The REAL Truth About the Air War over Ukraine
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 лис 2022
- Noted military aviation expert and frequent channel guest Justin Bronk joins Ward in person for an in-depth conversation about the lessons learned on both sides from the air war over Ukraine.
Read Justin's most recent white paper on the topic here: rusi.org/explore-our-research...
Support this channel by using the SUPER THANKS (heart icon above) or by becoming a Patron at / wardcarroll
Buy one or all three of the books in the PUNK'S TRILOGY, Ward's popular first three novels about life a Tomcat squadron, at www.usni.org/punks-trilogy-re.... Use the PUNKYT discount code at checkout for 25% off to UA-cam channel subscribers.
Also available in KINDLE format here: www.amazon.com/dp/B09R1MX8SY
And as an audiobook here:
PUNK'S WAR: www.audible.com/pd/Punks-War-...
PUNK'S WING: www.amazon.com/Punks-Wing-Pun...
PUNK'S FIGHT: www.amazon.com/Punks-Fight-Pu...
Get official channel gear at my-store-b7f9c9.creator-sprin...
Follow Ward on Twitch at / moochontwitch - Розваги
I'm gratified that Mr Bronk found a way to contribute despite the fact that he didn't get what he wanted. He learned to deal with disappointment without becoming bitter or despondent or both. That says a lot about his Character as a person. The world needs more people like him.
DOCTOR Bronk. He just got his PhD.
He'd have been wasted as a professional pilot, we're largely idiots. He's right where he should be.
@@matthewcoleman1919 Many a RIO would agree!
@@MrAWG9 Laddie, I am the Great Medicine Chief of the Council of the 13 Clan Elders, and I don't get bent when people don't use my Proper title. So don't start that Doctor B.S. with me. In fact my Father had 7 PhDs and never got bent when people didn't call him Doctor.
Fighter Pilots are a dime a dozen, it's quality Pilot Fighters who are rare, amirite?
As ever Ward asks short questions, just enough to let Justin expand and explain, and Justin does so with great ease.
The ease is most impressive.
We need more of him….very few people are as fluent and articulate …and I reckon he’d have been wasted as a fighter pilot….
Yes, the characteristics of an excellent interviewer. Ward has no need to interject or boast of his intelligence.
An expert in his field asking an expert in his field. He knows to get out of the way and Ward doesn’t operate on ego.
It’s called editing. That doesn’t discount the value of the response.
Based on Justin's description, I have to assume the Gripen was designed by the engineers at IKEA. You can service it from the ground, in the snow, wearing gloves, with little more than the supplied allen wrench.
Gripen was designed kinda to be that way. It was a cold war plane and swedish military assumed that all airports would b destroyed the first day of a war against ussr. So many highways in sweden were made very wide with no divider in the middle, especially in wooded areas. Where u could move your airplanes to cover under trees very fast if war broke out. And since most factories would be taken out it had to be easy to maintain.
I think Sweden if ever attacked would find itself in a Ukrainian position, a huge enemy, asymmetric warfare and they developed the tools for it !
@Jo LiMag 🇺🇦 yup.. that was the plan.. we have lots of mountain complexes all over sweden. When I was young they still trained on the beaches of southen sweden to repell an attack from Eastern Germany... I lived like 300m from it so you could hear the machine gun fire from blanks now and then.
The Most important part of Gripen was the Shipping container to maintain it with the APU and 1 person being the tech and the other 5 the monkey wrenches, its a pretty amazing achievement, that I suspect US industry would despise as they make so much money in parts and support programs...
Sweden should have sent some Gripens to Ukraine before joining NATO so the US couldn’t stop them. Then again, they should never have joined NATO. And they shouldn’t be harboring PKK either.
When Dr. Bronk talked about being medically disqualified from being a fighter pilot I felt that in my soul. I got diagnosed with cancer right after earning my private certificate and getting a congressional nomination to the USAFA. It was a tough pill to swallow, but I'm thankful for the content you produce Ward, I live vicariously through your experiences. And thanks for bringing Dr. Bronk back to the channel, I'm always fascinated to hear expert analysis that's really lacking from many mainstream sources.
