Fallout TV Show (Trailer) Breaks The LORE and I Have Major CONCERNS

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 227

  • @filipzietek5146
    @filipzietek5146 11 місяців тому +46

    NCR 700k population was before expansion north before the end of fallout 2. By the time of New Vegas is well over 1 million-1.5

    • @JohnDoe-sl6di
      @JohnDoe-sl6di 7 місяців тому +1

      Maybe the courier bombs ncr ending in lonesome roads is canon

    • @kyero8724
      @kyero8724 7 місяців тому +1

      Oh well get over it lol

    • @waterboi4846
      @waterboi4846 6 місяців тому

      @@JohnDoe-sl6di ho boi this comment aged well

  • @lordofthebuckets2676
    @lordofthebuckets2676 11 місяців тому +59

    Also why is the Brotherhood wearing the T-60 power armor when they’ve always used the T-51 armor on the west coast?

    • @lucifer0247
      @lucifer0247 11 місяців тому +16

      The TvShow plays 9 years after F4, so it plays 9 Years after Maxson took over the Brotherhood. You even see a Prydwin like Ship in the trailer. I think he is invading the West, reconnecting with the remnants of the West-BoS to take over California.

    • @KayJay940
      @KayJay940 11 місяців тому +7

      They appear to be going with the brotherhood ending of fo4 as canon for the show. Which is just bad on many levels. First being they were absolutely facist. And means they would have had to wipe out the Institue and any Enclave remaining in capitol wastes. Boriiiiing.

    • @creed8712
      @creed8712 11 місяців тому +13

      @@KayJay940so fascist, not liking super mutants or wanting to have people be murdered and replaced with robots

    • @KayJay940
      @KayJay940 11 місяців тому

      @creed8712 no because their primary goal is to horde technology and keep it from anyone else. That facism. Duh.

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому

      @@KayJay940I think what's left of Enclave in the East Coast will probably join them, seeing that the regular troops were originally not too keen on adding the FEV into the water project and are more focus on restoring America. Also I think the enclave leadership are either dead or just deserted by the time broken steel is over.

  • @nopenope3678
    @nopenope3678 11 місяців тому +34

    fallout tv writer: fallout 1 & 2 yeah not canon
    fallout fans: i beg your pardon

    • @WELSHGAMER99
      @WELSHGAMER99 7 місяців тому +1

      Source?

    • @theholyemu3716
      @theholyemu3716 7 місяців тому +1

      @@WELSHGAMER99 my source is I made it the fuck up

    • @waterboi4846
      @waterboi4846 6 місяців тому

      @@The-Red-Menace scattering props and cameos does not make it "in the show" the story has to support the game otherwise its just bunch of retcon garbage. id say the writers and showrunners did not have enough cash to create "an NCR city" it will be expensive what we got is some carnival in some old farmer's junkyard

    • @Gambit0590
      @Gambit0590 6 місяців тому

      ​@@waterboi4846the NCR most likely still exists

    • @ThisIsMyYouTubeAccount1
      @ThisIsMyYouTubeAccount1 6 місяців тому

      ​@@Gambit0590nah

  • @barricadedpurifier
    @barricadedpurifier 7 місяців тому +6

    Fast forward to today and it turns out they retconned Fallout 2 and New Vegas. It’s like Todd wants the setting to remain like Fallout 3.

  • @lbk2436
    @lbk2436 11 місяців тому +51

    Not only is the LA Boneyard smack in the middle of NCR territory, but it is indeed a thriving NCR city. It’s established in NV that LA is the NCRs most populated city that’s been rebuilt/renovated, complete with a Medical University and home to the Governments central banking system.

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому

      Well we don't get to see it in the trailers, it also odd that LA has that when the city is full of rads which tells me it's all NCR propaganda. The Medical University is probably vault 33 or 32 and the home to the Governments central banking system is probably that junkyard town they shown us in the trailer.

    • @K100Nukem
      @K100Nukem 11 місяців тому +8

      When Lucy enter the shantytown in the trailer you can see LA far in the distance. And her Vault is in Santa Monica not in the center of LA. I'm sure the Bonyard will be fine, they don't want to show everything in the first teaser.

    • @lbk2436
      @lbk2436 11 місяців тому +11

      @@K100Nukem don’t get me wrong I hope your right. That being said the whole point of a trailer even a first one is to show what to expect, the main characters, major players etc. if This takes place in new California primarily in the “Greater LA area” the NCR should play a massive role in the show in order to make sense with the established lore. The fact they don’t show even a tiny glimpse of anything NCR would be like the trailer for Return of the Jedi not including a single glimpse of anything Galactic Empire. Also I’m not so much concerned of the NCR not being in the show, as I'm worried of some massive ridiculous Bethesda game change like “the NCR fell” or “the brotherhood Defeated them”

    • @K100Nukem
      @K100Nukem 11 місяців тому +4

      @@lbk2436 The ncr population is around 700 000 by the time of Fallout 2. They could be like 1 or 2 millions in 2296. And it's for all of California, plus Oregon, new Mexico, and probably Nevada if they win the war in New Vegas. So I dont expect to see a lot of NCR presence in a small Shanty Town outside of the Boneyard. For comparison, the population of LA today is almost 4 millions. Plus, the boneyare is know to be a hard place to live by the time of NV, only à few years before the show.

