Steely Dan - Kid Charlemagne (FIRST TIME REACTION!)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 сер 2020
- #steelydan #music #reaction #instantbop
Thank you everyone for subscribing and becoming apart of the gang, be sure to subscribe and hit that bell to be notified when your boy uploads again. Comment below reaction suggestions. Follow My Patreon for blocked content and early reactions. Stay Blessed, Not Stressed. One love.
Help Support The Channel:
Donation - paypal.me/jayrahvisionroom
Follow My Social Media:
Twitter, Instagram & Snapchat - @jayrahvisions
Patreon - / illuminatedvisions
People that hate on anything they don't know, are just ignorant and miss an opportunity to expand and grow. I appreciate good hip hop. I think of sampling as a great compliment, and it is a form of art. Using technology in creating art is fine. It is it's own art. Don't let the haters keep you from exploring. They represent a small percent of the population. All this from an older white guy. Stay on Steely.... peace....
No one ever samples hip slop
@ShariSez1 No one ever samples hip slop
2
@@fredtello - No, they just make sad attempts at appropriating, using, or simply bastardizing it for some flavored down garbage, in almost every "genre" of music that exists today. Obviously, you've never been exposed to artists in hip-hop (I hate using genre specific identifiers, as it's frustratingly moronic) that understand music; otherwise, you would know artists who are also extremely adept instrumentalists, music theorist, and experimental artists. By your responses, one can only assume you have no formal training in music, or even music appreciation. But keep on in your idiot box. I'm sure it makes you feel special.
Appreciate you
That's funny learn how u o play intelligent music instead of remedial beats
Yes Steely Dan is the holy grail in music 🎵 😉
Yup that sums it up!
lol hell nah that'd be zepplin
Yep - I listen to lots of music and many genres but Steely Dan may be the best for me
Indeed. My favorite for decades.
This dude is hanging out way outside his comfort zone, I would hope that the people he was talking about at least gave that same open minded approach to hip hop that he is giving to rock (I hate the word rock but you get my meaning). There are a lot of these reaction videos where people are opening themselves to different shit... and that is a good thing. By the way, he obviously didnt listen to Kid Charlemagne at the proper volume, because if he did- that guitar solo would have melted his face off
I grew up a rock guy and only came to hip Hop when I was older through the really lyrical rappers like Talib Kweli, Lupe, Boots. Or the ones with really artful production work like Kanye. It can definitely happen the other way, and some of my favorite music now is in a genre that I didn't give the time of day as a kid.
He did compliment his phrasing :)
Indeed. Larry Carlton was without peers for a few years there.
Larry Carlton's guitar solo on this is mind blowing.
"All this machinery
Making modern music
Can still be open-hearted
Not so coldly charted
It's really just a question
Of your honesty, yeah, your honesty"
-Rush
😉 1 likes to believe in the Freedom of Music. But glittering prizes and endless compromises shatter the "illusion" of Integrity 🤔 (yeah.....) 😏🐰 #ENRGYZRBunny
Lee Lifeson & Peart- nuff said!
It's a real shame you had to stop and call out people slamming hiphop. I'm a 60 yr. old white guy and not gonna lie and say rap has been my thing since day one but I
enjoy lots of hiphop and totally respect it. SOOOO many comments I see everywhere about "there's just no good modern music" only means you've stopped listening 30 years ago.
You're a super impressive, intelligent young man and I really enjoy your insights into stuff that's new to you. Don't let closed minded people get you down.
you spoke for me. I'm a Boomer always trying to convince my friends that there is so much good new good music to check out - they just won't find it on mainstream radio. And really enjoying Rome Life's commentary about the instrumentation and musicality of all these songs
Peace and amen!
55 here, and grew up with all this classic rock, but for the last several years, hip hop dominates my playlists - mostly just the stuff that has strong social and political critiques of the status quo: Brother Ali, The Coup, Dead Prez, Bambu....
100% Most people are stuck with the music they listened to in high school. The fact is that there is good music in every genre, and there is bad music in every genre. Keep your mind open for the good.
63 myself and couldn’t agree more. There’s all kinds of great music in different genres.
