Aputure 600D LED vs. Joker 800 HMI

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 37

  • @davetinoco
    @davetinoco 2 роки тому +2

    This dude seems very chill. I liked your video.

  • @MichaelTotten-e6l
    @MichaelTotten-e6l Рік тому +1

    Thanks for this. I would be curious to see a comparison between these two lights as a hard light and which one looks like actual daylight.

  • @chetcreates
    @chetcreates 2 роки тому +5

    No more HMI bulb expense. Plus, I suspect the spotlight attachment will make Joe-Leko bulb changes a thing of the past.

  • @saulcastro110
    @saulcastro110 Рік тому +3

    You will invest a little more money on a Joker hmi but you will have a light fixture for life, you will have to worrie on changing the bulb when nedded... Otherwise the aputure will turn greener after the 2k hours of usage, the light will end up on the trash because theres no way to change the led chip, you will have to buy the whole light again...

  • @creativegreats6924
    @creativegreats6924 2 роки тому +2

    is this light more powerful than a ltm 1200 hmi? because 1200 ltm hmi is 19816.36 lux (1841footcandles ) at 50 feet . how many lux is this light at 50 feet ?

    • @tallpinesstudio
      @tallpinesstudio  2 роки тому +3

      That's a good question. I don't have or use a 1200 hmi to compare. I'm also in a smaller studio so my lights are within 10- 15 feet from the subject. Another reason this led was good for me was because its power draw. It only draws 8 amps as opposed to the joker 800 which drew 12 or 13amps. A 1200 HMI would draw even more. Something to consider in a smaller studio with a power limit.

    • @cfl4286
      @cfl4286 2 роки тому +3

      I have two ltm 1200s and have worked quite a bit with the 600d. I have not metered them, but used them both in real world situations. It really depends on the situation. Spotted in, meaning the ltm with no lens vs the 600d with the fresnel, the ltm destroys the 600d. When you have to start using lenses with the 1200 (which you will usually have to do) it becomes a fairer fight. I’d say even with a wider flood lens the ltm is a bit brighter, though I don’t have numbers to back this up. It’s up to the user whether or not the increased brightness is worth the hassle of using HMIs over LEDs. Though, I find that a good 1200 watt Hmi is what I still prefer to work with over a 600d, but that’s just personal preference. Cheers

    • @creativegreats6924
      @creativegreats6924 2 роки тому

      @@cfl4286 thanks .what Chimera softbox or lantern modification do you use with the 1200ltm lights ?

    • @cfl4286
      @cfl4286 2 роки тому

      @@creativegreats6924 If I'm using it as a soft source then I usually put it through a 4x4 frame of 216 or a 8x8 bleached muslin or Grid cloth. It has the output to light a larger area if you're diffusing it. I don't have a softbox or lantern for it. I'm actually not really sure if they make one for it, but it'd definitely be cool if they did. Again, it's situational. If easy modification with softboxes is a priority then I would go with the 600D all day.

    • @creativegreats6924
      @creativegreats6924 2 роки тому

      @@cfl4286 the thing I'm worried about with Ltm 1200 is reliability because it's used and I have not got it maintenance. I hear it's good to maintenance it thru a technician who understands these type of lights . For me I would need one in southern California cause I live in vegas and that's near by . Also I was looking into selling it and getting aputure 1200d to go with two 600d . But what I get Ltm lights for in so Cal is much cheaper than a new aputure 1200d and for some reason ..I still believe the 1200 hmi lights have more throw than the aputure 1200d light but I'm not sure how much more

  • @dingdong5601
    @dingdong5601 2 роки тому +5

    I've pronounced it shamirra all my life

    • @tallpinesstudio
      @tallpinesstudio  2 роки тому

      lol you may be right

    • @dingdong5601
      @dingdong5601 2 роки тому +2

      @@tallpinesstudio It's ok. You might be new to all of this. Most seasoned gaffers/grips pronounce it "sha-mirrah". Those working in hollywood anyway. Same as new people pronouncing ARRI "are-ee". If you've ever worked in LA, everyone pronounces it "air-ee". Hell, Roger Deakins does so that's proof enough.

    • @tallpinesstudio
      @tallpinesstudio  2 роки тому

      Ya interesting I’ve called it “shamira”too in the past. Don’t know where the “chai” inspiration came from hah!

    • @jmasked5082
      @jmasked5082 2 роки тому +1

      @@dingdong5601 however the various film communities throughout the world have decided to pronounce it, the traditional way to pronounce Chimera is actually "kai-mera", like if you started to say "kite" but dropped the T. If people learnt a bit more greek mythology growing up they'd have run into it. :P

    • @dingdong5601
      @dingdong5601 2 роки тому

      @@jmasked5082 for sure. It might be the correct way in the original language but this is a video for people who may work on a set some day which might save them from embarrassment.

  • @hzubovi1
    @hzubovi1 2 роки тому +2

    What about the colour rendition?

    • @tallpinesstudio
      @tallpinesstudio  2 роки тому

      I don’t notice a difference in color between the two. The cri seems great on the aputure.

  • @cagatota
    @cagatota 2 роки тому

    Yo have to try the ETC source four series 3, it’s led flicker free and full of color.

    • @tallpinesstudio
      @tallpinesstudio  2 роки тому

      Nice! what is the output on them?

    • @cagatota
      @cagatota 2 роки тому

      @@tallpinesstudio 5908 Lux at 3 meters for a 32 degrees lens, a great choice when you need clean cuts gobos or defined shapes.

  • @JaimeRealizador
    @JaimeRealizador 2 роки тому +3

    HMI lights is better than the LED.

    • @dingdong5601
      @dingdong5601 2 роки тому +2

      All depends on the situation. But yeah, HMI color accuracy is very hard to beat.

    • @JaimeRealizador
      @JaimeRealizador 2 роки тому

      @@dingdong5601 Thanks for response.

    • @tallpinesstudio
      @tallpinesstudio  Рік тому

      ya HMI color is great

  • @MichaelTotten-e6l
    @MichaelTotten-e6l Рік тому

    Thanks for this. I would be curious to see a comparison between these two lights as a hard light and which one looks like actual daylight.