man in half, and then bring him back to life, which will be one of the things that the doubters and disbelievers fall for. Taking him as their Lord. The prophet (saws) said don't fall for this, you won't meet your Lord until you die. He will show people a fake jannah and a fake hell fire. The prophet (saws) said jump into the one with the fire. If you recite the last two verses of Surah al khaf you will be safe from the fire says the prophet (saws).
Now you tell me how this makes sense with how you framed this dajjal to be?
Because you seem to be more informed than the prophet himself (saws)
@@adrianrouse83
Salam Brother
And please don’t put words in my mouth please
Where did I said that I am more informed than the Al-Amiin (sws)?
I am not the one who doubts any saying of Him (SWS)
Khadiss is a true knowledge but you need sometimes wisdom to understand the meaning in its context
Once again his eye “resembling “ a floating rotten grape) is a metaphor.
“Riding “the ten last verses of surate kahf frequently particularly in Friday will help you getting the wisdom to decorticate the tricks of dajal
@FamilyMBAYE
First of all, I'm only quoting what the Qur'an says and what the prophet (saws) says. Your are the one who has to explain why you are taking these things as a metaphor. Second of all, maybe you need to go back and read CAREFULLY what i said. I said you SEEM to be more informed. I never said you said anything. And reciting surah al khaf on Fridays was a separate hadith. May Allah guide us both. Ameen 🤲
As salâmu alaikum
My opinion money.. because human go to west for work n money not like before khalifah turkey Uthmani... correct me if i wrong..but Allah wnow all 😊.bad from me. all Good from ALLAH..
Sir, Quran,the words of the Arab God Allah many times say some funny things to please his devotees,muslims and should be taken as jokes of the almighty Allah.
Tu the earth is happening nothing but the sun yes.becouse hi is command the moon end sun
THE SON OF MAN OR GOD WILL COME FROM THE WEST,AND THE EVERY BODY KNEES WILL KNEEL AND SAY, YOUR THE LORD,😮
JUST SAYING DONT TAKE NOTES,
PROFESSOR THANKS,
God doesnt have sons daughters or any other relatives - read your own Bible and its very clear: John 5:30, 14:28 and dozens more references...
Google "The Physics of the Day of Judgment
Assalamu Aleykum ,
The sun will rise from the West is the second coming of the Prophet Muhammad as Imam Mahdi in the West. (Sura Al Baqara,2:258). The Prophet Muhammad came back with Prophet Issa (Sura Az-Zukhruf, 43:63).The 1883 eruption of Krakatoa is a scientific indication (en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1883_eruption_of_Krakatoa). Another scientific evidence is when their believers die and get buried the disappear from the grave right away (ua-cam.com/video/_ffVoOxbMf8/v-deo.html)
What ???
@@user-qb2lv8uo4x Yes, it is clearly stated throughout the Holy Quran the second comings of the Prophets Muhammad and Issa son of Maryam; here are some examples:
To the Prophet Muhammad, God said: “We will return you for another mission (Sura28:85) "to the people who have not joined yet (Sura 62:3)."
To Issa son of Maryam, God said:
"They neither killed him, nor crucify him (Sura 4:157),”"every soul shall taste death”(Sura 29:57)"; if you read through the lines it means Issa must die like all souls which implies a second coming.
And the meeting of the Prophets Muhammad and Issa, in their second coming is when God metaphorically talks about "when the sun and the moon are joined together at the same location, same descent" (Sura 75: 9); the same Sura talks about their skin color as “when the moon shall be black”(Sura 75:8).
@@plumlaye7836
Stop spreading lies, 28:85 says Allah will return Muhammad to Mecca, and He has. The verse refers to Muslims migrating from Mecca and states that they will return.
There is no teaching in Islam indicating the Prophet will return to this world after his death.
Only references to the return of the Messiah.
@@tanerserdar The Lord bless you. Why would a Muslim spread lies if he’s already the winner?
You’re just following the mainstream interpretation.
Unless you know what the abjad Aleef (ا) stands for, please don’t get yourself in trouble God, by doubting anyone. Please ask God to open for you the hidden, then you will know only God knows; man doesn’t know anything.Salam
@@plumlaye7836 my friend there is no such explanation in the Quran, hadith or scholarly sources.
Sorry about the term lies, but it is incorrect.
Simply bull shits😂😂
Why then so much talks?
Hi
Sorry
But the event will not happen physically
The sun rising on west is the metaphor
The meaning is the believers in general and the Muslim (ahlu suna) in particular will seek guidance and reference from the western civilization
Most of those signs that annonce the approche of the doomsday are metaphorical
For instance; the saying of dajal having one eye means that the people will only interest on the worldly things not the hereafter
Hi
Sorry
But the event will not happen physically
The sun rising on west is the metaphor
The meaning is the believers in general and the Muslim (ahlu suna) in particular will seek guidance and reference from the western civilization
Most of those signs that annonce the approche of the doomsday are metaphorical
For instance; the saying of dajal having one eye means that the people will only interest on the worldly things not the hereafter
It is not appropriate to speak in these matters with certainty. Yes it maybe metaphorical but only Allah knows.
Hi