    • @nygeriunprence
      @nygeriunprence 10 місяців тому +2

      @@K100NukemThey ruined the lore bro

  • @K369-v3o
    @K369-v3o 11 місяців тому +43

    Vault 33 is under NCR control. You can see NCR flags in some of the leaked photos.
    But yeah, all of California is pretty much settled and civilized as per New Vegas lore.
    The only thing that would make sense is if the canon ending of Lonesome road was the one where the Courier nuked the NCR.
    Also, the Enclave are back. I doubt the explanation for their return will be very satisfying assuming there is one.

    • @jormungaurd
      @jormungaurd 11 місяців тому +1

      It's possible that the areas they're showing in the trailer are parts of LA that have been taken over by desert and the NCR just never bothered to try to reclaim that area. The Brotherhood force that we're seeing could be an invasion force that is invading NCR territory. Heck, that could be who the Brotherhood is fighting in the one scene since we don't see any of their enemies.

    • @joaoemanuel9187
      @joaoemanuel9187 11 місяців тому +8

      @@jormungaurd man, can you share a bit of your copium with me?

    • @dimkodimko6894
      @dimkodimko6894 11 місяців тому +1

      why immediately vault 33? The leaked photos also show vault 32. also, where did you see the enclave?

    • @killgoretrout9000
      @killgoretrout9000 10 місяців тому +1

      First we don't know what is flashback and what taking place in the shows "present day" for the Ghoul shooting things up scene we have no real context in time or place, is that taking place 100 years after the bombs dropped or is it taking place on the fringes of or outside of NCR territory? One of the possible New Vegas endings for the BoS if the NCR wins has a thawing of relations between the NCR and BoS and even mentions the BoS protecting trade and travel on their stretch of the Mojave with no mention of them harassing people for tech. New Vegas constantly mentioned that the NCR was over stretching itself combine that with several years of bad harvests and food shortages the idea that the NCR would collapse or be reduced in size significantly within a 15 year period is not unreasonable. I'm gonna wait for the show before I judge the show.

    • @grzegorzbiedak
      @grzegorzbiedak 10 місяців тому

      Why is the Enclave back, I must've missed that in trailer? Also, I heard something that action of the show will be spread over 200 years, rather than placed in one particular time and it was the only reason I didn't have heart attack watching the trailer. Has anything changed, because I think I might be wrong somewhere?

  • @LiteralCrimeRave
    @LiteralCrimeRave 11 місяців тому +32

    Lost Hills still stands. Just north of the Boneyeard and still in command of other Chapters.
    NCR is confirmed to be in the show.

    • @dimkodimko6894
      @dimkodimko6894 11 місяців тому +3

      where did you get this from? from fallout 4? It doesn't say anything about Lost Hills. At the terminal in Prydwen there is also no mention of Lost Hills, only the presence of the elders of the west coast. and they may be in another bunker

    • @LiteralCrimeRave
      @LiteralCrimeRave 11 місяців тому +3

      @dimkodimko6894 It would have been mentioned in FNV or FO4 is Lost Hills fell. Especially considering that they extensively used lore from Van Buren, especially for the details of the NCR Brotherhood war. Silence on the subject speaks for itself IMO.

    • @dimkodimko6894
      @dimkodimko6894 11 місяців тому +1

      @@LiteralCrimeRave details of the war? It’s funny, because they literally didn’t say a damn thing. it’s just that the brotherhood attacked because of a disagreement over technology, NCR pushed them out, and carried out several campaigns to destroy bunkers. this is all. neither where did these bunkers come from, nor how many are left, nor even the damn information about the gold reserve, all this is not in the game. Sawyer says about the gold reserve like some NPC mentions it, but no! this npc doesn't say that! this is such nonsense really.

  • @dragonleo_
    @dragonleo_ 11 місяців тому +18

    Theory: Maybe the Brotherhood of steel is having a presence in LA because this guys are from the east coast in the Trailer we can see another prydwen so maybe the west coast brotherhood requested the help of the east coast brotherhood. And as for the lack of NCR presence I don't have an explanation but in some images we can see the NCR flag maybe we just have to wait for another trailer.

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому +1

      That Flag is inside Vault 33 which is closed current so it must have open many many years ago.

    • @thedeadyoutuberscollector8447
      @thedeadyoutuberscollector8447 11 місяців тому +3

      Well the story is ten years after fallout 4 so something bad could of happened

    • @codyc7036
      @codyc7036 11 місяців тому

      ​@@Alex-pj8nzis it in vault 33? Or is it another vault. Also Mr. House is supposed to be in the show too. Furthermore this teaser shows the brotherhood engaged with an advanced enemy via artillery fire. So its safe to say the ncr will play a role. As for the power of the brotherhood, the show takes place 9 years after fallout 4 wich is plenty of time to build another ship the size of the prydwen and to send that ship to the west coast bolstering their power.

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому +1

      @@codyc7036 Why would the BOS send another Prydwen class ship to the west unless they have ships to spare. That means the Prydwen wasn’t destroyed. . Also seeing that Maxson BOS is now in deep California the NCR must have been whipped by the eastern BOS. HA HA 🤣 to the NCR.

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому

      @@codyc7036 It has to be Vault 33 the other vault 32 has mutants in it and the vault guy doesn’t look mutated.

