Anti-IMF Solution
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 сер 2023
- It has become very clear that IMF policies are leading to rising electricity prices and stagflation. The simple alternative solution is regulation of imports through quotas. Please watch the video to understand and share widely.
*English UA-cam: / taimurrahman1975
*Instagram: / taimur_laal
*Twitter: / taimur_laal
Excellent & Logical Analysis ! ! ! May ALLAH عزوجل Protect Our Nation & Our Country PAKISTAN from all Internal & External Enemies. Aameen ! ! ! May ALLAH guide all of us towards his path of TRUTH. Aameen ! ! ! TRUTH Lovers ko SALAM ! ! !
Ameen, I hope people will spread this message to the government
@@gujjo9825lol...come out of your dreams
@@MuhammadUmar-jm7nithat's not a dream even Russia is trying to Islamic economic system on 2nd September
@@zeshanchandio3732 Bruh.....you will realise everything just wait for 1-2 years....in 2021 i was an islamist too ....and now, a democratic socialist
@@zeshanchandio3732jazbati jahil a gya russia nay is liya aisa kiya hai 10 percent abadi udr muslim hai aur wo middle east say capital ko attract kerna chahta hai kyon kay europe nay to sanction lgai howi hain aur ya system sirf 10 saal kay liya hai sood ko ya log hatem nahi kerain gay
Imports that we don't need:
1. Luxury cars
2. Millitary equipment
Imports that we need:
1. Cheap oil and gas from Iran..
Bro you need military equipment because you have conflict with India
Bro machines, industrial parts, and some other things are essential because we use those parts to get our industries work properly and with full potential - these imported items regulate our exports as well.... The problem is our 40% import directly influence our export...
@@sumitnimawat7408India is our friend
and luxury construction material and fixtures.
if you don't devalue how do you force people to stop over consumption of oil.
The only person who is doing their job with honesty and realisim
Prophet momos
Professor there could be few more helpful solutions.
- import from neighbouring countries like india and Iran (waivers might be granted considering the economic situation).
- trade in Rs. terms with countries from which pakistan import necessary items but also exports items which pakistan can easily produce. (One example would be export of agri products and import of oil from UAE).
- stopping important of luxury products or atleast highly taxing them like luxury cars and costly phones. (Tax wants and wishes).
-Introducing gold bonds. like sovereign gold bonds by RBI India.
-subsidies based on income levels.
- introducing green energy initiatives for vehicle and energy production. (This can be a long term measure).
-pause in defence imports (big ticket items) as the main threat to Pakistan today can be countered using existing items.
I wish i had learnt economics from you.
Typical secular RAW agent.
We dont need India. We need to follow Sharia. Why do u want to do trade with Kafirs.
Only Sharia can help us. Bis millaha
30:25
Forget solutions. Depopulate the land of Pakistan using chemical biological and nuclear weapons and then distribute the land between India, Iran, Afghanistan, UAE, China, USA and whoever wants to have a piece of it.
With these type of PDM/Army rulers and establishment, it is not worth living in or dieing in this country.
@@user-ww2lc1yo9c you a Pakistani?
@@PP-jf3tp
how does this question even arise?
look at the state of this country called pakistan, how much mismanaged it is due to blessings of the pathetic army generals and the politicians the power hungry establishment. Is it really worth trying to save this country with this lot ruling it ?
Live with in your mean!
Say no to loan!
Yes to import Regulation!
i am with your slogan!
Taimur bhai Adaab Sat Sri Akaal🙏
Dushiyant sahib ki ek Nazm me se .....
" Yeh Saara Jism Bojh Se Jhuk Kar Doohra Hua Hoga
Main Sajdey Me Nahin Tha , Aapko Dhokha Hua Hoga " ....
India me Kisan Andolan Panjab me Kisano ne aise hi sadkon par aa kar shuroo kiya tha aur Govt ki Cheekhain nikalwa di thee .🙏🙏
Zabardast
@@beyondgalaxies3960 🙏🙏
Prof. Rehman you nailed it . Very beautifully elucidate the intricacies of economic in very plane language.Respect salam to Hosts guests and viewers .
بہت سادہ الفاظ میں ہمیں بتایا کے ہماری معشیت کیسے بہتر ہو سکتی ہے بہت اچھے بہت خوب
It was so good that I felt like sitting in a classroom listening to a lecture. Hats off!
