Book Launch | The Unending Game: A Former R&AW Chief’s Insights into Espionage

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
  • As a country’s stature and reach grow, so do its intelligence needs. This is especially true for one like India that has ambitions of being a global player even as it remains embattled in its own neighbourhood. The Unending Game tackles these questions while providing a national and international perspective on gathering external intelligence, its relevance in securing and advancing national interests, and why intelligence is the first playground in the game of nations.
    Vikram Sood is Advisor at Observer Research Foundation. He was a career intelligence officer for 31 years and retired in 2003 after heading India’s external intelligence service, the Research and Analysis Wing.
    The book was launched by Smt. Smriti Irani, Union Cabinet Minister of Textiles, Government of India.
    Speakers
    Baijayant Panda, Member of Parliament, Lok Sabha
    Kanwal Sibal, Former Foreign Secretary
    Shiv Shankar Menon, Former National Security Advisor and Distinguished Fellow, Brookings India
    Sunjoy Joshi, Chairman, Observer Research Foundation
    Swati Chopra, Senior Commissioning Editor, Penguin Random House India

КОМЕНТАРІ • 60

  • @victor256in
    @victor256in 6 років тому +9

    Just ordered this book on Amazon! This book takes a long time to ship in the US though.

  • @quaintdeliveries247
    @quaintdeliveries247 6 років тому +10

    Kanwal Sibal has always been a top favourite of mine. Have ordered the book while watching this. Looks like Sood might be a contender soon. One thing that i love about these 3 is the gravitas. Savour it. Makes me want to consider a job in the services. So delicious.

  • @PoliticalMatter
    @PoliticalMatter 6 років тому +7

    Exactly menon explained it well.
    Political leaders are uneducated in India till now who have no idea how to process intelligence and how it is generated!

    • @TheKukun123
      @TheKukun123 6 років тому +3

      The very fact that eluded you is that Smriti Irani and Baijanta Panda were gathered there as member of the panel as well.
      And, if you proceed to rebut by saying that those political leaders aren't "educated" then, god help!

  • @neelranka6861
    @neelranka6861 6 років тому +5

    Discussion was very knowledgeable, Thanks for uploading it, was waiting for it

  • @KS-jr3ko
    @KS-jr3ko 6 років тому +3

    Gr8 foreward Smriti Maam

  • @deepanshusaxena7836
    @deepanshusaxena7836 4 роки тому +3

    While Mr. Sood never spoke about his achievements in Af-pak region, former dgISI Hamid gul talks about soods achievement in that region.

  • @ashokkaul3165
    @ashokkaul3165 5 років тому +4

    Penguin has done a good job in generating publicity for their book.
    Gone are the days of the legendary Kao and his”Kaoboys”. I believe RAW officials and others of their ilk engaged in undercover operations should be circumspect in both their public appearances and their speeches. They need to stay in the shadows and after retirement should , like good soldiers, just fade away.
    Experiences and insights gained by them over the span of their careers should perhaps be passed on to others of their community and not used in the service of their egos. For example , brilliant as Mr Doval no doubt is, his public pronouncements on “offensive defense” vis a vis Pakistan have provided a useful propaganda tool to them against India. Loose lips do indeed sink ships.

  • @dhulipalaj
    @dhulipalaj 3 роки тому

    Mrs. Smriti, very well spoke .

  • @vandematram7921
    @vandematram7921 3 роки тому +1

    I admire him...🙏🙏

  • @vkjpgroup
    @vkjpgroup 5 років тому +12

    A suggestion worth Trillions for RA&W
    Make your selection based on talent , eradiacte the reservation BS in all services, as we all know how well it's portrayed all over the over, some people are shameless and racist, for those, who are not, it becomes difficult world for some minds and clearly can be seen from the blind folded legal system, illiterate ministers, appointed pons and bullies, therefore change in recruiting process is a must, take a sneak peak at other intelligence authoritys recruitment around the world for example, recruit directly from clColleges, Universities, even unemployed youth who are not unemployment because they are worth to do nothing, maybe just they don't want to be part of "trash mentality workplace" and I mean it because I have experienced the world in a large spectrum too, need not be judged based on boundaries of framework or authority.
    India's intelligence recruitment need to be changed, including CBI, IB, DIA , ATS, NSG,Police etc ( citizens of India may have already seen how many rottens mangoes are inside the system, which infect others with their mental disease, history speaks )- Psychometric tests( not algebra BS, the UPSC exams, papers leaks) and many other technics, the worthy must be given opportunity not reservation worthy. A small example ai would like to give to the citizens of India as how intelligence can be synced, In Canada, I have seen a program called "Block Watch" even old uncle and aunty are paid by government to be society police and they are given lot of privalages to be secure and safe, we have more than million eyes, it's important to select the right one.
    India need a mindshift 🇮🇳🙏🏼

    • @Viruhemanth
      @Viruhemanth 4 роки тому +2

      back in those days, it includes non-ips also, like the author of this book himself is from the post office department. we don't know how it is now.

