How Sharpe Became Commander! | Sharpe Earns His Promotion | Sharpe

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 347

  • @HyakuSh1ki
    @HyakuSh1ki Місяць тому +1269

    Ridley Scott gets to waste money on Napoleon, meanwhile Sharpe over here was showing Waterloo with 30 people, with the price of a sandwich as the entire budget.
    And it is somehow *better*

    • @julianaylor4351
      @julianaylor4351 Місяць тому +63

      More authentic battle tactics and so on, plus very good stuntmen.

    • @Shadowkey392
      @Shadowkey392 Місяць тому +24

      The key difference is that THIS is solely about Waterloo, whereas Napoleon is about…Napoleon.

    • @CrazynToughKiwi
      @CrazynToughKiwi Місяць тому +32

      ​@@Shadowkey392more accurately, about him and an ex

    • @Faceonthewall
      @Faceonthewall Місяць тому +72

      Sharpe and Hornblower TV adaptations. BBC managed to portray the entire Napoleonic war, on land and sea, with a handful of actors and a smoke machine.

    • @imadeanaccounttocomment7800
      @imadeanaccounttocomment7800 Місяць тому +25

      @@FaceonthewallHornblower had a way larger budget than sharpe and they were both ITV shows, ITV was basically created as a direct rival to BBC to challenge their monopoly.

  • @meatballg8655
    @meatballg8655 Місяць тому +922

    After seeing the video was only 2 minutes old naturally I gave the order to watch, that’s my style sir

    • @moronicnapoleonic
      @moronicnapoleonic Місяць тому +131

      MAJOR LENNOX ANSWERED WITH A LIKE! AS YOU SHOULD’VE DONE YOURSELF HAD YOU ANY SENSE OF HONOR! YOU SUBSCRIBED YOURSELF, YOU COMMENTED YOURSELF!

    • @davidwright7193
      @davidwright7193 Місяць тому +65

      I believe I was most assiduous in obeying both your general order to watch all Sharpe videos and your particular order to watch this video. I have friends at Horseguards sir.

    • @yogodagorah5928
      @yogodagorah5928 Місяць тому +36

      I swear on oath that no one heard me make any promise with respect to leaving a like for this video to Major Lennox, sir!
      *(totally leaves a like for this video)*

    • @moronicnapoleonic
      @moronicnapoleonic Місяць тому

      @@davidwright7193 He who loses the king’s subscription, loses the king’s friendship.

    • @Shadowkey392
      @Shadowkey392 Місяць тому

      @@davidwright7193a man who neglects to leave a like loses the algorithm’s friendship, sir.

  • @jaquaviusdaquavious1702
    @jaquaviusdaquavious1702 Місяць тому +227

    Bro has been fighting Orcs, sieging Troy, Serving the British and being Lord of Winterfell

    • @KalimBanuz
      @KalimBanuz Місяць тому +17

      Don’t forget about him being Emperor on Elder scroll oblivion

    • @campandcook3118
      @campandcook3118 Місяць тому

      He even took over a russian mafia cartel, stole military satellites and was only stopped in his cuban base by the combines efforts of MI5, CIA and the USMC.

    • @jameselliott9866
      @jameselliott9866 Місяць тому +3

      That's soldiering!

    • @glennjanot8128
      @glennjanot8128 Місяць тому +3

      @@KalimBanuz The voice actor for the emperor in ES Oblivion was Patrick Stewart

    • @DaHawaiianGunner
      @DaHawaiianGunner 27 днів тому +1

      Don’t forget he’s also Zeus in the Percy Jackson Movies

  • @bundesautobahn7
    @bundesautobahn7 Місяць тому +227

    Disobeying the Prince of Orange and at the same time still getting rewarded with the toughest military missions and getting promoted to Commander? Now THAT is soldiering.

  • @jodycwilliams
    @jodycwilliams Місяць тому +82

    I swear on oath that nobody heard me make any promise in respect to a like to all Sharpe videos,sir.

  • @railfansteam7716
    @railfansteam7716 Місяць тому +247

    Sharpe was NOT promoted to the rank of Commander for that is a Naval rank. He was promoted to the rank of Lt Colonel at Waterloo and later to Colonel for his mission in India.

    • @debelmeis2311
      @debelmeis2311 Місяць тому +24

      You are correct on the rank but I think they meant the billet of commander

    • @ricksimon9867
      @ricksimon9867 Місяць тому +8

      It is similar to calling a navy commander "captain" if he is the commanding officer of a ship.

