UK Knife laws Theory VS Reality

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 вер 2024
  • UK knife laws in theory vs reality. UK knife laws allow you to carry a folding pocket knife with a blade under 3 inches provided it does not lock, however other knives can be carried in theory if you have a legitimate use for having one, but what you may consider legitimate use may not be legitimate to a Police Officer etc.
    This is why in my opinion selective application of the law is bad.
    Support me on Patreon
    / weaponsandstuff93
    Please comment, rate and subscribe for more.
    Follow me on Facebook and Twitter for updates:
    / weaponsandstuff93
    / weaponsstuff93

КОМЕНТАРІ • 471

  • @_Matsimus_
    @_Matsimus_ 6 років тому +461

    *knock at door* “POLICE! OPEN THE DOOR!! WE KNOW YOU HAVE A TOAST BUTTERING KNIFE!! WE HAVE A WARRANT FOR YOUR ARREST!”

    • @VictorGarciaR
      @VictorGarciaR 6 років тому +38

      IF YOU DO NOT COOPERATE, WE WILL TAZE YOU, OR EVEN CALL THE ARMED POLICE

    • @ChucksSEADnDEAD
      @ChucksSEADnDEAD 6 років тому +4

      Should have used incognito mode.

    • @alexk155k9
      @alexk155k9 6 років тому

      Ha

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +63

      Feel free to use the CS gas, I am prepared.

    • @jort93z
      @jort93z 6 років тому +8

      Most german police forces use pepperspray(OC based) instead of CS gas because its more reliable. Quite hillarous considering it is literally not allowed to be used against people. Civilians are only allowed to use pepperspray against animals, only CS gas is allowed to be used against humans. But police apperently doesn't care.

  • @pachicore
    @pachicore 6 років тому +409

    When a safety feature is illegal

    • @hamstermunchies5558
      @hamstermunchies5558 4 роки тому +17

      I collect knives and I always cut myself with non-locking blades. However I have never cut myself with locking knives

    • @greasythegreaser1825
      @greasythegreaser1825 4 роки тому +7

      @@hamstermunchies5558 Same I own like 14 and all of them have locks and I have literally NEVER cut myself once but I own one non lock and my thumb needed stitchs

    • @hamstermunchies5558
      @hamstermunchies5558 4 роки тому +3

      @@greasythegreaser1825 Ouch! My Victorinox SAK collection always gets me. So satisfying to play with and snap but can't let your mind wander off while you're playing with them

    • @eddiegluskin9601
      @eddiegluskin9601 3 роки тому +9

      Pretty much sums up the uk

    • @Blank-km4qr
      @Blank-km4qr 3 роки тому

      It’s to stop you from stabbing someone

  • @the0mighty0burrito
    @the0mighty0burrito 6 років тому +103

    I went to the royal armouries museum, and they had an entire room that was basically anti knife/gun propaganda.

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +64

      Sounds like a cuck museum sadly.

    • @the0mighty0burrito
      @the0mighty0burrito 6 років тому +36

      Weaponsandstuff93
      They have a bunch of “Statistics” that basically sum down to:
      “We need to ban knives so that our murder rate is 1% lower than Denmark!
      And best of all, they have a bizarre comic strip thing about a teenager that murders someone with a knife and is arrested, and they act like it was a weird accident, and he wouldn’t of hurt anyone if he didn’t have a knife.
      It ruined the rest of the museum for me.

    • @tracybeme1597
      @tracybeme1597 4 роки тому +1

      @@the0mighty0burrito It is just a political fad, it will pass the same as checks clothes disappeared over time.

    • @spiko-ou3bp
      @spiko-ou3bp 4 роки тому +10

      @@tracybeme1597 No it will never disappear because here, in the UK, the law doesn't care about legal citizens rights. They would rather protect the criminals.

    • @bobsaffron8284
      @bobsaffron8284 4 роки тому

      @@spiko-ou3bp "They" own both Parties and Houses of Parliament.

  • @untrust2033
    @untrust2033 4 роки тому +75

    Criminals will ignore the laws anyway, why force everyone else to have some freedom taken away.
    I'd say knife crime may go down if laws were laxed, the "american" way of thinking IE "I'm not going to stab anyone because everyone around me also has a knife"

    • @masondavies1621
      @masondavies1621 4 роки тому +11

      goes to stab someone in a shopping centre... 100 people turn around with 6 inch blade locking knives in their hand (cue temple run music)

    • @NotUndertaleAaron
      @NotUndertaleAaron 3 роки тому +2

      @@masondavies1621 this is funny 😂

    • @AaronW-ww4ds
      @AaronW-ww4ds 3 роки тому +3

      It really wouldn't go down since majority of knife crimes are not actually committed using knives like this they're committed using kitchen knives

    • @horror_punk480
      @horror_punk480 2 роки тому

      this comment aged horribly lol, england is in the situation you described and they have a very high knife crime rate

    • @untrust2033
      @untrust2033 2 роки тому

      @@horror_punk480 last time i checked no changes were made to knife law :/

  • @insertjjs
    @insertjjs 6 років тому +269

    And here in Texas, we legalized open carry of blades of any length from swiss army to broadswords.

  • @bennypazza5718
    @bennypazza5718 6 років тому +203

    *notices increase in crime with a certain item * *bans item* * crime using other item increases*. Repeat

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +48

      Crimes with said items still increase, for example the UK now has more shootings than at the peak when firearms were far easier to obtain.

