@@kahsin1342 他说是7:52的时候these kinds of fabrics 应该有s, 可是我觉得嘉尔没错，仔细听嘉尔说kind时是kind, 不是kinds,所以可能他不是统一的说明选择的布料，而是把不同布料单独挑出来一个一个的说成singular 'this kind of fabric'，不是plural form 的these kinds of fabrics,所以没必要加s? 我个人觉得非要说个问题就是'my parents just like, love Jackson so much', 可是要分析也是有两种方法，可以解读成(my parents)(just like)(love jackson so much) 或是(my parents)(just)(like/love jackson so much), 如果是第一种把just like归类为想事情用的多余词，那就在my parents 后加 are/were会顺畅一些, 变成(my parents are/were)(just like)(love jackson so much),可是如果解读成第二种，把just和like分开解读各自的字面意思，那嘉尔是没错的，对错就看怎么解读吧，嘉尔那句子的断句和音调确实比较像第一种解读，可是英语不像中文有规定的语调，如果嘉尔本人说他要表达的是第二种，就不能说他语法有问题了。
Nyte Lyte good enough, considering he knows like 7 languages. And he is also a rapper and all the other stuff so it is impressive if you stack everything
I am a native english speaker and am bi-lingual in Chinese, Jackson speaks fluent english. He's bi-lingual and sometimes it slips up. BUT HE IS FLUENT.
Jackson is such a good man, who respect everyone, but shows no fear when he’s performing. It’s interesting to hear how he uses English words, as he can be cool without using rude words.
You should review Jackson's interview with Zach Sang. They talked about some really deep topics and I was so impressed by how articulate he was. He used a lot of analogies, metaphors, etc.
Jackson sounds native mostly because he went to international school back in HongKong, and his supposedly-to-be native tongue, Cantonese, is not even that good. He doesn’t read much Chinese. I think his shanghainese is quite good because of his mom and mother side grandparents? His mandarin has only recently gotten better since he hosted and attended some reality shows in mainland China.
zaddy bigballs didn’t say he wasn’t. I do like him a lot. Just stating the fact why his English sounds native, and don’t think there is a need to evaluate his English at all.
True Jackson learned from American teachers and students at the American International School. Native-speaker of English here. Seems comfortable from him. I think he feels just as good in expressing his thoughts in Cantonese. He also does HK interviews. In an English-speaking Coachella video, Mr Wang says he counts in Cantonese during his stretches because it his first language. Speaking is one thing, but Reading is another. Jackson did go to a local school in Hong Kong for some time, but he went to and spent more time at an International School so of course his reading in Chinese Cantonese is not as developed as in English. This is all just in my opinion.
Kris lived abroad for years tho (both Canada and US, I think?) but Jackson really just lived his whole life in Hong Kong/Shanghai/Rest of China and then straight to Korea. But I love them both 💖
GOT7 fans, please realize the sole purpose of these videos is to teach people English. He's showing how popular (Chinese) celebrities speak English, why they say what they say, when to use phrases/words, and whether or not it is formal or informal. That's it. It isn't criticism. Chris isn't saying that Jackson has horrible English nor is he making fun of him if he corrects his English. This channel is focused on TEACHING people (mainly Chinese speaking) how to speak English efficiently and naturally. If Chris corrects Jackson's English, it isn't being Chris is being negative toward Jackson. He's JUST teaching. Realize the differences and stop being so emotionally defensive.
Wo de Putonghua shi bu hao. Can you Tube provide a translate button for the comment section where native speakers render characters like they have on Facebook?
Actually someone has already lmao. Check out ChineseWith-Xiaolu 's UA-cam channel she's a chinese teacher and she analyzed chris's chinese in one of her videos
soy fan de jackson wang y got7 gracias por tu apreciación el mismo ya que habla 5 idiomas y el mismo se disculpa por sus faltas y errores al hablar y quería saber por que no pones subtitulos en español
I think Chris was just trying to help anyone who wants to perfect their "American" English, and learn to speak like a native... No argument that being understood is the most important first step. Some folks just want to sound like a native to blend in.
