‘Done nothing in two years’: Bill Shorten ‘diagnosing problems’ without fixing them
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 чер 2024
- NIDS Minister Bill Shorten has “done nothing in two years”, says Shadow NDIS Minister Michael Sukkar.
“Two years he has been running around diagnosing problems with one minor detail - he is the minister who is actually able to make some changes,” Mr Sukkar told Sky News Australia.
“And he has done nothing in two years.”
This guy is possibly one of the worst
Bill isn’t that smart. I can’t believe the hardworking Australian taxpayers are having to fork out for his salary, perks, gravy train and the NDIS open to massive rorting.
not to mention his $300,000 / year speeches. My nephew needed a drug which cost that much which Labor kept denying to put on the PBS.
@@DJ-yj1vg I think you’ll find Bills speech writer was paid $600,000.
Bill looks like an out and out genius next to Albonazi though...
So is Aboriginal affairs and the dole is also being rorted not just the NDIS but let’s keep complaining yet fail to make all the other tax payers money with other groups who do exactly the same yet they are not under the microscope.
There are issues in both sides and both providers and participants have been involved with the way the NDIS has run with many participants thinking it is Centrelink money and have become entitled not trying to increase their capacity to improve their lives.
The NDIS is a program about building capacity in their lives not one to sit on their backsides to do nothing but many don’t understand program.
Bag O dirt Bill.
Labor promised everything and do nothing, always blaming the opposition.
He's the real NDIS thief how much is he getting paid to do nothing.
It isn't just hookers and drugs that need to be discussed, the pay rates charged to the NDIS by service providers is ridiculous.
Surely you don't expect him to fix anything he's too busy. Too busy blaming others
Don't call me Shirley!!!
And Albo has been driving in the car!
Bag of dirt Bill
It was clever of Albo to give Bill this portfolio.... it was never going to go well
I wonder what is more dangerous Shorten not doing anything in two years or Albo doing faulty policies causing the high inflation and terribly high costs of living Australians are currently enduring. .
Is there anything Labor can't fuckup???
0:33 0:35
Seems not 🫤
Just looked FXXX UP in the dictionary and found a photo of the whole "Labour" party!
Nope.
In Australia multiple furniture, bedding and appliances centres have NDIS stickers on their shop windows. Have a disability? New appliances, whatever new mattress you want even a $6,000 one, new furniture, new TV, appliances....whatever. Want a massage no problem. Want cooking lessons we provide that too. Want one on one fitness training no problem? Want holidays and overseas trips no issues. Want your garden done each month and pool cleaned, gutters cleaned, car washed and detailed, lawns mowed, a personal chauffeured vehicle no issues. NDIS is the worst train wreck of a scheme ever devised and makes pink batts look like a small blip
Not even true.
Oh yes it is. It's the rort that keeps on rorting!! It's not rocket science! I take it your own it?? @@Poorlineforeva
That's an exaggeration, I'm on NDIS, and it can take many knock backs and two years even to get a wheelchair
@helengormlie966 yes, he would be! 😂 The dole too.
@@grannyof12kids A customer of mine just got a 10m enclosed wheel chair access bridge from the road to the middle of their house, above the house.
There is a wheel chair elevator at the end of the walkway going down into the loungeroom.
I asked why and the answer was - They did it case my wife has to go into a wheel chair in the next few years.
Im not joking
How could anyone seriously expect Two Jets Albo and his motley crew to get anthing right when taxpayers money is concerned.
Ndis is so confusing, the disabled person doesn’t get one cent. All the money has been shared and split by nominees and agencies half and half. Very sad 😭
Pretty much
Dumb and Dumber combined, that’s Billy Boy!
Hasn't he hired a private consultant to help him with his speech at a cost of $600,000 of taxpayer money? And the NDIS has become a dog's breakfast under his watch.
Y has it taken this long to inform the people, I mean it’s been 2 F YEARS !!!!
Bc they’re 2 cheeks from the same @RSE
$620,000 for a speech writer! Why does he need a speech writer; doesn't he have a proper command of the English language?
@@Kelly-wf5ie
Ooooo k...
But it took the honesty of ALP to expose it ?
💩👉🤯
Pac Man
Fair Go , Bill is working in the NDIS. Cluster F , he’s asking his Speech Writer
Yeah, nice little income she gets
Why his speech writer is charging that much money that is paid by the taxpayers, this is unbelievable.
Absolute joke
Why can’t he write his own speeches, how the hell did he get the job
@@tlb2970 Exactly, might as well have you or I in there reading speeches.
Governer should sack the lot.
Oh that's right Labor supporter 😢
It will take a brave government to get the NDIS running properly because you will have every Harry handout whining
Tough
About time taxpayers get a break from this Labor failed scheme.
Whole new set of guidelines need to be drawn up, narrowing what is acceptable to be paid for by taxpayers.
