Messi vs Ronaldo - The Best GOAT Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 6 тис.

  • @DANGERProductions2020
    @DANGERProductions2020 3 роки тому +956

    This video looks eerily familiar. Well, I guess they say imitation is the highest form of flattery. 🤷🏾‍♂️

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +348

      OH MY GOD! I’VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS! Thank you for your inspiring video on the MJ/Lebron debate! None of this would be possible without you!

    • @DANGERProductions2020
      @DANGERProductions2020 3 роки тому +176

      Glad to help. Nice job on the video. :)

    • @cyrox5282
      @cyrox5282 3 роки тому +6

      for you, who is the goat ? Messi or Ronaldo ? :)

    • @maaamosiyarabot8003
      @maaamosiyarabot8003 3 роки тому +7

      @@cyrox5282 ronaldo

    • @iqiyi1928
      @iqiyi1928 3 роки тому +73

      @@maaamosiyarabot8003 haha nice joke

  • @ayato1292
    @ayato1292 3 роки тому +2189

    "There is a big difference between a great goalscorer and a great player" Johan Cruyff

    • @mahdirahman2006
      @mahdirahman2006 3 роки тому +189

      Ronaldo is one of the Top 3 assist provider of all time. Yeah, Messi's definitely the GOAT. No doubt abt that. But to say Cristiano's just a goalscorer is kind of disrespectful to his underrated playmaking qualities that he showcased in his prime.

    • @AlongLegend
      @AlongLegend 3 роки тому +92

      @@mahdirahman2006 Messi assist is within the offense while Ronaldo pass when he's not at the prime position to scores. There a difference and to call Ronaldo a great goal scorer is not an insult but an acknowledgement of his abilities. We always call Ronaldo (Brazil) a great goal scorer as well 🇧🇷🇧🇷

    • @arjuntb1204
      @arjuntb1204 3 роки тому +38

      Yes No one except Messi has crossed 300 assist . More than 350 assist 😎🤟

    • @biniyamin2970
      @biniyamin2970 3 роки тому +43

      @@mahdirahman2006 what is mind blowing is messi play making is even better than modric (who is one the greatest playmakers)

    • @wherewasronaldoagainstbene1658
      @wherewasronaldoagainstbene1658 3 роки тому +23

      @@mahdirahman2006 you look at the quality of most of his assist and it is poor a long ball or a lovely low ball from mostly marcelo kroos or modric and then he just taps it off to benzema or so. Messi assist he creates them himself

  • @sayan-4971
    @sayan-4971 Рік тому +266

    The fact that messi even made this video outdated....its just crazy...

  • @mahairman
    @mahairman 2 роки тому +308

    Right now Messi wins the International category by a lot. He has a Copa America beating Brazil in the Maracana and a World cup. In both tournament he had an exceptional performance.

    • @cripbk2147
      @cripbk2147 2 роки тому +53

      He actually won 3 international trophies after this video.
      He won the Copa America 2021 against Brazil.
      He won Finalissima 2022 against the winner of the Euros which was Italy.
      Now they won the 2022 World Cup
      In total Messi has won 5 trophies for Argentina. You can’t forget his U-20 World Cup & Olympic Gold medal.

    • @tb2571
      @tb2571 2 роки тому +21

      nations League and this finalissima shit are No trophies...Nobody Cares about this... Bayern and germany Fan Here and Messi is the best Player ever and nearly all the time He lost against Bayern or Germany but still I have never Seen a player comparable too him... Robben Had a similar playing Style in His Prime but still Messi was better in everything except pace and maybe shooting than Prime Robben...
      There will be No Other Player Like Messi again

    • @IrishGuysScarf
      @IrishGuysScarf Рік тому +13

      @@tb2571 I don’t care what stage in Robben’s career you look at, his shooting ability was never even close to Messi’s.

    • @fuaddanial2029
      @fuaddanial2029 Рік тому +1

      @@tb2571 bro they are not anywhere close in both position and ability. Messi plays a False 9, where Robben is a pure winger. Apart from the earlier years where Messi would play as a pure winger, at his peak Messi plays centrally in the attack mid position. In any case, Robben doesnt have the passing ability Messi has to even have the same playstyle.

    • @mikeisfenomeno
      @mikeisfenomeno 5 місяців тому

      won another

  • @kiyetojakhalu3160
    @kiyetojakhalu3160 3 роки тому +900

    91 GOALS IN A SINGLE CALANDER YEAR.
    " If u make RECORD make it UNBREKABLE "
    -LIONEL MESSI

    • @zacharybasil
      @zacharybasil 3 роки тому +60

      In 2014 his role changed to be more as a playmaker. Imagine if his role maintained as goalscorer he would score more

    • @Jolaniii
      @Jolaniii 2 роки тому +16

      iniesta and xavi carried him lol

    • @kabi2290
      @kabi2290 2 роки тому +66

      @@Jolaniii pendu carried by kroos modrich

    • @Jolaniii
      @Jolaniii 2 роки тому +8

      @@kabi2290 so kroos and modric are better than xavi and iniesta?

    • @SRi1023SRi
      @SRi1023SRi 2 роки тому +53

      @@Jolaniii 🤣 messi can do playmaking like xavi and Iniesta. Ronaldo is nothing without goals.
      In 2012 go and check who is 3rd best playmaker and cry. Ronaldo is really carried by Modric and kroos

  • @Ivanasbel
    @Ivanasbel 3 роки тому +2385

    Now that Messi won his first major title for Argentina, there’s absolutely no room for debate. G.O.A.T!

    • @alihammoud5250
      @alihammoud5250 3 роки тому +251

      Ronaldo ended it 2016

    • @arpitverma5720
      @arpitverma5720 3 роки тому +42

      @@alihammoud5250 don't agree with either but nice comment 😂

    • @nikosofidemporas
      @nikosofidemporas 3 роки тому +331

      @@alihammoud5250 No the difference is Ronaldo's international trophy was the only thing that kept him in the conversation since almost in every other aspect possible he is way behind Messi.
      But now that Messi has his and actually has a WC final to add to this too there is just nothing else the CR7 fans have to say to make him look better.

    • @alihammoud5250
      @alihammoud5250 3 роки тому +59

      @@nikosofidemporas hahahah man you are so dumb, maybe have forgotten about a torunament called champions League ? I just want you to look upp goals scored in the knockout stages in the cl and you Will se a big difference between the players hahahah. One of the is allways clutch and comebacks a game when it really mathers while the other becomes a ghost, just look at the last final against brazil Hahahha the first ”good opponent” in the whole tournament and in the match that he is supposed to step up in he becomes a ghost. You could clearly see that neymar was the best player on the pitch hahaha and messi one of the worst. Lastly i Will say look upp international goals scored against top 30 world ranked teams in competitions and not friendlys you Will se what comes up and you Will also ser that messi has not score a singel goal against top 10 world ranked team ahhahaha and last he has not scored a singel goal against brasil expept 5 goals in friendly games

    • @mgu-vx4ib
      @mgu-vx4ib 3 роки тому +152

      @@alihammoud5250 Great, you cherry picked the UCL, the knockout stages and the Brazil game and totally left out all the great accomplishments this man did. Watch the video and make an argument based off of that. Don't cherry pick a certain time or competition. Grab both their resumes career wide and compare. Then come back to me with that nonsense.

  • @cripbk2147
    @cripbk2147 2 роки тому +149

    Debate is over
    Messi won
    2021 Copa America
    2022 Finalissima
    2022 World Cup
    2024 Copa America
    He has 8 B’oro and 6 European golden boot
    He has 2 golden balls now. He the GOAT

    • @rayharley2959
      @rayharley2959 2 роки тому +14

      That's true, bro)) Pristiano penaldo fans are in tears

    • @CeuAzulll
      @CeuAzulll 2 роки тому

      ​@@miyamoto5161Pelé

    • @cripbk2147
      @cripbk2147 2 роки тому +6

      @@miyamoto5161nah ,Maradona is second place. Closest to Messi.

    • @vewayy
      @vewayy 2 роки тому

      @@cripbk2147 bro…

    • @cripbk2147
      @cripbk2147 2 роки тому +9

      @@vewayy CR7 isnt even top 5
      1.Messi
      2.Maradona
      3.R9/Romário
      4.Di Stefano(He could be#3)
      5.Ronaldinho or Pele
      6.Cruyff
      7.Zidane
      8.CR7

  • @Jeff_2x
    @Jeff_2x 2 роки тому +1114

    Who’s here after Messi won the World Cup?

    • @lupakochakulimba754
      @lupakochakulimba754 2 роки тому +11

      We hear to prove Ronaldo is better bro

    • @black.sasuke.uchiha
      @black.sasuke.uchiha 2 роки тому +97

      And Copa América, I noticed this must’ve been a while ago because in the video he said Messi has never won the title.

