When I made my own oobleck, I made it much thicker. It was easy to roll in your hand, yet after just a second, it melted. You should try it with thicker oobleck. As thick as possible, if trying to stop bullets
I would've suggested testing a control group (water-filled containers) as a basis for comparison. Then you could play with different mixtures of oobleck to see if a thicker consistency makes a difference in its bullet stopping ability.
This Ooblek was a lot thinner than the stuff I made with my kids back in the day. I think if it was thicker it would react more as a solid, yet would still be liquid.
Also, As a chef (food scientist) that uses "slurry" (cornstarch and water, essentially oobleck) to thicken soups and stews occasionally, I've played with my fair share. I think your ratio of liquid to cornstarch should be lowered. If you do mostly starch less liquid it'll be even more effective and less runny.
As one who did this once as a child, i absolutely agree. the later stuff was much better, but the bowl was not kosher. It must keep its shape as you pick it up, then turn to liquid..
@@tylerfitts8194 Ofcourse, I'd bet he filmed it the day later, and we're probably seeing this a week later after that. It's a good way to hype a video you're doing/done regardless.
When the bucket thing did a flip on the 357 shot I’m very confident that was a result of the bullet spinning when impacting and entering the ooblek the spin of the bullet was basically trying to churn the ooblek but it reacted as a solid for a very split second making the ooblek absorb some of the spinning momentum out of the bullet and transfer it in the way you see it in the vid. It would be interesting to see the ooblek in super slowmo with clear containers
i would say it was a shockwave effect where the energy of the bullet caused the fluid in the radius to solidify causing a transfer of momentum to the bucket itself, which is why it flew off so violently.
As a goalie, I've seen some goalie gear with this same consept, when you move it's soft, and flexible, but when the puck hits you, it becomes stiff, and hard
I dont know how many people have noticed, but the change to a mirrorless camera with a nice lens has really given the channel that bump in quality. Looks great, Matt!
FYI, there is a company that developed a non-newtonian material called D30 which is used in all sorts of sports protective gear, and even cellphone cases. They've figured out a way for oobleck to retain a molded shape and not flow or melt down like liquid. I would be curious how many D30 protective pads it would take to stop a bullet. Does D30 have more or less stopping power than homemade cornstarch oobleck?
I have armor in my motorcycle gear made of D30, as well as insoles for my skate shoes. The stuff works great for landing after a high jump, as it takes a lot of the force and keeps it from transferring up to my knees. Haven’t had a crash yet on my bike to test my armored jacket…but I’ve heard it works great to prevent what would be serious or life threatening injuries.
Hey matt, love your videos! Oobleck is a non Newtonian fluid, of course you would know since youre a scientist ;) however the best results ive ever read about came from a combination of kevlar and something similar to oobleck. the oobleck hardens on impact, reinforcing the kevlar, meaning thinner kevlar can stop hotter rounds in theory. i would LOVE to see you take some old kevlar, soak it in oobleck somehow and test it to see if it improves the armor at all!
Just want to say, thank you for making fire arms fun again. To many channels do pitiful or worse religious commentary. Even my wife loved this episode and kinetic sand and asked if you were Mythbusters with guns. So quite the high honor of praise. Thank you and yes I would love to see a 55 gl drum vs a tank. That would be awesomeness on rye bread!
That’s what most people love about Matt and his brother. Both of them skip the commentary and get straight into the action albeit with some comedy in the middle.
Get the barrel and shoot smaller cal rounds into the open top it before hitting it with the tank. I think watching the surface reacting in slowmo would be really interesting. At what point does the oobleck start shattering?
If you make it a bit less liquidy, it actually hardens a lot more when getting hit by fast moving objects. I saw a video on youtibe when someone trew a toilet at a pool full of oobleck from like 10 meters high and the toilet literally broke, so it could definetly work as a body armor.
I agree on the tank shooting a 55 gallon drum. Love the intros Matt and never miss a show. You rock! My personal favorite is that 500 magnum you got. What a beauty!
One larger container where the fluid has room to move and do it’s thing. Also hollow-points! Also buck shot! Super interesting stuff, thanks for doing this.
This idea is worth revisiting, but with some more hi-tech non-newtonian fluids. The stuff that's been researched for military/LE use is silica nanoparticles with kevlar fibers. The youtube science channel Tech Ingredients has recently done some work with nanoparticle suspensions, they could probably cobble some up for you.
Dude I don't just like this idea, but I LOVE it. But also I think a big appeal to this video is that pretty much ANYONE could make a bunch of Ooblek just in their kitchen in under an hour and basically do the same thing lol But I agree, I would absolutely love to see him do a video doing your idea! :D
@@Nuovoswiss after seeing your comment in my notifications I went to look and good and you're totally right. Not too cheap (at least not as cheap as cornstarch and water lol) but still VERY doable!
Matt is smart and plans out most of his videos well in advance. I'm sure when he was out shooting the tanks at the armored Suburban he already shot the 55 gallon drum at the same time. The question now is this: What else did he shoot with the tank at the same time? Just shooting a drum will only take up a small part of a larger video.
I remember seeing something about fine fabrics such as Kevlar being up to 8x more ballistically resistant when submerged in these types of non-newtonian liquids. They are called Viscoelastic liquids and if I recall correctly some do just what oobleck does but at a much greater degree, so it can probably be applied to some pretty effective personal and vehicle composites.
there was some non newtonian ferrofluid that was making all kinds of waves back in the early 2000s or so as a potential body armor. it was around the same time that dragon scale was being hyped up. dont think it went anywhere though or we would have seen production examples by now. the problem always seems to be you just need too much of it. yeah a non newtonian can stop a bullet but to do it you will have exponentially more bulk and weight than ceramic or even steel
@@GarlicSoda not really. you would need a bag that cant leak and has to be sealed up as opposed to the burlap or woven polymer that can just be loosely closed. and the moment it gets punctured it will start to leak and will have to be replaced as opposed to being just fine. also would likely be worse at stopping rounds than actual sand or dirt. i doubt that you would need 4 feet of sandbag to stop a sub sonic 300blk
That subsonic round was the best combination of speed, and shape of the round. The .50 bmg made it further (barely) by just brute force. Yes I would love to see the tank against a 55gal barrel of ooblek
This was really cool to watch, I thought the .50 cal was just going to blow through them all. One thing I was thinking about the whole time though, was that it would have to been interesting to see a side by side with water done to see if the Oobleck would do better than just water alone.
its not even close. with water, a regular handgun round will go thru about 4 gallon jugs x 8" each, or +-26-34", depending. This ooblek stopped a .357 in less than 5" and a 12 ga. slug on less than 3". Amazing!