    • @VeggiesOutFront
      @VeggiesOutFront Місяць тому

      ​@@debelmeis2311oh like he is officially in command of people?

    • @pm6693
      @pm6693 Місяць тому +4

      You beat me to it....🙂

    • @WarriorBard637
      @WarriorBard637 Місяць тому +4

      “That’s soldiering….”

  • @mjohnsimon1337
    @mjohnsimon1337 Місяць тому +136

    Getting promoted to Commander? Now thats soldiering!

    • @freemanlee5655
      @freemanlee5655 Місяць тому +11

      Well he did not.... commander is a navy rank..... He got promoted to Lt. Col when he was attache of prince of Orange.

    • @F40PH-2CAT
      @F40PH-2CAT Місяць тому +6

      Newly gazetted commander!

    • @yxx_chris_xxy
      @yxx_chris_xxy Місяць тому +4

      "Getting promoted to Commander? Now thats soldiering!" -- no, seamanship!

    • @eponaalbion
      @eponaalbion Місяць тому +3

      @@freemanlee5655
      @MrJpc1234
      17 hours ago
      So your partially right in the Army (British Army at least) there is no "Rank" called "Commander" so they would never promote into it.....however there is various positions that an officer will take the CO (Commanding Officer) and in some circumstances they would be referred to as a "Commander"

  • @leevespa4564
    @leevespa4564 Місяць тому +210

    The acting of the soldiers getting killed is absolutely......diabolical 😂😅

    • @MrAdamske
      @MrAdamske Місяць тому +15

      nineties british television was lit 🔥🔥🔥

    • @mhirroaceroyportillo875
      @mhirroaceroyportillo875 Місяць тому

      10:03 😭

    • @millny123
      @millny123 Місяць тому +3

      The key word is ACTING it's not real

    • @MichaelBlanchardII
      @MichaelBlanchardII Місяць тому +5

      My favorite is the guy dying when the british commander said to make ready but hadn't actually ordered anyone to fire. One french guy just arbitrarily collapses. XD Probably the only survivor of that fight lol

    • @LordInter
      @LordInter Місяць тому +2

      £10 and a packet of ciggies budget lol

  • @NixonRules963
    @NixonRules963 Місяць тому +89

    The French soldier bursting through the gates of Hougamont armed with an axe at 11:30 is based on a real event wherein a huge French officer, Lieutenant Legros, managed to break into Hougamont. A quick-thinking British sergeant took some men and instead of attacking the French cut them off by shutting the gates behind them, thus saving Hougamont.

    • @ChrisSmith-tr4lg
      @ChrisSmith-tr4lg Місяць тому +13

      And the only survivor of that attack was a young drummer boy, who also was shown briefly.

    • @MyFaithShines
      @MyFaithShines Місяць тому +6

      bro, french sappers all had axes bro

    • @NixonRules963
      @NixonRules963 Місяць тому +3

      @@MyFaithShines Clearly not a fan of history lol

    • @MyFaithShines
      @MyFaithShines Місяць тому +2

      @@NixonRules963 google french sappers bro

    • @NixonRules963
      @NixonRules963 Місяць тому +2

      @@MyFaithShines Read a history book about Waterloo lmao

  • @Shamino1
    @Shamino1 Місяць тому +81

    Bring 'em all back for one more round. Sharpe in Crimea. Have Major Hogan be 99, Sharpe at 70, I don't even care, I'd watch it.

    • @SilenTHerO78614
      @SilenTHerO78614 Місяць тому +6

      I thought of something similar but its hard to top Waterloo. I was thinking however doing a movie with an older Sean Bean and preventing an assassination of Princess Victoria. Call it sharpe's knighthood.

    • @soldierbr8726
      @soldierbr8726 24 дні тому +2

      Major general sharpe

  • @julianaylor4351
    @julianaylor4351 Місяць тому +92

    The real Prince of Orange, spent all day moving around on the battlefield, then got shot because he was such an obvious target and therefore an idiot. Meanwhile Wellington and his staff, stayed in carefully positioned places. That's why he was called Silly Billy.
    Sharpe dressed as a French country gentleman. 😁

  • @jdelark6428
    @jdelark6428 Місяць тому +68

    Again, it amazes me what was accomplished on a shoestring budget.

