wow that last section was so beautifully put. i'm so glad you're finding your groove with reviewing again, you're so many peoples favourite reviewer (mine included) and you really have helped to bring reading for fun back into the gen z-sphere. love you always. straighten out that key, 2025 is yours! xxx
I think people need to realise they are the ones who are choosing to watch your content, and if they don’t like what they’re watching THEY CAN STOP, not the other way around. Keep doing what your doing, whatever unlocks your door
I do agree, however I can see how and why he takes note of those comments- it is his business after all and wants to make the videos that resonate with the most people.
This. People need to stop telling others what to do or read, isn't just exhausting but super rude. Let people be themselves, and do things that makes them happy.
I don't know if anyone else can relate, but the pop culture references is one of the biggest reasons why I fell in love with your videos !! your humour is just my kinda humour
Jack, Please keep doing these videos and disregard the haters. I’m 70 years old (I can’t believe it. Where did the time go?) You have such a passion and enthusiasm for reading. I’ve bought so many books on your recommendation. I look forward to your videos. You give me so much hope for the world. Thank you for all the work you put into these videos. When I’m feeling down about the world I watch and rewatch your videos.
Thomas, your comment brings tears to my eyes. I’m 32 and suffer from a chronic illness that prevents me from doing a lot of the things I love. Reading is my passion and Jack recommended some books that have become my favourite. I’m so grateful for his work and I feel the same as you : when I feel bad, I watch and rewatch his videos. Not everything has to be overly intellectual or discuss the terrible things happening in the world. I’m so thankful we have witty and fun people like him who can bring us so much joy, good vibes and great book recs! All my love from France (and yes time goes by soooo fast, damn)
The puppy exposing its belly & all it wants is love comparison broke MY heart ! Omg jack you are single handedly responsible for reinvigorating my love for reading ! In my eyes you are a treasure and need to be protected and appreciated!
I’ve missed all the things you haven’t posted - please don’t make yourself small. The haters and the envious will always exist but you have so many lovers and supporters! It’s been a drought without your book reviews, when you feel safe and comfy, please come back Jack!
I agree, I have been missing his reviews so much! There are so few other places to turn for recommendations and reviews of the genres I like. I need his reviews. Booktube needs his reviews!
As someone who is also very vulnerable to others' opinions, I can only imagine how you felt. Please know that you have so many people who enjoy your content, you are our little safe corner of the internet. I usually never comment but I just adore your videos, you made me excited about books again. Whenever I need inspiration on what to read, I come here. If I finish a book, I will come here to check if you have read it and what you think about it. Thank you for doing this and please keep that unique sparkle you have (and the amazing sense of humour).
PLEASE i LOVED your celebrity book club series and your yearly wrap up/reviews!! they were always IMMENSELY helpful in highlighting and introducing new books to me, or telling me more about a book i'd heard about but didn't know much of!
Although I’m just a stranger on the internet, I also would like to take the opportunity to advocate for the return of the celebrity book club!🤞I discovered so many good works from there
aww jack the end of that video was so unexpectedly emotional, all i want to do is give you a huge hug now 🥺 please imagine you are receiving so many virtual hugs rn, so many of us will always love and support you with whatever pursuits you enjoy the most!!! like you said, it’s only a minority and this will hopefully give them a reality check and restore some of their humanity. sending so much positive energy to you 🤍
All the things you mentioned that you were being criticized for and were afraid to show are things I love about you and your content! Love your opinions, your humour, your creativity and ideas. I’m looking to branch out in the genres I read so I’ve been watching a lot of your content and look forward to what you make this year!!! What you make and like is important !!!
I’m glad you addressed this at the end! I’ve seen people be so unnecessarily rude in your comments and I’m always so confused. I love your content and even if we feel differently about a book I still love to hear what you think because your thoughts are always so deep and insightful! The loudest voices are not the voices of the majority. Most of us just watch and enjoy without commentary but we’re still here and always will be ❤
It's so bizarre. People will say the meanest things online that they wouldn't dare to say to someone's face. Plus, no one is forcing those people to watch the literally FREE content. Sigh, some people...
You are the reason i started reading again during the pandemic ; not only did ur videos help me get thought the lockdown , they helped me reconnect with reading and fight my depression . So we love Jack, the old one, the current one and the future one, even when Jack doesn't love Jack
"over consumption" "anti-intellectualism".... I feel like these words have been uncritically thrown around a lot lately. While these things are definitely problems not to be taken lightly, I think you’ve more than proven your devotion to reading-both as a passion and as a culturally curious/intellectual pursuit. Ngl, I've missed your reviews because as someone who can't dedicate that much time to reading, being able to get recommendations and insight from people like you who can read a large breadth of genres is something I appreciate. I'm glad that they'll be coming back! Also, thank you for spotlighting Palestinian authors over this past year and a half -- true allyship includes engaging with and valuing the perspectives and cultural heritage of oppressed peoples. That being said, I am looking forward to hearing your thoughts on the African literature that you'll be reading this year! 🕊
Yes, thank you for saying that about over comsumption. I don't think it is over consumption when it's a hobby. Hobby is supposed to be something you are obsessed with. And books can never be over consumption, especially when you are reading most of them.
Yes. I believe making more lowbrow-leaning, less academical, or even full-on 'non-intellectual' content isn't the same as being anti-intellectual. The popularity of such videos over others might be an indicator of an overall trend towards anti-intellectualism, but on the individual level it is more complex and nuanced
@camping_here7706 I think this is beyond a hobby in this instance. For this gentleman, it appears to be his livelihood. I liken it to this: Imagine telling a mechanic he is overconsuming because he has more than one wrench, or he has sockets in different drive sizes. Or imagine telling a lepidopterist they are overconsuming because they have specimen drawers on display.
@BrandonK4 I agree. In this case, obviously, Jack is going to read more books than average people. I was talking more in the sense of this recent overuse of the word 'overcomsumption' for hobbies.
and @BrandonK4 Just because something is a hobby doesn't mean your consumption won't be regarded as overconsumption (If I have an obsession with Legos and I'm buying tons of them because it's my hobby, it doesn't mean I'm not overconsuming) The same applies to a job (a mechanic having more than one tool is example is redundant in the sense that no mechanic would unnecessarily spend so much money on the same tool if it's not genuinely needed and if i strictly consider it as a job only then being an youtuber is public personality profession , it depends lot on your "image" than the other professions you have mentioned. Also I remember Jack Edwards talking about being on UA-cam for creative fun and community interaction, not just for making money. When you are such a big name on BookTok and your earnings depend heavily on the people, you have the moral responsibility to at least, on the surface, show that you care about a problem that is very pressing in recent times (The same applies to celebs: if they rub in everybody's face that they are getting roomfuls of packages every week while some can’t even afford basic necessities in the time of recession, they would get burned no matter what) Buying books has become a performance or code for being a reader in yt, if you don't own a lot of books you are not a serious reader. Maybe, like some smaller BookTubers do, encouraging people to use their local libraries and not rubbing in their face that you have 1,500+ books would be better for all
I'm glad you listened to the alarm bells, noticed what was happening, and are able to come back with a new perspective because I do not doubt that it's hard to always have someone trying to snuff out your light for no reason. I hope the feeling of being a vulnerable puppy has been able to transform into feeling like a BIG DAWG that's going to be as loud and joyful as he wants!
Jack you deserve to unlock your full potential. You're like a character from a book yourself.. boyishly handsome, well spoken with an incredible accent, charming, optimistic, introspective, genuine, and so much more with a sparkle in your eye. I think you can go all the way, so don't be afraid to make some big moves this year!
you really helped revive my interest in reading after a long moratorium since childhood. you helped me discover so many of my favourite books and to also think more critically about what i was reading; i’m really grateful and i love your channel!