    • @erebostd
      @erebostd 5 років тому +7

      @@Weaponsandstuff93 but... But... They are prohibited!!!.. Ni, the whole thing isn't funny anymore. I am really sorry for you, guys. Greetings from the other side of the canal...

    • @DialecticalMaterialismRocks
      @DialecticalMaterialismRocks 4 роки тому +2

      ACID

    • @ee-pd6oq
      @ee-pd6oq 4 роки тому +4

      Banning something makes more crimes, like if you try to get a gun, you are breaking 2 laws owning a firearm and someone dealing the firearm.

    • @ashleyoasis7948
      @ashleyoasis7948 3 роки тому +1

      War on drugs- more drugs war on Terror-more terriousts War on poverty-more poverty it be nice if we had a war on money becuse everything works opposite

  • @alexk155k9
    @alexk155k9 6 років тому +191

    Why did the walrus pressure check the gas mask
    He was looking for a good seal

    • @jort93z
      @jort93z 6 років тому +5

      The tighter the seal the better. Makes for a more fun time.

    • @SlickTwigDotWAVfile
      @SlickTwigDotWAVfile 6 років тому +1

      Skidaddle, Skadoodle, your Meme is now property of the glorious soviet regime.

    • @jesses.7107
      @jesses.7107 6 років тому

      Lol

    • @gooby8953
      @gooby8953 6 років тому

      Once I saw a walrus toss a poor little harbor seal off of a rock

  • @jackbagnall9851
    @jackbagnall9851 6 років тому +31

    Basically only allowed foldable toothpicks that when you stab something they fold back and cut your fingers off

  • @zucclinda9702
    @zucclinda9702 6 років тому +94

    when knife crime are nearly zero outside of London due to London gangs but you ban knives except the ones that are perfect for murder. #JustBritishThings

    • @forestwiids9710
      @forestwiids9710 4 роки тому +9

      Glasgow was the knife crime capital of europe

    • @user-to8qe5du9u
      @user-to8qe5du9u 4 роки тому +2

      Archetype Bias I don’t believe that

    • @gavokai1757
      @gavokai1757 4 роки тому +7

      Glasgow is stab capital of western Europe !! Razor gangs of like old days to football violence we never really let it go coz we still got the old firm 🖕

    • @michellenich3172
      @michellenich3172 4 роки тому +7

      @@user-to8qe5du9u believe it mate, Glasgow is rough even nowadays.

    • @user-to8qe5du9u
      @user-to8qe5du9u 4 роки тому +2

      Michelle Nich yh but football is everywhere and I’m pretty sure London is now

  • @undertaker666dead
    @undertaker666dead 6 років тому +101

    UK Knife laws are very crazy

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +14

      Yup

    • @spiko-ou3bp
      @spiko-ou3bp 4 роки тому +12

      @Anomaly90 lmao we can't even have knifes yet. worry about the guns later.

    • @123benley
      @123benley 4 роки тому +1

      @@spiko-ou3bp but we still have guns and shooting ranges legally, look up the Blackburn shooting recently he was part of / a member of Blackburn gun club, learning shooting an then Carrys out a murder

    • @123benley
      @123benley 4 роки тому

      My neighbor was part of this club in 80s- 90s they had alsorts of guns including replicars of Clint Eastwood's cowboy pistols guns,Rifle and gun belt fully working, had the same stitching to match they had 44 magnum same as dirty harry, Shot guns,
      9mms, Berettas ,Glochs, made there own bullets under the stairs.
      There son I grew up with
      Crazy that we as kids handled these guns when they went out as a they kept there porn locked up in same cupboard,
      back in betamax days, they where odd but lost some guns after the UK laws changed but kept some.
      We moved away so not sure if they still have them or not but as a child we did have gun shops and knife shops locally,
      I used to collect knifes when I was younger my grandad, Dad and brother did,
      We still have several throwing knifes Bowie knifes flick knifes butterfly knifes, Gurkyr and machetes, We used as we used to camp out a lot growing up with it being cheap holidays and such
      but was taught to be responsible an respectful with knifes how to use handle and throw them properly poorer trees where battered at end of weekend not once did I need to carry a knife for or want to for protection you had your ✊ for that.
      All are legal if they stay in house.
      But illegal if take out side the house to carry ect. With the new laws.
      These younger ones are stupid they have had some very nice expensive exceptional crafted knifes banned because they have no regard or respect for them
      which most of these idiots use kitchen knifes anyway for there stupid antics cheap things where as quality knifes cost and last a long time if looked after

    • @lozhell
      @lozhell 4 роки тому

      They are if you listen to this blokes poor understanding of the law.

  • @MikaJarvi86
    @MikaJarvi86 Рік тому +5

    The laws is so complicated and unreliable today's world, that it's just better to ignore them unless you believe there's a high change being get caught

  • @jaycee7594
    @jaycee7594 6 років тому +62

    Dude, The law is an ass.... we knew this though didn't we? Heard a tale about a carpet fitter who was collared for carrying a stanley knife....outrageous. It's a real shame that the government doesn't address the real causes of Knife crime...Gangs, drugs etc that sort of thing. Great video as usual sir.