    • @Shadowkey392
      @Shadowkey392 Місяць тому

      It wasn’t a shoestring by this point.

    • @SP-2317
      @SP-2317 Місяць тому +7

      ​@@Shadowkey392it was, the funding was tightened further and further as the years went on.

  • @dominiclaherty4099
    @dominiclaherty4099 Місяць тому +52

    Never has white smoke been so deadly

  • @Usulutan_
    @Usulutan_ 17 днів тому +5

    I forgot how much I loved this whole damn series
    Hornblower too !

  • @Ihaveaglitch
    @Ihaveaglitch Місяць тому +20

    I see UA-cam as circled back around recommending Sharpe. That’s UA-cam’s style, sir.

  • @quadparty
    @quadparty Місяць тому +9

    I feel like "I do wish you the joy of the day" should become a meme

  • @OGAcidJoe
    @OGAcidJoe Місяць тому +7

    Now that's Soldiering!. Thank you and damn you now I have to go watch Sharpe again...

  • @markspence5288
    @markspence5288 Місяць тому +13

    Whilst serving in Afghan. We used to do 3pm sharpe. Brew n sharpe. Now that’s soldiering

  • @joesephjoestar4449
    @joesephjoestar4449 Місяць тому +8

    You guys need to release full episodes!

  • @authortanyareed
    @authortanyareed Місяць тому +82

    Sharpe: "Will you stay here and fight with us?"
    Officer in the Family: "Sharpe, thats immensely kind of you..."
    Now that's Britishing

    • @KevinN-df8eo
      @KevinN-df8eo Місяць тому +4

      The thing is the gentlemen were really like that. Bad form, don't you know to get emotional or excited. Manners and understatement were natural to them.

  • @douglasharley2440
    @douglasharley2440 Місяць тому +61

    making a meme comment on a just-uploaded sharpe video?...now, _that's_ youtubing!

  • @jkent9915
    @jkent9915 Місяць тому +19

    When I saw a Sharpe video, I liked it. That’s my style sir!

  • @geoffreyrichardson8738
    @geoffreyrichardson8738 Місяць тому +69

    This is why the Duke of Wellington gave cause for Sandhurst to be created to train ‘professional officers’ to replace those ‘gentlemen officers’. Thank God.

    • @GeorgeFrei-g4l
      @GeorgeFrei-g4l Місяць тому +5

      That is also why the United States created the Service Academies after the War of Independence beginning with Military Academy and the Naval Academy, then the Coast Guard Academy at Kings Point, the Merchant Marine Academy and finally the Air Force Academy in 1955. During the Civil War, various U S Army State Militia Regiments created officer's training schools and the regular U S Army and U S Navy offered direct commissions to qualified army, navy and marine noncommissioned officers. Finally, in 1916 the first Army ROTC unit was established at Norwich University which led to the establishment of Army and Naval ROTC units at many universities and colleges, the creation of Army, Navy and Coast Guard Officer's Candidate Schools, Marine Corps Platoon Leader's Course(PLC) and state Merchant Marine Academies that granted Naval Reserve Commissions as well as Merchant Marine Officer's Licenses to graduates. An officer is supposed to be a "gentleman" or "gentlewoman" as well as a professional officer....some are and some are not! I was!

    • @geoffreyrichardson8738
      @geoffreyrichardson8738 Місяць тому

      @ yes but American was not plagued with idiots who thought because they were born into a fancy family they were entitled to command men in battle. You did have some idiots who didn’t know how to run a war but every country has those and a good war weeds them out pretty quick, look at your own civil war, three years the rebels ran rings around the union.

    • @OneofInfinity.
      @OneofInfinity. Місяць тому +6

      Only its not how the Prince really was, many un-historical liberties where taken.
      The Dutch fought bravely and even covered Wellington's "tactical" retreat at Quatre Bras.

    • @geoffreyrichardson8738
      @geoffreyrichardson8738 Місяць тому +3

      @ oh the Dutch did fight bravely just lead stupidly

    • @julianaylor4351
      @julianaylor4351 Місяць тому +2

      @@geoffreyrichardson8738 Parliament also banned the buying of commissions after the disasters during the Crimean War, like the Charge Of The Light Brigade.

  • @3Authoress
    @3Authoress Місяць тому +12

    Ah yes, the immortal currently going by the name Sean Bean. A man with a good heart and chose to end many of his lives among mortals in war.
    And holy crap! Is that Capt Arthur Hastings from Hercule Poirot at 16:38!?