I genuinely missed your book reviews so much! You are the reason I started to get back into reading. I'm so thankful to you for that. Please bring the review videos back!!
Awe Jack 🥺 I noticed your content had changed but I just thought you were out there living your best life, walking red carpets and traveling. Im sorry you felt that way. I love all of your content though, and you’re one of my favorite content creators. 🫶🏻
I’m so sorry to hear this! I absolutely love seeing your content and watching your creativity, passion and enthusiasm for the books you’ve read or will be reading. You’re my number one go to for recommendations and opinions on books since I came across your channel several years ago. Please don’t sacrifice yourself or your phenomenal content to fall into categories others would have you fit…you’re WAY more than that. Keep being you, whatever form that takes!
Jack, you’re right, 2024 was tough and I agree, we should all stop making ourselves feel small. You do you boo, those of us who enjoy your content will always support you.
I’m sorry to hear that people made you feel like you couldn’t be 100% you. Your warmth and enthusiasm have always made you one of my (and so many others) favorite booktuber. I hope to see your celebrity book clubs and the content you love come back
I literally have nothing in common with you and our book tastes couldn't be more opposite from yours but I still watch your videos because you're funny and your passion is lovely to watch. You do you and ignore the jerks!
Honestly at this point I take majority of my book recommendations only from you cuz it's neverrrr dissapointing. And when I read something I love, I instantly want to go to your videos just know how much you loved it.... You are doing an incredible job my friend. Don't let these masked ppl everrrr drain your energy. Virtual hugss 🫂🫂 I love you and your content so so much❤
My attempt to make the love as loud as the hate: I love love love every kind of video you said you stopped making because of other people’s negativity. I love your personality and how much joy and energy you bring to reading. Being loud and fun doesn’t make you “anti-intellectual”! I really love how you tie pop culture and books together! The I don’t find it cringy, I find it fun. I love someone who loves literature being completely unpretentious about it, and tying in your love of pop music and celebrities and whatever. I love your celebrity book club. I know it’s so hard to not let the rude voices drown out all the others, but I really love your channel and it brightens my day whenever you post! Can’t wait to see whatever you post this year 💜
It's absurd to me that anyone would call Jack's reviews "anti-intellectual". How bizarre. His reviews are so thoughtful and intelligent, he actually reads his books and loves reading, he reads across many genres and he's eloquent and clear in his opinions. Does he make pop culture references and laugh? Yes! Since when is being aware of your culture and audience, or being funny anti-intellectual? How many booktubers give such thoughtful reviews? Definitely not that many!
The internet is such a draining place but your videos and passion in your videos are so fun and important. Your ideas and the way you articulate things is so refreshing. I love all your content and while it's awesome watching the heavier/more critical thinking videos the ones that are more just for fun are also so great. Sometimes we just need to escape and I'm sure most people here love just escaping into the world of books and your videos provide that. I'm sorry some people are closed-minded about your content. ❤
I’ve been a silent watcher on your channels for years now (starting with your study tips vids) and you are just such a genuinely inspiring person! Whenever I lose my own passion and motivation to enjoy just about anything in life, I watch your videos for comfort, insight, inspiration. There is no other youtuber that I’ve followed for this long; your content and your lovely personality are something very special in today’s social media spaces. So, honestly, thank you for persevering and staying 🫶
you are my comfort content creator on youtube, please make whatever your heart desires. if you are putting your time, energy, creativity and love into your work then that is all that truly matters. just be you ❤
Some people are going to be mean and hateful no matter what, and it has nothing to do with you. Just know the vast vast majority of people watching are watching because we love you and your content!
Jack, I’ve been following your videos for so long now. You’ve literally been here at the start of my 30s. First of all thank you for being so honest and vulnerable to your viewers. It really gives us all an insight into how you are feeling, which I think is very important. Secondly I’m not surprised you weren’t able to do so many book reviews! You were being flown about to Bali, navigating a place to stay and going to lots of other events and this is only what you have chosen to share with us. I can’t imagine what else you have been working on during this time. You could be the most creative smartest person in the world and even they feel the weight of emotion, the pressure of atmosphere as you go somewhere new for the first time. What I am trying to say is you’re only human. I’m very excited for where this next chapter of your channel is going, but please do keep taking care of yourself. 🙂
ngl i really thought you stopped posting as much cause you were so locked in with writing your book. IM SO EXCITED TO READ THAT WHENEVER IT DOES COME OUT AND YEAH GO MAKE WHATEVER CONTENT YOU WANT OUT THERE MAN!! happy to be along the journey with you
O my, that last part really had me in tears. I've been a happy follower of your channel all the way back even to when you were in your dorm room. And of course I pick up on changes in atmosphere and the kind of energy you're giving off, but I hadn't realised things had gotten quite so dire. I for one have praised you for taking us along through your life journey and for being so diverse and inclusive in your content. You actually feel like a friend I would easily have wonderful discussions with in actual life, fully knowing and appreciating you're the creator and I'm the viewer. Just goes to tell it kinda breaks my heart to hear you've been struggling with consequences of doing what you do, doing it so well, so... Jack. We love your energy and quircks and humour and everything, otherwise we wouldn't be here. But obviously a small percentage can't handle the joy you're bringing. Well, that's on them. Easier said than done, obviously. But please Jack, stay you, stay unhinged, stay sensitive and bold and keep on being the mayor of yap city. I'm so proud (...) of your journey and choices and stories, I'm glad to hear you've found your old self back again. I think it's amazing that your channel blew up, but sometimes I secretly do wish we were back in your student room with the nice group of followers there was at the time. Yapping myself now, so leaves me to 🫂 you from the Netherlands / Christian
So happy you're back and you addressed this. Your content is brillant and got me into reading (45 books a year for the past 2 years) whereas before that, I considered reading one single book impossible. You got me excited about literature, be it classics or more modern fictions. Your creativity, happiness and person are so refreshing. I hope you're okay, it must be very tough to ignore or live with those stupid and unnecessarily mean comments. (pls keep yapping)
Jack, it’s truly unbelievable how big of an inspiration you’ve been to me and surely so many other people. Not only did I start reading more, but I also joined a few book clubs and opened my own one thanks to you and your passion for books which is truly contagious. The „heart to heart” part of this video really broke my heart because you deserve only love, support and appreciation for what you do and what values you show us. I hope 2025 treats you much much much better than the past few months did. Thanks for everything! ❤
ugh i am so sad to hear you went/are going through that this past year. you are amazing and wonderful and i hope this year is full of passion, confidence, and excitement for you!!!
Some of us have been watching you since your uni days.. and I definitely started to miss you giving opinions about the books you read. Look what happened with Dostoevsky sales when you gave your opinion. It's important. You got people that likely don't read classics to pick up meaningful literature. I have a small idea/request that you do a "classics video" once a month where you review one of the classics and make it approachable for people. Pleeease?
your videos are always so on point. btw, just wanted to mention this thing I found recently - Forbidden Money Printing Method Ebook. kinda cool if you’re curious.
it’s an ebook called Forbidden Money Printing Method Ebook. it reveals some methods people use to create income in ways most wouldn’t believe are even possible. honestly, it’s a total game-changer if you’re curious about unconventional strategies
@@istandagainstoppression oh it’s ebook called Forbidden Money Printing Method Ebook it dives into some ideas about money that feel kinda hidden or overlooked honestly I didn’t think it would work but it’s actually pretty eye-opening
@@istandagainstoppression I understand your curiosity about this book I was the same a few months ago and bought it out of curiosity the book is the real deal not some nonsense
So glad you're back! For African literary fiction, you might like Umar Turaki. His first book, Such a Beautiful Thing to Behold is about 4 siblings living in a quarantined village where all the adults have died. His second book, Every Drop of Blood is Red, came out in 2024. It's about two families - one Christian, one Muslim - dealing with the aftermath of a hate crime after religious violence in Jos, Nigeria. Both books have a speculative twist and gorgeous writing!
