Weston in a previous video you mentioned out of your mile stone boots only your Alden boots fit, so you’ve spent thousands of dollars worth of boots that do not fit you but you are giving sizing advice
My first pair of boots were ariat ramblers for Midwest winters..always hurts to wear so i never wore them Moved to Florida recently, my jim green vellies are in the mail
Here's my tip for new boots and blisters. Duct tape. If you find yourself in a situation with boots that are causing blisters and you have to continue wearing them, put a strip of duct tape across the blisters. Of course this requires that you HAVE some duct tape, so add it to your kit. I'm sure Red Green would agree. The duct tape won't slide around, and it will eliminate the hot spots that are causing the blisters. As your feet sweat the adhesive will become far less sticky, but it will still stay in place, and when you go to remove the duct tape it will pretty much fall off. I used that trick when serving as an infantryman (about a million and a half years ago) and it works great. My $.02
I know they sell stuff specifically for that but duct tape sounds like a good alternative. Especially since everyone pretty much has that readily available
@@SteelKreel There was some stuff called Mole Skin years ago that was for this purpose, and a lot of guys used it. Duct tape works better, and you don't have to be stingy with it. Pop the blister and take a strip 4 or 5 inches long and run it across the ball of your foot, or across your heel, or wherever you're blistering. It's really pretty amazing. The pain goes away like magic. The first time I used it was on a 35 mile movement (in a single day) that was partially road marching and partially cross country. I decided to break in a new pair of Corcorans that had an added Vibram sole on that little walk in the country, and they were eating me up at about the 15 mile mark. Slapped on some duct tape and did another 20 miles with no pain at all. That made a believer out of me.
MUGGS QUESTION: how to store my MUGGS during a Los Angeles summer?? I store seasonal stuff in vacuum bags w/ desiccant packets. Bad for leather? What about bugs? What conditioner to use? 1yr fan. VERY Excited 2 receive my MUGGS 📦! Most I’ve spent 💵 on footwear. Expect to enjoy for many decades. Video idea: what makes a good 🥾 cobbler? What to ask and request? Video idea: how to make leather shoe at home? Ur enthusiasm for leather & footwear is infectious and educational. With so much fast & cheap fashion, it’s nice to learn how to purchase something that will last. Thank you!
I’m looking at the nicks tactical boot. I’m curious if there is a big difference in water resistance between the 1964 leather and the rubber infused leather. I just love the look of the 1964 way more but I wanna how less practical it is with water.
Right!? I wear a pair of wingshooters with a composite safety toe and wedge sole for work (I work at Lowe’s in the garden center so the waterproofing has helped a ton and it’s the main reason I got them other than just the looks) and they are amazing! I swapped out the insoles bc I wasn’t the biggest fan of their standard insole but other than that, these boots have been so good and I really want to see what’s inside
@@TheWhiteTaco from what I can tell with mine, the Wingshooters actually have a leather welt correct? Where the Ashby’s I’m pretty sure don’t and use a plastic/rubber welt
Elk dude was just chilling, hanging out with his babies, scraping with the boys, and here comes uncle Kyle and the whole morman squad slinging led, ruining the vibe
Something that i always tell people looking to buy their first pair of leather boots is to keep in mind that they will not be perfect, especially the ones that are mostly handmade. just because it might not look aesthetically perfect does not mean its not well made. I've seen way too many post on reddit from first time buyers of any brand complain about "cosmetic flaws" that are due to the boots being handmade
Hundred percent agree. What i’d add to this is don’t buy boots if the price is at all a consideration. The cause of this complaining about little things imo is people spending $500 on a pair of shoes when they’ve never previously spent 100. From that persons perspective it seems a 500 pair should be a perfect product engineered to nasa specifications.
When measuring your foot size make sure you have had a decent day on your feet. Your feet expand during the day. So dont take your foot measurements in the morning, after a long drive, or working in a office. Make sure you have had a long walk or been on your feet most of the day. I use to work in a boot shop and i could measure my feet in the morning and after a long day on my feet and could have a difference of near half a size or full width.
I bought a pair of those Chippewa Apaches when I got promoted to a supervisor at my job 20 years ago. They looked like shoes but were rugged enough for work in a warehouse. They were horrendous to break in but were incredibly tough. Once broken in they were great and aged well.
Honestly Jim Green’s are my go to’s now. Got a double deal on the African ranger and Chelsea basically new on eBay and I’ve been wearing them nonstop. Great info!
stockman or the other one? are they ok in the ankle? i'm planning to buy them, but they will be my first chelsea style boots I don't know how should they fit
Ah yeah, sorry folks. I got the Stockman. I honestly love them and the fit is pretty nice. My only personal complaint is that the instep is a little bit low and causes a high pressure point, but I deal with that on all my non-custom shoes. If your instep doesn’t give you trouble in other boots and shoes, then you should be good!
Those chippewas were my first heritage style boots as well. I've had them for about 10 years and they've held up incredibly and are very comfortable. Still my favorite boots for riding ky motorcycle
I got Wolverine 1000 miles on sale for around $280 for my first heritage style boot. I thought they were more office wearable than others and I do wear them to the office. They are defiantly more clunky than a casual dress shoe but they look badass.
I enjoyed the hunting story, wish I could draw an elk tag. I appreciate the wealth of information and passion you bring to boots. You have a laser like focus on what is and is not working in footwear. As someone who: 1. wears boots 2/3rds of my life and 2. likes to be an informed consumer; I have learned so much from your channels over the last few years.
Drawing a good elk tag in Utah, Nevada, Arizona is going to take 10-30 years honestly it sucks. I buy otc tags in some states but it’s not as good of a hunt
I don't know how youtube works; however, I think anytime someone searches for a boot review then, this video should pop up. It will save us quality boot novices from making some expensive mistakes. Thank you!
For baristas out there, be aware you need oil resistant soles. If espresso or some syrup gets on the tile floor it will make night and day difference. Deanite, Grant Stone and Thursday soles dont work there unfortunately. Vibram 430 mini lug, v bar, doc Martin soles and cork soles work great. Tgis is one area where docks and solovare are good value though they are hated by many boot enthusiasts
As usual, Rose Anvil gives great, well researched, comprehensive content. But unless he has cut the boots open that you’re considering, it’s impossible to know the inner workings/construction of said boots unless the maker’s specify in their description especially in the x
I bought vivo magna esc, not sure if it's good but I wanted wide barefoot and flexible, well it wasn't as wide as I wanted even when I went for largest size on amazon 12.5. but it got streached overtime
My first pair was a pair of lineman 2904 from redwing. I got it for 30 bucks at a thrift shop. I've been researching boots for 2-3 years at that point and was knowledgeable enough but didn't really have the money to spend at the time. So when I saw that I jumped on it like a wild animal. Sometimes it pays to be a nerd.
The sizing point is the best imo, I went into Red Wing and they sized me at 9.5 which is 2 whole down from sneakers. So had I bought online and not gotten sized I would’ve completely screwed myself on an expensive purchase.
As a Brazilian who newly arrived in Toronto for a living, I'm pretty new to the 'boot world' so this kind of video is so helpful. I always liked this kind of roughed style of men's wear (that's why I've subscribed to your first channel for so long), but in the warm weather in Brazil is just not practical. I'm planning on acquiring my first boot, Blundstone is so popular here, but being a long-time subscriber, I just can't pull the trigger 😆 I'm going try some Canada West Boots or Thursdays to start it all, maybe in winter, I'll have to run to a 6-inch Timberland 'cause of the insulation and all of that.
As a Montrealer, I highly recommend Canada West! I got a pair of their Romeos (not insulated) and wear them throughout the winter with 2 pairs of socks (cotton and wool). And I've never had a problem with freezing toes 😊 They also sell insulated ones though, if you're planning on being outside all day in the winter.
@@annebojko9863 thank you so much for the feedback! The only problem is that they are hard to find haha but I'm gonna search for them here in TO. Do you have any suggestions for a rugged Chelsea-style boot other than Thursday and Blundstone for this price range?
Are there anymore companies making EEE width boots other than grant stone under 250? Thuraday kingmaker last fits pretty well as well as helm. Just wondering what else is out there under 300? Oh and allen edmonds also, fit decently dependent on style.
I got a pair of Thursday Captains after your first review, I agree these are a great pair of boots. I really wanted the slim silhouette and they look sharp! Thanks for your reviews, man, they definitely have helped me find exactly what I was looking for and I appreciate you. 🙏🏼
I'm glad you had a good experience.The speed hooks popped out of my Thursdays after less than 100 wears. $200+ boots and they wouldnt fix thier crap quality control.
@@lukecornett4874 geez, that’s pretty terrible. Hopefully that was just an isolated incident, but that’s pretty awful that they didn’t want to repair it. I’m sure it’s a cheap fix at a cobbler, though, right?