    • @alecrappa3430
      @alecrappa3430 2 роки тому +2

      Ronaldo is better

    • @markxnzz9840
      @markxnzz9840 2 роки тому +78

      @@alecrappa3430 Ronaldo isn't even better than Mbappe 💀

    • @valvevac-systemchecker3773
      @valvevac-systemchecker3773 2 роки тому +45

      @@alecrappa3430 at warming the bench? We know, bro is so good that no clubs wants him

  • @3ownsu
    @3ownsu 3 роки тому +125

    Funny… the only category Ronaldo is “better” than Messi in isn’t even an individual category, it’s about the teams they play on.

    • @largol33t1
      @largol33t1 2 роки тому +21

      Even in that category, Messi is excellent at setting up the ball for a teammate to score a goal and many of them do.

    • @Michiiigring
      @Michiiigring 2 роки тому +18

      even for winning now that he won copa and finalisima you could argue for messi
      imo messi is clearer of ronaldo than jordan of lebron
      that shouldnt be an insult to anyone but pls dont ever try to put anyone close to messi

    • @yes-wh1zj
      @yes-wh1zj 2 роки тому +14

      @@Michiiigring I genuinely don't understand how people still think it's a comparison

    • @enio3698
      @enio3698 2 роки тому +3

      @@Michiiigring no offense to messi but if finalisima existed before ronaldo would have also won it against chile

    • @jayantsaini3803
      @jayantsaini3803 2 роки тому +8

      @@enio3698 he lost to chile in fifa federation cup

  • @19_pisces_85
    @19_pisces_85 3 роки тому +450

    I often get in this conversation but I don't know how to argue that Messi is a better player... now I have a video to show my friends

  • @LM-wd3ly
    @LM-wd3ly 3 роки тому +732

    This is a debate that should have never existed. It's the media that fired this up. Messi has always been the better player

    • @emmanuelgazal9589
      @emmanuelgazal9589 3 роки тому +8

      This is what i hate its close otherwise there wouldn't be a debate

    • @LM-wd3ly
      @LM-wd3ly 3 роки тому +80

      Emmanuel Gazal you are right but there are some ronaldo fans who actually think ronaldo is better which annoys me.

    • @sadhuman7660
      @sadhuman7660 3 роки тому +90

      @@LM-wd3ly I think most Ronaldo fans like him more because of his lifestyle, not his football. Maybe that's why he has more followers on social media too.

    • @Kakashi-ck9tp
      @Kakashi-ck9tp 3 роки тому +11

      @@sadhuman7660 makes no sense

    • @Kakashi-ck9tp
      @Kakashi-ck9tp 3 роки тому +36

      Messi is better but not in every aspect of the game, there are certain fields where Ronaldo shines more than Messi

  • @ikedi6005
    @ikedi6005 3 роки тому +890

    This video is criminally underrated. Earned you a subscriber.

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +18

      🙌🙌

    • @michaeltrumph121
      @michaeltrumph121 3 роки тому +6

      @@GoodlyRogue
      Your video is very good and objective, yet at the same time it's garbage.
      When looking at statistics, how can you not take into account the era in which someone competed, rules, teammates, opposition, playing conditions (pitches, boots, ball), position he played in etc.
      How can you even compare a midfielder like Maradona with forwards ?!???
      It was a million times harder to score in his era.

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +47

      @@michaeltrumph121 I understand your point. Last season, a 33 years old messi played as a midfielder for the first time of his career, he scored 31 goals! Being an attacking midflielder, Maradona’s career high is 23 goals, he simply never was, statistically, as good as Messi!
      As for assists, for a career, it’s closer but messi still has 100 more… Also, as you pointed out, the average goals per game changed since Maradona best goalscoring season. Only by 15% though. So, if we would adjust Maradona's career high to today's goalscoring frenzies, he would have "26.45" goals in his best season? The average sport changed a lot in the last 40 years, but football isn't the best example. Maradona simply did not play his career the way he played the 86 World Cup! Thanks for your comment!

    • @michaeltrumph121
      @michaeltrumph121 3 роки тому +5

      @@GoodlyRogue
      _I understand your point_
      Your reply doesn't depict that. You still haven't taken into account many of those things I said.
      Stats comparisons are only valid when you compare players that played in the same era, same league, same playing position, with roughly the same talent to help them and roughly the same opposition.
      *1.* Maradona played in a much more brutal era, where defenders could break legs.
      *2.* Maradona played in a much more competitive league, and not for the best team. Napoli was battling relegation before he came along and made them champions. To put things into perspective, it's like Messi playing for Elche and beating the likes of Barca, Real and Athletico for the title.
      *3.* Messi's teammates at Barcelona have always been a million times better than Maradona's at Napoli. We now live in the era of superteams, a privileged few top teams that buy up the best talent out there.
      *4.* In the second half of the 80s Serie A, a win was only worth 2 points. That clearly diminished the incentive for a team to go for a win.
      *5.* Football was way more defensive back then, it was harder to score.
      Just look at the top goalscorers for a season in 80s Serie A:
      80-81, Roberto Pruzzo with 18 goals.
      81-82, Roberto Pruzzo with 15 goals.
      82-83, Platini with 16 goals.
      83-84 , Platini with 20 goals.
      84-85, Platini with 18 goals.
      85-86, Roberto Pruzzo with 19 goals.
      86-87, Paolo Virdis with 17 goals .
      87-88, Maradona with 15 goals.
      88-89, Also Serena with 22 goals.
      *The lowest was 15 for a season. Can you imagine anyone nowadays winning the top scorer award with just 15 goals ?!!!!!*
      Now compare that to 2010's La Liga:
      2010-11, CR7 with 40 goals.
      2011-12, Messi with 50 goals.
      2012-13, Messi with 46 goals.
      2013-14, CR7 with 31 goals.
      2014-15, CR7 with 48 goals.
      2015-16, Luis Suárez with 40 goals.
      2016-17, Messi with 37 goals.
      2017-18, Messi with 34 goals.
      2018-19, Messi with 36 goals.
      2019-20, Messi with 25 goals.
      *6.* Go play on a bumpy and often muddy and uneven pitch, with heavy boots, balls, against butchers and then come back to me. You will realize that scoring, dribbling, passing is way harder.
      _As for assists, for a career, it’s closer but messi still has 100 more_
      Messi has also played way more games, 984 compared to Maradona's 695. And again, for a much better team, with far better teammates, in an offense oriented era, with better playing conditions, nutrition, training etc.
      Assist depend a big deal on teammates. You can provide countless perfect passes per game, if your teammates are poor, they won't convert them.
      _Also, as you pointed out, the average goals per game changed since Maradona best goalscoring season. Only by 15% though. So, if we would adjust Maradona's career high to today's goalscoring frenzies, he would have "26.45" goals in his best season?_
      Yes, he might have around 26, but that's if he plays for Napoli.
      Put him in Barcelona, in a more advanced position, with Xavi and Iniesta behind him to feed him passes, with the protection from the refs they have now - and the story changes completely.
      _The average sport changed a lot in the last 40 years, but football isn't the best example. Maradona simply did not play his career the way he played the 86 World Cup! Thanks for your comment!_
      *Completely agree with you, but players should be judged based on what they achieve in their own era, not by comparing stats with players from other eras.*
      *Maradona proved himself at international level, by leading an average Argentina to the World Cup, Messi has not. And please don't mention 2014, cause Messi didn't do anything after the group stage, where he barely scored against weak teams*
      *Maradona turned an poor Napoli team into champions. Messi has has an all star Barca at his disposal*
      *Maradona could adapt to any league, team, playing system. Messi has never ventured outside Barcelona*
      *Maradona was a born leader that captained every team he played for, and could even make dogs play better. Messi is shy and introvert*
      *Maradona could handle pressure, Messi has crumbled countless times under it*

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +31

      @@michaeltrumph121
      Wow! I'm stunned by your research. You've done an amazing job. I agree with (almost) everything you said. Sadly, the longer part of my response will be about our differences, which are minimal in the grand scheme of things.
      Firstly, has football gotten less physical? Statistics on broken legs aren't that common. 😂 But, surprisingly, we are in the peak of football injuries. Only today, more penalties are being called.
      Secondly, looking at the differences in goalscoring. I maintain the fact that players score 15% more goals. It's just that Messi and Ronaldo (and possibly Suarez) created a distortion. We cannot take goalscorers like these guys for granted. They don't come in every decade. Besides, if we look beyond them, we end up with names like Falcao, Aspas, Negredo, Moreno, etc. Thereby, the 15% increase ends up making sense.
      Thirdly, it's true that we live in the superteam era, but with all due respect to Xavi and Iniesta, they have respectively assisted 5 and 9 of Messi's 91 goals season. Messi is known for creating his own shots (similar to Maradona). FiveThirtyEight also showed that Messi is more clinical when he's unassisted. fivethirtyeight.com/features/lionel-messi-is-impossible/
      Furthermore, even if Laliga is not the Champions League, his GPG average in Laliga is indistinguishable from his in the Champions League. (0.81 in both)
      The only thing that irritates me about your comment, which is also specifically why I've made that video is the emotional takes (in Messi just like Ronaldo's part). Football is the only sport where people argue with lines like « he could handle pressure better », « he was tougher mentally » or « he was more determined ». Why is it like that? All of the other sports' arguments are almost strictly statiscally based. You can't put a number on « willpower », « determination », « mental strength », « pressure handling », etc. Moreover, pressure isn't different in basketball, hockey, american football and baseball. Why do we keep saying that in football? Anybody who's ever played a sport a a high level knows that there isn't such things, because if there were, you wouln't have made out of the little leagues.
      In any case, thanks for your comment again! 😊

  • @basantapant198
    @basantapant198 3 роки тому +460

    Most of the players wants to be like CR7 because they know it’s possible but to become Leo is impossible.