Thank you Jack for being so open and vulnerable at the end. Never stop creating the content you want to make, being true to yourself and having grace with yourself. You've inspired me for so long and you continue to do so. We love you and your content both new and old. Never not be you please. Thank you honestly so much ❤
You are a precious bean, and I’ve enjoyed every single type of video you’ve done. The thoughts, the vibes, the fun, the range from deeper things to fun pop culture stuff. Do what makes you happy, and what’s healthy for you, whether that’s returning to the old or to step away. You rock. Thank you for endless entertainment for years now. You’re a treasure, that is all 💜
I think you have always done such a great job balancing pop culture/buzzy books and more literary books. You are truly the youtuber that I look forward to every single time a new video pops up. Love you and your content so much! I feel like I learn so much from you and you really help make my reading more fun. I hope that 2025 is much more healthy and positive and fun for you!
I love your content Jack! You are the singular reason why I got into reading. Your comments genuinely guided me find my favourite books. I read 40+ books in the last two years thanks to your content and recommendations. Please continue to follow your passion! Sending love and hugs
Jack! I have never commented on your videos and been a silent watcher for the past two years. BUT the last part touched my soul, I hope you know how many people love and support you! I ADORE all your videos, love your opinions and reviews. You are the reason I found my love for reading again, where I go for all my reviews, my comfort channel and has inspired me to read more fiction from around the world and translated fiction. You inspire me!
i’ve been watching your videos from the past few years cause i love to hear you talk about books and i’ve missed that. don’t listen to the cacophony of haters, listen to what’s in your heart. we’re here to love and support you. can’t wait for more jack x
As someone who watches pretty much every video you post (on both channels) since your studytube GSCE/A Level days, the celebrity book club and the fun, creative, pop culture videos you were making at the time were my absolute favorites. ❤
Always lifts up the spirits ... "Someday, I'll be living in a big old city And all you′re ever gonna be is mean Someday, I′ll be big enough so you can't hit me And all you′re ever gonna be is mean Why you gotta be so mean?" We're always here with u Jack
I just want you to know that your snappy, fun book reviews are what got me back into reading. I hope that you do what makes you happy moving forward, regardless of what other people say or feel. You have a lot of people that love your content💗
Hi Jack. I mainly read SFF and you are usually my guide for literary fiction. Don't listen to the hate comments. I know they are the loud ones. Your actual audience loves your content, no matter how you decide to present it. :) btw excellent list, many of thes were on my radar as well.
You are truly an amazing person. Whenever I feel overwhelmed by the stress of not being able to read for months due to college, I turn to your videos to find motivation again. Your passion for books shines through every time you speak, reminding me of the love for reading that I often forget. On top of that, your sense of humor makes your videos even more enjoyable than they already are. Never stop being who you are, because I know you are a wonderful person. There are very few people in this world who can genuinely be considered to have a big heart, but I know, without a doubt, that you are one of them.
Your content has been what kept me connected to books during a multi year struggle with depression and anxiety. I found you during the pandemic and have been incredibly grateful for the channel. I love books but struggled with being able to engage with them for nearly 4 years, which was its own kind of devastation. Your love of literature and passion for sharing kept me engaged in a thing I love even when I wasn't able to finish a book. Thank you. 💜 I'm sorry the internet has been such a brutal place, and I am glad you have been able to find some peace and rejuvenation. I look forward to whatever content you make this year, and hope you are able to find joy in the process.
Jack, you're so smart, funny, interesting, innovative, thoughtful, dedicated, kind, passionate, and so much more! Keep creating content that brings you joy. What you do and how you do it is truly special. The internet can be a scary place, but you make it brighter and better, and I’m so glad you’re here. I hope to find a job I’m as passionate about as you are about yours, and I hope you can find the kindness and comfort on the internet that I’ve found in your videos 💙
I was browsing my local bookstore a few months back and spotted a copy of Small Things Like These by Claire Keegan. I remembered you had talked about her and really like her writing, so I picked it up. I absolutely loved it - so thank you for that recommendation! ❤❤❤
Oh, Jack. Thank you for being so vulnerable and honest with all of your viewers. I have missed your videos and had a feeling something was going on, I am so sorry this was it. I work in an area where I receive massive amounts of people criticising but sometimes it feels like it is not to help me improve but rather to break me down ( and the ones who do that are a small number but wow can they have an impact). I am not on the internet, so I can not imagine experiencing that at your level. Your videos have always been such a comfort to me, and I have read so many great books because of you; I don't always like the same books as you but I appreciate your perspective and take on them. Not sure if you will even see this but your honesty compelled me to respond ( which I rarely do haha). I look forward to your future content.Take good care
jack i love you and your content. haters can only wish to have a smidge of your charisma and candor. keep being you and putting what you want to put out in the world and don’t let them bring you down. i’m giving you a forehead kiss
Dear Jack, I’ve been subscribed to your channel since you were working your publishing job and before you were actually able to have your graduation ceremony because of COVID. Everything you mentioned you had to stop doing because of comments, is the reason myself and many others loved and continue to your channel. I can’t begin to imagine what’s like to be someone with an online presence. It’s my wish for you for this new year that you find joy in this again. I hope you know just how much you’ve inspired us and have made us proud to support you. Not only because of your accomplishments but your dedication and willingness to better yourself. Much love to you from a stranger who is so thankful to have found your channel.
Thanks to you I fell in love with reading again, I've found a few of my new favorite books through your channels. I have had the most interesting discussions about books with other people thanks to you. I've broadened my horizons, reading more about real people than just straight fantasy novels. You deserve to feel safe, whether you're sharing an opinion online or with your friends and family, never apologize for being yourself-you can't be anyone else.
Aw the idea of the dog getting heaps of belly rubs but one punch is so true and sad. It sucks how people like to tear others down. Even just the number of opinions must be overwhelming sometimes. Putting yourself out there as you do is so brave. Sending you virtual hugs 💜
Your channel has helped me not only in my education but also my personal life too...getting me out of my reading slumps more times than I could count...please keep doing what you do...give your reviews...criticism...it lightens up my day to say the least...and that what makes your channel unique and interesting!!! Do what you want to do...and be what you want to be...ignore the haters...all the love 🥰
Jack, you are loved. There are 1.4 million people that like you. There will always be people who don't like you or are just unhappy and mean. Listen to those of us that love you and your channel.
This took such a deep and meaningful turn and I'm grateful that you felt comfortable enough to share with us how it's been for you lately. You are lovely and please don't let anyone take away your spark.
I wish you well, Jack. I hope you are loving your new living space and neighborhood! Your room is fantastic with the huge windows and sunlight, and you have made it quite a cozy bedroom & library, which is something to be proud of.
Jack, thank you so much for these past few years. It really means the world to me. You got me into reading when I was someone who couldn’t even look at a book. Please keep doing what you’re doing, and don’t listen to the haters. I’ve really missed your old content, especially the ‘celebrity’s favorite books’ series. And seriously, don’t hold back on your opinions-everyone’s entitled to them, and people should respect that. I hope 2025 is amazing for you, and I can’t wait for your new videos. Keep being yourself; you've come this far, so keep doing what you do. I even watch your videos with my mom, who’s super busy, but it’s become a great way for us to connect over literature. Thank you, really.