@@perseusrex614 apples and oranges. The ooblek is in super hard ice pack containers. That plastic is REALLY hard. You can't compare this with videos you've seen of bullets being shot at VERY thin, soft, and weak gallon jugs. A .22 LR would rip through a dozen empty gallon jugs, but wouldn't go very far in these. A gallon jug is about 7 inches across, and those are about half that. So for every 7", the bullet has to go through 2x as many walls, that are 10x thicker, and are 3x as strong.
@@xenonram the plastic is a factor but if you are telling me that a .357 out of a rifle would stop in 2 of those filled with water, then I cant help you
What's funny is tbh out of everything, is is not only the first thing I noticed, but also one of my favorite parts of the whole video...... Again tbh it might actually be tied with my favorite part lolol Btw my favorite part was (And this shouldn't be a shocking thing.) when the 50. Came out and not only did the 50, come out (Because we all knew it was going to come out at some point) but that when Matt guessed it wasn't going to make it out of the 10th one and not only was he right, but it actually didn't even MAKE IT to the 10th one! Like when he said the 10th one I actually agreed with him (And what's funny about that to me is that I don't normally agree with his guesses. But in this one I actually agreed with 3 of his guesses. So that pretty much NEVER happens to me. But that's just me and it made the video just that little bit more enjoyable haha 😆 :) 🤯 ) so I actually really really enjoyed that part lol So if I'm saying the fact that it's not just the first thing I noticed, but also that I enjoyed it just as much as him shooting the 50. at Ooblek and my guesses were the same as his. That really says a LOT about how much I like the new camera! Lololol 😅😆😂
Yes it was great except for when he shot the .50 BMG it blurred out the Oobleck/target so you can’t see it explode when shot. For long shots he should stick to the old one.
Didn't notice a thing. Oh wait, my desktop is 11 years old. My monitor, maybe 6 years. It looks good enough for me! :) AMD FX(tm)-8320 Eight-Core Processor 3.51 GHz. 1920 x 1080. Yeah, I'm old and don't care. LMAO!! Ha! Ha!
Matt you need to do this yest again but have the same containers on another table filled with water and see what the difference is first shoot the water ones and then the Oobleck.
Just did some reading, researchers have been experimenting with liquid, non-newtonian armor with promising results, but they're incorporating it into kevlar. Studies showed 4 layers of kevlar soaked in shear thickening fluid (Oobleck is one example) performed as well as 10 layers of kevlar without the STF. Not sure you could replicate their results with cornstarch, I'm willing to bet they're using a much more advanced STF, but it could be an interesting follow up experiment.
My idea was to suspend some kind of media inside of STF. Like maybe AR500 pellets or bb's, get a thick enough STF and suspend a lot of them in it. And when you shoot it, hopefully it would transfer the force to STF much better, while also providing more protection against slow moving rounds. I think the main advantage would be having flexible armor that's good against higher powered rifles, as opposed to the plates which greatly inhibit movement.
@@lazar2175 That's a really interesting idea. More experimenting to do with grain size, perhaps steel sand would work well and turn into something akin to concrete when hit. Not sure Matt's about to dive into the deep science though, maybe taofledermaus would be up for the challenge?
@@dick8997 All liquids are compressible, just to such a small extent we call them incompressible. This is also just describing normal fluids, when you start working with supper critical fluids, the distinction between liquids and gases break down and allow for highly compressible fluids.
Hi , hello, you need to pour a couple of large bags with a diameter of 1 m and see if it breaks through. the resistance of the liquid in the total mass when receiving damage will be different
This was hilarious. I met oobleck when I was 12 years old. I was way too young to be getting stoned or drunk. And it really tripped me out. Now I understand. Bring on the tank.
Thanks Matt! I got to watch this with my 5 year old daughter that loves science. We got the different bullets out so she could see the sizes. She used the word cool many times when looking at the bullets.
Great intro. "What the... where was that!?" That line killed me 😅 Matt is like a videogame character who just has several giant guns concealed on his body and can just pull out of thin air at will.
I wonder how an arrow or crossbow bolt would have done since it's travelling so much slower but still has a ton of kinetic energy behind a relatively small cross-sectional area.
The smaller the point is the better chance it has of going through basically the surface area of a fist versus a knife a knife will glide through easier then a fist given the same force because less surface are for the liquid to harden and slow it down.
Gonna keep requesting a collaboration video with Destin from Smarter every day where they shoot a 50bmg with a 50bmg in flight and catch it on slow mo. Bonus if they can get the slow mo guys in on it.
@DemolitionRanch The best way to have done this is to compare it to shooting the same containers with water. To isolate whether the oobleck was acting as a fluid versus solid
Hypothesis: any blunt bullet like 22LR 45 acp 9mm 40 sw 44mag anything with a rounded or flat bullet I think it will have a chance, now a thing sharp, like a rifle round I think will cut right through 556 762 300 blackout 308 30-06 all that fun jank
I think as a reasonably thin layer beneath hard armor it could be great as a concussive spreader/dampener. Where the overall armor needs to be thinner, helmets, joints soft moving and roomy, comfy but form fit stiff on impact
The tank idea seems like a good one, though I would make the oobleck a fair bit thicker. The mix you used was a bit thinner than I have seen used before.
Fyi the reason that happens is when you smack it you push all the water out of it, which makes the starch stick together, and when you let it rest the water seeps back in. A similar thing can be observed on the beach, if you smack moist sand next to the water it will become soggy.
Prediction: the .50 cal goes all the way through Follow up, I am sort surprised that it stopped but I would have loved to see some AP rounds in general or an incendiary .50 round
My guess was that it MAY have gone all the way through but that it would be deflected enough that it would exit by number 10 and miss the rest (as often happens with the .50 when firing through numerous items). I was shocked it stopped in 10.