    • @psg7565
      @psg7565 2 роки тому +23

      Nobody will become like Ronaldo you must respect him he is the 2nd GOAT behind Leo Messi 🐐 !! 🙃

    • @IrishGuysScarf
      @IrishGuysScarf 2 роки тому +39

      @@psg7565 It's entirely feasible that a player may become like Ronaldo. He's sublime but I wouldn't register him within my top 3 or even top 5. Messi quite literally the perfect attacking player, he can score goals through any way (yes, even headers.)

    • @psg7565
      @psg7565 2 роки тому +1

      @@IrishGuysScarf Not putting Ronaldo in your top 5 makes you lose all credibility and it just shows your hate or your lack of culture on Ronaldo dirty mentally retarded !!!

    • @mysteriousmessenger3258
      @mysteriousmessenger3258 2 роки тому +1

      @@psg7565 cap

    • @psg7565
      @psg7565 2 роки тому

      @@mysteriousmessenger3258 ??!!

  • @jeewssam8418
    @jeewssam8418 3 роки тому +1001

    When Ronaldo scores a goal we say "WOW!"
    When Messi scores a goal we say "HOW?!"

    • @t.valtorguhgen6512
      @t.valtorguhgen6512 3 роки тому +22

      True!!!

    • @arjuntb1204
      @arjuntb1204 3 роки тому +3

      💖

    • @bestboy4320
      @bestboy4320 3 роки тому +13

      @Mario López well i Don't but i also love Ronaldo

    • @shilpaprajapati4801
      @shilpaprajapati4801 3 роки тому +37

      @Mario López like that flying header, bicycle kick, wc free kick, etc...! And also all the last moment deciding goals... 🙌

    • @shilpaprajapati4801
      @shilpaprajapati4801 3 роки тому +18

      @Mario López CR7 may have scored many simple looking goals, but so many were literally in last 5-10 minutes and decided the match result. He is surely the most clutch player ever... 🙌

  • @danielschriever4531
    @danielschriever4531 2 роки тому +161

    Still the best and most objective comparison between those 2. Also explained why it's hard to compare old era (Maradona&Pele) to new era (Messi&Ronaldo). By far the best GOAT comparison out there.
    PS: I guess category "Winner" needs an update.

    • @sreddi83
      @sreddi83 2 роки тому +28

      @@wa57s577 cry more

    • @jackoplumkin6412
      @jackoplumkin6412 2 роки тому +28

      It's 4-0 now. Crazy times we live in

    • @dasurmel1424
      @dasurmel1424 2 роки тому +10

      @@wa57s577 its actually biased for cr7. he didnt checked if the trophies werde deserved and which part the player took in winning them. the euros 2016 was a joke i would consider not counting that at all and at least 2 balon dors for cr7 were not deserved. and dont forget the video doesnt weight the individual skill of the players very high. ronaldo is actually worse at everything but headers and penalties. if you look back in history you can easily find at least 5 strikers that were just better than him at most stuff but didnt had modern medical treatment or knowledge and still have better eyetest and stats. ronaldo is very good but if youre being honest not in the top 10 of all time.

    • @noroozjan8300
      @noroozjan8300 2 роки тому +5

      We need an updated version of this.

    • @azulgirmay937
      @azulgirmay937 2 роки тому

      @@dasurmel1424wooo you’re a fucking moron Ronaldo has better stats than any player except for maybe messi

  • @temurikakachiya5094
    @temurikakachiya5094 3 роки тому +206

    Pele was good so was maradona..my grandpa got to see them both..his favourite player was Zidane but when he saw Messi he said Messi is the best player he ever saw

    • @Cesar-zl3de
      @Cesar-zl3de 2 роки тому +2

      Don't worry your great grand children will see one greater than Messi.

    • @temurikakachiya5094
      @temurikakachiya5094 2 роки тому +24

      @@Cesar-zl3de I doubt that..Messi stats, accomplishments, accolades, dribbling, passing IQ, Shooting IQ is level that won't be reached..I give a 1% chance..maybe not even that

    • @deadchannel288
      @deadchannel288 2 роки тому

      @@temurikakachiya5094 too bad they didn’t see ronaldo

    • @carmelomalacalza8981
      @carmelomalacalza8981 2 роки тому

      You grandpa didn’t really understand this sport.’ He saw pele and maradona and his favorite player was zidane? Common that just ridiculous, i never got to see pele but i seen maradona and he was the best player of all time better than pele cr7 and messi and obviously way better than zidane.’ Cr7 is the best striker along with ronaldo the brasilian player

    • @temurikakachiya5094
      @temurikakachiya5094 2 роки тому +7

      @@carmelomalacalza8981 I don't know if you're slow,but I said his favorite, not who he thought was the best ever..
      Messi and cr7 are by far the best two players of all time
      Brazilian Ronaldo was half the time injured..I could care less about what ifs..I see the level of talent, consistency and don't even let me talk about the stats please..
      In my eyes maradona was better than pele as well.

  • @kshitij7304
    @kshitij7304 5 місяців тому +13

    Messi so goated that now he's far better than what he was in this video

  • @animeshpande1915
    @animeshpande1915 3 роки тому +914

    "Messi is just that Asian kid who is always better than you" facts😂

    • @thuypham-kt2or
      @thuypham-kt2or 3 роки тому +3

      No, no I dont agree with you An Asian kid like in Vietnam , my country is not better than anyone since they are educated in communist country

    • @GjilanE
      @GjilanE 3 роки тому +44

      @@thuypham-kt2or just a joke brother

    • @Jasim_1
      @Jasim_1 3 роки тому +13

      @@thuypham-kt2or ruh bro calm down Just a joke

    • @maaamosiyarabot8003
      @maaamosiyarabot8003 3 роки тому +2

      Haha great joke.. Messi is better than ronaldo 🤣what a joke..

    • @Jasim_1
      @Jasim_1 3 роки тому +45

      @@maaamosiyarabot8003 keep crying facts are infront of you

  • @VijaySingh-wz5xb
    @VijaySingh-wz5xb 3 роки тому +1117

    It's not that Ronaldo is bad, it's just that Messi is really too good -- that sums it up 🙌🙌🙌

    • @user-jn9rj7km9o
      @user-jn9rj7km9o 3 роки тому +46

      Yeah Ronaldo obv isnt bad mans one of the greatest to ever grace the game 5 ballondors is no joke just 2nd highest , that too just 1 less than messi and he even switched alot of clubs and actually he isnt that gifted like some of the others even Neymar is more gifted than him but Ronaldo has 5 ballondors and Neymar not its incredible how such hard work simply made him surpass alot of natural gifted players by such a huge margin but yeah Messi is simply the GOAT

    • @iqiyi1928
      @iqiyi1928 3 роки тому +13

      @@user-jn9rj7km9o FACTS. Neymar is criminally underrated

    • @soft-data
      @soft-data 3 роки тому

      ua-cam.com/video/jhj5Mzx6LMw/v-deo.html

    • @2kmichaeljordan438
      @2kmichaeljordan438 3 роки тому +11

      @@user-jn9rj7km9o because neymar has the talent but doesn’t put the work in. Messi and Rolando have simply dominated the sport for too long for neymar to get a chance at the ballondor, not mentioning that the competition under Messi and Rolando is fucking insane

    • @jonathanisrael1707
      @jonathanisrael1707 3 роки тому +3

      @@user-jn9rj7km9o He got all those awards just to hype up competition against Messi for financial and marketing purposes.

  • @467076
    @467076 2 роки тому +52

    After the 2022 World Cup, Messi is the G.O.A.T of G.O.A.T’s

    • @plm6523
      @plm6523 5 місяців тому +1

      He was already the goat by a long distance

    • @467076
      @467076 5 місяців тому +1

      @@plm6523 I definitely wouldn't say long distance lol there has certainly been other players to the likes of him. Many greats in this sport.