Can you make a vid about Mina of twice please ?she used to live in USA . She s my ult bias n I lookin for a vid about her engishhhhh thank you so much Laoma chris
It's kind of insulting to rate Jackson's English. He's fluent and feels most comfortable when speaking English. Like for me, i am trilingual but english is my native tongue. However, we fall in the category of knowing multiple languages but categorized as not "fluent" in all is complete bs to me lol.
Oh gosh... I didn't see any disrespect here AT ALL! If anything it was a compliment! He was using this to help teach English to non-english speakers! Plus, Chris speaks more languages than even you do! I cannot imagine him ever being rude. Perhaps you didn't understand why he was rating it? Or perhaps you were in the mood to take offense where none was given. Anyway, Chris certainly never even implied the guy wasn't fluent in Eng. Maybe watch it again with an open mind and heart. Peace.
Hey I've been following this channel for a while as an ABC who's into linguistics and likes to watch his videos to learn how to discuss linguistic topics in Chinese and I think there's a major misunderstanding - he never does a purely binary rating of fluent and not fluent. The main audience of his channel are Chinese speakers who want to learn how to sound more natural while speaking colloquial English, and the purpose of his analyses is to point out what makes people's English sound native and nonnative (both good and bad things they do) which learners can then apply in practice. These can range from phonological patterns (e.g. the alveolar flap he mentioned), vocabulary choices (slang, filler words), as well as prosodic elements (stress, intonation, flow, cadence). Yeah I see the exhaustion that many diasporic people have when it comes to being judged (especially often and ironically by monolingual Westerners) for their language skills but I assure you that this guy isn't about that. He's a polyglot, but also a linguistically trained EFL teacher who knows what he's talking about can clearly break these concepts down.
Yeah, like everyone is saying, Chinese people wanting to learn English look up to these idols as examples to model their English after. Chris isn't "rating" anything.
Yeah, like everyone is saying, Chinese people wanting to learn English look up to these idols as examples to model their English after. Chris isn't "rating" anything.
This was fascinating. (Have you checked out Jimmy O. Yang's standup routine on Netflix? He sounds like he was born and raised in the states, but apparently didn't get here until he was 13... Anyway, it's hilarious and I'd love to know what you think of his English)
Not all Americans speak perfect English, lol. It is ridiculous to compare Kris and Jackson. One is from Canada, an English speaking country and the other is from Hong Kong, an Asian country which uses Cantonese as a common language.
Hey, Jacky! Thanks for the comment! Regarding the first comment, that's for sure true. There are many people uneducated people who don't speak the standard language of their country well. As for the Kris/Jackson comparison, Kris actually isn't from Canada. He just happens to have a Canadian passport and lived there for 5 years from age 10 to 15. In many ways, Jackson probably had a similar level of exposure to English in his childhood because he was at an American international school in Hong Kong. At the end of the day though, they both speak phenomenal English, well beyond what any normal person would need to meet their needs.
According to his interviews, he speaks English, Cantonese, Mandarin and Shanghai dialect, and a little bit French. I can not tell how well he speaks English or Cantonese. He was educated in International School, so his English is supposed to be pretty good. however his Mandarin level and Shanghai dialect level are quite limited.
王嘉尔不只是英文厉害，用词口语地道，虽然没在美国居住，我感觉他性格也是很开放很符合美国人文化，所以去美国电台或采访都聊得特别自然特别开，不会尴尬，这是他很大的优势，也是特别受美国粉丝和电台采访喜爱的原因之一。
他在初中時是讀美式學校。我一直以來都是英式的（紐西蘭也是偏英式的）。
可以讲讲他哪里错了吗 我没找到他的语法错误在哪 求解
@@kahsin1342 他说是7:52的时候these kinds of fabrics 应该有s, 可是我觉得嘉尔没错，仔细听嘉尔说kind时是kind, 不是kinds,所以可能他不是统一的说明选择的布料，而是把不同布料单独挑出来一个一个的说成singular 'this kind of fabric'，不是plural form 的these kinds of fabrics,所以没必要加s? 我个人觉得非要说个问题就是'my parents just like, love Jackson so much', 可是要分析也是有两种方法，可以解读成(my parents)(just like)(love jackson so much) 或是(my parents)(just)(like/love jackson so much), 如果是第一种把just like归类为想事情用的多余词，那就在my parents 后加 are/were会顺畅一些, 变成(my parents are/were)(just like)(love jackson so much),可是如果解读成第二种，把just和like分开解读各自的字面意思，那嘉尔是没错的，对错就看怎么解读吧，嘉尔那句子的断句和音调确实比较像第一种解读，可是英语不像中文有规定的语调，如果嘉尔本人说他要表达的是第二种，就不能说他语法有问题了。
可香港人幾乎人人都會英文 跟他讀什麼沒太大關係 只要在香港英文是一定要學的
Thunderstar_ Warrior 對，是要學，但不是每個人都能說得這麼地道，很多人都有濃濃的港式口音，亦有不少人說英文說得不流暢
As an American who lives in Los Angeles, I can tell you Jackson speaks perfect English.