Video idea. Competition. Have a range of targets on tables and everyone gets to pick one ammo type to shoot. Whoever gets the furthest in and most points per target. Eg if you had picked 50cal today you would have lost points
I'd say more because in the small separate containers it only has a little bit to disperse out of the way with each one, and then only affects each couple inch segment at a time . With a lot in one it's affecting a bunch all at once, more resistance. But that stuff is weird, so I think it just needs to be done. I gotta look to see if it has now.
Oh! Good Grief,Matt now you've got me to thinking real crazy...What would happen if you used Oobleck In a projectile and fired it out of a mortar or as a tank round?
At: 2:08 If the bullet is really dull the bullet will not pierce due to the friction on the surface but pointy bullets will cut right through it like a neelde
I was actually thinking that maybe having a steel plate sort of "floating" directly in front of a "wall" of oobleck might help dissipate a lot of the energy of a bullet. So I'm guessing, to make a practical oobleck body armor, maybe we can have oobleck sandwiched between two quarter-inch plates of steel. Or perhaps many thinner, alternating layers of oobleck and steel plates.
I think thinner but with perforations... that way each layer of oobleck would respond individually and give a place for the oobleck to displace upon impact.
I think the advantages of oobleck (or some alternative non-Newtonian fluid) would be it's self-healing ability. I'd want to know how it works when mixed with kevlar fibres: on contact, it would stiffen up and hold the fibres like in a solid
@@One-way Yeah but that would create weak points on the plates. I'm thinking maybe alternating layers, like the way bricks are stacked alternately with the oobleck as the mortar, but all of them are somehow held together so they don't slide sideways yet they can still move forward and back allowing the oobleck to do its job.
@@jameshogge I was wondering about that too. Maybe the kevlar fibers would be strengthened. We definitely need a bit more research on that. The only thing I'm worried about is the force is still being concentrated mostly on one spot. Hence my idea of reinforcing steel plates, even thin ones, that is designed in a way that spreads the force of the bullet. I dunno. I'm just throwing ideas around. I'm certainly no "scientist" in a lab coat.
Mostly armor using shear thickening fluids is a base material like aramids that is soaked in a mixture of nano particulate colloidal silica and polyethylene glycol. This in effect gives more impact resistance to the fibers (increases the force required to separate said fibers) thus making the armor more effective.
You can tell he has a real science background because his labcoat is actually closed. Everybody that puts on a labcoat for fun, wears it open, because it looks cool. But if you have to wear it, one of the first things you learn, is to close that damn thing at all times. Well done mr. doctor'ish!
@@jodymooney255 oooo he got ya there! Guess you don’t know more than him like you thought in your first comment? We beeen knowing he has a doctorate degree, you thought you were breaking news 🗞 🤣😂
Rescale how you think about modern life. A personal shield today isn't necessarily about worn body armor. This looks like less than ideal armor, indeed. For a human. But I see this as a very slick hillbilly upgrade to vehicles. Image these oobleck vessels, 3d printed to fit, set in layers between body panels on cars. So that there's multiple layers&0wiggle. I image a soft plastic or silicone, that can self seal a little would be ideal.
@@arbhall7572 Non-newtonian fluids are being very heavily researched for body armor. Not oobleck, but fluids that become even harder with less speed. Think of a level 2 plate with a non-Newtonian fluid sack behind. The sack wouldn't protect against handguns at all, which is what the plate is for. Anything super high velocity will be stopped dead by the non-newtonian fluid sack behind.
I think that was the Serbu BFG-50A, it has an opening at the front of the barrel shroud unlike the Barrets, you can see the reflection if you pause at 0:45. I guess the charging sound was edited in.
Matt, I feel like a huge factor preventing the ooblek from stopping rounds is that the containers you had them in were vented which allowed the ooblek to move instead of compressing when struck. So I feel like you'll get a better result with ooblek in a pressurized container - even if you used some kevlar vests stitched together and lined to be water proof, so long as the ooblek had nowhere to go when struck by a round it would be much more effective....honestly the most effective, comfortable, and lightweight version of this could be a kevlar vest in front of the ookblek which is just in a bag and nothing behind it...oobvest...
your videos are the best! i was thinking, like others, less liquidy, and what if it's packed in tight, like vacuum sealed so there's no room to move around. it would only take 1 or 2 bullets, then it'd start leaking out, probably making it easier to get through, but the 1 or 2 bullets it does stop might be able to be impressive calibers.
I would like to see you try some flat nose rounds, like 40 S&W, 45 Long Colt, 500 S&W Magnum and 45-70 then do other tests where you compare round nose vs hollow point of other calibers.
As the Mythbusters already figured out, also water acts like this more or less, at supersonic rounds. So you have to repeat the experiment with pure water to possibly tell what the corn starch did.
You don't need to demonstrate a proper understanding of the scientific method to run a successful UA-cam channel, lol. "Gun go boom, bullet stop, wow! I hit 'Like' now!" Too bad the bullet/impact resistant properties of non-Newtonian fluid is the one thing I'd like to see experimented with correctly
@@bushwacker2048 ok mate, then do this, grab a gun, then shoot at whatever fluid you want. If you want the experiment, do it yourself instead of crying on UA-cam comments.
The understand is easy the more surface area the more stopping power the liquid has basically it'll stop a slap or punch easily because how thick those items are while a knife has a sharp edge with little surface area being forced in at its point giving the liquid less area to harden on a larger object making the knife go through easier.
@@spygun0442 Invalid argument. One can demand quality or at least improvement in methodology of a demonstration without it being "crying." Hell, it's the youtube audience's imperative.
What abt hollow point? Dumb theory but I think the bullet splits the oobleck when it goes through, like a knife. But would a hollow point catch the oobleck then get stopped?
Hey Matt I loved to see your revisit this Video but next time shoot vibrating ooblek Now that it would be in its starting state a solidish will have its actual density relatively mapped out And it would probably change bullet penetration
Nothings crazier than occasionally watching a Demolition Ranch video and seeing he has 10.5M subs when you first started watching him when he had 50k back in like 2014 or something.
Save 50% or more on your SimpliSafe security system. Visit SimpliSafe.com/Demoranch to learn more!
Hell9
100%
Hi
Idiotic
Lovely vid matt.