For me Thursdays just weren’t comfortable. They were too narrow and felt weird. Then, after reading multiple good reviews, I thought that it just my weight foot, and I gave a Thursday gift card to my friend. He also bought a pair, then changed size, but also ended up returning them. Recently I gave them the last chance and bought a pair for my wife. And guess what? After three size exchanges we just gave up. No more Thursdays for me. Btw, I have about 10 different boots, from White’s and Trumans to Iron Rangers. But only Thursdays didn’t work out for me.
@@kosta2177 that really stinks. I do have narrow feet and ankles, they honestly fit me perfectly, I guess I just got lucky. Well, I hope your boot adventures since have been more successful
Hi Weston and other guys! Can you say a few words about Drews Logger boots. They cost 350$ for a pair and it’s really good quality boots for this price? Frank at Spokane make their Patriots, and price 350$ for pair. It sounds like a good starter pack. But really it is? Or it’s a situation, when famous brand used their name for take more money? Interesting your opinion guys!
My first pair was also Chippewa service boot and 11 years on they still look great in fact I remember about 5 years ago throwing them at rocks and what ever I saw to age the things
Have had a pair of: Danners - too light and poorly built for any serious work. Whites - had to have a pair of steel toed logger boots to work on USFS fire crew. They were only thing I could find. Never cared for them. Never felt good on my feet even after ten years. Red Wing - just put my moc toes with 8 inch tops into semi retirement after 60 years. GREAT boots. Sticker shock on new pair almost killed me, but worth it IF a 75 year old can live long enough to justify purchase of new boots. Thorogood - moc toe, unwearable. Returned after one day. My advice - get better boots then you can afford. An extra $100 is nothing. You probably spend more than that on beer or your girlfriend in a week or two. Trust me, odds say a good pair of boots will be around long after your supposed soulmate has hit the highway.
From my own personal xp I totally agree with you. I work on a farm. Last year my cheap boots failed and I needed a new pair asap. I got a pair of Iron Rangers because, I thought, I could use them now and when I had moved on from this job, I would have them after for personal wear. They are great boots. However, because they're so nice, I have long felt that I should have gone with something more entry level.
i still wanna see the battle of the big box store boots. every time im like "ima get a really nice set of boots" i end up getting the 40$ special from walmart "Brahma Men's Alpha Waterproof 6" Steel Toe Work Boots" honestly i want a nice boot, but i can't try them on. I get scared to buy a 200-500 dollar boot that i cant feel on my feet first. but these bragma's are at least not a bad boot. i use them for work / welding in. they last about a year. the sole will basically get grinded off in about a year and the insole will fall apart after 4ish months of hard working or 6ish months of light work. then i just replace that insole and laces as the laces are just junk in general but i wont replace something that aint broke right away. my other issue is like you said in this video. my show size can be a 9.5 or a 10... while my boots can be a 9 or a 9.5, i just dont want to spend all that money for a boot that might not fit and have to send back. also my feet are not the same size. my right foot's pinky toe sits much farther up then my left foot making my left foot in this weird position that feels like i have a clown shoe on at some times. im just torn cause i want a nice every day boot like a jim green or a chippewa. i just can't pull the trigger on it... damn i ranted to long im sorry
Great video and very informative! In the budget segment of boots I recommend trying to find a boot with a leather insole or (more likely) a leather-topped insert. Standing directly on leather is (in my opinion) awesome! :) It's cooler than foam and does not stink.
Great story on that hunt. Those two young bulls owe you !! Another great idea is to check factory seconds of some of the mid-high brands. Some good deals there.
I liked that you told the story about the elk hunt to illustrate what you were looking for, awesome that you got a tag. Still trying to get one myself. I first got a pair of Iron Rangers, and I broke those in by wearing them with two pairs of thick wool socks. The breakin was pretty rough. I overconditioned them that first year so the amber harness colour is more of a very dark brown now, but they've got a nice patina to them (they're going on nine years of life!). I recently started adding some Thursday boots into my collection too, with a pair each of Captains, Vanguards, and Presidents. Those were a lot easier to break in, though the Vanguards were probably the worst of the lot breakin-wise (but probably my favourite pair of the three). Looking forward to being able to get a pair of Viberg service boots in shell cordovan one of these days!
I bought my first pair of whites 25 years ago I own 6 pair of whites 3 different styles. 1 pair of Wesco, 1 pair of drews I love them all 1 pair of my whites I had rebuilt by Frank's and had them lined for the winter my next pair will be Frank's they do very good work
It's good to see Chippewa has risen from the grave. Perhaps you will be cutting apart a new one?!? Here in Florida, Boot Barn carries nothing but junk. You find better boots at Boot Outlet.
I just bought and got in my African Rangers (got the regular instead of barefoot because I wanted that steel shank support) and they feel great. Had a little hiccup with UPS getting them to me, but I wore them for the first time today. Immediately put insoles in them, and I think they're gonna break in just fine. Thanks for awaring me to these.
@TravisHi_YT theyre going great. I've been wearing them as my primary shoe/boot. I haven't put miles and miles in them because I wear other shoes for work, but aside from putting insoles in them (just some Dr Scholl's Heavy Duty Support) they still feel great and look great for all day wear. I dont regret this purchase at all.
The way I used to breakin new combat boots is a short force march, and before folks call me crazy, the pain of unbroken in boots comes with standing for me more than walking. Walking with a heavy load for like 10 minutes the extra mass means you slide less, less blisters, and your foot pad presses down harder on the insole. After take them off and let them dry. Two or three times I they are set and I can go all day in them.
I really wanted the Jim Green barefoots for something easy to daily but lightweight hiking potential, but they didn't make them small enough for me 6/6.5. I bought Doc Martens years ago and I loved the style of them, but they aren't comfortable and have no support. The primary reason I wear them now is for concerts and I hate wearing them every time. I'm over the Docs and want something nicer. What could I get.
Cut a double h cowboy boot in half. I have been wearing them for 10 plus years to work and am just curious as to what I put on my feet. Quality has gone down drastically over the years. And wondering if I should search elsewhere for something else.
The major challange I face is quality boots for smaller feet. Someone is saying go grt ladies boots then. Well....the list of quality women's heritage or logger boots is extremely short and someone decided women have skis for feet and a D width is "wide". Mother's Day is months away, but making a list and doing reviews for a Mother's Day video or even mini series is an idea. I was also set up to order some Nick's when I had to hit pause for other priorities. But how do womens Carolinas, Cat Footwear, Chippawa, etc. compare? What brands make small boots but are terrible quality? I am still limping along a pair of Caterpillar boots from 15 years ago because PROPER boots under $500 are hard to come by.
Hey man, great introductory video, I've always liked boots but never bought anything over $100, though I use my boots often for camping, hiking and everyday (I'm a biologist); I'm looking into the Georgia boots, really like the logger style and their lace-to-toe waterproof boots. Would you recommend 'em to begin my journey? Are they true to size? Or would I be better looking at Irish Setter logger boots? I would mostly use my boots for hiking and trekking in dense, cold conifer forests, with occasional everyday use. Any and all recomendations and tips will be appreciated, keep up the videos!
I am glad Weston put out a video like this. There are many ideas we might have about boots that are incorrect. Regarding construction, I thought a leather or hard rubber outsole is best, combined with a cork or leather, midsole, and a leather insole/foot bed. While these are very tough and durable, they are not comfortable to be. I wore a pair of Red Wing moc toe boots casually for almost a year. They had the leather footbed and even a foam-ish outsole. While they were very tough and durable and the leather insole did conform to my foot like it was supposed to, the lack of rebound or give from the leather was uncomfortable to me. I ended up selling those boots (also, buying second hand boots can save you money!). I tried a pair of Thorogood moc toe boots. They also have a foam rubber outsole, but a foam insole. So dang comfortable from the first step out of the box. A lot of rebound and give. Sooooo, know what features and characteristics to look for in a boot. Also, find a store where you can try on multiple brands and styles. You may think you want one type, but a different brand or style may feel better on your foot.
@dyl940 oh man I’m already there lol. I look at Whites every other day and dream about them. My only saving grace is I’m horribly cheap…hence me gettin Thursday’s. I think some red wing iron rangers are next realistically.
I’ve hat boots since 14 but I got my first nicer pair over a year ago some Jim green razorback. I wanted franks patriots but being 20 I could not afford them so Jim green was my go to
i been thinking of pulling the trigger on some razorbacks, how was the size fitment? lets say, you wear a size 10, did the size you bought fit you right? i been dying to get a pair but my feet can be weird with boots.
I just came to the conclusion today that I should give up on my Razorbacks. I ordered my brannock but my toes touch the end of the boot. Really bummed.
I've watched a few hours from content from you and I feel I have a pretty good grasp of the basics. Now I get why my 10 year old timberlands still look and function decent in the leather parts and have fallen away everything else. Great channel man.
Yeah my timberland Men's Chocorua Waterproof Mid Hiker Boots fell apart at the soul other shoe and the inside material rubbed away so it's all shredded and crappy. I'm looking at JK boots and Red wing for my starter mid/ high grade boots. I'm still trying to get opinion for my use case though
First time I've heard a UA-camr tell a hunting story like I or my friends would tell each other. Love the channel man, thanks for helping me make more informed boot purchases.
