this should SCARE all of you and the internet addicted kids with gender dysmorphia and mental health issues ETC and the FACT the motha need to be juice for you to be JUICE !!!! The LOCATION should scare you. What they are trying to do. we know that all three religions coexisted in Jerusalem ! THE source of the three religions at the core is ONE. NEVER FORGET THAT. YOUR ACTIONS DEFINE YOU AND NOT YOUR FAMILY, SKIN COLOR OR ANYTHING ELSE.
All stories get exaggerated over time because people gradually lose interest in older versions. This is particularly true about mythology and religious stories. Noah's flood was local and all the animals he carried along were only that he needed to survive again. Mixing up stories of floods from around the world is not logical because we see that monsoon season hits a region in almost the same time frame.
Thats one view and it could be correct, but we can never be certain. When we say “this is the way it happened” there is a problem in this view because we were not there when it happened.
@burhanhashmi5355 You like Noha's homeless garbage version escaping on his donkey the rain asking god for help to replace his umbrella and begging for food.
1. Qur'an never mention that the flood is global flood. 2. Qur'an never mention that Noah bring the whole animals on earth. Those story is come from old testament.
not even in the old testament, these people just write their own bible for their own benefits, thats why there are no more authentics bibles words left. thats why manypeople confuses why there is old testaments n new testaments. thats why Allah send the last messenger, Muhammad to guide us w Quran words
The speaker says it is a ship with an engine, maybe that's a rocket. I am not convinced a boat to be very effective if front of a planetary catastrophy.
@@MrAminmohamedthe speaker provides an evidence from the Quran. Surah Hud, Verse 50 uses the term “tannuru” meaning furnace on the Ark. This may be considered as an evidence for the argument. But, Mars does not have oxygen to support life…
Salam Allah swt says take the pair of animal with you and it was Regional Flood not on whole Earth after the Flood Noah AS started Life Again with Those animal He Broght with Him they were Domestic Animals .Because after The flood they need Food and Allah swt Made it Easy for them to repopulate .to go and live in a place that people have moved away from, or to cause people to do this:Salam
Salam, these are all possibilities, however, it is not correct to speak about these things with certainty. You did not witness the incident. The Quran does not specify if it was local or global either. So, we can only make interpretations, we cannot speak with certainty about Kalamullah.
@@tanerserdar We Muslim Have to Revisit our Deen any Tafsir has no Final Authority only The Quran and Prophet 's Sunnah only We Muslim also Misunderstood who was Dhul quernain and Why Allah swt Chose Him i can tell you who was He and why Allah swt chose Him salam .
Sunnat Allah would summise to , his way that doesn't change for nobody, his signature, his laws So if the past people sinned and would need to counteract those actions with Good actions then you better believe we and the future generations will have to conteract our misdeeds, no wiping of the slate for nobody, instead you should seek opportunities to counteract only what you know have done , .
There was no global flood when humanity existed. The ice age happened long time before humanity existed. There is no evidence of human destruction during the meltdown of ice. The rest of your explanation could be only described as bizarre.
Salams. It should be easy to prove whether the ark had engines or not. The Quran states that the ark rested in Mount Judi. So dig up Judi and see if there is a structure that resembles an ark and locate the remnants of engines. If the civilisation was advanced then it would not have used steam engines, instead the ark should have been an aerial vehicle that could transport animals to a part of the world that has dry land. That is advanced, not steam engines!
Wa alaikum salam. Unfortunately we do not know where Mount Judi is, there are 3 different mountains which people refer to as Judi. Moreover we do not even know if it is a mountain that the Quran mentions, the verse does not use the term “mountain”
Noah Ark was like Dr Who Tardis!! The size inside was far more massive than what it looked like on the outside!!! AMAZING NONSENSE! Noah took pairs of a handful of Animals into the Ark! He did not take all the species!! The flood was not a world-wide flood, hence no need to take every animal.