really?
He speaks pretty well. But you can hear his accent slip out at times. Its very subtle though.
Nyte Lyte good enough, considering he knows like 7 languages. And he is also a rapper and all the other stuff so it is impressive if you stack everything
@@colinluo9360 Yeah, I agree. Hes very talented. Not taking that away from him.
I am a native english speaker and am bi-lingual in Chinese, Jackson speaks fluent english. He's bi-lingual and sometimes it slips up. BUT HE IS FLUENT.
Jackson is such a good man, who respect everyone, but shows no fear when he’s performing. It’s interesting to hear how he uses English words, as he can be cool without using rude words.
You should do a joke video analysing Trump's English.
we're on the same page.
OMG!! I would so love that!!! (trump knows all the best words)
Couldn’t agree more
＋1
Nobody knows English better than Trump does
王嘉爾我是很喜歡的，很謙虛很有才華，重要是很帥。他說他每種語言，只是會生活的程度，真的太謙虛了。
Hola
还有礼貌 还是个拿过无数个奖的前运动员 rap 跳舞 唱歌都很吊
他真的完美啊
对啊，骄傲！
@@路酒骨寒 no entiendo japonés xd
SOLO ABLO ESPAÑOM XD
You should review Jackson's interview with Zach Sang. They talked about some really deep topics and I was so impressed by how articulate he was. He used a lot of analogies, metaphors, etc.
DUDE AS SOMEONE WHO CAN SPEAKE SPANISH PORTUGUESE AND ENGLISH I LOVEEEEE THIS CONTENT!
Jackson Wang just a good stuff of everything in language also好有鬥心的音藝人值得respect💪🏽👍🏻🌹🥰🙏🏼🙏🏼
Jackson sounds native mostly because he went to international school back in HongKong, and his supposedly-to-be native tongue, Cantonese, is not even that good. He doesn’t read much Chinese. I think his shanghainese is quite good because of his mom and mother side grandparents? His mandarin has only recently gotten better since he hosted and attended some reality shows in mainland China.
Can’t deny he’s fucking talented though 从击剑到说唱到主持啥都能干
zaddy bigballs didn’t say he wasn’t. I do like him a lot. Just stating the fact why his English sounds native, and don’t think there is a need to evaluate his English at all.
=.= even his korean is better than his chinese tbh. Ahahhaha...
In my opinion his Chinese is very good in both mandarin and Cantonese
True Jackson learned from American teachers and students at the American International School. Native-speaker of English here. Seems comfortable from him. I think he feels just as good in expressing his thoughts in Cantonese. He also does HK interviews. In an English-speaking Coachella video, Mr Wang says he counts in Cantonese during his stretches because it his first language.
Speaking is one thing, but Reading is another. Jackson did go to a local school in Hong Kong for some time, but he went to and spent more time at an International School so of course his reading in Chinese Cantonese is not as developed as in English. This is all just in my opinion.
正在上老马的英语课，第一次上网课，感觉很新鲜，每周的直播也是很多干货!希望老马在美国🇺🇸也能常更新，当然是在安全的条件下↓
我刚看完王嘉尔的搞笑合集，就发现老马你上传王嘉尔的英语测评了😂好巧啊
Me encanta que seas muy desenvuelto!!! 🤗🤗🤗 Me gustan los contenidos de tus vídeos!
Kris lived abroad for years tho (both Canada and US, I think?) but Jackson really just lived his whole life in Hong Kong/Shanghai/Rest of China and then straight to Korea.