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +5

      Cheers, as said at this point I regularly just carry a lock knife on me if I have a reason for having it, as if they throw the book at me I'd rather have been carrying a safer knife to use.

    • @itisimatadvc
      @itisimatadvc 6 років тому

      Get a knife with a sheath and it is legal if it's under three inches, it doesn't lock because it doesn't fold so if it not a combat knife so if it is something such as a fishing or hunting knife then you will be able to carry this on you legally.

    • @spiko-ou3bp
      @spiko-ou3bp 4 роки тому

      @@itisimatadvc unless the cops decide to not like you..

  • @ottoman_reenactor_ct
    @ottoman_reenactor_ct 6 років тому +64

    *POLICE BRAKES IN*
    You goota loicanse for this video there mayte?????!!!!!!

  • @xencio557
    @xencio557 6 років тому +50

    They should ban breathing in my opinion

    • @spiko-ou3bp
      @spiko-ou3bp 4 роки тому

      @@Halon_1211 😂😂😂

    • @VinceMenger
      @VinceMenger 4 роки тому +1

      And there we are ! Thanks for giving them the idea...

  • @Max-kq6yn
    @Max-kq6yn 6 років тому +22

    i live in austria, i am allowed to have any knife i want, no matter how long, big, small, locking not locking, it doesnt matter in austria! You are even allowed to wear it in public

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +6

      Good for you, much better laws than here.

    • @worldwarwill1278
      @worldwarwill1278 4 роки тому +1

      From the episode of the Simpsons - Bart vrs Australia.
      When Bart had a knife whilst in a bar in Australia, a bloke came up to Bart and said "you call that a knife? This is a knife!" then pulls out a spoon. Bart tells him that it's a spoon and he says that he sees Bart has played "knifey-spoony" before.

    • @Uncle_Sam76
      @Uncle_Sam76 4 роки тому +2

      Lol wait until you hear what Americans can buy.

    • @davidw1634
      @davidw1634 3 роки тому

      Yeah a mate of mine got threatened whilst outside their hotel with a switch blade in Austria

    • @yesno9592
      @yesno9592 3 роки тому

      @Max
      You are mistaken.
      Australia has exactly the same knife carry laws as England.

  • @KillaKoi.
    @KillaKoi. 6 років тому +34

    2 weeks later we find out u went to jail for carrying a small knife for cutting hay bail strings.

  • @AndreMonthy
    @AndreMonthy 4 роки тому +11

    POLICE OPEN UP. IVE GOT A WARRENT TO CHECK YOUR THINKING.

  • @BB-br4qh
    @BB-br4qh 5 років тому +17

    Once all of the weapons are gone that's when the bastards can really start controlling us

  • @pjanoo6973
    @pjanoo6973 4 роки тому +4

    Imagine going to jail for carrying to protect your life.

  • @DRG2800
    @DRG2800 3 роки тому +5

    Moved to Bulgaria from my native homeland of Wales last year. In Bulgaria knifes are not classed as weapons as such and therefore there is no legislation on length/type/usage of any sort of blades, as so you can legally carry a 12 inch blade without any form of troubles, maybe a slight wonder why from a policeman but he will send you on your way without issue.

    • @cammi9948
      @cammi9948 2 роки тому

      Hungary is similar

  • @R04DR8G3
    @R04DR8G3 6 років тому +73

    Oi mate you got a loicense for that deadly butter knife you 'ave there?

    • @zucclinda9702
      @zucclinda9702 6 років тому +8

      [guywithaminigun ] you gota permit for that loisence mate

    • @R04DR8G3
      @R04DR8G3 6 років тому +11

      @@zucclinda9702 you got a loicense for asking ya cheeky bastard?

  • @jort93z
    @jort93z 6 років тому +26

    in germany you can (still) carry two handed locking knifes such as opinels. And funnily enough, theres a length limit for fixed blade knifes(that limit 12cm) but not for folding knifes, so you could legally carry an Opinel No 13(22cm blade length) or something, lol.

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +5

      Strange laws

    • @jort93z
      @jort93z 6 років тому +1

      Indeed

    • @gooby8953
      @gooby8953 6 років тому +2

      Cut the blade of a Longsword off and fix it into some PVC so it folds

    • @GrumpyIan
      @GrumpyIan 6 років тому

      And here in Indiana, USA as long as it isn't a ballistic knife or throwing star you're good. You can carry throwing knives, switch blades, long swords, etc and the most they can do is just tell you to put it in your car if you're going to an event or building that doesn't allow weapons.

    • @jort93z
      @jort93z 6 років тому +1

      You can own a longsword, but carrying "weapons" is not allowed. Long swords are weapons by design, so you couldn't carry those.

  • @tidge879
    @tidge879 5 років тому +13

    I think the opinel is in more of a grey area than you suggest. The home office definition states a locking knife that is unlocked with a button or switch. The opinel is neither. I think it's a lockable knife rather than a locking knife as the lock does not engage as soon as the blade is fully open.
    Would be a tough argument to make depending on the copper I guess.

    • @G1NZOU
      @G1NZOU 4 роки тому +4

      True I think when they originally wrote it they were thinking of the scary switchblades mafia guys always use in movies (same reason they banned basically all the ninja weapons), but the Opinel is more of a slow open, use two hands to slide the ring lock kind of deal. Less threatening.