Just an ignorant who creates imaginary possibility for some miracles while refuse the possibility for the occurrence some other. if we think about the possibility for how a miracle has happened we may not be considered Muslim since the nature and purpose of miracles were to leave no reason for mankind not to believe in Allah.
Do you have direct evidence (that is not Bible-based) that Noah brought any animals on a ship? I am asking about evidence, not hear say or books written by this person or that person. Full-k means plural of small boats, not ships. Please make sure that you do your homework before promoting biblical tales under the banner of Islam.
Assalamu alaykum, I am Dr Omer Atilla Ergi, the person in the video. I do not normally respond to comments but since you have accused me of fabricating information from the holy Quran (astagfirullah), I felt the need to respond. Firstly, let me give you some background about myself. I have been teaching Islamic sciences for the past 40 years, and on an academic level the last 12 years. I would fear Allah from making any comments that are not compatible with the Quran. When I was preparing for this video, I did not even look at any relevant text in the bible. Now in regards to your argument: 1- You ask where is the evidence in the Quran that Nuh (as) took pair of animals into the Ark. It is in Surah Hud, verse 40. If you read the verse carefullyh, you will see that the term كُلٍّ زَوْجَيْنِ اثْنَيْنِ means "pair of every species", this clearly indicates animals because, if you argue that it was pair of humans (husband and wife) the verse would not continue with the term وَاَهْلَكَ meaning AND your family, and then the verse instructs him to take those who believe وَمَنْ اٰمَنَۜ , so the verse first states pair of every species, and your family and those who believed. 2- If he did not take any animals, especially farm animals such as chickens, ducks, horses, goats, sheep, cattle and so on, how were they going to survive after the floods receded? Where would they get their sustanance from? There would be no crops, no eggs, no milk, no meat. 3- What difference does it make if the term الْفُلْكَ means ships or boat? Moreover, why would Nuh (as) make small boats when there is a big flood coming? He was commended to make a ship or maybe ships. Importantly, you will not find this interpreation anywhere in the Jewish or Christian sources. So, I would advise you to check their sources and see if there is anything that resembles my interpretation. Lasty, as a Muslim scholar, I was deeply hurt by your comments so next time please fear Allah before accusing your fellow Muslims using tales from other texts or fabricating false information from the holy Quran. Kind regards. Omer Atilla Ergi
@@bilimveitikat150 Dr Ergi, I wouldn’t take this commenter seriously. In his videos he claims we shouldn’t use certain supplications from the Quran, that Isa Jesus was deceitful, Sulaiman tricked Bilqees into showing her legs and that saying Allahumma in our dua is dangerous! I am appalled he has so many subscribers. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s a yahoodi agent.
@@bilimveitikat150 Safeenah is ship not fulk. Your response demonstrates your conceitedness. It seems that you are just like those who take pride in calling themselves scholars and are not humble in considering differing point of views. Being a "scholar" does not mean you are correct. You were simply asked to present evidence from quran, instead you present your opinion instead of evidences even to the point of discounting the word (fulk) of Allah as it does not fit your narrative. Put your cognitive biases aside and look at things with new eyes
Everything in the universe moves with the name of Allah. But Allah creates everything through laws. The laws of physics is created by Allah as well, so this is what the doctor is trying to explain.
@ true but archeology science and Quran proofs that iron started to be used 1000 before Christ and Allah says we made iron soft to David as and David as lived 1000-900 before Christ exactly the same time science and archeology date , so to be able to make steam engines u need Iron
@@gharibdunya6748 Dear friend, classical archeology’s narratives began to fall apart. I advise you to watch Graham Hancock’s “Ancient Apocalypse” Moreover, the steam engine argument comes from an important tafsir scholar, Hamdi Yazir. The term “tannuru” (furnace) does sound interesting…
This could be in the region where Noah lived. It cannot be referring to all mountains on earth as it is scientifically impossible. There is not enough water on earth to cover all mountains.
