Did you even watch season 3? Celestia explained why starswirl didn't become an alicorn despite all the achievements he made because he didn't realized how friendship magic works which led to his extinction. And then there's twilight saving their butt off.
@ClintonJayLintua It's because he's a dude, cozyglow doesn't really get friendship,but manipulation. As girl power show a male alicorn wasn't going to happen
@@christovalfloria8542I could explain it, According to my theory, A pony becomes an alicorn when they have created a new type of magic. Suppose Celestia raising the sun, Luna rasing the moon, Cadence Love, and Twilight, of course, Friendship. So while Starlight Glimmer was over-achieving she didn't create a new form of magic!
I think its makes sense that celestia said the birth of an alicorn is something EQ has never seen, cuz in the journal its said that starswirl went to a distant land to ask them to became the princesses of EQ, he believes that alicorns could represent all three types of ponies.
I think Luna having the element of laughter/smile fits because, while she doesn't show it outwardly until near the end, she really is a fun loving pony. When she's in the dream world she has the ability to help ponies have good dreams and spread happiness and fun. She even got a chance to have a little fun during Nightmare Night, the MLP version of Halloween. But, like it was shown, she was stuck in the castle having to carry on the responsibilities of her crown.
There was comic explaining that they were unicorns but once they raise the sun and moon changed There was one episode that showed that in twilight play but not everything was shown
It was a design choice in g5 so that we could recognise Celestia. Since the majority of people only know of her having the rainbow mane, and not the pink mane she had when she was younger.
@@katmaresparkles9578 yes, that's true, but at this point G5 can't really be canon cause of how much contradictions to g4. It may as well be an alternate universe.
I have a question Did Twilight rule Equestria alone or did her friends also share the position of ruler? They explained to us in the ninth season that Twilight and her five friends will rule Equestria together after Celestia and Luna abdicated, but they showed us in the last episode of the cartoon that Twilight alone rules Equestria. Also why do all her friends look old but Twilight is still young and beautiful. Does the alicorn magic make her immortal and not show signs of aging?
Actually they are separated, they are only meeting in council of friendship, And I think Twilight live longer than mane 5, i mean they died so either way twilight is the only ruler of Equestria at her era
The rest of the mane six have other purposes. Rd takes over the wonderbolts, rarity expands her line, fluttershy has her santuary to run, pinkie apprerently settled down and spread her cheer. AJ would ofc help in the farm. They only meet for the council of friendship. Twilight doesnt age since shes the ruler...until she decides to step down.
You should do a video on how Celestia was able to use Luna's own elements against her and banish her to the very things she represents. Ironic, twist, isn't it
Magic is growth in the case of alicorns. Very few ponies like Sassy Saddles and Trouble Shoes are naturally tall. It's sad to learn that Luna didn't have a purpose before she met the Nyx. Had Luna gotten the element of Kindness, she would have been resistant to turning into Nightmare Moon. It is unfortunate that the two sisters were never destined to find a love one, marry and have a next of kin. I'm not sure if immortal Alicorns can experience true happiness, let alone paradise. We' might not see if the G5 Mane Six can succeed where their predecessors failed.
Actually Luna and Celestia were born an alicorns, in comic season 10 Celestia has explain her past lfie and that time we saw them as alicorns in their childhood, and in Opaline past life she explained that time she were talking about Skyros the alicorns kingdom, which is mean Opaline born there and in her past she explaining she has met Celestia and Luna who is everyone beloved. So if anyone says that they were did an Successful mission like raised the sun and moon and then turned into alicorns, no it's not. And about Queen Galexia she is just fanmade characters so don't get misunderstood that she is mother of Celesita and Luna. (Just explain for people who still misunderstanding No hate for this videos everyone has their own comments and expectation. ;) )
@BrandonHenderson-n8f Equestria has never seen any alicorn born in Equestria and Luna and Celestia wasn't born in Equestria, right? Well, as the both of sisters came to rule the Equestria, none of them explained how they end up came here, and Starswirl He didn't explaining anything else about the sisters. You can try to read Comic if you wanted full infomation. (Some of information can be false or truth from me so don't thought it's all, right.)
Regarding Celestia's mane: it was how Opaline remembered the two sisters - or possibly just how she wanted to present them to Misty . It could be that Opaline misremembered Celestia had a pink mane when she was a filly - or Opaline could have also showed Celestia with a colorful mane so Misty would recognize her. Hard to say.