Jack I’ve been watching you for years now and I’m so sorry that you felt that way last year! Please know that the majority of people that love and connect with your videos are probably not commenting, they’re just watching and enjoying your content. Your videos and love for books are infectious and inspired me in my own life to start working in a bookshop and share that with even more people. Never stop doing what you love and certainly don’t apologise for it. We love you bestieee🫶🫶🫶
Discovering your channel (3 years ago) is one of the reasons I got back into reading, and since then I’ve read more than 150+ books. 📚 so please know that your job to influence people to get excited about reading have reached at least +1 audience. 😊 I'm cheering for you.
jack, you have gotten thousands of people into reading and literature by being your amazing self. your passion, optimism, and voice are infectious in the best ways. please never change & know that so many of us love and appreciate you for you!!! excited to see that passion reignite within you
You are my safe space on the internet and I’m sorry it no longer felt safe for you, I’m so glad you’re no longer going to let small minds dull your sparkle. I’m very excited to see what you have in store for us in 2025 x
So sad that you’ve felt so small and trapped, but I’m glad you took the time to take care of yourself and reconnect with what you loved. Keep being you!
thx for being vulnerable w us!!!! SENDING LOVE AND LOTSA HUGS!!! cant wait to watch more of the content YOU want to make. haters gonna hate, just gotta ignore them and do whatever you want to do :)
So so so much love for you and everything you create!! I wouldn't be doing my English degree if it wasn't for you sharing your passion for reading and your nuanced opinions on books. Your unique perspective and experience of literature is such a wonderful, positive contribution to the internet and brings joy into this online space which is so often dark and full of negativity. I hope you know the special place you hold in our hearts. Thank you for your light Jack :)
Your channel is a gem. Don’t let people make you small. Keep them patreon exclusive if you need. You are an adorable young man, so accomplished, and your enthusiasm for books shines, as does your knowledge. Take your time to recover when you need it, we will be waiting. I literally only follow you when it comes to booktubers because you keep such an open mind and make such varied recommendations, and your knowledge of the industry and studies in the field gave you such a solid starting point to build your taste but also allow you to highlight the good and bad in books regardless of your enjoyment of them. Keep it up in 2025!
I love your celebrity book series. I am sorry you were going through this. Love you, love your content, watching you makes me excited to read jack... please dont stop babe, we are with you❤
People can be so horrible online nowadays, and it's sad to see it. I'm happy you brought up the key analogy towards the end because, genuinely, trolls can be so horrible they can sadly change something you enjoy. But it's important to remember that many people, including myself, find you and your channel so inspiring and a joy to watch. Please keep posting what you want to post, and I'm looking forward to seeing your wrap-up on 2024 books❤Also, as a book recommendation for 2025, I recently bought Water Moon by Samantha Sotto Yambao and can't wait to start reading it.
After a year of 'easy reading', I've decided to challenge myself by finally tackling the collection of classics on my book shelf. I went to read the Italian but remembered it was written in response to 'The Monk' so I'm going to be reading 'The Monk' after I finish wuthering heights!
Love Wuthering Heights! The middle is the my favorite part, but I hope you enjoy the whole of it! And good luck with the others. I’ve dropped a lot of classics but might finally try some again
Please Jack don’t stop making the type of content you have always made! It is one of the reasons you stood out for me in the booktube community. I shared your chanel with so many of my friends because of your witty and whimsical attitude. The pop culture references and the celeb book clubs are a delight to watch. Don’t let snobbish people guide you, you are a true literary heart irrespective of what anyone might say. You introduce us to such a variety of literature and your reviews are always such that it can be seen how learned you are.
Don’t let other people stop you or shame you from enjoying what makes you smile and what gives you life. It’s fast and brief and none of us get it right or get it back.
Thank you for sharing that personal bit at the end. You were the reason I restarted reading years ago after I completely stopped in high school. I look forward to seeing the videos you love to make and to see your creativity flourish! ❤
Go Jack!! We love you, thank you for sharing your struggles and so glad that this has resulted in you wanting to be more of yourself, cause that’s why we’re here! ❤
no please don't stop! my favorite thing about your channel is how real and honest you are with your reviews. ignore the people who can't take criticism and are plain rude in your comments.
I am so glad you are still creating through your struggles. As someone who grew up autistic but with no diagnosis, I feel fully this needing to apologise for everything and people picking out things like the way you speak or your excitement over your passion and twist them in to something negative, when they are beautiful. Especially with the internet, at the moment there's this idea that if you aren't only focusing and speaking about all of the big world issues then you are wasting air time, but your content is important, both for it's joy and for the way that you encourage diverse reading without making it a gimmick. Your video's lit a fire within me to read again after years of not reading, encouraged me to try genres I had been told I would be too stupid to understand and find a new and renewed joy in reading. I am glad you are going to rediscover what you enjoy about making content. The right people love you as you are (not just parasocially but IRL), and to them you could never be too much
For African lit, I highly recommend Leïla Slimani’s In the Country of Others. It’s the first book in a trilogy that follows three generations of a Franco-Moroccan family dealing with being biracial in a rapidly evolving Morocco. This book tells the story of a French woman who moves to her husband’s native Morocco after World War II, just as it is undergoing massive waves of unrest against the French regime. It’s such a well-written, emotional take on the subject. I read it in French and loved it, but I’ve heard great things about Sam Taylor’s translation!
i’m happy to hear that you’re excited about this year because I really missed your videos last year lol. we missed the old jack as much as you did and it’s really nice that you got to find him again :) can’t wait to know what my next read will be!! (although I already got some recommendations from this video)
that was what i needed to hear about 2025, i don’t wanna make myself small either :’)) thank you for sharing this intimate part with us! aaaand i think you could definetely read bilge karasu’s works, he is a turkish writer that has such a unique way with words and prose that it’s insane… all the love ❤️
please please please dont stop making the videos you want to do because of mean comments i loved the celebrity book club videos a lot
It’s not my thing but I scroll through them occasionally cos I’m nosy 😂. I will always root for content creators to keep creating whatever they want.
100% agree. I love the reviews and have found some great reads through your videos.
The number of views tells you how we really feel, but it should be based on what you love to do.
Ok Sabrina carpenter
Don't let the haters get you down. You are engaging and have so much to say. Please don't stop
wow that last section was so beautifully put. i'm so glad you're finding your groove with reviewing again, you're so many peoples favourite reviewer (mine included) and you really have helped to bring reading for fun back into the gen z-sphere. love you always. straighten out that key, 2025 is yours! xxx
Omggggg Eleanor! I love your videos, I'm so surprised to have found you in the wild
And reading for fun back into the gen x-sphere of at least one 🤓
For a second I wondered how a book reviewer got to +1m subs and I realized it's the tumblr true crime demographic such as yourself.
I think people need to realise they are the ones who are choosing to watch your content, and if they don’t like what they’re watching THEY CAN STOP, not the other way around. Keep doing what your doing, whatever unlocks your door
I do agree, however I can see how and why he takes note of those comments- it is his business after all and wants to make the videos that resonate with the most people.
@@Pokjhbvcf yah but with 1.44M subs you absolutely cant please everyone
Well, most people like his videos. The mean comments are by far the minority.
This. People need to stop telling others what to do or read, isn't just exhausting but super rude. Let people be themselves, and do things that makes them happy.
I don't know if anyone else can relate, but the pop culture references is one of the biggest reasons why I fell in love with your videos !! your humour is just my kinda humour
Jack,
Please keep doing these videos and disregard the haters. I’m 70 years old (I can’t believe it. Where did the time go?)