Kabhi kabhi dil krta k apko hug kr lun....jitna ap humanity ke respect krty han agar to koe gharatmand nation hoti to apna president bana lati......some times I think we can revers the situation bad political system in Pakistan because we have teachers and leaders like you....God is with you❤
Thank you. Help me spread this message, please.
@@Taimur_Laal
Sure sir...thanks for reply.
This video is very well done. Simple, clear, & without losing the detailed points. Format is also getting better over time. Thanks for sharing
Masha'Allah very informative and useful talk. Very realistics analysis of economic situations.
ا بھائیوں اپ کی کاوشوں کا بہت بہت شکریہ جو اپ پاکستان کے لیے کر رہے ہیں لیکن مسئلہ یہ ہے کہ پاکستان انگریزوں نے ایک سازش کے تحت بنایا اور ہندوستان کے مسلمانوں کو تقسیم کر کے کمزور کر دیا اگر پاکستان نہیں بنتا تو ہندوستان میں مسلمان ,,،اکثر یت میں ہوتے اور ہندوستان کا اقتدار ان کے قبضے میں ہوتا اس سازش کے تحت ہے انگریزوں نے پاکستان بنایا اور پاکستان میں اپ لوگوں کو یرغا مال بنا دیا پاکستان انگریزوں کی چھاونی ہے جو کہ ان کے مفادات کے تحفظ کے لیے اس علاقے میں وجود میں لائی گئی لہذا پاکستان کا نام کوئی مستقبل تھا نہ ہے نہ ہوگا لہذا اس ملک سے ہجرت جتنی جلدی کی جائے اپ کے اپنے ذاتی مفاد میں ہے شکریہ
The story of Pakistan’s economy is incomplete without the character of its debt. Pakistan’s economic challenge began following Independence in August 1947, as it had to seek financial help. The structural diagnosis of Pakistan’s debt requires a deep understanding of policy interventions, which put the country on a debt trajectory, and an investigation of how certain groups pushed the country into debt to protect their vested interests
but it is not that hard to control now. We should focus on improving not going back to find the conspiracists
@@Sammyy_aiit's too late now. There's no option left. Just look at imran khan there is no opposition no protests and no revolution we behind India in everything.
@@pipipupu5104 As an Indian, I can say that Imran Khan tenure was good for Pakistan, he was making foreign policy independent. World was started being optimistic of Pakistan. Modi and Imran two good things happened in the neighbourhood we kept Modi but u guys.
Economic assessment
personal point of view at age 29
*Questioning the dynamics of what went wrong economically to wort down current crises of the last 75 years
Objectives of a collective economy
The far most objective of a collective economy is to save its basic consumer unit & his rights,From domestic & International burden & fluctuations
& Role of any govt is to minimise the impact in any form & substitution
The second Role is Growth/development in Accordance to the benefit & utility of consumer
So the far right poor,& minority is protected
Concise Economic Future & Offsetting
The Current Economic paradigm
The Current divide of Pakistan
Is not just as simple as HAVE NOTS,& HAVE TOO'S
Alleviate Poverty Class to a consumer class & play an international role in political dynamics for other countries
In a garrisoned security state
We're facing a myriad of problems
That are interlinked one into other
& Creating a national identity crises
Our solution of action should be
On two paths
Determining the problem of "garrison nation-state"
And cutting cost effective solutions at every level of integration between people
For this general law/guide Of Operability manual
For the servicing sector must be produced
That indoctrinates
Code of conduct in
Spending Sectors i.e
Education,Health
a government should not work in with the divisions & constraints of ministries
But the divisions be based on Proper institutionalised channels
For example Law division,in health sector,
establishment wing in health sector, budget & taxation wing
in health sector,
Media wing in health sector
should be linked & managed accordingly to local district & autonomous bodies on provicial level
& Such division should happen under every ministry so the control of ministry & sector is not vertical but parallel between institutions & ministeries.