I bought my first pair of leather boots almost 3 years ago. I had no clue what I was supposed to look for. But the use case was for all year-round everyday boots. I live in Nothern Europe where the weather swings a lot, 25C in summer, -25C, and a lot of snow. There happened to be this one very small local LP and hand-made clothing stockist store. At the time, I did not know they were also stockist for Solovair. While doing my research found this channel and also found that Solovair is a decent brand for the price. I still ended up buying those Solovairs from that store, just to support local businesses and skip the hassle with taxes, customs, and possible returns. Because of the previously mentioned harsh winter conditions, I ended up buying half-size up from my usual to have room for thick wool socks. During summer, I have an extra thick insole. That wool sock test is definitely my new standard when looking for winter boots.
Regarding boots not stretching, this is anecdotal and I'm not confident I understand all that's going on here, but this is my experience. I've been in the Marines for 15 years, have hiked/backpacked for 25+, and the only two magical pairs of boots I've had were an undersized/tight pair of Corcoran Jump Boots from 2003 and a pair of Danner RATs from 2013, both of which had leather uppers that had to stretch to conform to my big wide feet. I have a pair of Iron Rangers that were sized to fit and they are not comfortable despite breaking them in over a ton of road time and hunting in the bush and swamp. Based on my experience, I would buy a pair that is a bit too narrow if going with a traditional boot with a full leather upper, with the expectation the leather upper would stretch half a size to accomodate and form-fit to my feet. It goes without saying that a narrow or short toe-box is a non-starter.
Any recommendations for a truck driver? I’m 6’5” 305. I wore Redwing 4473 with laced in zipper as a firefighter for 9 years. I really liked them. Didn’t mind breaking them in. Lord knows I don’t remember the size. “Probably” 13 at the time but prob 14 by now. I wear 14 in ASICS and Nike sneakers and my current work shoe is Merrell Moab 3 Vent low cut in a 13. Mostly will be driving but am out at a truck stop (diesel all over the ground) or at a shipper or receiver in dirt, gravel, sometimes paved parking lots every day. I like the mobility of the low cut style and wouldn’t want anything taller than like a mid hight boot. Ice and snow 2-3 months out of the year but not most of the time. Does not have to be waterproof but of if it is. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Before I found your channel I didn't even know about heritage style boots. They are not found in local stores, well maybe Bomgaars, they some times have Dr Martens. Anyway Bomaars in the closest place to me to get boots. I also didn't know van's existed before finding you. I also had no idea what Nike made but new about the brand. Then again a lot of boots you cut in half I didn't know about. Some I did like Dr Martens but see more women wearing and talking about them.
Bordon is a Columbian company that makes stitchdown boots. They have a good reputation with some other UA-cam personalities. Aerosurfer, Bootlosophy, and I believe Nick from stridewise have given Bordon strong endorsements. A new brand gaining traction on the goodyearwelt subreddit is BLKBRD. It’s an Indian maker. They have similar models, and easy to upgrade leather to Horween, CF Stead and other name brand makers. Finally, Drew’s has launched a made in Mexico line with 8 and 10 inch loggers, and a boot similar to heritage semi dress. I’d love a review of Truman, Parkhurst, Bordon and BLKBRD. Drew’s Mexico line would be great to compare the leather to the bigger brands.
Helpful video. I have spent thousands over the past decade from Army to public safety and to bow hunting and beyond. I think I have tried just about every brand under 300 and now own a few Nick’s boots. I remember Garmont service boots where my go to in Army. Only to get a leather duty boot in black leather. I have wide feet and that boot was not wide. A painful lesson. Boots do not stretch as much one thinks. You said it well. One thing I have learned is a good paid of Merino wool socks can make a huge difference.
Wesley, you put together a nice guide on how to buy your first boot. I am not familiar with all of the earlier boots that you cut in two, so I am giving this suggestion in the dark. I think it would be helpful for those starting their journey into informed boot buying if you would dissect entry level boots. I think it would be helpful for entry level boot buyers if you made a priority list of boot construction features - like if the purpose of buying a pair of boots is to: be on your feet a long time/ have the cheapest re-solable/etc, then you’ve got to have (fill in the feature) and you can put (fill in the feature) a little further done the list of what you want in your boot. I am a gal with small wide feet who love barefoot shoes and I wish that there were more boot makers that would make men’s size 4 boots. Would you be able to highlight boots and boot makers that I could buy from?
Hello fellow wide footed gal! Redwings and nicks are two brands he has reviewed the women's versions of. They have the sizing that would work for you at two different price points. For a more barefoot style check out lems boulder boot, also reviewed on the rose anvil channel and has women's sizing with a wide footprint. Hope that helps!
@@Drwhitecloud I have the waterproof Chelsea boots from Lems. I really like them but wish the outer sole was more suited for hiking. I just wish there were more boot makers that would have sizing appropriate for small wider feet.
The issues I run into trying to buy any footwear is my size. I have a wide foot, but a small size, in a Redwing slip on rancher I'm a 7 EEE. I wore those for decades until something changed at Redwing and the boots didn't fit anymore, they were a bit loose, in the past I'd literally "click," my foot in. In most of the New Balance cross trainers I'm a 7 EEEE, if I go up a half size, I'm wearing clown shoes. 🙄 Currently I'm in Mexico on my motorcycle, and the chukka boots I found almost 20 years ago are done. I can find little here that fits. I did try a Mexican brand called Seven Leagues, in a 7.5 EE, but they were too small, and poorly made. I need help, money is not an issue, suggestions?
First pair of dress boots: Born Chelsea boots. love them still use to this day. First pair of work boots: Redwing Irish Setters. Very narrow, destroyed both pinky toes. Donated after a month. First pair of Heritage style boots: Jim Green Baobabs, love them still in the break-in process. Best feeling on the sole out of all Jim Green Boots so far. Current work boots: Jim Green Razorbacks with Safety Toe (9)/Keen Cincinnati with Composite Toe(9W)
11:39 Oh that is why my rothcos were so big despite being my size 13 medium... But yeah a thing to note is if a brand makes shoes and boots like they'll be similar like my Nike invicble run's and my Nike Manoa Leather SEs boot sfit me the same despite being all leather and 6 inches.
The REAL Service Boot was $300.00. My last pair. Much thicker, native American logo, cork outsole like a iron ranger. My first pair was bearly over 50 and was fitted with arch support and replaced my Buster Browns lmao! Saved my foot when i had a accident with a axe in the woods. Split vamp in half! Bannock size 11 1/2 E. 877s 12E or EE Iron Ranger 11E2 Chips arctic 50s 12 E Converse 70s 11. ( tight ) Asic 100.00 China sneakers size 13 😲🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤡
After 20 years of buying every boot under the sun and probably wasting thousands of dollars I finally broke down and ordered a custom pair of JK's which I suspect will last the rest of my life. Boot soles usually last me 4 to 5 years before needing a resole so I hope it's the last pair I will every have to buy
Could you please cut in half a Danner Quarry. I've got a pair and I'm wondering if they will ever break in! Obviously, I purchased them before finding your channel............😐
I made the mistake of sizing up for some boots because I was struggling to get my feet out easily when taking them off despite the others that seemed to fit well, not realising that breaking in and natural stretching would solve that. Comes from not knowing my true size since wide foot and everything fits inconsistently
My tip would be to avoid steel toe boots. Unless you specifically need steel toes, they add unnecessary weight to the boot and you’ll feel it by the end of the day. Plus when your feet swell as the day goes on, you’ll feel your toes being compressed from the sides. I bought a pair of Thorogood Moc Toe boots and while they’re wicked comfortable and my favorite boots, I regret getting the steel toe version.
Hey man, I love watching/learning from your channel. With all the newfound knowledge comes even more options and difficulty in buying a boot. Please steer me in the right direction. Please forgive me ahead of time for my lengthy message. My current work boots are close to 30 years old. Other than the last 4 years of using them about 50-60 hours a week, they were used for about 25 hours a week. They’ve been resoled a couple of times and haven’t needed much more than maintenance until now. They need some stitching. I’ve probably got about 25 years left to work and want a new pair of boots that will be as comfortable as my current boots with more life in them. I have been back to Red Wing but they don’t have anything that I LOVE and I don’t want to spend good money on something that I don’t love. I’d rather spend a little more to be thrilled with my purchase. I have pretty particular desires and they can’t match those desires. My boot hasn’t been made in some time. They look similar to 1907. They have 3 D-rings on the bottom and 2 speed hooks on top. 5” boot I believe and I can very very easily get my foot in and out of the boot. I realize that no one uses D-ring anymore so I have to surrender to that loss. I am currently looking at the Wood Butcher. I want these mostly for work (I hunt iguanas for a living) but also would like to wear them out casually. Please help. Thank you in advance
I miss the old Chippewa quality. I had the 6" utility boots. Years later I bought the same boots. They were flimsy junk. Same with Corcoran. I had a pair of jump boots in the late 60's. Bought them new in the box at a surplus store. They were solid! Now they make garbage.
