Voice Teacher and Opera Stage Director reacts & analyzes Ariana Grande vs SoHyang Singing same songs

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 128

  • @dulanjala
    @dulanjala 5 років тому +155

    this is very unfair comparison, Love Ariana, But SoHyang's in another level of her own... one of the best of the world...

  • @pickin4you
    @pickin4you 5 років тому +101

    So Hyang is the best I have heard in my 58 years. She is like Whitney, Celine, and Mariah all rolled into one, with a tad better technique.

  • @39murfy
    @39murfy 5 років тому +191

    So Hyang is the best!!!!

  • @eddianproject
    @eddianproject 5 років тому +11

    This lady could sing her weekly shopping list and I would have goosebumps she is simply awesome.
    Thank you So Hyang my ears have been blessed.

  • @robertmyers7383
    @robertmyers7383 5 років тому +46

    Ariana obviously is a super talented young singer but So Hyang is in her own league.

  • @mcthejiwoo
    @mcthejiwoo 5 років тому +16

    So hyang i want

  • @gentleman4491
    @gentleman4491 5 років тому +5

    Thank you for your interesting video.😂
    Sohyang is the most pure and emotional voice's singer in the world I've ever heard.

  • @Big12rocks
    @Big12rocks 5 років тому +171

    Unfair “competition” for Ariana. Sohyang is the best in the world!

    • @noemi6664
      @noemi6664 5 років тому +5

      baspringer true ☝️

    • @esthere.3754
      @esthere.3754 5 років тому +4

      Amen.

    • @Teeeeooo
      @Teeeeooo 5 років тому +4

      I dont think Sohyang is the best ...😒

    • @fearlessyuk
      @fearlessyuk 5 років тому +8

      @@Teeeeooo Well, number 1 can be personal pick. But Sohyang is definitely one of the best. May be the best of best.

    • @Teeeeooo
      @Teeeeooo 5 років тому

      BUZZ LIGHTYEAR for a lot of people she isn’t the best one ..... for me her voice just sounds ugly :/

  • @joem9987
    @joem9987 5 років тому +86

    Love em both! SoHyang is a master vocalist and has been singing for almost as long as Ariana has been alive so I would expect her to be more polished and controlled in her technique. She is truly one of the best in the world. You can also watch her older videos and see how she has progressed over the years. Ariana is so talented has many years ahead of her to grow and perfect her craft. Looking forward to watching her for a long time to come. Great reaction and assessment!

  • @mangchiy2382
    @mangchiy2382 5 років тому +18

    I love sohyang ♡♡

  • @ushdbrr1293
    @ushdbrr1293 5 років тому +58

    SoHyang is not human
    She is not an ordinary singer.
    She expresses the song lyrics in her voice and impresses the listener.
    I think she is one of the best singers in the world.

    • @DarrenHazel
      @DarrenHazel 5 років тому

      US HDbrr she is a human.

  • @brucelee2871
    @brucelee2871 5 років тому +29

    Oh ! As expected, So Hyang is the world's best singer ! Although Ariana Grande is a very good singer, So Hyang is the next level artist. I think So Hyang is out of this world ! I hope you watch the videos of So Hyang's amazing performances from beginning to end. Many thanks for your truly nice reaction. From the U.S.

  • @hetache07
    @hetache07 5 років тому +24

    Of Course The Queen SOHYANG

  • @fetraramamonjy5004
    @fetraramamonjy5004 5 років тому +9

    So hyang is the best

  • @abdieldelarosa9964
    @abdieldelarosa9964 5 років тому +42

    Love them both...but I prefer Sohyang my queen

  • @garysimcox345
    @garysimcox345 5 років тому +78

    i love that strong vibrato in sohyang’s “i will always love you”... she’s technically superior to my ears 😌

