As an Orthodox Jew, I must thank you, the video is edited in a very smart, beautiful and instructive way, may God grant you all the wishes of your heart for the best, Amen.
As an Orthodox Jew from Israel, I must thank you, the video is edited in a very smart, beautiful and instructive way, may God grant you all the wishes of your heart for the best, Amen. The fact that you joined the People of Israel is good for the People of Israel, you are doing a wonderful job.
Simply put: Milk is the essence of life and nurturing it's love and purity. Meat is the result of extracting the soul the blood and life of a creature Mixing death and life is seen as a vile action, especially when you do so for your own pleasure
Thank you for the explanation. I have never heard this despite being raised Jewish but it makes total sense to me. I knew about not giving flowers as gifts or putting them on a gravestone because it was mixing life and death but no one ever mentioned this towards meat and milk. Many thanks again. Am Yisrael Chai
Oyako. That's what the Japanese call it when you eat chicken and egg together. Oyako. [Oya=Mother, ko=child] (Perhaps you've heard of this when it's call "Oyako-don", which is just Oyako over rice.) Oh, let me remind you that Japanese are Godless heathens.
Great deep dive. Its literally a chok, Hashem commands us so we do it but another reason is that we don't cook a kid in its mother's milk is but its also a practice that people used to serve pagen gods and its also showing how to be kind. That it was considered an act of cruelty. Hashem is teaching us through his creations through animals around us how to act and behave in a mindful way and utilize these behaviors to elevate our actions. To show what separate Humans, and Jewish people from non Jewish people. Keeping kosher means what we put in our body elevates and informs are behaviors.
Ayurveda explains that certain food combinations lead to the creation of "ama" (toxins) in the body, and the rules of kashrut largely agree those Ayurvedic principles. So the rules of kashrut are actually health guidelines.
What a yummy adventure this was! 🙋🏻♀️😋❤️ Not mixing meat & milk was one of the first things I learned about kashrut (RIP steak & cheese 🥲), but it wasn’t until I came to 🇮🇱 that I learned about not mixing meat & fish…and then, a minhag of not mixing fish & cheese! The latter, I don’t follow at the moment, but I’m thinking about it more and it kind of makes sense to me based on this idea of (not) mixing spiritual energies. Gonna dig into this more.
I was told to not mix meat or milk when eating. I think Paul says that in the new testament that some cannot handle the meat of the word so they need to continue with ...some milk. never thought about why he said it like that till this very video. very interesting
@@GeorgeBrooks22 Yes George that is the Pshat, the obvious/plain understanding. But there are four levels of understanding above that, which give a much richer view into WHY the commandment was given.
0:29 I met an older woman who would not eat milk and meat within 24 hours of each other. There are stories in the Talmud of such people, and their piety is incredibly praise worthy. They are going well above and beyond the law.
Let's see. There are psukim that say not to take the bird and its egg at the same time. If I'm not mistaken, the mitzvah to not boil or seethe a kid in its mother's milk is repeated at least three times. I've seen arguments that g'di doesn't mean kid but rather some sort of plant, but no plant has a mother at all, let alone a lactating one, so the Ugaritic cognate is most likely spurious. There is a pasuk that lets future leaders make rules for their generation. Then there are two mishnayot. One has a snotty Jerusalem rabbi respond to a Galilean colleague who says no one in his village considers fowl meat to the effect that everyone in Jerusalem does, and that's supposed to be an argument. Combining with the one about creative future rule making, there is one in Avot that says make a fence around the Torah. What happened between no cream of goat soup and no milk in your coffee for hours after a chicken salad sandwich and separate sets of everything? Approximately 27 fences around the Torah mitzvah. How'd I do?
Well done! Kabbalah teaches that Milk/Dairy is associated with the forces of Chesed is associated with Loving Kindness, and Meat is associated Gevurah - Strength, Might and Fire. These are opposing forces. If meat is consumed first, the Gevurah as the heat or fire of the Meat will rise (as heat rises) and intermingle to conflict with the opposing force of the Chesed of Dairy/Milk.
1) This video misses the idea that even the non-dairy "milk" served with hamburger violates the spirit of the separation of milk and meat. 2) With all its profundity, the video also misses the, perhaps, mundane idea that the prohibition against using a mother's milk to boil the kid reminds us that the animals we're eating are sentient beings like ourselves: mothers that nurture and give milk and babies that suckle.
This a great video and wonderful explanations. However, if it is so important to separate meat and milk, why would you want to even have a fake no dairy cheese burger. I understand that it's kosher, but wouldn't that taste of Gevura mixed with Chessed be a little off putting? It kind of reminds me of the vegans that make all these vegan dishes that taste like meat.
Proverbs 30:4-6 Who hath ascended up into heaven, or descended? who hath gathered the wind in his fists? who hath bound the waters in a garment? who hath established all the ends of the earth? what is his name, and what is his son's name, if thou canst tell? Every word of God is pure: he is a shield unto them that put their trust in him. Add thou not unto his words, lest he reprove thee, and thou be found a liar.
Vastly less. If the cow's skin was ever pierced or ever broke a bone, it's not kosher. So the cows are kept in safer conditions to protect them. If the cow ever required antibiotics, it's not kosher. So the cows are kept in cleaner conditions to keep them healthy. The cow is slaughtered by a single slice of a razor sharp blade across its throat, preventing suffering and distress. But also prevent the release of stress hormones into the meat which are known to cause it to spoil faster. If the lungs of the cow has any dark spots, it's not kosher. So after slaughter the cow is examined again for it's health. Then the meat is salted to remove blood, which makes the taste better but also significantly reduces bacterial growth and spoiling.
The oral Torah isn’t an interpretation of the written Torah.. it’s two different and related Torahs that work together. The oral Torah came BEFORE the written.
Kind of depends. Some use the term "oral Torah" to mean only the mishnayot, which is what you are referring to. But some use the term "oral Torah" to include gemara, tosefta, kabbalah, chassidus, and commentaries.
I went on Sefaria, and I can't find a single translation that would agree with what you presented at 4:18. Every translation states 'kid' and 'mother's milk.' Not 'any kosher animal' and 'any milk.' Crazy that the scholars that spent years putting together the JPS are being told they are wrong by a random youtube video.
The opposite of meat is salad. The opposite of milk is sand. Note: this is just an nonreligious reasoning Everyone thinks the rule is about food. No; it's about relationships.
@garrettlees milk is sustenance that is a flowing liquid. Sand also flows, but is dry, coarse, and erodes, and is equated with death. Wandering in the desert, vs latched on to the mother's life giving, nurturing bosom.