I'd also recommend sticking to the domestically made options from any of the American manufacturers, they're the safe bet. If they're already compromising with some cost cutting materials inside on the boots they do make in house what do you think they're contracting for the imported boots ? They're always pushing their domestically made boots as the premium offerings and would not offer the exact same quality for less in the imported line. Another thing I'd recommend is sticking to boot companies/ manufacturers, don't buy anything from a clothing or sneaker...etc brand. If they don't personally manufacture anything traditionally made shoes or boots avoid them.
Hi there, it's a cool channel. I'm from Germany and recommend the shoes from Hanwag, Lowa and Meindl. Specialy for hiking. A lot from the American boot's they don't send them out to Europe. Greatings Branco
Aloha from the Big Island of Hawaii and I have a strange question. I've lived here for about 10 years now, but I'm from the mainland and grew up loving boots of all kinds. I love the nicer higher-end boots and don't mind spending the money for them. I currently do not own a pair here. The normal everyday dress is shorts and "slippas" (flip-flops). I only have one pair of shoes because you rarely need them here. Occasionally I'll take the Jeep off-roading, do some hiking, or go to some private shooting ranges, all good places to wear boots that are not too hot. The weather year-round is typically 65 to 85°. The ground is mostly made up of lava rocks and our relatively pointy and abrasive. Is there any boot that you would recommend that will satisfy my desire to have a nice pair of boots again and actually be able to wear?! Thank you, I appreciate it.
I was looking how to pair of JK and Red wings. I'm looking for an all-around boot that I can wear casual 8 or 4 when I'm doing moderate work. I need something that's somewhat well-rounded. Right now I have a pair of Timberland Men's Chocorua Waterproof Mid Hiker Boots and they fell apart from bare bones daily use after 3 years. So I'm looking for something more.
Not sure how many European viewers you have, but I'd love to see some boots that are easily accessible here, especially the more affordable options. (While I love the look of Nicks boots, their price and availability in the EU makes them a bit out of range for some.) Or, if you know of another channel similar to yours that covers the EU market, I'd be very interested to see the cut section comparison of the Panama Jack boot to the Timberland.
Yeah I would love to see some Carmina or Crockett & Jones cut in half, but I think he said he focuses on Pacific Northwest as he is more familiar with those and they are more rugged. European brands are more dressy aren’t they?
@@coffeedudeguy Dressy - no clue :D I didn't even know the two you mentioned, and I've lived in Palma for half a year! You're welcome to list other brands you're familiar with, I'd like to check them out :D It would be nice to have an expert dissect EU made leather boots so one can plan on buying their first high quality pair. Or even to know which budget brand is worth the money? I've been satisfied with my PanamaJacks so far, 4 winters in.
Just gotta say, great channel man! I’ve thoroughly enjoyed a nd benefitted from your channels for a couple years now. I loved the story of that monster bull you got! I always enjoy when you throw in mentions of your hunting and wildland fire life. Would love to hear more of that. The first pair of boots I had was a “semi-heritage” pair of Red Wings. Then I got into wildland fire with my brothers worn out Nicks. Then I got my own White’s 12” elk tan roughouts for my second season (and beyond. Have one rebuild on them). I’m not in fire full time anymore so now for the past six years I’ve had a pair of Red Wing 10877 moc toes. So basically 3 1/2 pairs of boots in my 25 years of labor on the farm, in excavating, in wildland fire, and now as a forester. I can’t say enough about high quality boots being worth it, based on my own experience, but your channel has taught me a lot as I look to get a rebuild done combing the wedge sole and moc toe styling of my Red Wings, and the high arch, support, and comfort of my White’s. Thanks so much for the awesome work you do! Keep it up! And keep the fire and hunting stories coming!
I wanna get a Dc Mrtn esque type boot and I know from his vids that solovair are the better option. However, I’m also willing to spend a bit more upwards of $300-$400 for my first boot. I really want it to be a pleasant experience so if anyone has any suggestions given the style/price range I’d appreciate anyone’s help !
If the forefoot and toebox were more biomedical (shaped like a normal human healthy foot basically extra extra wide for toe splay. ergonomically correct‼️‼️, that would be the only Boot, I will purchase from now on. I like the zero drop in the heavy duty leather in the 8 mm sole and the green laces and the height of the ankle.(almost looks like a desert boot from World War II. I believe they’re more looking like those types of boats.((please consider making them with an ergonomically, bio mechanically forfoot and oblique toebox.))
Just waiting for the trend to wear off and you will see many boot makers go under. Truman might survive but I doubt it. Oak Street and other similar makers will go under. The Whites, Nicks, JK, Wesco, Franks, will survive due to their core customer base.
Jim Green is doing some really cool stuff. Probably the best in their segment for build quality and durability. I have some Thursdays and some Jim Greens and I'm far more impressed with the Jim Green boots.
I recently got into boots this past year or so, introduction was a pair of wingtip Thursday boots, then I got Chelsea’s cavaliers after a break up. Tecovas cowboy boots, Beckett Simonon Jodhpur style boots on sale and I took a leap w some $68 on sale patina Portland leather boots lmao 🤣 way before seeing the video on their ethics being trash.. now I’m looking to save on my first whites or nicks maybe franks lol but first I think I’ll try some iron rangers to test my break in patience
Anyone experienced red wing roughneck ? I’m a trucker that goes through boots every 18-24 months. I also work in winter conditions for a few months of the year but we’re my boots all day everyday.
Just got myself my first ever steel toe boot...Steel boots made in Slovakia..drop a comment if any of you have any experience with ths brand..very few review about this brand on the internet..
My brannock size was 14 on one side and 13 on the other. I buy my boots in 11.5 it's crazy. I like a good snug fit. The guy at Red Wing sold me a size 13 and it was comically oversized. I took them back and got my 11.5 and was super happy.
I like redwing 606, but the soles crack before I feel like they should. Where would this boot fit in the scale of the recommendations listed here for something under $250??
I am thinking of getting my first pair of good boots. I do about 8-10 miles of walking/hiking a day (I’ve worn out multiple pairs shoes this year alone) and want to know if y’all had a good recommendation. I was thinking of getting iron rangers but I don’t know how good those are for hiking
Does anyone have any advice on looking for boots for people with smaller feet? It seems like a lot of these brands cut off their sizing at about a men's 7 or 8, does anyone know of any brands that go smaller or will do custom sizing? My instinct is that custom sizing is typically just done by the higher price point brands, but I would love to be proven wrong on that.
Help. Looking for really good work boots for on farm. Ones with heel and not a moc toe. I like JKs but missed the sale. I have GS boots which fit well and they are good for the office but not so much for work.
Get a handmade, handstitched, leather Rose Anvil wallet here - bit.ly/3XHs6CL
Weston in a previous video you mentioned out of your mile stone boots only your Alden boots fit, so you’ve spent thousands of dollars worth of boots that do not fit you but you are giving sizing advice
What about Golden receiver boots
Or ever boots for cheap work boots
nah im same size in all footwear
I'm just trying to find a good hiking boot
My first pair of boots were ariat ramblers for Midwest winters..always hurts to wear so i never wore them
Moved to Florida recently, my jim green vellies are in the mail
Here's my tip for new boots and blisters. Duct tape. If you find yourself in a situation with boots that are causing blisters and you have to continue wearing them, put a strip of duct tape across the blisters. Of course this requires that you HAVE some duct tape, so add it to your kit. I'm sure Red Green would agree. The duct tape won't slide around, and it will eliminate the hot spots that are causing the blisters. As your feet sweat the adhesive will become far less sticky, but it will still stay in place, and when you go to remove the duct tape it will pretty much fall off. I used that trick when serving as an infantryman (about a million and a half years ago) and it works great. My $.02
I've used gauze pads and medical tape, but duct tape is a great idea.
I know they sell stuff specifically for that but duct tape sounds like a good alternative. Especially since everyone pretty much has that readily available
@@SteelKreel There was some stuff called Mole Skin years ago that was for this purpose, and a lot of guys used it. Duct tape works better, and you don't have to be stingy with it. Pop the blister and take a strip 4 or 5 inches long and run it across the ball of your foot, or across your heel, or wherever you're blistering. It's really pretty amazing. The pain goes away like magic. The first time I used it was on a 35 mile movement (in a single day) that was partially road marching and partially cross country. I decided to break in a new pair of Corcorans that had an added Vibram sole on that little walk in the country, and they were eating me up at about the 15 mile mark. Slapped on some duct tape and did another 20 miles with no pain at all. That made a believer out of me.
Red Green. Now that’s a show I haven’t seen in a long time. 😂
@@aj_sanjuan It's getting to the point where you have to be like at least 50 to get my jokes. I'm glad SOMEBODY got it. Lol
MUGGS QUESTION: how to store my MUGGS during a Los Angeles summer?? I store seasonal stuff in vacuum bags w/ desiccant packets. Bad for leather? What about bugs? What conditioner to use?