I didn't write this. David Ryder gave this nice explanation of this song:
"Check out the wikipedia article about Owsley Stanley. He was not the creator of LSD, but he certainly was "the best in town" and made literally millions of doses in his East Bay underground lab and "turned it on the world", while moonlighting as the Grateful Dead's first sound engineer. "Those San Francisco nights" would be "The Matrix", "Avalon Ballroom" and those other tiny acid-drenched venues the nascent San Francisco sound began in. Bob Weir of the Grateful Dead owned an "A-frame" house in Mill Valley in Marin county and probably had Owsley's number on the wall. "Those day-glo freaks who used to paint the face have joined the human race." The daisy-chain hippies in Golden Gate Park with the painted faces eventually got jobs like their parents. Owlsey did go down to LA and supplied the six Acid Tests between Feb and March of '66 in southern California. "Still an outlaw in their eyes" ... LSD became outlawed in California in October of '66. Anyway... yeah, it's a potent song in many ways. Pregnant with meaning".
I'll add that the "White men in the streets" refers to the rise of cocaine and how people turned from LSD after it was outlawed. Also Stanley was captured by the police when his car ran out of gas (Is there gas in the car? Yes there’s gas in the car). For me nothing beats musicianship, and for me that means someone that plays an instrument (which includes the human voice), and can recreate their music with that instrument without electricity, without a microphone, and without augmentation. That means Malcolm Gladwell's 10,000 hours applies. But clearly I'm in the minority here.
Thank you for the background. I always thought this song was about the birth of freebasing, which of course led to nothing good.
As a 23yr old. The way I see it is that I'm learning to appreciate the music's essence and the creativity used to create it.(regardless of autotune) At the end of the day everything has its time and place.
It's all about keeping an open mind really, and not putting yourself in certain boxes only.
Thank you for introducing me to Steely Dan, I'm a new fan now🥰
I really love the hand painting in your background too... The design is so beautiful 😍
no boxes-thats where we get into unnecessary trouble. Open heart, open mind.
@@robertakline9785 Couldn't be further from the truth! 🙌🏾😊
they've got some amazing musicians playing with them they are Perfectionists they work is impeccable class act all the way
Thank you for reacting to Steely Dan. I am a black woman of a certain age and I've loved Steely Dan since I was in college. I just love music...all genres. To me sampling is the ultimate compliment and it's a testament that a lot of hip hop artists listened to all types of music and appreciated all types of music. These artist didn't keep themselves in a box. Didn't anyone see Migos singing Neil Diamond on Carpool Karaoke?? LOL. Keep it up kid!!
The drummer you're admiring is the great Bernard Purdie. He is know for the famous Purdie Shuffle which you can hear in the songs "Home at Last" and "Babylon Sisters". Those need to be your next 2 Dan songs.
"Is there gas in the car? Yes there's gas in the car!"
"Is there gas in the cah? Yes, there's gas in the cah."
Except there wasn't!!!
AmmaLeslie -
Exactly 🤣
The hit maker Bernard Purdie on drums and like Rainey On a lot of SD
The iconic "Purdie Shuffle."
He's the man. As is Larry Carlton.
You hit the nail on the head!!!
"Pretty" Purdie is truly a legend!
Rainey especially, he was on lockdown for them. I don't know why they even called anyone else.
Perfect Albums (just to name a few);
Kanye- MBDTF
OutKast- Aquemini
RHCP- By The Way
Bone- Art Of War
Nirvana- Unplugged NY
Led Zeppelin- IV
MGMT- Oracular Spectacular
Pink Floyd- Dark Side
Fleetwood Mac- Rumors
Jay-Z- Black Album
Beatles- Revolver
Wu Tang- 36 Chambers
The Roots- Game Theory
STEELY DAN- FIRST 7 ALBUMS (from ‘72- ‘80, not a bad song in the bunch)
I listen to every genre of music, I don't like it all, but every genre has their gems. I'm an old white man, I liked some Hip Hop back in the 80's, I like some now now, but not all of it. There's a lot of Rock, Soul, Funk, jazz, reggae, Folk, Blues, House, Trip Hop, Salsa, Afrobeat, new wave and so on that I love and more of it I don't like at all. point is, I don't get the haters of Hip Hop, It's more about bars than orchestras, and there's a lot to get out of it with that different perspective. Wordplay!
I haven't seen anyone react to Afrobeat. I would watch Jay Rah react to Fela Kuti "Opposite People" and think he would totally dig it. ua-cam.com/video/5y_bLL7ZGns/v-deo.html
Nobody should put people down for whatever music they like to listen to
I agree with you💯
The great Chuck Rainey on bass.
The Caves of Altamira
YES YES YES! One of Steely Dan's strongest songs. ❤️
man, i adore seeing these youngsters discovering old school music. love this!
preach my brutha!