@@tanerserdar It is possible though. The water did not vanish or "recede" when the flood finished, it was absorbed by the earth's internal canals. There is actually enough water to cover the whole earth if you take into consideration the buried waters in deep wells and springs.
@@scholarforpeace Yes I agree, earth has an estimated total volume of water of around 1.386 billion cubic kilometres. This includes all surface water, groundwater, and water stored in ice and glaciers. A significant amount of water is also stored within the earth’s crust in rocks and minerals. Therefore, if this water was to be distributed evenly on the surface, entire surface of the earth would be covered by water. However, we do not have the scientific evidence to support the notion that it actually happened. God knows best. What we know is all Divine Books, Torah, Gospels and the Quran mentions the great floods, so we believe it occurred.
Great lecture 👏 Recently I came across another interesting perspective of Noah story on “ Marvelous Quran “ by Dr Hanny . He say there was no ship , no flood and did not live long .. quite different interpretation of Quran
Stay away from that channel!! In his videos he claims we shouldn’t use certain supplications from the Quran, that Isa Jesus was deceitful, Sulaiman tricked Bilqees into showing her legs and that saying Allahumma in our dua is dangerous! I am appalled he has so many subscribers. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s a yahoodi agent.
It is not possible based on your limited knowledge. You don’t know until you don’t know. Don’t say it’s not possible, at once you quote Quran and then make imagination from your small head that it is not possible and Noah took chickens for his survivals
It is common sense. Mathematically it is not possible for all the animals to fit in a ship even if it was 10 times the size of Titanic. Moreover, how are you going to feed millions of animals and clean after them? Try using your peanut sized brain a little…
Brother whoever you are. You starting out wrong. Why do you insult this man. Don't give comments like this. This is showing how limited your knowledge is and you are surely very ignorant not to consider how others feel if you say something. Count your words bro.
There is no archaeological evidence for a global flood! It was a local flood. The Ark was powered by a Di-lithium crystal and also had Photon torpedo capability. The Photon torpedo was catapulted out of the Ark by steam!! Amazing!
@@Dr.SohailaIslam I already watched it DUDE! Are you one of those classical archeologists or someone who has no idea about latest discoveries? Maybe you are one of those who thinks Allah cannot guide Nuh to build a more advanced ship? Logs and ropes yeah 😂
Jazakallah khairan katheera Dr.Ergi for this great explanation.
Salam Doc, May Allah SWT give you more knowledge and wisdom and enough strength to share it with the rest of mankind. AMEEN.
. very interesting . advanced civilization in a purpose built Ark guided by Allah c.c. . Thank you Dr Ergi . 🌱
PALESTINE NOT isreal
this should SCARE all of you and the internet addicted kids with gender dysmorphia and mental health issues ETC and the FACT the motha need to be juice for you to be JUICE !!!! The LOCATION should scare you. What they are trying to do. we know that all three religions coexisted in Jerusalem ! THE source of the three religions at the core is ONE. NEVER FORGET THAT. YOUR ACTIONS DEFINE YOU AND NOT YOUR FAMILY, SKIN COLOR OR ANYTHING ELSE.
Not according to Allah in the Quran. No mentions of Palestine. Many mentions of ‘children of Israel’ referring to Jews.
@@shredx81do you believe in Quran?
Stop barking
@@Booyaboohmind your language mate. Now you sound like barking anytime you hear someone expresses love around Palestine and people of Palestine
subhanallah, may Allah protects all muslims in the world
Thanks a lot Isra Academy
Thank you
Salam Allahykum 💐TebarakAllah allahykum 🌺🌸💚🌸🌺
Salaam Aly kum M not sure about mistake Dr Ergi made he mentioned camel camels came long after during time of Saleh Aly salaam
All stories get exaggerated over time because people gradually lose interest in older versions. This is particularly true about mythology and religious stories. Noah's flood was local and all the animals he carried along were only that he needed to survive again. Mixing up stories of floods from around the world is not logical because we see that monsoon season hits a region in almost the same time frame.