  • @patslash8367
    @patslash8367 2 роки тому +104

    Now after Messi won the world cup it's 4-0 for Messi in this comparison.

  • @alexanderkhandolishvili5336
    @alexanderkhandolishvili5336 3 роки тому +446

    The stat that should also be considered was their peak level of play, Messi's peak was 2012 when he scored 91 goals and made 29 assists in 69 games, while Ronaldo's best year was 2013 scoring 69 and assisting 15 in 59 games, meaning that Messi's peak was also better in terms of numbers

    • @A123-c6o
      @A123-c6o 3 роки тому +43

      Messi's peak was 2012, of course in goalscoring...11,15,19 all were great years for him.

    • @minhtringuyen3835
      @minhtringuyen3835 3 роки тому +50

      even not in his prime Messi still dominates individually

    • @Jasim_1
      @Jasim_1 3 роки тому +4

      @@minhtringuyen3835 yup like this year

    • @gabrielgonzalez6456
      @gabrielgonzalez6456 3 роки тому +3

      Ronaldo will probably have the longer career. It might be too soon to have this debate.

    • @A123-c6o
      @A123-c6o 3 роки тому +5

      @@gabrielgonzalez6456 Don't think people will care or media will boost this rivalry if Messi wins Balon d or this year. Media will focus on younger talents like Haaland and Mbappe and set up new things which attracts fanboys.

  • @Callmeab50
    @Callmeab50 3 роки тому +596

    Idk why people call Messi a playmaker 😂 Man has more goal to game ratio too. Man is a goal soccer and playmaker at the exact same time. Simply the GOAT 🐐
    He has a world trophy now

    • @michaeltrumph121
      @michaeltrumph121 3 роки тому +1

      Pele is the GOAT

    • @Indra-2024
      @Indra-2024 3 роки тому +78

      @@michaeltrumph121 🤣🤣🤣

    • @michaeltrumph121
      @michaeltrumph121 3 роки тому +2

      @@Indra-2024
      Laugh like a idiot all you want, that's the truth.

    • @SuperBowlcountdown1
      @SuperBowlcountdown1 3 роки тому +57

      @@michaeltrumph121 Nope Pele is the greatest of his time, but the game has advanced wayyyy to much for him to be considered the best now. I watched his world cup games and the teams are laughably bad, like womans world cup level. They dont defend in formation, bad positioning, they dont close down spaces/passing lane, no pressing tactics ect, and the goalkeepers were a joke, playing in quicksand ect. Players back then didnt take care of thier bodies or train properly, and it showed on the pitch. Pele has the greatest legacy tho, more than messi/maradona.

    • @michaeltrumph121
      @michaeltrumph121 3 роки тому +1

      @@SuperBowlcountdown1
      Players should be judged based on what they achieved in their own era.
      That's why Pele is the greatest, not cause he'd still be good enough nowadays.

  • @omchriss
    @omchriss 3 роки тому +1313

    Messi now has more free kick goals than Ronaldo 😏

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +201

      You are right

    • @hudakhoirul7073
      @hudakhoirul7073 3 роки тому +16

      Nicee

    • @ilansimon3962
      @ilansimon3962 3 роки тому +105

      Also won the copa

    • @Rs-bs1rg
      @Rs-bs1rg 3 роки тому +16

      Messi takes like more than double the amount of freekick attempts each season than ronaldo. Theres no surprise he has more

    • @sozaabbbb
      @sozaabbbb 3 роки тому +183

      @@Rs-bs1rg haven't you seen the statistics? He has almost double conversion rate than Ronaldo 🤷🏻‍♂️

  • @raider1297
    @raider1297 3 роки тому +140

    Consider this video was made before Messi won Copa América while winning the Golden Ball and Golden Boot of the tournament as well as being the top assister. Also consider the "winning" point seems sort of a mercy point for CR7 since Messi has actually won more team trophies than CR7. Consider this video (like it's explained in it) can't award points for unmeasurable things like that play where Messi driblles past 4 guys and sets up a big and easy scoring chance for his team while CR7 just doesn't do much for chance creation, he's more of a finisher.
    I don't know how anyone can watch this video and still think they're at the same level or that CR7 is better. We should respect, admire and enjoy both, but at the same time we should be able to acknowledge Messi being the GOAT and CR7 one of the best, just not the GOAT. It's just being fair. Even when you see the answers from the pros themselves it's overwhelmingly Messi. Who would know better than the people who actually play and coach the game at the highest level for a living? Not the fans, that's for sure.
    I think that as time passes and videos like these are watched even more and fanboyism declines a bit we'll be able to recognize Messi as the GOAT more universally. It's already clear but I guess now it's more about time showing the inevitable.

    • @ThePapaupa12
      @ThePapaupa12 3 роки тому +11

      i love both messi and ronaldo i watch every game when they play and i must say you are right if you want to start this compare topic messi is just better i will cry in tears the day he retires

    • @trogmaster6579
      @trogmaster6579 3 роки тому +15

      And messi just won the ballon dor

    • @user-lr2iy7mc7w
      @user-lr2iy7mc7w 2 роки тому +8

      We have to keep in mind that football is at the end of the day a team sport that requires a lot of different positions and skillsets to come together in order to function and win titles. Therefore the greatest players are in my opinion those that contribute the most to the team "working" and elevating their teammates. In that regard I have never seen a more prolific finisher be such a teamplayer in the way messi is. His contribution to the offensive game of his teams is off the charts incredible.

    • @maximilianmaier3950
      @maximilianmaier3950 2 роки тому +3

      Ronaldo simply is the better player.
      One big difference between the two that barely gets mentioned is that for much of his career Barcelona built their entire team around Messi. He was the one big center piece of their offense, which greatly helped Messi's stats, but whenever Messi was injured or an opponent managed to shut Messi down, Barcelona struggled heavily, because their entire system revolved around Messi. Without Messi the team often looked pretty dysfunctional, even though their roster was loaded with skill and talent, just like Real Madrid's.
      Real on the other hand did not allow themselves to become as dependent on one single player. Ronaldo was by far their best player, but they did not build their entire system around him, like Barca did with Messi.

    • @danielvera9199
      @danielvera9199 2 роки тому +10

      @@maximilianmaier3950 To be a big center piece at 17-20 y. o. is a thing that only THE GOAT is capable. You are sure that you or me could be starters in that great Barcelona? Whatever, you sees the Barcelona of last years?

  • @traguy2625
    @traguy2625 2 роки тому +17

    This world cup win ain't even nail in coffin this is like putting flower on grave after 10 years person death

    • @rayharley2959
      @rayharley2959 2 роки тому

      HAHAHHA that was good one, bro)))

    • @vil.727
      @vil.727 Рік тому

      For people who actually watch football it's like seeing a body decay and pouring even more soil into their graves

    • @willhaack6094
      @willhaack6094 6 місяців тому

      @@vil.727 cringiest shit ive ever seen. why are you so bias

  • @adesokangm
    @adesokangm 2 роки тому +114

    Messi has now won the World Cup🤩🤩🤩
    He now has more international trophies (Copa America, Finalissima and World Cup).

    • @cripbk2147
      @cripbk2147 2 роки тому +29

      In just one year, Messi won all the important trophies for Argentina just like that.

    • @uacari
      @uacari 2 роки тому +12

      @@cripbk2147 EXACTLY. and now we hope he can win the ucl with psg so he can shut those ronaldo fans once and for all.

    • @cripbk2147
      @cripbk2147 2 роки тому +14

      @@uacari lmao he don’t need too. The World Cup ended the debate 100%

    • @cesargonzalez3599
      @cesargonzalez3599 2 роки тому +3

      @@uacari winning the UCL with PSG would be insane. After the World Cup at this point that would just be like completing a side-quest 😅

    • @nf9098
      @nf9098 2 роки тому +2

      @@uacari i want 1 more UCL for him before he retire cuz its been a long time since he won one. about 7 years thats a long time

  • @city6291
    @city6291 2 роки тому +43

    Messi saw this and went and won the copa america and world cup LOL

  • @anwarcharfaray7069
    @anwarcharfaray7069 2 роки тому +108

    I have watched this after Messi has won the Copa delarey and winning his 7th Ballon, and I am happy to say that all the stats available will still not justify how Messi does what he does, he is a Mystical Creature of note.

    • @lamp6121
      @lamp6121 Рік тому +4

      And now Messi won the Copa America, Finalissima and World cup, GOAT things 🐐

  • @willymacharia5614
    @willymacharia5614 3 роки тому +198

    Saying ronaldo is better is always followed by a need to explain yourself. But saying messi, everything kinda falls in place! Messi is GOAT.