A piece of equipment worth $100 is bought by the government NDIS for $1000.
That is being generous. I know one poor soul who got a $4500 hospital type bed. The provider charged $78,000 to the NDIS. There are expensive beds, sure, but this was an el-cheapo bed but they charged for a premium bed.
thank God this individual didn't get to the top job, can anyone name one Labor minister that is not incompetent.
No, now ask for a Labor premier that's not incompetent.
Sack albo now
3.........2..........1........... 🎣
😆😆😆
Labor are failures. They can't even satisfy their own supporters.
When nothing changes....that's how it ends 😊
I have to say, we have had tradesmen shortages for years.
Where are the schemes to put Australian people through trade apprenticeships.
Both sides of Government have failed miserably in this area.
Shorten, has done nothing, got script writers, rorts to ex staff, drugs ..wtf ?? 😮
it works like this. The NDIS pays $65.47 an hour to support people with disabilities. The agency then pays staff $30 an hour, pocketing the $35.47. The client gets half the services as the agency is keeping the other half to pay for houses and cars for the bosses of theses agencies.
I'm from the government and I'm here to help. Seems legit.
I call bullshit, Drugs, prostitutes and cars yes you are right but i bet a certain someone has a new yacht in the corruption 😂😂this is a cover.
NDIS is a mess, definitely. 🇺🇸🐖💯❤️🤗🌎🇦🇺👍 2:35
He has asked 3 questions though.Sure he would take his pay though.We are being dudded big time.😡😡😡
Labor don't have one solution for any problem. Just have a look at all the thing they have stuffed up since they have been in power. Australia is crippled by these goons.
BILL SHORTEN AND HIS SHONKY SCHEME .
Baaaad boy bill
The best of the best at the ALP/Greens/Teals
It's not too difficult to understand that as a politician, Shorten has been living on borrowed time. He no longer enjoys the confidence of his own party.
Bil Shorten can you please help, my husband is waiting to get his prosthetic legs , he wants to have normal” life. We want to live life ! We are waiting 5 + years for him to have his life back.
That’s the Labor party standard …. give a lot of promises, get into power, do nothing, cost a squillion, tell no-one anything and tell us how well they’re doing. We all have first hand knowledge of rorts while genuine others are living awful lives waiting.
One of the issues is that clients also have mental health challenges.
So plan managers are just authorising payments rather than deal with the tantrums from clients..
Thats the problem right there - only for ppl with disabilities? What constitutes disability? And tax payers paying for prostitutes???? you've got to be kidding.
Shorty Shorten's another politician, like Casanova Bowen. They make an absolute mess of everything they touch.
He's not allowed to fix anything. To his credit he seems ashamed.
Bill Shorten has Labor DNA approach, pretand you are doing something but accually doing nothing, definitely
Incompetence or something else???🇺🇸🐖💯❤️🤗🌎🇦🇺👍 5:11
Poor old Bill. He's still sulking over loss of the ALP leadership to turkey neck Albanese. He keeps talking about changes and fixes but it just keeps rolling along as the money pit it has always been.
I would have though that he would have had a shot of giving Turkey Neck the big heave ho by now.
Imagine getting ousted by Albanese, would be hard to get over.
I doubt anyone ever thought ALbo would be PM
NSW health staff is being ripped off.
NDIS is a fantastic idea, BUT, as usual any Labor policy will not be executed by them. Pink Batts, cash for clunkers,wind and solar. NDIS needs a good sweep out and looking into providers, . Per hour rate on some specialists is 40-60% higher through NDIS than a private client or customer.
This government isn’t listening to anyone the most people keep telling the Labor that the scheme isn’t working and needs to change.
I NEED TO GET ON THIS SCHEME... HAPPY DAYS, HOOKERS, DRUGS, PROBABLY BOOZE..
Bill Shorten will parrot the ALP echo chamber led by Anfony Albanese….”Peter Dutton”….
Sex, drugs and pocketin' dole.
All my brain and body need...
Just when you think things can't get any more stupider, BS starts to try and sound sensible.
Why don't you discuss the Digital ID bill getting rammed through parliament?
Done nothing in two years BUT still blames the Libs!!!
Bill the bag of dirt.
Hey Mick don’t U mean , “ we’ve, got NO responsibility, we’re just the corporation “, bc OZ doesn’t have a gov
Two double lung transplants, 4 crushed discs. Severed quad tendon. 60 percent lung capacity just tore the tendon on my bicep and I’m hospital for three weeks with right heart failure and still can’t get on the Ndis bill shorten sucks
Go see a disability advocate or a community centre worker with experience putting together applications. They will be able to aid you in getting the right evidence in the right formate. Often people with severe health problems miss out because they don’t make the effect on their day to day functioning crystal clear. The other problem is you need to demonstrate that there are no treatments available that will correct the condition. For example you need to show how you can’t do cleaning or self care tasks. You also need to show for example that there is no surgery options that will reasonably fix your back. I am not an expert, but this is my understanding.