1yr fan. VERY Excited 2 receive my MUGGS 📦! Most I’ve spent 💵 on footwear. Expect to enjoy for many decades.
Video idea: what makes a good 🥾 cobbler? What to ask and request?
Video idea: how to make leather shoe at home?
Ur enthusiasm for leather & footwear is infectious and educational. With so much fast & cheap fashion, it’s nice to learn how to purchase something that will last. Thank you!
I would like to have boots. The only issue is 4E has a very limited selection. Even with shoes It's difficult for me find ones that fit.
I’m looking at the nicks tactical boot. I’m curious if there is a big difference in water resistance between the 1964 leather and the rubber infused leather. I just love the look of the 1964 way more but I wanna how less practical it is with water.
I still can't wait to see an Irish Setter boot or boots cut in half. They do make two popular moc toe models and October is around the corner 🤞
Right!? I wear a pair of wingshooters with a composite safety toe and wedge sole for work (I work at Lowe’s in the garden center so the waterproofing has helped a ton and it’s the main reason I got them other than just the looks) and they are amazing! I swapped out the insoles bc I wasn’t the biggest fan of their standard insole but other than that, these boots have been so good and I really want to see what’s inside
Ashbys?
@@throwmypackage yes, Ashby's and Wingshooters. Both are fairly popular on the job site
@@TheWhiteTaco from what I can tell with mine, the Wingshooters actually have a leather welt correct? Where the Ashby’s I’m pretty sure don’t and use a plastic/rubber welt
@@jarenbosman9769 yes the Ashby's have a plastic welt so the Wingshooter should be easier/cheaper to resole
Elk dude was just chilling, hanging out with his babies, scraping with the boys, and here comes uncle Kyle and the whole morman squad slinging led, ruining the vibe
Something that i always tell people looking to buy their first pair of leather boots is to keep in mind that they will not be perfect, especially the ones that are mostly handmade. just because it might not look aesthetically perfect does not mean its not well made. I've seen way too many post on reddit from first time buyers of any brand complain about "cosmetic flaws" that are due to the boots being handmade
Hundred percent agree. What i’d add to this is don’t buy boots if the price is at all a consideration. The cause of this complaining about little things imo is people spending $500 on a pair of shoes when they’ve never previously spent 100. From that persons perspective it seems a 500 pair should be a perfect product engineered to nasa specifications.
Same with milltary stuff... Like if you don't have losse theads you haven't worn it yet.
When measuring your foot size make sure you have had a decent day on your feet. Your feet expand during the day. So dont take your foot measurements in the morning, after a long drive, or working in a office. Make sure you have had a long walk or been on your feet most of the day. I use to work in a boot shop and i could measure my feet in the morning and after a long day on my feet and could have a difference of near half a size or full width.
I bought a pair of those Chippewa Apaches when I got promoted to a supervisor at my job 20 years ago. They looked like shoes but were rugged enough for work in a warehouse. They were horrendous to break in but were incredibly tough. Once broken in they were great and aged well.
Honestly Jim Green’s are my go to’s now. Got a double deal on the African ranger and Chelsea basically new on eBay and I’ve been wearing them nonstop. Great info!
How do you like the Chelsea’s? Are they the stockman? I like the idea of those but don’t see many reviews of them
stockman or the other one? are they ok in the ankle? i'm planning to buy them, but they will be my first chelsea style boots I don't know how should they fit
Ah yeah, sorry folks. I got the Stockman. I honestly love them and the fit is pretty nice. My only personal complaint is that the instep is a little bit low and causes a high pressure point, but I deal with that on all my non-custom shoes. If your instep doesn’t give you trouble in other boots and shoes, then you should be good!
Those chippewas were my first heritage style boots as well. I've had them for about 10 years and they've held up incredibly and are very comfortable. Still my favorite boots for riding ky motorcycle
I got Wolverine 1000 miles on sale for around $280 for my first heritage style boot. I thought they were more office wearable than others and I do wear them to the office. They are defiantly more clunky than a casual dress shoe but they look badass.
I enjoyed the hunting story, wish I could draw an elk tag.
I appreciate the wealth of information and passion you bring to boots. You have a laser like focus on what is and is not working in footwear. As someone who: 1. wears boots 2/3rds of my life and 2. likes to be an informed consumer; I have learned so much from your channels over the last few years.
Drawing a good elk tag in Utah, Nevada, Arizona is going to take 10-30 years honestly it sucks. I buy otc tags in some states but it’s not as good of a hunt
@@Lexidezi225 Yea, I'll probably be shooting deer for the rest of my life.
I don't know how youtube works; however, I think anytime someone searches for a boot review then, this video should pop up. It will save us quality boot novices from making some expensive mistakes. Thank you!
Agreed, recently discovered this gentleman and I now have almost 10 boot brands websites open now lol
For baristas out there, be aware you need oil resistant soles. If espresso or some syrup gets on the tile floor it will make night and day difference. Deanite, Grant Stone and Thursday soles dont work there unfortunately. Vibram 430 mini lug, v bar, doc Martin soles and cork soles work great. Tgis is one area where docks and solovare are good value though they are hated by many boot enthusiasts
Same goes for chefs or kitchen hands I guess.
Yeah I discovered Dainite is good for wet floors, but not wet floors with some moss or algae on it
As usual, Rose Anvil gives great, well researched, comprehensive content. But unless he has cut the boots open that you’re considering, it’s impossible to know the inner workings/construction of said boots unless the maker’s specify in their description especially in the x
I bought vivo magna esc, not sure if it's good but I wanted wide barefoot and flexible, well it wasn't as wide as I wanted even when I went for largest size on amazon 12.5. but it got streached overtime
Six and a half minutes talking about how to kill a wild animal with a rifle - lost interest.
My first pair was a pair of lineman 2904 from redwing. I got it for 30 bucks at a thrift shop. I've been researching boots for 2-3 years at that point and was knowledgeable enough but didn't really have the money to spend at the time. So when I saw that I jumped on it like a wild animal. Sometimes it pays to be a nerd.
The sizing point is the best imo, I went into Red Wing and they sized me at 9.5 which is 2 whole down from sneakers. So had I bought online and not gotten sized I would’ve completely screwed myself on an expensive purchase.
I would rather get it too big the first time
As a Brazilian who newly arrived in Toronto for a living, I'm pretty new to the 'boot world' so this kind of video is so helpful. I always liked this kind of roughed style of men's wear (that's why I've subscribed to your first channel for so long), but in the warm weather in Brazil is just not practical. I'm planning on acquiring my first boot, Blundstone is so popular here, but being a long-time subscriber, I just can't pull the trigger 😆 I'm going try some Canada West Boots or Thursdays to start it all, maybe in winter, I'll have to run to a 6-inch Timberland 'cause of the insulation and all of that.
As a Montrealer, I highly recommend Canada West! I got a pair of their Romeos (not insulated) and wear them throughout the winter with 2 pairs of socks (cotton and wool). And I've never had a problem with freezing toes 😊 They also sell insulated ones though, if you're planning on being outside all day in the winter.
@@annebojko9863 thank you so much for the feedback! The only problem is that they are hard to find haha but I'm gonna search for them here in TO. Do you have any suggestions for a rugged Chelsea-style boot other than Thursday and Blundstone for this price range?
@KMVS8686 first time
What size u fit, I am Torontoian , would like to sell my chewppawa , 1000 miles brand new. Forget about blundstone cannot compare heritage boot.
Are there anymore companies making EEE width boots other than grant stone under 250? Thuraday kingmaker last fits pretty well as well as helm. Just wondering what else is out there under 300? Oh and allen edmonds also, fit decently dependent on style.
I got a pair of Thursday Captains after your first review, I agree these are a great pair of boots. I really wanted the slim silhouette and they look sharp! Thanks for your reviews, man, they definitely have helped me find exactly what I was looking for and I appreciate you. 🙏🏼
I'm glad you had a good experience.The speed hooks popped out of my Thursdays after less than 100 wears. $200+ boots and they wouldnt fix thier crap quality control.
@@lukecornett4874 geez, that’s pretty terrible. Hopefully that was just an isolated incident, but that’s pretty awful that they didn’t want to repair it. I’m sure it’s a cheap fix at a cobbler, though, right?
For me Thursdays just weren’t comfortable. They were too narrow and felt weird. Then, after reading multiple good reviews, I thought that it just my weight foot, and I gave a Thursday gift card to my friend. He also bought a pair, then changed size, but also ended up returning them. Recently I gave them the last chance and bought a pair for my wife. And guess what? After three size exchanges we just gave up. No more Thursdays for me. Btw, I have about 10 different boots, from White’s and Trumans to Iron Rangers. But only Thursdays didn’t work out for me.
Same exact story here, Loving these Captains!