    • @alihammoud5250
      @alihammoud5250 3 роки тому +14

      not at all

    • @ehanbhairakdar
      @ehanbhairakdar 3 роки тому +2

      No, you need to explain for both, in the United days ronaldo was more of everything he said in the video, that’d why he didn’t score that much. Not to forget how Ronaldo was robbed or a 6th balon d or.

    • @dadwithmilk3740
      @dadwithmilk3740 3 роки тому +8

      @@ehanbhairakdar and how 2013 ballon d'or of Ronaldo was a scandal

    • @willymacharia5614
      @willymacharia5614 3 роки тому +27

      @@ehanbhairakdar he wasn't robbed. It didn't belong to him in the first place. Just because he won the champions league doesn't make him the winner automatically. In that season, messi won laliga, copa del rey, and spanish super cup. He was also the leading goalscorer in all europe, provided the most assists, most key passes, most crosses and most chances created, only to be ranked 5th. Winning the UCL doesn't make you best. Ask virgil.

    • @willymacharia5614
      @willymacharia5614 3 роки тому +7

      @@dadwithmilk3740 Frank ribbery should have won it.

  • @durjoybarua5341
    @durjoybarua5341 3 роки тому +27

    This video should blow up. Great video.

  • @kenkaneki2842
    @kenkaneki2842 7 місяців тому +9

    If u have been watching full 90 mins football for the past 17 yrs , u already know that this was just a forced debate that shouldn't have existed.
    Messi was and will always be miles clear than Cristiano Ronaldo.

    • @captainfalconmain6576
      @captainfalconmain6576 7 місяців тому

      w

    • @anaftbl
      @anaftbl 7 місяців тому

      you would think so if you've been following football since past 10 years
      someone who has followed football since 2006-2008 would prefer ronaldo
      personally i think, ronaldo is a better athlete and messi is a better footballer

    • @amai-w8f
      @amai-w8f 2 місяці тому +1

      @@anaftbl Being a better athlete means nothing though.

  • @richardanwanakak5576
    @richardanwanakak5576 5 місяців тому +11

    You need to do an updated version of this video. Messi would outshine ronaldo in winning

  • @CR7andMessithegoat-c8l
    @CR7andMessithegoat-c8l 10 місяців тому +11

    If messi played for real Madrid he probably win 6 UCL

  • @Ivanasbel
    @Ivanasbel 3 роки тому +381

    I have never seen such a well produce and prepared video like the one I just watched. I can’t wait for this video to gain traction so that more people can experience your level of quality. Keep it up! Messi the GOAT!

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +11

      Wow! Thank you so much!

    • @raheimbowen8868
      @raheimbowen8868 3 роки тому +2

      no jokes bro. well put together and perfect

    • @whenisdinner2137
      @whenisdinner2137 3 роки тому +1

      Its based off a video comparing Jordan and LeBron in basketball that is of similar quality.

    • @toji267
      @toji267 3 роки тому +1

      @@GoodlyRogue who can paolo maldini win 6 UCL while his transfermarkt show only 5??????

    • @nelsonlourenco3781
      @nelsonlourenco3781 3 роки тому +1

      Really,? He doesn’t even mention the header game of Ronaldo, who is the best header of all time and makes a much more complete player than Messi.

  • @mathewhaukongo4303
    @mathewhaukongo4303 3 роки тому +49

    Johan Cruyff:"There's a difference between a great goalscorer and a great football player "

    • @pedrovitorut
      @pedrovitorut 2 роки тому +2

      And what's the point for you to put this Cruyff sentence here? Meaning what? That CR7 is only a great goal scorer and not a great football player?

    • @WildFactsDaily101
      @WildFactsDaily101 2 роки тому +4

      @@pedrovitorut no but messi is the better football player no doubt

    • @tyleristhemc
      @tyleristhemc 2 роки тому

      @@WildFactsDaily101 i can agree he’s better but he is not greater. There are still more factors of being “greater” rather than “better”

    • @SwerfXD
      @SwerfXD 2 роки тому +1

      @@tyleristhemc like ? Scoring penalties ?

    • @Dinozor3
      @Dinozor3 Рік тому +1

      @@pedrovitorut exactly. He is only great goalscorer and nothing more

  • @borismuca9643
    @borismuca9643 5 місяців тому +8

    He was the goat even before two back to back Copa America's and a World Cup.

  • @sarahhenri-christine6423
    @sarahhenri-christine6423 3 роки тому +345

    Ronaldo just turns me on but Messi would get me to heaven with his amazing passes

  • @raghavmohan1735
    @raghavmohan1735 3 роки тому +348

    I LOVE THIS VIDEO....it is unbiased and statistically accurate...prefect blend and impressive execution

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +15

      I appreciate that! Thank you!

    • @noroozjan8300
      @noroozjan8300 3 роки тому

      Who made this video?

    • @raghavmohan1735
      @raghavmohan1735 3 роки тому +5

      Now Messi has won Copa America as well!!

    • @akcsamiru
      @akcsamiru 3 роки тому +3

      Yes but i gotta say, the video doesnt mention the assists. Maradona played 490 games and scored 260 goals and 220 assissts.
      Messi in 900(ish) games he scored 740(ish)goals and 350 assissts.
      Messi is the GOAT for me but totally misses out on maradona, sorry man

    • @_.LZ._
      @_.LZ._ 3 роки тому

      @@akcsamiru i agree on that that was my thought too, messi is better than diego but that's not the right way to prove it

  • @vusimatimbe1938
    @vusimatimbe1938 3 роки тому +91

    This video is so well executed, so well edited, plus the arguments this guy makes are so comprehensive. I hope he makes more, there just aren't enough people enjoying this and loving it.

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +7

      Wow! Thank you!

    • @hannasaad495
      @hannasaad495 3 роки тому +1

      @@GoodlyRogue you deserve more subscribers man!

    • @whenisdinner2137
      @whenisdinner2137 3 роки тому +1

      ua-cam.com/video/tl3mR6eoEa8/v-deo.html he used this as reference. Still good points but he could have given the original some props.

    • @noruzbaloch3486
      @noruzbaloch3486 2 роки тому

      We need an updated video. Pls upload an update.

    • @eoghanmatthews5771
      @eoghanmatthews5771 2 роки тому

      @@GoodlyRogue bro great vid and I'm so happy I came across it!

  • @greasy_beefcake
    @greasy_beefcake 2 роки тому +24

    Time to revisit the winning category

  • @kevin_annan
    @kevin_annan 3 роки тому +45

    Most comprehensive video on the Messi vs Ronaldo debate I’ve seen. Great work

  • @hovercopter1949
    @hovercopter1949 2 роки тому +21

    Im watching this after Messi won a Copa America, Finalísimo, and the World Cup, so I think Messi takes the GOAT criteria in all four categories now

    • @cripbk2147
      @cripbk2147 2 роки тому +1

      Facts. Messi is now getting compared to Maradona & Pele now🤣😂

    • @thunder6676
      @thunder6676 Рік тому +1

      ​@@cripbk2147Messi started being compared to them like 12 years ago.

  • @steves4562
    @steves4562 2 роки тому +120

    The debate is over. It's Messi. He's been to the world cup finals twice and beat the defending champions and won a world cup in maybe the greatest finals match ever.

    • @aryanshah1529
      @aryanshah1529 2 роки тому +29

      The only reason to pick Ronaldo is emotional now. Messi is the goat and it's not close

    • @musadlinimardan4502
      @musadlinimardan4502 2 роки тому +1

      agreed bro.. the best final and Leo Messi no 1 G.O.A.T 😀

  • @nikebrojj
    @nikebrojj 2 роки тому +10

    Watching this after the 2022 World Cup, I think the GOAT debate is for sure settled now that Messi finally has a world title to his name!

  • @adelekedunmininu7098
    @adelekedunmininu7098 3 роки тому +272

    When he said l “at the end of this video, one guy would have the edge”, I knew he was referring to Messi👍🏾

    • @JoeMama-sd2kl
      @JoeMama-sd2kl 3 роки тому +33

      I think pretty much everyone apart from delusional Ronaldo fans

    • @babutukku6303
      @babutukku6303 3 роки тому +3

      it's the hint which refers to ronaldo you pessi fans

    • @QuarkSzz
      @QuarkSzz 3 роки тому +6

      @@babutukku6303 you don't have brain ,good enough to understand whom the youtuber mentioned in his video , just stfu

    • @inurshoes3097
      @inurshoes3097 3 роки тому +2

      Still Ronaldo wins in the most important thing, better throphies

    • @adelekedunmininu7098
      @adelekedunmininu7098 3 роки тому +9

      Lucas Cafuzquez el verdadero goat Still Messi is the best, better individual gameplay. And just so you know, Messi has more trophies

  • @nap0038
    @nap0038 2 роки тому +22

    The greatest and most astonishing FACT of this video is that we may never have someone better than Messi ever again.