    • @chronicle6861
      @chronicle6861 5 років тому

      Gary Simcox lol Ariana was better there🥺

  • @쿠킹마마-g7d
    @쿠킹마마-g7d 5 років тому +8

    Thank you~~~
    So yhang's an angel~ :)

  • @skylerpowers8871
    @skylerpowers8871 5 років тому +105

    So Hyang is definitely the technically superior vocalist. Better support and resonance among many other skills, but she’s also much older and has taken many years to perfect her voice. Thus, I would say most of her covers were better, as well as more artistically original and unique. Sohyang makes every song her own while Ariana tends to stick to the original arrangement. Ariana is still very talented though and probably had a better Emotions cover due to her more reliable access to the whistle register.

    • @angelo-pl9kt
      @angelo-pl9kt 5 років тому +1

      Skyler Ariana did not use a whistle tone in this clip, head voice only.

    • @skylerpowers8871
      @skylerpowers8871 5 років тому

      angelo I know, but she still whistles in that particular cover, even if it wasn’t shown here

    • @TwsWithSai247
      @TwsWithSai247 5 років тому

      angelo that was whistle tone

    • @cloroxbleach1342
      @cloroxbleach1342 5 років тому +2

      Of Course So Hyang will be a technical vocalist. She was inspired by Mariah Carey ❤️

    • @bstb1958
      @bstb1958 5 років тому

      whistle register is a novelty no true vocalist will use it often, it can damage the vocal chorrds

  • @andrewpark1769
    @andrewpark1769 5 років тому +15

    I like So Hyang better

  • @saraiyaicate3640
    @saraiyaicate3640 5 років тому +74

    SoHyang is my favourite vocal singer ever!!

  • @afrojack5689
    @afrojack5689 5 років тому +82

    react to more so hyang !!!

  • @juliekeesee3499
    @juliekeesee3499 5 років тому +29

    I'll give you credit for trying to hide it 😂

  • @ChrisPhamQ
    @ChrisPhamQ 5 років тому +2

    Dr. Marc Reynolds even though you refused to say who is the favorite, your body language (in round 3) tells me that you couldn't bear to listen to Ariana straining those high notes anymore and you had that big smile on your face when Sohyang sung.

  • @piyagi0705
    @piyagi0705 5 років тому +8

    Sorry Ariana... Sohyang... wins...ㅠㅠ

  • @pamrenee6906
    @pamrenee6906 5 років тому +53

    The Whole Worlds favorite is Sohyang 😇🎤🤷‍♀️

  • @jhyounyo
    @jhyounyo 5 років тому +3

    Ariana is good but SoHyang is a legend.

  • @jenniferelliott3101
    @jenniferelliott3101 5 років тому +29

    Hands down. So Hyang is more consistent. 🙌🏼

  • @davidlaughs3144
    @davidlaughs3144 5 років тому +30

    I love Ariana she is my queen 👸 but everyone know that nobody can sing like Sohyang

  • @0101-g8j
    @0101-g8j 4 роки тому +2

    소향에 걸맞는 상대를 데려 와야지. 너무 차이나니 이건 누가 들어도...

  • @choo1030
    @choo1030 5 років тому +11

    To be fair, Ariana is still young compared to Sohyang. Im sure she will improve.

  • @MinuDeIcaza
    @MinuDeIcaza 5 років тому +1

    I am having SoHyang’s withdrawal syndrome 😢so I will comment ... as for this one Dr Mark, I would humbly point out diction... an unfair comparison since you would think Grande would beat Sohyang in a Hands-down-no-contest manner yet I find Sohyan’s pronunciation and enunciation to be better. As always thank you Dr. Mark I am always grateful.

    • @DrMarcReynolds
      @DrMarcReynolds  5 років тому +1

      Oh man! If that’s what I communicated that’s not what I think. I think they are so different that saying one is better than the other is impossible. My personal preference is to listen to SoHyang. Again - not better or worse just more to my taste. Hopefully I will get another Sohyang video up soon. I’m slowing down the quantity of my videos because I want to improve the quality and because other projects are demanding more of my attention. Thank you for watching and for commenting!