Thats one view and it could be correct, but we can never be certain.
When we say “this is the way it happened” there is a problem in this view because we were not there when it happened.
@burhanhashmi5355 You like Noha's homeless garbage version escaping on his donkey the rain asking god for help to replace his umbrella and begging for food.
Since we found the ark and now we know how big was the ark.
Some kind of animals for making foods during the great deluge at that areas.
1. Qur'an never mention that the flood is global flood.
2. Qur'an never mention that Noah bring the whole animals on earth.
Those story is come from old testament.
not even in the old testament, these people just write their own bible for their own benefits, thats why there are no more authentics bibles words left. thats why manypeople confuses why there is old testaments n new testaments. thats why Allah send the last messenger, Muhammad to guide us w Quran words
What do you think about the possibility that Noah came from planet Mars ?
:) Evidence ?
@@tanerserdarGravity on Mars is lower, people can be taller and live longer.
The speaker says it is a ship with an engine, maybe that's a rocket. I am not convinced a boat to be very effective if front of a planetary catastrophy.
@@MrAminmohamedthe speaker provides an evidence from the Quran. Surah Hud, Verse 50 uses the term “tannuru” meaning furnace on the Ark. This may be considered as an evidence for the argument. But, Mars does not have oxygen to support life…
Maybe Mars also lost it's atmosphere and water because of a comet passing too close.
Salam Allah swt says take the pair of animal with you and it was Regional Flood not on whole Earth after the Flood Noah AS started Life Again with Those animal He Broght with Him they were Domestic Animals .Because after The flood they need Food and Allah swt Made it Easy for them to repopulate .to go and live in a place that people have moved away from, or to cause people to do this:Salam
Salam, these are all possibilities, however, it is not correct to speak about these things with certainty. You did not witness the incident. The Quran does not specify if it was local or global either. So, we can only make interpretations, we cannot speak with certainty about Kalamullah.
@@tanerserdar Salam Kalamullah is telling us Read and Ponder Brother Read Surah Bani Israel .
@@kakabawani4212 I have read 10 different tafsirs, how many did you read my friend? I am just wondering your expertise in the field.
@@tanerserdar We Muslim Have to Revisit our Deen any Tafsir has no Final Authority only The Quran and Prophet 's Sunnah only
We Muslim also Misunderstood who was Dhul quernain and Why Allah swt Chose Him i can tell you who was He and why Allah swt chose Him salam .
maybe prophet noah nation is the lost atlantis
Sunnat Allah would summise to , his way that doesn't change for nobody, his signature, his laws
So if the past people sinned and would need to counteract those actions with Good actions then you better believe we and the future generations will have to conteract our misdeeds, no wiping of the slate for nobody, instead you should seek opportunities to counteract only what you know have done , .
It is possible to fit all creatures of the world in a small box by only keeping DNA samples.
Yes true, but did they wait for the animals to grow and start giving eggs, milk and meat, and starve in the mean time?
There was no global flood when humanity existed. The ice age happened long time before humanity existed. There is no evidence of human destruction during the meltdown of ice. The rest of your explanation could be only described as bizarre.
Salams. It should be easy to prove whether the ark had engines or not. The Quran states that the ark rested in Mount Judi. So dig up Judi and see if there is a structure that resembles an ark and locate the remnants of engines. If the civilisation was advanced then it would not have used steam engines, instead the ark should have been an aerial vehicle that could transport animals to a part of the world that has dry land. That is advanced, not steam engines!
Wa alaikum salam.
Unfortunately we do not know where Mount Judi is, there are 3 different mountains which people refer to as Judi. Moreover we do not even know if it is a mountain that the Quran mentions, the verse does not use the term “mountain”
Submarine with advanced tech .
Noah Ark was like Dr Who Tardis!!