    • @McFlashh
      @McFlashh 2 роки тому +3

      People said that when Pele was playing

    • @ajaini1709
      @ajaini1709 2 роки тому +2

      No way Wel ever see another messi

    • @jfedol7760
      @jfedol7760 Рік тому +1

      History always finds a way to repeat itself

    • @amai-w8f
      @amai-w8f Рік тому

      @Nothing-lr3dt The way football develops into an extremely tactical and numbers game we won't get the chance to see someone be greater than Messi. Nobody will be given that much liberty again

  • @shikharbatta2978
    @shikharbatta2978 2 роки тому +26

    Who’s here after Messi’s WC win 🏆

  • @LOL-pb5se
    @LOL-pb5se 3 роки тому +133

    If we look closely at “winning”, Messi has more trophies than Ron
    Just saying

    • @robertmensah2002
      @robertmensah2002 3 роки тому +19

      It is true. But initially they were just emphasizing on int trophy. But messi has under 20 wc, Olympic gold and now a copa america. So where is the argument now?

    • @HeadshotaZ731
      @HeadshotaZ731 3 роки тому +8

      It's kinda close as Ronaldo had more UCL's and I think it's actually irrelevant to bring the trophies into a topic where you're debating who's the better player. Messi have 6 b'ors and 7

    • @anassaeed2392
      @anassaeed2392 3 роки тому +5

      @@HeadshotaZ731 he only has 1 more UCL, but his stats in UCL r crazy but once he retires messi will probably have more

    • @arroe8386
      @arroe8386 3 роки тому +6

      @@HeadshotaZ731 exactly my thought, it doesn't really make sense to evaluate the greatness of a player by the trophies he's won in a team sport

    • @LDKNERO
      @LDKNERO 3 роки тому

      @@arroe8386 yea xd

  • @zeo4481
    @zeo4481 3 роки тому +70

    Messi is better in every concevable metric. You can even make up a metric and Messi would still be better. Or you know-- you can clearly put on a match and see that Messi is better-- whit your eyes instead of counting on any kind of statistic.
    Edit- NOW MESSI HAS WON COPA AMERICA AS WELL . Thats 4-0 gg
    What im saying is that the media made this into a debate. Anyone who consistantly watches football KNOWS w
    that Messi is the best.

    • @petartosevski8994
      @petartosevski8994 3 роки тому +1

      Headers

    • @edd2649
      @edd2649 3 роки тому +1

      Ronaldo is more gifted, Messi dribbling is not flashy but efficient. That sets him apart. Ronaldinho is the best at his peak of all time. Cr7 has just as much impact on the outcome of any given game as Messi

    • @user-lr2iy7mc7w
      @user-lr2iy7mc7w 2 роки тому

      @@edd2649 dude have you watched the video? Ronaldo literally doesn't have the same impact on the team as messi. Ronaldinho is my favourite player ever but his peak was nowhere near as great as messi or ronaldo's. The statistics that messi has in almost all aspects of offensive football skill is incomparable. We have never seen a player as efficient as he is and that's just facts. He doesn't have to be your idol or your favourite player but his greatness is undeniable.

  • @trivialqed
    @trivialqed 2 роки тому +7

    Theres no shame in being the 2nd of all time over legends like Zidane, Pele, R9, Platini... Idk why Ronaldo stans want him to be the overall GOAT when its painfully clear he's not

  • @Jeff_2x
    @Jeff_2x 2 роки тому +4

    Never seen a video age as beautifully as this one.

  • @aryesh2326
    @aryesh2326 3 роки тому +16

    Nations league is not a major international tournament btw

  • @chappiedelicieux3337
    @chappiedelicieux3337 2 роки тому +13

    Who’s here after Messi won the would cup

  • @grinchoi1
    @grinchoi1 3 роки тому +99

    All I need is my 2 eyes to tell me Messi is the greatest player. Now he's even won the Copa America. There is no argument or debate.

    • @c.s1393
      @c.s1393 3 роки тому +12

      Once he wins number 7, the argument is officially dead

    • @user-jn9rj7km9o
      @user-jn9rj7km9o 3 роки тому +2

      @@c.s1393 it was 5-3 earlier too with a 2 lead on messi argument was dead but then Ronaldo suddenly won 2 back to back and leveled it but yeah now with messi winning copa and Ronaldo age catching up I doubt that he will be able to level

    • @c.s1393
      @c.s1393 3 роки тому

      @@user-jn9rj7km9o But if Ronaldo goes to city and wins a treble...

    • @deemoney3362
      @deemoney3362 3 роки тому

      @@c.s1393 daaaaaamn

    • @elpatron4350
      @elpatron4350 3 роки тому

      Ronaldo has a Euros and uefa nations league🤔

  • @cl5rys
    @cl5rys 5 місяців тому +6

    international is even more outdated now, since this video he has won copa america 2021, finalissma 2022, world cup 2022, copa america 2024, and no that di maria has retired finalissma 2025 is unlikely but dont count out messi

  • @yoyo-mp3os
    @yoyo-mp3os 3 роки тому +239

    I am ronaldo fan.. but now i know who messi really is 🔥

    • @ItsThaKingHomie
      @ItsThaKingHomie 3 роки тому +9

      U a ronaldo fan.. Cool Story.

    • @toji267
      @toji267 3 роки тому +2

      I'm just like both they're are great player but I'm messi fan no hate to Ronaldo instead I like his mentality

    • @maaamosiyarabot8003
      @maaamosiyarabot8003 3 роки тому +2

      You are a messi fan you liar💯🤣🤣

    • @ankushkhandar689
      @ankushkhandar689 3 роки тому +1

      Bro u are a true fan... I find very less people like me 🤘🏻🤘🏻

    • @pindertoor8408
      @pindertoor8408 3 роки тому

      And debate over pele is much better than maradona

  • @edgaraggtown
    @edgaraggtown 2 роки тому +8

    Great video, I think as of today Dec 18, 2022, the answer is definitive. Messi is the goat.

  • @IPFGaming
    @IPFGaming 3 роки тому +9

    The amount of work and level of editing you put into this video is just beyond my imagination. Great work dude.

  • @p4pthebaddestmanalltime
    @p4pthebaddestmanalltime 2 роки тому +8

    You know Alex Ferguson once Said : "Statistics are like mini-skirts, shows a lot of things but does not show what is essentially"

    • @NG-gu7dx
      @NG-gu7dx 2 роки тому +3

      Ok then
      Speed - Ronaldo
      Control - Messi
      Vision - Messi
      Playmaking - Messi
      Finishing - Messi
      Dribbling - Messi
      Skills - Ronaldo
      More Versatile - Messi
      Free-Kicks - Messi
      Penalties - Ronaldo
      Headers - Ronaldo
      Weak Foot - Ronaldo
      Creativity - Messi
      Passing - Messi
      Strength - Ronaldo
      These aren't statistics but these are things i noticed throughout their respective careers and you can't disagree with the things I said and if you correct me pls reply.

    • @fkdkfnfnldbjdbfjd7179
      @fkdkfnfnldbjdbfjd7179 2 роки тому +1

      @@p4pthebaddestmanalltime LOL, you mean penalties and tap ins? Such variety. Yeah he can score with both legs, head, that's nice, but that isn't creativity. Messi is the definition of creativity on the pitch with his playmaking abilities, creating chances where there are none.

  • @ga1921
    @ga1921 3 роки тому +23

    Dude, the amount of research you put into this is mind-blowingly satisfying. Subscribed! Can't wait for more content!

  • @chimuchunga4051
    @chimuchunga4051 2 роки тому +11

    I always been saying this , sure ronaldo is a good player but football is much more than just scoring goals . Messi is the complete player, not selfish, can play in almost every position, wide vision, and the most accurate in every part of the pitch and almost never losses the ball.

    • @giannisms1861
      @giannisms1861 2 роки тому +1

      Exactly man. Ronaldo is mostly a goal scorer the last 5-7 years who waits on the box, and even back then he was a goalscorer only who also made runs. There was not much dribbling involved or playmaking. Messi delivers the whole package. And also he is more efficient of a scorer as well. Only a matter of time till messi outscored cristiano.

    • @Just_giuseex
      @Just_giuseex Рік тому

      @@giannisms1861you crazy boy, go watch golf instead of football

    • @Just_giuseex
      @Just_giuseex Рік тому

      Also you

    • @Just_giuseex
      @Just_giuseex Рік тому

      Ronaldo selfish ahaha wtf

  • @lamp6121
    @lamp6121 Рік тому +4

    Now, Messi even has the ''winning'' stat, since he won Copa America, Finalissima and the WORLD CUP, Messi really said ''i won't give you even that one boy'' lmao

  • @mortiephan-gamesfilmstvssp8304
    @mortiephan-gamesfilmstvssp8304 2 роки тому +8

    Now Messi vs Ronaldo 4-0 according to GOAT criteria. Clean sweep thanks to Messi being able to achieve Copa America 2021 and recently World Cup 2022.

