Political history of Pakistan - Asim Sajjad Akhtar - TPE
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- Asim Sajjad Akhtar is a left wing politician, academic and columnist.
Asim comes on The Pakistan Experience to discuss the history of politics in Pakistan, from the leftist politics of the 70s to the emergence of PTI, Asim does an overview of how we got here discussing some of the forks in the road along the way.
The Pakistan Experience is a podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan, and Pakistanis, through the lost art of conversation.
Dude, this is probably the best Pakistani podcast channel on UA-cam right now.. The Pakistan Experience indeed!! More power to you!!
I am becoming addicted to these podcasts. Always looking forward.
The more frequent such discussions are are shown on media the better it is for Pakistan and its future.
Hey , I'm addicted to these podcasts listening to these while doing work... It's great ke you yourself is quite well aware of the topics w.r.t guests ❤️
Right is right even no one is doing it.
Wrong is wrong even if everyone is doing it. Nice to listen some kind of perspective. Keep it up.
Sir is doing great need more people like him on your podcast.
Brilliant podcast. great to hear Aasim Sajjad. Will hope that people from peripheries could be invited too to give thier insights into what they think. that could be great conversation. Though you have already invited some of the critical voices we have in this country. whose politics and academic work is truly pro people. looking forward to new episode 👍
This is the best Pakistani channel for indians to follow to understand the country rationally ,not blaming Hindus ,India for every ill of that country . Since they often lapse into Urdu which a hindi knowing audience can easily follow.
What is the equivalent of this podcast for India, Indian politics, and Indian history?
This is something out of the box that we don't come across usually. It's so imformative and I know this will reach a lot of people and for sure they will learn a lot from it. Keep on doing it.
Very refreshing & insightful 👍
A wonderful contribution to society, Shehzad. Still watching after a year, It's enlightening us and helping shape our narratives. More power to you!
Thanks shazad for this interesting and informative program . I heared asim sajjad first time and impressed the way he expressed his ideas , he must be a very popular teacher .
What a wise, sagacious man! It is so heartening to have such people in our country, many many respects, sir!
Thanks for the brilliant podcast, great work in the right direction!
Akhtar sahab doesn’t find any difference between Pakistan and India. That’s very intriguing. 😅
My ass was glued to the chair for an hour kuddos to the man Asim Sajjad Akhtar bring him again and subscribed your channel ❤
Beautiful analysis of present situation, Mr. Asim also shows us where we are making mistakes and we can do about this, how to make our lives better for us and our children.
I would love see Baloch/Sindhi/Paktoon nationalist on your podcast. please invite them .
Studying history of pakistan as a student of Political science is very rewarding, especially when it comes to what not to do as a country.
Very nice show
Our Pakistan military interfere too much in the countries politics. People will call you unpatriotic, if you call out the military. Religion and state should be separate until then no hope for this country.
this professor is not going to agree with your assessment
Recently found your channel through Tamkeenat, I watched your show with Moiz and Tamkeenat 🙈 and since then I am watching everything you do here. Very progressive.
Rightly said.. the ist thing we need to do is to come out of blame game first .. even at personal level...
Zbradst comrade asim
It was the fear of the of majority which created Pakistan, and broke it too ... Even today if the Indians change their attitude and give a respectable position to Muslims and other minorities... Things will be entirely different...
Yr is bande k columns main 2 cheezain hene which I get it.
1. the military and gated communities( apathy of elite) are really doing the damage in Pakistan
2. And Communism and worker led leftist movement is the way forward.
Am I correct, get his whole philosophy and worldview?
Transfer of power didn't occurred on the scheduled because Bhutto said I will not go to inaugural session better resolve issues outside of the parliament ...I will break legs of those going to attend from west pak...So, did the President decide to help 'bring both sides together...' and then all went wrong?
Well done man.. doing great job
Dear I'm also benefited more from your podcast knowledgeable information.
It is easy to get better understanding.
I'm enjoying it during my exams
Really helpful.
Thank you so much
The policies that led to Sakoot-e-dhaka are being continued in Sindh, Baluchistan and Pakhtoonkhwa as well.