The size inside was far more massive than what it looked like on the outside!!! AMAZING NONSENSE!
Noah took pairs of a handful of Animals into the Ark! He did not take all the species!!
The flood was not a world-wide flood, hence no need to take every animal.
Just an ignorant who creates imaginary possibility for some miracles while refuse the possibility for the occurrence some other. if we think about the possibility for how a miracle has happened we may not be considered Muslim since the nature and purpose of miracles were to leave no reason for mankind not to believe in Allah.
Do you have direct evidence (that is not Bible-based) that Noah brought any animals on a ship? I am asking about evidence, not hear say or books written by this person or that person.
Full-k means plural of small boats, not ships. Please make sure that you do your homework before promoting biblical tales under the banner of Islam.
Assalamu alaykum,
I am Dr Omer Atilla Ergi, the person in the video. I do not normally respond to comments but since you have accused me of fabricating information from the holy Quran (astagfirullah), I felt the need to respond.
Firstly, let me give you some background about myself. I have been teaching Islamic sciences for the past 40 years, and on an academic level the last 12 years. I would fear Allah from making any comments that are not compatible with the Quran. When I was preparing for this video, I did not even look at any relevant text in the bible.
Now in regards to your argument:
1- You ask where is the evidence in the Quran that Nuh (as) took pair of animals into the Ark. It is in Surah Hud, verse 40. If you read the verse carefullyh, you will see that the term كُلٍّ زَوْجَيْنِ اثْنَيْنِ means "pair of every species", this clearly indicates animals because, if you argue that it was pair of humans (husband and wife) the verse would not continue with the term وَاَهْلَكَ meaning AND your family, and then the verse instructs him to take those who believe وَمَنْ اٰمَنَۜ , so the verse first states pair of every species, and your family and those who believed.
2- If he did not take any animals, especially farm animals such as chickens, ducks, horses, goats, sheep, cattle and so on, how were they going to survive after the floods receded? Where would they get their sustanance from? There would be no crops, no eggs, no milk, no meat.
3- What difference does it make if the term الْفُلْكَ means ships or boat? Moreover, why would Nuh (as) make small boats when there is a big flood coming? He was commended to make a ship or maybe ships. Importantly, you will not find this interpreation anywhere in the Jewish or Christian sources. So, I would advise you to check their sources and see if there is anything that resembles my interpretation.
Lasty, as a Muslim scholar, I was deeply hurt by your comments so next time please fear Allah before accusing your fellow Muslims using tales from other texts or fabricating false information from the holy Quran.
Kind regards.
Omer Atilla Ergi
@@bilimveitikat150 Dr Ergi, I wouldn’t take this commenter seriously. In his videos he claims we shouldn’t use certain supplications from the Quran, that Isa Jesus was deceitful, Sulaiman tricked Bilqees into showing her legs and that saying Allahumma in our dua is dangerous! I am appalled he has so many subscribers. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s a yahoodi agent.
@@bilimveitikat150
Safeenah is ship not fulk. Your response demonstrates your conceitedness. It seems that you are just like those who take pride in calling themselves scholars and are not humble in considering differing point of views. Being a "scholar" does not mean you are correct. You were simply asked to present evidence from quran, instead you present your opinion instead of evidences even to the point of discounting the word (fulk) of Allah as it does not fit your narrative. Put your cognitive biases aside and look at things with new eyes
Noah ship moves and stop by name of Allah, name of Allah was engine of ship. Recite Quraan chapter Noah, bismila hei mugreyha o mursaha.
Everything in the universe moves with the name of Allah. But Allah creates everything through laws. The laws of physics is created by Allah as well, so this is what the doctor is trying to explain.
U lost me with the steam engine !
Not possible? Modern humans have been around for 50,000 years and you think we advanced in science and technology only in the last few hundred years?