Dear Jennifer, thanks for the reply. I am a Jew. I will note I don’t like politicians dictating their leftist views to control me. Nor do I want to Rabbis dictating as they do for anyone who is ultra orthodox or Haredi. As a Jew I can turn to a Rabbi for hopefully his knowledge & wisdom with respect to life & Halacha. It is the way that what the majority agrees to do with respect to Halacha is the way. I do not question HaShem but I do question much of our appreciation and understanding of Halacha. Remember that when HaShem led us out of bondage into the desert, it is said that only one out of 200 hundred Jews left either Moshe Rabeinu. That is incredible to me, that so many remained as slaves. Well most of us are sheeple. The Rabbis failed us in the Holocaust, not HaShem. The Rabbis are failing us today both in Israel & in America. If you completely abdicate your HaShem given critical thinking, then more then ever I pray that HaShem protects you. But never did HaShem tell you to walk in the middle of rush hour traffic and as long as you believe I’ll save you. You must do for yourself and believe. Get תורה בעל פה But that leaves a lot open to manipulation by our Rabbis. In Bereshite HaShem told Moshe just before we entered the holy land promised to us that We were to be a light to bring HaShem’s way to the world. And if we didn’t we would suffer exile etc. how do you think we are doing?
Completely agree with you! It’s the blind leading the blind! I almost became a Jew by converting but I’m “Jew-ish” (some DNA) and practice with a congregation that follows Judaism closer to Orthodox than Reform and also read Brit Chadasha! I urge you [beg you🙏] to read Brit Chadasha (only TOJB, NMV, CJB, KJV and YLT versions] just for interest or as Oral Torah! You will see exactly what you said is what the issue was at hand - with Yeshua Ben Yosef (NOTJesus !!)! Don’t believe Christianity it’s a decoy to those who want the nice easy life! Also, funny but truth their leaders have done copy and paste from the Jewish leaders!, and taken it even higher with fancy cars, and planes! [he that ignores history will definitely repeat it]. If a rabbi or priest is not a servant of the people and one of the poor ones of that congregation then there is something wrong there! Baruch HaShem! “Woe to you P’rushim (Pharisees) [separatists] and Torah-teachers (Scribes), hypocrites because you close up the Kingdom of heaven before men; you yourselves do not enter and those who wish to enter you do not permit to enter”. “But oy to you, Sofrim and Perushim, tzevuim (hypocrites), for in front of Bnei Adam you shut the Malchut HaShomayim. You do not go in yourselves, and the ones entering, you do not permit to enter “Woe to them, Torah-teachers (Scribes) and P’rushim (Pharisee [separatist]s) [separatists], who tithe mint, dill and pomegranate, but who commit robbery and leave undone that which is weightier, that is, the judgments of the Torah which are: kindness, tand faithfulness. These are commands worthy of doing; one should not forget them”. Oy to you, Sofrim and Perushim, tzevuim, for you give maasros (tithe) of mint and dill and cumin, and you have neglected the matters of the Torah of greater consequence: mishpat, chesed, and emunah. These things it was necessary to do and those not to neglect. “Woe to you P’rushim (Pharisees) [separatists] and Torah-teachers (Scribes), because you cleanse cups and platters on the outside but inside them is full of wickedness and uncleanness”. “Hypocrites, cleanse first that which is inside in order that that which is outside might be pure”.” Matthew 23:13, 23, 25-26 Oy to you, Sofrim and Perushim, tzevuim, you cleanse the outside of the kos (cup) and the dish, but inside they are full of chamdanut (greed) and taavanut (lust). Blind Parush, first cleanse the inside of the kos, that perhaps also the outside may become clean.” Mattityahu 23:13, 23, 25-26
אח שלי זה אחד הסירטונים היותר טובים בנושא כשרות וזה מגיע למקומות מאוד פנימיים מהות האכילה של יהודי ואיך יהודי אוכל ומה התכלית באכילה -- כל האחרים אוכלים בשביל לשרוד והאמונה שלהם במקנשים ובמנזרים שם הם משקיעים כסף יוקרה ופאר והרב בסירטון מסביר שאצלינו זה בתוך הבית במטבח כשר מיוחד וקדוש תן לי עוד מהתוכן המעולה הזה תודה רבה ליוצרים ולמנחה המעולה מאחל לך חתונה השנה
Wow! Subscribed immediately! Brilliant work! Well explained Rabbi! And the Kabbalah is also on point! Whilst it makes sense, I do think HaShem intention was for us to live our lives and not be hamstrung with too much weeds! To go to this lengths to separate meat and milk and then ignore your brother ie another human soul (Jew or non-Jew) begging and dying in the street and you have a house with two kitchens and fridges etc… is losing the purpose of life! “Missing the wood for the trees!” This was the first sin Rabbi, “Now the Nachash was more arum (cunning, crafty, wiley) than any beast of the sadeh which Hashem Elohim had made. And he said unto the (woman), REALLY? Hath Elohim said, Ye shall not eat of kol etz hagan (garden)?”Bereshit 3:1 The Adversary was use detail to debate the Oral Torah given to our first parents! This is what’s leading both Jews and Gentiles alike into condemnation! Why? Because it’s impossible to be a good Jew and be poor - so we accumulate all the money in order to do our mitzvah, live walking distance to shul and Gentiles, they look at the Jewish life and say aibo, (means 😮 wow) I can’t live like that so I follow Jesus - where I don’t have to be wealthy to be a good person! Meanwhile Jesus is the “unkosher” imposter from Rome and Yeshua the real Yehudi of Jews who took a balanced view of walking the narrow path and exercise chesed on those that would not be able to destroy a whole rainforest just to ensure they separated milk and meat, starve because they could not wash their hands before a meal (nitliyat hadamin) - we also have these rules as a Semitic African people but we have not taken them to heaven and hell and back! It is for this reason actually HaShem does not give this verse alone but in context! Please hear me out: see the verses… The Bible verse that says "do not cook a kid in its mother's milk" appears in Exodus 23:19, Exodus 34:26, and Deuteronomy 14:21: Exodus 23:19 "The first of the first-fruits of thy ground thou shalt bring into the house of Jehovah thy God. Thou shalt not boil a kid in its mother's milk". “The reshit bikkurim of thy land thou shalt bring into the Bais Hashem Eloheicha. Thou shalt not cook a kid in his motherʼs cholov.” Shemot 23:19 Exodus 34:26 "The choicest first-fruits of thy land thou shalt bring unto the house of the Lord thy God. Thou shalt not seethe a kid in its mother's milk". “The reshit bikkurim of thy land thou shalt bring unto the Beit Hashem Eloheicha. Thou shalt not cook a kid in cholov immo.” Shemot 34:26 Deuteronomy 14:21 "Ye shall not eat of any thing that dieth of itself; thou mayest give it unto the stranger that is within thy gates, that he may eat it; or thou mayest sell it unto a foreigner; for thou art a holy people unto the Lord thy God. Thou shalt not seethe a kid in its mother's milk". “Ye shall not eat of anything