    • @caskwith
      @caskwith 4 роки тому +1

      The law was clarified in Harris vs DPP, so the locking opinel is not a grey area, quite clear cut (pun intended).

    • @tidge879
      @tidge879 4 роки тому

      @@caskwith so it's illegal to carry without "good reason"?

    • @caskwith
      @caskwith 4 роки тому

      @@tidge879 Correct.

    • @averageknifeenjoyer3108
      @averageknifeenjoyer3108 2 роки тому

      Nah Bcs non locking have to be able to be refolded without the use of any other mechanism

  • @jeffreybarton8095
    @jeffreybarton8095 5 років тому +7

    Good video! I've been collecting knives for the last 40 odd years, and the vast majority of my collection have to stay at home, in a box.
    This is a sad situation. It's getting to the point that emigrating to America or some other less strict country is becoming more attractive to me every day.

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  5 років тому +2

      Cheers, and sadly these new laws will not do anything to actually restrict knife crime.

    • @jeffreybarton8095
      @jeffreybarton8095 5 років тому +3

      @@Weaponsandstuff93 True.....Nobody in power wants to really tackle it.....They choose a public pacifying option that has no hope of ever working.

    • @GanymedeXD
      @GanymedeXD 2 роки тому

      Meanwhile I assume plenty of your collection must be turned in as we are not allowed to keep em at home any more.

    • @jeffreybarton1297
      @jeffreybarton1297 2 роки тому

      @@GanymedeXD No, I'm Ok. It's still legal for most knives to be kept at home. The only restricted ones being gravity knives, ballisongs, button spring knives, and probably a couple more I can't think of.
      I can have pretty much any knife other than that. When the blades get to 'sword length' then I'm still Ok, as long as they don't resemble curved Samurai swords.......Even Samurai swords are still legal, as long as they're hand made Carbon steel. That loophole might be tightened, if it already hasn't been.

  • @wehraboowaifu2428
    @wehraboowaifu2428 6 років тому +17

    Thank god I live in Texas.

    • @David-cm4ok
      @David-cm4ok 3 роки тому

      Where everyone carrys guns and knives 🤔

    • @fadli_1577
      @fadli_1577 3 роки тому

      @@David-cm4ok not everyone

    • @nt7594
      @nt7594 3 роки тому

      @@David-cm4ok yeah good

  • @bhgtree
    @bhgtree 3 роки тому +3

    Police (to knife attack victim): "Sir, could you identify the attacker."
    Victim: "Yes officer, he was 5'10, slim wearing a hoodie......Oh, and after the attack he was missing his right index finger, cos his knife had no lock."

  • @VarnHomestead
    @VarnHomestead 6 років тому +6

    It blows my mind Knife laws are crazy in the UK. We can carry any knife were I live in the US. The only thing that is illegal are Dirks in certain circumstances.

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому

      Strange there's a law on dirks but yes UK knife laws are nonsensical at best.

  • @archstanton1628
    @archstanton1628 6 років тому +4

    Good video, sums up a lot of the silly aspects of UK knife law. Though for me, I think the Opinel would be more likely to get your collar felt than the Victorinox.
    The law actually specifically mentions Swiss army knives as being everyday carry legal.

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +5

      And people have still been charged for having swiss army knives on them, so your basically not safe with our laws.

  • @sexguy7638
    @sexguy7638 3 роки тому +2

    Luckily all my knives are disguised as spoons

  • @gavokai1757
    @gavokai1757 4 роки тому +5

    It's up to the arresting officer to just make up his own laws on the spot and bully people with it !! People have been arrested in Scotland for carrying paint scrappers before

    • @AaronW-ww4ds
      @AaronW-ww4ds 3 роки тому

      Wrong it is down to judges and courts to decide whether you have a valid excuse for carrying one as for the police whether you have a valid excuse or not they don't care you'll have it taken off you and booked into a cell so when released will be brought in front of a judge for the judge to decide whether you did wrong or not as far as the police are concerned you've done wrong as you're still carrying a weapon and maximum prison sentence for it is 4 years and they can give you an unlimited fine since the fine laws used to be £5,000 until it changed in 2015 and the police are only doing what they're told to do and chances are they've more than likely been given the chance but then they got gobby which led to their arrest

  • @OverlandTT
    @OverlandTT 6 років тому +2

    People need to understand a knife is a tool, lobbyists are plain stupid and they don't seem to realise a ballpoint pen is as dangerous as a knife!

  • @shawnmartin1306
    @shawnmartin1306 3 роки тому +6

    Meanwhile in the US we argue over who should be allowed to own fully automatic firearms. The license for those is a pain in ass.
    The UK they are debating over 3in knives lol

    • @GanymedeXD
      @GanymedeXD 2 роки тому

      Firearms? Oh, know them from TV … never seen one in real life! Do they really exist? 😜

    • @shawnmartin1306
      @shawnmartin1306 2 роки тому

      @@GanymedeXD come to America and we can show you the light 😇

  • @WeaponCollector
    @WeaponCollector 6 років тому +9

    Great video mate, our knife laws are so backwards, I agree a better law would be if it was sub 3 inch CAN lock and be carried for no reason, even a 2 inch lock knife would be good for using.

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +3

      Yeah I used to have a Gerber lock knife under 3 inches with no flip mechanism useless for nefarious uses, but very safe for utility uses, but the law treats it the same as a giant Bowie for example.