  • @ramen_guru
    @ramen_guru 11 місяців тому +10

    The first season will be an introduction with flashbacks, sort of like, to get the audience acquainted with the story and the background of the characters. The NCR will appear by the end of the first season and will be a big thing in the second. Just because it was not featured in the trailer it doesn't mean it will be out of the series. Keep calm and enjoy!

    • @braddishv3146
      @braddishv3146 11 місяців тому +5

      Sorry, but that makes less sense than the actual trailer.

    • @ramen_guru
      @ramen_guru 11 місяців тому

      @@braddishv3146 there's no need to be sorry

    • @TheMash-upChannel
      @TheMash-upChannel  11 місяців тому +6

      We will have to wait and see. Fingers crossed, it will all work out.

    • @ramen_guru
      @ramen_guru 11 місяців тому +1

      @@TheMash-upChannel amen

    • @RyanLBC
      @RyanLBC 11 місяців тому

      the trailer didn't make sense for reason. they don't want to spoil the entire storyline. people be jumping to conclusions. when nolan and howard were interviewed they said this story is canonical and will be set during after the events of fallout 4 and will start in los angeles. @@braddishv3146

  • @eleven99
    @eleven99 7 місяців тому +3

    How about instead of having major concerns for the series thats well and truly dead and you know will not be addressed, you just don't waste your time with the show whatsoever?

  • @thatguy57
    @thatguy57 11 місяців тому +13

    If the show is going to take place in 2296, the lore states a prediction of food shortages in the NCR by 2291. Based on the dates, it could be that the NCR has fallen into civil disorder or even civil war due to those predicted food shortages. Maybe the New Vegas campaign economically broke the NCR, regardless of how that campaign ended. Either would make for an interesting background, if the NCR is embroiled in an internal conflict or economic depression and would make it even darker than we already expect for Fallout.
    We really don't know any details, so at the moment, it's all just speculation.

    • @sorenludwig3978
      @sorenludwig3978 11 місяців тому +2

      and its imaginable, that a loss of hoover dam could end the the hole ncr, since it is the primary water source for california.

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому

      Well this could explain how the BOS can enter deep NCR territory, they must have bribe NCR towns and settlements with Food and water from the East Coast delivering via airships.

    • @harleygunn4783
      @harleygunn4783 11 місяців тому +4

      That's a really good theory, and if the ncr is going through all those problems then it makes more sense that the brotherhood would have been able to use it to their advantage and regain their strength and numbers while the ncr was too busy fighting each other

    • @enclavesoldier769
      @enclavesoldier769 11 місяців тому +2

      But food prediction scenarios are generally impossible past such a long time, today we can hardly if at all predict accurately within a month. I highly doubt a mildly competent OSI is able to create predictions 10+ years.

    • @Youarekenough
      @Youarekenough 8 місяців тому

      ​@@harleygunn4783especially since its more likely the east coast BOS that is present in the tv show with prydwen and the abundance of t60 power armor

  • @corypowercat7277
    @corypowercat7277 8 місяців тому +3

    It's definitly going to have retcons. Like why is the BOS that large and why is there a scrap city in LA where that location was rebuilt?

    • @Princess_Celestia_
      @Princess_Celestia_ 8 місяців тому +3

      Oh you just know it's gonna have retcons. Bethesda loves retconning s**t.

  • @Kujer708
    @Kujer708 7 місяців тому +4

    I'm sure they will write the NCR out saying they got wiped out.. But not by the legion but by the BOS 😂

    • @alexloponte7056
      @alexloponte7056 7 місяців тому +1

      Surely

    • @barricadedpurifier
      @barricadedpurifier 7 місяців тому +1

      Apparently New Vegas is no longer canonical and the NCR is now a small time raider faction.

  • @CptJackmoto.
    @CptJackmoto. 11 місяців тому +38

    if you look at the leaked photos there's a ncr flag in the vault, cmon bro

    • @bedrockboy2194
      @bedrockboy2194 11 місяців тому +16

      The NCR controls from Oregon to Baja and Los Angeles aka the Boneyard is a major settlement so there should be way more presence and that was a leaked photo and could have been replaced.

    • @CptJackmoto.
      @CptJackmoto. 11 місяців тому +9

      @@bedrockboy2194 besides the fact that the NCR is a big deal and probably a surprise in the show, they wouldn’t replace that. the flag was on set during filming clear as day

    • @tpost117
      @tpost117 11 місяців тому +5

      People think this trailer needed to show every single thing. When it didn’t, they let their imaginations run wild just so they could find things to worry about or criticize. We shouldn’t review a show before it airs but here we are. They’ll always find a reason to complain.

    • @CptJackmoto.
      @CptJackmoto. 11 місяців тому +2

      @@tpost117 exactly and they did such a good job, they showed so much in the trailer yet we know nothing. Most trailers spoil half the show. They know what they're doing by getting everyone excited

    • @sw-gs
      @sw-gs 11 місяців тому +1

      That is flag of California Republic, not NCR.