I guess not. She was really mean to Nyx, some creatures who live on the Moon. They treated her nice and even called her beautiful and everything, but she decided to use her dark magic on them to control their minds :(( Sadly, Nightmare Moon is pure evil
They said a birth of an Alicorn is something EQUESTRIA hasn't seen so maybe they were born somewhere else and just came to Equestria right after the events that started heartwarming eve
There could be two potentially reasons for the hair color change: 1) some people's and animal's have their hair color change with age, and not just to grey or white as they get old - personally, my hair changed from dark brown to almost black as a middle schooler with no hair dye; or 2) hair dye and styling options exist in the MLP universe - perhaps Celestia liked the pink mane look and went back to her natural mane color later.
THATS Not true bruh (didn’t finish yet) celestia and Luna weren’t born alicorn! There’s prove in the episode flurry heart comes she’s the first born alicorn
He didn't use to raise the Sun and Moon all alone, he had other powerful alicorn by his side, got it? Thou Celestia and Luna did this kind of magic with no problem at all, for them being born alicorn
Celestia's size being related to magic is just a fan theory. There's nothing in canon that can confirm this theory. Perhaps support. But in order to be a theory, the evidence has to support it above any other theory. There's another theory. An alicorn's size is simply biology. And if magic were related to size, Twilight would've been bigger than Shining Armor even before becoming an Alicorn. Out of curiosity, when did Faust say that magic was related to size? She might've meant that she'd grow to the size she used to be? And even if she said it while still working on the show, why assume it's canon if it's not in the show? Just because the creator of the show says it, it doesn't make it true. The comics with the mirrors and alternate Equestria isn't canon. It literally cannot be canon, considering that Starswirl went missing before Nightmare Moon and was surprised at how big they've grown, and in the comics, Celestia was already that size, and Luna was already on the moon. Finally, someone else who acknowledges that Celestia and Luna were born Alicorns. Even if the Journal of the Two Sisters wasn't canon (which there can be debate about), it's revealed in the Season 10 Comics that they were Alicorns even as Children. But even if THAT wasn't canon (which isn't up for debate), Starswirl doesn't have the ability to turn a Pony into an Alicorn. Not even Celestia has that power. It was NEVER canon that Celestia had a pink mane. That was just the artwork in the book that Twilight was reading. Also, Luna was redesigned. But she always had darker colors in canon as shown in the Season 10 Comics. And the comics never show Celestia with a pink mane. Not even in the comic panels you were showing. In each one, her mane was multicolored. I could see how one could be mistaken as pink. But in all of them, though pink may be more prominent, that's more likely the result of the art style rather than anything else and show her mane as clearly multicolored.
Celestia and Luna we’re not born à la corn’s because you’re in a flurry heart was born she was born I have a call into Luna Saturday Celestia and Luna did not ever see a bird of a Alcorn before
How is Starswirl not an alicorn, given all that he has done and the magical abilities he had?
Did you even watch season 3? Celestia explained why starswirl didn't become an alicorn despite all the achievements he made because he didn't realized how friendship magic works which led to his extinction. And then there's twilight saving their butt off.
@ClintonJayLintua
It's because he's a dude, cozyglow doesn't really get friendship,but manipulation.
As girl power show a male alicorn wasn't going to happen
@@ClintonJayLintuacan you explain why starlight glimmer didn’t become an alicorn even she’s over achieving student of twilight and powerful unicorn
Because he’s a dude.😢
@@christovalfloria8542I could explain it, According to my theory, A pony becomes an alicorn when they have created a new type of magic. Suppose Celestia raising the sun, Luna rasing the moon, Cadence Love, and Twilight, of course, Friendship. So while Starlight Glimmer was over-achieving she didn't create a new form of magic!
short answer:
they were born as alicorns, confirmed in the journal(however the journal is canon but the show forgets about it)
I think its makes sense that celestia said the birth of an alicorn is something EQ has never seen, cuz in the journal its said that starswirl went to a distant land to ask them to became the princesses of EQ, he believes that alicorns could represent all three types of ponies.
The birth of an alicorn is something Equestria has never seen before.