@@kosta2177 that really stinks. I do have narrow feet and ankles, they honestly fit me perfectly, I guess I just got lucky. Well, I hope your boot adventures since have been more successful
My approach is to buy the best possible long lasting boots and use them for years.
Hi Weston and other guys! Can you say a few words about Drews Logger boots. They cost 350$ for a pair and it’s really good quality boots for this price? Frank at Spokane make their Patriots, and price 350$ for pair. It sounds like a good starter pack. But really it is? Or it’s a situation, when famous brand used their name for take more money?
Interesting your opinion guys!
My first pair was also Chippewa service boot and 11 years on they still look great in fact I remember about 5 years ago throwing them at rocks and what ever I saw to age the things
Have had a pair of:
Danners - too light and poorly built for any serious work.
Whites - had to have a pair of steel toed logger boots to work on USFS fire crew. They were only thing I could find. Never cared for them. Never felt good on my feet even after ten years.
Red Wing - just put my moc toes with 8 inch tops into semi retirement after 60 years. GREAT boots. Sticker shock on new pair almost killed me, but worth it IF a 75 year old can live long enough to justify purchase of new boots.
Thorogood - moc toe, unwearable. Returned after one day.
My advice - get better boots then you can afford. An extra $100 is nothing. You probably spend more than that on beer or your girlfriend in a week or two. Trust me, odds say a good pair of boots will be around long after your supposed soulmate has hit the highway.
From my own personal xp I totally agree with you. I work on a farm. Last year my cheap boots failed and I needed a new pair asap. I got a pair of Iron Rangers because, I thought, I could use them now and when I had moved on from this job, I would have them after for personal wear. They are great boots. However, because they're so nice, I have long felt that I should have gone with something more entry level.
Wow what an elk. Great shot. They are such cool animals.
Please don't ever do this, never put yourself on the way of a chainsaw: 2:56
Omg, what were they thinking
i still wanna see the battle of the big box store boots. every time im like "ima get a really nice set of boots" i end up getting the 40$ special from walmart "Brahma Men's Alpha Waterproof 6" Steel Toe Work Boots" honestly i want a nice boot, but i can't try them on.
I get scared to buy a 200-500 dollar boot that i cant feel on my feet first. but these bragma's are at least not a bad boot. i use them for work / welding in. they last about a year. the sole will basically get grinded off in about a year and the insole will fall apart after 4ish months of hard working or 6ish months of light work. then i just replace that insole and laces as the laces are just junk in general but i wont replace something that aint broke right away.
my other issue is like you said in this video. my show size can be a 9.5 or a 10... while my boots can be a 9 or a 9.5, i just dont want to spend all that money for a boot that might not fit and have to send back. also my feet are not the same size. my right foot's pinky toe sits much farther up then my left foot making my left foot in this weird position that feels like i have a clown shoe on at some times. im just torn cause i want a nice every day boot like a jim green or a chippewa. i just can't pull the trigger on it... damn i ranted to long im sorry
Great video and very informative!
In the budget segment of boots I recommend trying to find a boot with a leather insole or (more likely) a leather-topped insert. Standing directly on leather is (in my opinion) awesome! :)
It's cooler than foam and does not stink.
Yep. And once it does break in it's more comfortable, imo.
4:30 🤣Im dead man!
9:40 You are killin the edits fam! Hahahah
Great story on that hunt. Those two young bulls owe you !! Another great idea is to check factory seconds of some of the mid-high brands. Some good deals there.
I would say go with a brand of boots that you can trust, for me personally it’s always been red wing
I liked that you told the story about the elk hunt to illustrate what you were looking for, awesome that you got a tag. Still trying to get one myself.
I first got a pair of Iron Rangers, and I broke those in by wearing them with two pairs of thick wool socks. The breakin was pretty rough. I overconditioned them that first year so the amber harness colour is more of a very dark brown now, but they've got a nice patina to them (they're going on nine years of life!). I recently started adding some Thursday boots into my collection too, with a pair each of Captains, Vanguards, and Presidents. Those were a lot easier to break in, though the Vanguards were probably the worst of the lot breakin-wise (but probably my favourite pair of the three). Looking forward to being able to get a pair of Viberg service boots in shell cordovan one of these days!
This is almost the same story as mine.
I bought my first pair of whites 25 years ago I own 6 pair of whites 3 different styles. 1 pair of Wesco, 1 pair of drews I love them all 1 pair of my whites I had rebuilt by Frank's and had them lined for the winter my next pair will be Frank's they do very good work
It's good to see Chippewa has risen from the grave. Perhaps you will be cutting apart a new one?!? Here in Florida, Boot Barn carries nothing but junk. You find better boots at Boot Outlet.
would love a review of drews logger boots
I just bought and got in my African Rangers (got the regular instead of barefoot because I wanted that steel shank support) and they feel great. Had a little hiccup with UPS getting them to me, but I wore them for the first time today. Immediately put insoles in them, and I think they're gonna break in just fine. Thanks for awaring me to these.
How are they going, I was thinking of getting some Jim Greens as my first leather shoes too.
@TravisHi_YT theyre going great. I've been wearing them as my primary shoe/boot. I haven't put miles and miles in them because I wear other shoes for work, but aside from putting insoles in them (just some Dr Scholl's Heavy Duty Support) they still feel great and look great for all day wear. I dont regret this purchase at all.
The way I used to breakin new combat boots is a short force march, and before folks call me crazy, the pain of unbroken in boots comes with standing for me more than walking. Walking with a heavy load for like 10 minutes the extra mass means you slide less, less blisters, and your foot pad presses down harder on the insole. After take them off and let them dry. Two or three times I they are set and I can go all day in them.
I really wanted the Jim Green barefoots for something easy to daily but lightweight hiking potential, but they didn't make them small enough for me 6/6.5. I bought Doc Martens years ago and I loved the style of them, but they aren't comfortable and have no support. The primary reason I wear them now is for concerts and I hate wearing them every time. I'm over the Docs and want something nicer. What could I get.
Cut a double h cowboy boot in half. I have been wearing them for 10 plus years to work and am just curious as to what I put on my feet. Quality has gone down drastically over the years. And wondering if I should search elsewhere for something else.
The major challange I face is quality boots for smaller feet. Someone is saying go grt ladies boots then. Well....the list of quality women's heritage or logger boots is extremely short and someone decided women have skis for feet and a D width is "wide". Mother's Day is months away, but making a list and doing reviews for a Mother's Day video or even mini series is an idea. I was also set up to order some Nick's when I had to hit pause for other priorities. But how do womens Carolinas, Cat Footwear, Chippawa, etc. compare? What brands make small boots but are terrible quality? I am still limping along a pair of Caterpillar boots from 15 years ago because PROPER boots under $500 are hard to come by.
Lmao, i *just* ordered a pair of JK OT's, its alright though, i dont regret it lol.
I was the world's biggest Danner fan until about 3 weeks after I got my JK OTs. ;) No ragerts.
For people in europe: check out urban shepherd boots
Hey man, great introductory video, I've always liked boots but never bought anything over $100, though I use my boots often for camping, hiking and everyday (I'm a biologist); I'm looking into the Georgia boots, really like the logger style and their lace-to-toe waterproof boots. Would you recommend 'em to begin my journey? Are they true to size? Or would I be better looking at Irish Setter logger boots? I would mostly use my boots for hiking and trekking in dense, cold conifer forests, with occasional everyday use. Any and all recomendations and tips will be appreciated, keep up the videos!
I am glad Weston put out a video like this. There are many ideas we might have about boots that are incorrect. Regarding construction, I thought a leather or hard rubber outsole is best, combined with a cork or leather, midsole, and a leather insole/foot bed.
While these are very tough and durable, they are not comfortable to be. I wore a pair of Red Wing moc toe boots casually for almost a year. They had the leather footbed and even a foam-ish outsole.
While they were very tough and durable and the leather insole did conform to my foot like it was supposed to, the lack of rebound or give from the leather was uncomfortable to me. I ended up selling those boots (also, buying second hand boots can save you money!).
I tried a pair of Thorogood moc toe boots. They also have a foam rubber outsole, but a foam insole. So dang comfortable from the first step out of the box. A lot of rebound and give.
Sooooo, know what features and characteristics to look for in a boot. Also, find a store where you can try on multiple brands and styles. You may think you want one type, but a different brand or style may feel better on your foot.
Just bought my first pair of boots a week ago….
What you get?
Thursday Captains.
@@uneartherosA decent entrance into boots. They’ll leave you wanting, prepare your wallet brother
@dyl940 oh man I’m already there lol. I look at Whites every other day and dream about them. My only saving grace is I’m horribly cheap…hence me gettin Thursday’s. I think some red wing iron rangers are next realistically.
@@uneartheros Hahaha, we have the same path. Started with the Thursday Moc Toe and just got Whites C355
I’ve hat boots since 14 but I got my first nicer pair over a year ago some Jim green razorback. I wanted franks patriots but being 20 I could not afford them so Jim green was my go to
i been thinking of pulling the trigger on some razorbacks, how was the size fitment? lets say, you wear a size 10, did the size you bought fit you right? i been dying to get a pair but my feet can be weird with boots.
