Same thing I have commented in his (NMS sir) Video... The persons who are working on just 11 and 12 level are marketing themselves as a scientist types in you tube university which is very dangerous for the students now a days.... But thanks you to make a video on this....
Don't you think that this is how math should work? Questioning something is the most important thing. At last, math is just all about tackling the problems.
@@blazingzest9380 let them be they are still suffering from colonial mindset , maths is not about who said what , he has all the right to question something whether he teaches 8th grade math or topology to college grads .
This explanation is still suspicious to me , there is nothing like some other type of summation, its just like analytical continuation, NMS sir's point was , the proof mostly people use to prove it is absolutely incorrect.... Before using "=" sign please first check whether its a number or not ... And after some basic divergent, convergence tests , we can see that 1, 2,3,4,5,6,7.... is a divergent series ... So we cannot use "=" this symbol in eqn ..... But then how we got -1/12 , its like defining something with something else to elongate the domain .... For example Factorials was only for wholes but then using some other definition we got our gamma function ...... Similarly we first define zeta in some other way and then substitute x=-1 , and got -1/12 This video's explanation was suspicious to me because.... you just said bunch of terms and didn't explain them ..... Saying heavy terms and then saying that " we cannot understand the genius's notebook " makes no sense ...... Thanks for reading.... If there is some mistake in my interpretation pls reply back in this comment
Thank you for watching this video... The very purpose of this video is to rectify the words of NMS sir not to prove him wrong about his intelligence. He said, "galatiyan ho jati h sabse, ramanujan se v galati hui". That was the point I was discussing. Ramanujan was absolutely correct in his own sense. You analysed very well that people use normal "=" sign and then fascinate others about that the sum of infinite natural numbers is -1/12. We all know it's incorrect. It's an entirely different thing that NMS sir has probably missed it or what, I don't know. I didn't explain them in depth because of the video length however I put three links and mentioned them in the video. If you are curious about it. Just have a look over them. You will come to know. If you want a dedicated video on this... Let me know Actually the whole controversy was because of the Numberphile's video about ramanujan summation. (May be, because I found his video circulated all over the internet. Sone other persons might have contributed in this misinformation due to misinterpretation) Once again, thank you for your valuable feedback...
Right explanation, best explanation no words for you , great work I will spread this video , who is try prove ramanujan ji as wrong . ramanujan ji is god.
Maine casmir effect se related ek snapshot video m paste Kiya hai... Usme apko niche ek series dikhegi jo ki sigma k terms m likhi hui hai. Us series ko expand krne pr wahi same series ati hai. Wha Ramanujan k is summation ko dalne m casmir effect ki ek specific value nikal kr ati hai jo experimentally v utna hi ati hai.
@@SanuAdhikari-ib8wn Ok... I will prepare a dedicated video for the options and paths that a dropout can pursue. I will try to include as many degrees as I can and will put forward all the opportunities available to you. Subscribe and stay tuned 🙂↔️😉
Excellent explanation Sir ji.NMS sir is a genius and excellent physics teacher butI think NMS should rectify it that it is not be true for convergent but true for divergent and Ramanujan was right from his perspective and that's why we call him the man who knew Infinity btw you are too a genius.🫡🫡
Bhai.. dont comment like this.. He is my physics teacher and he never behaved like he is god..And a human can never behave or become like god, Please have a scietific temprament, DoNot just spill anything from ur mouth, thats ur lack of observation or inferiority complex that u thought in this way.. Hope u understand
@@prashantthakur113 Accha bhai mene bohot bari baat kehe di hai unko God bolke I can understand your feelings since you are his student aur uske liye mein apse shama chata hoon mujhe please Shama kaar digiye.
@@prashantthakur113 actually kya hua ki sir ne bola ki Ramanujan ki jo infinite series hai wo convergent ka liye true nahi hai I agree but it is true for divergent and ye cheez string theory jaisa advance topics mein use hota hai aur Ramanujan is someone who is God for me aur jis karan mujhe gussa agaya ki yeh kya baat Hui.I too know how great NMS sir is he is an extraordinary teacher but Sir ko rectify karna chahiye ki bhale yei ye convergent ke liye true nahi hai but divergent ka liye true hai. Once again shama kar dena.🙏🙏
He has now apologized in his recent video🗿🗿
Indeed... 🙂
Same thing I have commented in his (NMS sir) Video...
The persons who are working on just 11 and 12 level are marketing themselves as a scientist types in you tube university which is very dangerous for the students now a days....
But thanks you to make a video on this....
Thank you for your feedback. I completely agree that it's important to have accurate information available.
Don't you think that this is how math should work? Questioning something is the most important thing. At last, math is just all about tackling the problems.
@@blazingzest9380 let them be they are still suffering from colonial mindset , maths is not about who said what , he has all the right to question something whether he teaches 8th grade math or topology to college grads .
Indeed... Absolutely correct...