Its tough being told "NO". Two nephews got the thumbs down from the Army for a hip issue that's inherited. One had done 4 years of ROTC before being nixed. The Army shoved me out the door after hearing of my problem knee that a horse slammed into the ground. I could've lied and toughed it out for most of BT but knew it wouldn't last the whole program. The Navy didn't think it was a problem but it was downsizing (post Vietnam) so that got nixed.
A friend got washed out of USAF flight school because during a certain maneuver he had to flip oxygen to 100% to keep his thinking sharp. I forget the OX setting that was required but 70-80% sounds right. To the AF credit they tried to work with him to overcome his need for 100% OX but he couldn't do it. So he was out.
But a success story was a squadron mate who wanted to get off the ground into a pilot seat. Every he was taken out for small aircraft acclimation flight (T-41B) he barfed his guts out. He discovered his garrison cap worked good for a puke bucket.!! Not sure how he did it but eventually he became a C-130 pilot and still is. He was a great "kid" and great asset for USAF so I was super happy for him. He certainly deserved it for his effort and skills.
@@LuvBorderCollies A son had two years of high school ROTC and was looking forward to a first career in the Army. When the recruiter asked if he had an asthma attack since whatever age the threshold was, his dreams came to an abrupt end. He recovered from the disappointment and is doing well outside the Army. He has a son who was recently discharged from active duty with the Marines, and that helps.
I was medically disqualified from being a fighter pilot too. It's a POS feeling. Nowadays i'm finally better, but sadly I don't have the age anymore. Still working on my PPL/CPL nonetheless and I really hope that one day I can fly something that at least resembles a fighter.
It's a tougher pill to swallow when you weren't medically disqualified, because that means you could have done it but just didn't. In my case people lied to me and told me that there was a very low chance of ever becoming a pilot of any kind.
@@LarsLarsen77 Sorry to hear that. For what it's worth, now is a great time to become a commercial pilot if that's a path you're still interested in & able to pursue. Not quite the same as flying tactical jets for sure, but still a great opportunity.
As I have commented before, this analyst is by far the best I have heard about the conflict. The level of detail and nuance is fantastic. THNX Mooch for interviewing this man.
This man is shockingly well informed. He should be brought before Congress to testify. I wholeheartedly agree that the Saab Gripen is the best choice of a Western airplane. The argument he puts forward against any hesitation to supply them is straightforward and reasonable.
@@petergreenwald9639 Yep, It might be a reasonable time for the whole world to go "America f*ck yeah". Curious times we live on. Besides, we learned in Afghanistan that proxy war is a helluva thing. ;)
Maybe not airforce/airpower related, but i cant reccomend Perun enough.
Defence procurememt expert with weekly varied topics on about 1 hour reports. Tends to scratch our info itch in a interesting way.
Lmk what you think!
@@sandwich5344 I concur.
I even emailed RUSI suggesting they watch his presentations, with a view to offering him a position.
@@gajofre Thanks for the reply! I used to get a notice on my phone, but I am not getting them now. I finally saw I had notifications in YT.
I genuinely think this is some of the most if not the most interesting piece of content to come out on the conflict. The insights given after conducting these studies are incredible.
I agree. The tactical analysis of suppression of enemy air defenses (from Russian side) is eye opening. It explains a lot of what has been seen in this war. I hope Sweden relents and supplies the Saab Grippin fighter. It could give the Ukrainian Air Force more of an edge. An air launched hypersonic air to air missile to really reach out and splash those MiG-31s would be nice.
YT is going to bury the MSM. This guy is better than any journalist.
As someone who dives deep into the Ukraine news every day, I agree this has to be in the top one or two pieces of analysis I’ve seen. Really outstanding. 👏
I agree with you totally.