  • @monsterfreek82
    @monsterfreek82 14 днів тому +1

    First time I watched this was in like 1997-1999, was one of the few shows I watched with my dad ! Good times ..

  • @Tt23-oi3nh
    @Tt23-oi3nh Місяць тому +15

    unlike other sharpe movies his indian campaign was really brutal and it wasnt like goofy backpack kills.

  • @nocturnalrecluse1216
    @nocturnalrecluse1216 Місяць тому +18

    I just realized that the Prince Regent is Paul Bettany.

    • @alanmichael5619
      @alanmichael5619 Місяць тому +7

      Yup! My favourite casting in Sharpe is Daniel Craig as Lt Berry - who Sharpe kills. So in Sharpe a bond villain kills James Bond

    • @nocturnalrecluse1216
      @nocturnalrecluse1216 Місяць тому +4

      @alanmichael5619 Don't forget about James Purefoy. He was also early in on the season as the traitor who redeemed himself with valor.

    • @gwtpictgwtpict4214
      @gwtpictgwtpict4214 Місяць тому +4

      @@nocturnalrecluse1216 Erm, valour. He was British, remember? :-)

    • @nocturnalrecluse1216
      @nocturnalrecluse1216 Місяць тому

      @@gwtpictgwtpict4214 What?

    • @nocturnalrecluse1216
      @nocturnalrecluse1216 Місяць тому +3

      @gwtpictgwtpict4214 I'm American, not British. I speak GA, not RP. So it's "VALOR" where I come from.

  • @MichaelTheRead
    @MichaelTheRead Місяць тому +16

    23:21 "I believe I am killed, ma'am..."
    And far too young to be dying for anything, including honor. But at least he saved those women from an even worse fate. 😔

    • @kapitan19969838
      @kapitan19969838 Місяць тому +1

      You're never to young to give your life for honour

    • @RogerRabbit-b6q
      @RogerRabbit-b6q 24 дні тому

      @@kapitan19969838 Yep, that;s the BS governments sell you to get you to die for them

  • @sivikasi
    @sivikasi Місяць тому +8

    Getting promoted to Commander, now that’s…sailoring

    • @leeenfield4900
      @leeenfield4900 Місяць тому +1

      The author went back and wrote several books around Pte. Sharp... grabbing his first fortune in India, then leading a covert action through the streets of Copenhagen, Denmark. One can only wish these were filmed as the very young Sharp saves various political snobs and engages beautiful women... sigh.

    • @UisgeBeathaMountain
      @UisgeBeathaMountain 15 днів тому +1

      That's seamanship, Mister Pullings...that's seamanship

  • @v1e1r1g1e1
    @v1e1r1g1e1 Місяць тому +12

    ''Break square... form line... attack... '' When there's French cavalry behind that rise? Now that's NOT soldiering!!!

  • @migranthawker2952
    @migranthawker2952 Місяць тому +24

    Here we go again - solid shot from cannon exploding like a shell! Film makers never do get it right!

    • @julianaylor4351
      @julianaylor4351 Місяць тому +10

      Too expensive and dangerous to use the real thing. The film production would be breaking health and safety laws.

    • @Iain1957
      @Iain1957 Місяць тому

      its just stupid.+

    • @alanmichael5619
      @alanmichael5619 Місяць тому +3

      Well to be fair... exploding shells *were* used at waterloo.

  • @Sleeping_Insomiac
    @Sleeping_Insomiac Місяць тому +8

    Strange, I didn't even remember Boromir being at the siege of Helm's deep...

  • @ziplockbag420
    @ziplockbag420 13 днів тому

    Ive been a hornblower fan for years now and ive always heard of Sharpe but never really had a chance to get into it... this here is a quality youtube recommendation

  • @OldProphet61
    @OldProphet61 Місяць тому +20

    I piddled in 8 hours late to comment on this video. That's my style, sir!

  • @NationalDevin
    @NationalDevin Місяць тому

    I really like the fact that the engineer that breached the gate wasn't, muck like his real counterparts, didn't catch a round to the face immediately like everyone else, but had the honor of having enough "Captain" time to lead his charge in before being cut down. That was a really dramatic scene for that and it makes it better.

  • @franz-dominikimhof4940
    @franz-dominikimhof4940 9 днів тому

    Becoming a Naval Officer without a minute on sea, now thats soldiering!