But I love them both 💖
Brazilian here, I really like your videos, because they help me to improve English and also to know more about Chinese culture
Mi admiración jovencito , como domina los idiomas inglés y chino 👌
王嘉尔的中文也是进步超快的😜
嘉尔英文好好，你的中文也超棒的
I like your explanation
Very helpful videos. Support from China.
最初关注老马就是因为这样的英语研究。以后多做这样视频吧，我一个来美国3年的人，还是刚知道cats and dogs这种。老马视频用来学俚语真的很受用。不光中国idol，美国艺人的分析也可以有啊~
⬇️看到王嘉尔的名字直接点进来的🤣
GOT7 fans, please realize the sole purpose of these videos is to teach people English. He's showing how popular (Chinese) celebrities speak English, why they say what they say, when to use phrases/words, and whether or not it is formal or informal. That's it. It isn't criticism. Chris isn't saying that Jackson has horrible English nor is he making fun of him if he corrects his English. This channel is focused on TEACHING people (mainly Chinese speaking) how to speak English efficiently and naturally. If Chris corrects Jackson's English, it isn't being Chris is being negative toward Jackson. He's JUST teaching. Realize the differences and stop being so emotionally defensive.
終於等到了😍😍😍
Trevor Noah is hella funny. I'm glad you included him this time.
王嘉尔❤❤❤❤
He’s practically fluent... but I love your vids. I’m learning mandarin and your videos are really helpful and interesting!
Jackson Wang 😙
他唱的＂安靜＂是我聽過最好聽的版本
Wo de Putonghua shi bu hao. Can you Tube provide a translate button for the comment section where native speakers render characters like they have on Facebook?
Ironically I use your English breakdown videos to help explain to me the equivalent in Chinese. :D
Jackson
Buenos días desde Colombia. Felicitaciones por tus excelentes videos. Te encargo un saludito. 👍
我穿越了么？以前是不是也出过Jackson的分析
他自小读国际学校，英文当然不差，不过他是剑擊青年組冠軍，王嘉尔是个阳光大男孩，而且好正面，是个好傍佯
王嘉尔英文讲得太清楚，太正式
潘玮柏，觉得他特有自己的味道
貌似老马以前分析过潘玮柏
分析得很好，very helpful, thx!
one day someone's going to analyze Chris's Chinese and rate him 5 😂
actually, someone did make a video of him and she said his Chinese is amazing lol!
Actually someone has already lmao. Check out ChineseWith-Xiaolu 's UA-cam channel she's a chinese teacher and she analyzed chris's chinese in one of her videos
Xiaoyuan Hu Link Please！
Yeah, for sure. Nobody‘s gonna doubt that
I like this content
谢谢分析嘎嘎，感觉你可以分析一下他的中文哈哈哈
Hola
哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈
哈哈哈 以推荐老炮看嘎嘎普通话搞笑集锦。
Jackson 在國際學校讀書 英文肯定好
我爱王嘉尔😭
謝謝您的短片
在座的，都知道我说的吧。。。chris教的是你在任何学校都学不到的英语~举个很恰当的例子，我们现在在说的中文，和老外说的中文是两码事对吧，但是现在chris在教的就是我们说的中文，不知道我这么说大家懂我的意思嘛~我小时候要有chris这种人教我英语，我也不至于小时候英语不及格~小时候的老师要么英语不好，要么中文不好没法教我~
Me encanta su contenido 💯
How many times you want to rate Jackson's English???
NO ONE SPEAKS BETTER CHINESE THAN YOU, YOU ARE THE BEST!