He basically admits that US aircraft are useless when the other guy actually shoots back at you and threatens your airbases.
It's also clear he doesn't think any of this "help" will do more then prologue the invitable defeat of Ukraine.
Once those S-300s Ukraine has run out or are suppressed they are finished Russia rules the sky, game over.
Another gripping instalment from Justin Bronk. You've found a brilliant contributor, whose knowledge, clarity and insight is truly outstanding. More serious and trustworthy information in 45 minutes than most media outlets could deliver in a month. Thanks for getting Justin on. Great content.
Gotta say, this tops Perun in terms of quality. ^^
And I consider that one of the best compliments in my vocabulary, regarding UA-cam military analysis. ❤
Beginning to believe whole heartedly that the media is only there to tell you what to think. Not to inform you
Slight correction to that statement - 'More serious and trustworthy information in 45 minutes than all mainstream media outlets deliver ever...!' :)
Very useful to hear the analysis of the air war in Ukraine. Strategically, this "best investment ever!!1" in terms of US defense spending going to Ukraine, not so much. This whole war was preventable, but fomented by the US.
@@executivelifehacks6747 agree
I learned more about the strategic and tactical situation in Ukraine from this single interview than from all other sources during the previous year, including major news networks and publications.
Thank you, Ward and Justin.
...so true...Ward's channel is always very informative!
Once again, Justin's insight is mightily impressive. Thanks Ward for asking the right questions and giving him airtime.
"I wanted to be a fighter pilot." Jeez... that explains a lot. I respect and admire that he still found his place.
I wanted to be a navy pilot as well however my Beloved Mother and Father were married to one another so it would’ve never worked out….😂😂😂
we all wanted to be fighter pilots at one time or another
@@markmusselwhite2820 hahahahahahaha
Health problems.
Sometimes those early years of dreaming about a career sets one's mind into learning paths that can still benefit those who DO get to become military pilots. (Becoming and Intelligence officer for instance) Knowing basics of flight, having an interest and knowledge of both friendly and enemy aircraft grants one a step up over someone who is say an Political Science major. The former can understand and have a grasp of the nature of threats, limits and capabilites of both friendly and enemy aircraft, while the latter may be great in understanding the political machinations that are ongoing. Mr Bronk clearly found his niche and is doing well.
How nice it was to see Ward settle back and allow this clever young man to speak at length and in depth.
A fine interview Ward, and a nod to the art of listening. Wish other interviewers would emulate you.
Thanks for posting!
Well said GM, totally agree
Totally agree, fantastic interview
Bronk is one of my favorite SMEs in this knowledge space who has put himself out there on YT. I came across him on other channels I follow, and he is consistently prepared, encyclopedic, authentic and it's great. Him being interviewed by a guy like Ward, in person, is the cherry on the sundae. Thanks so much!
Where can I find more of Justin’s material?
@@ryanpeck4691 just type his name in the YT search bar...you'll get a bunch of hits. I've come into it mostly through channels covering to Russo-Ukraine war.
@@MrAjmay1 for some reason searching YT never occurred to me. (Checks head for wood content)
@@ryanpeck4691 🤣
Justin Bronk - Dr. Bronk officially, he has his PhD in the field - is one of the best sources on the air war in Ukraine. For the overall picture Danish naval Commander Anders Puck Nielsen gives some of the most concise analysis of the war.
Another great "big picture" guy is an Aussie UA-camr named Perun. Master of the economics/logistics PowerPoint presentation!
@@seafodder6129 Not to take away from Perun, but his style is not for me.
It's more like a college lecture when I prefer an intelligence briefing in this area.
General Ben Hodges as well.
@@ericdeer5887 Another very good one.
These 46 minutes really went by in a flash!
Lots of information and concepts laid out clearly and articulately.
Ward is an excellent interviewer and J. Bronk is pretty much the perfect host: direct questions are followed by precise, well-argued answers. *Without unnecessary interruptions!*
Journalists and TV hosts/anchors could learn a thing or three about how to conduct a great interview here. Top notch work!