@ true but archeology science and Quran proofs that iron started to be used 1000 before Christ and Allah says we made iron soft to David as and David as lived 1000-900 before Christ exactly the same time science and archeology date , so to be able to make steam engines u need Iron
@@gharibdunya6748
Dear friend, classical archeology’s narratives began to fall apart. I advise you to watch Graham Hancock’s “Ancient Apocalypse”
Moreover, the steam engine argument comes from an important tafsir scholar, Hamdi Yazir.
The term “tannuru” (furnace) does sound interesting…
@@gharibdunya6748bro you are too literal. He doesnt mean a steam engine like of the 1800s. But as a concept.
"The waters rose and covered the mountains to a depth of more than fifteen cubits" (Genesis 7:20)
This could be in the region where Noah lived. It cannot be referring to all mountains on earth as it is scientifically impossible. There is not enough water on earth to cover all mountains.
@@tanerserdar It is possible though.
The water did not vanish or "recede" when the flood finished, it was absorbed by the earth's internal canals.
There is actually enough water to cover the whole earth if you take into consideration the buried waters in deep wells and springs.
@@scholarforpeace
Yes I agree, earth has an estimated total volume of water of around 1.386 billion cubic kilometres. This includes all surface water, groundwater, and water stored in ice and glaciers. A significant amount of water is also stored within the earth’s crust in rocks and minerals.
Therefore, if this water was to be distributed evenly on the surface, entire surface of the earth would be covered by water.
However, we do not have the scientific evidence to support the notion that it actually happened.
God knows best. What we know is all Divine Books, Torah, Gospels and the Quran mentions the great floods, so we believe it occurred.
@@scholarforpeace
My friend, you don't need to believe everything is literal. Jesus Christ is literal, humanity was created in Eden not earth.
Christians want literal interpretations when it suits and metaphorical when it suits.
Great lecture 👏
Recently I came across another interesting perspective of Noah story on “ Marvelous Quran “ by Dr Hanny . He say there was no ship , no flood and did not live long .. quite different interpretation of Quran
When a person ask money to do dakwa, then need to reject that person
He rejects the Sunnah
@faiyazkhan5970 And he ask payments on his dakwah
Stay away from that channel!! In his videos he claims we shouldn’t use certain supplications from the Quran, that Isa Jesus was deceitful, Sulaiman tricked Bilqees into showing her legs and that saying Allahumma in our dua is dangerous! I am appalled he has so many subscribers. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s a yahoodi agent.
God may put us with those we follow in the next life....
What a bunch of creative liars.
It is not possible based on your limited knowledge. You don’t know until you don’t know. Don’t say it’s not possible, at once you quote Quran and then make imagination from your small head that it is not possible and Noah took chickens for his survivals
It is common sense.
Mathematically it is not possible for all the animals to fit in a ship even if it was 10 times the size of Titanic.
Moreover, how are you going to feed millions of animals and clean after them?
Try using your peanut sized brain a little…
Brother whoever you are. You starting out wrong. Why do you insult this man. Don't give comments like this. This is showing how limited your knowledge is and you are surely very ignorant not to consider how others feel if you say something. Count your words bro.
There is no archaeological evidence for a global flood!
It was a local flood.
The Ark was powered by a Di-lithium crystal and also had Photon torpedo capability. The Photon torpedo was catapulted out of the Ark by steam!! Amazing!
Watch Graham Hancock’s Ancient Apocalypse…
Amazing gibberish - you yourself can , dude!
@@Dr.SohailaIslam I already watched it DUDE! Are you one of those classical archeologists or someone who has no idea about latest discoveries?
Maybe you are one of those who thinks Allah cannot guide Nuh to build a more advanced ship?
Logs and ropes yeah 😂
@Dr.SohailaIslam
Aye! Captain Kirk. ..... Damn it I'm a Dr, not a weather expert ( says Dr McCoy).
@@user-k229 😂
No living animals in the arch, their DNA was preserved, at that time Noah was surrounded with extraterrestrial beings including humans.