    • @MinuDeIcaza
      @MinuDeIcaza 5 років тому

      Dr. Marc Reynolds DR Mark Hello😊 I am so honored for your comment, thank you so much. I look forward to another Sohyang’s performance and your reaction to it, could you react to her song Fate on I am Singer2? I would love to listen to your reaction to the stage and her presence the song is not as challenging but her vocals are beautiful in it’s simplicity. As usual may you continue your successful presence here I will continue watching and enjoying. (All but BTS... not a fan😣😣🤣

  • @instasingingvids3529
    @instasingingvids3529 5 років тому +8

    Pls react t Sohyang everyone if you haven’t already

  • @hanakim2993
    @hanakim2993 Рік тому

    수많은 리액터들이 소향에게 열광하는 이유를 생각해보멘

  • @cbs710815
    @cbs710815 5 років тому +13

    소향은 현존하는 세계 최고등급의 가수입니다.
    보다 많은 사람들에게 알려지길 바랍니다.
    Singer Sohyang is the best singer in the world.I hope to be more known than now.

  • @dailylifeofanything399
    @dailylifeofanything399 5 років тому +7

    Sohyang def more mature and controlled voice. Consistent. Ariana has strains going high and runs out of breath quick. Not hatin. Just telling what i hear

  • @brittag.pedersen5340
    @brittag.pedersen5340 5 років тому +44

    💗💗💗💗SOHYANG!!!!!💗💗💗💗

  • @hans052163
    @hans052163 5 років тому +26

    She is a queen in her 40s and a queen in her 20s.👸🏽👸🏽💕🎤🎵🎶

  • @DarrenHazel
    @DarrenHazel 5 років тому +17

    Their vocal ratings :
    Sohyang: ⭐️ (G#3-C#6-E6)
    Ariana G: A- (F#3-Eb5)

  • @stevebuckskinner5482
    @stevebuckskinner5482 5 років тому +7

    No contest. Sohyang hands down. Now that's not taking anything away from Ariana Grande. She is a very talented singer. She's just not as good.

  • @stoneshack2000
    @stoneshack2000 5 років тому +39

    So hyang no doubt about it, you could read that with Braille, thank you Marc..

  • @carolannelabellekarlin440
    @carolannelabellekarlin440 5 років тому +1

    You nailed it! That's my first listen to both...it seemed to me that Ariana wasn't as relaxed with her instrument. 😅😎your refusal to choose the better voice reminded me of Dimash getting asked what kind of girl he likes and his answer was "it's a secret!" SMART YOU TWO!!❤

  • @afrojack5689
    @afrojack5689 5 років тому +30

    slayhyanggg

  • @nyuws
    @nyuws 4 роки тому +1

    Good video 👍

  • @Panorama-memory
    @Panorama-memory 4 роки тому

    To be honest...
    korea ...
    any karaoke in town has ariana grade...
    kiddiing?
    you can see many korea amature singer in youtube

  • @zetzu6460
    @zetzu6460 5 років тому +9

    showing 18 year old ariana isn’t making it fair. and also the fact they picked the worse clips and the worst parts. sohyang is better but this isn’t a good comparison

  • @asdzxc12334
    @asdzxc12334 5 років тому +9

    SOHYANG!!!!!

  • @kely1482
    @kely1482 4 роки тому +2

    비교대상 자체가 잘못된거다. 나도 아리나라 좋아하는데. 이건 마치 비보이와 체조선수를 비교하는 격이야. 그리고 다 봐놓고 내가 누굴 좋아하는지 말을 안 한다니. 백인우월주의자 티내냐?

  • @Price_of_Fame
    @Price_of_Fame 5 років тому +21

    oof, whoever made that video picked bad clips for both of them (outside of Sohyang's I Have Nothing). Not really worth comparing.