I’ve found Jim Green’s African Ranger at least, fits true to the brannock@@AlteredCarbons
I just came to the conclusion today that I should give up on my Razorbacks. I ordered my brannock but my toes touch the end of the boot. Really bummed.
I've watched a few hours from content from you and I feel I have a pretty good grasp of the basics. Now I get why my 10 year old timberlands still look and function decent in the leather parts and have fallen away everything else. Great channel man.
Yeah my timberland Men's Chocorua Waterproof Mid Hiker Boots fell apart at the soul other shoe and the inside material rubbed away so it's all shredded and crappy. I'm looking at JK boots and Red wing for my starter mid/ high grade boots. I'm still trying to get opinion for my use case though
Are we just not going to talk about 9:40?
First time I've heard a UA-camr tell a hunting story like I or my friends would tell each other. Love the channel man, thanks for helping me make more informed boot purchases.
I bought my first pair of leather boots almost 3 years ago. I had no clue what I was supposed to look for. But the use case was for all year-round everyday boots. I live in Nothern Europe where the weather swings a lot, 25C in summer, -25C, and a lot of snow. There happened to be this one very small local LP and hand-made clothing stockist store. At the time, I did not know they were also stockist for Solovair. While doing my research found this channel and also found that Solovair is a decent brand for the price. I still ended up buying those Solovairs from that store, just to support local businesses and skip the hassle with taxes, customs, and possible returns. Because of the previously mentioned harsh winter conditions, I ended up buying half-size up from my usual to have room for thick wool socks. During summer, I have an extra thick insole. That wool sock test is definitely my new standard when looking for winter boots.
Regarding boots not stretching, this is anecdotal and I'm not confident I understand all that's going on here, but this is my experience. I've been in the Marines for 15 years, have hiked/backpacked for 25+, and the only two magical pairs of boots I've had were an undersized/tight pair of Corcoran Jump Boots from 2003 and a pair of Danner RATs from 2013, both of which had leather uppers that had to stretch to conform to my big wide feet. I have a pair of Iron Rangers that were sized to fit and they are not comfortable despite breaking them in over a ton of road time and hunting in the bush and swamp. Based on my experience, I would buy a pair that is a bit too narrow if going with a traditional boot with a full leather upper, with the expectation the leather upper would stretch half a size to accomodate and form-fit to my feet. It goes without saying that a narrow or short toe-box is a non-starter.
I’m a woman so would love to know how to go about finding some feminine looking boots 🥲
There are women's boots. Red Wing makes them. Maybe some of the Pacific Northwest boot makers.
Any thoughts on wolverine boots?
I like them.
Any recommendations for a truck driver? I’m 6’5” 305. I wore Redwing 4473 with laced in zipper as a firefighter for 9 years. I really liked them. Didn’t mind breaking them in. Lord knows I don’t remember the size. “Probably” 13 at the time but prob 14 by now. I wear 14 in ASICS and Nike sneakers and my current work shoe is Merrell Moab 3 Vent low cut in a 13. Mostly will be driving but am out at a truck stop (diesel all over the ground) or at a shipper or receiver in dirt, gravel, sometimes paved parking lots every day. I like the mobility of the low cut style and wouldn’t want anything taller than like a mid hight boot. Ice and snow 2-3 months out of the year but not most of the time. Does not have to be waterproof but of if it is. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks a lot for that video, I appreciate the information you shared with us! could you do a video about good quality boots from Europe?
I would also appreciate that kind of video. At one point he made a video about ECCO boots and those looked great.
Before I found your channel I didn't even know about heritage style boots. They are not found in local stores, well maybe Bomgaars, they some times have Dr Martens. Anyway Bomaars in the closest place to me to get boots. I also didn't know van's existed before finding you. I also had no idea what Nike made but new about the brand. Then again a lot of boots you cut in half I didn't know about. Some I did like Dr Martens but see more women wearing and talking about them.
I need help getting a steel toe boot. Do you recommend the Chippewa Men's Classic 2.0 Boot? Please help.
Bordon is a Columbian company that makes stitchdown boots. They have a good reputation with some other UA-cam personalities. Aerosurfer, Bootlosophy, and I believe Nick from stridewise have given Bordon strong endorsements.
A new brand gaining traction on the goodyearwelt subreddit is BLKBRD. It’s an Indian maker. They have similar models, and easy to upgrade leather to Horween, CF Stead and other name brand makers.
Finally, Drew’s has launched a made in Mexico line with 8 and 10 inch loggers, and a boot similar to heritage semi dress.
I’d love a review of Truman, Parkhurst, Bordon and BLKBRD. Drew’s Mexico line would be great to compare the leather to the bigger brands.
Colombian*
Helpful video. I have spent thousands over the past decade from Army to public safety and to bow hunting and beyond. I think I have tried just about every brand under 300 and now own a few Nick’s boots. I remember Garmont service boots where my go to in Army. Only to get a leather duty boot in black leather. I have wide feet and that boot was not wide. A painful lesson. Boots do not stretch as much one thinks. You said it well. One thing I have learned is a good paid of Merino wool socks can make a huge difference.
Wesley, you put together a nice guide on how to buy your first boot. I am not familiar with all of the earlier boots that you cut in two, so I am giving this suggestion in the dark. I think it would be helpful for those starting their journey into informed boot buying if you would dissect entry level boots.
I think it would be helpful for entry level boot buyers if you made a priority list of boot construction features - like if the purpose of buying a pair of boots is to:
be on your feet a long time/ have the cheapest re-solable/etc, then you’ve got to have (fill in the feature) and you can put (fill in the feature) a little further done the list of what you want in your boot.
I am a gal with small wide feet who love barefoot shoes and I wish that there were more boot makers that would make men’s size 4 boots. Would you be able to highlight boots and boot makers that I could buy from?
Hello fellow wide footed gal! Redwings and nicks are two brands he has reviewed the women's versions of. They have the sizing that would work for you at two different price points. For a more barefoot style check out lems boulder boot, also reviewed on the rose anvil channel and has women's sizing with a wide footprint. Hope that helps!
@@Drwhitecloud I have the waterproof Chelsea boots from Lems. I really like them but wish the outer sole was more suited for hiking. I just wish there were more boot makers that would have sizing appropriate for small wider feet.
The issues I run into trying to buy any footwear is my size. I have a wide foot, but a small size, in a Redwing slip on rancher I'm a 7 EEE. I wore those for decades until something changed at Redwing and the boots didn't fit anymore, they were a bit loose, in the past I'd literally "click," my foot in. In most of the New Balance cross trainers I'm a 7 EEEE, if I go up a half size, I'm wearing clown shoes. 🙄 Currently I'm in Mexico on my motorcycle, and the chukka boots I found almost 20 years ago are done. I can find little here that fits. I did try a Mexican brand called Seven Leagues, in a 7.5 EE, but they were too small, and poorly made. I need help, money is not an issue, suggestions?
Congratulations on the awesome Elk hunt. I still waiting to get my first boots. Love your videos!
First pair of dress boots: Born Chelsea boots. love them still use to this day.
First pair of work boots: Redwing Irish Setters. Very narrow, destroyed both pinky toes. Donated after a month.
First pair of Heritage style boots: Jim Green Baobabs, love them still in the break-in process. Best feeling on the sole out of all Jim Green Boots so far.
Current work boots: Jim Green Razorbacks with Safety Toe (9)/Keen Cincinnati with Composite Toe(9W)
11:39 Oh that is why my rothcos were so big despite being my size 13 medium... But yeah a thing to note is if a brand makes shoes and boots like they'll be similar like my Nike invicble run's and my Nike Manoa Leather SEs boot sfit me the same despite being all leather and 6 inches.
The REAL Service Boot was $300.00. My last pair.
Much thicker, native American logo, cork outsole like a iron ranger.
My first pair was bearly over 50 and was fitted with arch support and replaced my Buster Browns lmao!
Saved my foot when i had a accident with a axe in the woods.
Split vamp in half!
Bannock size 11 1/2 E.
877s 12E or EE
Iron Ranger 11E2
Chips arctic 50s 12 E
Converse 70s 11. ( tight )
Asic 100.00 China sneakers size 13 😲🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤡
After 20 years of buying every boot under the sun and probably wasting thousands of dollars I finally broke down and ordered a custom pair of JK's which I suspect will last the rest of my life. Boot soles usually last me 4 to 5 years before needing a resole so I hope it's the last pair I will every have to buy
Could you please cut in half a Danner Quarry.
I've got a pair and I'm wondering if they will ever break in!
