XG Is amazing ! I love the vocals. Can we call it Xpop for all global groups ? Personally, I consider that a song is not Kpop when there are no Korean lyrics.
That was a great reaction! Especially the "pause" just before the chorus. Very honest. Again, thank you for your appreciation of and reaction to the Xtraordinary Girls. ! Hesonoo!
space and galaxy concept means unlimited posibilities simon really get it straight to the world why did he name the group extra ordinary girlz it means they have unlimited concept 🔥🐺🤘
great reaction and commentary ! my opinion is that i believe what simon / xg team were intending to do with the pause was to create some tension. the chorus can be seen as the climax of the song, so the whole song serves as a building up of tension until the chorus where there is a final release. the pause is there is better facilitate this release, when the music disappears you can’t help but sit up and wonder huh? especially because you are expecting the chorus, ur attention is piqued. then the chorus comes in and the release comes and u feel relief - of course, this ended up doing the opposite for a lot of people and served as a distraction instead, i actually do not like the pause myself, just wanting to provide maybe a sort of explanation
unfortunately this seems to be a common trend among many music video, not just kpop, the emphasis being on facilitating a sort of cinematic feel instead of a music experience which is what a music video should be. otherwise, i enjoyed the music video immensely and it’s a 10/10 for me
Thanks for commenting on the "pause" before the chorus. Pretty much every other reactor just seems to ignore it, but I find it an odd (and distracting) choice by the video director. The only reason I can think of why it's included is that it could possibly tie into a broader story arc covered by other songs/videos from their forthcoming mini album. (Is that why we only get a short peek of their spaceship in this video? Will it be making a return appearance?) Enjoyed your reaction! 👍
Thank you for your comment! During the "pause" there is a frame with some Japanese text: 感覚異常 うちゅうかいだん. Which roughly means "Problem with the sensor on the space staircase". I'm not sure how it connects with the exact storyline of this, or in XG's universe, but it seems the production thought it was a good idea to do this "pause". As I've explained, I personally find it very annoying. Pop music is like collecting feelings in your brain during the verse, energising them during the pre-chorus and letting them explode during the chorus, filling your body with energy. Right when all those feelings were ready to explode, the video and music is faded out, destroying the feeling. It's a poor choice no matter what. There is no excuse. It would be slightly worse if they have at least done it during the bridge and before the last chorus, but still a big no from me.
Thank you for your comment! It's a little more complicated than that. The language doesn't always dictate the primary target market. There are songs in English by Korean artists that the target market is Korea. Another example is a Japanese version of a K-pop song by a Korean group. Did the song magically transform into J-pop? Furthermore, K-pop can also be regarded as a music genre with specific characteristics both in presentation and production that are not found in that combination in other genres. So, technically somebody could make "k-pop" style music in any language by following those standards 🤔
Thank you for your comment. Of course, it's not KPOP. I'm also explaining it in the review. It's a global group with Japanese members, with huge involvement from Korea in the production.
Thank you for your comment. Of course, it's not KPOP. I'm also explaining it in the review. It's a global group with Japanese members, with huge involvement from Korea in the production.
XG Is amazing ! I love the vocals.
Can we call it Xpop for all global groups ? Personally, I consider that a song is not Kpop when there are no Korean lyrics.
That was a great reaction! Especially the "pause" just before the chorus. Very honest. Again, thank you for your appreciation of and reaction to the Xtraordinary Girls. ! Hesonoo!
space and galaxy concept means unlimited posibilities simon really get it straight to the world why did he name the group extra ordinary girlz it means they have unlimited concept 🔥🐺🤘
Japanese group sing in English, XG ❤🎉 xxx from Tokyo, JP🎉 Arigatou❤
You have so much more XG to listen to.
great reaction and commentary ! my opinion is that i believe what simon / xg team were intending to do with the pause was to create some tension. the chorus can be seen as the climax of the song, so the whole song serves as a building up of tension until the chorus where there is a final release. the pause is there is better facilitate this release, when the music disappears you can’t help but sit up and wonder huh? especially because you are expecting the chorus, ur attention is piqued. then the chorus comes in and the release comes and u feel relief - of course, this ended up doing the opposite for a lot of people and served as a distraction instead, i actually do not like the pause myself, just wanting to provide maybe a sort of explanation
unfortunately this seems to be a common trend among many music video, not just kpop, the emphasis being on facilitating a sort of cinematic feel instead of a music experience which is what a music video should be. otherwise, i enjoyed the music video immensely and it’s a 10/10 for me
Technically the pause is in the MV and not the song.
Thank you for your comment! Of course, that's what I'm saying too. Thank god it's only in the MV anyways 😊
Thanks for commenting on the "pause" before the chorus. Pretty much every other reactor just seems to ignore it, but I find it an odd (and distracting) choice by the video director. The only reason I can think of why it's included is that it could possibly tie into a broader story arc covered by other songs/videos from their forthcoming mini album. (Is that why we only get a short peek of their spaceship in this video? Will it be making a return appearance?) Enjoyed your reaction! 👍
Thank you for your comment! During the "pause" there is a frame with some Japanese text: 感覚異常 うちゅうかいだん. Which roughly means "Problem with the sensor on the space staircase". I'm not sure how it connects with the exact storyline of this, or in XG's universe, but it seems the production thought it was a good idea to do this "pause". As I've explained, I personally find it very annoying. Pop music is like collecting feelings in your brain during the verse, energising them during the pre-chorus and letting them explode during the chorus, filling your body with energy. Right when all those feelings were ready to explode, the video and music is faded out, destroying the feeling. It's a poor choice no matter what. There is no excuse. It would be slightly worse if they have at least done it during the bridge and before the last chorus, but still a big no from me.
👍🔥🔥🔥🐺
How do you know it’s not Kpop simple it’s not sung in Korean, it’s sung in English, much like Jpop is Japanese, Cpop is Chinese and so on
Thank you for your comment! It's a little more complicated than that. The language doesn't always dictate the primary target market. There are songs in English by Korean artists that the target market is Korea. Another example is a Japanese version of a K-pop song by a Korean group. Did the song magically transform into J-pop? Furthermore, K-pop can also be regarded as a music genre with specific characteristics both in presentation and production that are not found in that combination in other genres. So, technically somebody could make "k-pop" style music in any language by following those standards 🤔
XGはKPOPでは無いのです💦
コメントありがとう！XGはKPOPじゃないですね。その点についてはレビューでも説明しています。日本人メンバーがいるグローバルなグループであり、韓国が制作に大きく関わっています。
@@kpopnerdshow 理解して下さっているんですね。ありがとうございます。XGがXPOPを名乗っているのは深い意味があるのでコメントせずにはいられませんでした💦ごめんなさい
次のリアクションも楽しみにしています🥰
They are all Japanese and not k-pop.
Thank you for your comment. Of course, it's not KPOP. I'm also explaining it in the review. It's a global group with Japanese members, with huge involvement from Korea in the production.
not k-pop
Thank you for your comment. Of course, it's not KPOP. I'm also explaining it in the review. It's a global group with Japanese members, with huge involvement from Korea in the production.