  • @aiongaiong6237
    @aiongaiong6237 5 років тому

    Can you do a reaction to brooke fraiser?

  • @홍대광-d7l
    @홍대광-d7l 5 років тому +5

    so hyang win.....

  • @pricelollil
    @pricelollil 5 років тому +28

    Those videos are not from the era which So Hyang's vocal shine on the top.

  • @denabach
    @denabach 5 років тому +6

    They picked the worst versions of their performances for these songs to compare.

  • @111-i6c
    @111-i6c 5 років тому +1

    im fan of both great singers but its a bit stuffs that cause misconceptions of two its not enough to explain two singers in one clip especially sohyang(considering Arian is known worldwide)

  • @tunamusic6540
    @tunamusic6540 5 років тому +1

    To me So Hyang more rich and clear. Ariana is very gifted singer but she has some intonation problems. I think Jessie J vs So Hyang would be fair. I love Jessie performance. I love So Hyang too.

  • @andreymussr7988
    @andreymussr7988 5 років тому +1

    Please analyze performance Diana Ankudinova - Wicked Game. You never heard such a voice like she have. She is only 15 y.o.

  • @리플-e8k
    @리플-e8k 4 роки тому

    어디다 뭘 비교해.
    소향님 제가 대신 사과드립니다.

  • @brownie3275
    @brownie3275 5 років тому

    I don't know why I feel like majority of Ariana's voice is located in her head/nose. Like way up compared to Sohyang.

  • @wg4716
    @wg4716 5 років тому +2

    Hi Dr Marc Reynolds, can you please please please react to EXO’s Chen & Beakhyun ‘s ‘Really I didn’t know’ live performances?
    Both Chen & Beakhyun are amazing and talented main vocalist from the famous Korea boy group. I hope you can give some opinion. I am really impressed by that performance.
    Also, EXO’s Exo’rdium concert in Seoul -Acoustic Medley performance. You can analyse each of their members’ vocal abilities. Thank you very much.

    • @wg4716
      @wg4716 5 років тому

      By the way, I think So Hyang is more powerful n better control. But Ariana is awesome too!

  • @R.C.Bullar
    @R.C.Bullar 5 років тому +6

    Do you have any techniques on helping your speaking voice more easily blend in to your singing? As in like, just speaking healthier and not getting a sore throat from talking a lot. Would love to hear your ideas :)

  • @wannabedavid147
    @wannabedavid147 5 років тому +7

    You're a Solomon! :) As one of her fans, I LOVE Sohyang, of course.

  • @TheBongReyes
    @TheBongReyes 5 років тому +7

    Sohyang is just a beast. Unfair to compare her to 99.9% of singers. Only a handful of singers are on the same level of greatness as Sohyang.

  • @hjban2977
    @hjban2977 5 років тому

    Thanks for not making it as competition & turn it into healthy learning tutorials! I hate those people Who requests a reaction of “who is better than who” video! People should just enjoy their music as they are because as you said they both are amazing singer with two different beautiful voices.
    FYI: I hate that most of the SoHyang Live performance Videos are from Korean singing competition shows & some of the people only know SoHyang as singer who can sing higher notes but she is truly amazing singer because her abilities to immerses in that song & pass that emotion to the audience through her singing so beautifully!
    If you are planning to do another Kpop reaction, I would really like to request your review & analysts of .
    This is Award show performances & the first 2 performances is impressive but the 3rd Intro+Idol performance is so amazing, a lot of people call “BTS’s epic performances”.
    As you are the Opera Stage Director, your professional point of view will be greatly appreciated & helpful to those who are in on an entertainment/theatre/music business or studying to becomes one. Also I am sure you would like to share your professional point of understanding & view with your other subscribers as well!
    This live Award show was world wide televised last Dec.01.2018 & BTS team worked extra hard (BTS performances are always more specially these Award shows) to make this special performance possible & it amazes a lot of people worldwide who doesn’t know BTS as well & some of them become fans because of this show.
    BTS performance is 20mins of intro+2songs+into+idol performances, So you can ether chooses full performances or just the Idol performance clip.
    And as a typical BTS performance, they’ve put a lot of meaningful details with in their performance but this time they’ve explained what kind of Korean traditional cultures they’ve put in to their one of the popular song < Idol> & < Idol music video> to their fans all over the world who is not familiar with Korean cultures through their performances. So in case you want to know details background information of their performance, there is explained video clip in English as well.
    Also there is < Idol> music video clip as well.
    FYI: As these Award shows pay equal amount money to each song to performance budget & BTS paid extra to make this performance to shows pieces of Korean cultures to their fans all over the world.
    BTS >. ua-cam.com/video/pBuZEGYXA6E/v-deo.html
    >. ua-cam.com/video/ayGl-igrwy8/v-deo.html
    >- ua-cam.com/video/zPEiY65fkko/v-deo.html
    .
    ua-cam.com/video/TA5X24c2FhI/v-deo.html