No doubt about it. Mr. Ward and Dr. Bronk are a team that is hard to beat.
He makes me proud to be British. Clear, concise, as accurate as is currently possible and easy to understand. I'm certainly more informed watching this video.
Realy? A political puppet makes you proud of beeing british? Is that only a thing in Britain? I mean this guy has no conciousness. He is proud that Britain and USA don´t have to fight and kill russians cause it´s cheaper to let ukrainien do this... He is proud that USA is destroying the people in Donbass, and ruining the Europe... He should be ashamed of himself. Despite beeing intelligent not knowing shit about the real reasons,, or he just does not care at all... Britains know how to fight for freedom... Dude... Anyone knows which country had and has the most colonies in the world? It ain´t russia, that´s for sure....
well, he is a native speaker, what can you expect. Regardless, he is well-articulated and his narrative is being pushed everywhere, making me believe that the Grippen is the solution.
P.s sorry for my English, obviously I'm not a native speaker.
I am not talking against the AngloSaxons but the assholes who took over your Nation and you still don't know about it.
What a fascinating watch, I have seen Justin on News Channels, but to see him here, non stop, sharing his incredible knowledge of military technologies, kept me glued to the screen! I did a little search on YT and now have some more vids to watch!! Thanks Ward, for inviting him on board!!
Ward, thanks for having Justin Bronk on your channel again. He's very knowledgeable, as you also are. Good job with your interview questions, & thanks for defining the acronyms as they were used in the video!
Great interview! Mr. Bronk is a great resource, it's always wonderful to have his input.
The title felt too clickbait so I avoided clicking the video several times in the last days. Took the chance now and damn glad I did. Awesome depth of insight from Justin, thanks, guys!
Great interview between two guys who know exactly what they are talking about. Such a rarity these days. Thank you.
From a another person who couldn't fly military aircraft due to medical-related issues, I humbly submit that Justin is doing his country a FAR greater service with his analysis...than in the cockpit of a fighter plane. Wonderful summary of the action there thus far, and (as usual) some non-BS insight offered right there at the end.
Brilliant, Mr. Bronk.
There are a lot more great fighter jocks than great analysts.
I concur.
I really enjoy your chats with Justin Bronk, such an affable and hugely technically talented expert and speaker. Very much looking forward to watching him on your channel again at some point in the future. Thank you.
Another superb interview with Justin Bronk. Don’t you just love listening to someone who has such in depth expert knowledge. I look forward to these interviews with Ward. Keep them coming please.
@Ward Carroll, Justin is golden, he is the greatest guest on this topic ! But YOU do the best job of interviewing him and busting through the excess abbreviations. Asking the right questions, and letting the interviewee answer them fully, while keeping them on topic, is an art. And you are excellent at it. Excellent at discovering and picking guests too.
Brilliant! The most informative conversation on the air war I've ever heard. More of these please Justin and Ward
Thanks both. One of the few, if not the only channel, that gives a professional assessment and report of the situation in a way that is easily digested.
Hands down Mr. Bronk is a consummate professional with a sober analysis slinging cold hard truths. Respect.
Man this is the exact type of review on the war so far that I’ve been wanting. Straight facts and enough detail to better understand the war so far.
I 100% agree. Dr. Bronk's analyses are often (as in this case) the only ones that makes sense to me.
Intelligent conversation on the internet, this is indeed a scarce thing!! Thanks Ward and Justin.
Finally some realistic, sensible, and fact-based assessment of the air war.
"Finally some realistic, sensible, and fact-based assessment "
If you want more of that then watch "RedEffect."
@@rael5469 I have not watched any of his videos. Once I saw a title saying "Why are (Russian made) Polish T-72 tanks better than Russian T-72 tanks" I have decided to pass on his material. I understand that any claim should be investigated and researched but with a title like that, I cannot look for "realistic, sensible and fact-based assessment". I'd rather watch Operator Starsky. Although I don't like his material, at least I know he's openly biased and he doesn't hide it.