老马太谦虚了，说中文的网红外国人我基本都关注了个七七八八，包括什么世界青年说、非正式会谈以及汉语桥等等都看过，可能也就几个人能勉强和老马一战，但要说稳压一头的话我能想到的也就只有中文口语界的OG大山老师了(暴露年龄🙈)，人家毕竟是说相声的是练过功的
曹操啊，曹操中文有的一拼
@@qiufeng7594 也是哈哈，曹操也是一口京片子，真的🐮🍺
抖音一个叫王渊源的美国人,也是一口标准普通话,而且每天还读道德经,专研中国古代经典文学
过奖了过奖了！
大山和曹操都是长辈了。希望有一天我能说得跟他们一样好
老马您好，我是一个北方人，而且是一个相声爱好者（组织参加过业余相声活动）。我觉得您的中文，语法用法上几乎没有错误（往期视频记得起来的错误可能也就一处，当然这是正常现象）。发音某些词语有些奇怪，但是已经很不错了。对于一个外国人发音要跟河北承德一带完全一样字正腔圆是有些困难的，哪怕是对中国南方人也是有些困难的。反观我的英文，简直马一样，一口地道的北方口音英语，虽然在国外别人也听得懂，但是自己听自己录音还挺搞笑的😂
soy fan de jackson wang y got7 gracias por tu apreciación el mismo ya que habla 5 idiomas y el mismo se disculpa por sus faltas y errores al hablar y quería saber por que no pones subtitulos en español
If the listener can understand what the person is trying to say, that's perfect English. the rest is just "style", no right or wrong.
I think Chris was just trying to help anyone who wants to perfect their "American" English, and learn to speak like a native... No argument that being understood is the most important first step. Some folks just want to sound like a native to blend in.
謝謝分享👍
支持
学到了 👍 Thanks
Coloca los sub en español tambien..😔😔😔
教得很好呀！👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
I love Jackson! He is a language talent, he speaks, if I’m not wrong, 5 languages fluently! His speaks English fluently!
可以分析一下Lily Chen的英文吗
Cuando vas a enseñar Inglés y chino para los hipanohablantes?
👍👍👍支持老炮！你还是说中文吧，怎么听英文反而别扭了，来自美国加州的问候！希望大家平安健康
王嘉尔！！！
马斯瑞，你中文比一半的中国人好了！
自信点 不止一半
普通话只是现在方便国人交流的，普通话好不代表中文好。
只是普通话而已，方言讲得好不就能算中文好了？
@@打鸡鸡的三分 看老马早期视频，他北京话说得贼溜，我这种南方人可能一辈子都捋不顺舌头
@@biasbalance4376 我没说他北京话不好。我只是想表示普通话好不代表中文好。老一辈的人不好普通话，难道中文还不如外国人?
I think you can do Jackson's Mandarin from 2015, when his Mandarin wasn't fluent until now, where he lost his Cantonese accent.
Nice video, you have mentioned several times that you are a polyglot, could you please tell us what languages you speak?
马老师您好！，我听不懂学校教的语法课，请问我该怎么办？我很想学懂英语。
嘉尔呀！怀挺～
Ik you're an English teacher but i wish you did these or something similar for mandarin
This is such a brilliant way to learn Chinese
who is the singer at 2:30? she's super cool
第一
又学到了
Por qué no hay subtítulos en español 💔
Can you make a vid about Mina of twice please ?she used to live in USA . She s my ult bias n I lookin for a vid about her engishhhhh thank you so much
Laoma chris
請問有人知道中間那段2:30是出自哪裡的影片嗎?
@ 3:44 Hmm... I am not sure using Trevor Noah, a South African, imitating American Southern accent is a good example here...
Could u please analyze 张静初？
Ppl are weird why they always put Jackson vs kris they're friends and never show any hate to each other
Thiiiis, and they're accents come from different parts
Kris lived in Canada and Jackson, I think his accent is more like American accent
Yep, but please write the first letter of Kris' name in capital letter
Wonderful💕 Hi of Perú..
Hola no se inglés podrías poner subtítulos no siempre nos deja UA-cam plis
谢谢你
求分析雷柏辛Lexie的英语
cuz he studied at American International School in HK.
Ta shuo hen kuai. I find his northern / Harbin style twang hard to follow too.