    • @prodbykaji
      @prodbykaji 5 років тому

      WeaponCollector dude, i love your vids
      surprised to see you here

  • @sme5130
    @sme5130 6 років тому +6

    I usually carry a spring assisted, 4 Inch, locking knife. I live in the US

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +1

      Then you are safe.

    • @sme5130
      @sme5130 6 років тому

      Weaponsandstuff93 I live in the state of Connecticut, and basically, I can own any knife, but if the blade is longer than 4 inches, or if it's a switchblade you can't be caught with in out in public

    • @schleybailey
      @schleybailey 4 роки тому

      I live in wa and could stay strapped with a sword if I wanted to.

    • @kova1577
      @kova1577 2 роки тому

      How do you own a deadly assualt weapon? Don’t go on a mass stabbing spree where the knife grows legs and magically becomes evil

  • @averageknifeenjoyer3108
    @averageknifeenjoyer3108 2 роки тому +3

    If there’s literally any crime in the uk with pistols (there is) something very very very illegal in the uk, then why do police expect to stop criminals carrying knives that you can buy from a common store just because they told them not to

  • @theschlong3844
    @theschlong3844 3 роки тому +2

    *But how do I get a license for stabbing by the Queen?*

  • @oldbaldguy6151
    @oldbaldguy6151 6 місяців тому

    In my day (80's) you could carry a machete when backpacking/bush crafting with no problems, as we had no ill intent. Now, I still have no ill intent but am unable to carry one. I checked with the Police regarding the law and it comes down to the intended use. I carry a small folding non locking multi tool on me and a sheath knife squared away in my pack for wood craft at camp. If I have interpreted the law correctly, I should have no issues! This conversation with the police was done via 101 and the call was logged and an email sent to me, so I can say I followed the law to the best of my knowledge!

  • @slamblamboozled1245
    @slamblamboozled1245 5 років тому +2

    I carry a Boker+ XS. Always worried I might get nicked for it though, as it's got that super-dooper-tactical olive drab handle and the scary clip point.

  • @Demonmixer
    @Demonmixer 3 роки тому

    I got a knife with a three inch locking blade from a market stall. I wanted it as a fishing and general utility knife. The bloke tried selling me this thing which was over twice the size and also locking. He told me it was legal because it didn't have a button to eject the blade. I told him I wanted it for fishing, not hunting buffalo.

  • @thepenultimateninja5797
    @thepenultimateninja5797 4 роки тому

    Another reason you might be less likely to get into trouble for carrying an Opinel is that they don't lock automatically, and many people do not even know they are capable of locking.
    My friend had kept an Opinel in his fishing tackle box for many years, and he had absolutely no idea the collar could be rotated to lock the blade until I showed him.
    If you happen to encounter a police officer who is not familiar with Opinels, there's a good chance they will not figure out the lock.
    I carried a No. 7 for many years when I lived in the UK. I ground the blade into a drop point, which shortened it just enough to bring it to legal length, and I removed the locking collar with circlip pliers.
    Now I live in the US, I carry a No. 8 with the locking collar intact. Great little knives.

  • @MegaBoilermaker
    @MegaBoilermaker 3 роки тому +1

    Opinel lock knives for example are used by thousands of Commercial Fishermen (not Anglers) across Europe and any Fisherman will tell you why you need a locking blade on the rolling, pitching deck of a working vessel.

  • @rogaldorn605
    @rogaldorn605 4 роки тому +1

    "maybe you are breaking the law depends on the policeman's attitude" italian knife laws in a nutshell

  • @Oldman525
    @Oldman525 Рік тому

    The law is clear, however under certain conditions you may argue that you have a good reason to carry a certain knife besides the ones deemed everyday carry (EDC), you can not argue that a kitchen knife 10" carried in the belt by a 14-year-old for personal protection or because he is taking it home is a good reason if stopped by an officer whilst he is acting suspiciously. You can carry within reason a knife for a good reason and one example is camping however it is not a good reason to openly carry a knife in a city centre or in a pub or school even if it is legal, you need to have a good reason to carry any knife.

  • @hoopsfan92
    @hoopsfan92 4 роки тому +1

    Only discovered your channel last night. Loving your videos. Keep it up 😁

  • @bajamus69
    @bajamus69 6 років тому +27

    Come to the us, your inter justice system is broken and they might ban your hands for punching people

    • @bigjizzyD
      @bigjizzyD 6 років тому +5

      rattlesnake survival that's already been done, it's called self defence and that's not allowed here in the UK. Just have to lay there and take the beating from the criminal and then one from the police afterwards

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому +16

      I wish reason for emigrating could be as simple as UK refugee.

    • @bajamus69
      @bajamus69 6 років тому +3

      bigjizzyD plese just move to America

    • @MadDogSurvival
      @MadDogSurvival 6 років тому

      Wished I could bro! Best wishes friend 👍🏽👍🏽

    • @crowmagpie
      @crowmagpie 5 років тому

      @@bigjizzyD not true

  • @kova1577
    @kova1577 2 роки тому

    A tool should never have stupid laws against it

  • @eimdeima
    @eimdeima 3 роки тому +1

    However a nice 1.5m walking stick is perfectly legal.