  • @sw-gs
    @sw-gs 11 місяців тому +1

    NCR has fallen to New Eclave who emerged from mystery Vaults deep into north of Oregon. West Coast Brotherhood of Steel is in conflict with New Enclave, when suddenly East Coast Brotherhood of Steel arrives with new technology and weapons. There are refugee cities of former NCR citizens that are hurt both by Brotherhood and New Enclave. Story will follow three character: Lucy tech savy Vault Dweller who in search of cure for disease that hit Vault 33 stumbles upon New Enclave and is held by them as prisoner; Maximus loyal yet cowardly Squire of the West Coast BoS who is assigned to Knight of West Coast BoS who is brutal and cruel which makes him question entire BoS existance and The Ghoul former actor, turned bounty hunter whom daughter was one of the victims of nuclear war. When Maximus deserts BoS puts bounty on his head which The Ghoul picks up while in meantime Lucy who is tech genius reprograms few robots and escapes NE, she stumbles upon Maximus who discovered truth about entire conflict: somewhere in California is secret Vault-Tech facility Vault 0 that had prototype G.E.C.K. which can terraform entire continent and that's why BoS and NE fight eachother. Lucy belives that Vault might also contain cure to strange feral disease that Vault 33 population is struck by. So Lucy and Maximus will venture to find that secret Vault while being followed by The Ghoul.

  • @braddishv3146
    @braddishv3146 11 місяців тому +6

    After the objective destruction of most IPs over the last decade - I'm not even remotely interested. If they wanted to play "fast and loose" with things that have already been established, they should have just created a show "based" on the Fallout universe. See, I fixed it right there with one word. Problem is that Hollywood now is creatively bankrupt. All they do is take, repackage, and subvert: endless prequels, "reimagined" for the modern (and seemingly non-existent) audience, or just blatantly copy something (Star Trek: Into Darkness - I'm looking at you! They didn't even bother to change the dialogue in many cases).
    To the other comment, "Well it's just a trailer". Yeah - that's kind of the point. Those who know are thinking, "this doesn't make any sense". It's just a collection of Fallout "stuff" on film. Why are they sending this unprepared person out alone? The task or outcome must not be THAT important why risk it with someone who is clearly clueless. If the task isn't that important, why should the audience care? The point of the trailer, or any trailer, is to get you invested. There is nothing to invest in here... For people who love Fallout this is just a head-scratching moment. To people who have never been introduced to Fallout this is just generic sci-fi. So they have failed to engage the existing fans or give a compelling reason why someone not familiar with it should be interested. This isn't a teaser for something years away - this is already shot and releasing in a few months. All this tells me is, "Look - Fallout show!" and that isn't a very compelling argument.

    • @TheMash-upChannel
      @TheMash-upChannel  11 місяців тому +2

      Good points! The creators of the show are also claiming this show will fit into the cannon of the games as if it was fallout 5. 😂

    • @manic_hearts
      @manic_hearts 11 місяців тому

      ​@@TheMash-upChannelWant to know my favorite part: didn't Bethesda have HUGE beef with the creators of West World because of them stealing the scripts/coding for Fallout Shelters? Said beef turned into a LAWSUIT? Am I the only one who remembers this drama? Now said creator is making a show for a Bethesda title? Anyone else find that kind of alarming or fishy?

    • @icefarrow7959
      @icefarrow7959 11 місяців тому

      @@manic_hearts Lol, what? The creative team had nothing to do with the game, that was the parent company WB. Why would writers and directors make a game based on an IP they don't own? C'mon, think.

  • @adamdoran1398
    @adamdoran1398 11 місяців тому +3

    its so crazy how you see a 2 minute trailer and lose your shit for no reason god i hate fandoms

    • @Mirthful_Midori
      @Mirthful_Midori 10 місяців тому +1

      You're really just going to pretend the interviews don't exist? You're going to pretend that the show's director didn't describe it with "It's Just A Gonzo, Crazy, Funny Adventure" and that it's not a very bad sign for the show's quality?

    • @hayro252
      @hayro252 8 місяців тому +1

      ​@@Mirthful_Midori Wait he really said that? Yet despite this Todd wants me to believe that this show is canon?
      Nah man, this TV show's canonity is null and void in my opinion.

    • @Mirthful_Midori
      @Mirthful_Midori 8 місяців тому

      @@hayro252 She was one of the producers and the exact line was "It is just a gonzo, crazy, funny, adventure and a mindf*** like none you've ever seen before,". You can easily find the article by typing that line into Google.

  • @Based_Stuhlinger
    @Based_Stuhlinger 11 місяців тому +1

    The cowboy ghoul is the only thing that's cool to me because it evokes that western style of FNV.

  • @carsonkouts
    @carsonkouts 11 місяців тому +6

    It cracks me up when people talk about what isn't there in the unreleased show based off of a few small previews of what most likely is the first 2 episodes if that lmao. like come on man can't be saying no ncr!!??? From the very initial teaser trailer

    • @vicemontey4297
      @vicemontey4297 10 місяців тому +5

      I mean you kind of can. This is set in the core of the NCR territory near a major metropolitan hub that is pretty large in population even in Fallout 2.

    • @carsonkouts
      @carsonkouts 10 місяців тому

      @vicemontey4297 you see like 4 locations lmfao what are you talking about. we see a bunch of wasteland and one settlement, a random house, and a brotherhood base. Kinda a limited selection out of the overall area.

    • @vicemontey4297
      @vicemontey4297 10 місяців тому +3

      @@carsonkouts I don't think you know how large the Boneyard is at this point...which is where this is taking place. The NCR Reserve (think federal reserve) and many of the major government and corporate buildings of the NCR would be in this exact area. We even get a shot of the wider area from one the sequences that plays and it looks pretty barren for such a major government, trade and corporate hub of the NCR. We should be able to see some semblance of the Old World in this region since it's such a major part of the NCR infrastructure. It would be like going to Washington D.C today and have it be a flat land still untouched by man....