that dieth of itself; thou shalt give it unto the ger that is in thy she'arim, that he may eat it; or thou mayest sell it unto an alien; for thou art an Am Kadosh unto Hashem Eloheicha. Thou shalt not boil a young goat in its motherʼs cholov.” Devarim 14:21 To me the meaning is obvious on a read of this! Basically the give of life (HaShem) shall not eat or destroy or suffocate the life of its young and it extends to and that which He (the give of life, the Kodesh One) gives to give us life [Life breath, Spirit, soul, food for life, the Tree of Life (Etz Chaim) - the Word, Torah] Milk, you should not use to destroy life to gain life or strength! - even when you see pagans doing it to gain life from their gods! Why? Because I HaShem your God-Elohim doesn’t do that! Ye be kodesh (holy) because I’m kodesh (holy)! - this is to worlds priests the Jews! This why he gave us the rainbow 🌈 in Bereshit showing that water which supports life he will not again use to destroy life (even though) he was not cooking life for his benefit or consumption which is doubly worse! - death only benefits the HaSatan!’ This is the problem with Oral Torah it takes one evil person to add or to pass on untruths and the whole generation is lost! If written Torah has differences as we know imagine word of mouth in this day and age! We are not when generations saw their 5th generation born! I do love and honour that you [Jewish] have tried so much to walk in HaShem’s ways but be careful that for whatever credit you put on your account you’re putting 100 debits - that’s the problem with chasing the wood for the trees Rabbi! Am Yisra’el Chai! Just a view of ‘Jew-ish’ sheep of the great shepherd! We will ALL sit before the righteous judge and explain our actions! Much love… Shalom Shalom! Baruch HaShem!🙏🔥🙌🏾
If you love somebody, you'll do things for them even if you don't completely understand why they wat you to do it. If your pregnant wife wants pickles and peanut butter ice cream at 9pm, you don't argue with her about why she wants it - you put on your shoes and go to the grocery store, you know? God asks Jews not to mix milk and meat - it's not a huge ask.
Great Job and nice presentation. But let’s go back to Torah B’ al peh. I give you several arguments to ponder. The Kippah was not worn at Mount Sinai, it came into norm about the 2nd temple period. Why is a chicken considered meat yet an egg is parve? What if in fact we have mis interpreted HaShem’s meaning & wants and are just following dictates by Rabbis. Why can you essentially eat a milk product clean your mouth and then eat meat. But for meat you must wait 6 hours? Why 6 why not four or 8 hours? Note the Amidah was once only two sentences to day it’s 19 albeit we also call the prayer Shemona esraei? Why is turning on the lights considered work and thus not done on Shabbat. But if one lights a candle before Shabbat it’s kosher to transfer the flame to another candle? Thank you Rabbis for the dictates & interpretations. But I question the origin of many of our practices. An unapologetic Jew.
@@gingebrien2408 We can't know for sure. But the halachic rules we currently follow are the result of centuries of scholarship from the greatest Jewish minds of the post-exilic period. When in doubt, it makes sense to me to rely on Rashi or Maimonedes, you know? Plus, Jewish tradition has always emphasized the idea that God wants our best efforts and doesn't really expect perfection from most of us (we aren't Moses!). You see this distinction in the laws - like how if you don't know/forget it's Shabbat and you kindle a fire, you can atone for this with a sacrifice. If we no longer know exactly what God wants from us, but we keep to our best understanding of what Torah says, then I have faith that we are still on the right path. There's even some modern situations that deal with this - like how there's a company now making what they claim is tekhelet blue dye for tzitzit strings. It's made from the same snail that we know was used to make royal purple dye in the Roman era, but a different approach is used to set the dye that makes it turn blue instead of purple. Some Jews wear the blue string in their tzitzit now, but others aren't comfortable with this and still wear all white strings. This is because we don't actually know for sure how to make tekhelet - the process was lost to history. Maybe this new dye is the correct dye, and maybe it isn't. So like all things, each of us needs to use our best judgement and stay humble in our approach to halacha.
@@Jennifer-cl1clExactly HaShem wants everything in moderation! Not destroying earth to keep meat and milk separate that is NOT the intention of this verse! The Oral Torah is wrong or if it is correct it’s only for Moshe’s of this world - who is like Moshe or the Shepherd! Let them raise their hand. I sin on the first breath…of rising! Even in my dreams I break HaShem instructions! Let us not miss the wood for the trees! Baruch HaShem!
@@garrettlees You're correct ultimately according to Jewish law. There were 3 times in history where the entire world was vegetarian (and some were vegan). 1) garden of Eden 2) Noah's ark 3) in the future world of the Messiah It is a higher level of spirituality that eventually the entire world will attain. You just got there a little early.
I love your videos. You might have made the (obvious) observation that milk and meat come from the same animals. I'm sure the rabbi would have some insight into that too :)
Rather selfishly and off topic, I am happiest for the halachic Asian Jewish representation. I'd like to believe if I was still in Israel, we'd meet. Maybe our paths will cross one day.
Great video and interesting explanation behind it. However It remains a stupid idea which from a materialist perspective requires so much effort to adhere to the rule, the effort could be better spent on other things. There is no scientific reason why it is positive to segregate meat and milk.
every where else tho where it would say G'di would just be like a baby goat tho? Hard to believe they interpreted that correctly. More likely it was a prohibition of a pagan practice, where pagans literally cooked a baby goat in the mother's milk.
Believe ?? I don't think Jewish people "believe" in NOT eating milk with meat : instead it is one of 613 commandments in the the Old Testament . Hence, a religious Jew may believe that eating such a combination is phsyically harmless, but violates God's commandment.
This is a stretch upon a stretch upon another stretch, why don't you just listen to the Torah and don't cook a child of any animal (nowhere does it say kosher) in "it's" mother's milk (not any milk), if you're worried it's mother's milk could be mixed in, use milk from a different type of animal.
Because when Moshe received the Torah on Mt. Sinai, he was also taught the oral tradition which expounds upon the verse, and the significance of it being written 3 times. I think a very problematic misconception is that the oral tradition was just invented by the rabbis, when in reality it was practiced and transmitted from Moshe’s time.