I am 60 and I really enjoy hip hop. Live poetry with a beat. What's not to love?
I have listened to every form of music there is for my whole life. And there is something to learn from everyone of them.
Chet Atkins (One of the worlds greatest guitar players) was told by a fan "That is an amazing guitar...it sounds amazing!"... Chet Atkins put the guitar on its guitar stand and said... "Hows it sound now?". :)
As I've always said, you just can't go wrong with Steely Dan.
Music is the universal language. Live and let live.
😊✌
I totally agree with your statement about hip-hop, I love the sampling as long as they’re giving credit to the original artist. And to me, it only makes songs more legendary, and brings new people down to rabbit hole like you’re going right now music that they may not have heard before
Nothing makes me smile more than listening to Steely Dan on a relaxing Sunday afternoon.
The Royal Scam, along with Aja are 2 of the greatest albums ever made.
IN ANY GENRE. Periot. Right on man. All respect to REAL Hip Hop. Representin Jamaica, Queens here. ✌
😉 Da Boogie Down representing 🎤 " in the South Bronx! South, South Bronx!" 😊🐰 #ENRGYZRBunny
Bernard Purdie on the drums. Talk about "in the pocket" . . . no one could get that shuffle beat with groove, and soul, like Bernard Purdie. Amazing. Check out Steely Dan's "Home at Last" from the Aja album for more amazing Bernard Purdie genius. And while you're there, check out the title track, "Aja," for some life-changing drum work from Steve Gadd.
Love RAP, HipHop, Opera, classical, prog rock, reggae, Saharan blues, Indian classical, Billy H, Nina, Black Sabbath ... as long as the music is good, from the heart ... well said Man
Outstanding bass line on this song.
IMHO, Kid Charlemagne is the best dance song ever written. You can't help but move and groove to it.
This makes you rethink music. Imitation is the most sincere form of flattery. I love all good music.
Love your reactions. Thank you for all your work to put these together for us to enjoy.
Steely Dan always has musicians at their concerts! 💞. They are loved!
One of
The best most talented ears of any reactor out there. This guy knows what he’s hearing. Very nice
The kid made the best drugs back then, sold to Greatful Dead and many others....
David King Owsley yes. Also Engineer extraordinaire. helped develop a lot of on stage technology for the dead that all bands use now. And made the best acid around🔥
@@phillinfree ua-cam.com/video/r86Sb4heCWM/v-deo.html
Patrick Neal the Bear
Probably my favorite SD track. Bass line is fire. Also the way the bass and the left hand of the clav keys interact.
Sampling something, cutting it up, flipping it, and making something new, all that takes talent and EARS! Plus, it's like collaborating with another musician: something they did then inspires you to do something else. Plus, it's fun to listen to music and figure out where the sample came from.
I appreciate your reaction to this song and your breakdown in the middle about every genre of music having crap as well. I'm 51 and grew up on classic & southern rock,blues etc. Never thought I'd listen to any rap but I've branched out a bit and found some gems worth the time. What you said was well said.
Thank you soooo much for pausing for that comment young brother.
Nearly 56 y.o. w.w. who's lived most of my life & came up in a predominantly rock / c.w. radio market and who's loved hip hop since the early 80s.
Yes, just like any other generes of music, its over commercialization has yeilded some truly wretched results. But the vast majority of the nearly 50 y.o. artform is pure poetry.
People who think that sampling is "stealing" are just plain ignorant to what all art forms have done since the beginning of time.
Nothing is created from nothing; you cannot create something from nothing. Not without borrowing a riff, or a brush stroke technique, or an angle of hitting a chisel.
I'm 52 old white dude and I love Steely Dan and lots of funk, R&B, rock, jazz, soul, etc...Huge Stevie Wonder and Prince fan, MJ, but also Pink Floyd, the Beatles, the Stones, the Who, Zep...and I also love hip hop. I've enjoyed hip hop since the 80s, almost from the very start. Heavy D, the Fat Boys, Slick Rick, Dougie Fresh, Run DMC, the Beastie Boys, then a few years later, Tribe Called Quest (my favorite), the Pharcyde, Black Sheep, Arrested Development, OutKast...OutKast!! and so on. I probably missed a ton too, this is just off the top of my head...Loved all of that.