You have such a passion and enthusiasm for reading. I’ve bought so many books on your recommendation.
I look forward to your videos. You give me so much hope for the world.
Thank you for all the work you put into these videos.
When I’m feeling down about the world I watch and rewatch your videos.
What a precious comment! 🥰
I am in my 70s also. I have also said to many, including our local librarians, that young people like Jack give me hope for this world.
Thomas, your comment brings tears to my eyes. I’m 32 and suffer from a chronic illness that prevents me from doing a lot of the things I love. Reading is my passion and Jack recommended some books that have become my favourite. I’m so grateful for his work and I feel the same as you : when I feel bad, I watch and rewatch his videos. Not everything has to be overly intellectual or discuss the terrible things happening in the world. I’m so thankful we have witty and fun people like him who can bring us so much joy, good vibes and great book recs! All my love from France (and yes time goes by soooo fast, damn)
We need more people like you
this is so sweet! i hope that jack will still be making videos when I’m 70
The puppy exposing its belly & all it wants is love comparison broke MY heart ! Omg jack you are single handedly responsible for reinvigorating my love for reading ! In my eyes you are a treasure and need to be protected and appreciated!
I’ve missed all the things you haven’t posted - please don’t make yourself small. The haters and the envious will always exist but you have so many lovers and supporters! It’s been a drought without your book reviews, when you feel safe and comfy, please come back Jack!
I agree, I have been missing his reviews so much! There are so few other places to turn for recommendations and reviews of the genres I like. I need his reviews. Booktube needs his reviews!
As someone who is also very vulnerable to others' opinions, I can only imagine how you felt. Please know that you have so many people who enjoy your content, you are our little safe corner of the internet. I usually never comment but I just adore your videos, you made me excited about books again. Whenever I need inspiration on what to read, I come here. If I finish a book, I will come here to check if you have read it and what you think about it. Thank you for doing this and please keep that unique sparkle you have (and the amazing sense of humour).
PLEASE i LOVED your celebrity book club series and your yearly wrap up/reviews!! they were always IMMENSELY helpful in highlighting and introducing new books to me, or telling me more about a book i'd heard about but didn't know much of!
Although I’m just a stranger on the internet, I also would like to take the opportunity to advocate for the return of the celebrity book club!🤞I discovered so many good works from there
Agreed!
I loved them, too!
aww jack the end of that video was so unexpectedly emotional, all i want to do is give you a huge hug now 🥺 please imagine you are receiving so many virtual hugs rn, so many of us will always love and support you with whatever pursuits you enjoy the most!!! like you said, it’s only a minority and this will hopefully give them a reality check and restore some of their humanity. sending so much positive energy to you 🤍
genuinely teared up imagining puppy jack getting punched instead of getting belly rubs omg love you so much!
Keep being you. Some of your videos have helped me through difficult times.
All the things you mentioned that you were being criticized for and were afraid to show are things I love about you and your content! Love your opinions, your humour, your creativity and ideas. I’m looking to branch out in the genres I read so I’ve been watching a lot of your content and look forward to what you make this year!!! What you make and like is important !!!
your celebrity book club videos / book reviews in general were always so creative and fun! don’t stop making them please!
I’m glad you addressed this at the end! I’ve seen people be so unnecessarily rude in your comments and I’m always so confused. I love your content and even if we feel differently about a book I still love to hear what you think because your thoughts are always so deep and insightful! The loudest voices are not the voices of the majority. Most of us just watch and enjoy without commentary but we’re still here and always will be ❤
It's so bizarre. People will say the meanest things online that they wouldn't dare to say to someone's face. Plus, no one is forcing those people to watch the literally FREE content. Sigh, some people...
You are the reason i started reading again during the pandemic ; not only did ur videos help me get thought the lockdown , they helped me reconnect with reading and fight my depression . So we love Jack, the old one, the current one and the future one, even when Jack doesn't love Jack
"over consumption" "anti-intellectualism".... I feel like these words have been uncritically thrown around a lot lately. While these things are definitely problems not to be taken lightly, I think you’ve more than proven your devotion to reading-both as a passion and as a culturally curious/intellectual pursuit.
Ngl, I've missed your reviews because as someone who can't dedicate that much time to reading, being able to get recommendations and insight from people like you who can read a large breadth of genres is something I appreciate. I'm glad that they'll be coming back!
Also, thank you for spotlighting Palestinian authors over this past year and a half -- true allyship includes engaging with and valuing the perspectives and cultural heritage of oppressed peoples. That being said, I am looking forward to hearing your thoughts on the African literature that you'll be reading this year!
🕊
Yes, thank you for saying that about over comsumption. I don't think it is over consumption when it's a hobby. Hobby is supposed to be something you are obsessed with. And books can never be over consumption, especially when you are reading most of them.
Yes. I believe making more lowbrow-leaning, less academical, or even full-on 'non-intellectual' content isn't the same as being anti-intellectual. The popularity of such videos over others might be an indicator of an overall trend towards anti-intellectualism, but on the individual level it is more complex and nuanced
@camping_here7706 I think this is beyond a hobby in this instance.
For this gentleman, it appears to be his livelihood.
I liken it to this: Imagine telling a mechanic he is overconsuming because he has more than one wrench, or he has sockets in different drive sizes.
Or imagine telling a lepidopterist they are overconsuming because they have specimen drawers on display.
@BrandonK4 I agree. In this case, obviously, Jack is going to read more books than average people. I was talking more in the sense of this recent overuse of the word 'overcomsumption' for hobbies.
and @BrandonK4
Just because something is a hobby doesn't mean your consumption won't be regarded as overconsumption (If I have an obsession with Legos and I'm buying tons of them because it's my hobby, it doesn't mean I'm not overconsuming) The same applies to a job (a mechanic having more than one tool is example is redundant in the sense that no mechanic would unnecessarily spend so much money on the same tool if it's not genuinely needed and if i strictly consider it as a job only then being an youtuber is public personality profession , it depends lot on your "image" than the other professions you have mentioned. Also I remember Jack Edwards talking about being on UA-cam for creative fun and community interaction, not just for making money. When you are such a big name on BookTok and your earnings depend heavily on the people, you have the moral responsibility to at least, on the surface, show that you care about a problem that is very pressing in recent times (The same applies to celebs: if they rub in everybody's face that they are getting roomfuls of packages every week while some can’t even afford basic necessities in the time of recession, they would get burned no matter what) Buying books has become a performance or code for being a reader in yt, if you don't own a lot of books you are not a serious reader. Maybe, like some smaller BookTubers do, encouraging people to use their local libraries and not rubbing in their face that you have 1,500+ books would be better for all
I'm glad you listened to the alarm bells, noticed what was happening, and are able to come back with a new perspective because I do not doubt that it's hard to always have someone trying to snuff out your light for no reason.
I hope the feeling of being a vulnerable puppy has been able to transform into feeling like a BIG DAWG that's going to be as loud and joyful as he wants!
Jack you deserve to unlock your full potential. You're like a character from a book yourself.. boyishly handsome, well spoken with an incredible accent, charming, optimistic, introspective, genuine, and so much more with a sparkle in your eye. I think you can go all the way, so don't be afraid to make some big moves this year!
YES!! I totally second this! 🙌 ❤
Simp
Totally ❤
you really helped revive my interest in reading after a long moratorium since childhood. you helped me discover so many of my favourite books and to also think more critically about what i was reading; i’m really grateful and i love your channel!
That is so cool, I hope you keep at it and that you enjoy reading as much as you can!