How about an explanation from the 'rabid' rabbi. The 'mother's milk' refers to the teachings of the Torah. Torah is a feminine word - thus the 'mother of all' is the 'law'. Since a goat represents those who are rebellious to the 'unbreakable law', and the 'milk' the teachings, it should be plain to see why these do not go together. Do NOT let the LEFT HAND know what the RIGHT HAND is doing had more MEAT inside than is obvious. Each 'hand' has a divine purpose and symbolic meaning. See Isaiah 45:7
Quite the stretch. A more practical read would be don't take and consume a young animal before it's weaned from nursing. Jewish mysticism makes many questionable declarations, some of which state when lying to others is acceptable and required. After such a declaration, what's to be believed?
Yes she is. A Jew can be of any race although we are an ethno religious group. It's something that antisemites have a hard time with. The first Jews had an homogeneous background but as we are welcoming converts among us without other restrictions than religious ones, our typology evolved. What we call gerout or conversion is in reality much more than that: it's an adoption into our nation, so race is not relevant. In the same manner Native Americans used to adopt white or black people into their tribes that's why you have black Seminoles and blue eyed Cherokees. So this young woman could be a Jew because both her parents are Jewish, or only her mother, or she might have been adopted, or she can be a convert. Noa Argaman one of the surviving hostages is of Chinese origin, her mother Liora z"l who died shortly after her liberation was a convert . Israel is the true rainbow 🌈 nation.
@@SamianHQuazi Judaism is both a faith and an ethnicity. DNA studies show that most Jewish men and many Arab men are descended from the same Middle Eastern male who lived approximately 4000 years ago. HTH.
Very interesting video. But I wonder about the kosher cheeseburger - doesn't putting a "fake" cheese defeat the purpose, the same way as "real" cheese? If it looks like a cheeseburger, smells like a cheeseburger, and tastes like a cheeseburger, then it's a cheeseburger, isn't it? It somewhat feels to me like it's trying to find a loophole in the law, and if so, why bother with the law itself? Just have a normal cheeseburger...
I’ll admit it looks wrong, but it’s clearly not milk. Someone who is lactose intolerant won’t drink milk, but he could drink almond/oat/cashew milk. Fake cheese is just not cheese, no matter how hard it pretends to be.
@PALE1ISTEHBEST Right, it is not real cheese, but I think there is a difference between an intolerance and a religious law. In case of intolerance, the issue is the ingredient itself. In the case of religion, the issue is with what the ingredient symbolizes. Fake cheese still somewhat symbolizes the same thing as real cheese. It may solve the problem for an intolerant person, but for a religious person? Seems to me it just misses the very purpose of not mixing meat and dairy, even when just "fake" dairy.
No. Cooking a baby goat in its mother’s milk was a common Canaanite ritualistic practice. God wanted to prevent the children of Israel from participating in paganism so He established a law for it. In other words, it’s okay to mix dairy and meat, but it’s not okay to literally boil a baby of any kind in its mother's milk.
@@tuff947 The texts referencing Canaanite rituals of cooking meat in milk found at Ugarit are fragmented. There is no consensus that these references are the source of the biblical prohibition to not cook young goats in their mother's milk. But the proof that the Torah does not prohibit eating milk and meat together is right in the Torah itself. There are 3 references to this prohibition (Exodus 23:19, 34:26 and Deuteronomy 14:21) and they all reference cooking (בשׁל) not eating. And they all refer to a גדי which is certainly referring to a young goat and perhaps also a young lamb, but certainly not beef or fowl. The expansion of this prohibition created by our sages is based on mysticism, not the Torah given to Moshe.
Sorry this is just too much philosophy when the reality is just a matter of basic morality! Think about it, you take the kid and cook it in his mother's milk ?? Don't you see why it is morally wrong ? 🤷🏻♂️
European mysticists have no problem regarding the mixing of meat and milk. I even sometimes eat pork and bacon. My Jewish prophet doesn't see an issue with it. We still believe organic cattle are better than bio-factory-raised ones. A farm has to elevate the energy of the animals, otherwise it will be cursed by God and hunted down by the government. I hope you learnt something from me. We also put more emphasis on mindful living than church/synagogue service in our faith. We do most of our religion at home.
That's really interesting. Could you share more about your religious practice? Is this like a Kabbalist idea? What sort of mysticism are you practicing?
As an Orthodox Jew, I must thank you, the video is edited in a very smart, beautiful and instructive way, may God grant you all the wishes of your heart for the best, Amen.
As an Orthodox Jew from Israel, I must thank you, the video is edited in a very smart, beautiful and instructive way, may God grant you all the wishes of your heart for the best, Amen. The fact that you joined the People of Israel is good for the People of Israel, you are doing a wonderful job.
This is the best video I've seen in a while. Blown away! Amazing explanation with a great edit that was so fun to watch. 🙏
Very nicely edited and interesting information!
Simply put:
Milk is the essence of life and nurturing it's love and purity.
Meat is the result of extracting the soul the blood and life of a creature
Mixing death and life is seen as a vile action, especially when you do so for your own pleasure
Thank you for the explanation. I have never heard this despite being raised Jewish but it makes total sense to me.
I knew about not giving flowers as gifts or putting them on a gravestone because it was mixing life and death but no one ever mentioned this towards meat and milk.
Many thanks again. Am Yisrael Chai
This was very well done, makes a complicated topic more approachable and encourages me to watch more movies from you. Hatzlacha!
Outstanding, uplifting, video. These videos are going to have impact. Keep them coming!
Thank You for this !!!!
Great video!
Love this video thank u for the explanation
I like this rule. I feel very uneasy when people eat chicken and egg together too.
Oyako. That's what the Japanese call it when you eat chicken and egg together. Oyako. [Oya=Mother, ko=child] (Perhaps you've heard of this when it's call "Oyako-don", which is just Oyako over rice.) Oh, let me remind you that Japanese are Godless heathens.
Excellent content I have shared your work with my high school students. keep it up Thank You
Incredible. I actually learned something new today. On UA-cam!!
Great deep dive. Its literally a chok, Hashem commands us so we do it but another reason is that we don't cook a kid in its mother's milk is but its also a practice that people used to serve pagen gods and its also showing how to be kind. That it was considered an act of cruelty. Hashem is teaching us through his creations through animals around us how to act and behave in a mindful way and utilize these behaviors to elevate our actions. To show what separate Humans, and Jewish people from non Jewish people. Keeping kosher means what we put in our body elevates and informs are behaviors.
Beautiful!
As a Jewish man I've learned from this, thanks! 🎉😊
This is a very well explained kabbalah,
Really interesting 🧐🤔❤
Thank you!
Pretty cool vid. Commenting to make sure algorithm promotes it.
great video, was fascinating!
Well done vid
oh my god that was amazing!