Shorten is a Master at the blame game whilst at the same time uttering I have it all under control as NDIS becomes unsustainably expensive as criminal syndicates rort NDIS schemes
And Shorten answers "the party is over," Mr Shorten the rorters are those who are on the NDIS or Labor voting NDIS providers
Bullshit Bill, created the Problem and Now He's going to Fix His Own Mess ......Yeh Right !
Non-disclosure agreements. Don't Labor say they're transparent?
Who rorts the system? Michael Sukkar doesn’t say. Surely not the disabled tenants, doubtful it’s not the the property developers although they, in some cases, receive an astronomical 100,000 pa per apartment which contains one bedroom for the disabled person and one for a carer -100m2 in area. A lot of money too much .
It must be the property managers/ service providers but in a small minority. I mean prostitution and drugs seems beyond belief.
The big issue sadly is the NDIS can’t be substantiated in the medium term. The expense to the budget is off the chart and Shorten knows it.
I tell you about this massive problem as one of my family is this care and it is absolutely ridiculous and shocking. Even we’re shocked. Horrible as it can be.
Rotting system NDIS it is.
Start at the bottom and find out just what qualifies a person for NDIS funding. According to Centerlink a drug or alcohol addiction is classed as a disability for the purposes of claiming a disability pension. Also inmates who have served 5 years or more and are released are also classed as disabled because they will have difficulty adjusting to society. These are not disabilities. Providers need to be qualified and funding only used for these services. Un-licensed or un-qualified providers should be banned immediately. Qualified providers should only be able to invoice the NDIS and be audited for services provided and the cost. Purchasing drugs, alcohol, sex worker services or even holidays etc are not an appropriate use of public money.
It was te registered, "qualified" providers who were claiming for services they didn't provide when I was plan managed. I would report the invoices as no service provided and get told there was nothing they could do about it. The biggest problem is much higher up than small self managed funds. As a person in a wheelchair I can't get a ramp to my front door and a shower every day funded but if I get a anxiety or depression diagnosis I can get all sorts of stuff. I just want well fitted wheelchairs, an accessible car, an accessible home and the minimum carers I can get away with. If I want a holiday I will save up for one like everyone else. Like a lot of people I can't afford to buy a house and have to rent. The reason given for not funding a ramp is I might have to move and that is a waste of taxpayers money.
2 year he’s a butterfly flys around and dose fuck all wish I was on his salary 27 years working for a company and you worked hard for
your weekly wage
When I had a relation in the state based disability system, it was run as tight as a drum, except when Pollies interfered, of course. Now I'd doubt that the supervision of the NDIS is in the hands of empire builders, not staff keen on rooting out rorts and prosecuting criminal misuse of money. The NDIS should supply only basic supports for living, specialist therapies, special equipment, minor home modifications ( no elevators), and limited boondoggles like holidays, and those only in the home state, perhaps every three years at most.
Extra 300,000 dollars a year on spin still won't fix it.
Actually 620 000 for 2 year contract with services australia @@trevorbramich4849
The 450 million spent on ALBOS voice referendum could have gone into the NDIS ,,,, This Labor government like the NDIS is financially out of control!!
The whole NDIS is a joke, there are real honest genuine people in need of assistance and don't get it, it all goes to the ones who know the system haven't got anything wrong with them and milk it for everything they can, then there are the scammeres
The answer is sooooo simple. Make everyone plan managed so no-one gets cash.
Why doesn't the Government run the NDIS like the Aged Care scheme. Under this scheme the recipient is allocated a package dependent on the disability/ how frail the recipient is so they can get what they need. Each person chooses a provider but the big difference is that every purchase has to be approved and 'passed' by the provider. Most purchases need the input of an O.T. or a letter from the person's doctor to say that they would benefit from this purchase. The scheme seems to work quite well and there is little chance of rorting so it's value for money and keeps the recipient in their own home.
It is Sort of run like that, however, do not forget the absolute mess the aged care system is in, too
While the participants get told to like it or leave!!!
Useless comes to mind.
Labor 👎
CAP the NDIS. They CAP EMDG and many other schemes. So cap the NDIS at $20 Billion a year indexed to CPI.
Waste of space
NDIS great deal for 620K jobs part time, drugs cars etc on the taxs payers thank you Australia. Started by J Gillard if I think back, but Labor blames any one else for the failings, "not my fault Shorton", FIX IT that is your job not to blame .
go to PARIS with OLD MATE ALBO it cant get any worse" on the way you 2 truthbenders run this joint! swing by scicily and find out how to rule and run a country!
Hi Sky , as stated by the Shadow NDIS Minister that all types of illegal drugs are being purchased & used , my Q. has the AFP been notified of this illegal activity - if not why not .