  • @lingokim8502
    @lingokim8502 5 років тому +6

    Love ur reaction! I think you'll like too.
    Please react to "Forestella-Bohemian Rhapsody" :)

  • @pamrenee6906
    @pamrenee6906 5 років тому +7

    3 things here. I'm not sure how you intend to help with shower singing 🤔😳🎤🤷‍♀️
    It's not fair to others to be compared to The Heavenly Diva 🎤😇
    In addition, Arianna is supposedly a native English speaker.😅

    • @juliekeesee3499
      @juliekeesee3499 5 років тому

      That straw could be dangerous around water 😂😂

    • @whatthell
      @whatthell 5 років тому

      I see you deleted your comment on my thread but I can still read it. I was just talking about who is a 'better singer' in terms of techniques, something that it seems like you really really like to talk about. I am sorry to break your bubble but in terms of breath support and overall 'techniques' Sohyang does not come close to Jo Sumi. You must not know Jo Sumi's reputations as an opera singer. She's a living legend. Comparing her to Sohyang is like comparing Pavarotti to David Phelps. In reality, pop singers does not come close to a good technique comparing to opera singers in terms of support. They all scream. The only competitors of the modern opera singer are the old opera singer in the gold period.

    • @pamrenee6906
      @pamrenee6906 5 років тому +1

      I'd rather hear Sohyang yawn. 🎤🤷‍♀️

    • @whatthell
      @whatthell 5 років тому

      @@pamrenee6906 Yeah because you are a FAN. But I am strictly talking about techniques because the these VS videos are about techniques.

    • @pamrenee6906
      @pamrenee6906 5 років тому +1

      @@whatthell i already said it wasn't fair to the other people. 🤷‍♀️

  • @mikek1635
    @mikek1635 5 років тому

    I win.

  • @kristianp.405
    @kristianp.405 5 років тому

    Try reacting to Nightwish, Ghost love score Live @ Wacken 2013 or Nightwish, The poet and the pendulum Live @ Wembley arena London ☀️😱🤗

  • @choo1030
    @choo1030 5 років тому

    Ariana Grande no longer sings in high notes like she used to. Such a shame.

  • @周恩牧
    @周恩牧 5 років тому

    please react to 袁娅维-开往春天的地铁 and Youn Sun Nah - Momento Magico

  • @싼프란시스코-u9h
    @싼프란시스코-u9h 5 років тому +11

    Sohyang win

  • @그냥그래그냥
    @그냥그래그냥 4 роки тому

    뭐래요?

  • @R.C.Bullar
    @R.C.Bullar 5 років тому

    Not the best examples of Ariana. However your points are correct.