我个人觉得jackson比kris说的自然 可能因为kris不怎么说了 每次听他说英语感觉很刻意 而且kris说的太短 不太说长句 这个跟我现在一样 因为不怎么说 不太有那种思维了 jackson有时候会有一丢丢奇怪说不上哪儿的地方 其余完全native的感觉 英语不说真的会rusty🤭ps 您说38个人比您中文说得好 很好奇哪38个 that precise 哈哈哈哈
我感觉kris是不熟练的同时还喜欢讲的比较“streets” 的感觉， Jackson有时候有些香港英语
嗯嗯 吴亦凡的英文真的没多好… 好多留学生都不他好… 吴说英文就很装很刻意… 不过随着吴逐渐长胖逐渐姨化 变得没那么装 貌似感觉还挺可爱 像个装x失败的小青年 哈哈哈
吴亦凡好莱坞的电影用的原声啊。
@@minoumeow6157 装逼失败？你去看看新说唱的文案，还是young og。而且人家现在去开赛车装逼了。
He studied in American International School(AIS) in HK since primary school to high school, that's probably why he speak like a native speaker.😉
No just in high school
no,since grade 3 in primary school
老马，请问一下你的英语发音课什么时候开课，在那个平台上授课的，谢谢。
It's kind of insulting to rate Jackson's English. He's fluent and feels most comfortable when speaking English. Like for me, i am trilingual but english is my native tongue. However, we fall in the category of knowing multiple languages but categorized as not "fluent" in all is complete bs to me lol.
Oh gosh... I didn't see any disrespect here AT ALL! If anything it was a compliment! He was using this to help teach English to non-english speakers! Plus, Chris speaks more languages than even you do! I cannot imagine him ever being rude. Perhaps you didn't understand why he was rating it? Or perhaps you were in the mood to take offense where none was given. Anyway, Chris certainly never even implied the guy wasn't fluent in Eng. Maybe watch it again with an open mind and heart. Peace.
Hey I've been following this channel for a while as an ABC who's into linguistics and likes to watch his videos to learn how to discuss linguistic topics in Chinese and I think there's a major misunderstanding - he never does a purely binary rating of fluent and not fluent. The main audience of his channel are Chinese speakers who want to learn how to sound more natural while speaking colloquial English, and the purpose of his analyses is to point out what makes people's English sound native and nonnative (both good and bad things they do) which learners can then apply in practice. These can range from phonological patterns (e.g. the alveolar flap he mentioned), vocabulary choices (slang, filler words), as well as prosodic elements (stress, intonation, flow, cadence). Yeah I see the exhaustion that many diasporic people have when it comes to being judged (especially often and ironically by monolingual Westerners) for their language skills but I assure you that this guy isn't about that. He's a polyglot, but also a linguistically trained EFL teacher who knows what he's talking about can clearly break these concepts down.
@@smileveryday1 Damn, a truer Chris fan there never was.
Yeah, like everyone is saying, Chinese people wanting to learn English look up to these idols as examples to model their English after. Chris isn't "rating" anything.
Yeah, like everyone is saying, Chinese people wanting to learn English look up to these idols as examples to model their English after. Chris isn't "rating" anything.
This was fascinating. (Have you checked out Jimmy O. Yang's standup routine on Netflix? He sounds like he was born and raised in the states, but apparently didn't get here until he was 13... Anyway, it's hilarious and I'd love to know what you think of his English)
可以分析一下Taylor Swift ？谢谢老马
想看博恩英語分析!
Not all Americans speak perfect English, lol. It is ridiculous to compare Kris and Jackson. One is from Canada, an English speaking country and the other is from Hong Kong, an Asian country which uses Cantonese as a common language.
Hey, Jacky! Thanks for the comment! Regarding the first comment, that's for sure true. There are many people uneducated people who don't speak the standard language of their country well.
As for the Kris/Jackson comparison, Kris actually isn't from Canada. He just happens to have a Canadian passport and lived there for 5 years from age 10 to 15. In many ways, Jackson probably had a similar level of exposure to English in his childhood because he was at an American international school in Hong Kong. At the end of the day though, they both speak phenomenal English, well beyond what any normal person would need to meet their needs.
According to his interviews, he speaks English, Cantonese, Mandarin and Shanghai dialect, and a little bit French. I can not tell how well he speaks English or Cantonese. He was educated in International School, so his English is supposed to be pretty good. however his Mandarin level and Shanghai dialect level are quite limited.
Por favor traduce al español para los que no hablamos inglés ni mandarin🙄🙏🙏🙏🙏
Please 湯唯，thank very much!
你求生意志真高
能评论一下抖音上的 Scott 学口语的博主Scott 吗😊
来分析下胡宇崴的英文
第二
馬哥～推薦分享王力宏
马思瑞分析王嘉尔的英语三遍啦！
yes, I just want to say that
吹毛求疵囉
没必要真的