Absolutely agree! He got me into japanese/korean translated fiction and it's seriously a fav of mine now.
I genuinely missed your book reviews so much! You are the reason I started to get back into reading. I'm so thankful to you for that. Please bring the review videos back!!
Awe Jack 🥺 I noticed your content had changed but I just thought you were out there living your best life, walking red carpets and traveling. Im sorry you felt that way. I love all of your content though, and you’re one of my favorite content creators. 🫶🏻
Same! I thought he was just living his best life, not having an existential crisis because of hateful comments.
I’m so sorry to hear this! I absolutely love seeing your content and watching your creativity, passion and enthusiasm for the books you’ve read or will be reading. You’re my number one go to for recommendations and opinions on books since I came across your channel several years ago. Please don’t sacrifice yourself or your phenomenal content to fall into categories others would have you fit…you’re WAY more than that. Keep being you, whatever form that takes!
Jack, you’re right, 2024 was tough and I agree, we should all stop making ourselves feel small. You do you boo, those of us who enjoy your content will always support you.
I’m sorry to hear that people made you feel like you couldn’t be 100% you. Your warmth and enthusiasm have always made you one of my (and so many others) favorite booktuber. I hope to see your celebrity book clubs and the content you love come back
DONT STOP IM A TEEN WHO LOVES READING AND YOU HELP SO SO MUCH...
Ditto!!!
For sure
Please keep doing your book reviews. As a fellow literature major, I find your reviews really fascinating!!!
I literally have nothing in common with you and our book tastes couldn't be more opposite from yours but I still watch your videos because you're funny and your passion is lovely to watch. You do you and ignore the jerks!
Honestly at this point I take majority of my book recommendations only from you cuz it's neverrrr dissapointing. And when I read something I love, I instantly want to go to your videos just know how much you loved it.... You are doing an incredible job my friend. Don't let these masked ppl everrrr drain your energy.
Virtual hugss 🫂🫂
I love you and your content so so much❤
My attempt to make the love as loud as the hate: I love love love every kind of video you said you stopped making because of other people’s negativity. I love your personality and how much joy and energy you bring to reading. Being loud and fun doesn’t make you “anti-intellectual”! I really love how you tie pop culture and books together! The I don’t find it cringy, I find it fun. I love someone who loves literature being completely unpretentious about it, and tying in your love of pop music and celebrities and whatever. I love your celebrity book club. I know it’s so hard to not let the rude voices drown out all the others, but I really love your channel and it brightens my day whenever you post! Can’t wait to see whatever you post this year 💜
It's absurd to me that anyone would call Jack's reviews "anti-intellectual". How bizarre. His reviews are so thoughtful and intelligent, he actually reads his books and loves reading, he reads across many genres and he's eloquent and clear in his opinions. Does he make pop culture references and laugh? Yes! Since when is being aware of your culture and audience, or being funny anti-intellectual? How many booktubers give such thoughtful reviews? Definitely not that many!
The internet is such a draining place but your videos and passion in your videos are so fun and important. Your ideas and the way you articulate things is so refreshing. I love all your content and while it's awesome watching the heavier/more critical thinking videos the ones that are more just for fun are also so great. Sometimes we just need to escape and I'm sure most people here love just escaping into the world of books and your videos provide that. I'm sorry some people are closed-minded about your content. ❤
I’ve been a silent watcher on your channels for years now (starting with your study tips vids) and you are just such a genuinely inspiring person! Whenever I lose my own passion and motivation to enjoy just about anything in life, I watch your videos for comfort, insight, inspiration. There is no other youtuber that I’ve followed for this long; your content and your lovely personality are something very special in today’s social media spaces. So, honestly, thank you for persevering and staying 🫶
you are my comfort content creator on youtube, please make whatever your heart desires. if you are putting your time, energy, creativity and love into your work then that is all that truly matters. just be you ❤
Some people are going to be mean and hateful no matter what, and it has nothing to do with you. Just know the vast vast majority of people watching are watching because we love you and your content!
So true! You can never please everyone
Jack, I’ve been following your videos for so long now. You’ve literally been here at the start of my 30s. First of all thank you for being so honest and vulnerable to your viewers. It really gives us all an insight into how you are feeling, which I think is very important. Secondly I’m not surprised you weren’t able to do so many book reviews! You were being flown about to Bali, navigating a place to stay and going to lots of other events and this is only what you have chosen to share with us. I can’t imagine what else you have been working on during this time. You could be the most creative smartest person in the world and even they feel the weight of emotion, the pressure of atmosphere as you go somewhere new for the first time. What I am trying to say is you’re only human. I’m very excited for where this next chapter of your channel is going, but please do keep taking care of yourself. 🙂
ngl i really thought you stopped posting as much cause you were so locked in with writing your book. IM SO EXCITED TO READ THAT WHENEVER IT DOES COME OUT AND YEAH GO MAKE WHATEVER CONTENT YOU WANT OUT THERE MAN!! happy to be along the journey with you
O my, that last part really had me in tears. I've been a happy follower of your channel all the way back even to when you were in your dorm room. And of course I pick up on changes in atmosphere and the kind of energy you're giving off, but I hadn't realised things had gotten quite so dire. I for one have praised you for taking us along through your life journey and for being so diverse and inclusive in your content. You actually feel like a friend I would easily have wonderful discussions with in actual life, fully knowing and appreciating you're the creator and I'm the viewer. Just goes to tell it kinda breaks my heart to hear you've been struggling with consequences of doing what you do, doing it so well, so... Jack. We love your energy and quircks and humour and everything, otherwise we wouldn't be here. But obviously a small percentage can't handle the joy you're bringing. Well, that's on them. Easier said than done, obviously. But please Jack, stay you, stay unhinged, stay sensitive and bold and keep on being the mayor of yap city. I'm so proud (...) of your journey and choices and stories, I'm glad to hear you've found your old self back again. I think it's amazing that your channel blew up, but sometimes I secretly do wish we were back in your student room with the nice group of followers there was at the time. Yapping myself now, so leaves me to 🫂 you from the Netherlands / Christian
So happy you're back and you addressed this. Your content is brillant and got me into reading (45 books a year for the past 2 years) whereas before that, I considered reading one single book impossible. You got me excited about literature, be it classics or more modern fictions. Your creativity, happiness and person are so refreshing. I hope you're okay, it must be very tough to ignore or live with those stupid and unnecessarily mean comments. (pls keep yapping)
Jack, it’s truly unbelievable how big of an inspiration you’ve been to me and surely so many other people. Not only did I start reading more, but I also joined a few book clubs and opened my own one thanks to you and your passion for books which is truly contagious. The „heart to heart” part of this video really broke my heart because you deserve only love, support and appreciation for what you do and what values you show us. I hope 2025 treats you much much much better than the past few months did. Thanks for everything! ❤
ugh i am so sad to hear you went/are going through that this past year. you are amazing and wonderful and i hope this year is full of passion, confidence, and excitement for you!!!
glad you are going back to your true self. we all love and support you jack
Some of us have been watching you since your uni days.. and I definitely started to miss you giving opinions about the books you read.
Look what happened with Dostoevsky sales when you gave your opinion. It's important. You got people that likely don't read classics to pick up meaningful literature.
I have a small idea/request that you do a "classics video" once a month where you review one of the classics and make it approachable for people. Pleeease?
Please rethink the things you love and consider bringing them back. There's always haters, pay them no mind.
your videos are always so on point. btw, just wanted to mention this thing I found recently - Forbidden Money Printing Method Ebook. kinda cool if you’re curious.