The greatest hip hop producers, in my opinion, were in the 90s, when they would really weave together a full tapestry or collage of various sounds (snare from there, kick from there, horn from another place, etc) and really turn it into a beautiful piece of music for the artist to rap over. You can still find great production today, but I think the world (not just hip hop) got trapped in that trap trap. It was cool for a while, but come on, let's move on now. Also, rapping well is a talent. I think Eminem is a beast, right up there with some of the best of them (Nas, Busta, Lupe Fiasco, Kendrick etc). These guys are sick. They can do things that regular people just can't, whether it's clever word play, sophisticated across-the-bar syncopated rhythms, cadence, and so on. (In my opinion Eminem is the best, but I know that's debated).
There is talent in all genres. Respect the art. Keep doing what you're doing. You have a great ear.
The fact that you expand your mind with different genres will only make your music better my friend
Your knowledge of music makes your reactions fire. It's fun watching younger cats listening to this music that we grew up on.
Having an 'open mind' toward music is how it should be. I discover new music I like constantly by holding on to an open mind and ears.
Loved your impassioned talk concerning people disrespecting hip hop. I'm an old white guy who for years was a jazz snob. As the years went by I opened myself up to all kinds of music including the hip hop my kids have turned me onto. Don't get me wrong, Monk, Miles, Trane, Mingus etc are monsters, but there's so much other music to enjoy. While some musicians may be technically better than others, they all create something worth listening to and respecting.
When I was a kid we lived in Oregon. We had some friends that had a nice house by the lake. When they would go on vacation we would stay at their place and take care of their horses. They had a high end stereo system (this being the late 70's) and a vast music library. I would pull out Steely Dan and Boston and cue it up to and do my homework.
Good days.😁♥️
Good times, good music, good memories.
Kudos to you for exploring the OGS!
I LOVED what you said about not showing disrespect to hip hop (or any other music style). Really important sentiment!
Rap artists I read in the 90s in Rolling Stone always pointed out the polished sound layered over hard,gritty street themes and payed respect. Imitation is a form of flattery.
I love it! Great reaction! Thanks for keeping it real and speaking your truth! Unity in Music, Love, and Spirit!!
Music--let alone art of any kind--is a big tent. Those that don't understand that are only breathing out, not breathing in. And you know how long you can last doing that...
The guitar is jazz legend, Larry Carlton. Steely Dan always got the best musicians.
I appreciate that call out about hip hop at the top; the sampling of these pieces of music are 100% creative, it’s not just some accident, and HELL YES, I love the fact that you took the time to educate here. Those tracks are just as creative, just from a different direction. Thanks for that. And I’m an older dude who grew up with Steely Dan and the rest and I’m not offended at all. Go on...
Even saying sampling isn't music is stupid, sampling has been around forever. Guy's like Zappa we're messing around with sampling since way early on. Would love them to argue that Zappa, Jazz from Hell is 100% sampled. It's narrow-minded.
It's music for sure. Let's just not forget to give credit to the original artists who wrote and created what we "sample".
So glad at your age you are exploring a different genre of music. I have been a fan of this band since I was a teenager(I/m 61 now and proud of it) and still their music sound so unique and timeless. II have all their albums but the earlier albums and their songs resonate more for me intrumentally. I /m a big fan of drums too so I highly recommend:
All songs in AJA(masterpiece)
All songs in ROYAL SCAM
All songs in GAUCHO
Pretzel Logic
Boston Rag
Dr. Wu
Thank you and enjoy. YOu are an old soul and I admire you for it. Great music is timeless.
Great reaction, great comments.
I absolutely love that you said what you said here. I have discovered Hip Hop that im really starting to get into. And its because of folks like yourself who are doing the same thing like you did here with Steely Dan. I have watched your reviews on all types of music that i grew up with. And you get it. Just like i did back in the day with funk and Motown. Props!! Keep this shit up!!
Don't worry about it.......music has no color or boundaries.......the old folks of the 60's are passing it on to you...because we are on our completion of the journey...and you ...and ..you are just starting yours.....Have a good one and stay positive....learn more things and grow...make this place called Earth ...a better place...Peace!
Salute to you for being open minded, and dont worry about haters because they dont change their mind. Keep flyin above it, Jay Rah
I used to go to a bar on Friday nights where the bartender played hip-hop off her phone all night long. It's the best bar music, period.
Thank you, your reactions are very real. Yep Steely Dan is iconic.
Check out YES-Roundabout, the Bass is funky insane!
One of the greatest bands.....................E-V-E-R!