Ayurveda explains that certain food combinations lead to the creation of "ama" (toxins) in the body, and the rules of kashrut largely agree those Ayurvedic principles. So the rules of kashrut are actually health guidelines.
What a yummy adventure this was! 🙋🏻♀️😋❤️ Not mixing meat & milk was one of the first things I learned about kashrut (RIP steak & cheese 🥲), but it wasn’t until I came to 🇮🇱 that I learned about not mixing meat & fish…and then, a minhag of not mixing fish & cheese! The latter, I don’t follow at the moment, but I’m thinking about it more and it kind of makes sense to me based on this idea of (not) mixing spiritual energies. Gonna dig into this more.
Beatyful ❤
I was told to not mix meat or milk when eating. I think Paul says that in the new testament that some cannot handle the meat of the word so they need to continue with ...some milk. never thought about why he said it like that till this very video. very interesting
Milk is mercy, meat is judgement. That is why we seperate the two.
The two are separated because God said so. That's all. The rest is superfluous.
@@GeorgeBrooks22That's true and the primary reason why we do so, but that's not all. All the rest is extremely important as well.
@@GeorgeBrooks22
Yes George that is the Pshat, the obvious/plain understanding. But there are four levels of understanding above that, which give a much richer view into WHY the commandment was given.
@@GeorgeBrooks22which god?
@@JohnnyArtPavlou The God, creator of the universe.
The Torah says do not cook a Gid in its mother's milk 3 times. for cooking, eating and benefit. that is the source.
0:29 I met an older woman who would not eat milk and meat within 24 hours of each other. There are stories in the Talmud of such people, and their piety is incredibly praise worthy. They are going well above and beyond the law.
Meorah Ha-Me'ir - ❤❤❤❤👍👍
Let's see. There are psukim that say not to take the bird and its egg at the same time. If I'm not mistaken, the mitzvah to not boil or seethe a kid in its mother's milk is repeated at least three times. I've seen arguments that g'di doesn't mean kid but rather some sort of plant, but no plant has a mother at all, let alone a lactating one, so the Ugaritic cognate is most likely spurious. There is a pasuk that lets future leaders make rules for their generation. Then there are two mishnayot. One has a snotty Jerusalem rabbi respond to a Galilean colleague who says no one in his village considers fowl meat to the effect that everyone in Jerusalem does, and that's supposed to be an argument. Combining with the one about creative future rule making, there is one in Avot that says make a fence around the Torah. What happened between no cream of goat soup and no milk in your coffee for hours after a chicken salad sandwich and separate sets of everything? Approximately 27 fences around the Torah mitzvah. How'd I do?
Well done!
Kabbalah teaches that Milk/Dairy is associated with the forces of Chesed is associated with Loving Kindness, and Meat is associated Gevurah - Strength, Might and Fire. These are opposing forces.
If meat is consumed first, the Gevurah as the heat or fire of the Meat will rise (as heat rises) and intermingle to conflict with the opposing force of the Chesed of Dairy/Milk.
Wow❗️
I believe being actually born Jewish that the oral law is the torah as there are some rare sects that only follow the written laws or the talmud
1) This video misses the idea that even the non-dairy "milk" served with hamburger violates the spirit of the separation of milk and meat. 2) With all its profundity, the video also misses the, perhaps, mundane idea that the prohibition against using a mother's milk to boil the kid reminds us that the animals we're eating are sentient beings like ourselves: mothers that nurture and give milk and babies that suckle.
This a great video and wonderful explanations. However, if it is so important to separate meat and milk, why would you want to even have a fake no dairy cheese burger. I understand that it's kosher, but wouldn't that taste of Gevura mixed with Chessed be a little off putting? It kind of reminds me of the vegans that make all these vegan dishes that taste like meat.
Proverbs 30:4-6 Who hath ascended up into heaven, or descended? who hath gathered the wind in his fists? who hath bound the waters in a garment? who hath established all the ends of the earth? what is his name, and what is his son's name, if thou canst tell?
Every word of God is pure: he is a shield unto them that put their trust in him.
Add thou not unto his words, lest he reprove thee, and thou be found a liar.
Dairy and meat are forbidden. That's why Jewish delis are either meat or dairy delis.
There is a difference between a kosher deli and a Jewish deli.
@@simonfuller4492 Yes, I have learned that!
Delis are meat by definition. The dairy equivalent is called an appetizing store.
I imagine there is less food borne illness with keeping kosher not combining both Milk & Meat. Cross contamination.
Vastly less.
If the cow's skin was ever pierced or ever broke a bone, it's not kosher. So the cows are kept in safer conditions to protect them.
If the cow ever required antibiotics, it's not kosher. So the cows are kept in cleaner conditions to keep them healthy.
The cow is slaughtered by a single slice of a razor sharp blade across its throat, preventing suffering and distress. But also prevent the release of stress hormones into the meat which are known to cause it to spoil faster.
If the lungs of the cow has any dark spots, it's not kosher. So after slaughter the cow is examined again for it's health.
Then the meat is salted to remove blood, which makes the taste better but also significantly reduces bacterial growth and spoiling.
@gavinriley5232 Lots of steps l had heard about the slaughter but that was it. Thanks for sharing your information.
The oral Torah isn’t an interpretation of the written Torah.. it’s two different and related Torahs that work together. The oral Torah came BEFORE the written.
Kind of depends. Some use the term "oral Torah" to mean only the mishnayot, which is what you are referring to.
But some use the term "oral Torah" to include gemara, tosefta, kabbalah, chassidus, and commentaries.
I went on Sefaria, and I can't find a single translation that would agree with what you presented at 4:18. Every translation states 'kid' and 'mother's milk.' Not 'any kosher animal' and 'any milk.' Crazy that the scholars that spent years putting together the JPS are being told they are wrong by a random youtube video.
Great video. PS: I caught a glimpse of Micah Smith. Send him my warm regards. :)
😘
So basically are you a Chinese Jew from Kaifung or else you might be a convert.
Sweet!
I've been a butcher in the past 😊
I've been working with cheese in the past 😊
The opposite of meat is salad. The opposite of milk is sand.
Note: this is just an nonreligious reasoning
Everyone thinks the rule is about food. No; it's about relationships.
Correct. The opposite of meat (basar) is salad (eisev). But what do you mean the opposite of milk is sand. Please explain that part.
@garrettlees milk is sustenance that is a flowing liquid. Sand also flows, but is dry, coarse, and erodes, and is equated with death. Wandering in the desert, vs latched on to the mother's life giving, nurturing bosom.