  • @chuck1prillaman
    @chuck1prillaman 2 роки тому

    Virginia law allows carrying a butcher knife so long as you aren't threatening someone.

  • @ev1677
    @ev1677 4 роки тому +1

    It's even illegal to make a campfire 😂😂😂😂😭😭

  • @williammcconville4967
    @williammcconville4967 2 роки тому

    In reality in uk if you have a pillow and you intend to use it as a weapon its against the law

  • @Nwolf1840
    @Nwolf1840 5 років тому

    Why the hell is a knife that locks illegal? That's a safety precaution.

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  5 років тому +1

      Because politicians here would rather blame scary knives than answer to the fact that cutting police numbers and fucking over poor people has lead to a stabbing epidemic.

  • @literallyramennoodles7393
    @literallyramennoodles7393 4 роки тому +1

    "You got a *License* for that *butterknife* ?"

  • @veidorje1681
    @veidorje1681 3 роки тому +1

    france : the swiss army knife is just about the only knife you are allowed to carry forget the more recent model with the liner lock
    that's pathetic in reality millions of people do carry knives and mostly knives with a locking device what is more important dumb laws or cutting your finger to the bone ?
    ps : si t'as pas le droit prends le gauche : if you don't have the right take the left : ) thanks 4 sharing

  • @martinspalding374
    @martinspalding374 2 роки тому

    if you use a knife raguly its only sensible to have a locking one , the last thing you want is sharp blade closing on your fingers

  • @MegaBoilermaker
    @MegaBoilermaker 4 роки тому

    Opinels are also extensively used by Fishermen (commercial) and Agricultural workers.

  • @rossewing8006
    @rossewing8006 3 роки тому

    I got a 12 month suspended sentence when I was about 13 for having a lock blade with a blade of 1” I was using it for carving wood.

    • @AaronW-ww4ds
      @AaronW-ww4ds 3 роки тому

      If that was in the UK that's because its illegal for anyone under 18 to be sold or in possession of or own them but if it was under adult supervision then it shouldn't have even mattered since it was an adults property and you were just using it

  • @J276
    @J276 5 років тому

    If the police is reading this, I have a d2 razor style japanese pocket knife. Modern from Haoming knives and its over 3 inches. It's not fair but there are less than 3 inches.

  • @zenoweeb3331
    @zenoweeb3331 3 роки тому

    It shouldn't depend on what the mood of the officer is if you've got a uk legal knife or if they dislike you or something but sadly that's how it is and I hate it knowing that i could go thru court even though the knife is fully uk legal

    • @GanymedeXD
      @GanymedeXD 2 роки тому

      There is no such thing like ‘fully’ UK legal … depends in situation! And hence on cop!

  • @DelNiceBeto
    @DelNiceBeto 6 років тому

    In georgia,usa you can legally carry any any knife under 5 inches. anymore and you need a permit for it.

  • @clarky4492
    @clarky4492 4 роки тому +2

    I find our knife laws weird...I find myself justifying my legal collection which is more legal to carry! when the lawful answer is all of them .

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  4 роки тому

      Yeah very sad isn't it

    • @clarky4492
      @clarky4492 4 роки тому

      @@Weaponsandstuff93 yes but my sec 139 curiosity has caused me to make a mace for curiosity alone

  • @codenamebravo2212
    @codenamebravo2212 3 роки тому

    Why don't they allow licence to carry, then they will make money and we can still get to enjoy bushcraft with a proper tool.

  • @ronaldayres546
    @ronaldayres546 3 роки тому +1

    Rights are granted by God and what greater right that self defense.A person need to be able to be armed at all time with the weapon of their chose.

  • @jammy86
    @jammy86 4 роки тому +1

    Thank you this is really informative do these laws still apply in 2020?

    • @rc59191
      @rc59191 4 роки тому +1

      They've only gotten worse.

  • @broken1394
    @broken1394 3 роки тому

    The Law is already a chip on a shoulder.
    I'm a SAK EDC person.
    Looking to add an opinel no 4 soon - park whittling is my jam.
    Enjoyed the vid.

  • @strangelyjamesly4078
    @strangelyjamesly4078 3 роки тому +1

    As well as falling foul of the knife specific laws you can have a perfectly legal knife and still be charged with possession of an offensive weapon. Going to a football match with a knife will get you charged while going to a rugby match with the same knife will like not be punished. All laws with a "reasonable excuse" clause should be rewritten.

    • @AaronW-ww4ds
      @AaronW-ww4ds 3 роки тому

      Depends as and where you have it as not every situation you are in requires it to be on you and it all comes down to who searches you and if you start get cocky and gobby which majority of people start to do which escalates the situation to the point they pretty much bring an arrest on themselves and all legal pocket knives have to be concealed and not on show to the public as when it's not concealed is when it becomes illegal and you get in trouble

    • @GanymedeXD
      @GanymedeXD 2 роки тому

      Most annoying is that shitloads of items is now illegal to have in your home! Goodbye decorative swords in your living room!

  • @matthewmathers2944
    @matthewmathers2944 4 роки тому

    A lock knife is legal but not without a reason and you need a good reason then you can have it. Examples like a construction worker police officer army soldier etc.