  • @klt479
    @klt479 3 роки тому +13

    Let's see, grest striker, great dribbled, great pitch vision, great passer, great free kick shooter, and great play maker. Messi regularly beat 3, 4, and 5 defender to score. Renaldo is simply a great striker. We are lucky to be able to watch them both. However, only Messi stands alone as the GOAT by a huge margin.

  • @axelsanchez6865
    @axelsanchez6865 3 роки тому +24

    I’m here watching this video thinking man this guy must be huge for how amazing this video came out it’s a robbery he deserves way more views and way more likes. Keep up the great work on your stats and unbiased and you’re sure to go big

  • @BeerLicious
    @BeerLicious 3 роки тому +71

    Well,only Reason Cristiano's been considered at the level of Messi is because of his goals Count. Everything else & influence on the Pitch even without scoring , Messi's miles ahead. As an individual , it's hard to find someone as good as him & his tactical influence is much more advanced. You're already 3 players up from your Opponents with Messi, mostly 3 players gaurd him & somehow he still scores & if he doesn't , he'll create. To Win with Messi , all you need is other 10 players to do a decent Job.

  • @csokops
    @csokops 2 роки тому +19

    Proper football fans don’t need to see stats just watch both of them play in their peak and it’s very obvious who the better footballer is.
    Dribbling: Messi
    Passing: Messi
    Finishing: Messi
    Vision: Messi
    IQ: Messi
    Versatility: Messi
    Consistency/longevity: both
    Free Kicks: Messi
    Penalties: Ronaldo
    Individual awards: Messi
    Trophies: Messi
    Messi is a waaaaaay better and far more complete footballer. It’s like what johan cruyff said “Never compare a great goalscorer to a great footballer” and he was 100% spot on. All this coming from an **UNBIASED** Man United supporter. Ronaldo fanboys should stop crying and open their eyes I know these man would stop watching football once Ronaldo retire because most of them aren’t football fans they just like Ronaldo.

    • @de7518
      @de7518 2 роки тому

      you finished me

    • @ItzOzyyy
      @ItzOzyyy 2 роки тому

      True brother

    • @menesebastiao2468
      @menesebastiao2468 2 роки тому +1

      Maybe you shouldn't be a fanboy of a footballer at all and stop comparing two completely different players with arbitrary statistics... Like a normal person

    • @Deano-Dron81
      @Deano-Dron81 2 роки тому +1

      That is kinda bias lol, you’ve just picked attributes you wanted and left out a lot 😂😂

    • @csokops
      @csokops 2 роки тому +1

      @@Deano-Dron81 what footballing attribute did I leave out? Since you’re so smart enlighten me.

  • @tirthankarchakraborty2276
    @tirthankarchakraborty2276 3 роки тому +4

    One of the best comparison statically I have ever seen. Very unbiased comparison. Loved the VAEP concept.

  • @slavdog3180
    @slavdog3180 2 роки тому +10

    I don’t know anything about football/soccer/whatever you call it, but Messi looks like the goat for me

  • @debodatta7398
    @debodatta7398 2 роки тому +9

    2:52 ,Messi won world cup now so he takes the international spot win.

  • @markthomas6227
    @markthomas6227 2 роки тому +7

    Ronaldo fans the type to see this and then watch Messi win the Copa
    America, 2022 World Cup and another Ballon d’or and still think Ronaldo is better

    • @raider1297
      @raider1297 2 роки тому +4

      Messi has been better ever since he existed lol and I think everyone is pretty clear on that and knows it. Some people just would never admit it because they're hardcore fans and to them logic or reality doesn't matter. It's just an emotional thing for them. Everyone knows there has never been a logical debate at all.

  • @istg5619
    @istg5619 3 роки тому +130

    Messi gonna win his 7th Balon D'or with the Copa win 💪

    • @zacharybasil
      @zacharybasil 3 роки тому +4

      That's crazy Messi always consistent every year. He's eternal. But the most ridiculous things is lukaku and salah greatest achievement is average for messi and he can do it in his worst season. Now wonder why cruyff admire messi so much

    • @aaryankohli5600
      @aaryankohli5600 3 роки тому

      Yes after the worst performance with 29 goals stats in which 24 comes out against really weaker teams and just with one cup for his team he's gonna win that ballon dor seriously it's just pathetic.

    • @istg5619
      @istg5619 3 роки тому

      @@aaryankohli5600 idk if you're being sarcastic or not 🤣🤣🤣

    • @ZephiroXGD
      @ZephiroXGD 3 роки тому +2

      @@aaryankohli5600 lol i love how you’re yourself so used to see messi score +50 that you still call a 29 goals season pathetic, you’re proving his greatness yourself, if not messi in 2021 then who else????? Who else deserves that ballon d’or except for lewa? It’s not even close to being pathetic if he wins it

    • @DanielFerreira-qk8bh
      @DanielFerreira-qk8bh 3 роки тому

      @@ZephiroXGD jorginho or kante

  • @taroshdabreo580
    @taroshdabreo580 3 роки тому +5

    This is the best messi ronaldo comparison video ive seen
    Im sharing this video to every Ronaldo fan I know

  • @projyel8534
    @projyel8534 3 роки тому +4

    One of the best video I ever seen keep up the great work

  • @bobx8647
    @bobx8647 3 роки тому +71

    You seem to forget that crucial stat :
    Ronaldo :6 kids,2 sets of twins=1 child every 6 years (on average)
    Messi : 3 kids,0 set of twins = 1 child every 11.33 years (on average)

  • @Random360M
    @Random360M 3 роки тому +78

    Ronaldo has influenced some people so badly they literally leave the comment saying Pessi everywhere 🤣🤣🤣🤣
    Penaldo makes sense
    Pessi . What is Pessi?
    Pele + Messi= Pessi

  • @FB-bf9ow
    @FB-bf9ow 3 роки тому +8

    Excellent video bro! Just one thing, at minute 10:20 you say that Ronaldo has 4 FIFA awards for the best player while Messi has 3 but this is not the case, Messi won the FIFA World Player in 2009 (in addition to the Golden Ball) and won the FIFA Ballon d'Or in 2010, 2011, 2012, 2015 and in 2019 FIFA the best (in addition to the Ballon d'Or), therefore it has 6. Ronaldo has 5 since he won the FIFA World Player in 2008, the FIFA Ballon d'Or in 2013, and 2014 and the FIFA the Best in 2016 and 2017.

  • @roberboy55
    @roberboy55 9 місяців тому +7

    Outdated. Messi has won a Copa America and the WC, Ronaldo losses his point and it goes to Messi. Messi wins by a landslide 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @radiologicphysicist1083
    @radiologicphysicist1083 2 роки тому +1

    Liked the analysis, desperately need an updated vid after Copa, Finalissima and WC.

  • @newtonowaga6433
    @newtonowaga6433 3 роки тому +82

    This one of the best videos I've enjoyed watching, I've downloaded it after watching... Messi is the GOAT, no debate... I respect Ronaldo a lot, but Messi is the best... Plus, i think Louis Suarez would have better stats than Ronaldo if he had the same opportunities... but i'll leave that discussion for another day... thank you for giving us insights into the statistics, and the detailed analysis... I didn't know Messi surpassed Ronaldo's overall tally if you substact the penalties for both of them... I'm off to meet some of my friends, who are Ronaldo fans, hehehe...

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +4

      😂

    • @surajs.sharma7430
      @surajs.sharma7430 3 роки тому +11

      comparing luis suarez to ronaldo, bruh.... I agree that messi is better and is the ultimate GOAT but this is too much

    • @arroe8386
      @arroe8386 3 роки тому +5

      Messi has a disadvantage when you compare his goals with Ronaldo because he plays further back, but there is a similar problem if you compare Ronaldo with Suarez because Ronaldo played less central than Suarez at the beginning of his career

    • @truelifepromotion9306
      @truelifepromotion9306 3 роки тому +2

      That ststement sbout susrez is so true n thst season wen dey both won the golden boots susrez dhud of get it cuz he had more sssist n no penslty

    • @surajs.sharma7430
      @surajs.sharma7430 3 роки тому +1

      @@truelifepromotion9306 bruh seriously, suarez has always been a cf or a lone striker, but ronaldo was a proper winger at united and he became a goalscoring monster at RM, Messi is the GOAT for sure, but ronaldo is the second best after him no doubt. Suarez is amazing but nowhere near ronaldo

  • @DidiDongs
    @DidiDongs 2 роки тому +7

    bro every Ronaldo fan has to see this

  • @disagol
    @disagol 3 роки тому +46

    Even if messi had half of his numbers id always pick him cause i think is football himself and has mastered the sport fundamentals. Props to cr7 to put incredible numbers he is top 10 material for sure

    • @dt5beats892
      @dt5beats892 3 роки тому +13

      Top 10?? 🤣🤣🤣🤣 after Messi its Ronaldo, behave

    • @The_Duude99
      @The_Duude99 2 роки тому +3

      @@dt5beats892 not necessarily. He is a goalscorer and up with messi as one of the best ones at that but as an overall player? Pele was much better in his days and others like Maradona and cruyff are in the discussion too. Especially Pele could basically did everything in attack and did it for a long time just like messi and ronaldo. Ronaldo is still in my top 5 but I couldn't justify putting him above Pele either who was just so far ahead of his time and more than a pure goalscorer

    • @dt5beats892
      @dt5beats892 2 роки тому +3

      @@The_Duude99 hahahahahahahah, one day you’ll grasp the game. Messi, Cristiano and Maradona are the top 3 ever, Pele comes after them.