@@5thHouse interesting
Dear Jennifer, thanks for the reply. I am a Jew. I will note I don’t like politicians dictating their leftist views to control me. Nor do I want to Rabbis dictating as they do for anyone who is ultra orthodox or Haredi. As a Jew I can turn to a Rabbi for hopefully his knowledge & wisdom with respect to life & Halacha. It is the way that what the majority agrees to do with respect to Halacha is the way. I do not question HaShem but I do question much of our appreciation and understanding of Halacha. Remember that when HaShem led us out of bondage into the desert, it is said that only one out of 200 hundred Jews left either Moshe Rabeinu. That is incredible to me, that so many remained as slaves. Well most of us are sheeple. The Rabbis failed us in the Holocaust, not HaShem. The Rabbis are failing us today both in Israel & in America. If you completely abdicate your HaShem given critical thinking, then more then ever I pray that HaShem protects you. But never did HaShem tell you to walk in the middle of rush hour traffic and as long as you believe I’ll save you. You must do for yourself and believe. Get
תורה בעל פה
But that leaves a lot open to manipulation by our Rabbis. In Bereshite HaShem told Moshe just before we entered the holy land promised to us that We were to be a light to bring HaShem’s way to the world. And if we didn’t we would suffer exile etc. how do you think we are doing?
Most of us are sheeple, indeed. Meat is not kosher. It's trayf.
Completely agree with you! It’s the blind leading the blind! I almost became a Jew by converting but I’m “Jew-ish” (some DNA) and practice with a congregation that follows Judaism closer to Orthodox than Reform and also read Brit Chadasha!
I urge you [beg you🙏] to read Brit Chadasha (only TOJB, NMV, CJB, KJV and YLT versions] just for interest or as Oral Torah! You will see exactly what you said is what the issue was at hand - with Yeshua Ben Yosef (NOTJesus !!)! Don’t believe Christianity it’s a decoy to those who want the nice easy life! Also, funny but truth their leaders have done copy and paste from the Jewish leaders!, and taken it even higher with fancy cars, and planes! [he that ignores history will definitely repeat it].
If a rabbi or priest is not a servant of the people and one of the poor ones of that congregation then there is something wrong there! Baruch HaShem!
“Woe to you P’rushim (Pharisees) [separatists] and Torah-teachers (Scribes), hypocrites because you close up the Kingdom of heaven before men; you yourselves do not enter and those who wish to enter you do not permit to enter”.
“But oy to you, Sofrim and Perushim, tzevuim (hypocrites), for in front of Bnei Adam you shut the Malchut HaShomayim. You do not go in yourselves, and the ones entering, you do not permit to enter
“Woe to them, Torah-teachers (Scribes) and P’rushim (Pharisee [separatist]s) [separatists], who tithe mint, dill and pomegranate, but who commit robbery and leave undone that which is weightier, that is, the judgments of the Torah which are: kindness, tand faithfulness. These are commands worthy of doing; one should not forget them”.
Oy to you, Sofrim and Perushim, tzevuim, for you give maasros (tithe) of mint and dill and cumin, and you have neglected the matters of the Torah of greater consequence: mishpat, chesed, and emunah. These things it was necessary to do and those not to neglect.
“Woe to you P’rushim (Pharisees) [separatists] and Torah-teachers (Scribes), because you cleanse cups and platters on the outside but inside them is full of wickedness and uncleanness”. “Hypocrites, cleanse first that which is inside in order that that which is outside might be pure”.”
Matthew 23:13, 23, 25-26
Oy to you, Sofrim and Perushim, tzevuim, you cleanse the outside of the kos (cup) and the dish, but inside they are full of chamdanut (greed) and taavanut (lust). Blind Parush, first cleanse the inside of the kos, that perhaps also the outside may become clean.”
Mattityahu 23:13, 23, 25-26
@@aleftav12 Thank you for your amazing response and recommendation. I can't wait to read it. Can I ask, are you Essene?
אח שלי זה אחד הסירטונים היותר טובים בנושא כשרות
וזה מגיע למקומות מאוד פנימיים
מהות האכילה של יהודי
ואיך יהודי אוכל ומה התכלית באכילה
--
כל האחרים אוכלים בשביל לשרוד והאמונה שלהם במקנשים ובמנזרים שם הם משקיעים כסף יוקרה ופאר
והרב בסירטון מסביר שאצלינו זה בתוך הבית במטבח כשר מיוחד וקדוש
תן לי עוד מהתוכן המעולה הזה
תודה רבה ליוצרים ולמנחה המעולה
מאחל לך חתונה השנה
תודה אחי! הירשם כדי לראות עוד סרטונים שלנו
Wow! Subscribed immediately! Brilliant work!
Well explained Rabbi! And the Kabbalah is also on point! Whilst it makes sense, I do think HaShem intention was for us to live our lives and not be hamstrung with too much weeds! To go to this lengths to separate meat and milk and then ignore your brother ie another human soul (Jew or non-Jew) begging and dying in the street and you have a house with two kitchens and fridges etc… is losing the purpose of life! “Missing the wood for the trees!”
This was the first sin Rabbi,
“Now the Nachash was more arum (cunning, crafty, wiley) than any beast of the sadeh which Hashem Elohim had made. And he said unto the (woman), REALLY? Hath Elohim said, Ye shall not eat of kol etz hagan (garden)?”Bereshit 3:1
The Adversary was use detail to debate the Oral Torah given to our first parents!
This is what’s leading both Jews and Gentiles alike into condemnation! Why? Because it’s impossible to be a good Jew and be poor - so we accumulate all the money in order to do our mitzvah, live walking distance to shul and Gentiles, they look at the Jewish life and say aibo, (means 😮 wow) I can’t live like that so I follow Jesus - where I don’t have to be wealthy to be a good person! Meanwhile Jesus is the “unkosher” imposter from Rome and Yeshua the real Yehudi of Jews who took a balanced view of walking the narrow path and exercise chesed on those that would not be able to destroy a whole rainforest just to ensure they separated milk and meat, starve because they could not wash their hands before a meal (nitliyat hadamin) - we also have these rules as a Semitic African people but we have not taken them to heaven and hell and back!
It is for this reason actually HaShem does not give this verse alone but in context! Please hear me out: see the verses…
The Bible verse that says "do not cook a kid in its mother's milk" appears in Exodus 23:19, Exodus 34:26, and Deuteronomy 14:21:
Exodus 23:19
"The first of the first-fruits of thy ground thou shalt bring into the house of Jehovah thy God. Thou shalt not boil a kid in its mother's milk".
“The reshit bikkurim of thy land thou shalt bring into the Bais Hashem Eloheicha. Thou shalt not cook a kid in his motherʼs cholov.”