  • @GrumpyIan
    @GrumpyIan 6 років тому

    Here in Indiana you can carry any type of blade as long as it isn't a ballistic knife or throwing star [switchblades are legal]. Anyone can carry a knife [18+] (you don't need an I.D. or permit to carry one) Only time you can get in trouble is if it is a government owned property that doesn't allow 'weapons', or a privately owned place that doesn't allow them..(Those places has someone that will ask if you have one on you and will use a metal detector) though the worst they can do is just tell you you can't enter until you get rid of it. (Though there where many times where I've shown them my pocket knife and they let me through anyways) So yes you can carry a machete into a store or police station and they can't do anything about it until you actually try to hurt someone.

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому

      Those sound like sensible laws rather than "OI WHERE'S YOUR LICENSE!"

  • @54V4
    @54V4 4 роки тому +1

    Awesome content... I think a lot more people should consider your video. The law allows the police to have a lot of wiggle room and that's 100% wrong in my view, also, I love your idea of being able to carry anything while you are not threatening and/or if someone's "clean"... WHY NOT? Thx for the awesome info! {sub}

  • @mathewofborg7280
    @mathewofborg7280 4 роки тому

    I think Florida has sort of reasonable knife laws, any knife over 10 centimeters can’t be conceal carried.

  • @northumbriabushcraft1208
    @northumbriabushcraft1208 4 роки тому

    Just ordered a new poket knife, a Japanese Higonokami. I've been putting off getting it for ages, but my trusty Opinel no.5 (no.5 doesn't lock) shut on my fingers and i got pretty badly hurt. Ordered a new bushcraft knife at the same time, literally did this 2 minutes ago and this video popped up.

  • @MadDogSurvival
    @MadDogSurvival 6 років тому

    Totally and utterly agree with all that you have said brother! Very well done! Best wishes friend 👍🏽👍🏽😎

  • @WyliesOutdoorWorld
    @WyliesOutdoorWorld 5 років тому

    the law actually states that a"Button" locking the knife, opinals and have a collor but you will find it's up to the officer in real life

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  5 років тому

      Yeah that's the problem even if you technically don't break a law, you could still have to endure all the legal proceedings just for it to be thrown out later on

    • @caskwith
      @caskwith 4 роки тому

      Read Harris vs DPP which clarified the law on that. Basically it cannot have anything that impedes the folding of the blade.

  • @Salad360
    @Salad360 5 років тому

    Meanwhile I'm legally allowed to carry a conceald handgun with no license or permit of any kind.

  • @thebritishww2man
    @thebritishww2man 4 роки тому

    Great video!
    Lots of useful information on nice knives. Thanks for posting!

  • @MegaBoilermaker
    @MegaBoilermaker 4 роки тому

    If any UK laws were well drafted then they would not need the attention of the a lawyer in court and that would defeat the object of the exercise.

  • @jakesteele7754
    @jakesteele7754 4 роки тому

    Whether or not the carrying of a knife is just is decided in court.

  • @ronaldayres546
    @ronaldayres546 4 роки тому

    Why is it that politicians want to take away your rights,an not do their job and put criminals away.At least here in Indiana I can carry my Glock 42 or about any knives I want.

  • @ghost-jesus
    @ghost-jesus 5 років тому

    I wonder how easy itd be to make some sort of "80 percent" locking knife that you could set up in such a manner that a screw head in the handle could be turned to make it into a locking knife, but when the screw is turned the other way it is not a locking knife such that when you are walking down the street and get stopped the officer would examine a non locking knife, but when you use it you could turn the screw and have a locking knife?

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  5 років тому +1

      Weaponcollector has done a video on a knife like that, that used a Allen key to lock the knife, quite a clever design.

  • @Diabolical-Tyrant
    @Diabolical-Tyrant 4 роки тому

    I’m more scared of the TV license man my self

  • @kyoukotoshino5600
    @kyoukotoshino5600 4 роки тому +1

    The great steak knife and spoon roundup.

  • @ozzyzanini2460
    @ozzyzanini2460 2 роки тому

    Well said mate. Still extremely relevant even after 3 years. 🤘🏻😎

  • @tylermills2807
    @tylermills2807 5 років тому

    So what about in my house or property, i want a locking blade not very big just to stay around the house opening boxes and cutting various bits can I have one? If I can get one through the post

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  5 років тому +1

      Lock knives are perfectly legal to own in your home.

    • @tylermills2807
      @tylermills2807 5 років тому

      @@Weaponsandstuff93 perfect thank you for the reply

  • @jacobcarolan1172
    @jacobcarolan1172 5 років тому

    I live in a midwestern state and so many people carry knives probably 25%. The way our law works is you can carry any bladed weapon in public, if its blade is over 4 inches you have to have it easily visible. I don’t hear about knife crimes like this probably because everyone around here knows that any random victim could be and likely is armed with a weapon capable of ending their criminal career if ya know what I mean.

  • @Jones-xx2gc
    @Jones-xx2gc 5 років тому

    I use a lock knife at work now. Nearly had a bad accident with one that was UK legal with a slip joint.

  • @roundtheloopandback
    @roundtheloopandback Рік тому

    06:11 I am interested, could you point me to the case where someone has been arrested, charged and then successfully prosecuted for carrying a SAK, because unless they have said they are carrying it for self defense or have been waving it about causing someone to take offense that really should not have happened. And honestly I'd be interested in the circumstances where that has happened as it seems on the face of it to be a mis-carriage of justice, unless they had it in a banned location. I appreciate this comment is necromancy of the highest order. If people wonder why you can't have a locking blade its because the law sees it as a fixed blade and its not legal to carry a fixed blade without "good reason".

