Let's not make this complicated. Manchus existed in Manchurian land with various names throughout the history. They were ruled under Goguryo, Balhae (Bohai), Tang, Yuan, Ming rules over the years. They established Jin dynasty and invaded North China but failed to capture all of China. But, later established Qing dynasty and ruled over not only China but also successfully took over Tibet, Mongolia, Uygars to create a vast Empire. At first, they put heavy pressure on Chinese (han people) to adopt Manchurian ways, such as hair and clothing, and put Han people as a second class citizen. But as time went by, Manchus became sinicized and realized they need to pacify Han people to maintain their hold on the empire, so they came to assert that Manchus and Han are the same people. Manchus are closely related to Northern Asian people in their language and culture, vastly different from Chinese. However, unlike Mongolians, they have lost their land to Chinese and their identity has all but been lost. It is an integral part of China now.
just google what the Taiping Rebellion was about. Driven by their fierce hatred of Manchus, the Taiping launched a massive genocide campaign against the Manchus to exterminate their entire race. After conquering Nanjing, Taiping forces stormed the Manchu fort, killing some 40,000 Manchus, which was the city's entire population of Manchus. It's just one example. Taiping rebellion, which is well known, covered the major area of Qing empire. Solely on this you could make a conclusion, no need to be very smart to figure out the consequences for Manchu nation after only this rebellion.
@@eugenic12 I did not know much about the killing of Manchus.... knew that Han chinese were trying to push out the Manchu government towards the end of the Qing dynasty but did not know there were mass killings... thanks for the info.
If they had repulsion to the Han, maintained distance from them and built “Manchuria” the country, Mongolia could be bigger, closer to the ocean ports and most importantly have 3rd neighbor. They would immediately bridge us to Korea and Japan. East Turkistan - Yughur’s country could have been possible as well(4th neighbor). Disappearance of Manchus took toll on all Mongolians on many levels. They just left us between uneasy Han and Rus to suffer. This is sad to me as a Mongolian. These Manchu people in the video def look more Mongolian/Korean than the average Han. 😢
The difference between Korean and Manchurian? Korean has much more O2b and even some O2a Austronesian. 40% O3 in Korean comes from North Chinese, during the Han Dynasty occupation of Korean peninsula. Manchu are pure Tungusic nomads. They cluster close to Mongolians on a PCA. They are related to other Tungusics such as Evenki, Buryat etc. They have no O2a Austronesian Southern haplogroups.
Korean might have been a tungusic Paleo Siberian group a long time ago but North Chinese DNA was input into the Korean genome. Koreans also have slight O2a and that is austronesian haplogroup from coastal southeastern China.
Ahahah Han dynasty occupation? When? We share dna because we are East Asian you idiot. We all come from a similar place.😂😂😂 there was no such thing as Han Korea or China then😂😂😂
We Vietnamese have Lunar New Year too, and we prefer calling it “Lunar New Year” or “Traditional New Year”. The term Chinese New Year is used by mostly Chinese and Westerners.
I'm kind wondering Manchu people and Miao people the same people. Why is the Manchu and Miao traditional clothing so identical also music the way they dance?
Real Chinese are han people, or people known to have built Great Wall. Chinese were ruled by mongols and then manchus. And today Chinese conquerred back half land of mongols and manchus. Today's manchus do not have their own country today; their one half land is under China's rule and the other half land is integrated into Russia.
Hey, were working on it! Manchukuo will be free once more just like under the rule of the great Kangde Emperor. It will once more be the envy of East asia! China had enough time suppressing us and it's time for a new nation to arrise out of the old and corrupt china! As a member of the newly founded Concordia Assosiation of Manchuria an assure this!
Love Manchurian from Han Chinese.💓
Qing 😡😠😡
@@KishoreKumar-cs6dd so? So?
Let's not make this complicated. Manchus existed in Manchurian land with various names throughout the history. They were ruled under Goguryo, Balhae (Bohai), Tang, Yuan, Ming rules over the years. They established Jin dynasty and invaded North China but failed to capture all of China. But, later established Qing dynasty and ruled over not only China but also successfully took over Tibet, Mongolia, Uygars to create a vast Empire. At first, they put heavy pressure on Chinese (han people) to adopt Manchurian ways, such as hair and clothing, and put Han people as a second class citizen. But as time went by, Manchus became sinicized and realized they need to pacify Han people to maintain their hold on the empire, so they came to assert that Manchus and Han are the same people. Manchus are closely related to Northern Asian people in their language and culture, vastly different from Chinese. However, unlike Mongolians, they have lost their land to Chinese and their identity has all but been lost. It is an integral part of China now.
Agree
just google what the Taiping Rebellion was about. Driven by their fierce hatred of Manchus, the Taiping launched a massive genocide campaign against the Manchus to exterminate their entire race. After conquering Nanjing, Taiping forces stormed the Manchu fort, killing some 40,000 Manchus, which was the city's entire population of Manchus. It's just one example. Taiping rebellion, which is well known, covered the major area of Qing empire. Solely on this you could make a conclusion, no need to be very smart to figure out the consequences for Manchu nation after only this rebellion.
