Vinyl Sticker Showdown: comparing the BEST vinyl sticker companies (Stickermule, Jukebox, & more!)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 лип 2024
- I've always been curious what the best vinyl sticker company is, so I finally put it to the test! I've been selling vinyl stickers since 2018 and I've always used Stickermule. When I started in 2018, there wasn't much competition. But now there are SO many companies it's hard to know which one to go with, so I put them all to the test.
By using the same exact design file I'm able to compare how each vinyl sticker company prints. In this video I review @Stickermule, Jukebox, @stickergiant, @stickerapp, Sticker Beat, Sticker Blitz, @stickerbros, Sticker Ninja, and Vinyl Disorder.
PS. I accidentally forgot to change the text for the Vinyl Disorder unboxing - my bad!!
Quick Facts:
✿ Fastest: Jukebox
✿ Cheapest: Sticker Bros
✿ Buy More Save More: Stickermule and Sticker Bros
✿ Best Print Quality: Jukebox was the sharpest and most vibrant. But Stickermule, Sticker Bros, Sticker Giant, Sticker Blitz, and Sticker Ninja were comparable.
Watch Next: • Make Printable Vinyl S...
Other places to find me:
✿ Website: www.JordynAlisonDesigns.com
✿ Blog: blog-jordynalisondesigns.com
✿ Cricut: design.cricut.com/landing/pro...
✿ Favorite supplies: www.amazon.com/shop/jordynali...
✿ Instagram: / jordynalisondesigns
✿ Tiktok: / jordynalisondesigns
Timestamps:
00:00 Intro
00:48 Jukebox
01:11 Stickermule
01:26 Sticker Giant
01:58 Sticker App
02:30 Sticker Beat
02:58 Sticker Blitz
03:20 Sticker Bros
03:43 Sticker Ninja
04:09 Vinyl Disorder
04:25 Side by side comparison
05:36 Who was the fastest?
06:58 Printing yourself
07:43 Who has the best pricing?
09:25 Water test
09:30 Peeling off for more comparisons
11:00 Grey paper??
11:15 This feels just like Stickermule…
15:17 Close up shots
16:13 The only eco friendly option
16:43 Which ones sell holo, glitter, clear?
** Affiliate links may be used in video descriptions. Your purchase price remains the same but I may receive a small commission. **
#vinylstickers #makingstickers #customstickers #diecutstickers
Thank you so much for including us in your review! If there is anything we can do to improve your customer journey or improve our stickers, please feel free to give us feedback. Happy sticking!
The crack and peel stickers were cool! You guys have great quality stickers. I'd love to see you be plastic free with your shipping, to give another option for people wanting sustainable options 🙂
Great idea@@JordynAlisonDesigns! We will pass on your feedback to the powers that be. Thanks again!
I love that you all responded. That shows respect for the reviewer
@@latasharosich905 always! 🫡😍
This is amazing. I've been dragging my feet on committing because sustainability and eco friendly are very important to me. I wish there was an ecofriendly glue adhesive. Love that Jukebox uses ZERO plastic. Thank you for this video. Super Awesome.
I love when a company talks about wanting to be sustainable/plastic free and actually does it. I have a friend who gets other products from them and they're still plastic free with larger boxes!!
Wow, thank you so much for including us! If you send me your order # we will send you an updated order on our new vinyl! No more blueish hue and much more premium than most ❤️. Thank you for this video!
Oooh that's exciting to hear! I believe I deleted the email with the order number. Loved your stickers regardless 🎉
This is the best sticker comparison video on the internet. 😊 Thank you for doing this and all the information you included into it.
Thank you so much, I appreciate it! It took a lot to prep this video, so I'm glad it's helpful 🙂
@@JordynAlisonDesigns One more thing I'm still curious about this sticker app Matte finish I don't think they got represented.
@@ScottRayok I didn't see an option for matte when I purchased. I saw someone else comment that it is available when you're in the image editing section, so it's not as easy to find as every other site!