I think Luna having the element of laughter/smile fits because, while she doesn't show it outwardly until near the end, she really is a fun loving pony. When she's in the dream world she has the ability to help ponies have good dreams and spread happiness and fun. She even got a chance to have a little fun during Nightmare Night, the MLP version of Halloween.
But, like it was shown, she was stuck in the castle having to carry on the responsibilities of her crown.
Well, guess you're right about Luna's Element of laughter! She is really extrovert when has to do something she loves or wanted to ~
There was comic explaining that they were unicorns but once they raise the sun and moon changed
There was one episode that showed that in twilight play but not everything was shown
It was a design choice in g5 so that we could recognise Celestia. Since the majority of people only know of her having the rainbow mane, and not the pink mane she had when she was younger.
Adding on the episode that introduced Flurry Heart. Celestia said herself that there had never been a naturally born alicorn
@freakillusion yeah in Equestria. Skyros is outside of Equestria.
@@katmaresparkles9578 yes, that's true, but at this point G5 can't really be canon cause of how much contradictions to g4. It may as well be an alternate universe.
Is that canon, the pink mane?
@BrandonHenderson-n8f yes
I have a question
Did Twilight rule Equestria alone or did her friends also share the position of ruler?
They explained to us in the ninth season that Twilight and her five friends will rule Equestria together after Celestia and Luna abdicated, but they showed us in the last episode of the cartoon that Twilight alone rules Equestria.
Also why do all her friends look old but Twilight is still young and beautiful. Does the alicorn magic make her immortal and not show signs of aging?
Actually they are separated, they are only meeting in council of friendship,
And I think Twilight live longer than mane 5, i mean they died so either way twilight is the only ruler of Equestria at her era
Twilight is indeed now immortal. Like celestia and luna, and also cadence
The rest of the mane six have other purposes. Rd takes over the wonderbolts, rarity expands her line, fluttershy has her santuary to run, pinkie apprerently settled down and spread her cheer. AJ would ofc help in the farm. They only meet for the council of friendship. Twilight doesnt age since shes the ruler...until she decides to step down.
You should do a video on how Celestia was able to use Luna's own elements against her and banish her to the very things she represents. Ironic, twist, isn't it
Magic is growth in the case of alicorns. Very few ponies like Sassy Saddles and Trouble Shoes are naturally tall. It's sad to learn that Luna didn't have a purpose before she met the Nyx. Had Luna gotten the element of Kindness, she would have been resistant to turning into Nightmare Moon. It is unfortunate that the two sisters were never destined to find a love one, marry and have a next of kin. I'm not sure if immortal Alicorns can experience true happiness, let alone paradise. We' might not see if the G5 Mane Six can succeed where their predecessors failed.
you incresed my mlp knowlage
Aww thats so sweet!!
@@ToonTimeEUA btw merry Christmas
Actually Luna and Celestia were born an alicorns, in comic season 10 Celestia has explain her past lfie and that time we saw them as alicorns in their childhood, and in Opaline past life she explained that time she were talking about Skyros the alicorns kingdom, which is mean Opaline born there and in her past she explaining she has met Celestia and Luna who is everyone beloved. So if anyone says that they were did an Successful mission like raised the sun and moon and then turned into alicorns, no it's not. And about Queen Galexia she is just fanmade characters so don't get misunderstood that she is mother of Celesita and Luna.
(Just explain for people who still misunderstanding No hate for this videos everyone has their own comments and expectation. ;) )
The birth of an alicorn is something Equestria has never seen before.
@BrandonHenderson-n8f well, Celestia has said that but she wasn't born at Equestria, so that's why most people misunderstood it.
@JNDreamp That doesnt even make any sense.
@BrandonHenderson-n8f Equestria has never seen any alicorn born in Equestria and Luna and Celestia wasn't born in Equestria, right? Well, as the both of sisters came to rule the Equestria, none of them explained how they end up came here, and Starswirl He didn't explaining anything else about the sisters. You can try to read Comic if you wanted full infomation. (Some of information can be false or truth from me so don't thought it's all, right.)
Regarding Celestia's mane: it was how Opaline remembered the two sisters - or possibly just how she wanted to present them to Misty . It could be that Opaline misremembered Celestia had a pink mane when she was a filly - or Opaline could have also showed Celestia with a colorful mane so Misty would recognize her. Hard to say.
I hate mlp 5 i wouldn't consider what they as the truth because they really can't keep their own storyline straight.