Loved your comments about having an open mind to all music they loved music to with all the influences they use a natural fit with hip hop
Yes. Hiphop has its place. 61 yro woman here. 🥰
This song is a tribute to the legendary Owsley; acid maker of the 60s in the Bay Area.
Regarding what you say about hating on hip hop, as a white man in my 60s, hip hop isn’t the music I grew up with, but I can appreciate great music in ANY genre. 95 of the output in every genre is “stupid shit,” rock, pop, hip hop, country, etc. but the great music UNITES. Besides, everybody “samples;” Keith Richards talks about “sampling” Muddy Waters and Eddie Van Halen admits he sampled Hall & Oates “Kiss on My Lips” for his hit “Jump.”
You're exactly right! All music has its purpose.you miss alot when you close yourself off to other possibillities.
The bass and synth gave it such low end power. Epitomizes the 70s sound
Great words of wisdom about opening your mind to all types of music, including hip hop! Keep the videos coming!
I love to see the smile on your face during this song man love to see it
Well stated young man.
Keep it up!
Remember - Your mind is not for rent. That doesn't mean you are arrogant.
Peace.
best reaction video to steely dan ive ever seen. and ive been weirdly watching a lot of reaction videos to steely dan idk why
Thats Larry Carleton on guitar - one the greatest ever - hired by Steely Dan. On drums is the famous Bernard Purdie playing his equally famous Purdy Shuffle. I forgot who's on bass, but obviously a badass..
And good for you for standing strong and calling ppl out. I respect all musicians - especially if theyve broken through and released music nationally or internationally. - I dont love every piece of music I hear of course, but I respect the talent and work it took to release it.
I hope you're a producer cause you got a good ear. As both a hiphop and jazz head I feel the same way when people are dismissive about rap music. You can draw a direct line from how jazz musicians incorporate phrases from other different songs into their solos to how rapper copies another rapper's cadence or a famous rhyme scheme. It adds so much texture and meaning, but you only know if you know.
this is about an LSD chemist/dealer made the purest stuff anyone had ever seen.
The story behind the song is worth checking out . en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kid_Charlemagne
it's stupid for us to expect you to be open-minded to rock music, when most of us are close-minded to hip Hop.
I'm a sixty-year-old white rocker, and although I cant relate to most hip hop, I'm a huge fan of immortal technique, and Jasiri X.
I love your channel Jayrah you're one of my favorite reactors. Peace.
“On the hills the stuff was laced with kerosene, but yours was kitchen clean...”
When growing up, there were 2 bands i liked and Steely Dan was one of them. The other one was the band my dad played bass and leadsinger called Solution. I was 5 or 6 at that time. Love SD.
Thank you for your commentary on musical ignorance (and stereotypes in general). Right on point. Good music is good music. I love the fact you’re open enough to find it- regardless of musical genre. You’ve inspired me to explore other genres as well. Well said and much respect.
I dig you, man. I like that you're honest, have serious depth and especially that your taste is wide. Keep it up Brother.
It's called real skill.They're all professional musicians
There is an art to sampling (i'm a dj/producer of House music), and have lived the life of defending sampling for over 20 years now. I recently spent over 60 hours working with a 2 bar sample, deconstructing, splicing, mixing down, mastering...there's a LOT that goes into it.
I'm 53 years old and a musician and appreciate younger wisdom these days. Thanks for explaining that regarding finding the heart behind all creativity (music). People today are truly waking up to what's true. I've learned more from my wise younger co-workers than would ever imagine. It's very encouraging. Thanks!
Your point is well made. I chose to subscribe before your discussion of diversity in music. You are showing an open mind, and you inspire me to learn more about hip hop and rap. Thank you!
100% agreed with your "rant" about music, flavors and the person behind the art of machines, be it an instrument or a turntable or a wine glass filled with water. In fact, it's a testament to what you're saying by the fact that so many samples of absolute classic beats, riffs, and great songs have been lifted and used, like a collage of influences being turned into more than the sum of it's parts. I'm only 2 videos in so far, but I'm loving your content and subscribed! Keep doing your thing, sir! Music could smooth out a lot of the turmoil in our society right now, imo.
If folks stop bringing anger, and start spreading joy in it's place, maybe we could work it all out together.
Well said about open-mindedness to other kinds of music. No matter the genre, the instrument, or anything else, when the cats are good you can hear it in the first 5 seconds.