One has the right to question something and this is the tendency which enabled humans to reach this state.
Same thing came to my mind when I watched that video of NMS sir. I knew that this Ramanujan sum is used in string theory.
This explanation is still suspicious to me , there is nothing like some other type of summation, its just like analytical continuation,
NMS sir's point was , the proof mostly people use to prove it is absolutely incorrect....
Before using "=" sign please first check whether its a number or not ...
And after some basic divergent, convergence tests , we can see that 1, 2,3,4,5,6,7.... is a divergent series ...
So we cannot use "=" this symbol in eqn .....
But then how we got -1/12 , its like defining something with something else to elongate the domain ....
For example Factorials was only for wholes but then using some other definition we got our gamma function ......
Similarly we first define zeta in some other way and then substitute x=-1 , and got -1/12
This video's explanation was suspicious to me because.... you just said bunch of terms and didn't explain them .....
Saying heavy terms and then saying that " we cannot understand the genius's notebook " makes no sense ......
Thanks for reading....
If there is some mistake in my interpretation pls reply back in this comment
Thank you for watching this video... The very purpose of this video is to rectify the words of NMS sir not to prove him wrong about his intelligence. He said, "galatiyan ho jati h sabse, ramanujan se v galati hui". That was the point I was discussing. Ramanujan was absolutely correct in his own sense. You analysed very well that people use normal "=" sign and then fascinate others about that the sum of infinite natural numbers is -1/12. We all know it's incorrect. It's an entirely different thing that NMS sir has probably missed it or what, I don't know.
I didn't explain them in depth because of the video length however I put three links and mentioned them in the video. If you are curious about it. Just have a look over them. You will come to know.
If you want a dedicated video on this... Let me know
Actually the whole controversy was because of the Numberphile's video about ramanujan summation. (May be, because I found his video circulated all over the internet. Sone other persons might have contributed in this misinformation due to misinterpretation)
Once again, thank you for your valuable feedback...
Ecelent
Right explanation, best explanation no words for you , great work I will spread this video , who is try prove ramanujan ji as wrong . ramanujan ji is god.
Thank you for watching 😊 ❤️
Your partice became successfull bro Mr.NMS sir , ne sorry bola for his mistake.@@vakrahara
@@virat-k9g Are sach m... 😱😳
Maine av dekha after reading your comment... 😃
What????how it is used in casmir effect
Maine casmir effect se related ek snapshot video m paste Kiya hai...
Usme apko niche ek series dikhegi jo ki sigma k terms m likhi hui hai.
Us series ko expand krne pr wahi same series ati hai. Wha Ramanujan k is summation ko dalne m casmir effect ki ek specific value nikal kr ati hai jo experimentally v utna hi ati hai.
Thanks sir🙏🙏
U r rlly respectful nice
He is next ramanujan❤
I have no words to you...❤❤🙏🏻🙏🏻❤
Sir please up up ki digree ki bare mai kuch bataye ,,,,wo mujhe bohat inspire karegi mujhe 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
I am dropper student of jee
Thank you for watching ❤️
Do you mean Top-Up degree?
Kuch vi digree
@@SanuAdhikari-ib8wn Ok... I will prepare a dedicated video for the options and paths that a dropout can pursue. I will try to include as many degrees as I can and will put forward all the opportunities available to you. Subscribe and stay tuned 🙂↔️😉
thank you sir ❤
Welcome dear
Great sir......❤
Thank you ❤️
@ 1:54
Excellent explanation Sir ji.NMS sir is a genius and excellent physics teacher butI think NMS should rectify it that it is not be true for convergent but true for divergent and Ramanujan was right from his perspective and that's why we call him the man who knew Infinity btw you are too a genius.🫡🫡
Thank you for the comment
@@vakrahara Sir you are bigger than me there is nothing to say thank you rather than that I should say thank you to you.
Bhai.. dont comment like this.. He is my physics teacher and he never behaved like he is god..And a human can never behave or become like god, Please have a scietific temprament, DoNot just spill anything from ur mouth, thats ur lack of observation or inferiority complex that u thought in this way.. Hope u understand
@@prashantthakur113 Accha bhai mene bohot bari baat kehe di hai unko God bolke I can understand your feelings since you are his student aur uske liye mein apse shama chata hoon mujhe please Shama kaar digiye.
@@prashantthakur113 actually kya hua ki sir ne bola ki Ramanujan ki jo infinite series hai wo convergent ka liye true nahi hai I agree but it is true for divergent and ye cheez string theory jaisa advance topics mein use hota hai aur Ramanujan is someone who is God for me aur jis karan mujhe gussa agaya ki yeh kya baat Hui.I too know how great NMS sir is he is an extraordinary teacher but Sir ko rectify karna chahiye ki bhale yei ye convergent ke liye true nahi hai but divergent ka liye true hai.
Once again shama kar dena.🙏🙏