Exactly you mean to say that the work twilight and co only is harmonious as long as their alive.
Question can nightmare moon be nice is she wanted to?
I guess not. She was really mean to Nyx, some creatures who live on the Moon. They treated her nice and even called her beautiful and everything, but she decided to use her dark magic on them to control their minds :((
Sadly, Nightmare Moon is pure evil
I they were born as alicorns why did tthey say in epizode when flurryheart born that there was never bor alicorn before
They said a birth of an Alicorn is something EQUESTRIA hasn't seen so maybe they were born somewhere else and just came to Equestria right after the events that started heartwarming eve
WHY IS NOBODY ELSE GONNA TALK ABOUT HOW BIG MAC WAS ABLE TO PULL THE PRICESSE LUNA 😢😢
Hes a big boi
A strong boi
Thank you
Ur welcome sugar cube
All of them
😳😳
There could be two potentially reasons for the hair color change: 1) some people's and animal's have their hair color change with age, and not just to grey or white as they get old - personally, my hair changed from dark brown to almost black as a middle schooler with no hair dye; or 2) hair dye and styling options exist in the MLP universe - perhaps Celestia liked the pink mane look and went back to her natural mane color later.
THATS Not true bruh (didn’t finish yet) celestia and Luna weren’t born alicorn! There’s prove in the episode flurry heart comes she’s the first born alicorn
Exactly. She's just built different
Can you please watch THE WHOLE video...?
@ I did did I maybe miss smth? I’m sorry maybe I didn’t understood smth cuz I’m not speaking perfect english
Exactly!
Did you know Cadance actually has wavy hair it's just curled in the wedding episode when shining armor and Cadance shared magic it went curly to wavy
ToonTime, starswirl use to raise the sun and moon, and teach the princess celestia and Luna so how come he’s not an alicorn?
He didn't use to raise the Sun and Moon all alone, he had other powerful alicorn by his side, got it? Thou Celestia and Luna did this kind of magic with no problem at all, for them being born alicorn
Celestia's size being related to magic is just a fan theory. There's nothing in canon that can confirm this theory. Perhaps support. But in order to be a theory, the evidence has to support it above any other theory. There's another theory. An alicorn's size is simply biology. And if magic were related to size, Twilight would've been bigger than Shining Armor even before becoming an Alicorn. Out of curiosity, when did Faust say that magic was related to size? She might've meant that she'd grow to the size she used to be? And even if she said it while still working on the show, why assume it's canon if it's not in the show? Just because the creator of the show says it, it doesn't make it true.
The comics with the mirrors and alternate Equestria isn't canon. It literally cannot be canon, considering that Starswirl went missing before Nightmare Moon and was surprised at how big they've grown, and in the comics, Celestia was already that size, and Luna was already on the moon.
Finally, someone else who acknowledges that Celestia and Luna were born Alicorns. Even if the Journal of the Two Sisters wasn't canon (which there can be debate about), it's revealed in the Season 10 Comics that they were Alicorns even as Children. But even if THAT wasn't canon (which isn't up for debate), Starswirl doesn't have the ability to turn a Pony into an Alicorn. Not even Celestia has that power.
It was NEVER canon that Celestia had a pink mane. That was just the artwork in the book that Twilight was reading. Also, Luna was redesigned. But she always had darker colors in canon as shown in the Season 10 Comics. And the comics never show Celestia with a pink mane. Not even in the comic panels you were showing. In each one, her mane was multicolored. I could see how one could be mistaken as pink. But in all of them, though pink may be more prominent, that's more likely the result of the art style rather than anything else and show her mane as clearly multicolored.
Were allowed to have Plot holen i think
Then what about the scene when they talk about flurry heart.❤
Celestia and Luna we’re not born à la corn’s because you’re in a flurry heart was born she was born I have a call into Luna Saturday Celestia and Luna did not ever see a bird of a Alcorn before
My1Gotta be Nightmare boyfriend Half A boyfriend
😎💯👍👍👍👍💯💯😎😎
Rainbow dash is tobe a alicorn
mia ela esta te copiando
Sou eu xuxu kk
This was fun and btw I wouldn't blame big Mac for going out on a date with princess Luna because princess Luna is smoking hot
your blaming them im unlike
👿👿👿😡😡
Thirdd
Fourth