  • @wedgeantillies66
    @wedgeantillies66 Місяць тому

    First minute above offers a visually vivid demonstration of why regiments massed squares made such a tempting and easy target for massed artillery to concentrate on.

  • @georgeleong1572
    @georgeleong1572 20 днів тому

    Big fan of Sharpe's book series.

  • @captainstriker3341
    @captainstriker3341 Місяць тому +2

    Give em' steel lads!!!!

  • @FusionInPain
    @FusionInPain Місяць тому +1

    Moral of the story, people without hats are more important that those with

  • @neilkerry1483
    @neilkerry1483 Місяць тому

    Having been a fan of Mr Sharp for many years I must admit i was slightly surprised to see he had changed service and joined the navy since the last time i saw him. I am well aware of the rank of commander as that as my grandfathers final rank in the Royal Navy during WWII.

  • @meintveldman4769
    @meintveldman4769 4 дні тому

    Despite the total misrepresentation of the Prince of Orange, who according to those who fought with him as a good and brave commander, Sharp remains one of, if not the best depiction of the Napoleonic wars on film and TV.

  • @lizziesangi1602
    @lizziesangi1602 14 днів тому

    I love how Sharpe hates the Royals! "Royals! We're surrounded by Royals!"

  • @jason200912
    @jason200912 Місяць тому +2

    Is Sharpe just like Horatio hornblower where he gets promoted every few episodes after winning a battle?

    • @BlackDiamond2718
      @BlackDiamond2718 15 днів тому

      Its not just about winning battles but yeah. I saw him like the army version. Both had clever tactics, quick wits, and followed their duty to the letter.

  • @Ablk84
    @Ablk84 Місяць тому

    Love the fact Sharpe uses a pencil from Ikea

  • @Alizada-Hamidlinski
    @Alizada-Hamidlinski 7 днів тому

    Just realized that's Paul Bettany as Prince William! Didn't realize he was in another great Napoleonic flick besides Master and Commander. After all, surprise in on his side ;)

  • @Intreductor
    @Intreductor Місяць тому

    "I do wish you the joy of the day." - Witherspoon, right as the Battle of Waterloo kicks into full gear

  • @JSAnstock
    @JSAnstock 17 днів тому

    Richard Sharpe, a man so tough he survived being played by Sean Bean. 😉

  • @GuttersMN
    @GuttersMN 11 днів тому

    Richard Sharpe- the only character strong enough to survive being played by Sean Bean

  • @LebronTraveled24
    @LebronTraveled24 11 днів тому

    Oh that Simmerson is at it again

  • @csch1510
    @csch1510 Місяць тому +11

    Sharpe, silly billies staff...😂😂😂

  • @brodozer2515
    @brodozer2515 4 дні тому

    Naturally on seeing french cavalry, i ordered the battalion into line formation! Thats my style sir!

  • @galaxyinfinite7819
    @galaxyinfinite7819 19 днів тому

    Love SHARPE

  • @diraska
    @diraska Місяць тому +1

    That French axe man was a total boss

    • @johncarveti8375
      @johncarveti8375 Місяць тому

      Not in that apron he’s not

    • @BishopTakesqueen-ck4bk
      @BishopTakesqueen-ck4bk 11 днів тому

      He was a combat engineer called a pioneer. The apron was to carry tools and for protection from fire and digging. They where hard as nails

  • @grimgun100
    @grimgun100 Місяць тому +5

    Oh God!
    Oh God?
    Oh God.

  • @keithwhisman
    @keithwhisman 18 днів тому

    I was a big fan of the books I had to buy at Barnes And Noble back in the 1990’s in the US and love watching what’s available on youtube. Did they make a series About Sharpe at Trafalgar one of the books I remember reading.

  • @lordprimus2410
    @lordprimus2410 Місяць тому +8

    Commander? don't you mean Colonel

  • @herauthon
    @herauthon Місяць тому +1

    those suicidal strategies are awes - dressed in red-white-blue-black - nice living running targets - great ending.. splinter solutions

    • @Lwis
      @Lwis Місяць тому

      Back in the days where having a professional looking army meant that they looked good for parades. It really only changed with WW1 with all the mud.

  • @elisarinaldi8056
    @elisarinaldi8056 Місяць тому +1

    È stata fatta una traduzione della serie Sharpe in italiano? Dove si potrebbe vedere? Cmq Sean Bean fantastico!