A ministry should be run according to 3 standards,i.e
1.spending
2.Growth/development
3.Separate department for bookkeeping, logging & keeping tabs
These 3 departments should be separate,the third one should manage record keeping & purposefully digitalise it
Simplifying our government terms would be beneficial for our community for long run
Criteria for appointment of BS-17 & above officers
An appointing file must be created that reviews officers action
His engagement with budget & his spending decisions & services
Along side an assistant that maintains his serving & minute timings to solve inter/intra departmental issues
& That file be reviewed every year
& Merits of pension be given according to that file.
Economy of a country is its natural & human resources & proper management of human resource is the bedrock, foundation & standing of every country
Our Economy is spending economy in broader terms
Let's Review our economy from a spending point of view.
Our Problem can be listed as
We buy Foriegn goods,into foreign reserve currency $
We need to offset this balance
It can only be offset if our youth finds its international role in international community
Our own people can bring value to PKR,no one else
When everyone's loosing confidence in currency how can we gain value & trust?
Our Plan by 2040 should be to settle atleast a minimum of 330m people here & earn resources so they can live prosperously
We must observe UAE model & see how it has attracted foreign wealth,tourism & FDI into the barren land
That model could have been implemented if our budget spending was wise we could have updated atleast 75 cities to the likes of UAE
Our economy can no longer be led
By building roads & repairing them year on year & some mad man comes at night & stomps on them
Nor can our economy be to build a building & install a banking branch near it
Like temple of solomon"Built it & they will come"
We need to attract foreigners by engaging them at people to people level
Other part of Economy sector is local demand for goods & what goods can be produced locally, keeping the cost of production low,so that Others can buy those goods
A great example is during covid the demand of Pakistan made short capacitors were peaking because production slowed down in china
We need comprehensive research to seek local businesses that can venture out & seek demand of our goods into other countries Latin America is a particular market
For example Bangladesh has taken over manufacturing clothing articles
Now we're tagging goods but production must be maintained of those industries that are constantly importing raw material
They need to be kept in check
We cannot manufacture unlimited supply of towels & men's brief etc
The same principle can be applied to other sectors
Most important point is the political point of economics
That we can smartly maneuver our banking system by allying Turkey & Muslim countries behind a single logistics body from KSA
that can offset our import goods demand to atleast 45%
This alone would deflate the pressure on our economies & give us more time for restructuring the fundamentals
After that objectivise 10 year old plan for steady development be executed
Other economic plans listed are the problems related to fiat currency
Consider these three problems inherent with fiat
goods are unlimited,crops & goods are produced unlimitedly
so cost of production keeps on going up,so does fiat currency
Consider the face value of
10PKR NOTE
10pkr that is rated among 100 people represents trade service of 1000pkr
but still represents only rupees 10 which infact is not it's facevalue
it's service unit of use has increased
So has its fiat numbers
The next problem is banking
Banks likes to keep notes locked up & inflate digital numbers by loan equity & cash deposit payment methods
While still price manipulation & inflation price of goods keeps going up
Govt borrows it's spending from banks because they don't want to print & print required numbers
Yet the government gets blackmailed by bank
To offset this primary issue
Govt must take steps to decouple internal economy from international monetisation
Since we're not in international supply chain except for our spending we can mostly shield ourselves from this effect
Other thing that can be done is
Calculating the value of our currency using a new standard that is ratioed between
Debt/goods:services
Influx of foreign currency/FDI/good will faith of other countries i.e population measure of a country
Our country in theory should be kept near Bangladesh, Afghanistan
Goods on defer payments/schedule payments
Reserving face value of currency to atleast 25% of the Gold within country
& Reserve currency of other countries
& A future indice point of trade & stocks/bonds into the country
This all can be negotiated first with allies & then be presented to IMF & World banks
Then they can submit their draft for our proposal
Thinking like this will create a balance for our currency instead of sloping slide
Other part of the process should be
Allowing banking sector of India in Pakistan to facilitate communal trade between two countries of same nation
Our 5000pkr note should be suspended for in favour of 2500pkr note & that should be equal to Indian 2000pkr note
Such an incentive could engage India
This will never happen. Nothing ever happens in this country except corruption and TTP blasts.
You make learning economics so easy 😊
I am sure govt must be aware of these measures, but what are the hindrances or majbooryan k woh iss pe amal nahi karte?
Sir your totally criticising IMP
Not even single word against our corrupt political system
It is a snapshot of the state of Pakistani thinking because it precedes the planning and policy. Excellent work, Taimur.