  • @kuchenzwiebel7147
    @kuchenzwiebel7147 6 років тому +2

    What is your opinion on gun bans in most countries in Europe?

  • @oldcol8923
    @oldcol8923 3 роки тому

    3:10 you'd better hope that a police officer seeing you opening bags or hay bales with a locking knife & that is your "reasonable excuse" is having a VERY good day, otherwise you're toast! My reasoning? You do NOT require a locking knife to cut bags or string! BTW 30+ year knifemaker, founding member of BB

  • @GuerrillaSauce
    @GuerrillaSauce 3 роки тому

    You're really not wrong on anything you've said, and it is nice for people putting themselves out there publicly to at least get all the facts right! However I have to say it seems like you don't know the complete history as to why our laws are the way they are, and why, as someone who in the UK, has been collecting knives longer than you've (probably) been alive, I'm happy to offer that insight. I'm not saying it's going to make any difference to your conclusions (let's be honest the laws are not entirely logical), but I can at least see why the laws we have now are now the way they are.

  • @cammi9948
    @cammi9948 2 роки тому

    Im shocked about the swiss army knife. It looks like the most harmless thing out there it’s literally supposed to be a little harmless pocket tool

  • @m.g.540
    @m.g.540 2 роки тому

    Just get a large fork or spoon and sharpen the edges

  • @J276
    @J276 5 років тому +1

    How come the lock blade is not OK for the law?

  • @kellykapowski4004
    @kellykapowski4004 5 років тому

    I've sat at work using an openel no 6 and no one batted an eyelid pulled out a Stanley to open a parcel every one jumped it's crazy

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  5 років тому

      Yeah very strange

    • @deanwaller8283
      @deanwaller8283 3 роки тому

      @@Weaponsandstuff93 especially considering the opinel is likely as sharp as the Stanley

  • @ojsimps701
    @ojsimps701 3 роки тому

    A gardener I carry a 17" golok in uk

  • @JamesDC42
    @JamesDC42 5 років тому

    3:48 It may be legal to carry but it looks a bit menacing. So the public and the police would not like it compared to something like a Spyderco Urban.

  • @ThomasRonnberg
    @ThomasRonnberg Рік тому

    You might like those lagioulle folders

  • @austinhernandez2716
    @austinhernandez2716 3 роки тому

    I'm lucky to live in the US when it comes to this issue. Although, even here it varies greatly by state. Luckily I live in Georgia, where "knife" is defined by a blade longer than 12"(30cm), so any knife with a blade shroter than that isn't even mentioned in the Georgia code and they're perfectly legal to use and carry like any other object(except for in government buildings, schools, etc). At least in theory, because the police officers here seem not to know the damn law. I think that's something all countries have in common, under trained law enforcement officers.

    • @GanymedeXD
      @GanymedeXD 2 роки тому

      US … well … we only know firearms from TV!

  • @ojsimps701
    @ojsimps701 3 роки тому

    I am a labourer I used to have several lock knives but nowadays it's so problematic I dont use them outside of home. I still likena good blade just not gonna take it out and about . Personally I do like swiss army knives they are legal I think?

    • @AaronW-ww4ds
      @AaronW-ww4ds 3 роки тому

      Swiss army pocket knives are one of the legal ones as the blade is way under 3 inches its not lockable and its technically a foldable blade aswell which is one of the requirements for a legal pocket knife to be carried on you and I wonder why Stanley blades can be legal when once they open it locks into place and you have to press a button to press the blade back into the case and painters and decorators etc always have one on them when working

  • @hamstermunchies5558
    @hamstermunchies5558 4 роки тому

    Speaking of Promithi pocket knives, they have made a knife that is supposed to be UK legal but according to buyers its serious cop bait. The blade is under 3 inches and it doesn't lock but it is in the style of a karambit so it is always seen as a weapon. Ok I kinda get it since karambits have been used as lethal weapons in martial arts but this is where the current UK knife law doesn't work. From everything I can find karambits are legal if they have only one blade on the inside and they fold closed

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  4 роки тому

      The worst ones are the folding utility knives some companies make that the police can claim is a concealed blade pretending to be a credit card

  • @confedboia5820
    @confedboia5820 6 років тому +1

    Have you seen or heard anyone being arrested for having a knife for a good reason yet? Like a knife for fishing or camping?

    • @confedboia5820
      @confedboia5820 6 років тому

      Haha I see

    • @Weaponsandstuff93
      @Weaponsandstuff93  6 років тому

      Not personally but there are lots of news articles of people being arrested for possessing a knife with perfect justification for having it.

  • @BaddaBigBoom
    @BaddaBigBoom 2 роки тому

    Theoretical situation: Searched and found to be in possession of Tangram locking knife and claims it's just for cutting hay bales at a charity event.
    Quick background check:
    Hmm, clever knowlegeable guy, lives with his parents, is a militaria enthusiast and collector of airguns, bows, knives, uniforms and riot gear with a UA-cam channel called "Weapons And Stuff" is friends with another UA-camr called "Weapon Collector" has a skinhead and is wearing a black shirt AND expresses anti police strategy regarding our "selective application of the law".
    Just sayin' ;-)