    • @carsonkouts
      @carsonkouts 10 місяців тому

      @vicemontey4297 except we don't know what has happened in the world so... it's literally during an unexpored time period in the fallout universe. literally anything could have happened

    • @vicemontey4297
      @vicemontey4297 10 місяців тому

      @@carsonkouts I mean if we are going by that then I hope the Enclave returns as like some HUGE faction with HUGE amounts of resources (i.e. they conqured the rest of America that aren't part of the games) that can be explained away some how or that Ceasars Legion wins at the second battle of Hoover Dam and survives his brain tumor and found a genius successor and reformed the Legion and marched into California core territories and is waging a devastating based war of genocide. I hope the latter more than the former so that we get a cringe/based/troll FNV ending as cannon since anything could have happened.

  • @michaelsuk6440
    @michaelsuk6440 9 місяців тому

    NCR was confirmed by the producers of the show. There’s an NCR flag in vault 33, there’s also what looks like an index of names and groups and the list shows both the BOS and NCR in the same column.

  • @darkhole333
    @darkhole333 11 місяців тому +6

    "breaks the lore" its the furthest in the future bit of canon we have now, it decides whats happened in the 15 YEARS in universe since new vegas.

    • @smokedbeefandcheese4144
      @smokedbeefandcheese4144 11 місяців тому +1

      Maybe so but fallout media doesn't stay completely cannon for long especially stuff outside the games. They will treat this like the fallout bible in 5ys when microsoft puts on the pants and retires todd and emile

    • @landon7301
      @landon7301 11 місяців тому +2

      i agree, i feel it is hard to criticize a piece of lore that has not happened in any other form before.

  • @JohnOh0701
    @JohnOh0701 8 місяців тому

    The boneyard is pretty civilized at this point in new vegas its the heartland of the NCR and most vaults around the area were opened long ago

  • @jacobyullman5005
    @jacobyullman5005 11 місяців тому +1

    1) There have been leaked set photos which show the presence of NCR flags.
    2) The show is set to be the most recent thing in the timeline, taking place 9 years after Fallout 4.
    3) This is just a teaser trailer, so just because they didn't show something doesn't mean it's not in the show. They haven't shown Super Mutants or Deathclaws yet either.
    Everybody needs to take a chill pill and just wait till we see more of the show before making assumptions.

    • @GGDC1997
      @GGDC1997 11 місяців тому

      And Mr. House is confirmed on the show, this could mean that maybe the Courier got the House Always Wins ending explaining why the NCR is loosing ground for the brotherhood.

    • @angelmendez2211
      @angelmendez2211 10 місяців тому

      @@GGDC1997 Mr house would probably be shown as robco ceo pre war most likely.

    • @vicemontey4297
      @vicemontey4297 10 місяців тому +3

      @@GGDC1997 The NCR would not lose ground to the Western BoS in this scenario. Just because the NCR doesn't win in Nevada doesn't mean it losses California...The Western BoS would be SO FUCKED if they fought an OPEN war with the NCR no matter which ending is the case in NV.

    • @GGDC1997
      @GGDC1997 10 місяців тому

      @@vicemontey4297 We dont know how much the NCR lost, we just saw an air base and an airship and the series passes a couple of years after New Vegas. In the game its implied that loosing the mojave would fuck up the faction pretty hard due to political caos, low morale and how much they invested. They could even say that Elder Maxon chapter helped to defeat the ncr.

    • @GGDC1997
      @GGDC1997 10 місяців тому +1

      @@angelmendez2211 I hope they do more with him, even if it is a few references about new vegas

  • @andrewobrien8325
    @andrewobrien8325 7 місяців тому +1

    I’m not a huge expert on the western fallout lore and I’m also bad at geography of America…..I know where Texas, Florida and California are aside from that….uhhh pass. Anyway I’m pretty sure this show will probably include the NCR….i can see a video next to yours that shows the NCR flag in the image. I don’t know loads about western fallout but I know the NCR flag is a bear with two heads. However another defence I’m going to offer the show is one I’m pretty sure no one in this comment section will like(including myself but I already made sure my front door was reinforced so here goes) but this show maybe more for a general audience therefore they maybe being more flexible with the lore(don’t hurt me!) so that’s it’s easier to follow before they begin expanding it so that the show gets more seasons…..I’m sorry! I’m just saying what the show developers maybe going for!

  • @HadesCowboy
    @HadesCowboy 11 місяців тому +3

    The NCR is in, as others have already said.
    According to Tod Howard, the show will be canon, and given that Bethesda has a habit of rewriting lore (especially stuff that is mentioned but not seen) I have decided to give the TV show the same leniency as Bethesda.
    Maybe large parts of California are still uninhabited due to shortages of resources in the local areas that makes settling more of a burden on the NCR
    Maybe the BoS are active due to the canon events of New Vegas being siding with the NCR and allying with the BoS

    • @Crusader_Fair
      @Crusader_Fair 11 місяців тому

      The NCR and BOS fought the Enclave together. Five minutes later the NCR fucked over the BOS. The NCR getting help in NV doesn't mean shit to the NCR. They would most likely not care about the help in NV.