A tank shooting a 55 gallon drum of ooblek is something I'd very much love to see.
same
I agree dude I wish the had a 88 mm or a pak 40 to shoot it with
good idea, but a 55 gal drum isn't big enough. Im thinking a residential above ground LNG tank.
Maybe the govt is still selling off some of fpsrussia's arsenal
Also put a explosive inside of one and see what happens from the inside with a explosion!?
Matt: “Spitballing ideas, shoot oobleck with a tank. Good idea? Let me know your thoughts.”
Demolitia: “Is that a question?”
Incendiary!
OOBLECK VS TANK? HMMMM
YEAH, DO IT! ! ! ! :)
OnLy question is why didn’t we try that sooner brother
I would try the same rounds on the barrels of oobleck to see if there's a difference, and then to finish it off, hit it with the tank round.
Of course it is. And the answer is HELL YES!!!!!!
When I made my own oobleck, I made it much thicker. It was easy to roll in your hand, yet after just a second, it melted. You should try it with thicker oobleck. As thick as possible, if trying to stop bullets
I agree, a bit “watery”
Probably was the easiest way to fill up the small jugs with it a bit more fluid though
Last time I used home made oobleck you were concieved, my son.
How do you make the oobleck thicker
@@zeph6768 dont put as much water in it when making it, or use more cornstarch if its too runny
Typical is 1 part water to 2 parts corn starch.
I would've suggested testing a control group (water-filled containers) as a basis for comparison. Then you could play with different mixtures of oobleck to see if a thicker consistency makes a difference in its bullet stopping ability.
Came here to suggest the same
I was wondering the same thing
This Ooblek was a lot thinner than the stuff I made with my kids back in the day. I think if it was thicker it would react more as a solid, yet would still be liquid.
Yea they put too much water, I was thinking the same.
I hear keeping it cold ruins it aswell
Yeah they way over did the water cause it would not splash like that
It did look a little on the thin side. Although it didn't splash when he was punching it so at least some of the properties are there...
Yeah I agree
Also, As a chef (food scientist) that uses "slurry" (cornstarch and water, essentially oobleck) to thicken soups and stews occasionally, I've played with my fair share. I think your ratio of liquid to cornstarch should be lowered. If you do mostly starch less liquid it'll be even more effective and less runny.
As some dude that just wanted to play with oobleck, these were my thoughts as well
As one who did this once as a child, i absolutely agree. the later stuff was much better, but the bowl was not kosher. It must keep its shape as you pick it up, then turn to liquid..
Partly you want it to solidify at the right pressure, a weak one might well be better for this. It'd be nice to try some different thicknesses first
My thoughts exactly, it's to wet, punching oobleck shouldn't even leave residue on the hand
@forrestholmun64 it's ok, I do the same thing and people get all confused or take offense 😆
I love how Matt brings up the tank idea knowing full well that he doesn't even have to ask if we want to see that XD
For real, I'm sure at this point he's like, "if i wanna blow it up or shoot at it, I'm sure they wanna see"
That's his way of justifying doing it to Mere lol he blames it on "us" 😂
@@KS_OUTDOORS91 for real lol. That little fucker probably already rented the tank XD
@@tylerfitts8194 Ofcourse, I'd bet he filmed it the day later, and we're probably seeing this a week later after that. It's a good way to hype a video you're doing/done regardless.
@@saladin7467 I didn't think about that man. I'm honored by such sage advice, from the terror of the east himself no less.
When the bucket thing did a flip on the 357 shot I’m very confident that was a result of the bullet spinning when impacting and entering the ooblek the spin of the bullet was basically trying to churn the ooblek but it reacted as a solid for a very split second making the ooblek absorb some of the spinning momentum out of the bullet and transfer it in the way you see it in the vid. It would be interesting to see the ooblek in super slowmo with clear containers
i would say it was a shockwave effect where the energy of the bullet caused the fluid in the radius to solidify causing a transfer of momentum to the bucket itself, which is why it flew off so violently.
“When I start going fast, it gets hard” what a fantastic sentence, couldn’t have said it better myself Matt 👍
Also said 11:04
@@sexygirls3166 what in the actual fu-
@@Realizinq LMAO NOOO
Don't tell Mare
I like your bike
It would have been cool to fire the same rounds at the same jugs filled with water to see how it compared.
This
Yup, need control tests.
Bump
I thought the same thing.
It’s going through
Needs to be a more starch heavy consistency. That’s a bit too liquidy
Came here to say the same thing.
Yeah seemed way too runny
I thought so
As a goalie, I've seen some goalie gear with this same consept, when you move it's soft, and flexible, but when the puck hits you, it becomes stiff, and hard
i can say the same thing about ME HAHA
Yeah this guy is telling the truth except no need for the puck for this concept to work. Just hand.
I dont know how many people have noticed, but the change to a mirrorless camera with a nice lens has really given the channel that bump in quality. Looks great, Matt!
yea it looks really good.
This is true. But the over the shoulder shots, are never in focus. That is the only thing left to fix.
Production values have gone way up.
Happened right around the time he started doing collabs with flannel daddy.
🤔
Mirrorless camera?
FYI, there is a company that developed a non-newtonian material called D30 which is used in all sorts of sports protective gear, and even cellphone cases. They've figured out a way for oobleck to retain a molded shape and not flow or melt down like liquid. I would be curious how many D30 protective pads it would take to stop a bullet. Does D30 have more or less stopping power than homemade cornstarch oobleck?
wow, i actually didn't know this. thanks for telling
I have armor in my motorcycle gear made of D30, as well as insoles for my skate shoes. The stuff works great for landing after a high jump, as it takes a lot of the force and keeps it from transferring up to my knees. Haven’t had a crash yet on my bike to test my armored jacket…but I’ve heard it works great to prevent what would be serious or life threatening injuries.
@@westabon420 Hopefully. Wrecking mine sucked😂
What's the brand name?
D30 is a must have for me in motorcycle gear. The shit is incredible.
Hey matt, love your videos!
Oobleck is a non Newtonian fluid, of course you would know since youre a scientist ;) however the best results ive ever read about came from a combination of kevlar and something similar to oobleck. the oobleck hardens on impact, reinforcing the kevlar, meaning thinner kevlar can stop hotter rounds in theory. i would LOVE to see you take some old kevlar, soak it in oobleck somehow and test it to see if it improves the armor at all!