What's that thing? I'm kinda interested
it’s an ebook called Forbidden Money Printing Method Ebook. it reveals some methods people use to create income in ways most wouldn’t believe are even possible. honestly, it’s a total game-changer if you’re curious about unconventional strategies
@@istandagainstoppression oh it’s ebook called Forbidden Money Printing Method Ebook it dives into some ideas about money that feel kinda hidden or overlooked honestly I didn’t think it would work but it’s actually pretty eye-opening
@@istandagainstoppression I understand your curiosity about this book I was the same a few months ago and bought it out of curiosity the book is the real deal not some nonsense
So glad you're back! For African literary fiction, you might like Umar Turaki. His first book, Such a Beautiful Thing to Behold is about 4 siblings living in a quarantined village where all the adults have died. His second book, Every Drop of Blood is Red, came out in 2024. It's about two families - one Christian, one Muslim - dealing with the aftermath of a hate crime after religious violence in Jos, Nigeria. Both books have a speculative twist and gorgeous writing!
Thank you Jack for being so open and vulnerable at the end. Never stop creating the content you want to make, being true to yourself and having grace with yourself. You've inspired me for so long and you continue to do so. We love you and your content both new and old. Never not be you please. Thank you honestly so much ❤
You are a precious bean, and I’ve enjoyed every single type of video you’ve done. The thoughts, the vibes, the fun, the range from deeper things to fun pop culture stuff. Do what makes you happy, and what’s healthy for you, whether that’s returning to the old or to step away. You rock. Thank you for endless entertainment for years now. You’re a treasure, that is all 💜
I think you have always done such a great job balancing pop culture/buzzy books and more literary books. You are truly the youtuber that I look forward to every single time a new video pops up. Love you and your content so much! I feel like I learn so much from you and you really help make my reading more fun. I hope that 2025 is much more healthy and positive and fun for you!
I love your content Jack! You are the singular reason why I got into reading. Your comments genuinely guided me find my favourite books. I read 40+ books in the last two years thanks to your content and recommendations. Please continue to follow your passion! Sending love and hugs
Jack! I have never commented on your videos and been a silent watcher for the past two years. BUT the last part touched my soul, I hope you know how many people love and support you! I ADORE all your videos, love your opinions and reviews. You are the reason I found my love for reading again, where I go for all my reviews, my comfort channel and has inspired me to read more fiction from around the world and translated fiction. You inspire me!
i’ve been watching your videos from the past few years cause i love to hear you talk about books and i’ve missed that. don’t listen to the cacophony of haters, listen to what’s in your heart. we’re here to love and support you. can’t wait for more jack x
As someone who watches pretty much every video you post (on both channels) since your studytube GSCE/A Level days, the celebrity book club and the fun, creative, pop culture videos you were making at the time were my absolute favorites. ❤
Always lifts up the spirits ...
"Someday, I'll be living in a big old city
And all you′re ever gonna be is mean
Someday, I′ll be big enough so you can't hit me
And all you′re ever gonna be is mean
Why you gotta be so mean?"
We're always here with u Jack
WE LOVE YOU JACK PLS NEVER STOP POSTING SOMETHING YOURE PASSIONATE ABOUT BECAUSE OF WHAT PEOPLE SAY ❤
I just want you to know that your snappy, fun book reviews are what got me back into reading. I hope that you do what makes you happy moving forward, regardless of what other people say or feel. You have a lot of people that love your content💗
Hi Jack. I mainly read SFF and you are usually my guide for literary fiction. Don't listen to the hate comments. I know they are the loud ones. Your actual audience loves your content, no matter how you decide to present it. :) btw excellent list, many of thes were on my radar as well.
You are truly an amazing person. Whenever I feel overwhelmed by the stress of not being able to read for months due to college, I turn to your videos to find motivation again. Your passion for books shines through every time you speak, reminding me of the love for reading that I often forget. On top of that, your sense of humor makes your videos even more enjoyable than they already are. Never stop being who you are, because I know you are a wonderful person. There are very few people in this world who can genuinely be considered to have a big heart, but I know, without a doubt, that you are one of them.
Your content has been what kept me connected to books during a multi year struggle with depression and anxiety. I found you during the pandemic and have been incredibly grateful for the channel. I love books but struggled with being able to engage with them for nearly 4 years, which was its own kind of devastation. Your love of literature and passion for sharing kept me engaged in a thing I love even when I wasn't able to finish a book. Thank you. 💜
I'm sorry the internet has been such a brutal place, and I am glad you have been able to find some peace and rejuvenation. I look forward to whatever content you make this year, and hope you are able to find joy in the process.
i appreciate your honesty and vulnerability so much Jack, give yourself credit, choosing yourself takes bravery
Jack, you're so smart, funny, interesting, innovative, thoughtful, dedicated, kind, passionate, and so much more! Keep creating content that brings you joy. What you do and how you do it is truly special. The internet can be a scary place, but you make it brighter and better, and I’m so glad you’re here. I hope to find a job I’m as passionate about as you are about yours, and I hope you can find the kindness and comfort on the internet that I’ve found in your videos 💙
I was browsing my local bookstore a few months back and spotted a copy of Small Things Like These by Claire Keegan. I remembered you had talked about her and really like her writing, so I picked it up. I absolutely loved it - so thank you for that recommendation! ❤❤❤
This was my favorite book from 2024! Did you know there's a Cillian Murphy adaptation?
Oh, Jack. Thank you for being so vulnerable and honest with all of your viewers. I have missed your videos and had a feeling something was going on, I am so sorry this was it. I work in an area where I receive massive amounts of people criticising but sometimes it feels like it is not to help me improve but rather to break me down ( and the ones who do that are a small number but wow can they have an impact). I am not on the internet, so I can not imagine experiencing that at your level. Your videos have always been such a comfort to me, and I have read so many great books because of you; I don't always like the same books as you but I appreciate your perspective and take on them. Not sure if you will even see this but your honesty compelled me to respond ( which I rarely do haha). I look forward to your future content.Take good care
jack i love you and your content. haters can only wish to have a smidge of your charisma and candor. keep being you and putting what you want to put out in the world and don’t let them bring you down. i’m giving you a forehead kiss
I yearn to have a book collection as big as yours!
SO TRUEE
Likewise
Dear Jack,
I’ve been subscribed to your channel since you were working your publishing job and before you were actually able to have your graduation ceremony because of COVID. Everything you mentioned you had to stop doing because of comments, is the reason myself and many others loved and continue to your channel. I can’t begin to imagine what’s like to be someone with an online presence. It’s my wish for you for this new year that you find joy in this again. I hope you know just how much you’ve inspired us and have made us proud to support you. Not only because of your accomplishments but your dedication and willingness to better yourself. Much love to you from a stranger who is so thankful to have found your channel.
Thanks to you I fell in love with reading again, I've found a few of my new favorite books through your channels. I have had the most interesting discussions about books with other people thanks to you. I've broadened my horizons, reading more about real people than just straight fantasy novels.
You deserve to feel safe, whether you're sharing an opinion online or with your friends and family, never apologize for being yourself-you can't be anyone else.
Aw the idea of the dog getting heaps of belly rubs but one punch is so true and sad. It sucks how people like to tear others down. Even just the number of opinions must be overwhelming sometimes. Putting yourself out there as you do is so brave. Sending you virtual hugs 💜
Your channel has helped me not only in my education but also my personal life too...getting me out of my reading slumps more times than I could count...please keep doing what you do...give your reviews...criticism...it lightens up my day to say the least...and that what makes your channel unique and interesting!!! Do what you want to do...and be what you want to be...ignore the haters...all the love 🥰
Jack, you are loved. There are 1.4 million people that like you. There will always be people who don't like you or are just unhappy and mean. Listen to those of us that love you and your channel.