  • @Cifer77
    @Cifer77 11 місяців тому +1

    Omission from a trailer doesn't indicate it won't be in the show... lol

  • @jcg9998
    @jcg9998 11 місяців тому

    Just keep in mind that 18 years is a long time. The Brotherhood still existed with substantial power. There easily could have been a war in which the Brotherhood crushed the NCR. Afterall, the show seems to prominently display the Brotherhood. Technology is everything in war. We haven't seen everything they have. It's very possible that they built weapons or found some nukes and either used them or threatened to use them. What if another nuclear attack was launched by either an existing or unknown power?

    • @Ulysses_S_Grant1870
      @Ulysses_S_Grant1870 11 місяців тому +3

      The NCR already beatend the BOS once, they can do it again

    • @vicemontey4297
      @vicemontey4297 10 місяців тому +3

      The NCR defeated a bigger, meaner and far more plentiful and resourced heavy Western BoS in the first war with fewer overall manpower and firepower, The NCR post Hoover Dam could utterly CRUSH the Western BoS given how much they lost in the first war. Not only that only 1-3 generation of BoS could have grown since the end of the first NCR-BoS war. The BoS was chopped in half (at least) by the end of that war (this isn't just manpower, but equipment and supplies as well). The BoS, if fighting the NCR again, would barely be 85% (optimistic estimate) of their original strength prior to the NCR-BoS war while the NCR would have been 100%-200% more powerful now compared to the first war. There is no way the Western BoS could win against the full might of the NCR in a second war unless the East coast BoS comes to help, but I don't see why they would given how much they have going on back East.

  • @Krazyman1999
    @Krazyman1999 11 місяців тому

    I didn't know there were Cyclops in Fallout.
    I'd have liked to have seen the TV Series follow the Vault-Tec Rep, from the beginning of Fallout 4. As opposed to the Vault Dweller, finding out about his life. Going from a Sales Rep, to trying to survive the Bombs, as he is told he isn't able to get into Vault 111, with a spinning Mini Gun in his face, getting him to run for a place to hide from the bombs.
    The Bombs dropping, the people in Sanctuary turning into Ghouls, as they do in Fallout 4. Along with the Vault-Tec Rep, struggling to survive Radiation and the horrors of the Wasteland...
    A lot of the people in Sanctuary, from Fallout 4, eventually turned into Feral Ghouls.
    I'd have them all huddled in the Sanctuary Cellar, as they try to survive the bombs. Meeting the Ghoul crime boss, before the bombs dropped, and the head in the jar guy from Nuka World.
    Meeting Kellogg, and seeing the development of prototype Synths. Seeing Nick Valentine, the original one.

  • @MandaloreTheReclaimer
    @MandaloreTheReclaimer 11 місяців тому +1

    Everyone trying to make sense of this trailer from a lore stand point. It's Hollywood guys, they'll have a few references, some imagery, copy some names and aesthetics. Ultimately, they'll do their own thing because to these writers your silly video game story isn't good enough and what they'll make is better. I can't shake the feeling it will end up just like halo.

    • @braddishv3146
      @braddishv3146 11 місяців тому +1

      ^^^Yup, sadly I think this is just Halo: "Try" Season 2

    • @Mirthful_Midori
      @Mirthful_Midori 10 місяців тому

      This will be worse than Halo, since the Fallout how is supposed to be canon to the games too.

  • @zombielizard218
    @zombielizard218 11 місяців тому

    There's NCR flags in promotional images from the show, they're gonna feature

  • @istrumguitars
    @istrumguitars 11 місяців тому +2

    Very concerning that the settlements seem to be littered with heaps of garbage, that there’s no NCR in sight other than a random flag, and that the BoS is trying to “bring order to the wasteland” rather than pursuing their true goal (at least in the California chapters) of hoarding prewar technology.

  • @derrattenjunge
    @derrattenjunge 8 місяців тому

    In the new Trailer you can shortly see a NCR Flag carried to Battle against the Brotherhood in L.A.

    • @alexloponte7056
      @alexloponte7056 7 місяців тому +1

      It still doesn't make sense they have such power and resources

  • @mariolis
    @mariolis 9 місяців тому +2

    I just hope they explain this as the East Coast brotherhood leaving the Commonwealth after Fallour 4 , and coming to aid the West, they discover the ongoing war between the Brotherhood and the NCR and since the Brotherhood's main base is near LA, it would be a very good place to he the front line of that war
    They could also explain the NCR weakness by having the House or Yes Man endings of F:NV being cannon & for FO:4 I think the cannon ending would have to be the peaceful minutemen ending, where the brotherhood stays alive but since the minutemen help the Commonwealth rebuild and with the Brotherhood unwanted , that would explain why they would want to leave in the first place
    This might be me coping but I cant see any other way for them to not break established lore

  • @taliats
    @taliats 8 місяців тому +4

    This didn't age well
    NCR were confirmed

  • @AngelusNielson
    @AngelusNielson 11 місяців тому

    Don't freak out until you actually see the show. Trailers, literally by definition don't show everything.
    But then again how would you be able to have a clickbait title like that without hyperbole?