Shemot 23:19
Exodus 34:26
"The choicest first-fruits of thy land thou shalt bring unto the house of the Lord thy God. Thou shalt not seethe a kid in its mother's milk".
“The reshit bikkurim of thy land thou shalt bring unto the Beit Hashem Eloheicha. Thou shalt not cook a kid in cholov immo.”
Shemot 34:26
Deuteronomy 14:21
"Ye shall not eat of any thing that dieth of itself; thou mayest give it unto the stranger that is within thy gates, that he may eat it; or thou mayest sell it unto a foreigner; for thou art a holy people unto the Lord thy God. Thou shalt not seethe a kid in its mother's milk".
“Ye shall not eat of anything that dieth of itself; thou shalt give it unto the ger that is in thy she'arim, that he may eat it; or thou mayest sell it unto an alien; for thou art an Am Kadosh unto Hashem Eloheicha. Thou shalt not boil a young goat in its motherʼs cholov.”
Devarim 14:21
To me the meaning is obvious on a read of this! Basically the give of life (HaShem) shall not eat or destroy or suffocate the life of its young and it extends to and that which He (the give of life, the Kodesh One) gives to give us life [Life breath, Spirit, soul, food for life, the Tree of Life (Etz Chaim) - the Word, Torah] Milk, you should not use to destroy life to gain life or strength! - even when you see pagans doing it to gain life from their gods! Why? Because I HaShem your God-Elohim doesn’t do that! Ye be kodesh (holy) because I’m kodesh (holy)! - this is to worlds priests the Jews!
This why he gave us the rainbow 🌈 in Bereshit showing that water which supports life he will not again use to destroy life (even though) he was not cooking life for his benefit or consumption which is doubly worse! - death only benefits the HaSatan!’
This is the problem with Oral Torah it takes one evil person to add or to pass on untruths and the whole generation is lost! If written Torah has differences as we know imagine word of mouth in this day and age! We are not when generations saw their 5th generation born!
I do love and honour that you [Jewish] have tried so much to walk in HaShem’s ways but be careful that for whatever credit you put on your account you’re putting 100 debits - that’s the problem with chasing the wood for the trees Rabbi! Am Yisra’el Chai! Just a view of ‘Jew-ish’ sheep of the great shepherd!
We will ALL sit before the righteous judge and explain our actions!
Much love…
Shalom Shalom!
Baruch HaShem!🙏🔥🙌🏾
If you love somebody, you'll do things for them even if you don't completely understand why they wat you to do it. If your pregnant wife wants pickles and peanut butter ice cream at 9pm, you don't argue with her about why she wants it - you put on your shoes and go to the grocery store, you know? God asks Jews not to mix milk and meat - it's not a huge ask.
But what if your pregnant wife wants a cheeseburger?
Great Job and nice presentation. But let’s go back to Torah B’ al peh.
I give you several arguments to ponder. The Kippah was not worn at Mount Sinai, it came into norm about the 2nd temple period. Why is a chicken considered meat yet an egg is parve? What if in fact we have mis interpreted HaShem’s meaning & wants and are just following dictates by Rabbis. Why can you essentially eat a milk product clean your mouth and then eat meat. But for meat you must wait 6 hours? Why 6 why not four or 8 hours? Note the Amidah was once only two sentences to day it’s 19 albeit we also call the prayer Shemona esraei? Why is turning on the lights considered work and thus not done on Shabbat. But if one lights a candle before Shabbat it’s kosher to transfer the flame to another candle? Thank you Rabbis for the dictates & interpretations. But I question the origin of many of our practices. An unapologetic Jew.
@@gingebrien2408 We can't know for sure. But the halachic rules we currently follow are the result of centuries of scholarship from the greatest Jewish minds of the post-exilic period. When in doubt, it makes sense to me to rely on Rashi or Maimonedes, you know? Plus, Jewish tradition has always emphasized the idea that God wants our best efforts and doesn't really expect perfection from most of us (we aren't Moses!). You see this distinction in the laws - like how if you don't know/forget it's Shabbat and you kindle a fire, you can atone for this with a sacrifice. If we no longer know exactly what God wants from us, but we keep to our best understanding of what Torah says, then I have faith that we are still on the right path.
There's even some modern situations that deal with this - like how there's a company now making what they claim is tekhelet blue dye for tzitzit strings. It's made from the same snail that we know was used to make royal purple dye in the Roman era, but a different approach is used to set the dye that makes it turn blue instead of purple. Some Jews wear the blue string in their tzitzit now, but others aren't comfortable with this and still wear all white strings. This is because we don't actually know for sure how to make tekhelet - the process was lost to history. Maybe this new dye is the correct dye, and maybe it isn't. So like all things, each of us needs to use our best judgement and stay humble in our approach to halacha.
@@Jennifer-cl1clExactly HaShem wants everything in moderation! Not destroying earth to keep meat and milk separate that is NOT the intention of this verse! The Oral Torah is wrong or if it is correct it’s only for Moshe’s of this world - who is like Moshe or the Shepherd! Let them raise their hand. I sin on the first breath…of rising! Even in my dreams I break HaShem instructions!
Let us not miss the wood for the trees!
Baruch HaShem!
@@jbs0009
Then get the fake cheese, or fake meat.
If your pregnant wife wants poison, you don't give it to her.
They are not supposed to eat blood in the meat but they do it. People do what they want to do.
Todah Rabah ✡️
Don’t mix life and death.
yes. in fact, avoid death altogether. reject meat
@@garrettlees
You're correct ultimately according to Jewish law. There were 3 times in history where the entire world was vegetarian (and some were vegan).
1) garden of Eden
2) Noah's ark
3) in the future world of the Messiah
It is a higher level of spirituality that eventually the entire world will attain. You just got there a little early.
@@gavinriley5232 Thank you, brother. Amazing response. Looking forward to seeing you in a Messianic vegetarian reality
I love your videos. You might have made the (obvious) observation that milk and meat come from the same animals. I'm sure the rabbi would have some insight into that too :)
What would non Jews say are the opposites?
“What’s the opposite of meat?”
Non-Jew: “Tofu.”
@HazzanDevorahFick good point
Rather selfishly and off topic, I am happiest for the halachic Asian Jewish representation. I'd like to believe if I was still in Israel, we'd meet. Maybe our paths will cross one day.
Great video and interesting explanation behind it. However It remains a stupid idea which from a materialist perspective requires so much effort to adhere to the rule, the effort could be better spent on other things. There is no scientific reason why it is positive to segregate meat and milk.
Eating cheese bacon burger would bring you DOUBLE SINS.
Eating pork, eating pork with dairy, eating beef with dairy, and if you said a blessing over the food then also saying a blessing in vain.