Sir ye hukumran humain es bat ki Mubarakain datain hai. Sir app he humry Mulk Kay wazir e khazana ban Jaye ❤❤
Well done, a remarkable solution. You should be a caretaker PM.
❤ form India....u r so amazing and social realistic.....
ALLAH KARE AP KI YRH BAT GOVERNMENT KO SAMJH AA JAEY
Sir I m ur biggest fan Pakistan mn esy e intellectual mind set ki zarort hy I learned alot from ur lectures or jesy apki kisi b topic py lecture ata Mera Dil hota bsss as soon as possible soon liya jye
OMG this is alarming, I know economic situation is very bad in our country but it’s going to be worse day by day. Very informative video with a solution
Thank you and please keep sharing these type of video
I shared this with an extremely educated group. This is one comment that I received. Kindly address this in your future videos..
"He has himself admitted that our exports are dependent on imports to the extent of 37%.
Restricting imports will have two adverse effects one exports will be restricted second inflation will rise which will again make exports costlier.
The suggested solution will only give short term benefit.
Long-term solution is to increase local production with least or none import content.
If private sector is not coming forward we can revive Ayub Khan's strategy of first starting manufacturing companies in the public sector and then privatizing them. PIDC can play an important role."
this was so well put up, even more amazing was the fact that you explained every slide with so much examples and vividness
"Elite apki cheekhaigi, unko cheekhnay dain" ye cheezzz
We can never thank you for the efforts you put for us in the understanding concepts and contemporary issues.
Masha Allah AJ Sir sari confusion door ho gi economy ka bary mn kha Pakistan q in halat sy fu char hn
Very Impressive and Analytical
Such video's are much needed to understand root cause of our problems! Thank you so much sir, very informative 👍
Words are less to describe the excellence of your lecture. COMPREHENSIVE, SIMPLE, RATIONAL & REALISTIC, SOLUTIONS IN THE END ARE ❤❤
Best teacher in world. Mr.Taimoor rahman ❤
Not Allah 😂
@@plato7553 yes Mr.Taimoor indeed. Cz he teaches us economics, critical thinking and much more .
Allah doesn't teach us that xD
Dear you seem ignorant,
Allah SWT always said that live a simple life, na Tou hath bandh lo k Kuch kharch he na Karo aur na hath aisa kholo k fazool kharchi Karo.
Besides that Allah SWT also said k bewaqoof and na ehal aur fazool kharch krnay walay Shaitan k Bhai Hain, aisay logon ko apna wali na Bnao.
Our prophet Muhammad SAW always emphasized on mianarawi ikhtiar Karo.
@@NasirMehmood-mm5gy 75 years you stayed ignorant. How many more years you think 🤔 you can live?
@@NasirMehmood-mm5gy as long you and likes don’t understand Quran Hadith and get fooled. You will live on Katora and street
Love your points Sir keep going & enlightened us ❤
Excellent presentation
Thanks sir you should be financ minister of pakistan great lecture
AoA.
Good Information & Good solution
Allah aaapko sehat day
Thanks
Waiting for more videos
You’re a very good teacher Sir 😘 Prayers and blessings your way
Arguably, the most valuable content of this day and age in Pakistan.
thanks for such great presentation.
JazakAllah
Good work.Thanks for knowledge!!!
May this content reach to Government...MashaAllah❤❤❤
The already know and they also hide this from public
😂 will reach masha Allah 😂
@@plato7553 what you just said doesnt even makes sense. Ager mai bolon "mujhe pani khana hai" to sunnay mai kitna ajeeb lagay ga, us terha he apne abhi jo kaha uska kuch matlab he nhi ban raha aesa lag raha hai apne kuch random words likh diye. Aesa lag raha hai apko language ka sahi se istemaal nhi ata
unka already sab pata hai bus wo kerna nhi chahte
@@khizarkhan7305 get over Islam. Love nature, like science 🧪
Thanks, it is the voice of every sane person
Very insightful summary of crisis
MashaALLAH
JazakALLAH
Boht hi Khoob 👍
Dr. Sb.! I am your regular listener! Today you look emotional and concerned about people of Pakistan. Thanks for showing concern! May Allah guide our people to choose right people.
very well brief. right to the issue. JazakAllah
Zbrdst... Ye achi bat ki apny
Great Analysis and solutions for the improvement of the economy.