  • @holymelon8011
    @holymelon8011 11 місяців тому

    Wait till the show comes out, could be in mexico for all we know

  • @elementz301
    @elementz301 11 місяців тому +1

    NCR is confirmed by leaks and it matches the tone of the bethesda games exactly. People can complain about anything

  • @RadBrainZ
    @RadBrainZ 11 місяців тому +2

    Its one trailer. You think they'll show everything in the first trailer?

    • @gmanbergdorf7548
      @gmanbergdorf7548 11 місяців тому +2

      I’ve seen this point all over the internet
      Half of the trailer has no talking lmao
      People on the internet doing what they do

    • @TheMash-upChannel
      @TheMash-upChannel  11 місяців тому +1

      Like I said. I hope I'm wrong.

  • @nick15684
    @nick15684 11 місяців тому +1

    People bitching and complaining about not seeing the NCR in this trailer is wild honestly. As if it wasn't incredibly obvious that they are intentionally withholding showing that. All of California has already been settled by the NCR, as per Fallout NV lore. We've already seen an NCR flag in one of the leaked photos for Vault 33, so yes they're in the show.

  • @tkaki6029
    @tkaki6029 11 місяців тому

    So many dudes looking for reasons to hate this. It’s pathetic

  • @Jacob-ce7nh
    @Jacob-ce7nh 11 місяців тому +2

    Did you play fallout 1 & 2?

  • @enclaveleader6245
    @enclaveleader6245 11 місяців тому +1

    Where is the Enclave aswell. Always the Brotherhood

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому

      I think they are around in the West Coast, in Fallout 2 I think there was a warning that the oil rig is going to self destruct so there is plenty of warning to leave and why only a single squad just stands before the final boss. Most of them went east, but if there are not enough Vertibirds some are force to stay behind in functioning Vaults or bunkers.

    • @enclaveleader6245
      @enclaveleader6245 11 місяців тому

      @@Alex-pj8nz The Enclave are still out there I just know it probably regrouping after there defeat. There is rest of the United States some of which the Enclave has a bit of a foothold on parts of the US. The Enclave is out there but It’s all up to Bethesda now

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому

      @@enclaveleader6245 I think they will actually show up in the TV series or at least what’s left of them on the west coast, still doing war crime stuff. As for those in the east, they got beaten by the BOS and off somewhere licking their wounds or they are the ones pulling the strings on the BOS or at least a faction of the enclave which kind of explains why Maxson suddenly became imperialists.

  • @waterboi4846
    @waterboi4846 6 місяців тому

    every is gone... they murdered my boy

  • @adamek1503
    @adamek1503 10 місяців тому

    Safest ?!? Boy you didnt hear of arizona or what ?

  • @John_Thomas96
    @John_Thomas96 11 місяців тому +1

    No ncr? I thought the c stands for California? Which LA is the capital of. Also the show is set 219 years after the Great War so ncr should be thriving.

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому +1

      Capital of the NCR is Shady Sands not LA which is a blasted Nuclear wasteland full of rubble.

    • @John_Thomas96
      @John_Thomas96 11 місяців тому

      @@Alex-pj8nz the capital of California is LA, not ncr.

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому +1

      @@John_Thomas96 it’s Sacramento not LA.

    • @John_Thomas96
      @John_Thomas96 11 місяців тому

      @@Alex-pj8nz I don’t know anything I’m English!

    • @G-Mastah-Fash
      @G-Mastah-Fash 10 місяців тому

      @@Alex-pj8nz No the Boneyard is actually the financial center and most populous city of the NCR.

  • @gggMagggss
    @gggMagggss 11 місяців тому

    dude theres already a leaks images of ncr flags what do you mean no ncr?

  • @amarqzm5082
    @amarqzm5082 7 місяців тому

    Because Bethesda d rides the brotherhood lol

  • @theunepicdude
    @theunepicdude 11 місяців тому

    This show better not fuck with the west coast.

  • @NOTSabreSouls
    @NOTSabreSouls 11 місяців тому +2

    Simple bethesda touched the side of america that obsidian made and Bethesda is doing what they do best allowing Todd to fuck it up this show will be a failure

  • @barewitness2281
    @barewitness2281 8 місяців тому +1

    New trailer shows ncr fighting BOS I lost my mind

  • @serioussoldier7977
    @serioussoldier7977 11 місяців тому +2

    You should check out the vanity fair interview with the show runners, I’ve got a feeling ham fisted political points are going to be thrown around because what escapist entertainment doesn’t need more of that bs nowadays.

    • @icefarrow7959
      @icefarrow7959 11 місяців тому +2

      Jfc, clearly you've never actually played a Fallout game in your life, considering they're crampacked with political and capitalist commentary 💀

    • @vicemontey4297
      @vicemontey4297 10 місяців тому

      @@icefarrow7959 I think he was getting more at the
      "see we needed a Female character to be a male character to then act like a female character, but not really because she's actually trans and bi, but not really because she's not a she, but a they/them, but not really because they/them isn't real enough with modern trends so der/zer would be more accurate, but that would be too offensive for the DEI score so we instead changed it back to a female who has a male attitude, but retains some emotional restraints that are socially acceptable for DEI scores only to subvert everyone expectations by going deep into the mind of this character and creating a realm where everything and nothing ever happened only to then back out into the wider expanse and give a hard finger waving hand waving social commentary on how everyone watching is too stupid to understand how fascist they really are and how they are all Hitler because they aren't this godlike character we created for DEI score."
      That basically sums up what I think OP was getting at. So basically poorly written characters along with trash (and I mean trash like believing everybody is a fascist, misogynist/misandrist, homophobic and racist pig because they don't agree with you kind of trash) social commentary for the sake of investment ratings.