  • @audioadventurer6892
    @audioadventurer6892 19 днів тому

    Now that's uploading.

  • @stijnvandamme76
    @stijnvandamme76 Місяць тому

    he got it through good soldiering

  • @king_of_sin
    @king_of_sin 22 дні тому

    There truly is no greater enemy than incompetent allies

  • @Discosn8ke
    @Discosn8ke 17 днів тому

    Thay frebch sapper though. Absolute unit

  • @arthurnolasco185
    @arthurnolasco185 Місяць тому +1

    Is this from sharpes waterloo?

  • @sbkenn1
    @sbkenn1 13 днів тому

    Battle strategy has progressed a little since then. How could commanders have thought that that was the right way ?

  • @bpooboi
    @bpooboi Місяць тому +1

    Still cant believe that people just stood there while people killed them. Because of "respectiveness" lol. Insane

    • @Lwis
      @Lwis Місяць тому

      Line battles were a product of their time. Muskets were cheaper to produce than rifles and easier to train soldiers to use. You were more likely to hit more targets with volley fire due to a musket's inaccuracy, so it became a mission of training soldiers to reload quickly and stand their ground when under fire.

  • @holdenchute7883
    @holdenchute7883 Місяць тому +1

    21:23 this might be one of the hardest lines in cinema dragovich basically drago from rocky 💀

  • @mrwidestrides4802
    @mrwidestrides4802 12 днів тому

    By Wellington’s welly boots…is…that a young Paul Bettany I spy.

  • @seamusmckim4833
    @seamusmckim4833 Місяць тому +2

    Young Hakeswill at 7:15?

    • @julianaylor4351
      @julianaylor4351 Місяць тому

      @@seamusmckim4833 Son of Obadiah, Barabbas.

  • @Booker8991
    @Booker8991 Місяць тому

    Still more historically accurate that Ridley Scott's version

  • @McGoughable
    @McGoughable День тому

    I would have thought having a Marvel superhero as your leader would have gone better for the Brits

  • @Patrick-fo9he
    @Patrick-fo9he Місяць тому

    I wish they would make a modern version of sharp

  • @Shift12
    @Shift12 15 днів тому

    Is it just me or do you hear "Sean Bean" at 10:07 ?

  • @D-Rv8iv
    @D-Rv8iv Місяць тому +1

    Simmerson needed a quick stab or two. Waaaaaay earlier in the book series.

  • @gypsylovecharm123
    @gypsylovecharm123 Місяць тому

    Didn't know Vision was at Waterloo!

  • @drxym
    @drxym Місяць тому +1

    The French cavalry are charging, all 12 of them

  • @maverick8697
    @maverick8697 18 днів тому

    @2:48 I bid you stand men of the east ;)

  • @natedorney7032
    @natedorney7032 22 дні тому

    The actor who played Dragomirov is the same one who played Almaric in Kingdom Of Heaven.

  • @cattiethecat4896
    @cattiethecat4896 Місяць тому

    almost didnt rec sean bean

  • @cail592
    @cail592 Місяць тому +1

    Ok, (13:08) Sharpe did that French Sapper dirty. I'm just saying. CHIMO!

  • @MrBendylaw
    @MrBendylaw 8 днів тому

    I am too tired to post about another Sharpe clip, and yet my hatred for the Prince of Orange has compelled me to...now _that's_ soldiering.

  • @BowTiedSpacey
    @BowTiedSpacey Місяць тому

    Ned Stark doin alright in this war.

  • @jackson_craft_gamingscates9324

    0:04 - Tom Cruise cameo

  • @kmarasin
    @kmarasin Місяць тому

    Wellington not telling Sharpe about Harper being the missing man was somewhat ridiculous. If he wanted the "best man for the job" that's not something he would've withheld. It's not even honorable.

  • @GamerX13X
    @GamerX13X Місяць тому

    "Then you should know that God does not work upon a Sunday."
    That line is fucking cold and I LOVE IT

  • @williamdavis3609
    @williamdavis3609 18 днів тому

    The prince of orange did this three times that day. Same mistake

  • @joelellis7035
    @joelellis7035 Місяць тому +1

    This compilation is highly inaccurate! Sean Bean doesn't die anywhere!

  • @pl7992
    @pl7992 Місяць тому +1

    Vive l'EMPEREUR !