I've learned so much about hip hop/rap (because I too, couldn't stand the 'sound') but I patiently watched and SAW THE PASSION of folks like you who love it, and I started to really understand....the distinctions between the "forms of art". Keep it coming! you've got the right "feels" for reacting..its like sitting with my friends in our rooms jamming out...g
I'm so glad you brought up the Hip Hop side to light. I'm 61 years old and I have never to Rap with my 20 year old son and there is a lot of good music in Hip Hop or rap witch ever one you subscribe to. Doesn't matter how young or old you are music is universal. Grand reaction keep it up young fellow.
Agree 100% with what you said about respecting other peoples music, don't listen to hip hop but have much respect for it
so much great Steely Dan man, pick anything you cant miss!
Good for you, standing up for what you believe in. Respectfully, too. You're a credit to your parents.
ATCQ, De la Soul, Outkast, Mos Def, Kendrick Lamar, and on and on and on. There’s some absolutely killer hip hop out there. I’m an old guy but what I love about the genre, apart from the lyrical innovation, is the fantastic sampling from legendary funk soul and jazz artists which has led me to discover a world of great music . Anyone who can make those samples really knows and loves great music.
well said dude-music is personal. Love your spirit.
I'm 50+ years on this planet and as a youngster, old skool Hip Hop was my first love - it was just called hip hop at the time :). I used to do "audio trainspotting" like you. Particularly as 80's hip hop was almost all samples and loops, I would then go on a vinyl hunt to find the originals. So my record collection is pretty diverse!
I completely agree with you. Hip Hop is an art-form. I don't see much of a difference between borrowing a bar or two from an existing track or just being influenced by a track. Hip Hop, in a sense is a celebration of music, by highlighting the best bits and reinventing it in a new form. To take an example: "Night of the Living Baseheads" by Public Enemy samples "The Grunt" by The J.B.'s. I prefer the former, which wouldn't exist without the latter.... Now I am showing my age!
I’ve been lucky to grow up and witness the birth of one, of only three, original American art forms. The first Jazz, the second Abstract Expressionism and the third Hip Hop. I watch your reactions for Rush and Steely Dan, this old white guy’s favorite bands, but I have learned since first hearing Run DMC in high school to spinning the last Tyler the Creator or Kendrick album that HipHop/Rap is the most significant art form of my 52 years on this planet. DJ’s and Producers use the history of music like color on a painters’ palette and Rappers took lyrics from the melody and gave it to the rhythm section. Awesome! Next time someone disses sampling play “Introducing DJ Shadow’ and remind them that Led Zeppelin got famous playing riffs created by Bluesmen.
You are telling truth here JR ,,,, thanks for speaking your mind,,,,
Thank you for your message. I understand everything you're saying about music genres, including hip-hop.
Lovin the attitude of open mindedness and the honesty about how this music moves ya. I think the attitude against sampling ( not mine btw ) is bourn from the fact that this music is a culmination of actual lifetimes worth of work, love and dedication. When you think how many master musicians are on any, let's say for easy example, Steely Dan track and that it takes 10,000 hours of practice just to be competent on any instrument, It fuels the argument that sampling is a cheap shortcut. Not only does the musicianship have to be revered but the talent of foresight to come up with the musical ideas not to mention the sheer amount of time spent putting something original, of this caliber, together . This is not my argument! But I can see where it has it's roots. Sampling to me is feeling the beauty of something around and using it afresh, is cool so long as the original is acknowledged. Let me say again I've got respect for your attitude towards this I'm just saying, as a musician of 40 years, these are some of the arguments I've come across. Be really interesting to see any thoughts they provoke here..... Peace ✌️
For the record, I am a heavy rocker, and I like following your reviews. I think you get it. Especially your reviews on Rush...they were spot on.
I agree with you. i would never disrespect hip-hop or any type of music. I am 55 years old and watched hip-hop progress from rappers delight into what it is today. Each generation offers a new flavor to music. And I have seen steely dan live.. I promise there is no auto tune. They sound just like there album..
There is only one music but many styles. I listen to Jazz, Country, HipHop, Rap, Progressive Rock, Jazz Fusion, World Music, Classical, Choral, Blues, Bluegrass, Indian and Arabic... Music is a journey and like all journeys, every corner you turn offers a new view and enriches your life... turn every corner with your eyes wide open.
I agree with your comments. People should open themselves up to any good music. There are some great lyrics, stories, and creativity in hip hop. The sampling is honoring these great songs of the past.