@@eugenic12 I did not know much about the killing of Manchus.... knew that Han chinese were trying to push out the Manchu government towards the end of the Qing dynasty but did not know there were mass killings... thanks for the info.
So now they identity as han already?
If they had repulsion to the Han, maintained distance from them and built “Manchuria” the country, Mongolia could be bigger, closer to the ocean ports and most importantly have 3rd neighbor. They would immediately bridge us to Korea and Japan. East Turkistan - Yughur’s country could have been possible as well(4th neighbor).
Disappearance of Manchus took toll on all Mongolians on many levels. They just left us between uneasy Han and Rus to suffer.
This is sad to me as a Mongolian.
These Manchu people in the video def look more Mongolian/Korean than the average Han.
😢
I laughed my head off when they began to argue over Kenya's climate hahahahaha
So cute!
The difference between Korean and Manchurian? Korean has much more O2b and even some O2a Austronesian. 40% O3 in Korean comes from North Chinese, during the Han Dynasty occupation of Korean peninsula.
Manchu are pure Tungusic nomads. They cluster close to Mongolians on a PCA. They are related to other Tungusics such as Evenki, Buryat etc. They have no O2a Austronesian Southern haplogroups.
Korean might have been a tungusic Paleo Siberian group a long time ago but North Chinese DNA was input into the Korean genome. Koreans also have slight O2a and that is austronesian haplogroup from coastal southeastern China.
Ahahah Han dynasty occupation? When? We share dna because we are East Asian you idiot. We all come from a similar place.😂😂😂 there was no such thing as Han Korea or China then😂😂😂
Korean is related to Japanese
@@profile1565 fool, parts of north korea were under Han dynasty control, until they lost it.
Pls call it Chinese new year otherwise korean will claim new year is theirs.
Koreans celebrate Chinese New Years no shame in that.
@@anyaforger8409 I see what you did there😂
@@anyaforger8409 poor chinese, normal day died by hunger, during pandemic died by bat soup.
korea will take over your country soon, just wait and see.
We Vietnamese have Lunar New Year too, and we prefer calling it “Lunar New Year” or “Traditional New Year”. The term Chinese New Year is used by mostly Chinese and Westerners.
@@안녕-f1l6g
Which Korea?
I am very interested in the Manchu culture. Please do more videos.
I'm kind wondering Manchu people and Miao people the same people. Why is the Manchu and Miao traditional clothing so identical also music the way they dance?
Really? I see that the manchurian have more common characters with the korean than the miao.
Because the Manchus changed the dress of most ethnic groups in China when they ruled China, modern Miao dress was formed on the basis of Manchus dress
@@KPho150Korean is more related to Japanese not Manchu bro
Without China, Tibet would still be a poor country like Nepal and Bhutan. Xinjiang would be a rich country like Kazakhstan, rich in oil.
How do you write the name of the city?
Mukden/᠁ᠦᠺᠳᠡᠨ /沈阳/盛京
@@xDx95 sorry. I have not :(
Real Chinese are han people, or people known to have built Great Wall. Chinese were ruled by mongols and then manchus. And today Chinese conquerred back half land of mongols and manchus. Today's manchus do not have their own country today; their one half land is under China's rule and the other half land is integrated into Russia.
Hey, were working on it! Manchukuo will be free once more just like under the rule of the great Kangde Emperor. It will once more be the envy of East asia! China had enough time suppressing us and it's time for a new nation to arrise out of the old and corrupt china! As a member of the newly founded Concordia Assosiation of Manchuria an assure this!
@@torismund2100 The manchus already ruling the CCP/PRC now lol.
No such thing as "real Chinese". That's racist rhetoric. You are racist.
And most Manchurians became Chinese.
Siberia was part of Manchuria
Manchurian people should at least pay a visit to He-tu-ar-lah once in their life
I wonder if they were still in power...what if ??
I can't make difference between Chinese and Manchurian!
Difference is in the language and culture
Manchu and HAn is Chinese but they are difference ethnic
semua suku suku ada banyak di beijing
sulit membedakan mana han mana manchu mana miao li zhuang
Didn’t manchurian men wear ques?
Manchuria is not Mangi
What is Manji then?
Free Tibet 🌟
Tibet is already free from feudalism.
Free Arunachal, free Khalistan
Free Palestine free Türkistan free Kürdistan ✊🏼
@@pirdaoshaq11 East Turkistan*
Without China, Tibet would still be a poor country like Nepal and Bhutan. Xinjiang would be a rich country like Kazakhstan, rich in oil.
Manchu culture is absurd 😂
Classified Yuan conquest of Jin dynasty moment
Chinese actor. Real manchus dead in
1911.
There are still Manchus, but pretty much all of them are fully Sinicized.
@Gamer
How not?
@Gamer
Like, what do you think happened after the Qing dynasty fell? The Manchus were all massacred? Because they weren't.
Sorry. We Manchus are very well and alive. Take your racist uneducated bigoted low class comments somewhere else
@@josephpeters7627 Manchurians adopted Han culture in Qing era. So they mixed each other.
我們的世界非物質及物質文化遺產，與人類科學並進
満州独立！！
満洲民族はいま存在しない。
Mansui Manchu!!!