I actually like the idea, hopefully he does more with oobleck
I’m actually curious
That is an Ingenious idea!
Just came here to say the same thing.
This guy is obviously trolling for some weird fetish film.
The opening skits are worth tuning in for. They keep getting better.
The best one is where they have an intervention and his buddy comes in with one and says what you said we were giving him an intervention 😂
Matt: "I have an idea..."
Demolita: "yes"
What i’ve learned from this channel: if you strap enough of it onto you, anything could be body armor
ikr 😆
@H I K A M A R U 🅾️
another stupid bot
literally every time i watch the body armor vids
That’s so true
It would be good to see if a 50cal makes it through a large drum of it instead of the many small cases
“This is America” Is it just me, are the quality of Matt’s intros starting to reach cinema level quality?
He hired an actual production team.
Matt's are good, but not on par with Garande thumb yet. That guy is insane with his intros
Yes
The intros are getting worse and worse.
Yeah, I think so. He's definitely got a new camera and is using VFX for the gunshots (I love VFX they're so cool)
Just want to say, thank you for making fire arms fun again. To many channels do pitiful or worse religious commentary. Even my wife loved this episode and kinetic sand and asked if you were Mythbusters with guns. So quite the high honor of praise. Thank you and yes I would love to see a 55 gl drum vs a tank. That would be awesomeness on rye bread!
That’s what most people love about Matt and his brother. Both of them skip the commentary and get straight into the action albeit with some comedy in the middle.
It really doesn’t matter what you aim at, the answer to “shoot it with a tank” is always yes.
An orphanage?
@@buzzfeedlgbtq3194 that depends. Do they pour the milk before the cereal?
@@jeffjacobs6104 Doesn't matter. The answer is always yes
We talkin 105mm or a 120mm?
Speaking facts
Get the barrel and shoot smaller cal rounds into the open top it before hitting it with the tank. I think watching the surface reacting in slowmo would be really interesting. At what point does the oobleck start shattering?
I’ve shot into a cup with oobleck and splashes out in small chunks
@@Davie272 Yeah, but what happens with a .50 hits a 3 foot deep barrel? This are the questions that need answers. For science
If you make it a bit less liquidy, it actually hardens a lot more when getting hit by fast moving objects. I saw a video on youtibe when someone trew a toilet at a pool full of oobleck from like 10 meters high and the toilet literally broke, so it could definetly work as a body armor.
I was just thinking the same thing. He needs a little bit more corn starch.
I agree on the tank shooting a 55 gallon drum. Love the intros Matt and never miss a show. You rock! My personal favorite is that 500 magnum you got. What a beauty!
One larger container where the fluid has room to move and do it’s thing. Also hollow-points! Also buck shot! Super interesting stuff, thanks for doing this.
This idea is worth revisiting, but with some more hi-tech non-newtonian fluids. The stuff that's been researched for military/LE use is silica nanoparticles with kevlar fibers. The youtube science channel Tech Ingredients has recently done some work with nanoparticle suspensions, they could probably cobble some up for you.
Dude I don't just like this idea, but I LOVE it.
But also I think a big appeal to this video is that pretty much ANYONE could make a bunch of Ooblek just in their kitchen in under an hour and basically do the same thing lol
But I agree, I would absolutely love to see him do a video doing your idea! :D
There's a mushroom for it certainly. We just gotta find it.
@@Shiznittlebizbampop1 Thanks to the internet, it's more doable for average people than you think. Almost every ingredient can be bought from Amazon.
@@Nuovoswiss after seeing your comment in my notifications I went to look and good and you're totally right. Not too cheap (at least not as cheap as cornstarch and water lol) but still VERY doable!
matt literally anything involving you and a tank i want to see
Think Matt is having more fun trying to splash than anything. Gr8 episode !
Matt is smart and plans out most of his videos well in advance. I'm sure when he was out shooting the tanks at the armored Suburban he already shot the 55 gallon drum at the same time.
The question now is this: What else did he shoot with the tank at the same time? Just shooting a drum will only take up a small part of a larger video.
Maybe he put a grenade in a big bowl of oobleck? O.o Or he tested some C4 vs Oobleck?
If not I hope this is an input for future videos... ;p
No, the question is what DIDN"T he shoot with the tank while he had the opportunity.
He's probably withholding the head to tail SUV tank shot to put in that video.
I love Matt’s little back up energy when he starts shooting the idea of a tank and ooblek. He already knows we wanna see it
I remember seeing something about fine fabrics such as Kevlar being up to 8x more ballistically resistant when submerged in these types of non-newtonian liquids. They are called Viscoelastic liquids and if I recall correctly some do just what oobleck does but at a much greater degree, so it can probably be applied to some pretty effective personal and vehicle composites.
there was some non newtonian ferrofluid that was making all kinds of waves back in the early 2000s or so as a potential body armor. it was around the same time that dragon scale was being hyped up. dont think it went anywhere though or we would have seen production examples by now.
the problem always seems to be you just need too much of it. yeah a non newtonian can stop a bullet but to do it you will have exponentially more bulk and weight than ceramic or even steel
@@crazysilly2914 lol your crazy
IIRC, it only went into use in the production of trauma pads, not mainline armor.
could be a cool sandbag filler idk if it would be better or worse tho
@@GarlicSoda not really. you would need a bag that cant leak and has to be sealed up as opposed to the burlap or woven polymer that can just be loosely closed.
and the moment it gets punctured it will start to leak and will have to be replaced as opposed to being just fine.
also would likely be worse at stopping rounds than actual sand or dirt. i doubt that you would need 4 feet of sandbag to stop a sub sonic 300blk
Do it again with sealed containers. I bet the extra pressure would have a solidifying effect on the oobleck!
That subsonic round was the best combination of speed, and shape of the round. The .50 bmg made it further (barely) by just brute force.
Yes I would love to see the tank against a 55gal barrel of ooblek
This was really cool to watch, I thought the .50 cal was just going to blow through them all. One thing I was thinking about the whole time though, was that it would have to been interesting to see a side by side with water done to see if the Oobleck would do better than just water alone.