@@MrGolov-te5eb To each his own Golov but RedEffect does his homework. He has been debunking some bogus claims about the war by a detailed analysis of the claims. I think he's pretty solid.
@@MrGolov-te5eb "Once I saw a title saying "Why are (Russian made) Polish T-72 tanks better than Russian T-72 tanks""
Can you provide the link to that one? I searched it and couldn't find it. Is that the exact title?
@@rael5469 The title is “Polish tanks are in Ukraine. Here’s why they’re better than Russian tanks”. I mean, these Polish tanks are Soviet made T-72’s just as the Russian T-72’s are. Sure, the Polish may have did upgrades to it but come the f on! I won’t even bother watching it. Even if it was better, the Polish Soviet made T-72’s, , upgraded or not, can’t match the T-80. So why even make a video about it? I know why but like I said, If I want to watch bias I’d rather watch Operator Starsky.
What a gentleman. I have a similar story with colorblindness and the RAAF (Australia) and was humbled to see the success and level of expertise Justin has displayed for us yet again. Thanks Ward and thank you Justin.
As a Swede, it gladdens me that the Gripen is the best choice for fighting the Russians.
Proves the doctrine was right. Well spent taxes
This.
When I think how long it takes for our German Eurofighters to finally get AESA and Meteor integration… - we should have just bought Gripen. Not even speaking about the smaller logistics and maintenance footprint or its EW-suite, and that it even was available in time. Eurofighter originally was named Jäger 90 in Germany, but it was so badly delayed: we were lucky that the Sowjetunion / USSR collapsed and Germany was unified: when you think of it: the Luftwaffe was trying to play catch-up and introduce something that could beat the Flankers, and it pretty much relied on the integration of AESA and Meteor, which is still not done 30 years later! - Even Saudi Arabia got the newer / better versions. Tranche 1 is trash. Tranche 2 is only viable in Air-Air with IRIS-T and the very small amount of outdated AMRAAM the Luftwaffe might still have, and only Tranche 3 now is really something living up to what was promised on paper 30 years ago…
@@Stadtpark90 I agree, but Germany never "just buys" something to be fair. Their procurement is a mess. I don't think this is news to you, but Perun has a great video on why this is the case with Germany.
Corruption can kill an army, but so can bureaucracy.
But great info, I learned something new here!
Outstanding interview. Cogent analysis of the ongoing situation. Thank you both
Interesting take on smelling the environment in an open cockpit plane. That smelling the environment is one thing I like about riding motorcycles.
So interesting that Justin tried everything to Sunday getting and serving his Country. I'm so glad he found RUSI. Justin's a really smart dude and a Patriot for his Country. Thank you for your service to this channel, as well.
Justin stars in about 50% of the most informative in-depth analyses of the war.
Ward, of all the things you're good at, you're an excellent communicator, be that to camera or when in conversation. May the channel continue to grow, as many people as possible deserve to see measured and objective analysis delivered by people who know their onions.
Anyone else noticed the short comment Justin made about a russian missile with an improved motor ”cause he took one apart in Ukraine”. That is dedication!
Justin Bronk is smart, and funny, and always a joy to hear.
definitely my favorite analyst of the conflict, taking the detailed look at the beginings and explaning the changes. The comment that the drone footage was all taken early and then metered out for politcal reasons to help maintain public support was outstanding
basically everyrthing we were told is a lie. shock.
@@JeanLucCaptain Technically not a lie, just not exactly the truth.
Outstanding interview Please bring Justin back for more.
This video has delivered! The amount of indepth information provided was emence and very well delivered, enabling those of us not well conversent with operations and war tactics to easily follow the conversation. Your editing was excellent, keeping a smooth and easy to follow subject matter.
I admire this young man. The world could do with more like him. He has also explained more about the war than anyone else. And most importantly. He has told the truth.