You are doing a great service. Please I would suggest you to make a schedule and adhere to that. It makes me really anxious when i keep searching if there is any new video on your channel and end up getting nothing new. Please
@@ThePakistanExperience 👍🏻👍🏻
Pata lag Ra hai k shehzad ek teacher k samne betha hai...Dara Daba wa...jese bnda classroom me HOTA hai:D:)))) haha...wese to her wqt shararten he Hoti hen podcast me lollllxxxx btw I am a student of Asim in qau and he is a great teacher :))))
👏👏👏
It had been nice to listen neutral views n analysed to a small extent, what n where wrong is going on with solutions offered. Examples r there that anmoisty has ruined the nation's n progress hold up.wish better sense prevails. Wud love to listen more.
excellent work
Good discussion.
While people in Pak hate Modi, Modi was never against Pak. He met Nawaj Sharif in Pakistan unscheduled. Unfortunately the establishment used that to call Sharif, Modi ka yaar. Used that slogan to get rid of Sharif. Modi then realized, Pak establishment is not at all serious about maintaining close relations with India. Back stabbing like Kargil defines the relationship.
Wish this changes.
Pakistan also not aware of changes Modi has brought in India. Swatch (clean India), removing corruption at least in central govt, Free gas connection to poor, Smart cities, Jan dhan, crop insurance, pension for poor etc etc. Though economy has not been managed well.
I agree with you. He is either too afraid of overturning the Nehru-Indira model of economics or he himself does not believe in the alternative. If only he had pushed for economics reforms in agriculture, banking, labour and land laws the last 6 years, we would be doing well now.
What do you think about agri reform of post covid time. I think this agri reform is long over due. Mandi culture is such a curse for farmers.
U got Uri attack in return and nawaj sharif termed as gaddar. What else modi could have done
@@prabhaskumarmohanty5910
Essential Commodoties Act 1955 was the direct outcome of Nehru's visit to China in 1954 and his "admiration" of Mao"s collectivisation of agriculture. He could not do it here and do he came up with the most oppressive and stupid Essential Commoditirs Act.
@People before profit Humanity there is a section of left media which has always been against Modi. They are getting desperate.
" zulam krney wala nizam hi khatam krna" - dono ka maksad 👌👌
How ignorant one can become in order to prove one's ideological positions? This is a good example. Only one example: the gentleman does not know that Bhutto was brought into ower by a Field marshal Ayub Khan whom he used to refer to as dady. Bhutto was in his cabinet when the military operations were going on ib Baluchistan, He was the alternate candidate for Ayub in the general election when he was being oppsed by Fatimah Jinnah. He was one of the supporters and advocate for the 1965 war in Kashmir that led to the debacle that followed. Yes, he was one of the principal architects of East Pakistan separation along with Yahya and others and allowed the country to be divided just so that he can stay in power. He was Yahya's minister when he went to the UN to defend him. He was the one who started bloody operation in Baluchistan again simply because his wadera mindset did not accept any opponents who would not agree with him. How many civilian leaders and people he had killed during his rule till 1977? This is just a very short charge sheet against Bhutto. Your guest is simply an ignoramus and ideological fanatic. Please keep him away.
I don’t think so buddy, Pakistan will not change, I will brake not change
Yes indeed this guy is very good. Have a few disagreements with his views but have to say he's really good ....
Crush!!
I think this channel is casting one of the best pakistani content.. now i cant think of any 2nd :)
Asam sajjad you look like Hollywood film hero.
Red salutes to comrade
Shehzad, what was the name of book he suggested?
The people's history
Surkh salam
Brilliant work and well done for kind of effort. But, somehow I am getting this feeling that you are pro PPP and lover of Z. A. Bhutto. Please remain unbiased and know that Bhutto was truly a brutal and typical feudal. He helped military get stronger to serve Pakistani feudalism. He uttered the words, "udher tum iddher hum". He was power hungry and wanted power by hook or crook. Yes, he was lucky that at his time under the nose of military Dr. Qadeer offered him to assemble nuclear technology, and he accepted. He is the one who destroyed education system and economic industry in Pakistan. Please, please do not portray him as a hero. His family is very dangerous for Pakistan and all feudal have destroyed Pakistan already. Please do not try to picture the feudal as saviors. Military is their servant and establishment is they themselves. Imran Khan also came to power like others under their nose. Pakistan is a failed state, never to rise only to exploit its own masses and keep them illiterate, impoverished and crushed under the feet of feudal and their Goons.
* searches awaami workers party in incognito so establishment won't start spying on me *
haha:) funnyyyy lmfao :)
Hmaari Awam bbi tu aisii hai na k marshal law lgny pr mithayan tqseem hoti hain ......Sir we have to educate the public ....when public will be educated and well awared about their constitutional rights then no one will be able to rule forcefully
Mutabadil mumkin hai( Alternative is possible).