Obviously, I purchased them before finding your channel............😐
Irish Setter................ there owned by Red Wing but half the price....you need to cut some of them....wingshooter...elk tracker....farmington
I made the mistake of sizing up for some boots because I was struggling to get my feet out easily when taking them off despite the others that seemed to fit well, not realising that breaking in and natural stretching would solve that. Comes from not knowing my true size since wide foot and everything fits inconsistently
Great video you put out yesterday! lol These extra channels are worthless! lol
My tip would be to avoid steel toe boots. Unless you specifically need steel toes, they add unnecessary weight to the boot and you’ll feel it by the end of the day. Plus when your feet swell as the day goes on, you’ll feel your toes being compressed from the sides. I bought a pair of Thorogood Moc Toe boots and while they’re wicked comfortable and my favorite boots, I regret getting the steel toe version.
Hey man, I love watching/learning from your channel. With all the newfound knowledge comes even more options and difficulty in buying a boot. Please steer me in the right direction. Please forgive me ahead of time for my lengthy message. My current work boots are close to 30 years old. Other than the last 4 years of using them about 50-60 hours a week, they were used for about 25 hours a week. They’ve been resoled a couple of times and haven’t needed much more than maintenance until now. They need some stitching. I’ve probably got about 25 years left to work and want a new pair of boots that will be as comfortable as my current boots with more life in them. I have been back to Red Wing but they don’t have anything that I LOVE and I don’t want to spend good money on something that I don’t love. I’d rather spend a little more to be thrilled with my purchase. I have pretty particular desires and they can’t match those desires. My boot hasn’t been made in some time. They look similar to 1907. They have 3 D-rings on the bottom and 2 speed hooks on top. 5” boot I believe and I can very very easily get my foot in and out of the boot. I realize that no one uses D-ring anymore so I have to surrender to that loss. I am currently looking at the Wood Butcher. I want these mostly for work (I hunt iguanas for a living) but also would like to wear them out casually. Please help. Thank you in advance
I miss the old Chippewa quality. I had the 6" utility boots. Years later I bought the same boots. They were flimsy junk. Same with Corcoran. I had a pair of jump boots in the late 60's. Bought them new in the box at a surplus store. They were solid! Now they make garbage.
I'd also recommend sticking to the domestically made options from any of the American manufacturers, they're the safe bet.
If they're already compromising with some cost cutting materials inside on the boots they do make in house what do you think they're contracting for the imported boots ?
They're always pushing their domestically made boots as the premium offerings and would not offer the exact same quality for less in the imported line.
Another thing I'd recommend is sticking to boot companies/ manufacturers, don't buy anything from a clothing or sneaker...etc brand.
If they don't personally manufacture anything traditionally made shoes or boots avoid them.
Hi there, it's a cool channel.
I'm from Germany and recommend the shoes from Hanwag, Lowa and Meindl.
Specialy for hiking. A lot from the American boot's they don't send them out to Europe.
Greatings Branco
How about a cut away and review of the newer rock roosters with the vibram sole.
Aloha from the Big Island of Hawaii and I have a strange question. I've lived here for about 10 years now, but I'm from the mainland and grew up loving boots of all kinds. I love the nicer higher-end boots and don't mind spending the money for them. I currently do not own a pair here. The normal everyday dress is shorts and "slippas" (flip-flops). I only have one pair of shoes because you rarely need them here. Occasionally I'll take the Jeep off-roading, do some hiking, or go to some private shooting ranges, all good places to wear boots that are not too hot. The weather year-round is typically 65 to 85°. The ground is mostly made up of lava rocks and our relatively pointy and abrasive. Is there any boot that you would recommend that will satisfy my desire to have a nice pair of boots again and actually be able to wear?! Thank you, I appreciate it.
I was looking how to pair of JK and Red wings. I'm looking for an all-around boot that I can wear casual 8 or 4 when I'm doing moderate work. I need something that's somewhat well-rounded. Right now I have a pair of Timberland Men's Chocorua Waterproof Mid Hiker Boots and they fell apart from bare bones daily use after 3 years. So I'm looking for something more.
Not sure how many European viewers you have, but I'd love to see some boots that are easily accessible here, especially the more affordable options. (While I love the look of Nicks boots, their price and availability in the EU makes them a bit out of range for some.) Or, if you know of another channel similar to yours that covers the EU market, I'd be very interested to see the cut section comparison of the Panama Jack boot to the Timberland.
Yeah I would love to see some Carmina or Crockett & Jones cut in half, but I think he said he focuses on Pacific Northwest as he is more familiar with those and they are more rugged.
European brands are more dressy aren’t they?
@@coffeedudeguy Dressy - no clue :D I didn't even know the two you mentioned, and I've lived in Palma for half a year! You're welcome to list other brands you're familiar with, I'd like to check them out :D It would be nice to have an expert dissect EU made leather boots so one can plan on buying their first high quality pair. Or even to know which budget brand is worth the money? I've been satisfied with my PanamaJacks so far, 4 winters in.
Just gotta say, great channel man! I’ve thoroughly enjoyed a nd benefitted from your channels for a couple years now. I loved the story of that monster bull you got! I always enjoy when you throw in mentions of your hunting and wildland fire life. Would love to hear more of that. The first pair of boots I had was a “semi-heritage” pair of Red Wings. Then I got into wildland fire with my brothers worn out Nicks. Then I got my own White’s 12” elk tan roughouts for my second season (and beyond. Have one rebuild on them). I’m not in fire full time anymore so now for the past six years I’ve had a pair of Red Wing 10877 moc toes. So basically 3 1/2 pairs of boots in my 25 years of labor on the farm, in excavating, in wildland fire, and now as a forester. I can’t say enough about high quality boots being worth it, based on my own experience, but your channel has taught me a lot as I look to get a rebuild done combing the wedge sole and moc toe styling of my Red Wings, and the high arch, support, and comfort of my White’s. Thanks so much for the awesome work you do! Keep it up! And keep the fire and hunting stories coming!
I wanna get a Dc Mrtn esque type boot and I know from his vids that solovair are the better option. However, I’m also willing to spend a bit more upwards of $300-$400 for my first boot. I really want it to be a pleasant experience so if anyone has any suggestions given the style/price range I’d appreciate anyone’s help !
If the forefoot and toebox were more biomedical (shaped like a normal human healthy foot basically extra extra wide for toe splay. ergonomically correct‼️‼️, that would be the only Boot, I will purchase from now on. I like the zero drop in the heavy duty leather in the 8 mm sole and the green laces and the height of the ankle.(almost looks like a desert boot from World War II. I believe they’re more looking like those types of boats.((please consider making them with an ergonomically, bio mechanically forfoot and oblique toebox.))
Good timing. About to purchase pre owned Coniston CJ. Do you have a cut in half video for cj? Thanks
Please do the Chippewa classic 2.0s. I loved my original pair and am glad to see them come out with these, but let’s see inside!!!
Just waiting for the trend to wear off and you will see many boot makers go under. Truman might survive but I doubt it. Oak Street and other similar makers will go under. The Whites, Nicks, JK, Wesco, Franks, will survive due to their core customer base.
Jim Green is doing some really cool stuff. Probably the best in their segment for build quality and durability. I have some Thursdays and some Jim Greens and I'm far more impressed with the Jim Green boots.
How are the Jim Greens after a month?
@TravisHi_YT I've had my African rangers for a year now and have loved them
I recently got into boots this past year or so, introduction was a pair of wingtip Thursday boots, then I got Chelsea’s cavaliers after a break up. Tecovas cowboy boots, Beckett Simonon Jodhpur style boots on sale and I took a leap w some $68 on sale patina Portland leather boots lmao 🤣 way before seeing the video on their ethics being trash.. now I’m looking to save on my first whites or nicks maybe franks lol but first I think I’ll try some iron rangers to test my break in patience
Anyone experienced red wing roughneck ?
I’m a trucker that goes through boots every 18-24 months. I also work in winter conditions for a few months of the year but we’re my boots all day everyday.
Just got myself my first ever steel toe boot...Steel boots made in Slovakia..drop a comment if any of you have any experience with ths brand..very few review about this brand on the internet..
My brannock size was 14 on one side and 13 on the other. I buy my boots in 11.5 it's crazy. I like a good snug fit. The guy at Red Wing sold me a size 13 and it was comically oversized. I took them back and got my 11.5 and was super happy.
I like redwing 606, but the soles crack before I feel like they should. Where would this boot fit in the scale of the recommendations listed here for something under $250??
I am thinking of getting my first pair of good boots. I do about 8-10 miles of walking/hiking a day (I’ve worn out multiple pairs shoes this year alone) and want to know if y’all had a good recommendation. I was thinking of getting iron rangers but I don’t know how good those are for hiking
Does anyone have any advice on looking for boots for people with smaller feet? It seems like a lot of these brands cut off their sizing at about a men's 7 or 8, does anyone know of any brands that go smaller or will do custom sizing? My instinct is that custom sizing is typically just done by the higher price point brands, but I would love to be proven wrong on that.
Do you still own the Oak Street Bootmakers' Indigo Trench Boots? How about an updated review?
Help. Looking for really good work boots for on farm. Ones with heel and not a moc toe. I like JKs but missed the sale. I have GS boots which fit well and they are good for the office but not so much for work.