Outstanding explaination
Amazing video and amazing knowledge, waiting for more education videos relating to current situation
Taimur bhai it was very informative and educational video for even people with no knowledge of economics. You made it Very easy to understand the current economic scenario. This is the type of content we need to educate our people.
Alhamdulillah someone is wise enough to present a true economic perspective related to the current situation instead of a blame game political perspective!
Very well explained.
sir boht kuch seekhnay ko mila aap ki is video say, kaafi concepts clear huway jo zuban zad e Aaam to thay but unclear thay.
Great Work
Very informative Mr. Taimoor keep it up. Stay Blessed
Sir g ... what a teaching bht bht achy sy smj aya IMF h kya wah kya kehny apk
what a brilliant mind u have.
Great 👍
Great sir
Excellent explained well done ✅
Informative
Creating Awareness , Doing Great Job. Wish You All the Best.
Thanks Sir, informative video 👍
I request you sir to please use this video as a sponsor add .. everyone should listen this video
What do you mean sponsor add?
Good job done
Excellent discussion sir! 👍
Great analyst
Well Done !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I watched your complete video but the solutions you proposed were actually similar to PDM policies to control LC's and reduce CAD which infact was done successfully. However despite reduction of CAD the country barely posted a GDP growth of about 0.3pc which means unemployment and rise in poverty. Moreover,You talked about the banning of luxury products. Luxury products are cause of concern only if they are huge in value but if we look closely in our import bill we find that petroleum and olive oil share the largest volume of import bill. Unfortunately regulating the LC's of these products will only create demand supply problems and will result in higher prices. In this scenerio i think the best solution is to reduce corporate taxes and invite foreign companies to invest in Pakistan. In the consequence of their investments the balance of payment crisis would be averted. As india's CAD is also 67bn usd and run high trade deficit but all is balanced due to investment of 70.4 bn usd.
Sir kuch questions hain
1. Jin items ki import total ban kareyn gey un ki smuggling start ho jaye gi. Dollar to phir bhi jaye ga ulta import duty bhi nahi miley gi.
2. Jin items ki import kum kareyn gey quota sey un ki prices high ho jayen gi. Again another form of inflation.
3. Labour flight ko ap ney negative kaha jab ke agar humari Labour bahir na jaye ya na gayi hoti to aj trade account deficit 3 to 4 times hota.
4. Ab agar trade account balance ho bhi jaye to pichley International loans ka kya kareyn. Un ki repayment ke liye hi humey new loans leney par jatey hain or IMF ki zaroorat rehti hai
Level kar Diya ha sir g ap NY
Excellent 👌❤❤
Good suggestions
Excellent sir , listening you since 2018 , big fan of your thoughts.
Ma Sha Allah sir g
Excellent research sir👌👌👌👌
Excellent lecture 👍
Best info video
Highly impressed!!
Sir very beautiful anylses.....Allah Pakistan ki Khair karay ameen
Very interesting
Your presentation is awesome.
GOOD JOB
good information sir
Thank u sir for simple explanation. ❤❤❤
Thanku for the wise analysis
Zabardast
Thanks for great info
Very well explained sir.
this is the real version of Dr. Taimur. please dont make those sarcastic comments or sarcastic videos. the kind of knowledge you purport is best suited with a serious and a compact kind of nature.
I'm happy to do it this way. My only reason for doing it the other way is basically to get people interested.
@@Taimur_Laal sir I wanted to read the constitutional history of Pakistan. Which book should I read?
Excellent
Agar Quota lagaya jai ga tou black market bhi tou form hogi. Phir preference bhi hogi keh jo bara importer hain uss ko zada quota milay ga. Kuch aur bhi maslay houngai lekin lagta hai yehi solution sab sai behtar hai. Well put 👏
Great
Really loved your to the detail explanation no BS 👌
Genius Dr. Saab
Well done 👍
Well explained, May Allah grant you a powerful post in govt., For the welfare of the individuals and for the Pakistan...Aameen.
Macroeconomics was the easiest subject I ever took, unfortunately it takes a brilliant brain to explain it to the government which lacks a common sense Brian.
Taimur bhai keep it up buhat khoob
Sir Taimur is a blessing for Pakistan❤