  • @CursedInEternity92
    @CursedInEternity92 11 місяців тому +1

    Honestly i hate people who still consume the content more than the people who nake this trash. Its trash because you will still watch it, play it, talk about it and make videos on it. You are the reason it sucks because you consume it even when its bad aa youre deaperate for anything. They use that addiction against you. If you watched even 1 episode of this or thought maybe there was a chance it was goingbto be good, youre the problem. They dont care about lore in the games. So why would the show care? Its a nerd show with a fallout skin and they are only making this because gaming in bigger than tv and movies now. Its trying to pander to you but not knowing whats acctually good about the lore. And you eat it right up. You people killed gaming and these franchizes, so pat yourself on the back neckbeard, you have nothing now.

  • @XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXZ
    @XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXZ 6 місяців тому

    So with the series now released I assume you feel like an idiot, don't you? I mean, NCR is a very big part of the series.

  • @desperado8960
    @desperado8960 7 місяців тому +4

    according to the show NV didn’t happen

  • @a-billz3737
    @a-billz3737 6 місяців тому

    Lol the show is good

  • @Noms_Chompsky
    @Noms_Chompsky 7 місяців тому

    Ha ha, you did assuming bad

  • @FelipeSalesGuitar
    @FelipeSalesGuitar 11 місяців тому

    I think they are going to make the NCR the bad guy of the series. Maybe they've become imperialistic like the Enclave. Hell, maybe the courier's interference set them on the path to a militaristic, opressor state, hellbent on conquest. Who knows

    • @chiefsean16
      @chiefsean16 11 місяців тому

      Tbf they're pretty imperialistic in NV.

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому

      @@chiefsean16 Well they are going to be more imperialist if they won at FNV after Mr house is killed by them. But I think Mr House won that one seeing that there is a Mr House Bot following an old NCR veteran ranger going after a bounty seeing that Yes man, the Legion and NCR has no idea to do programming for the Securitrons.

  • @brittaniekessler4576
    @brittaniekessler4576 11 місяців тому

    I understand what ppl are saying but this is the first fallout movie ever why can't ppl be happy about it

    • @G-Mastah-Fash
      @G-Mastah-Fash 10 місяців тому +2

      Because it'll suck. Mark my words.

    • @vicemontey4297
      @vicemontey4297 10 місяців тому +1

      See Rings of Power was the first major Tolkien live action TV show. Halo was the first major live action TV show with big budgets. How many more do we need to "give hope and have faith so just shove money" before we say hey "somethings fishy here"...

  • @lonewanderer2982
    @lonewanderer2982 11 місяців тому

    Bruh relax... Its just a teaser and not a full fledged trailer

  • @JakeRyanBooth
    @JakeRyanBooth 7 місяців тому

    The NCR was in the latest trailer.

  • @rafaelcooperdealmeida8511
    @rafaelcooperdealmeida8511 11 місяців тому

    It looks like you have to review the scripts of your videos. You start saying you are cautiously optimistic, but ends up saying you hope you are wrong and the show will be good. I mean, you either lie, changed opinion or have no clue how to sustain a simple 5 minute video logic. Looks like you slept through some classes in college.

  • @matthewflores4183
    @matthewflores4183 11 місяців тому +1

    It doesn't even break the lore what are you talking about bro?

    • @TheMash-upChannel
      @TheMash-upChannel  11 місяців тому +12

      No NCR. Brotherhood of steal having a presence in the LA area. Both break lore.

    • @commanderminh7402
      @commanderminh7402 11 місяців тому +1

      You never play New Vegas,right?

    • @braddishv3146
      @braddishv3146 11 місяців тому +1

      You've never actually played a Fallout game before have you?

    • @matthewflores4183
      @matthewflores4183 11 місяців тому

      @@TheMash-upChannel if you payed attention to the leaks you'd know that the BOS has been confirmed to be at a military base located in wendover which is in-between Utah and navada and you can even tell where the location is from the teaser because they actually filmed there. the NCR is obviously going to be in California and just cause they didn't show them in the teaser doesn't mean there not gonna show up. there is a leaked set photo of the NCR flag being used in a vault as well. nothing breaks the lore if you know who to go to to find your information

    • @alcor4670
      @alcor4670 11 місяців тому +3

      @@TheMash-upChannel If you've played Fallout 1, you'd know that Lost Hills was a BoS settlement to the north of Boneyard (also known as LA).
      And if the show's set in 2296, it'd mean that the show happens ~135 years after the events of Fallout 1. A _lot_ of things can happen in 13 decades, like the NCR-Brotherhood War in New Vegas.

  • @colonelherzog4316
    @colonelherzog4316 11 місяців тому

    Mabye, the enclave, were able to rebuild 5 and wiped out most of the ncr or something idk

    • @Alex-pj8nz
      @Alex-pj8nz 11 місяців тому

      In the trailer, there is a lady in vault 33 not wearing a Vault suit but a white dress when mass fighting took place there. I think she is enclave.

  • @iamanowl26
    @iamanowl26 11 місяців тому

    There is an NCR flag in one of the shots of the vaults. calm down