    • @The_Duude99
      @The_Duude99 2 роки тому

      @@dt5beats892 Maradona in his prime was on a lvl with messi and Pele and above ronaldo but he didn't have their longevity so it depends on what you value most. It's either him or ronaldo. Putting both up there above Pele makes 0 sense because they're the exact opposite of one another, either prioritize longevity or peak. Maradonas longevity wasn't all that crazy, neither was ronaldos peak.
      Pele on the other hand was the star in the arguably best national team ever at 17... Peak wise he's similar to Maradona imo, maybe even a tiny bit below but his longevity is only reached by messi and ronaldo. The man was sooo far ahead of his time it's not even a fair comparison

    • @dt5beats892
      @dt5beats892 2 роки тому +1

      @@The_Duude99 I don’t care about what you’re saying, nothing changes the fact that Messi maradona and Ronaldo are top 3 and Pele isn’t even close to them. Have a good day 💪

  • @ankanmukherjee2291
    @ankanmukherjee2291 2 місяці тому +7

    Its not even close..... Ronaldo is far behind.

  • @SyedSaad016
    @SyedSaad016 3 роки тому +66

    Again here after Messi has finally won an International trophy with Argentina! 😊

  • @rumonnsu4u
    @rumonnsu4u 3 роки тому +64

    Ronaldo's goals are the goals, but Messi's goals are not only the goals, but also the beauty of football history.

    • @PengaYT
      @PengaYT 2 роки тому +7

      Ronaldo has the most greatest goals ever. I literally got bored while watching a messi highlight video but for Ronaldo its like he makes everyone he's playing against look like plumbers bro got that MJ effect. He also has the greatest clutch goals ever and heaps of them

    • @uacari
      @uacari 2 роки тому +14

      @@PengaYT u surely have taken a vaccine against seeing beauty at things. if u got bored while watching messi's highlights i feel sorry for u.

    • @sentienttoyotacamry3283
      @sentienttoyotacamry3283 2 роки тому +3

      @@PengaYT lying aint no way

    • @vincentvalentino6566
      @vincentvalentino6566 2 роки тому +6

      @@PengaYT Bro ain't no way seeing Messi dribble 10 players is boring💀

  • @RoyTapan13
    @RoyTapan13 2 роки тому +59

    POV: You are after Messi won his second major trophy with Argentina 😎😎

  • @aguywithareallyreallylongu5912
    @aguywithareallyreallylongu5912 2 роки тому +4

    I thought i was the only person in the world that knew about VAEP. It should be the only factor in determining who is the better player.

  • @homosapien7793
    @homosapien7793 3 роки тому +60

    I think Messi is the goat but how are you genuinely judging maradona on his stats

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +43

      you are right, I forbade myself from going in too much details into Maradona's statistics. I feel like he cannot be judged by stats. In Europe, Maradona's best goalscoring season is 23 goals. On the other hand, both Messi and Ronaldo have scored 50 goals or more 6 times. They also cumulate a couple of 40s and 30s.
      I wouldn't want to go in on Maradona's statistics as I feel it would be perceived as disrespectful.
      The same goes for Ronaldinho. As great as people portray him, in his best goalscoring season, he put up 26 goals.
      Statiscally, other than Pelé, nobody rivals Messi and Ronaldo. Not even the great Maradona.

    • @topchannel-qx4me
      @topchannel-qx4me 3 роки тому +1

      @@GoodlyRogue could you pls give me the link where you found the vaep stat cause I was looking for it and didn't find it

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +4

      @@topchannel-qx4me www.researchgate.net/publication/323302738_Actions_Speak_Louder_Than_Goals_Valuing_Player_Actions_in_Soccer

    • @topchannel-qx4me
      @topchannel-qx4me 3 роки тому +3

      @@GoodlyRogue thanks a lot i hope stats like those will exist in the near future it would be a game changer and you made a mistake those are not for the 2017/18 season it was for the 2016/17 season

    • @GoodlyRogue
      @GoodlyRogue  3 роки тому +1

      @@topchannel-qx4me sorry, I've sent you the wrong link... Here's the study from KU Leuven: lirias.kuleuven.be/retrieve/543010/
      Anyways, you're right, it'll be a massive game changer in the future

  • @alitijani3398
    @alitijani3398 3 роки тому +4

    My word, I have not seen a video so detailed about this age-old topic like this video . It’s a fantastic video which contains the forensic analysis required for this very controversial topic . A very good job by the person/people who made this video

  • @Dinozor3
    @Dinozor3 2 роки тому +4

    8:35 This perfectly summarise it. I dont know why there is even a debate. Ronaldo is just another striker(like you can see in the video), but he scores more tap ins goals and penalties, and shoots more and inaccuretely.

  • @m0ntypth0n
    @m0ntypth0n 2 роки тому +1

    Man big ups to you. You probably might need to do another video after the events that occured on December 18th 2022. Cheers!!

  • @namanverma3876
    @namanverma3876 3 роки тому +11

    Hey mate, brilliant video! Would you make a change to the winning side of this video now that Leo has an international trophy?

  • @syafiqkamalazmi
    @syafiqkamalazmi 2 роки тому +6

    need to update this.. the guy won the world cup

  • @KeinyeiLukyem
    @KeinyeiLukyem 2 роки тому +5

    As of now, every category had been updated all in favour of Messi.
    +1 ballon d'or
    +1 copa America
    +1 finalissima
    And may be many more i guess. I didn't know all of them. NOW Only thing left is to convince those who says Ronaldo is GOAT..

    • @alibek_bagautdinov
      @alibek_bagautdinov 2 роки тому +1

      Winner of the French championship, best assistant of France, best player of Copa America, best scorer of Copa America, best assistant of Copa America.

  • @messii648
    @messii648 Рік тому +1

    Bro we need an updated version much has happened now, many people loved it and many reactors gets confused when they see these video cuz new numbers and trophies has come in ect.. but I appreciate this it’s one of the most detail video between Messi and Ronaldo

  • @erigor11
    @erigor11 3 роки тому +8

    It's in general a very well done video. Thank you and congratulations!
    I would also have included a discussion on sportsmanship, which should also be something worth mentioning.

    • @leomouhsin
      @leomouhsin 3 роки тому +2

      yep that would have been great to mention at the end.
      I personally admire Ronaldo for his outstanding performances but I just cannot force myself to like him because of his lack of sportmanship in several occasions.

    • @erigor11
      @erigor11 3 роки тому +2

      @@leomouhsin I'm exactly in the same place. He simply displays way too many pathetic behaviours time after time. I just can't respect him. I respect his football feats, but he's far from the exemplary professional the media and he himself tries to sell you.

  • @nikolasthalmann799
    @nikolasthalmann799 3 роки тому +8

    I always said messi is better just because he has like this goat feeling. If u see Ronaldo playing u see a great forward. If u see Messi playing u see a god. He is doing things no one can do

  • @MohAd79
    @MohAd79 Рік тому +6

    Goats
    1. Messi
    2. Pele
    3. Maradona
    4. Beckenbauer
    5. Zidane
    6. Cruyff
    7. R9
    8. Di Stéfano
    9. Cr7
    10. Garrincha

    • @Yusuf-zc1jr
      @Yusuf-zc1jr Рік тому

      cr7 needs to be higher, hes definitly top 3.

    • @cripbk2147
      @cripbk2147 Рік тому

      Maradona is #2

    • @riquelme1907
      @riquelme1907 8 місяців тому

      u dont know shit about football kid go back to school

  • @FlokiG
    @FlokiG 10 місяців тому +2

    Part 2 updated plz!! Now that their careers are ending we need a video like this to really end the debate

    • @captainfalconmain6576
      @captainfalconmain6576 7 місяців тому +1

      bro really wants to a destruction goat video

    • @FlokiG
      @FlokiG 5 місяців тому +1

      @@captainfalconmain6576 just to show my Portuguese friends how much better Messi is

    • @captainfalconmain6576
      @captainfalconmain6576 2 місяці тому +1

      @@FlokiGyep