Well….. Justin does it again! That was absolutely enthralling. Could’ve listened to a further hour of his analysis. Such an interesting and knowledgeable gentleman. Thank you both 👍
Justin would have a top tier channel if he made one. He would be perun tier.
Amazing mind and communicator. Thanks for having him on. I bet you were ecstatic to meet up personally!
These discussions & interviews with Justin are pure gold!!
To find a place where those. Ring interviewed are asked a brief question and then given the space to answer - so refreshing - while I always find the Justin interviews so thought provoking and full of nuances I hadn’t considered. Thanks Mooch and I note your ever increasing audience!
Anyone wavering about continued U.S. military aid and support should watch the last 10 minutes of this great interview. Brilliant stuff Mooch. Thank you!
Ward you have done it again . A brillant interview out of nowhere .
Justin is a credit to Britain, and we are lucky to have him guest on the channel - thanks Ward and Justin! :)
and you are no credit to Europe or whatsoever, but keep your nationalist view, it helped you in the apst few yours like Putin helped Russia and now i think you even deserve your downfall
Truly outstanding content & superb double team. Judicious use of relevant questions. Well recorded under demanding cafe conditions!
Justin is outstanding as usual. Thanks, Mooch, great analysis.
An amazingly coherent explanation of the intricacies of complexities of this war. Mr Bronk's cogent explanation of why support for Ukraine must continue is absolutely compelling and it is to be hoped that it is one that is received, accepted and acted upon until Russia's ability to even attempt a repeat of this criminality is eradicated.
yep Russia's ability to even attempt a repeat of the criminal attack and invasion of Iraq Afghanistan Syria and bombing Yugoslavia and organising coups like Bolivia and Ukraine must be eradicated
OEPS
Of course the guy from the military think tank is pro war. His rationale seems to be, shit, we are already involved, might as well make all the neocons and those who think like them happy, and keep spending money and fighting Russia to the last Ukraininan! This war would NOT be happening if the US and the collective west hadn't been planning this since at least 2008. Not justifying Russias invasion, but also can't justify NATO poking the bear for so long.
Just excellent content. Thought I would just watch bits and pieces, but I stayed tuned for the whole thing. Really good discussion, thanks for making this!
Good to have guys like Justin on our side. Exceptional knowledge, intelligence and delivery.
Unfortunately, your side is the losing side. Unlucky this time.
@@paulpritchard1998 You must be coming form those self-hating Pritchard renegades.
@@tryingtotryistrying Disregard Justin Bronk's detailed and balanced analysis. Embrace Pavel's tankie hot-take!
Great analysis. Interesting points about how Gripen would be such a good fit for Ukrainian needs.
Seems like the ideal aircraft for Ukraine.
I really hope that we can supply Gripen aircrafts to Ukraine.🇺🇦🇸🇪🙏
@@ThePettho I can't see that ever happening.
Thank you both for this truly information filled video. Justin is amazing with his unwavering and instant reply to any questions asked. Brilliant
Awesome video! Glad you and Justin got to meet face to face.
Great video. Always an immediate click when Justin Bronk is on.
I am always impressed by the number of factors that Justin analyses in any question or situation. A SAM having to accelerate initially through denser air which thus affects it's performance characteristics? A subtlety I would not have guessed at.
Top stuff!
Yes, and it is a major factor in air to air missile engagements too!
The physics is irrefutible. Starting high and fast means more energy and thus speed when a missile strikes at lower altitude...yeah, I can see that's a problem. I know the US has been running near continuous AEWACS sorties...I am sure they have to have been advising Ukrainian Air Force with real time tactical intel like inbound missile threats. Probably from air launched threats too.
Its almost like the work that goes into obtaining a PhD in a field makes you an expert on the matter. More people should apply this same realization to all the other areas of expertise they think to disregard with whatever they learned on facebook.
Air to air missiles triple in range from 1000 feet to 40k. And that's conservative.