Awami Workers Party 👍
Comrade Asim sajjad the great
What's the name of the philosopher that Prof. Asim Sajjad mentioned at 44:31 , who gave the mentioned liberation concept of struggle of oppressed?
Paulo Friere
Kindly If anyone can mention which thinker did he mention at 25:46 regarding control over thought process.
@@abhishekchakraborty7102 Antonio gramsci
With establishment supported Islamists on the rise, the future looks bleak for pakistani society and politics.
Great podcast
By the way, British were in control of “Pakistan” areas from 1860. That makes British rule to be less than 90 years and not 200 years.
It all started in 1757
@@lizawasique7436
That’s true. In 1757 British government took control of UP and central India from East India company. In that year Punjab however was not under British government control.
Peace.
Ary Bhai kehna kya chahty ho
laal Salaam Comrade
When God makes you Asim, be a " sajjad akhtar " , not a "salim bajwa"
Bring some baloch intellectual too
Agents of new cold war
Ye to Gandhi ka bahut bada theory hai non voilance
India moved away from British Legacy? Your whole question is based on a comparison at 36:12 which is nothing but an assumption. India is experiencing an identity crisis and people are literally protesting against their true meaning of being Indian. Our history is distorted, so as our podcasts. :D
I really dont agree. Yes people are protesting but not against being indian identity but for their own rights. They are protesting to gain level playing field
@@prabhaskumarmohanty5910 Well, I have no intension to become a light to open your eyes. Gandhi Heroic movement is in crisis, Godhsey is becoming your new hero, Do you see it as a protest against their rights? Alright then, Sub acha hai :D
@@iTalha .. . In my opinion there should be Truth and reconciliation. .. do you agree to this? My question is "did the Bristsh leave India only because of Gandhis movement? " or were there other factors and movements also. Similarly why did the Congress at that time not implement uniform civil code for all Indians?
@@TruthPrevails2023xx Dude nobody suggested that it was only Gandhi!!! And thank you for proving my point. Today India is questioning their own Heroes, which shows an identity crisis, either Godhsay was right or India lied everything about Gandhi all this long. I am nobody to decide who served your nation the most. I am not answering your question only because I am not here to debate Gandhi's greatness. If you think the truth was different, then please go on :D Actually whenever somebody defamed Gandhi, everybody in India used to make noise and today you people are doing it yourself :D What an amazing time :D
@@iTalha .. we are questioning narrative put forth by Congress party of India that only they are credited with Indian independence. We don't have identity crisis as we know our ancestors lived on this land for thousands of years. Only those who identify themselves as aligned with foreign invaders have identity crises.
bhai jan Pakistan ki history hai....kuch urdu mai b bol leta hai bnda.....
To reject the Politics of hate, one has to but begin with negation of the very idea of pakistan. Calling yourself a progressive and yet clinging to "pakistaniat" is clearly contradictory.
To reject the politics of hate, one has to begin with accepting Pakistan as a state
PARTITION. OF.
INDIA.
WAS. THE. WRONG IDEA.
We considered Taliban as assets, After APS we wanted to attack them, Now they are assets again. There is one complication, Please differentiate between Taliban and Terrorists. Taliban are assets for their own country and for our country.
aapke PPP left wing hai PMLN right wing aur PTI wo khacchar hai jo kuch bhi complete nai ban paaya .. haha sp please comparing him to the right of the world. i.e trump borris modi etc..
@@ThePakistanExperience i mean PPP is pretty left wing ideology, talks about welfare and equality whereas PMLN is very pro business. PTI is just confused..
That's quite an observation...Agreed
Teenun Right wing Hain. Teenun ki Economic policies wahi IMF wali Hain. Teenun Capitalist Parties Hain.
Maybe you are talking about difference of narrative. For example, If you observe PTI narrative, it is all about poor people but in reality all policies are anti-poor e.g., Anti encroachment drive etc.
Same goes for PPP and PML-N. Of course one cannot say their whole politics is crap. But more or less it is same.
@@imaginaryfriend1891 more or less its the same, and i 100 percent agree with you . i am just saying imran is just trying to cherry pick the ideas which pakistanis want to hear. he has no narrative. PPP at its core is still socialist and PMLN is capitalist. and i am a capitalist . and for the reason i like nawaaz saab.