That’s what I’m sayin
I was thinking the same thing lol. I am also not a scientist like Matt is, so...
its not even close. with water, a regular handgun round will go thru about 4 gallon jugs x 8" each, or +-26-34", depending. This ooblek stopped a .357 in less than 5" and a 12 ga. slug on less than 3". Amazing!
@@perseusrex614 apples and oranges. The ooblek is in super hard ice pack containers. That plastic is REALLY hard. You can't compare this with videos you've seen of bullets being shot at VERY thin, soft, and weak gallon jugs. A .22 LR would rip through a dozen empty gallon jugs, but wouldn't go very far in these. A gallon jug is about 7 inches across, and those are about half that. So for every 7", the bullet has to go through 2x as many walls, that are 10x thicker, and are 3x as strong.
@@xenonram the plastic is a factor but if you are telling me that a .357 out of a rifle would stop in 2 of those filled with water, then I cant help you
Let's take a moment to appreciate Matt's new camera... Noticed the higher framerate, more accurate colors, and focused depth of field right away!
Yes! It was the first thing I noticed! From the beginning of his channel to now, this is a huge thing in my opinion!
i agree
What's funny is tbh out of everything, is is not only the first thing I noticed, but also one of my favorite parts of the whole video...... Again tbh it might actually be tied with my favorite part lolol
Btw my favorite part was (And this shouldn't be a shocking thing.) when the 50. Came out and not only did the 50, come out (Because we all knew it was going to come out at some point) but that when Matt guessed it wasn't going to make it out of the 10th one and not only was he right, but it actually didn't even MAKE IT to the 10th one! Like when he said the 10th one I actually agreed with him (And what's funny about that to me is that I don't normally agree with his guesses. But in this one I actually agreed with 3 of his guesses. So that pretty much NEVER happens to me. But that's just me and it made the video just that little bit more enjoyable haha 😆 :) 🤯 ) so I actually really really enjoyed that part lol
So if I'm saying the fact that it's not just the first thing I noticed, but also that I enjoyed it just as much as him shooting the 50. at Ooblek and my guesses were the same as his. That really says a LOT about how much I like the new camera! Lololol 😅😆😂
Yes it was great except for when he shot the .50 BMG it blurred out the Oobleck/target so you can’t see it explode when shot. For long shots he should stick to the old one.
Didn't notice a thing. Oh wait, my desktop is 11 years old. My monitor, maybe 6 years. It looks good enough for me! :) AMD FX(tm)-8320 Eight-Core Processor 3.51 GHz. 1920 x 1080. Yeah, I'm old and don't care. LMAO!! Ha! Ha!
Matt you need to do this yest again but have the same containers on another table filled with water and see what the difference is first shoot the water ones and then the Oobleck.
Just did some reading, researchers have been experimenting with liquid, non-newtonian armor with promising results, but they're incorporating it into kevlar. Studies showed 4 layers of kevlar soaked in shear thickening fluid (Oobleck is one example) performed as well as 10 layers of kevlar without the STF. Not sure you could replicate their results with cornstarch, I'm willing to bet they're using a much more advanced STF, but it could be an interesting follow up experiment.
poland.
My idea was to suspend some kind of media inside of STF. Like maybe AR500 pellets or bb's, get a thick enough STF and suspend a lot of them in it. And when you shoot it, hopefully it would transfer the force to STF much better, while also providing more protection against slow moving rounds.
I think the main advantage would be having flexible armor that's good against higher powered rifles, as opposed to the plates which greatly inhibit movement.
@@lazar2175 That's a really interesting idea. More experimenting to do with grain size, perhaps steel sand would work well and turn into something akin to concrete when hit. Not sure Matt's about to dive into the deep science though, maybe taofledermaus would be up for the challenge?
I was wondering about this, thanks!
as a professional ooblecker, I can tell you right off the bat theres not enough corn starch in your mix lol
Yeah, it's far too watery.
Too watery but dude don't define yourself as a professional ooblecker
Agreed, too watery. But he did end up with the same desired effect, just not as dense
True
@@itsmebutwhoami8177 Let the man be a professional ooblecker
In all honesty, ooblek in the "armor scenario" would possibly be best used in bomb squad suits, armor for rapid concussive force. But idk 🤷♂️
You can't compress a liquid.
@@dick8997 There is an exception. If you get a water bed and put your mother on it, it will compress.
@@dick8997 All liquids are compressible, just to such a small extent we call them incompressible. This is also just describing normal fluids, when you start working with supper critical fluids, the distinction between liquids and gases break down and allow for highly compressible fluids.
I remember seeing a motorcycle gear company trying to use non newtonian fluid in some sort of jumpsuit
@@dick8997 That's why it's called a "Non-Newtonian " solid :)) It only slightly resembles a liquid, but it's not a liquid !!
Hi , hello, you need to pour a couple of large bags with a diameter of 1 m and see if it breaks through. the resistance of the liquid in the total mass when receiving damage will be different
This was hilarious. I met oobleck when I was 12 years old. I was way too young to be getting stoned or drunk. And it really tripped me out. Now I understand. Bring on the tank.
Thanks Matt! I got to watch this with my 5 year old daughter that loves science. We got the different bullets out so she could see the sizes. She used the word cool many times when looking at the bullets.
That's high quality parenting right there.
Great intro. "What the... where was that!?" That line killed me 😅 Matt is like a videogame character who just has several giant guns concealed on his body and can just pull out of thin air at will.
They were hidden in his prison wallet
wait Matt is not a video game character i have been lied to my entire life
would be interesting to have a direct comparison between the goo and the same canisters filled with water.
Oobleck settles out really fast. you HAVE to keep it mixed up or it's just turns into water and starch after a few minutes.
That only happens if there is too much water. And it takes a couple hours for it to settle completely.
I wonder how an arrow or crossbow bolt would have done since it's travelling so much slower but still has a ton of kinetic energy behind a relatively small cross-sectional area.
Big boom in one word mate
I bet it would work better than the guns.
Time to ask Tod Cutler of Tod's Workshop
@@Stroopwafe1 time to ask joerge
The smaller the point is the better chance it has of going through basically the surface area of a fist versus a knife a knife will glide through easier then a fist given the same force because less surface are for the liquid to harden and slow it down.
"This is America !"
I think this was the best intro.
Let's go Brandon!