Rob, you think it is subtle? so you have no clue about air / aviation, really.
There’s nothing like an expert opinion. Very proud 🇬🇧
Excellent interview!! Justin is an amazing young man and spot on with his analysis, situation awareness in the Ukraine war. I always enjoy his commentary..
Absolutely fascinating conversation, thanks so much for this insightful discussion 👍
Loggies = Supply Officer (Logistics)
Cheers! 🍻
Thanks Benjamin. I was wondering if he meant carpenter (engineer) or lumber jack. 😆
"Royal Logistics Corps" yes they deal with supplies but also Explosive Ordnance Disposal.
@@PsilocybinCocktail I think he meant Loggie (Stacker) in the RAF. But they don't EOD as that's a Plumbers job (Armourer).
@@PsilocybinCocktail
🤔🤔🤔
You can’t be EOD if you’re color blind, especially RED/GREEN color blind!
The whole red wire/green wire thing is mostly Hollywood……MOSTLY.
INITIAL SUCCESS OR TOTAL FAILURE.
What a brilliant presentation! Bravo Justin and Ward.
Excellent and fascinating all round. I was mesmerised by that stream of information!
Great job Mooch and Justin (does Justin have a call sign?).
Can't get enough Justin! Another great interview Ward!
I hate war but I cannot deny the value of the sort of expertise that Dr. Bronk brings to this conflict or the value in Ward sharing it with us. This really needs wider viewership so that everyone understands why continued U.S. support for the Ukrainians is so important. This should not be a partisan issue.
Ward + Justin = Must See TV!
This is a true expert who is able to impart very advanced and technical information in a way that is understandable to the lay person, such as myself. Thank you so much for this superb interview.
Its so awesome to watch you interview someone. Good job!
Again great interview, very nice to here a short bit on his history, its great to hear what's going on now and what we now know about what was happening early on. I think what he points out at the end is great, that we are spending a lot but are getting slot for it. It would be much more expensive if we had to go with our own troops to stop a collapse, we need to send what we can, and work our allies to do the same
Very thorough and accurate analysis Gentlemen, well done. 😊✌️❤️
Glad to be a patron love it every time I see a new episode
Very clarifying interview, big thumbs up to both Justin and Ward 👍👍
Mooch and Brock,
Phenomenal Intel and detail on what's happening on ground and in the air! Once again your BUF approach is incredibly insightful!!!!!
Blessings to you both!
The same filter that allowed the TB2 to fly below the Russian radar detection threshold is the same filter that allowed the slow moving Iranian drones to reach their targets without being intercepted. The dopler filters on the radar guided AA guns have to be opened up to allow them to detect and target an airborne target going 80 mph.
Another reason for the filters on military radars is to weed out clutter such as toy helium balloons, swarms of insects and flocks of birds.
@@orlock20 Absolutely, the filtering is called MTI - moving target indicator. Set the speed too low and the false alarm rate goes through the roof.
To deal with slow movers you need additional techniques such as bistatic radar, electro optics (eg visual and laser tracking), infra red scanners, super high frequency radars able to spatially separate targets from clutter and most importantly point air defence.
Hardening critical infrastructure like power, sub stations and pumping stations is also clearly very important. Even old fashioned things like barrage balloons may work.
Great analysis- quite riveting , thank you both.😃
I was a medic in the US Army and had to assess a chopper pilot. He was colorblind and had fooled medical exams for years. It broke my heart, and the guy begged me not to report my test. I'm sure he was an excellent pilot. It wasn't my call to make because I just report the findings, and I would have been court martialed for faking his results. I felt sick for many weeks later, but the physician I worked for said I did the right thing. I'm sure I did the right thing ethically, but it has never felt good or right.
Steve Nichols.......how did that helicopter pilot pass all his previous physical and medical boards including his flight physical which specifically tests for color blindness using the Ishihara Test which has hidden numbers insides different shades of colors that you have to identify that a color blind person would never be able to see? Furthermore...why were you as a Army medic doing vision tests for pilots instead of the actual physicians and specialists that are officers? In my whole military career I never heard or medics giving vision tests to officers for flight qualification.........