This took such a deep and meaningful turn and I'm grateful that you felt comfortable enough to share with us how it's been for you lately. You are lovely and please don't let anyone take away your spark.
I wish you well, Jack. I hope you are loving your new living space and neighborhood! Your room is fantastic with the huge windows and sunlight, and you have made it quite a cozy bedroom & library, which is something to be proud of.
Jack, thank you so much for these past few years. It really means the world to me. You got me into reading when I was someone who couldn’t even look at a book. Please keep doing what you’re doing, and don’t listen to the haters. I’ve really missed your old content, especially the ‘celebrity’s favorite books’ series. And seriously, don’t hold back on your opinions-everyone’s entitled to them, and people should respect that. I hope 2025 is amazing for you, and I can’t wait for your new videos. Keep being yourself; you've come this far, so keep doing what you do. I even watch your videos with my mom, who’s super busy, but it’s become a great way for us to connect over literature. Thank you, really.
Jack I’ve been watching you for years now and I’m so sorry that you felt that way last year! Please know that the majority of people that love and connect with your videos are probably not commenting, they’re just watching and enjoying your content.
Your videos and love for books are infectious and inspired me in my own life to start working in a bookshop and share that with even more people. Never stop doing what you love and certainly don’t apologise for it. We love you bestieee🫶🫶🫶
Discovering your channel (3 years ago) is one of the reasons I got back into reading, and since then I’ve read more than 150+ books. 📚 so please know that your job to influence people to get excited about reading have reached at least +1 audience. 😊 I'm cheering for you.
jack, you have gotten thousands of people into reading and literature by being your amazing self. your passion, optimism, and voice are infectious in the best ways. please never change & know that so many of us love and appreciate you for you!!! excited to see that passion reignite within you
You are my safe space on the internet and I’m sorry it no longer felt safe for you, I’m so glad you’re no longer going to let small minds dull your sparkle. I’m very excited to see what you have in store for us in 2025 x
it’s much easier for people to criticize unfairly than admit they’re jealous that they don’t have your talent and influence.
love your channel ❤
So sad that you’ve felt so small and trapped, but I’m glad you took the time to take care of yourself and reconnect with what you loved. Keep being you!
Hi again 👋 So glad you’ve found your voice & fire again! We love seeing YOU here.
I'm so glad that you found your way back to us. 😘😇 Please continue to be yourself, that's why we love you.
thx for being vulnerable w us!!!! SENDING LOVE AND LOTSA HUGS!!! cant wait to watch more of the content YOU want to make. haters gonna hate, just gotta ignore them and do whatever you want to do :)
So so so much love for you and everything you create!! I wouldn't be doing my English degree if it wasn't for you sharing your passion for reading and your nuanced opinions on books. Your unique perspective and experience of literature is such a wonderful, positive contribution to the internet and brings joy into this online space which is so often dark and full of negativity. I hope you know the special place you hold in our hearts. Thank you for your light Jack :)
we love u jack dont ever change ❤
Your channel is a gem. Don’t let people make you small. Keep them patreon exclusive if you need. You are an adorable young man, so accomplished, and your enthusiasm for books shines, as does your knowledge. Take your time to recover when you need it, we will be waiting. I literally only follow you when it comes to booktubers because you keep such an open mind and make such varied recommendations, and your knowledge of the industry and studies in the field gave you such a solid starting point to build your taste but also allow you to highlight the good and bad in books regardless of your enjoyment of them. Keep it up in 2025!
I love your celebrity book series.
I am sorry you were going through this. Love you, love your content, watching you makes me excited to read jack... please dont stop babe, we are with you❤
People can be so horrible online nowadays, and it's sad to see it. I'm happy you brought up the key analogy towards the end because, genuinely, trolls can be so horrible they can sadly change something you enjoy. But it's important to remember that many people, including myself, find you and your channel so inspiring and a joy to watch. Please keep posting what you want to post, and I'm looking forward to seeing your wrap-up on 2024 books❤Also, as a book recommendation for 2025, I recently bought Water Moon by Samantha Sotto Yambao and can't wait to start reading it.
After a year of 'easy reading', I've decided to challenge myself by finally tackling the collection of classics on my book shelf. I went to read the Italian but remembered it was written in response to 'The Monk' so I'm going to be reading 'The Monk' after I finish wuthering heights!
Love Wuthering Heights! The middle is the my favorite part, but I hope you enjoy the whole of it! And good luck with the others. I’ve dropped a lot of classics but might finally try some again
Please Jack don’t stop making the type of content you have always made! It is one of the reasons you stood out for me in the booktube community. I shared your chanel with so many of my friends because of your witty and whimsical attitude. The pop culture references and the celeb book clubs are a delight to watch. Don’t let snobbish people guide you, you are a true literary heart irrespective of what anyone might say. You introduce us to such a variety of literature and your reviews are always such that it can be seen how learned you are.
0:27 I swear Jack always has immaculate taste in everything
Akwaeke Emezi is a fantastic author who writes African fiction. The Death of Vivek Oji was my favorite book the year I read it
Don’t let other people stop you or shame you from enjoying what makes you smile and what gives you life. It’s fast and brief and none of us get it right or get it back.
Thank you for sharing that personal bit at the end. You were the reason I restarted reading years ago after I completely stopped in high school. I look forward to seeing the videos you love to make and to see your creativity flourish! ❤
Go Jack!! We love you, thank you for sharing your struggles and so glad that this has resulted in you wanting to be more of yourself, cause that’s why we’re here! ❤
no please don't stop! my favorite thing about your channel is how real and honest you are with your reviews. ignore the people who can't take criticism and are plain rude in your comments.
I am so glad you are still creating through your struggles. As someone who grew up autistic but with no diagnosis, I feel fully this needing to apologise for everything and people picking out things like the way you speak or your excitement over your passion and twist them in to something negative, when they are beautiful. Especially with the internet, at the moment there's this idea that if you aren't only focusing and speaking about all of the big world issues then you are wasting air time, but your content is important, both for it's joy and for the way that you encourage diverse reading without making it a gimmick. Your video's lit a fire within me to read again after years of not reading, encouraged me to try genres I had been told I would be too stupid to understand and find a new and renewed joy in reading. I am glad you are going to rediscover what you enjoy about making content. The right people love you as you are (not just parasocially but IRL), and to them you could never be too much
For African lit, I highly recommend Leïla Slimani’s In the Country of Others. It’s the first book in a trilogy that follows three generations of a Franco-Moroccan family dealing with being biracial in a rapidly evolving Morocco. This book tells the story of a French woman who moves to her husband’s native Morocco after World War II, just as it is undergoing massive waves of unrest against the French regime. It’s such a well-written, emotional take on the subject. I read it in French and loved it, but I’ve heard great things about Sam Taylor’s translation!
we miss you, jack! there are a lot of people loving you instead of the hate. stay strong! we are always here for you. *huggsss with consent*
i’m happy to hear that you’re excited about this year because I really missed your videos last year lol. we missed the old jack as much as you did and it’s really nice that you got to find him again :) can’t wait to know what my next read will be!! (although I already got some recommendations from this video)
that was what i needed to hear about 2025, i don’t wanna make myself small either :’)) thank you for sharing this intimate part with us! aaaand i think you could definetely read bilge karasu’s works, he is a turkish writer that has such a unique way with words and prose that it’s insane… all the love ❤️
The internet is a wild and uncertain place! You are so so sweet and as a new subscriber, I can’t wait to see you being your true, unapologetic self! ❤