That’s the last sentence in the intro…couldn’t make it out?
If the ooblec is pressure sealed it performs better as the wave can’t exit through the big holes so pressure seal the ooblec
Gonna keep requesting a collaboration video with Destin from Smarter every day where they shoot a 50bmg with a 50bmg in flight and catch it on slow mo. Bonus if they can get the slow mo guys in on it.
I was just gonna mentioned that Destin did a small scale version with the golf ball cannon... (edit) as I was... it was the Backyard Scientist...
Matt is the forerunner of the personal shield in dune lore, where projectiles must penetrate slowly to avoid activating kinetic protection.
You stole my statement dude! 🙃
@@martincolvill5453 i made the joke, then scrolled down and saw this. F
This test has been done before. Copying someone's idea and adding a commercial
Slow is smooth, smooth is fast. A bit of KY helps too.
@@eggbert191 link
@DemolitionRanch
The best way to have done this is to compare it to shooting the same containers with water. To isolate whether the oobleck was acting as a fluid versus solid
Hypothesis: any blunt bullet like 22LR 45 acp 9mm 40 sw 44mag anything with a rounded or flat bullet I think it will have a chance, now a thing sharp, like a rifle round I think will cut right through 556 762 300 blackout 308 30-06 all that fun jank
I think as a reasonably thin layer beneath hard armor it could be great as a concussive spreader/dampener. Where the overall armor needs to be thinner, helmets, joints soft moving and roomy, comfy but form fit stiff on impact
Concept proven in mountain biking pads
@@ilidor4219 football gear too. Also fairly sure I've seen articles on body armour using similar materials.
The new camera looks so good. It’s crazy to see how far you’ve come
The tank idea seems like a good one, though I would make the oobleck a fair bit thicker. The mix you used was a bit thinner than I have seen used before.
Fyi the reason that happens is when you smack it you push all the water out of it, which makes the starch stick together, and when you let it rest the water seeps back in. A similar thing can be observed on the beach, if you smack moist sand next to the water it will become soggy.
The subsonic round going further in than the supersonic round is crazy. Nice method too, certifiably scientifically fresh
Matt deserve a award from UA-cam for best intros on the platform
"Your mom tied better knots than this last night "
Damn man. You didn't have to do him dirty like that 😭😭😭😭
who's "him" did you refer to btw
I think it's a good idea. About the tank and the barrel.
Prediction: the .50 cal goes all the way through
Follow up, I am sort surprised that it stopped but I would have loved to see some AP rounds in general or an incendiary .50 round
My guess was that it MAY have gone all the way through but that it would be deflected enough that it would exit by number 10 and miss the rest (as often happens with the .50 when firing through numerous items). I was shocked it stopped in 10.
But how many biceps will it go through?
Same I'm going for all the way through
shooting anything with a tank is a go! that was a great intro!!
so what you're sayin is Oobleck basically is the cheapest knockoff of Dune's energy shield armor? damn we livin in the future boys
Was just thinking that
It might fall short of the "causes a nuclear explosion if hit by a laser" part, though.
Well, that is intro material...
@@michaelschumacher597 Are you sure, did you do the science? ;D
You are Such an Awesome and Amazing Person Matt and I really learn another about ballistics in a fun and funny way experimenting is fun.🥰
Video idea. Competition. Have a range of targets on tables and everyone gets to pick one ammo type to shoot. Whoever gets the furthest in and most points per target. Eg if you had picked 50cal today you would have lost points
It'd be interesting to see if one large tank of ooblek is more or less effective than several small tanks of ooblek
A true scientific mind
less most likely
I'd say more because in the small separate containers it only has a little bit to disperse out of the way with each one, and then only affects each couple inch segment at a time . With a lot in one it's affecting a bunch all at once, more resistance. But that stuff is weird, so I think it just needs to be done. I gotta look to see if it has now.
Oh! Good Grief,Matt now you've got me to thinking real crazy...What would happen if you used Oobleck In a projectile and fired it out of a mortar or as a tank round?
At: 2:08 If the bullet is really dull the bullet will not pierce due to the friction on the surface but pointy bullets will cut right through it like a neelde
"Tank Go Boom But Oobleck Stand Strong." - Sun Tzu Art Of War (Probably)
I was actually thinking that maybe having a steel plate sort of "floating" directly in front of a "wall" of oobleck might help dissipate a lot of the energy of a bullet. So I'm guessing, to make a practical oobleck body armor, maybe we can have oobleck sandwiched between two quarter-inch plates of steel. Or perhaps many thinner, alternating layers of oobleck and steel plates.
I think thinner but with perforations... that way each layer of oobleck would respond individually and give a place for the oobleck to displace upon impact.
I think the advantages of oobleck (or some alternative non-Newtonian fluid) would be it's self-healing ability.
I'd want to know how it works when mixed with kevlar fibres: on contact, it would stiffen up and hold the fibres like in a solid
@@One-way Yeah but that would create weak points on the plates. I'm thinking maybe alternating layers, like the way bricks are stacked alternately with the oobleck as the mortar, but all of them are somehow held together so they don't slide sideways yet they can still move forward and back allowing the oobleck to do its job.
@@jameshogge I was wondering about that too. Maybe the kevlar fibers would be strengthened. We definitely need a bit more research on that.
The only thing I'm worried about is the force is still being concentrated mostly on one spot. Hence my idea of reinforcing steel plates, even thin ones, that is designed in a way that spreads the force of the bullet.
I dunno. I'm just throwing ideas around. I'm certainly no "scientist" in a lab coat.
Mostly armor using shear thickening fluids is a base material like aramids that is soaked in a mixture of nano particulate colloidal silica and polyethylene glycol. This in effect gives more impact resistance to the fibers (increases the force required to separate said fibers) thus making the armor more effective.
This was cool! Do more with it, if it prevents faster moving things what about incendiaries? Will it contain an explosion?
🤔
I have never heard of this stuff before, nor do I have as much experience with 50s as you do, but I’m still rooting for the 50 going through
Demoranch back at it again. I've watched you for years and love your content. Keep up the good work!!
You can tell he has a real science background because his labcoat is actually closed. Everybody that puts on a labcoat for fun, wears it open, because it looks cool. But if you have to wear it, one of the first things you learn, is to close that damn thing at all times.