Colorblindness never seems as bad for the colorblind person as it does to people with normal color vision. Misidentifying a target because distant markings seem to be the enemy's colors would be tragic.
We all have alternative paths and we learn to live with them when we have to take them. You did the right thing.
I wouldn't beat yourself up too badly - as one who has flown many hours as a passenger in UH-1, UH-60 and CH-46/47 aitframes I appreciate and assume the fact that the pilot is able to fully react to input. Imagine how you would have felt if you saw on the news that a platoon was lost in a helo crash and the pilot was your guy...
There is a lot about this comment I don't understand. Smh
@@patrickbrinkmeier1858 Galland lost eyesight in one eye and flew all of WWII with it... happened aftter the initial examination. Rickenbacker...
Yeah I know, ancient times. You ask the right questions.
Great interview, thank you both.
(Yet) Another superb interview/discussion, Ward. Justin Bronk never disappoints.
There is just no alternative source for this broad expert analysis presented in a clear, understandable way. Your videos with him are priceless.
Fantastic episode. I fortunately became aware of Justin early on in the war and immediately following him on Twitter. The quality of his analysis was immediately apparent.
Thanks for giving Bronk a more public platform to air his analysis and observations.
Dr. Bronk is absolutely brilliant, and you are an excellent interviewer Mooch. Thank you both, I look forward to the next one because Justin is too good to not be a regular guest 😉
Always enjoying listening and watching you guys! Really deep and great stuff! Keep on!
That was excellent. Putting the puzzle together isn't just point and shoot. There is very much an informative study on how to use the hardware correctly.
The more I learn about the Saab Gripen, the more I like it. I've loved that thing since i was about 7 years old.
Definitely one of your better episodes. As you stated, this interview was brilliant at cutting through all the noise and giving an average joe like me greater insight into the war. Thank you.
Amazing interview! Thanks for that Ward. Justin is just the best analyst about military aviation that I know of.
Mooch, (Sir), it’s thanks to your channel that I discovered Dr Bronk. The RAF’s loss is RUSI’s (and our) gain. It’s not just his encyclopaedic knowledge, it’s his articulation and communication skills that get so much information and knowledge across clearly, concisely and without dumbing down. This was a 45 minute intel brief given over a coffee without notes, script or (thank goodness) PowerPoint slides(!). The stand outs for me (apart from all of it) were the F16/F18/Grippen comparison and his explanation of why support to Ukraine is tax/defence funds well spent.
Don’t diss PowerPoint slides until you’ve watched Perun’s channel out of Australia 😉🤷🏼♂️
That's probably why the RAF wouldn't allow him to commission as an Intel analyst, lack of ability to colour coordinate the PP slides....
That was very insightful. Thanks!
Justin is an excellent speaker and adds great content to your channel Mooch. His ego does NOT get in the way of his analysis of the airwar in Ukraine.
Wow! That was something else. Thanks for the interview. Brilliant fellow.
Justin is the best analyst in the world. I'm dazzled!!! Ward, you are always "hitting home runs."
Justin seems like a nice guy, I really like him. Not everyone needs to be a fighter pilot, he seems to be where he needs to be. :)
he seems really useful there. I hope that di not soun stupid.
Really appreciate listening to you both!
Dr Bronk is so right , well read , informed and a great grasp of reality people in power should listen to him ,always good to hear what he has to say
FANTASTIC Interview!!
Give this man and his team deserve a job at the CIA or Defense Department or specialist To Anthony Blinken or Lloyd Austin or some advisory role........
Jesus this guy is smart.
Ward, this was the best video I ever watched from your channel.
Men like him can change the outcome of a War !
Slava Ukraine.
Amazing insight to a fairly complex scenario. Thank you so much!
Wow! Best I’ve heard yet. Thanks to both of you.