  • @georgeqiao3309
    @georgeqiao3309 2 години тому

    Wait, Sean Bean didn't die in this one?

  • @ОбИван81
    @ОбИван81 Місяць тому

    В дестве с удовольствием смотрел этот сериал.
    .

  • @196Stefan2
    @196Stefan2 Місяць тому +1

    13:16 It sucks to be a sappeur..

  • @padraiclukowski
    @padraiclukowski 25 днів тому

    Vive la France!

  • @DuramaterOZ
    @DuramaterOZ Місяць тому +1

    Stand you Boogers! Stand!

  • @remisanders9714
    @remisanders9714 Місяць тому +2

    I love the serie. But its a shame that they make the Prince of Orange look so bad and incompetent. In truth he was a fine commander and held the advance of at Quatre-Bras. Napoleon spoke highly of the Dutch bravery and the Prince. But the British want to be the heroes and taking al the credits. But in fact ,there where more foreign troops than English at the battle of Waterloo

    • @Perseus7567
      @Perseus7567 Місяць тому +2

      There was also more French troops at Dunkirk than British, doesn't make it any less of a heroic British story, does it?
      There was more British and Canadian troops on D-Day, does that take away the heroism of the US servicemen on Omaha, Utah and Point du Hoc? That's before we even mention they got there on mostly British ships, crewed by British men. So, under your logic, was the successful capture of Omaha beach purely thanks to the British?
      Waterloo was a stunning display of bravery and skill by the British. Would they have lost without the timely arrival of the Dutch? Maybe, probably even. Does that mean the British didn't hold out for hours, outnumbered - through pure brilliant tactical leadership, and otherworldly bravery?
      The Prince of Orange was incompetent, comparatively to the other officers surrounding him. Obviously, Sharpe himself is fictional and going to be over-powered as all TV/Movie main characters of any nationality are, but the historical characters present were, on the most part, more competent than the Prince of Orange. Out of all four main commanders present at the battle of Quatre Bras, both French and Seventh Coalition, the vast majority of historians would rightfully put the Prince of Orange lowest of the four. Start adding in some of the brightest lower-level commanders, and the Prince would probably fall lower in the list still.
      They aren't unfairly painting themselves "as the heroes", they were heroes. The real soldiers earned the right to be portrayed as such.

    • @SlyBlu7
      @SlyBlu7 19 днів тому

      ​​@@Perseus7567 I would argue that actually, the French effort to hold the approaches to the beach so that the British could make it to the boats was the more heroic story. For example, 40,000 French with 50 tanks holding up 4× their number and nearly 900 tanks at the Siege of Lille.
      So, yes. I would say that the erasure of heroic efforts by their allies DOES diminish the heroicness of their actions, because Hollywood and the BBC has everyone convinced that the British were *more* heroic than they really were - because they pretend to have done it all alone, spare a little help from God and St. George.

    • @SlyBlu7
      @SlyBlu7 19 днів тому

      And for fairness, having expanded your comment - the US pulls the same stunt, re. D-Day
      Media alone is a horrible way to teach a war.

    • @eriktreptow827
      @eriktreptow827 11 днів тому

      ​@@Perseus7567untimely arrival of the Dutch? You mean the Prussians, right?

  • @month32
    @month32 Місяць тому

    Now, say it with me lads...
    God save Ireland!

  • @philportway5988
    @philportway5988 Місяць тому

    The action at La Haye Sainte is from the wrong direction and no wood like this, I think they have this and the action at Hougomont, but still 100 times better than Ridley's attempt!

  • @occamraiser
    @occamraiser Місяць тому +2

    I hate Sharpe for one reason only.....but that reason is burned into my soul. 99% of Napoleonic artillery fired round-shot WHICH DOES NOT EXPLODE. You can have a decent percentage of exploding shells in American Civil War films if you must, BUT NOT NAPOLEONIC.

    • @catriona_drummond
      @catriona_drummond Місяць тому +1

      How would you film non exploding shells and make it look deadly?

  • @MondoBeno
    @MondoBeno Місяць тому

    Weren't British infantry trained to spear enemy cavalry?

  • @alvingallegos6367
    @alvingallegos6367 23 дні тому

    Ole Sharpe played on Ronin as a wannabe. The bloke on the left played on Knights Tale as a guy with a gambling problem.

  • @user-ve3gh5xg9q
    @user-ve3gh5xg9q Місяць тому +6

    Boromir Sharpe 😊