So the HEAD of this illegal drug supplying activity will be getting jail time right ? right ? , cheers ( Aussie ) Phil .
No surprises there from labor
Is this story a put up by Albo Wong and Bandt to discredit Bill to try to ward off the inevitable challenge?
NDIS doesn't need a budget of 40 billion. It just needs to stop the rorts and spend efficiently and with strict oversight. Paying for sex workers is definitely on on. Do they know how many normal people don't get sex? What makes people with disabilities any different?
Except pilfering.
Short stop.
there is no doubt that food is being taken of the table for families though taxation and spent far less beneficially by the ndis and its participants
Sunset the NDIS
If NDIS has more accountability and responsibility would be much more affordble to rest of us, people with disabilities, definitely 🇺🇸🐖💯❤️🤗🌎🇦🇺👍 8:04
Try really having serious disabilities that you care for & imagine how hard it is, I could tell you we have 2, it's full on, he is a failure
Which drug is he accessing from his case worker?
Mainstream media has reported heroin & ice
Sadly Bill has failed the NDIS again and we still have issues on all sides that are doing the wrong with the NDIS. If they continually want to cut the NDIS then aboriginal affairs and the dole need to also be cut as you cannot complain about one system that has issues and not fix the others that also get drugs, smokes , tattoos etc with tax payers money.
Hi Sky , be thankful ( not ) that Shorten is only in charge of this NDIS gravy train that he designed - don't forget he nearly became Prime Minister- what a very big gravy train ( don't worry peasants we have ALBO to look after our best interest - right ? right ? ) these jerks need to go .
Governor General do your job & remove these Machiavellian Politicians otherwise GG stand yourself down , cheers ( Aussie ) Phil .
NDIS rort
Take a long term unemployed crook, give them free training in disability support , ..
What have you done in2 Njyears between. Bill Shorten. Nothing. You’ll never be PM.
If your in a wheel chair,,,,you should get a cleaner,,,, gardener,,,,,,money for taxis,,,,,,looking for,,,,,now you Decide
Not all disabilities require a wheelchair
ROBODEBT ROYAL COMMISSION
That's not important to normal people, Shaun. Keep squealing though.
A problem can’t truly be fixed, a problem is already fixed, existence is an inevitable process of creation and destruction, nothing is truely perpetual in its individual aspect of motion, eventually everything will return to raw electron and be turned into new matter, in theory.
The NDIS might have been a noble idea in the first place. But the way it's structured is open to massive fraud. And Shorten is a political creature who still thinks he is the smartest guy in the room but would not last five minutes in the private sector, where if you don't bring in results you are out. Shorten is very good at fixing nothing.
Every scheme Labor has put in place gets rorted, vis pink batts,free set top boxes and tv antennas, some very big companies,get poorly or not qualified people who are actively looking to rort the system for themselves and put more money in the boss pocket
I was asked to come on board for the tv jobs, and declined as I am not 7
:06 WA7:06 caa
WTF
Sounds to me that the best way to sort out the NDIS is to scrap it. If you are genuinely disabled...surely the welfare system ought help look after you!!
That hurts the oness that desperately, genuinely need the help. And no, the welfare system doesn't help nearly enough
@@daralee936 I thought I said that if someone needs it, the welfare system OUGHT...and should help them!!!! The way the NDIS currently is is a scam!!!
I will give Shorten the benefit , and I think he can cut the cost back. I have a son on NDIS, and he is high needs now after hospitalisation for 5,5 months , but has a very small plan compared to some I know hat are a lot better off than our son.
The NDIS is absolutely life changing and I wish people would stop labelling the whole scheme as dodgy. Most of these journalists and armchair experts have no idea on the subject and just regurgitate unsubstantiated claims as fact.
They are facts but they are admitting these facts because worse is going on within the NDIS, this them covering this them covering thier behinds.
There's ALOT worse going on behind the scenes that hopefully one day will be revealed to the average Australian.
Kind of like Gina ‘Australian of the year’
Who on earth did that
He was a very poor quality choice to put in a horse race and expect to win
Backing the wrong horse again hey
Please worship the CREATOR OF THE UNIVERSE, THE LORD GOD and try not to worry too much about the differences between the different religions and denominations, try to think about the similarities and the things they may have in common more than the differences. Daily prayer is a fundamental part that many people do not practice although it is encouraged
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
"CREATOR OF THE UNIVERSE, LORD GOD, I beg you to never force me to worship any false god or object and I ask you for forgiveness for my sins and immorality. Thank you for everything. Amen."
Please pray this now, pray the words as you read them if you cannot look and remember them
Your a 🌰
NDIS funds spent on drugs and alcohol, that's better than wasting funds i suppose.
He is on ndis for big pay outs shorton is a fool