    • @vkjpgroup
      @vkjpgroup 4 роки тому +1

      @@Viruhemanth
      Look my friend , human souls is powerful.
      Now you have power of internet and many archives , research reports etc etc on so called dark web too ;) so spend some time scanning the system just like any other Bharatiya youth can do irrespective of mindbending brainwash, I love Bharat & I have spent years doing self Funded research other th n getting paid by tick tock 9AM-6:30PM.
      Youth population is 65% ,let's make as far as we can awake. Thanks for replying as most of them must have got a bouncer over their head.

    • @kapil4641
      @kapil4641 3 роки тому

      @@Viruhemanth it's still the same for R&AW.

  • @anujchoudhary8172
    @anujchoudhary8172 6 років тому +2

    I didn't quite get the last part of what Mr. Sibal was saying. Why do you need charter to get rid of bad people in enemy territory. (if I understood him correctly). Can anyone please explain?

  • @quaintdeliveries247
    @quaintdeliveries247 6 років тому +2

    ORF cant get the audio right when you have these top names there. So bad.

  • @urjasvi
    @urjasvi 6 років тому +17

    Ajit Doval Sir should've been here

    • @herehere5754
      @herehere5754 6 років тому +2

      Ankush Kashyap what do you think he is..means what ..you naive..
      he is a goddam nsa..
      means ..god..i need to bomb ghq,pindi as fast as possible.

    • @hippocrazy4233
      @hippocrazy4233 6 років тому +3

      He has created a mess in our neighbourhood. He is the most overrated NSA of our country. Like everything else in this govt, even the post of NSA was PR'd.

    • @herehere5754
      @herehere5754 6 років тому +4

      what do you mean over rated.
      if you have to be agressive have you looked your SIZE. we are 1.2 billion for fuck sake.
      if 20 cr country eyes us..should we drop our pants.
      DOVAL is the NSA we need and require.

  • @chaitanyag.8415
    @chaitanyag.8415 5 років тому +2

    Smriti Irani read my mind, I was thinking what is she doing here?

  • @nikhilpawdia2045
    @nikhilpawdia2045 5 місяців тому

    Is this place for only English class?

  • @dikshantsingh1962
    @dikshantsingh1962 6 років тому

    Was shiv Shankar Menon pointing out Ajit doval @ 46:00..?

  • @sandipansen4778
    @sandipansen4778 6 років тому +2

    38:00 minutes chinese hackers attacked the session; the high frequency wave could lead to controlled explosion before speaker

  • @vishal8271
    @vishal8271 6 років тому

    why cant i fast forward it?

  • @attorneyumarghazalli
    @attorneyumarghazalli 5 років тому

    (14:49) It's Paulo Coelho's quote.

  • @herehere5754
    @herehere5754 6 років тому +1

    what should i become to be NSA IFS or IPS .

    • @srividyadhardantu6
      @srividyadhardantu6 6 років тому

      amit nath goswami anything is fine
      Shiv Sankar Menon is IFS
      Ajit Dovak is IPS
      Both are NSAs

    • @bhagwatmahesh1
      @bhagwatmahesh1 6 років тому

      If u are gud, NSA will fetch u out. U may even be jobless

    • @ashokraina4155
      @ashokraina4155 6 років тому

      Let me read first.

    • @herehere5754
      @herehere5754 6 років тому +1

      i m brahmin and will be ips.

    • @herehere5754
      @herehere5754 6 років тому +1

      @Oing Fuck you.
      Now i will be Chief Executive de jure and de facto of India like Putin.

  • @mayurganekar447
    @mayurganekar447 3 роки тому

    और भी भाषाओं मै प्रसिद्ध हुआ है क्या ?

  • @richatiwari3003
    @richatiwari3003 6 років тому +2

    She is going to be pm in future.

    • @Iangrey11
      @Iangrey11 6 років тому

      Richa Tiwari You are really poor fellow; May god bless you with some brains, Idiot.

  • @vishal8271
    @vishal8271 6 років тому +1

    1st...

  • @jackbond4453
    @jackbond4453 6 років тому +1

    Oh the Yale wali madam bhi hai . Star plus ka serial hai kya

  • @SinghRishabh27
    @SinghRishabh27 6 років тому +7

    Smriti Irani ? Seriously ? She should be the last person to comment on national security or for that matter anything which requires an intellectual bend of mind.She is at best a propagandist and at worse the worst performing minister india has arguably ever seen.

    • @BharatUIMe
      @BharatUIMe 6 років тому +11

      Rishabh Singh , It’s a book launch, not policy making body on intelligence.

    • @Iangrey11
      @Iangrey11 6 років тому +1

      Rishabh Singh Exactly man.

  • @bluesajjad1
    @bluesajjad1 6 років тому

    that irani woman looks very attractive. is she available?

    • @imdeep5839
      @imdeep5839 6 років тому +3

      @@amitkrishnani3160 Aisha is available for halala

    • @myfeedback572
      @myfeedback572 5 років тому

      Yes, she is. Please take her. She will fit right in Pakistan.

    • @star-lordson-in-lawofthano848
      @star-lordson-in-lawofthano848 2 роки тому

      Yes she is available..... Just like your sister is available for me😉

  • @brijeshmandavi6795
    @brijeshmandavi6795 6 років тому +2

    What Irani mam doing here???