    • @Hdhshshs-el2h
      @Hdhshshs-el2h 5 років тому +6

      You think those were good examples for sohyang tho? Lmao. Her vocal peak is now. Those were old performances

    • @R.C.Bullar
      @R.C.Bullar 5 років тому +1

      Mark CC true!
      But I feel her voice sounds relatively the same. Her technique has been spot on for years and she is definitely only improving as well. And I love her sound! Don’t hear me wrong. A straight up angels voice.
      But I prefer the tone of Ariana(mainly for her ear for phrasing and artistry) and she has improved immensely in my opinion now.
      If their phrasing was reversed, I would prefer So Hyang. Both amazing for different genres and truly top level vocalists

  • @dandychopper
    @dandychopper 5 років тому +6

    I think Ariana is a great POP singer.
    And So-hyang is a great textbook of singer.

  • @samuelkim3203
    @samuelkim3203 5 років тому +2

    both are equally talented

  • @Ali-sf1rj
    @Ali-sf1rj 5 років тому +2

    please react to Mariah Carey vocal range (by mariahxlambily)

  • @hyperloid2143
    @hyperloid2143 5 років тому

    End of the day..... Ariana still the 👑 ......why hmmmm... You know the answer.....

  • @focushuman1816
    @focushuman1816 5 років тому +3

    Ariana Grande is out of tune and lack of breath.

    • @taskhn
      @taskhn 5 років тому

      theseare here worst clips

  • @jamesbee-xg2ss
    @jamesbee-xg2ss 5 років тому +1

    SoHyang hands down!

    • @jamesbee-xg2ss
      @jamesbee-xg2ss 5 років тому

      Minah
      Why is it rude? Just my opinion! Btw I like Grande as well!

    • @jamesbee-xg2ss
      @jamesbee-xg2ss 5 років тому

      Minah
      Why is it childish to have an honest opinion?

    • @jamesbee-xg2ss
      @jamesbee-xg2ss 5 років тому

      And it's not disrespectful either, I respect both their talents but I just like Sohyang’s a lot better!

  • @DarrenHazel
    @DarrenHazel 5 років тому +1

    Technique: sohyang definitely lmao
    Tone: theres no Competition here. Ariana all the way. Sohyang is too “shouty sounded” “twangy” but still... Issa personal choice.

  • @조국대통령만들기운동
    @조국대통령만들기운동 5 років тому

    해석이 필요함

  • @birisinden
    @birisinden 5 років тому

    Sir, when I look at your video list, I see 50 videos named 'Voice Teacher and Opera Stage Director reacts to and analyzes...'. Analyzes What? We can't understand it because youtube doesn't show more than 60 characters under video thumbnails. Half of your video thumbnail shows your face. So you're advertising yourself. But we are not buying you. We are looking for reaction videos about singers we like. When we can't see them, their names, faces, song name etc. we don't click.
    Why I'm telling this? Because I like to listen to your knowledge-based opinion. I want to click.

  • @blakejohnson9498
    @blakejohnson9498 5 років тому +4

    They literally put the worst of Ariana

  • @Rosannasfriend
    @Rosannasfriend 5 років тому +2

    I believe Ariana Grande does a better job with her jaw tension nowadays.

  • @sosolulua9327
    @sosolulua9327 5 років тому

    도무지....이런거는 왜하시는지

  • @dinookumape3220
    @dinookumape3220 5 років тому

    sohyang is old....react to ariana nd morissette....thts a good fight how morissette will eat ariana,......hhhhhhhhh

  • @kely1482
    @kely1482 4 роки тому

    나도 소향까에 속하지만 아리아나를 비비는건 좀 역하네. 퍼포먼스형 가수를 소향한테 들이대냐... 에휴~

  • @steveheckle8847
    @steveheckle8847 Рік тому

    You will learn nothing from Ariana Grande because shes nothing i haven't heard a million times before, SOHYANG on the other hand is in a league all of her own 🇬🇧🔥👌❤️

  • @goldyun-u3j
    @goldyun-u3j 4 роки тому +4

    Of Course The Queen SOHYANG