So there are cute asian jewish girls well versed in Kabbalah? You learn something everyday I guess!
Yes, and cute French old ladies, too!
@@DrD2You😂❤
every where else tho where it would say G'di would just be like a baby goat tho? Hard to believe they interpreted that correctly. More likely it was a prohibition of a pagan practice, where pagans literally cooked a baby goat in the mother's milk.
🎉
That’s the thing about religion you get into it then they tell you what you believe and then you start defending those beliefs.
Believe ?? I don't think Jewish people "believe" in NOT eating milk with meat : instead it is one of 613 commandments in the the Old Testament .
Hence, a religious Jew may believe that eating such a combination is phsyically harmless, but violates God's commandment.
What percentage of jews follow kosher laws??
Most of us
@chanabayla1823 I doubt that. A lot of Jews I know are atheists or at least secular.
the real question is why is vegan-cheeseburgers not Kosher!
Why not?
ни хера не понятно, но очень интересно
This is a stretch upon a stretch upon another stretch, why don't you just listen to the Torah and don't cook a child of any animal (nowhere does it say kosher) in "it's" mother's milk (not any milk), if you're worried it's mother's milk could be mixed in, use milk from a different type of animal.
Because when Moshe received the Torah on Mt. Sinai, he was also taught the oral tradition which expounds upon the verse, and the significance of it being written 3 times. I think a very problematic misconception is that the oral tradition was just invented by the rabbis, when in reality it was practiced and transmitted from Moshe’s time.
Theres a reason. That video uploads false content about things they arnt obligated to concern about.
How about an explanation from the 'rabid' rabbi.
The 'mother's milk' refers to the teachings of the Torah. Torah is a feminine word - thus the 'mother of all' is the 'law'.
Since a goat represents those who are rebellious to the 'unbreakable law', and the 'milk' the teachings, it should be plain to see why these do not go together.
Do NOT let the LEFT HAND know what the RIGHT HAND is doing had more MEAT inside than is obvious.
Each 'hand' has a divine purpose and symbolic meaning. See Isaiah 45:7
Any word that ends in 'ah' is feminine. Thus, Torah, Ruah (spirit), and Rah (evil) are all feminine words.
Quite the stretch. A more practical read would be don't take and consume a young animal before it's weaned from nursing. Jewish mysticism makes many questionable declarations, some of which state when lying to others is acceptable and required. After such a declaration, what's to be believed?
Wait so the Asian girl is Jewish...??
Yes she is. A Jew can be of any race although we are an ethno religious group.
It's something that antisemites have a hard time with.
The first Jews had an homogeneous background but as we are welcoming converts among us without other restrictions than religious ones, our typology evolved. What we call gerout or conversion is in reality much more than that: it's an adoption into our nation, so race is not relevant. In the same manner Native Americans used to adopt white or black people into their tribes that's why you have black Seminoles and blue eyed Cherokees.
So this young woman could be a Jew because both her parents are Jewish, or only her mother, or she might have been adopted, or she can be a convert.
Noa Argaman one of the surviving hostages is of Chinese origin, her mother Liora z"l who died shortly after her liberation was a convert .
Israel is the true rainbow 🌈 nation.
@@Iditsl So its not anything ethnic about it. Just an ideology.
@@SamianHQuazi Judaism is both a faith and an ethnicity. DNA studies show that most Jewish men and many Arab men are descended from the same Middle Eastern male who lived approximately 4000 years ago. HTH.
@@Iditsl Amen! Baruch Hashem!
@@DrD2You lol so if you start believing a new religion you can change your ethnicity? Get real
Very interesting video. But I wonder about the kosher cheeseburger - doesn't putting a "fake" cheese defeat the purpose, the same way as "real" cheese? If it looks like a cheeseburger, smells like a cheeseburger, and tastes like a cheeseburger, then it's a cheeseburger, isn't it? It somewhat feels to me like it's trying to find a loophole in the law, and if so, why bother with the law itself? Just have a normal cheeseburger...
I agree that eating fake cheeseburger or fake bacon is fake observance.
I’ll admit it looks wrong, but it’s clearly not milk. Someone who is lactose intolerant won’t drink milk, but he could drink almond/oat/cashew milk. Fake cheese is just not cheese, no matter how hard it pretends to be.
@PALE1ISTEHBEST Right, it is not real cheese, but I think there is a difference between an intolerance and a religious law. In case of intolerance, the issue is the ingredient itself. In the case of religion, the issue is with what the ingredient symbolizes. Fake cheese still somewhat symbolizes the same thing as real cheese. It may solve the problem for an intolerant person, but for a religious person? Seems to me it just misses the very purpose of not mixing meat and dairy, even when just "fake" dairy.
No.
Cooking a baby goat in its mother’s milk was a common Canaanite ritualistic practice. God wanted to prevent the children of Israel from participating in paganism so He established a law for it.
In other words, it’s okay to mix dairy and meat, but it’s not okay to literally boil a baby of any kind in its mother's milk.
You're completely wrong lmfao
@ Sure.
@@zGoldie i mean you never provided proof lol
@@tuff947 The texts referencing Canaanite rituals of cooking meat in milk found at Ugarit are fragmented. There is no consensus that these references are the source of the biblical prohibition to not cook young goats in their mother's milk.
But the proof that the Torah does not prohibit eating milk and meat together is right in the Torah itself. There are 3 references to this prohibition (Exodus 23:19, 34:26 and Deuteronomy 14:21) and they all reference cooking (בשׁל) not eating. And they all refer to a גדי which is certainly referring to a young goat and perhaps also a young lamb, but certainly not beef or fowl. The expansion of this prohibition created by our sages is based on mysticism, not the Torah given to Moshe.
And yet they adopted YHWH, a Canaanite god. Go figure…😂😂😂
i’m Jewish. never eaten kosher and i NEVER will. chzburgers and shrimp scampi all the way!!!
Sorry this is just too much philosophy when the reality is just a matter of basic morality! Think about it, you take the kid and cook it in his mother's milk ?? Don't you see why it is morally wrong ? 🤷🏻♂️
European mysticists have no problem regarding the mixing of meat and milk. I even sometimes eat pork and bacon. My Jewish prophet doesn't see an issue with it. We still believe organic cattle are better than bio-factory-raised ones. A farm has to elevate the energy of the animals, otherwise it will be cursed by God and hunted down by the government. I hope you learnt something from me. We also put more emphasis on mindful living than church/synagogue service in our faith. We do most of our religion at home.
That's really interesting. Could you share more about your religious practice? Is this like a Kabbalist idea? What sort of mysticism are you practicing?
What is the name of your "Jewish prophet"?