Well done mr. doctor'ish!
He is a veterinarian so yes.
He is no a doctor’ish, he is a Doctor of Veterinarian Medicine.
@@jodymooney255 And he usually refers to this as: "I am a Doctor ... ish"
His words, not mine.
@@jodymooney255 oooo he got ya there! Guess you don’t know more than him like you thought in your first comment? We beeen knowing he has a doctorate degree, you thought you were breaking news 🗞 🤣😂
@@Abcdefghijllmnop God, you're insufferable.
“A giant bulge in the backside, just the way I like it”. Matt is a man of culture
Einhorn is Finkle. Finkle is Einhorn!
@@cdegenova1761 he found Captain Winkie!
Her gun was poking me in the hip…
You guys a terrible lol. What I took from that is Matt's a ass guy, not a boob guy.
Baby got back!
I am a Gifted and Talented teacher, and this is the best science experiment I've seen.
Oobleck must be like the personal shields in “Dune.” Why does Matt like “a big bulge in the back?”
The slow blade passes the shield, right?
@@P3x310 Exactly.
Rescale how you think about modern life. A personal shield today isn't necessarily about worn body armor. This looks like less than ideal armor, indeed. For a human. But I see this as a very slick hillbilly upgrade to vehicles. Image these oobleck vessels, 3d printed to fit, set in layers between body panels on cars. So that there's multiple layers&0wiggle. I image a soft plastic or silicone, that can self seal a little would be ideal.
Dat ass
@@arbhall7572 Non-newtonian fluids are being very heavily researched for body armor. Not oobleck, but fluids that become even harder with less speed. Think of a level 2 plate with a non-Newtonian fluid sack behind. The sack wouldn't protect against handguns at all, which is what the plate is for. Anything super high velocity will be stopped dead by the non-newtonian fluid sack behind.
Intros keep getting better and better. Matt: Pulls out the Barrett
Jigsaw: Where was that!!!!!🤯
🤣🤣🤣
You always store the Barrett in your prison wallet.
I think that was the Serbu BFG-50A, it has an opening at the front of the barrel shroud unlike the Barrets, you can see the reflection if you pause at 0:45. I guess the charging sound was edited in.
Also, the bipod is farther from the end of the shroud on the Barretts.
"When I go really fast on it, it starts getting hard"
- Mat, 2021
I was waiting for this comment 😂
Came here to comment the same thing, left with a like
I’m just going to say it
That’s what she said
Reminds me of a videogame I played where there was this type of leather armor that hardened in response to impacts
It’s seriously amazing how far you’ve come Matt!
I love how the end of every video is just "ok so we have the 50 BMG"
You spelled "BFG" wrong...
Been playing with this stuff for years. It's so freakin cool! So glad you're doing it!
My friend made ooblek, I tried it and it was fun, we placed catch with a ball of it.
"When I start going really fast in it, it gets hard" - Demo King 2021
haha theres 69 likes on this comment
This one deserves to be pinned
New camera, looks great, love the vids and these intros are getting creative
It coulda been really cool if you had set up the same row of containers filled with water and seen how they compared
I believe if you fill the jugs to the brim and cap them off, the caps will pop on impact, but the contents will grab the projectile more efficiently.
Basically when pressure is applied to it, the water is instantly pushed out of the cornstarch and it turns into a solid powder.
Matt, I feel like a huge factor preventing the ooblek from stopping rounds is that the containers you had them in were vented which allowed the ooblek to move instead of compressing when struck. So I feel like you'll get a better result with ooblek in a pressurized container - even if you used some kevlar vests stitched together and lined to be water proof, so long as the ooblek had nowhere to go when struck by a round it would be much more effective....honestly the most effective, comfortable, and lightweight version of this could be a kevlar vest in front of the ookblek which is just in a bag and nothing behind it...oobvest...
your videos are the best! i was thinking, like others, less liquidy, and what if it's packed in tight, like vacuum sealed so there's no room to move around. it would only take 1 or 2 bullets, then it'd start leaking out, probably making it easier to get through, but the 1 or 2 bullets it does stop might be able to be impressive calibers.
You should do with one big container because it probably had a delay to stiffen up so if it’s hardens then all of it will
I would like to see you try some flat nose rounds, like 40 S&W, 45 Long Colt, 500 S&W Magnum and 45-70 then do other tests where you compare round nose vs hollow point of other calibers.
Hollows would be interesting..
As the Mythbusters already figured out, also water acts like this more or less, at supersonic rounds.
So you have to repeat the experiment with pure water to possibly tell what the corn starch did.
You don't need to demonstrate a proper understanding of the scientific method to run a successful UA-cam channel, lol.
"Gun go boom, bullet stop, wow! I hit 'Like' now!"
Too bad the bullet/impact resistant properties of non-Newtonian fluid is the one thing I'd like to see experimented with correctly
@@bushwacker2048 ok mate, then do this, grab a gun, then shoot at whatever fluid you want. If you want the experiment, do it yourself instead of crying on UA-cam comments.
The understand is easy the more surface area the more stopping power the liquid has basically it'll stop a slap or punch easily because how thick those items are while a knife has a sharp edge with little surface area being forced in at its point giving the liquid less area to harden on a larger object making the knife go through easier.
Everything behave more like a solid at supersonic or trans sonic speeds....
That's what the sonic barrier is.
@@spygun0442 Invalid argument. One can demand quality or at least improvement in methodology of a demonstration without it being "crying." Hell, it's the youtube audience's imperative.
Enjoy the new way your video are. Love the effort of adding quality to your videos. Great job Matt 👏
What abt hollow point? Dumb theory but I think the bullet splits the oobleck when it goes through, like a knife. But would a hollow point catch the oobleck then get stopped?
I think you need to shoot the same containers full of water, so that we can see the difference.
Would be the same results I'd reckon.
Hey Matt I loved to see your revisit this Video but next time shoot vibrating ooblek Now that it would be in its starting state a solidish will have its actual density relatively mapped out And it would probably change bullet penetration
Nothings crazier than occasionally watching a Demolition Ranch video and seeing he has 10.5M subs when you first started watching him when he had 50k back in like 2014 or something.
direct correlation to amount of people losing faith in government bodies, we need to know what the average man can use for body armor in a pinch :)