OMG I love you for making this video! Choosing the right companies to order from demands so much research, thank you so much for your generous review 🫶🫶
you are SO welcome! I had my mind set on making this video for months, and was so glad I did it! I'm glad you found it helpful 😊
I have been ordering stickers from Sticker Mule for a long time and I just want to add my experience with them.
Sticker Mule sent me a wrong order (someone else's) and they were not able to replace my stickers saying that it was too large of an order for them to fulfilled in time for my show. (I had an extra week until my show, but they still weren't able to do it in time). I wasn't happy with their customer service.
Also their hologram stickers tend to have a big line that goes through it. They replaced them for me before admitting it as their fault, but the last time, they said their paper is like that and didn't replace them for me. Also one time, their hologram stickers had debossed dust/sand prints. They said that their machine needed to be cleaned and they did replace those for me, but it happened 2-3 times.
Ohhhh yikes! Thank you for sharing your experience. I had good customer support when I had one issue, but I'm assuming that as they've grown it's made their rules get tighter around what they'll refund.
@@JordynAlisonDesigns I just felt like they treat small orders better because it’s easier to replace and they get more good reviews.
For the large order that I placed for my trade show, I did end up getting my refunds in the end, but it was a lot of back and forth emails. I didn’t have the merchandise for my event. It was upsetting because I felt like they had enough time to reprint them or at least let the other person know so we can maybe send the correct stickers to each other. (I got stickers for a wedding event). I didn’t mind paying for expedited shipment and I’m sure the other customer wanted their stickers too.
Thanks for doing this video. I was looking for alternatives, but I wanted it to be somewhat consistent with the stickers that I already have, so it was very helpful.
@@purinpat Yeah that's really crappy, because now two people are upset. They should have sent you shipping labels to ship to the other person and it'd be fixed sooner! I'm sorry you dealt with that. Hopefully one of these other brands will be a good replacement for you!
Really super job on this video! Thank you so much for the breakdown!
thank you so much!! 🙂 I'm glad you liked it!
This was really interesting, thanks for showing these all side by side! This is a good starting place knowing that a lot of these brands at least have similar print quality, and I made sure the take a screenshot of your graph of all the sticker types each brand offers! I do wish you included a little more info about each of the brands such as the minimum order amount as I know that can be a huge variance between brands.
I will say also that Stickerapp does offer matte stickers! It's not for every sticker (I was recently looking into their glow int he dark stickers and that one is only glossy) but they do offer it for their standard vinyl stickers like shown here. It's a bit hard to find in their image editing check out but it is there.
Most sites are min. 50 stickers, which is pretty standard, only a few let me do samples! Since 50 is a standard ordering option I went with that for comparing the pricing (even if some let me do 25).
And thank you for the additional info!
incredible breakdown, thank you for doing this!
You're very welcome! I'm glad you enjoyed it!
Thanks for the informative video!!
You’re welcome!! I’m glad you liked it 😊
This is super helpful! Thank you!
You're very welcome!! 🙂
informative. Thank you
I'm glad you enjoyed it! 🙂
Jukebox looks more detailed. It’s the easiest for me to see and my vision is not too great but it really stood out the best.
Yeah I was honestly surprised with their quality since I had never used them before!! Highly recommend :)
what kind of matte sticker did you buy from jukebox? was it regular permanent or super
I believe I did standard matte!
Did you try a dishwasher test with them?
No, but they all should be waterproof! I handwash all my waterbottles, but I do know for sure Stickermule and Jukebox are dishwasher safe as I've tested those years ago. Stickermule stickers have been out on my car for 5+ years through rain, snow, sun as well!
I was going to try Jukebox but it doesn’t look like they ship to Australia 😭 stickermule seems too much to be just starting off too
ohhh no!! 😭 maybe Sticker Bros? I'm not sure if they ship worldwide, but they were similar quality to Stickermule
@@JordynAlisonDesigns I think I decided on sticker ninja, sticker bros was more expensive than both of sticker ninja and sticker mule 🥴😭 but I’ll be making my own to start with
Good idea! I hope it goes well for you 😊
Sticker app does have a matte option
I've learned that now, thanks to some comments! I didn't see that option when I was ordering though.